Probe Returns, Space Council, Rocket lab Chomp // May 4th 2025 SHOW EDIT. #space #nasa #roscosmos

TMRO Space News
221 followers
This week we Talk about a 40 year old Soviet Venus probe returning to earth after a malfunction , Space council coming back ! and peter becks rocket lab shows off it new set of choppers on the neutron rocket.
And remember you can always help out the shows of TMRO by becoming a member here: https://www.youtube.com/user/TMRO/join
Continue the conversation by joining TMRO on Discord: https://discord.gg/htEJMHyFBE
#launch #space #rocket #iss #nasa #isro #jaxa #roscosmos #esa #cnsa #viralvideo #youtube #shorts #epic #youtubeshort #youtubeshorts #youtube #venus #rocketlab
public being like, "Oh my gosh, this
thing might land anywhere." Three
rockets for three presidents and they
can all do amazing things. Or tomorrow
begins right now. Good morning. How's
everything up in the sky?
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
Hello everybody. Welcome to Tomorrow. We
have a very interesting show for you
today. We've got some interesting topics
about uh old Soviet area probes
re-entering the potential for the
National Space Council and some rocket
lab updates among a few other things as
well. I am very pleased to be joined
today by our own Botham who is still a
little sick. So, please uh um offer your
well wishes and good vibes and all those
things so that she has a speedy
recovery. We also have Ryan here who uh
we're very happy to have with us and
just finished up an NSF stream. We also
have Dada back after uh celebrating uh
last week and uh we also have Jared Head
here as well. So, we're going to have a
really interesting discussion and a lot
of cool things that we want to talk
about today. So, thank you for being
here. Welcome. Get comfortable. Get your
coffee, whatever you uh your uh uh
beverage is for your morning and let's
get into it. How's everybody doing?
Really awesome. But uh Dada, what were
you celebrating? May the fourth be with
you also my anniversary.
Of course. I I should have known. I did
know, but I forgot. In that order.
Congratulations in that order. Thank
you. you you were a different person
back then
in in more ways than one. Mhm. Mhm. Went
to go see Hamilton and it was uh fun. We
took the the kids and and the the
in-laws and had a good had a good old
time. Well, did you bring a lightsaber?
I did not. Only in my mind. They would
have checked it at the door anyway. They
would they would have checked it at the
door. Yeah. I don't I don't know if the
lightsaber would have been period
appropriate for Hamilton. So, no, it
would be it would be because it's from a
long, long time ago. Yes. Ah, yes, it's
true. True. I'm sure you could have
tweaked the two so that it would have
just done the Alexander Hamilton.
Anyway, we're here to talk about space.
Let's talk about space. So, yesterday um
it looks like that a probe that has been
up there for over 50 years, one of the
Vanera probes. Um here, actually, here
let me go. Let's go to uh this screen
instead so that we can get a uh full
picture of that. So this is what the
probe looks like or at least a
reconstruction of one of the probe and
uh this was uh kind of in the middle of
the Vanera program that the Soviet space
program was doing in the ' 60s7s and uh
uh last one almost in the 80s and this
particular one failed its upper stage
failed um to get it on its transfer
trajectory towards Venus. And so it was
in this really highly elliptical orbit
where it goes really far out and then
comes in somewhat close to the
atmosphere and over the past uh 53 years
it's been slowly degrading its orbit
til. I do want to switch to give you a
different view to give you a little bit
better idea of what it looks like. If
you look in the top right hand corner
there you can just barely make out
somebody's work glove to give you a
sense of scale of how big this thing is.
And this was a a kind of a smaller piece
too of the the bigger picture. Here's
one of the early uh Vanera probes. And
you can see with um this one
that at the bottom, the spherical piece
at the bottom is we are looking for um
that is the piece that separated from
the rest of the probe and got stuck in
the orbit that it has been in. And
people have been tracking it for a
little while and over the past 2 years
they got a few more um measurements of
what it would look like. In fact, uh
this one might be a little bit hard to
see, but this was a um some observations
that an astronomer in the Netherlands
was able to take uh last year. Um, and
with this one, what's really interesting
about it is it kind of looks like that
the parachute that was meant to help it
um, deploy in Venus's atmosphere had
already deployed and has been dangling
for who knows how long. And that might
have just been the drove parachute
because it did have two different
parachutes for it. In any case, the
capsule was designed to be able to
withstand, you know, not just the the
heat of of re-entry entering the Venian
atmosphere, but just Venus itself having
almost 8,500 degree Fahrenheit
temperature. So, there's a large chance
that this probe was able to survive. and
um they believe that um the pieces from
it that didn't fully deploy and that
there might have been enough of it that
could survive re-entry and there was
even I mean there was quite a few
different uh estimations of where it
would land where it it might go. Um but
it turns out that the closest thing that
people are uh able to figure out is that
it land off the coast of India in the
Indian Ocean. So, um, there is a couple
of rumors that I've seen out there that
I haven't confirmed yet that it might
even be able to still have some buoyancy
and be able to float a little bit, which
is crazy if that's true. Um, in any
case, they are hoping to be able to look
for this a little bit and and search for
it. So, this is a pretty mind-blowing
thing that uh has been ongoing over the
past week or so. And I think that it's
pretty um incredible that uh we've been
able to follow this and that this probe
that has been in stuck in orbit
for 52 53 years now uh has been able to
re-enter and looks like it survived
re-entry. Although there's a lot of
other weird footage out there of people
claiming that they saw it and it's
really hard to confirm any of those at
the moment. But I don't know if you
could find a place on the earth that is
more like farther away from
in what do you mean in the Indian Ocean?
What? Yeah, like landing in the middle
of the Indian
Ocean. I mean, there's quite a bit of
stuff that lands there. I don't know if
you're being facicious or not.
