There Are No More Chinese Adoptees

FUNG BROS.
592 followers
1.7K Video Views·Sep 17, 2024
China has officially stopped all foreign adoption
and this has a lot of people wondering why.
Yeah, let's take a look at some of the news clip headlines.
China stops foreign adoptions,
ending a complicated chapter.
Why did China stop its foreign adoption program?
Beijing said the move was in line with international trends
as more countries have limited such adoptions.
Many would-be adoptive families are left in limbo.
Wow, so China's trying to say it's trendy now,
so that's why we're doing it.
But anyways, guys, we're gonna get into this,
the reasons why China may have cut
foreign adoption right now.
And it is messing with a lot of families
who are in limbo, who are in the process
of adopting a Chinese baby, but now they can't
and that's very disappointing for them.
Right, right, right.
And you know, I will say this early on,
that's sort of the way China does things.
Like, they could've eased into this a little bit better
or allowed the pending cases to process, then ended it.
But obviously, when you do things in a very heavy-handed,
strict way, you make a lot of people mad.
Yeah, China doesn't care about feelings,
let's just say that, for better or for worse.
Right, with its own people, outside people,
I mean, that's just how it is.
I mean, I guess, David, let's just really quickly
talk about the past few decades.
Obviously, we've known Chinese adoptees ourselves.
We also know Korean adoptees, for example.
So a lot of countries, at a time when in need
or if another country is doing better than another country,
then oftentimes, they will adopt from the other countries.
Yeah, I mean, if you grew up anywhere around America,
everybody knows an adopted Asian.
Yes.
Like, it's a very common trend.
South Korea still actually has it going on,
but they have many programs in place
that highly prioritize domestic adoption.
And that's sort of the phase
that China's trying to move into.
Now, a lot of people are saying
this is spurred by the population problem.
Obviously, it was initially started three decades ago
by the one-child policy.
And I guess a lot of people are saying,
like, what are the reasons why?
Right, and so we're gonna get into a list
of possible reasons why,
which I don't think it's fully clear
what the single reason is,
or if there's multiple reasons for,
there's probably multiple reasons.
And then we're gonna get into the reactions
of even some Chinese adoptees on the internet.
So everybody, please hit that like button.
Check out other episodes of the Hot Pop Boys.
Number one, it could be for population reasons
because for the second year in a row,
Andrew, China has had a negative birth rate,
meaning that the population's shrinking.
Right, so I think they figure like,
hey guys, if people are having less babies
and people are getting married less,
then maybe we should try to keep
as many Chinese kids as possible
and do internal adopting.
And I think that this is probably the number one reason
that people are going to because they think,
from a mathematical standpoint, it kind of makes sense.
But I think the only reason why
I don't think this is the only reason,
although I think this is one of the reasons why,
is because over, let's say, the past 35 years
since adopting from China has been a popular thing,
there's been about 82,000 adoptees
from China to America, for example.
Now, 82,000, that is quite a few people,
but over the span of 35 years
and in the sense of China's general population,
it's not that many people to really make a dent
in the decline, you know what I mean?
But other people were saying that of that 82,000,
obviously there was a mixture of people in there,
but it was mostly girls.
Yes, that is true.
So I mean, I think if it's like,
if it was either, okay, we're gonna let people adopt
10,000 Chinese baby girls every year for the next 20 years,
that's probably, we should be able
to support those people ourselves.
Right, right, right, and by the way, guys,
the majority of kids that are giving up for adoption
are either female or kids with disabilities.
Moving on, number two, it could be a statement of,
we don't need to allow overseas adoption anymore
because we have better systems,
better systems for single mothers,
better systems in the orphanages or foster care,
et cetera, et cetera.
It has to do with confidence in internal system building.
Yeah, and I mean, the foreign adoption thing,
it was mostly because China had a fear
that they could not support more kids, right?
That's why they had the one-child policy.
It led to a lot of ugly stories, a lot of terrible stories
of especially baby girls getting thrown away
and essentially these terrible stories.
But the reason was because they were scared
they couldn't support it.
So now China's like, hey, guys, we're a lot better now.
We can support everybody in our country.
We don't have to let people adopt our kids.
Right, number three, it may just be a point of pride
in the sense of trying to let people know
we're not a country that gives up our babies
to Western countries anymore.
I think it's partially nationalism for the internal market.
