And then all of a sudden you have like a American flag on your forehead.
It doesn't work like that.
I don't even have my full American card in this country.
So cocky motherland Asians disagree with sensitive Asian Americans
on what counts as cultural appropriation, who is right and who is wrong.
Let's play the clips that represent the two main viewpoints.
If you're a mainland Asian, your perspective on cultural appropriation
of Asian culture is essentially meaningless.
And if you're not Asian at all, it's completely meaningless,
because in both cases, it doesn't affect you.
I just want to say I'm so tired of seeing on TikTok
that Asian-Americans telling a white person or a black person
or anyone in general that's not Asian to stop cultural appropriating our culture.
I mean, first of all, you're American.
Like if you go to China, if you go to Hong Kong, Japan.
Yeah, you look like us, but you're American.
Welcome, everybody, to the Hot Pop Boys.
David, what is going on in Asian-America?
Brad Pitt has a new movie called Bullet Train, Andrew.
It's set in Tokyo, but there are no main Asian actors in it.
Of course, the Asian-Americans, they're up in arms about it,
calling it racist, whitewashing, you know, Emma Stone, Scarlett Johansson.
The jokes don't stop.
And then, of course, Andrew, in Asia, Asia, the writer of the original source
material, whose Japanese was like, hmm, it's OK to me.
The West is the West.
The East is the East.
Let them make a Hollywood movie.
All right, guys.
So listen, this is a discussion that pops up all the time.
And what we're trying to do here is move the discussion forward.
So we're going to break it down from a micro mid to a macro level.
And hopefully by the end of this video, we'll give you a reasonable answer.
Let's get into it, David.
What's the definition of appropriation and appreciation?
Real quick, real quick.
I'll just pop them up on the screen.
I think the main overlooked aspect is the power dynamic from typically
dominant groups to typically non-dominant groups.
So anyway, let's get into it.
In the micro, Andrew, it really just boils down to attitude and details.
If you have a good attitude and spirit about something, Andrew,
you'll learn more than you use.
So, for example, if you're wearing traditional clothing
and you're celebrating a traditional holiday, that's like what?
Two out of ten, three.
Then your knowledge base should be out of four.
So you should just know more than you use showing that you actually care.
I think someone who is most famously known for having a good attitude
was Anthony Bourdain about Asian food and especially Southeast Asian food.
He really gave it its praise.
He didn't try to claim it.
He didn't try to invent it.
He just promoted it.
And people appreciated that. Yeah.
And if you look at the power
dynamic between like Western Europe and Southeast Asia, it is gigantic.
And for him to like close that gap, like it meant a lot to a lot of people.
Right now, sometimes is it murky, though?
Like, can you mix it up? Appropriation and appreciation.
Can it be both at the same time?
Yeah, I think it shifts even in the context.
And sometimes it can be both.
Like, for example, Andrew, all those videos, they got 20,
30 million views of white guys speaking Mandarin to like some villagers,
whether that's in Chinatown or in China.
And just like there's 30 million views because they're like
treating that person like a god.
That's appreciation and appropriation at the same time.
The appreciation to learn the culture, to learn the language.
But the appropriation is playing off that power dynamic to get the views.
Because basically, of course,
like people lower in the power dynamic are shocked that the master or like
the A1 is learning like the B1 or C1 or D1 language.
Yeah. And then there's that one PragerU video where this guy's wearing a straw
like rice hat with a silky, shiny cheongsam asking people like, oh,
is this wrong? Is this wrong?
And a bunch of people say it's wrong.
And then he's trying to make them look stupid.
And I was like, listen, you might not be saying any race,
anything racist with your words, but you're definitely trolling
and trying to look ridiculous because that's not even an outfit anybody wears.
And it's not even like there's no point in wearing it on the UCLA campus.
But I would not expect Asians in Asia watching that or an Asian who like lives
in a fully Asian world like he goes to Chinatown and gets like an affirming
response to fully understand it because they're living in a context
where they're dominant.
It literally has to go back to the original definition of appropriation.
It has to do with who's dominant in what context.
That has a lot to do with the political ideology and the threshold of
did you violate, did you not violate?
Of course, everybody's threshold is somewhat calibrated differently.
Yeah. Basically, if someone comes to what you consider is your zone,
your home, your land or your context,
and even if it's like 50 50 trolling or disrespect,
you might just feel so comfortable.
You're just like, whatever. Yeah, it's cool.
I mean, you bought that turn some off the street.
So you put money in Chinese pockets where say whatever. Yeah.
And I mean, that's just literally driven
from your own personal incentive and experiences.
It's like I can see why reasonable people could disagree on this issue.
And that's why nobody can agree on appropriation versus appreciation,
because the answer is so murky, to be honest.
Let's move on, Andrew, to the middle view.
I think that both C.K.
Lam and Yong Wheezy make some points.
And it kills me to say that because I want to just take Yong Wheezy's
perspective, Yong Wheezy, I'm sorry.
But I think they both get split at 50 50 because C.K.
Lam is right that a lot of Asian
Americans don't even know enough about their traditional culture
to be gatekeepers because they haven't done the research. Right.
And number two, I'll say she didn't say this.
I think sometimes we put too much of our stock and self-worth
in the Hollywood narratives, not understanding that.
Like, why would Hollywood value us like an equal?
Like we're just simply not in their eyes.
So why do we keep getting mad and losing sleep every time it happens?
Wait, you're saying too many Asians are putting their self-worth
in something that we can't control?
Yeah, they're like basically
complaining about the crumbs off the mainstream piece of bread
that are thrown to us, but they're still making that piece of bread
or the crumbs that get thrown down their God.