However, still could be a bit uh still
could be a bit difficult in order to uh
to discover that. So, um I don't know
how many of you guys were able to uh uh
follow this, but I think that this is a
radical thing. Um again, this was in the
middle of the Vanera program. There was
quite a few different designs for the
Vanera probes. So, we think that the
images that we just showed you are
correct for the model that this one was
supposed to be, but also kind of hard to
get, you know, definite answers for a
lot of the for some of the Soviet era
stuff that gets classified in the Cosmos
section. And if you want to get learn
more information about this, you can
just look up Cosmos 482. Cosmos spelled
with K and 482 to find more information
and see what all the predictions were of
where they thought that this thing might
land. There was quite a bit of I mean
there I I don't know about you guys, but
I saw quite a bit of panic in the
general public being like, "Oh my gosh,
this thing might land anywhere. It could
land in Brazil. It could land in Europe.
Oh my goodness." And thankfully, it
landed in the ocean like most things
that can survive re-entry that are
uncontrolled.
Yeah. The the thing with this is that
most of the world is the ocean. So yeah,
the thing with these old probes coming
back down is that they're
uncontrollable, right? So the predict
even the most accurate predictions we
had right up until like the final point
that it was caught is like this time
plus or minus 3 hours plus or minus 3
hours. That's like four orbits worth of
places that this thing could land on.
And along these orbits were places like
uh Houston, New York, the inity of
India, Australia, like Perth, Australia.
These were places which were in the
direct line of the orbit that this thing
could have re-entered in. Luckily, it
appears that the tracking has detected
it. Um or rather the the last time it
was caught uh how should I word this? It
was caught at a time and then it wasn't
caught in the same place 90 minutes
later. So, you know, within the last 90
minutes, the probe has re-entered. So,
that's kind of how they can then give
those predictions. We saw it at this
spot on last orbit. We didn't see it on
this orbit, which means it's re-entered
somewhere previously within the orbit.
So, that's where those predictions have
come from. But, yeah, it's still kind of
It reminds me of the Long March 5 core
stage that was left uncontrolled a
couple of years ago, and Spain shut down
like their entire air traffic uh uh
system because they were worried that
the that the core stage was going to
going to reenter. Maybe that was a
little bit over the top from the from
the Spanish side, but you know, the
these things, you know, this is
something we need be very considerate of
because, you know, like Mike was saying,
this thing was designed to reenter
Venus's atmosphere. If it can, if it was
designed to get through Venus, it could
easily get through Earth.
If Spain turned off their ATC, is this
maybe why Newark didn't have radar this
last week in the US? You think they just
shut off their radar and uh Oh, that
only that joke only works if you guys
realize that we had ATC issues in the
US. Otherwise, it doesn't land. Yeah.
No, every day. Yeah, indeed it doesn't
land. So,
um I was I was going to note with uh
Cosmos uh 482 here uh that first of all,
you know, it failed before it was able
to do its departure burn for Venus. uh
which is then when it was labeled Cosmos
482, which was very much like a uh oh,
hey, it didn't work. Um what do we what
do we call our sag satellites that we
get up there regularly anyhow? Cosmos.
Cool. Uh just throw it on the list.
Throw it on the list. Um, and if that
wasn't enough for you, 4 days after it
launched in 1972,
uh, there was a re-entry of spacecraft
material over New Zealand that actually
made it into uh, if I recall correctly,
basically the a farmer's field and they
were able to look they were able to
actually grab the material and it was t
four titanium spheres which were likely
propellant tanks. uh on this vehicle and
uh yeah, they the Soviets were like,
"Huh, look at that. Not ours." Uh even
though it very much obviously was from
Cosmos 482. U so nobody ended up having
to pay for anything, which is typically
how things work under international law,
but the Soviets just essentially were
like, "Not ours. Not ours. Actually, not
ours." Uh I mean able to make that
happen. to add on. Technically, they're
right. Right. Technically, it's not the
Russians. It's the Soviets. And it's not
Well, back this was back So, back in
1972, the Soviets said that's not ours.
Which that's not really how that should
work. But also, like, nobody was really
going to throw a a fit over it. So,
everyone in New Zealand, New Zealand is
like the Canada of the Southern
Hemisphere. They're all polite and they
just knock. Dude even saved the the
piece of whatever tankage that might be
and never gave it to anyone.
Yeah, finders keepers. Yeah. Hope there
weren't hypergalls in there.
Looks like they uh uh hopefully drained
out one end. Maybe what that's what all
the melting that we see there is. Uhhuh.
Oh my goodness. Hypergalls uh drain very
very well and in in full. They're
they're known for not creating issues
after the fact. They're known for that.
Yeah.
Okay, then you're definitely being
facitious.
Yeah. By the way, there were a couple
more of those spheres discovered several
years later in New Zealand. So, it's
it's almost like it might it may either
they all fell together or this is one of
the greatest coincidences in space junk
history. And and they all just kind of
ganged up and said, "Look at that small
island right there. let's go for it.
Which honestly, it's pretty beautiful,
so I don't blame him. So, you know, as
time time goes on, we're going to have
more and more stuff that just gets, you
know, naturally de-orbits and comes back
down. So, I'm wondering if we should
have a new segment on the show like this
week in space junk history or something
like that, talking about whatever is
coming back down. What came down this
week? We could call it welcome back
spacecraft
or or you know, we used to have a
departures board. We'll call it
arrivals.
You're absolutely right. There seems a
lot more of than I remember in the past.
Or maybe we just didn't hear about it as
much, but yeah, there seems to be a lot.
I refuse. I was rooting for it.
I I rendevu with refuge. Um yeah, that's
good. I was rooting for it to land near
Perth. uh simply because that just seems
to be a really great place because this
where Skylab came down at in 1979. So I
was like let's just put some more stuff
there while we're at it. I'm sure
nobody's gonna mind it. So next time
this we should do re-entry bingo.
