Why does it seem that Asian-Americans get targeted the most?
And I'm here with two self-defense instructors to talk about it.
Guys, I'm here with Dr. Hu and Dr. Z of the Dragon Combat Club,
based in New York City.
It's a volunteer group that focuses on teaching self-defense
to the Asian-American community primarily,
and they have over 40 years of martial arts experience between the two.
Thank you guys for being here.
Thanks for having us.
Huge honor to be here.
Lots to talk about because obviously we've,
me and my brother have covered a lot of the hate crimes.
You guys have been deep in the weeds,
like teaching people for the past few years,
sparked by the pandemic and everything that was happening,
but you guys are still doing it.
So I guess like on our channel,
me and David have discussed why we thought Asian-Americans get targeted so much,
particularly let's just talk about New York City for now.
And we can't, we have our own reasons,
but I wanted to get your guys's ideas because between what a native New Yorker,
you guys have also been in New York for many, many years now.
So like you guys have a possibly a different experience than me.
You guys teach self-defense, a lot of martial arts experience.
So yeah, I mean, that's what I would like to talk about.
And I'd also want to talk about what the current situation is of anti-Asian hate crimes,
right? And you guys have a read on that.
Would love to start off on just stereotypes.
Stereotypes of Asians in America is not a pleasant thing.
And if you think about the stereotypes that are typically portrayed,
and it's usually Asians with really small penises, really skinny attitudes.
And you know, the assumption is if you have a small penis, you're also weak.
Exactly. So there's like a lot of stuff that comes along with it.
Yeah, exactly. I think no matter also where you go to,
no matter what kind of social circle you're in, right?
There's a very good chance that you're going to bump into some kind of stereotype, right?
Because there's also there's overt racism and there's also more covert racism, right?
You could go to a space that is allegedly more progressive and then boom,
you'd be, you know, you're like, you know, they see Asians as like the backwards,
you know, the backwards patriarchal ones as well.
And then you go to another place and they,
oh, you're these people who don't belong in this country.
And then you go to that space that, you know, Dr.
Who talked about you have a small penis.
It's like no matter where you go, right?
There's going to be some kind of stereotype that people not only believe,
but you know, it gets reinforced over and over again.
I mean, is there some well, I think the penis one is like not everybody can see that.
But I guess like let's say like Asians are short.
That's another stereotype and Asians are weak and skinny or something.
That's another stereotype that people commonly maybe they see enough of it with their eyes,
whether they're looking at the men, the women, the elderly, right?
So, of course, they think like Asians are weak.
Definitely weak slanted eyes, you know, exotic to a lot of degree.
There always seems to be that one Asian out of any white friend group
and it's just it's something that's constantly portrayed all the time.
But do you think the exoticness does make Asians more of a target?
I guess is what we're alluding to. Absolutely.
I would say other things. Yeah, absolutely.
Say the exoticness brings to the appeal of the unknown, right?
And so if you don't know what your target is and you don't feel for your target,
you're more likely to target them to begin with.
And also possibly could the exoticness
and maybe we're referring to women mostly but it could be men as well.
But like mostly for Asian women how they're viewed as exotic
that could make people curious in a good and bad way usually bad right
or they're it's a strong attraction, right?
And anything that attracts people it could be good energy and bad energy, right?
Okay. Yeah, right. It's it's energy, but you don't know what energy it is.
Okay. What else the other day?
I want to mention is that there's also now,
of course are there you know Asian women that are strong
and extremely aggressive and the opposite submissive.
Absolutely. And we've trained many of them, right?
Are there agents who stand up and fight back?
I've had that we've had the pleasure of working and training many.
However, there's this thing, you know called selective abstraction.
What that means is that if you believe in something right everything you see
that confirms it no matter how minuscule
and how small you assume that represents everything
and that's also what we see so it's not that there aren't strong Asians.
It's not that there aren't aggressive Asian women that fight back.
It's that people choose not to see it
because of how they've been brought up or the way that they already see Asians,
right? And do you think there's maybe some incentive of other people
to not view Asians that way like in their mind.
They're actively fighting the urge to have their perceptions flipped
because they want to maybe keep Asians where they're at,
right like keep them in the weak nerdy space
because if now we if I have to start considering
about all these dangerous aggressive Asians,
then it's like well are Asians nerds
and aggressive like what's going on here?
I can't I'll I know it's so complex to just see us as human beings,
right as entire human beings, right?
It's a little too much for them,
but they got to deal with it,
but they do there is a lot of push to make things simple for them right
and make things comfortable for them.
What was the term you used selective abstraction,
right? Is that kind of like confirmation bias in a way?
Yeah, in a way. It's selective abstraction.
Yes, you are a doctor man.
You guys are both you guys both have doctorate degrees.
That's crazy to me. That's so funny.
Okay, so we got stereotypes, right?
