Fra Angelico, The Annunciation

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
39 Video Views·Nov 22, 2022
We're in the large complex that is the convent of San Marco
in Florence, and we're standing in one of the cloisters.
It's a beautiful space with frescoes in all of the lunettes
and a large fresco by Fra Angelico of the crucifixion.
The monastery itself is Dominican,
and that is one of the begging orders.
This is a space where people would
have given up their worldly possessions
and traded them in for a life of prayer and solitude.
And it's a famous place, largely because this
is where Fra Angelico spent most of his life
and where he painted a whole series of frescoes
that we're going to go take a look at.
As we walk past the second cloister
on the left and the refectory, which
includes a large fresco by Ghirlandaio
of the Last Supper, we walk up the stairs.
We pass numerous family crests of the Medici,
which reminds us that they were the dominant patrons
of this convent.
And in fact, Cosimo de' Medici had a cell of his own
that he used on occasion.
When we get to the top of the stairs,
we can see down two long hallways.
About every 10 or so feet, there's
an opening with a small wooden door
into a small cell that would have
been a space for a monk to sleep,
but also a place for prayer and meditation.
And on the walls are frescoes by Fra Angelico and his followers.
This must be freezing in the winter.
There's no insulation whatsoever.
Let's turn our attention to the large fresco
at the top of the stairs, though.
It's really a masterpiece.
This one is quite large and has figures that are life-size.
It starts about four feet off the ground,
so we can look up at the scene of the Annunciation.
But it also allows us to see this fresco much more
close up than we'd normally be able to in a large, say,
basilica environment.
That's true.
We're not far away the way we might see an altar.
It's just a beautiful image, but it's also very spare.
And the spareness seems to really
be fitting for this monastic space.
Right, and the actual loggia, or open porchway space
that the Madonna and Angel Gabriel occupy
seems to match the cloister that we were just in
and the windows that we see around us.
We see in the room behind Mary.
So it really feels as though Mary and the Angel Gabriel
are in a space very much like the one
that the monks themselves inhabited,
which must have helped them to think
about this moment of the Annunciation.
This is the Annunciation.
Our Archangel Gabriel has appeared
to Mary to announce to her that she'll be bearing God.
Now, what's interesting is that in many paintings
of the Annunciation, you would expect to see a lot
of other kinds of accoutrements.
You'd expect to see white lilies as a symbol of her virginity.
You would expect to see her having been interrupted
reading the Bible, expressing her piousness.
And some art historians have suggested
that some of these symbols are missing
because the monks already know the story well.
This painting doesn't have to be as didactic
as it might have to be if its audience was
a lay audience in a church.
It gives room to the monks themselves
to fill in the rest of the story for themselves.
And I think that's one way in which it was an aid in prayer.
It was so simple and so spare, not only this fresco,
but the ones in the cells, too, that it would not
interfere with the monks' own imaginings.
There's two things that I think are worth pointing out,
which is understanding this fresco
within the context of these hallways
on the second floor of the monastery.
For one thing, as we look down the hallway,
we see doors that are too small for this space.
And there's a kind of interesting relationship
between the receding doors and the receding
orthogonals that we see down the hallway on the left
and the loggia, the columns on the left,
leading to a doorway that is visually too small also.
And so there's a nice complement that exists there.
The other thing is that the vanishing point seems too high
and the floor seems to be too steep.
But when you look at this fresco as you ascend the staircase,
it makes more sense.
You're seeing it at an extreme.
From far below.
That's right, in an oblique angle.
And so I think it's really important to understand
this painting, not in the isolation of a reproduction,
but spatially in the context of San Marco.
I think that's true.
There's really no atmospheric perspective.
So that raises another interesting issue here,
which is there's real ambiguity in the space of this painting.
You've got that flatness on the left side,
this insistence on the two-dimensionality
of the forest, of the lawn.
And then there's ambiguity on the right side as well.
There is some reference to linear perspective.
But at the same time, the figures
are much too large for this space.
Right.
If Mary stands up, she's going to hit her head on the ceiling.
For Masaccio, the space and the scale of the figures
would really have to be perfectly aligned.
I think that there are a number of ways
that Fra Angelico is balancing competing needs.
For example, if we think about light,
which is one of the things that was so important for Masaccio,
just 20 years or less before this was painted,
we do see light coming in from the left.
Yes, from the upper left.
And so when you look at the columns,
they're clearly modeled.
We can see shadowing on the right.
Especially in the groin vaults.
But I don't see cast shadows from the columns.
So maybe there is a little bit of one in that one on the left.
But very soft.
But there is more of a shadow that Mary casts on the right.
In the earthly sphere.
And the angel Gabriel doesn't seem to cast a shadow.