Where's it going to land? Yeah. Yeah.
Where's it going to land? Have you guys
not Yeah. Have you guys not played
re-entry re-entry bingo before? Right.
You put your little piece on the world
where you think it's going to come back
in and whoever gets closest gets the
pot. You need confirmation of of
touchdown for that though, don't you?
Like they don't know exactly where it
landed and everyone everyone disagrees
where it landed. So then who do you
believe in? Yeah, actually me. Me. I got
it. I got it. I mean it make it makes
the re-entry game even more. You don't
know who won. Well, we do know one
thing, which is that it landed between
52 degrees north and 52 degrees south
latitude. So that narrows it down a bit.
[Music]
It's been pretty wide 80 years.
Oh man.
But yeah, this is I I think that that's
a great idea to to um do those things
and have everyone kind of bet on what
they think it's going to be and at the
very least uh whoever gets closest or
wins will will get the bragging rights.
So I I love that idea. I think we should
do that for for the next ones. By the
way, I just want to say I just I looked
it up on Wikipedia real quick just to
have everything set. Um and uh I am
amazed at the fact that they have noted
for the the re-entry the descent craft
uh they have noted that it is 495 kg
which is
1,19 pounds. And then my favorite one on
here is that they also threw in
77.9 stone in order to say how much it
weighs cuz you know the famous
engineering uh you know unit of weight
for engineering stone. Uh so I didn't
realize we had medieval peasants who
were following this type of stuff.
That's that's that's that's news to me.
Yeah, I I sure was surprised to find out
about this. So,
if if you came across a piece of space
junk that landed in your vicinity or
your proximity and you were able to take
possession of it, what would you do with
it?
Put it on the mantle piece.
Definitely put it on the mantle piece.
Maybe give it a little like a um stand
so that you can know where a little bit
of hydroine
I actually have a couple of pieces of
concrete I keep meaning a little stand
for and uh you know Starbase launchpad
number one and put it up on on the
shelf. It just looks like a piece of
concrete but it is
special. I would uh if it had been if I
so if that vanero lander had landed on
my backyard mostly intact, I think it
would make a great table.
Why? Wait, no, I don't. Why does
everyone want to turn space stuff into a
table, right? I don't know. I need
tables and
this is a point of particular uh uh pain
with Jamie.
I want I I personally of space stuff
want a nozzle so that I could have like
a backyard like you know fire place
somewhere and the nozzle can be where we
do the burning of stuff in it at for
that. I will say an inverted nozzle on
the ground that's like a fire pit sort
of thing or like a grill would be kind
of awesome. Especially if you can get
like a good fire coming up. That would
look pretty cool. That would be awesome.
Yep. My idea is everyone's to take. So,
you're welcome. Enjoy everybody. I mean,
it would be the world's most expensive
barbecue if you think about it. Yes. And
don't use the actual propellants for it
either. It's just going to be too hot.
It's just No, it's not just too hot, but
think of the velocity, too. Cuz like
you'd light the engine and if you had it
like on the top, all would just go
bes you see you're like, "Let's light up
the grill." And you see the mock
diamonds form.
It's a reverse suborbital launch.
Hey, who wants a burger? And then he
could just gimble it. So that way he
could just flush some different
directions.
You have a you you have a pre grill
sequence where it goes through like this
gimbling procedure to make sure
how grill wiggles. I'm sorry. I'm I'm
medicated. I hit my skiff button earlier
which is why I off the screen to go take
more medication. And so like I'm in a
weird headsp space today. I'm sorry
everyone.
Yeah, I got to say Mac, you could have
active cooling on it so you don't burn
your shins.
Mac in the chat room is right there.
Anything is better than MDF to make a
table. So yeah,
for those who don't know, um the old
studio MDF
and um you know, Dada just cut
everything wherever he could, right? And
so in the old studio space until the day
we left and even probably to this day,
we found MDS MDF dust everywhere. And
you could no matter how much vacuuming
you did, no matter how much clean you
did, that facility was infected with MD.
You I I never thought there was anything
worse or more contagious than glitter.
MDF. MDF dust.
Whenever they Yeah. You thought white
you thought the leftovers of whitands in
Colombia was still appearing years
later. Let me tell you
to be a fly on the wall when the owner
came in to inspect the place being like
did they spread a speestous everywhere?
What is going on?
You know what was I never expected to
get I know we're way off topic. I'm
sorry. I never thought we'd get our
deposit back, but we got it back in
full. Did you really? Yeah. Wow. Holy
crap.
Wow. Impressive. And Jamie Jamie died.
Jamie froze. Darn. I mean, that was
maybe the landlord is watching and just
discovered uh that there was MBF
everywhere and then I don't know.
Finally got the confession they needed.
Uh oh. Uh so continue on nonspace
related topics. Uh what happened there
was um I run everything in Orlando off
of a MacBook Pro and when it's not in
use it like I will often leave my
MacBooks like sideways and kind of
leaning against a nightstand or whatever
it is that I can, you know, reach down
and grab it if if necessary for
whatever. Well, inadvertently one day I
knocked water over the side of the thing
and it went into the USBC ports and the
power ports and everything on the
MacBook. And so, and this happened like
right before a show. And so I I was
like, "Oh god, I hope not." And I kind
of blew out the water and then I plugged
the cable in and it was like, "No, water
detected. No joy." And some, "Uh, crap."