Like as much as some people,
and we're gonna talk about maybe the geopolitical play
or the symbolism behind this,
but essentially China would try to tell its own citizens
like, hey, everybody, we can handle this
and we're not just going to like,
because a country, you know, for nationalism,
you wanna keep your people essentially.
Right, right, right.
Well, especially it's saying like
the West is not incredibly so superior to us anymore
that we just gotta like offload everything
that we can't handle.
Right, because it was out of disparity
usually to let people adopt thousands of babies.
But I do think, for example,
Russia and recently ended adoption only to America.
So that was more geopolitical
because if you know Russia and America
are kind of at a proxy war through Ukraine right now.
We're not going to let America take any more of our babies.
Number four, China has promoted domestic adoption
over the past few years.
Like we said, you get, if people are having less babies,
that may mean there's more couples that want to adopt.
Yeah, I do think adopting is a little bit more accepted
in China than it was 20 years ago.
I think that there was, obviously there's this stigma
of like, okay, adopted kids,
well, what families do they come from
or people didn't want them for some reason.
But I think in China, yes,
now people are actually kind of trying to adopt.
So 90% of adoptions in China
from the statistic that I found are domestic.
So China's not adopting too many foreign babies, really.
Right, right, right.
Point number five, it's just flexing,
showing that they could just change programs
whenever they want.
Yeah, I think that, is this, David,
kind of a geopolitical flex a little bit?
Just being like, yeah, you know, like,
we'll just, you just can't have any more babies.
Possibly.
I mean, I know in China, I'll tell you this, man,
they make decisions just quick.
They do not feel the need
to ease the international community into anything.
Point number six,
maybe just all children are more valued nowadays.
And point number seven, I will say this, man,
this is my major takeaway from this,
because in terms of this actual adoption sort of minutia,
I'm not too familiar with it.
But I will say this,
it is true that the Chinese government
makes very brash decisions.
I don't know how it takes place internally,
but the way they implement it on an international scale,
it's kind of just like, yeah,
that's what we decided to do.
We're gonna change the ship.
And I think that that's the thing that it's kind of like,
maybe it's like,
they probably could think of a better way to do that.
So I guess, David, for reactions to this,
like, obviously, I'm not an adoptee and, you know,
but I went into the subreddit, the adoptee subreddit,
to get some reactions from other Chinese adoptees.
And I think they actually kind of had,
surprisingly, a range of reactions.
Right, right, right.
And I think the range of reactions
is based off the fact that, Andrew,
every adoptee has a wildly variable experience
being raised by, quote, unquote,
like a white family in America.
Like some people get born,
adopted by upper middle class family in San Francisco,
and they're like learning Chinese from a young age,
along with their parents.
And then there's people who get adopted
to like rural, rural Wyoming,
and they like struggle with their identity
every single day when they looked in the mirror.
Yes, that is true.
And I think that that's the crazy thing about it,
because look at all these different reactions.
Not sure how to process this.
I kind of feel relieved that there won't be
future adoptees completely severed from the roots like me,
but I also feel hollow.
It makes me think, why did it have to be like this?
What was the point of it all?
Somebody said, this hits us really hard
as a Chinese American adoptee,
don't even know what to think.
We're just gonna exist as a demographic
within a demographic, a niche within a niche.
There won't be any Chinese American adoptees in Gen Alpha.
We're just product of a birth in a certain time,
in a certain place, but in the end, aren't we all?
Actually, yo, this comment was actually very poetic,
and he does make the point that
maybe this mass Chinese adoption,
yeah, it's probably not ever gonna be
at the same level again.
You know, but again, nothing is.
Like, due to war and migration,
there's all these stories and identities
that are not going to be replicated
or imitated or repeated.
You know what I mean?
Like the Chinese diaspora or the Chiu Chau diaspora
from Vietnam, and then the Vietnam War,
they gotta move to Cambodia and Thailand,
and then they come to America.
Right, which creates such delicious noodles, right?
Well, that's one of the positive byproducts of it, yes.
The Chiu Chau noodles are delicious,
but that whole identity is not gonna be replicated,
and that's not becoming more, you know?
So not every identity, yeah.
No, no, it'll cease to exist forever.
Yeah, it's just, it's from a certain place in time,
and yeah, so I guess,
shout out to the Chinese adoptees out there.
I think that however they identify,
they should, you know, like keep it up with that identity.
This person says, as a Chinese adoptee,
I'm happy I was adopted and not left for dead
in an orphanage years ago.
This kind of pisses me off.
I hope those children will get the care they need,
but I doubt they will.