If you look at their halos, he's using those flat, round halos
like we saw in the 1300s, and not those foreshortened halos
that we see Masaccio use.
There does seem to be a willful kind
of historicizing in that sense.
Or a kind of not complete acceptance
of the fully earthly rendering that
is so prominent in Florence in the 15th century,
and especially at this moment.
It's almost totally aware of Masaccio
in what we might call the most advanced humanist styles.
But also an unwillingness to go that far
and holding to a more conservative or traditional
aspects in some ways.
And it does seem to totally make sense,
given the monastic environment that we're in.
And also Fra Angelico's own spirituality.
That kind of tension really speaks
to these developing techniques as having
a spiritual or even political dimension.
And that these were things that could be chosen.
There were lots of styles that were
available in the 15th century in Florence,
depending on a whole lot of things.
There's also subtlety, for example.
We were talking about the spareness of this painting.
There are areas where the artist allows himself to really create
a very decorative set of forms.
For instance, look at Gabriel's wings.
Not only are they just beautifully detailed,
but if you look really carefully,
and this is something that doesn't
come across in photographs, he must
have used a kind of mica or some sort of mineral
that really catches the light.
Because as you walk past this fresco,
it picks up light and twinkles.
It does.
It sparkles a little bit, especially in the darker paint.
Look at how Mary and the angel look similar.
Both idealized, but a kind of lack of specificity.
The faces, although they're generalized,
are very specific in certain ways as well,
especially around the eyes, which
are actually the most detailed part of the entire painting.
You really feel, even though they're
separated by this column, that their gazes meet
and are locked in place.
And the way that Mary bends forward a bit
and accepts her responsibility that Gabriel's announcing
to her feels very, very serious to me.
Very solemn.
So should we go and take a look at some of the cells?
Sure.
We're looking in one of the very small monk's cells.
It's a small dorm room, really.
And what would you say, maybe 8 by 10 feet, not even?
It's very small, with a window and covered by a barrel vault.
The wall opposite the doorway is a fresco
by Fra Angelico of another Annunciation scene,
this time even more spare.
We don't have the garden that we saw in the Annunciation
scene in the hallway.
We have the Archangel Gabriel, this time standing,
Mary on a small stool, kneeling.
Although her body is so elongated,
it's actually hard to tell where her knees would be,
where the lower part of her body is.
And like all the other frescoes in the cells,
St. Dominic is included, although you
can see he's very carefully put outside the space
that Mary and the Angel Gabriel occupy.
Very much like we are as we gaze into this cell.
So he's a witness, as we're a witness.
Exactly.
He's, in a way, a kind of stand-in for us,
a kind of way for us into the painting.
I am struck by the way in which the architecture depicted
within this smaller fresco is such a beautiful complement
to the spare space that we're in.
And to think about this as a painting
that a monk would have lived with for much of his life.
This is something that you would have gone to sleep with,
that you would have prayed with, that you would have woken to.
And that this was the single bit of ornament in this room.
So the Convent of San Marco is well known
not only for the extraordinary frescoes by Fra Angelico,
but also by another resident.
We're talking about Savonarola, who
was a fervent religious leader in the late 1490s in Florence.
He was actually the prior of this convent.
That is, he was in charge.
And he was zealous about renouncing
the luxuries of the mercantile culture
that Florence had developed.
His religious beliefs became stronger and more radical,
and came into increasing conflict
with the wealth and artistry of the city.
He denounced the humanist culture of Medici, Florence.
It's interesting, because the Medici's were originally
his sponsors, his patrons.
He advocated book burning, and the burning
of what he considered luxury items.
This was called the Bonfire of the Vanities.
And it took place just outside of the Signoria,
where we think paintings, books, and articles of luxury,
including clothing, were burned.
There's a brief period when Savonarola actually
took over the government of Florence.
He was ultimately excommunicated by the pope,
but refused to abide by the excommunication, which
put Florence in real jeopardy.
His advocacy of a really spare and ascetic lifestyle
made things very difficult in Florence economically.
The economy was based on trade and luxury goods.
And the manufacture and sale of luxury goods, that's right.
And so you can see that this kind of conflict
would have ultimately created a backlash, and it did.
San Marco was stormed.
And Savonarola was taken prisoner,
and would ultimately be hanged with two of his compatriots
until he was almost dead, at which point a large fire was
set below him, and they were burned to death.
It's hard to remember those kinds of details sometimes
when you walk through and you look at these lovely paintings,
to remember this as not just a place for tourists' visit,
but a place that had a real role in Florence's history
in the 15th century.
And a kind of religious intensity
that I think is difficult to remember.
Certainly that story speaks of it,
and its excesses, and its dangers.