And then I realized, "Oh, this is a
MacBook Pro, not a MacBook Air. There
are USBC ports on the other side." So, I
took that cable out like a freaking
idiot. That is not the word I was going
to use. And I without using a different
cable, the cable that I just put into
this wet USBC port, which is now a wet
cable, I moved it to the other side into
a good USB port and made the dry USBC
port now a wet USBC port. So I nuked
like all of the ports. And ever since
then, once in a blue moon, the entire
USBC subsystem, like every everything
that is USBC connected would just gosh
and go down. So, I'll lose my
teleprompter. I'll lose my camera. I
lose my microphone. Everything goes down
and then I have to scramble really
quickly and reset cuz it goes down and
it comes back and I got to scramble and
reset all the devices really quickly.
So, now you know. And it doesn't matter
what port I use cuz I made them all.
It's a Ryan story. That's not a Ryan
story. My laptop works perfectly fine.
My laptop works perfectly fine. Maybe
that's your problem, Jamie. You didn't
use Ryan's solution. You need to put
that bad boy in in a bag of a bag of
rice.
Yeah, because we were literally minutes
away, right? And so I didn't have time.
I'm just like, "Oh my god, whatever I
need to do." I was I was thinking like,
"Oh, I'm just going to grab my iPad sort
of thing." And like for those who don't
know, EVM is hot garbage on an iPad.
It's kind of hot garbage on all
platforms, but it's really hot garbage
on an iPad. So yeah, there you
go. That's my story. Right on. Right. I
know in the chat I'm reading the chat
room. They're all judging me. I I think
the solution here is I'm just going to
get like an iMac in this space. I'm
going to get some sound treatment and
iMac and everything. It'll be great. You
like you guys like the space. But I am I
am in Orlando because I know you all
like like to use my background to figure
out where I am. I'm in Orlando this
week. It's just that instead of having
to set everything up in the living room
cuz I really do not feel good today. Uh
I was like uh too much effort. And so I
just moved it into the into the uh
office and I'm like this will be fine.
So, I'm probably just going to do them
from here from now on.
Well, yeah, we got to get you some some
more decorations and stuff and get you
get you a proper set there. It's going
to look great. Yeah, I I will take a
picture and post it on uh X of like what
it looks like in front of me cuz it's a
little hilarious with all the pillows to
try to cut down on the uh I'm going to
do that. In fact, I'm going to do that
right now as I assume we're moving on to
next topic. H have the MDF delivered. I
will I will cut it in place and make
your set.
Oh
god.
Actually, that might be kind of cool. I
got a little bit of room here. I might
take you up on that. Da get a little
mini window back. Little mini space
station window back. God, can you
imagine the neighbors as you're like,
[Music]
here you go. For everyone who follows me
on X, I'm uploading that picture now.
It's okay. It's Florida. There's worse
things have happened to people.
Not like worse things in the air filters
already. Although we're gonna have to
write the I can see the news story on it
already. California man
with Da going there to to do it. Gota
got to have some specificity on who's
doing the crazy.
Oh man. California man. Florida woman.
Florida woman hires California man.
Yes, breaking news. Breaking news. So,
um something that is uh interesting that
we can do a little bit of speculating
and maybe uh throw out a couple of names
that we might like for this is that uh
the White House has decided not to do
away with the National Space Council.
For those who remember during the last
uh Trump presidency, uh they revived
that. It's kind of been a thing off and
on over over the decades. and they
revived that and got a bunch of experts
uh industry leaders and astronauts
together to help you know the
administration and NASA decide what
their policy should be and what
directions they should go and then it
was kind of done away with. It wasn't
exactly cancelled, but it was just kind
of ignored and uh done away with during
the Biden administration. And there was
a little bit of, you know, talk of like,
hey, are we going to do that again this
time around or no, not really. What's
what's up? And so there was a little bit
of an announcement this week of no,
we're not going to cancel it. We are
going to try to keep it going, but there
hasn't been a whole lot yet for whether
or not they are going to reassemble that
and whether or not Vice President uh JD
Vance is going to to head that up or
not. Um I can tell you though that uh
probably the the number one person who
most excited about this is Homer Hickham
and is happy to rejoin the National
Space Council and share his opinions on
what the direction of NASA and the space
program should be. So, I figured we
would kind of go around. Um, who do we
think that we would like to see on that?
Um, is there I mean, you know, probably
to get the elephant out in the room out
of the way. Uh, I think that Elon
probably has his hands in enough stuff
right now that he probably need to join
that again, although he was exactly a
member before, but he did show up to
several meetings before to kind of
represent SpaceX and do that. So, what
do we think here? who who do we think
would be um good people to to to have on
that and would be able to you know share
their wisdom and help us craft the the
right direction for for NASA at least
over the next three and a half four
years.
I mean, I guess my question before we
get in into who is like, does the
council have any real impact here,
right? Because like it's all going to
come down to what Congress says anyhow.
It's all going to come down to dollars.
And so the the space council can make
recommendations, but they have no real
power, right? Like they can't
actually do it's like I feel like it's
just like a little like here's a show
But is there a history of the National
Space Council's advice being adhered to
in Congress in Congress allocating funds
based on their recommendations? It's a
great question. I don't know. Does
anyone know?
At least this last time around, I I feel
like they were pretty influential in
helping to kind of craft the Aremis
program. I mean there was a lot of stuff
that was ongoing on already but they
kind of helped set in stone what the
process should be for it and coming up
with the the Artemis Accords. Not every
single recommendation was followed but
it seemed like quite a few of their
recommendations were followed at the
time between 2016 and uh 2020.
So whether there's going to be a
beautiful irony because it was the Trump
administration that created like Artemis
and whatnot and now Trump I bet the
Trump administration is going to come in
and they're going to be
[Music]
like right like they don't uh I think
they're done with Artemis now. Right.
So man this is this is a weird time we
live in. Super weird time.
Don't man super weird time. I just
I think the con the concept is good. I
think you if you can you can put you
know scientists that want I'll do it
because I can feel Jamie looking at it.