I suffered from severe malnutrition
as a baby orphan in China,
and I would have died if I had not been adopted.
So this person was like very, very grateful.
Right, right, right, yeah.
But then there's other people that are more like,
well, I had a terrible time growing up in my adopted family,
and I feel like such emotional trauma from it,
so how can I feel grateful for it?
So you see, like I said, this is a really interesting one.
It says, conflicting feelings as a Chinese adoptee.
International adoption only opened up in 1992,
so the oldest of us are only in our early 30s.
I feel the same sense of loss,
and yeah, this was necessary
when the one-child policy ended in 2016.
This feels like a bittersweet end of an era
for a generation of Chinese people.
I can't help but feel like we were discarded
in China's sprint toward economic development,
and now we're just a relic of a bygone chapter
in China's modern history.
That's a really interesting comment.
Basically, they're saying like it's bittersweet,
but like you said to the previous comment, who are we?
Are we just like disappearing to the sands of time?
No, I mean, the truth is we're all,
everybody, me, you, everybody watching,
we're all a product of the times.
We're all a product of what happened,
and yeah, it's, again, this Chinese-American adoptees,
I'm not saying there will be zero more ever in the future,
but it's really, it's just not,
yeah, it's not an identity that's going to be repeated.
Yeah, by the way, they are making exceptions
for anybody who's related or like stepchildren
or something like that.
For example, like the only person who can adopt
is left in America in the family.
Those kids will still be able to be processed.
Right.
I guess, Andrew, this led into a bunch of discussions
saying like why do white people
want to adopt Chinese girls so much
when there's like other kids in foster care
or orphanages in America waiting to be adopted?
Yeah.
This was like, these are auxiliary
sort of like side conversations.
Yeah, exactly.
I mean, there's definitely a lot of,
there was a lot of interesting discussion there
about why not more adopt domestically?
Why do Americans adopt from overseas so often
when there's so many kids in America
that need help themselves?
But a lot of people were saying
it's because it makes it easier
because it's like you're getting a fresh kid
versus like a kid who's like gonna have an uncle
like that's gonna come find you or something like that.
Yeah, again, there's,
I'm not saying that you should or shouldn't.
I mean, hey, I'm not, I haven't had this conversation.
It's not something I'm initially looking into.
So I think that's why.
But yes, there's a ton of different layers of like,
well, the kid's family's still in America.
Where are they at?
They're like a local kid.
Do you adopt locally from some kid
who's grew up 20 minutes down the other side of the city
or do you adopt across the country or whatever?
So I think there's a lot of different reasons
why people do it.
But I guess like overall, I guess like,
I do think overall there is the declining birth rate issue
and China's like, hey,
we might as well keep as many kids as we can.
We can afford to financially support all our kids now.
And hopefully they have better systems,
especially for the disabled kids, man,
or the orphanage system.
Yeah, and I also think another reason is
from a nationalistic standpoint
and from a geopolitical standpoint,
China's probably thinking like,
yeah, well, if America's our rival,
why would we give them more Chinese people
if we don't have to?
Yeah, I mean, I think that's another reason.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I mean, guys, let us know what you think
are the reasons in the comments section below.
I think it's like absolutely a move
that seems in line with global trends.
Like we said, South Korea had its adoption program
from 1950 all the way to 2019.
That's when it like seriously slowed down
from South Korea, which is an American ally,
let alone the whole geopolitical like frenemy,
cold war we're at with the panda diplomacy
and everything between China and America.
If even South Korea is gonna slow it,
then what do you think China's gonna do?
Yeah, I mean, the biggest reason why countries
do mass foreign adoption is because they're desperate
and they don't think that they can support these kids
and that these kids are not even gonna have a chance.
Well, they think it'll crush the infrastructure, right?
Yeah, they think it'll crush the infrastructure
or that these kids will just die on the streets.
I guess my biggest takeaway from this,
and I actually don't think that there's like
as much as all the Reddits and this,
especially depending on where you are
in the political spectrum, you're gonna read into this
or read into that aspect or the identity aspect
or the more of the financial aspect
or the population aspect.
My whole thing is like, man,
it is in line with global trends,
but I wish that the Chinese government
would have let the pending cases go through.
You know what I mean?
Because then it would have avoided all the negative,
the hyper negativity around it.
Anyway, guys, listen,
let us know what you think in the comment section below.
Until next time, we're the Hot Pop Boys.
We out.
Peace.
