Mantegna, Dead Christ

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
24 Video Views·Nov 23, 2022
We're in the Brera in Milan, and we're
looking at one of Andrea Mantegna's most
extraordinary and most famous paintings.
This is the Dead Christ.
Mantegna's son called it the foreshortened Christ.
And this way of representing Christ, so foreshortened,
is really unusual in art history.
Well, certainly I've never seen anything like this.
Now, Mantegna was fascinated throughout much of his career
with extreme perspectives.
You might think about St. James being
led to his execution, where you have a view upward.
Foreshortening is often used by Renaissance artists
to create an illusion of space, an illusion of depth.
But here, Mantegna's using it to draw us in,
to make us feel as though we're at Christ's side
at this moment.
After he's been taken down off the cross,
he's been placed on this stone.
His body is ready to be anointed and shrouded and placed
in the tomb.
One of the comments that people often
make when they look at this and they
think about that kind of very careful perspectival structures
that are being developed in the 15th century
is that this is, in fact, distorted.
That is, the feet are much too small.
And in fact, there's a kind of odd distortion
as you move up the body, where the body seems to grow in size.
But what's fascinating is when you stand
in front of the painting, at least for me,
the feet are seen almost through our peripheral vision.
And our eyes are drawn right up to the face.
No question.
We're drawn to that look of suffering.
We don't have an image of Christ that
transcends human suffering.
There's real pain etched on his forehead,
the way that his eyebrows have been pressed together.
There's a sense of his humanity here.
There is this incredible sense of physicality.
We are so far away from the medieval conception
of the dead Christ that is transcendent and completely
divorced from any kind of pain.
Here, just look at the wounds in the hand or in the feet.
There's almost clinical accuracy.
Look at the way in which the skin has dried.
And it feels like it might even be sharp.
Look at how Mantegna's lifted up the hands
as though he wants to show us Christ's wounds.
The hands are propped up in the same way
that the head is propped up by the pillow.
Well, those are almost the only verticals.
Now, we've been focusing on Christ and the body of Christ
for good reason.
But Christ is not the only figure here.
We seem to be in the tomb itself.
It's dark, but we can make out that there
are three other figures closest to us.
We can just barely make out the profile
of Saint John, the evangelist.
Next to him is an unusual rendering
of the Virgin Mary, who's quite old here and clearly suffering,
seeing her son die.
But just beyond Mary, you can just make out Mary Magdalene.
And the reason that we know it's her
is because on the stone, you can see a jar of the ointment
that Mary Magdalene used to anoint Christ's feet.
We often see that jar as an attribute of Mary Magdalene.
So we know that this painting still
belonged to Mantegna at the time of his death.
In other words, it was never delivered to a patron.
And so this has led art historians
to speculate that perhaps it was rejected by the patron
because of its extreme focus on the dead body of Christ
in this literal way and its intense foreshortening.
It's also possible that Mantegna painted this
for his personal use.
We're just not sure.
We're also not sure if perhaps the intended patron,
if there was one, was somebody who was focusing
on the wounds of Christ.
Right.
Someone whose devotional practice
was focused on the wounds of Christ,
someone who perhaps especially venerated
what's known as the Stone of Unction, the stone
that his body was laid on for anointing.
So these are all questions.
What we do know is that this is a painting that in so many ways
exemplifies the changes that are taking place
in Italian art in the 15th century, where
you have this increasing focus on the physicality of Christ.
We begin to see in the later part of the 1400s
images of Christ, of the saints, depicted very close to us.
It's likely that this is related to ideas of the image
as a kind of prompt to meditate on Christ's suffering,
to imagine what it was like to be at the crucifixion,
to put ourselves there at the tomb at this moment.