If you can put scientists in place that
that are are after exploration and uh
people that that have kind of kind of
the grand picture in mind and you know
kind of along the lines of the the
10-year plan sort of thing where this is
your opportunity to be able to establish
the the the the road road map for what
you want to happen in space and indicate
that as your your desire in an optimal
world and then you can get people in
Congress to lobby to have different
aspects of it in their congressional
districts and whatever and then they can
allocate funds in order to be able to
happen like that. That's you have to
have a plan in order to be able to to
have money
uh to to have a need for money. And if
you can convince people that your plan
is sound, then you can convince people
to spend money with with your plan. Um,
so I I think this is a a a good idea and
concept, but I I I worry about it being
politicized too much and the the wrong
kinds of recommendations being made and
being taken
seriously in not in good faith. Don't
panic EU. That comment's a good one. a
10-year plan when Congress works on
two-year cycles. I think like that makes
sense as long as you know the next
administrations follow said 10-year plan
cuz this is this is the thing, right?
Like NASA and anything with regards to
going out into the cosmos needs to work
on a longer timeline, right? We need we
need more just
um uh you
know a a two-year cycle or even a
four-year presidential cycle. We need
something that's a good decent long-term
plan. And this is part of where even
like the Artemis program
uh I don't know uh I'm a split brain of
all of this, right? Because then the
where I was going is like you need to
have these good 10-year plans and these
good long-term plans, but what happens
when you've got a long-term plan like
Artemis where it's clear that you should
be like maybe not doing this
plan and then you're you're backed into
a corner and like I don't know. I don't
know.
Yeah. I mean, it's just if you look at
things historically and how the big
movers and shakers have operated
throughout aerospace history, it's
always been these very long-term
projects that end up being the most
meaningful ones, right? I mean, project
Apollo with all the resources that were
dumped into it, you still had the better
part, if not an entire decade of of, you
know, R&D, design and build, test, and
then finally operations in order to
actually accomplish your goal there. And
sure, we were coming from building from
scratch with something like that. Um,
but nowadays, I still feel like it's,
you know, going to take the better part
of a decade in order to actually get a
significant program going. Uh so long
timelines do work very very well for
aerospace in terms of the stability of
programs. It's just that these long
timelines, you know, at least long
timings are not stuff that typically
happens politically. Um and that's
always the hard part of it is that the
the the
uh how would I just I'm trying to figure
out how to describe so many things
today. uh the political power behind the
ability to run a program uh is not
necessarily in the end result 10 years
down the line, but in the immediate
results uh that your constituency can
see uh as soon as you announce it. Oh,
you know, it's it's it's a challenge and
uh one that I I I am not envious of the
people who have to sit on this council
and try to figure out how to approach
these these problems and figure out
solutions without uh stepping on the
toes of the multitude of people who want
them. So I I I'll I'll add to your
project Apollo, which was built on
project Gemini, which was built on
project Mercury, which was which each of
those were were a couple or several
years in in the making in order to be
able to accomplish what we accomplished.
And without uh a cohesive plan of what
that arc should be, uh you can't ask for
funding. If you don't get consistent
funding, you can't execute. And if you
can't execute, then you can't accomplish
your goals. So I I understand that
there's a a great desire to be
uh flexible and and be able to be
reactive with a lot of this stuff. But
uh the the time scale we're working on
for most exploration is many many years
if not decades if not multiple decades
to be able
to develop and and build a program and
you know show some execution and then
wait for the results. Look at Voyager
who who has been operating for 40
years. You you're coming up on 50 pretty
soon. Don't remind me. I'm
old. You know, like that's a that's a
long time
for money to be spent. And if you don't
have it in the plan, then you can't
execute and you can't get the kinds of
results that you're looking for out of
out of something that's got a long
timeline like
that. I feel like there has to be a
little bit of political maneuvering.
Like if you do have a solid plan, that
sounds good. You've got all these
milestones that are
achievable. I feel like in order to have
a good proposal that's going to last,
you have to cut it up into phase that
the political parties at B can take
credit for. You know, you can have this
phase during this four-year segment if
it's a really long plan and then have
this phase that can be implemented
whenever a next presidential
administration comes in and they can
take all the credit for it so that that
plan can stay. It feels like to me over
the past 20, 30 years, there's been a
lot of plans that we're making decent
progress, but change of administration,
they're like, "Oh, that was the previous
person's uh program." No, no, no, no.
We're going to do my program, even
though in the end it ended up being the
same program anyway. So, and that's just
me. It's kind of a little bit of
political trickery to allow them to take
credit for it and everyone feels good.
but to stay on the course and keep the
plan but allow that bit of flexibility
to to you know change things as needed.
I have a proposal for you Mike. What if
we take those phases but call them
blocks and say have block one and block
one B and block two and then everyone
could take credit for each block and you
know we'll have block one which will do
like I don't know three missions and
then we can have block one B which will
do say a few more missions after that
and then we go to block two but we'll
we'll leave the rocket as it is but
we'll just replace the solid rocket
boosters with like a new solid rocket
booster design and then we can like
three rockets per three presidents and
they can all do amazing things or we can
just do one of them
[Laughter]
and just yeah change the name uh call it
block one block two and then allow the
presidents to take change the name for
it. We're we're now doing the uh Trump
phase of the plan. We're now doing the
Newsome phase of the plan. We're now
doing the Kelly phase of the plan.
Whatever.
I don't want my phase of the plan being
built on his
No, that's when you radically change the
name of a program partway. That's called
pulling a SpaceX, right? Version one to
block two to
full thrust. I was about to say we could
just do them as program numbers, right?