So how can you like worship like a God that doesn't like like you, I guess,
like or ranks you as a second class citizen or a third class citizen?
Isn't that kind of ridiculous?
Wouldn't the you know, theoretically, you should just stop looking
at that piece of bread like it's God because it doesn't value you.
And then it's also confusing, on the other hand,
because America has such a deep history of trying to like erase
marginalized groups, cultures or forget about them or oppress them.
So like now you got to be sensitive and shout out to them
and always acknowledge it or else you're being wrong.
Now, I would say this.
The motherland Asians got to hear us out on this one in a way,
just because like this is a battle that we fight in America.
We're talking about Western faces, Western media, Western country,
Western dynamics, and the Western media affects Asians in the West the most.
But it's a fight that when Asians in America fight for respect,
it also does help Asians worldwide because, for example,
Hollywood is exported worldwide.
So it does kind of matter. Right.
I mean, at the end of the day, if you're not in the field,
you're not in the field. Right.
And obviously, Asian-Americans, us growing up in the West,
we're in the field.
So, you know, the other people,
they may make some valid points as spectators on the outside,
but they're spectators, you know.
And one thing that C.K.
Lam said that really pissed a lot of people off was like, yeah,
you guys are just American.
Like who cares about your opinion on Asian things?
And it's like, dang, man, it's not like, you know,
you cross the border, you're born here.
And then all of a sudden you have like a American flag on your forehead.
It doesn't work like that.
I don't even have my full American card in this country.
So that's how I feel.
I think at the end of the day, my macro takeaway is that it really
just comes down to like dominance and comfortability.
And, you know, a lot of Asians that are growing up in Asia, not all of them.
And by the way, I don't think 100 percent of Asian-Americans feel the same.
A hundred percent of motherland Asians feel the same.
They just don't want to lose that comfortability and sense of dominance,
even if they like move to the West.
Like, for example, CK Lam, I think she lives in America.
It's like they just don't want to lose that sense of feeling dominant
because it doesn't feel good to be a minority.
So they're just going to align themselves with the perspective
that makes their own mental feel the most comfortable.
Yeah, well, I mean, in their defense, you know, of like you're
from a well-off family in like Beijing, you're like, yeah, I'm cool in Beijing.
I feel very secure about my identity.
I moved to America.
Why would I want to drop my identity of being cool
and have to complain about all these minority issues?
Yeah, no, it's true.
I mean, it is a human nature, guys, because you don't necessarily run off.
What is the truth?
You run off. What is your truth?
Yeah, David, this is just a funny idea.
I'm going to throw it out there.
What if some white people are trying to defend themselves
because they're like, dude, China's coming up?
China's power is going to be more than America, at least economically.
So that means we can start doing these funny accents
without it being appropriation and disrespectful.
Yeah, I mean, they could be going off some sort of like shift
in global power metric.
You know, I don't know.
I mean, they'd have to be pretty geopolitical if I want to wear a rice hat.
I just think at the end of the day, my final takeaway is that if Asian-Americans
were really doing the first and second tier work of building community,
understanding socioeconomic differences, building alliances
with other groups of people, including white people,
then they wouldn't be as concerned with what a few people in Hollywood
or like conservative pundits say.
You know what I mean?
Because if you're really doing the work, it's not that the complaints
about cultural appropriation or disrespect aren't real.
But when you're just focused on first and second tier building
and you're just building and building and building and attacking,
you're not as sensitive on playing the defense
and you're not like always on your heels.
So I just think that, you know, I'm not trying to toot our own horn,
but we do the work to understand like deep diasporic communities,
deep ancient culture.
We try our best.
I'm not saying we do a ten out of ten job all the time.
But we really try.
So that's why when I see this type of stuff like Tilda Swinton
not caring about Asians or Prager, you not caring about Asians,
I'm just like, yeah, they don't.
But moving on, I got other projects to work on.
I mean, are you trying to say that if you're a true contributor,
you're probably not the biggest complainer?
Yeah, because at the end of the day,
you know what it means to like build something at its core.
It's that's really important.
Yeah, I do think more Asian-Americans need to work and not worry.
I'm not saying worry and a complaint is wrong.
It's not wrong, but it usually comes from a place of feeling like helpless.
And that's the only thing that you can do.
But if other Asians can like, you know, figure out other ways to help,
I think it's better.
I think it overall makes us stronger.
And my last final point on this is like I would take the more Asian-American
angle on this just because, listen, we're dealing with Western dynamics,
with Western media. This is our fight.
I know a lot of Asians from Asia.
They might not have to go through the same things that we go through.
Some of them have when they got here, but a lot of them didn't.
So I'm saying like you just have to understand our viewpoint
and don't write it off because this is this is an American thing.
Human nature is selfish, man.
At the end of the day,
a lot of people just want to think about the perspective
that makes their life the best rather than what is the macro
zoomed out bird's eye truth.
David, guess what?
CK Lamb, she doesn't want to feel bad about appropriation.
And guess what?
Young Woozie, he wants to make CK Lamb feel bad about not feeling bad.
Yeah. And both are right and both are wrong.
I don't know. It just depends on how you perceive life.
Let us know what you think in the comments section below, guys.
I thought we wrapped up an eternal discussion.
Like I said, you know, people are going to have different lives
so they can have a different perspective on it.
But hopefully we move the discussion forward from one to two to hopefully
to three to that's our goal.
Let us know what you think.
Only on the Hot Pop Boys are we touching these crazy topics.
Let us know. And until next time we out. Peace.