Cimabue, Santa Trinita Madonna & Giotto's Ognissanti Madonna

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
69 Video Views·Dec 6, 2022
So we were going to do a comparison of two
great Proto-Renaissance masters, Cimabue and Giotto,
and compare them by looking at two paintings of the Madonna
and Throne, so exactly the same subject.
These are both in the Uffizi in Florence.
But originally, of course, there were altar paintings, panels,
which are very large.
In fact, the Cimabue is, what is it?
More than 12 feet.
Yeah, it's 12 feet tall.
It's huge.
And that was so that it could be seen
in the full distance of the church nave.
And the Giotto, too, is more than 10 feet high.
The Cimabue is a little earlier.
And Cimabue is the very first artist
that Vasari talks about at the very beginning
of this incredible tradition of Italian painting.
So Cimabue is really seen to make this first step away
from a medieval style toward a more
human-focused Renaissance style.
Yeah, and there's a lot of controversy and interest
in terms of why the Renaissance has
its roots at this particular moment
in this particular place.
Why in Florence, and why right here
at the end of the 13th century?
And one of the theories that's been put forward
is pressure that was being felt in the Byzantine Empire
to the east by Islam.
And some of the art is perhaps fleeing
the great traditions of the east and coming to Italy,
and perhaps prompting it to think beyond the traditions
of the medieval.
The first thing to say is that this is just
a really standard subject that we see all the time.
Mary, the mother of Christ, holding the Christ child
surrounded by angels and or saints and prophets.
Lots and lots of gold.
These are tempera paintings on wooden panels.
It's egg tempera, and it's using minerals that
are suspended in that egg media.
It's good for little lines.
It doesn't blend well.
It dries quickly.
And so there's a really linear aspect
to this painting, which may in some respects
result from the tempera.
This is gold that's been flattened out.
It's a very thin gold leaf.
And in fact, even tooled, that is to say,
patterns have been pounded in to make it even more interesting.
And then it's been glued onto the wooden panel.
It's been burnished, and sometimes there's
a clay layer underneath, which you can sometimes
see, a little reddish.
But the gold itself is really meant
as this ornamental reflective material that
had a symbolic quality in that it was meant
to reflect the light of heaven.
Neither of these are set in any kind of earthly realm.
The flat gold background indicates
a kind of divine, heavenly space for these figures to occupy.
And that makes sense when you look at the Chimabue,
because the Madonna, for instance, she's so,
I guess maybe because she's defined by line,
if she stood up, she would be so tall.
She would be very elongated.
And her drapery is defined by line primarily,
and not as much by modeling from light to dark,
although a little bit.
There are some distinct medieval or Byzantine elements
that are still visible here.
Her fingers are very long.
Her mouth is very small.
The nose is very long.
Kind of symbolism of the body, not
a representation of a real person
so much as a representation of a kind of ideal heavenly form.
The angels are all stacked kind of on top of one another.
It's a good thing they have wings, isn't it?
Yes.
Because what are they standing on?
I don't know.
But we do begin to get some sense
of the beginnings of an illusion of space in Chimabue.
She's got a little modeling under her chin.
And you're right.
The throne on which she sits does sort of recede.
Except here's the funny thing.
When you look at the throne carefully,
it looks as if we're looking across at the Virgin Mary,
but we're looking down at the seat on which she's seated.
And in some ways, we're also looking up at her.
There's not a single perspectival point
in which the viewer is situated.
We have sort of multiple viewpoints.
And that's something that, of course,
will disappear more than a century later when
we get to Brunelleschi in the early Renaissance.
But I'm not comfortable with the idea
that Chimabue couldn't do it.
No.
So what about the four figures underneath?
It's interesting that they're behind there.
It does show some illusion of space.
It does.
And it kind of frames them as well.
It does.
And they're adorable down there, those prophets.
You can always tell the prophets because they're
holding scrolls.
OK, so these are Old Testament prophets.
Right, who would have predicted the coming of a Messiah,
a Christ.
And here, in the Catholic tradition, of course,
that would have been understood as Christ, as you said.
Let's look over now at the Giotto
because things have really changed.
Madonna just looks so massive and bulky.
And look at how her hips and her thighs cover that seat
And her knee projects forward.
Her breasts are in these.
And look at how differently the drapery is indicated.
Instead of by these tiny lines, we now
have real modeling from light to dark
to indicate her knees and her lap.
And even how the drapery pulls across her chest and her
breasts.
Look at the back of the Cimabue now.
The Madonna looks so thin, almost
as if she's a paper cutout.
And the Giotto looks so substantial, so solid.
It's also interesting if you compare the angels
because in the Cimabue, in the earlier painting,
the angels are stacked up.
They don't sort of respond to gravity.
And they're also all very similar.
They're sort of an idealized face.
But if you look at the angels in the Giotto rendering
from a few decades later, actually
what's really interesting is Giotto
is willing to put the angels in back of each other,
even obscuring their faces.
And the way that they sort of seem
to go back behind the throne is peeking his head
through in the back there.
And yeah, the prophets aren't in some sort
of impossible basement now.
And look at how much more modeling is in her face
and in her neck.
There's one aspect of the painting by Giotto
that I think is really significant and really
interesting.
In the Giotto, there's a very particular single point
that the viewer is looking at this from.
If you look, for instance, at the steps moving up
to the Virgin, you're looking down
at the top of the step clearly.
So you know your eyes above that.
But you're also looking up at the ceiling of the throne.
So you're looking.
So you're somewhere in between.
And in fact, you're looking down at the seat.
But you'll notice that just where the prophets' chins are,
that's where everything sort of is exactly horizontal.
So that's the line at which our height.
And that makes sense because that
would put us just below Christ, a nice, humble position.
There's a kind of left-right access,
too, which is to say that I think
we can see a little bit more of the right window.
So I think we're facing Christ.
This begins to situate the viewer.
This is not linear perspective.
It's only kind of a more awareness
of the human presence in front of the painting.
I think that's exactly right.
One of the things that I like to think about
is how similar these two images are despite their differences
and the ways in which the understanding of originality
was so entirely different than in our own culture.
Right.
So this is not so much derivative
in a negative sense, as we might think.
In fact, there was a real tradition of the ways
that you represent these figures because these are holy figures.
That makes sense.
And also, this is very universal.
This is something that transcends time.
It transcends space.
Right.
But even within that, Giotto is still
creating this new image because obviously things
are beginning to change in the early 1300s.
But he must be responding to cultural changes.
That is, putting an emphasis on the here and now in a way
that will, of course, blossom into the Renaissance.
Exactly.