Program number one, program number
eight, program number nine, program
number 10, and then something happened
to 11 and 14. So, we just went straight
to program number 15. I mean, who knows
at this point. So, it's just it's all
over the place. Mike, you had asked who
we'd like to see on the cons council and
um I've been thinking about this for a
minute and I think I don't think it
happened because I don't think the
administration would like it, but I
think one of the most influential people
at NASA that created the largest amount
of positive change that radically
transformed the entire agency and we
still see the outcome of that today is
Lorie Garver. Right. 100% agree. She's
the one She's the one who brought in
commercial space. She's effectively the
one who fought for companies like
SpaceX. Like she had a vision and
everyone pushed against her. They're
like, "You're crazy. This isn't it." And
she made it happen and she had a great
vision for the future and she set NASA
up for she set the entire country up for
success with that. And so I would love
to see her um I'd love to see her on the
council. I don't think that would happen
in a million
years, but yeah, 100%. But I think I
think you also need a lot of the
industry partners that are available in
there. So, you know, Peter Beck and
whoever's the new head of relativity and
Elon and Tory Bruno and maybe leaders to
represent SpaceX
just to understand the the realm of of
possible so that so that companies can
get involved ear early on and say, "Hey,
look, we've already got this this sort
of thing and you can be involved in the
selection process, whatever, but like
these are the capabilities that we're
aiming for or you know we have these
manufacturing capabilities that could be
used to do X Y or Z and you can get them
in early and have them uh bear the brunt
of of the workload and that does a
number of things. you can then
determine, you know, where those jobs
should go so that you can have favored
congressional districts be able to pay
for them and, you know, it can be a good
thing for everybody across the board and
kind of share the the that whole pie
amongst all of those those players to
keep the engineering talent in those
locations to keep progressing towards
the goal without stagnation, without
overcost overruns. It's like there's a
lot of benefits that could be be made
from that. Certainly. There's a couple
of suggestions from the chat room, too,
that I would like to to point out.
Aravail thinks that Wayne Hail would be
would be good. Oh, that's another really
good one. Yeah. Yep. Love him. He'd be
great. Jacob Buchard thinks that Barbara
G would be a good And forgive me guys,
but I've kind of forgotten who that is.
Um, but uh Barbara G, that's that's who
you say. Uh Aravail again, Pete Warden
and Scion Proctor would be good um since
they've been on previous ones. Would
love to see them return. Absolutely. Um
I certainly think that there has to be
at least one or two uh astronauts on
there to especially if it's d for human
spaceflight stuff to actually have
someone in the room who knows what it
actually is going to be like to do that
and be like, um, wait a minute, excuse
me. What about this? What about that?
you know, let's make sure that those
types of of things aren't forgotten
about and we don't put someone in a, you
know, 4x4 area for six months and have
them go crazy with cabin fever if we're
trying to do a Mars program or something
like that. So, um, a couple other, uh,
suggestions from the chat room.
Actually, this made me laugh. Lone
Phoenix. I don't even know uh, uh, but
two to three other people in the space
industry. what are the expertises best
suited for this order? Um, and that's
kind of what got me thinking about at
least one or two astronauts and uh
someone else, you know, gamers, too. We
need
gamers. You know, there's another person
that I think had a really great and
positive change on NASA, interestingly,
on the other side of the uh aisle. Uh,
and that's Jim Benstein. I think it
would be really great. He's a former
administrator. um you know he he's
Republican and I was really really
worried because I was like oh this isn't
like when he got confirmed of like you
know all the things he but he ended up
being like he proved me wrong. I I think
he did
great phenomenal things for NASA. I
think Lori Garver had a lasting impact
that we're seeing to this day. Um but
Jim was able to push through projects
and really understood what needed to get
done um you know for America for for the
agency on a you know on on that level of
scale right so I think I think that
would be a great person in there as
well. Yeah. Launching American
astronauts on American rockets in
American capsules from American launch
pads. That's him in American state and
American soil on the continent.
Launch America.
I like I like this suggestion too. Eric
Aravel Garrett Reed would be would be a
good one for uh someone from the
astronauts to to be a member of that.
Yeah, I can one astronaut I would love
to throw in the mix is Eileene Collins
because she's just like absolute expert
and like one of those like legendary
astronauts who who is is definitely
always happy to to help out and figure
things out with that. My final
recommendation
Chris
Hatfield that'd be fine. I know. Oh,
we're allowed to have folks from outside
the US on this. Probably not. Because if
we are, then let's throw Peter Beck in
the mix as well on it. I think he'd be a
very good perspective to have.
I wonder if he's hold up. Hold up. This
needs to We need to hit this in after
dark. Okay, stick around. Chibi Chi
Chibi, did you Chibby, were you
responsible for the ground ilical
carrier plate on the space shuttle? Do
you do you have a membership to are you
a member and and can we get you an after
dark?
Because we're gonna he he's got some
words for you. Um while we're questions
while we're working that um another
person who I think has had a great
impact on NASA and Frank actually I
think just aerospace as a whole um and
would just be a truly remarkable
candidate is me. I think I should be on
the console.
I would actually be okay with that cuz
you're a master communicator. You at
least would be able to get people on the
same page even when they have opposing
views. So, I would not be okay with
that. Otherwise, I was going to say my
final recommendation would be data so
that he can tell them when they're all
stupid and ground them into reality. Oh,
I don't think that I don't think that
will go over very well. That would that
would not go over well at all. However,
uh Dustin Sandlin would be a good good
position or a good candidate for that
position. The Space Council streamed in
perfect 4K. Absolutely. And HDR. Let's
go. I'd get this in front of everyone.
I'd be like I'd be like, "Hey, let's
take questions from the community. They
like everyone gets a voice here. Let's
go. YOLO. Let's have at it." Heck yeah.
