This Mona Lisa video has been updated, please see link below

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
25 Video Views·Nov 22, 2022
We thought we would start by looking at what is perhaps the most famous painting in the world
and whether we can actually even really still see it. Right, because I have seen this before
and I've even visited it at the Louvre. I know I'm pronouncing it wrong.
Yes, you're right. This is probably the most famous painting in the world.
And I just read that most people spend about 15 seconds in the Louvre looking at the painting,
which is a funny statistic. Well, it's stressful because there's people behind
you. And on top of that, it's actually surprisingly small when you see it in real
life. I mean, now that I'm able to take my time and not worry about the tourists behind me and
I'm looking at it for real, I'm already things are jumping out at me that I actually had never
noticed before. Like what? Well, it looks like the scenery in this some kind of like
Vulcan territory or something. It's like mountainous. And like you said,
there's a little bridge in there. There's a road. I guess I never paid much attention to that
before. And yeah, actually, I never even noticed this chair she was on before either. You see her
hand resting on it actually. And I never noticed that there's a ledge right behind her where
there's like jars. But yeah, I could probably keep going. I like your analogy to Vulcan territory.
As a Star Trek fan myself, that landscape is otherworldly and very mysterious. But
it's interesting, isn't it? How the bottom part of the landscape at her neck and below
looks like an inhabited landscape with a winding road and a bridge. But the landscape that's at
her neck and head is more mysterious and looks very much like another planet.
That's right. And actually, when you when you point that out and how that painting is divided
based on where those landscapes and the ledge divide the painting, I don't have my ruler out,
but I would guess that it's pretty close to the golden mean. I think you're probably right. Those
things that look like jars are actually the bottom of columns cut off on either side of the painting.
So Leonardo da Vinci actually painted the columns and it was cropped.
That's right. And so the space that she's in would have made a lot more sense as a balcony.
And well, you know, all of this, actually, just take a step back. And we started with this
presumption that it's true that that is probably the most famous painting in the world. But
I guess I've never quite gotten why. I mean, is this just a case of marketing?
I think it happened in 1911 when the painting was stolen from the Louvre and disappeared for a
couple of years and became notorious at that point. In the 19th century, the Mona Lisa was
not the most popular painting at the Louvre. Paintings by other artists like Titian and
Raphael were much more popular and even valued more highly for insurance purposes. So it really
probably is only in the 20th century that she became as important as she is now.
If you go back 150 years ago, Mona Lisa was not something that was just ingrained in our culture.
She was important. People were interested in her and people were writing about her and they said
some interesting things. But she wasn't as famous as she is now. And also, don't forget that
the technology to reproduce her existed only really in the 20th century in terms of
mass color reproductions. And so her currency has certainly increased, I think, in the last
hundred years or so. I see. If you go back 150 years,
there was probably no such thing as super famous paintings.
I think that might be true, actually. There were paintings that were famous or important,
but not celebrities in the way that the Mona Lisa is.
Probably not something that every person on the street would recognize.
Yeah. And, of course, now I think most people would say that what's so interesting about her
is her look and her smile, which have been interpreted in many different ways.
You know, and I know that's kind of what, I guess, one of the claims to fame of the
painting. And you see that. I mean, you know, people like to look at it. Is she smirking?
Is she happy? Is she sad? All of these things. Is she looking at you? All of these things that
people try to. But I guess trying to look at it without all of the social programming that I've
had around this painting, it strikes me as an interesting painting. And it seems very
technically well done and something very bright and just kind of aura around her face. I don't
know if I wasn't programmed to really know this painting and if I were to see this in the museum,
amongst many, many others, that it would really jump out at me.
Portraits really took off during the Renaissance, beginning in the 1400s in Italy. And Leonardo
painted this in Florence. And that's because of humanism. One way that we define humanism is
taking an interest in human beings and the things of this world and human achievement
and individuality, all of those values becoming more important in the 15th century. And so we
begin to see a lot more portraits. Also with the beginnings of a wealthy merchant class in Florence
in the 15th century, people can afford portraits and begin to want them. At first, portraits were
painted with a figure in profile. But later, especially in Northern Europe, artists like
Durer or Memling started to put their figures in believable spaces. And so Leonardo is really
the first artist in Italy to do those things, to make an oil painting, which is a relatively new
medium in Italy. What were the people used before oil? They used fresco and tempera painting, tempera
for panel painting. So this is oil on wood, whereas before artists would paint tempera on wood.
Tempera tends to look more flat than oil paint, where you can really get a sense of modeling and
light and dark. So Leonardo's making this three-dimensional figure. And he's using another
technique called sfumato, which means a kind of smoky haziness. So he obscures the hard outlines
around the forms, which tend to flatten them. One of the things that's fun to talk about with
Mona Lisa, too, is all the things that people have said about her over the years. You might not be
aware of the fact that Sigmund Freud actually had a particular interpretation of the Mona Lisa.
Yes, I'm sure he did. I'm somewhat skeptical of it. I would like to interpret his interpretation
someday, but yes. Freud said that the Mona Lisa's smile combined the two ways that we tend to look
at women in our culture. In one way, she's very mothering and nurturing. And in the other way,
she seems very seductive. I think that says more about Freud than about Leonardo. You could
be right. And later artists, another artist that you already know, Duchamp. Duchamp, my favorite.
Your favorite. He took a reproduction of the Mona Lisa and drew a mustache on her. I could imagine
him doing that. I think the mustache is interesting because there is something not entirely feminine
about her, something a little bit masculine. Do you think it's that, or I mean, I guess there's
a certain, I mean, it's kind of old now, especially because Duchamp did it, I'm guessing,
you know, 80, 90 years ago. But there is something hilarious about drawing a mustache on a feminine
form. We all remember doing it as school kids, just getting a kick out of it. And I could see
it's especially funny for this painting. Taking something that's so high art and making it silly.
Exactly. Recently, the Prado in Madrid found what turns out to be, after some scientific testing,
a copy of the Mona Lisa, which in and of itself is not that unusual. But it turns out that their
copy was made by another artist sitting right next to Leonardo, copying what he did stroke
for stroke. And they can tell this by analyzing the underdrawing. Yeah, she looks much younger.
She has eyebrows. Oh, that's right. I mean, it makes you appreciate it. That's where the
creepiness comes from, because the Mona Lisa looks jaundiced. It's yellow. And so the painting
is a little bit different. The face is a little bit different. But we can assume that the colors
might have not been that different. Exactly. And it's a really interesting thing to think
about what she would look like if she was cleaned. And if she would still mean what
she means to us. Oh, I don't think she would. Because when I look at this cleaned painting,
it loses a lot of the mystery. Yeah, I agree. And you can then understand the Lou's decision
not to clean her. I mean, the cleaned one, she looks better. She looks younger.
She loses a lot of the motherly aspects that Freud seems to want to ascribe to her. Yeah,
because the colors are brighter. They're more vibrant. It's not as muted as the one that we've
learned to like. Yeah. Although her reputation has grown over the years. He used to say that
we won't care so much about her again. There might be a post-celebrity world at some point.