Should we uh should be a good good
person to be in there? Yeah. Yeah, I was
going to say, should we also throw Bill
Nye in the mix so that we can cover
space sciences and stuff like that? So,
by Bill Nelson, no one said Bill Nelson.
Bill Nelson about China. That's weird.
No one No one said Bill Nelson. Huh,
that's weird. Yeah, Jim. He wasn't
invited for America and then Bill Nelson
was the administrator for China cuz he
talked about China. It was like, yeah,
you have to beat the Chinese. I did not
I did not think Yeah. I don't think
Senator Nelson did a great job of
administrating NASA in my humble
opinion. Yeah. Yeah. He kind of sat
there and was just like, "Huh?" Yeah. I
could do something. But why when I get
paid to not? Huh?
All right. All right. Time for me to go
on the stage and give a really awkward
introduction to these to these people.
So yeah, he was he was he was really
good at that.
So but yeah, I think that I I really
hope that this does come together though
and that we can get good people on it
and if JD Vance doesn't want to head it
up, maybe they can find to be the the
head of this. And I feel like last time
around they did have good
recommendations. Again, not everything
was adopted, but there was quite a lot
that that was. And yeah, things are in
flux and and the Artemis program is
probably going to change a lot before we
we uh see how it what its conclusion
might be. But, you know, I really do
like those types of of recommendations
from experts who are qualified and know
what they're talking about
and experience and all the sort of
things that whether or not Congress
adopts their recommendations or not is
another story. But I do like that sort
of of thing of of having that group
together to try to keep us on some sort
of straight and narrow path.
So just my opinion anyway. Yeah. I
wonder like what would happen with JD
Vance becoming if if they were to choose
him to be head of the National Space
Council considering that he comes from a
venture capital background and I would
imagine almost certainly has in a
multitude of investments in in private
space flight companies like would would
that possibly come into play or
like just just something to throw out
there. Don't know. So, well, why don't
we why don't we all watch for ourselves
and because I agree. I think this was a
little bit subjective. So, why don't we
uh roll the video and see and hear for
ourselves uh what uh this this test
actually was. Um so, uh we there we go.
Um this was the uh first stage uh
qualification testing of uh the fairing
which we have seen open and closed
before but this time integrated with the
kind of interstage uh canister with
obviously we see those grid fins moving
around here and we should be getting the
the test any second now we can finally
put this to bed of what sound it makes.
Let's see. They could be cans
cans. You're right. You're right.
They're canards.
Oh, that's not the noise. That's not the
noise. Posing noise. This is very much
a listen.
See, it's a ding. I I heard a ding. It's
not a ding. I heard a ding. Sounds more
like a clunk to me. It's a clunk. I
heard a dick. I don't know about you
guys. I heard a dick. But there there
it's like plastic on plastic as it
approaches the plunk. So it is not it's
not just a simple plunk. As someone who
is like obsessed with sound design and
stuff. This is not just a humble plunk.
This is something significantly more
than that. So don't try to pull the wool
over my ears about this one. I've heard
it. Here's what I think. Here's what I
think. Ryan, your question sucked.
I got one right. All right.
Was Was the real answer all of the
above?
Oh man.
I really do think if you go back to the
questions, I really do think he had it
set up so that if I had guessed a not
number one or number two, he could have
flipped the answer and still been
correct. Right. He guaranteed he guar he
you he created a question that would
guarantee that I I could not get it
right if you want me to. I think you're
noticing too much.
I think we should be honest and just
talk about Neutron instead of coming up
with these wild wildly incorrect
conspiracy theories that you know they
they don't benefit anyone.
[Laughter]
Also, a huge huge thank you to Dave
Avery who week after week uh contributes
five uh gift memberships uh to the show.
Um really appreciate it. Um you you
that's the lifeblood of the show helping
helping to keep make it go. The question
is did what's his name get a membership?
Oh yeah. No, he had he has one. Okay,
good. Okay, good. I don't I don't I
don't think he was green before, but
okay. I'll I'll take your word for it.
He answered that he has one. Okay, we'll
get we'll get him in though and we'll
tell that story in After Dark. You You
say he has one, but Chibi is coming up
as not green in the chat room, which
means he does not have one,
just so you know. Yep. All good. All
good.
Well, um
I think that it's great. We only we got
an update just a couple of months ago
for Rocket Lab and the progress that
they've been making on Neutron and this
was another one for uh the last one was
the kind of their report for uh quarter
4 of 2024 and this one is their report
for quarter 1 of 2025 and they've been
making excellent progress. Um, not only
did we see that test of the interstage
with its canards and uh the hungry hippo
uh fairing opening and closing, which is
that goes
punk goes ponk or all of the above, who
knows? Um, but they've been making a lot
of progress on a lot of the other
pieces, the the dome pieces, which
interestingly they've been uh
transporting back and forth by
helicopter, which is interesting to see.
and they have been making excellent
progress on the launchpad at launch
complex 3 in Wallops Island, Virginia.
And uh in fact, I even have another
video pulled up to show a uh delouch
test that they have done with their
launch mount for it. Um, and so things
are moving right
along hopefully be able to pull
off these static firings of the uh first
stage and the upper stage. They've
already done a lot of We have water. We
have water.
They've already done uh quite a bit of
um uh testing for uh
the doing like not not a full uh wet
dress rehearsal, but doing tanking tests
to see if um the the the tanks that they
have for the upper stage and the core
stage are going to be able to handle the
pressure that um they have going on. And
let me pause that. Sorry for the noise.
Um, so they've been making excellent
progress and it it really does look to
me like they will be able to to at least
do some static firings of an integrated
rocket. They've already been uh doing
several test firings of the individual
engines, but I really believe that
they'll be able to get everything
together and that's kind of the next
step that they were talking about. Uh
they've been able to do all the
qualifications for their structures. Uh
they've been able to do the engine
qualification. uh they say that
everything so far with launch complex 3
is pretty much ready to go and maybe
most importantly they've gotten their
regulatory approval going. So the next
step is to integrate everything together
and do those tests uh before you know
doing a a full up wet dress rehearsal
and doing their first launches. And also
exciting they've announced their first
um uh payload or paying customer for
Neutron. They claim that they have
payloads for it, but this is the first
official one that they've announced and
it's actually for the Air Force doing
the pointto-point cargo delivery. Uh,
but not with the booster. We know that
the booster of Neutron is going to be
reusable. But whatever the upper stage
delivers for this point-to-point cargo
delivery is either going to have some
sort of parachute system or some sort of
maybe even a rocket propelled system to
be able to land directly pinpoint to
wherever they need that specific payload
to go. And it's a multi-launch contract
as well. So there's going to be quite a
few of those uh that the Air Force wants
to do over the years. Um, I believe that
Rocket Lab, correct me if I'm wrong
here, Ryan, but I believe that Rocket
Lab said that the first one of those
launches for the Air Force will happen
sometime in
2027, you know, pending if there is any
other delays with their development in
the first launch, but I believe that
that's what they said was 2027 for those
Air Force. Yeah, I think they're still
gunning for like a a maiden launch
sometime this year. Whether that
materializes or not, obviously, we'll
just have to wait and see. Once they get
that maiden launch out of the way,
they'll then obviously be able to work
on customer launches. So maybe late
2026, maybe 2027, but I think, you know,
18 months minimum is probably a
realistic bet for that. And using
Burger's law, that then means Q1 2027.
So
who's going to do point to point first,
Rocket Lab or SpaceX? Uh, Rocket Lab.
Well, define pointtooint because SpaceX
has already done it many times to the
Caribbean. Uh, but intact Rocket Lab.
Yeah. Intact. Intact. Delivery. Intact.
An actual delivery. Someone can pick up.
Yeah. Like two too. You you wouldn't
complain.
Like if if your package arrived as uh as
pieces, then you wouldn't you would you
would register a complaint with FedEx,
right? So like a
non-complaintative delivery.
since it's for military purposes, you
know, that whoever is on the receiving
end of that would be able to grab it and
process it pretty quickly. Um, I know
that there was talk of wanting to do
that with uh with Starship, but I don't
know if they've actually gotten any
contracts for it for sure. Um, I could
be wrong. They might already have that.
It just hasn't been announced. Uh,
research. I don't know whether a grant
is the correct term but they have a
research uh uh uh research funding from
the space force uh to point to point and
with it the spaceport spaceport space
force put out an illustration of
something that looks very similar but
isn't exactly a starship landing in some
kind of like remote area with
humanitarian trucks driving out. So the
there's something in there with SpaceX
with pointtooint. Something that's
definitely on in the brain of Elon Musk,
but you know, Optimus,
Mars, yeah, a lot of different things
they want to do with that. So, we'll
see. We'll see what comes first. But I'm
kind of with you. I'm betting on Rocket
Lab being the first one to do this, you
know, military point-to-point transport
thing.
Also, quick thank you to uh Sakura's
Light who just gifted another five uh
memberships to folks in the chat room.
So, thank you very much for that. Much
appreciated. Let's see. I just wanted to
catch up on a couple of things as well.
Jib is a member. All right. All right.
Thank you, Jibby. And we'll all be able
to get that story in a little
bit. All right. Was there anything else
that we uh wanted to discuss when it
comes to uh the Rocket Lab progress? Is
that Did we kind of go over that or did
you guys have any thoughts that this
It's just exciting to finally see
something. You I wish I would I I I like
the investor updates every quarter,
right? But could they do it like every
month? Maybe just give us something a
little bit more often. I want I'm
excited for the progress they're making.
It's uh it's it's nice to
Yeah, absolutely. It is really nice to
see.
All right. Well, um Jamie's in the pixel
protection program.
That was a fun one. That required like a
full restart of Chrome and everything.
Like the whole computer was like
everything's awful and just dumped me.
Time for a new computer, I think. Oh,
you know, you Yeah, Ryan's question
pissed me off.
[Music]
[Laughter]
Oh
man. Well, with that, I think that um we
should probably end things and uh move
over to the after dark. But before we
do, I do want to give a big uh shout out
and thank you to everyone who supports
us through the membership program. And
we have quite a few new people who
signed up for the ground supportable uh
since last week. I want to give a thank
you to David Campbell who has joined uh
Redneck uh Mark Simon Mirmir, Kenneth
Neely, NRJ and Vesters who have uh
rejoined as ground support members. And
then joining for the first time, we also
have Matthew Ki Varela. I hope I
pronounced your name right. Uh
Crossstron and Sun FH. So, thank you to
everyone who is supporting us and uh who
has helped us out week after week to be
able to do this show. We wouldn't be
able to do it without you guys and uh
very much appreciated that for for
everything that you guys are doing. And
for those who have signed up as uh one
of our YouTube members, you'll be able
to get the notification and uh uh tune
in to our after dark show where we
sometimes talk about uh some of the
space stuff, a lot of non-space stuff
and kind of share uh personal stories
and other things that are going on. So
uh if you have that, be sure to tune in
to hear
uh story that we that has piqued all of
our interest as to why DA missed a
shuttle launch apparently. So let's be
clear, I don't wait for after dark. I
just tell you my personal stories in the
middle of the main show. You're welcome.
You're welcome. That's a little preview
that you guys get for free. Yeah. Yeah.
No more stories about your computer.
Dave Avery says obviously it's touchy
about criticism.
Maybe that's why it's going down.
So again, big thank you to everyone for
being here and for joining us today and
uh stay tuned and we will be starting
after dark
momently. So thank you again to
everyone.
[Music]