Obviously negative stereotypes.
We got confirmation bias selective abstraction.
I guess what are some other reasons that come to mind
why Asians would get so targeted on even for bullying for robberies
for just random attacks obviously that we saw over the years.
Thank God that you know, we feel like it probably peaked
but I guess what else what else comes to mind?
I would also say history when you look at Asians in America
for as long as since this country has been founded Asians
have always been portrayed as the weaker,
you know, it wasn't until the 1800s when Asians in general
in the United States were actually granted citizenship
and that's a crazy thing is that they were around since Civil War,
right? They were imported in mass to be a labor force in America
before they were granted citizenship to me.
That's just madness and to a certain degree.
It's history reading itself, right?
But why do you think and this could be a very very long conversation
possibly an entire video on its own.
But like why do you think history repeats itself within Asians?
Is it because obviously it's not the same Asians walking the street today
in New York a lot of them maybe just came from Asia
but within the past couple decades or just could have been two years ago,
you know what I mean?
So I guess like it doesn't feel like that
because there's constantly new waves of immigrants
and it's not like the fourth generation Chinese immigrants
necessarily that we're referring to even though they're not necessarily safe
fully safe, but you would assume that if you're fourth generation in America
that you're more I guess attuned to the culture
and more know how to like move and stuff.
Yeah. So another reason I would say is culture clash
is that the Western and Eastern cultures are very different
compared when compared to each other.
Right. How would you describe I meant the differences?
Well, how about we just speak on the differences between like safety and danger,
you know, like the argument is always like one Asia.
Most cities are safe.
There's people are not as aggressive.
You don't have guns.
It's also it's also I mean, that's also very like
so what's very interesting is that when I go back to China, right?
They assume that New York has the same gun problems as the rest of the country
and I've explained that New York is,
you know, a very different place from you know, everywhere else.
It's not just a function of being Asian.
It's also a function of being Asian in America when we when people move to one,
you know, our parent when parents bring their kids to America for better
and for worse, but usually through I think noble intentions.
What are we told?
What did the parents of the kids, you know, keep your head down,
you know, don't bother them, you know,
we should be grateful that we are here.
Now you can choose to at the kids may choose to kind of speak up against that
or maybe hey, this is you know, complete bullshit at the same time.
They're still going to repeat that dynamic with other Asians
and I have seen that over and over again.
Oh, you know, we should be where I don't and I'm sure you've seen this before right?
There are a lot of Asian American and this is not unique to Asian Americans,
but it is very prevalent amongst Asian Americans
where we're just afraid to take up that space
and we're afraid to take up the space when we need to even when people's lives
and safety depend on it,
I guess and being afraid is I feel like the result of lacking other things
whether it's confidence or practice like we've and you know,
we did a demo.
We're going to we're playing some of the footage down below the demo that we just did
because the next video I want to talk about like,
you know the common scenarios and how to how to deal with them,
but I guess a lot of Asians are afraid because what they're not raised to be
they're raised they don't have confidence.
They are from a different culture.
Like you mentioned our parents raised us that way.
Maybe they in the household.
They don't we don't practice standing up for ourselves to our parents,
you know, I guess there's obviously a lot of even reasons to amount to we're afraid to stand up.
We're to stand up and also when we do that,
like our parents get very afraid for us.
So I'm not going to speak on behalf of that hoop right for me.
My mom has a big idea of what I do for the community
and it's better that I keep it big because I don't want her to worry about what could hey mama.
I actually teach people how to like stab other people.
So don't worry about it.
No, no, it's all you'll get it.
You understand it.
Your mom's probably like no.
Yeah, she kind of respects it at the same.
I think I've once mentioned it because the thing is that I kind of just
but and then I think she looked a little disgusted
and then I was like, okay, you know what I probably shouldn't touch that topic.
Isn't that funny?
You're you got a doctorate degree.
Yes, you teach martial arts and self-defense to people who need it
and the Asian people in the community
and then you're still like, yeah, I don't know how to explain this to my mom.
She's not gonna like it.
I do know as little as possible, right?
I teach them things we have fun.
You know, just keep it at that.
I don't want to go to the Green Hills.
I get it for me.
It's very vague details.
I remember during covid.
I had a very serious conversation with my mom because I wasn't sure how to
actually approach the conversation.
I was like, hey, I'm going for my doctorates, but also in my free time.
I'm also teaching self-defense in the city and also doing patrols through Chinatown.
Oh, you actually tore it apart.
I did tell her that part and it was she was she was completely shocked.
She was like why and then her follow-up question was why you specific?
Oh, why would my son?
Why my son don't know how many sons you have but like, you know,
I'm trying to think of a Taiwanese accent like my son.
Why would you do that?
Like, you know, why would you want to put yourself in harm's way, you know,
and so I guess we're all telling these family stories just to use it as a it's
a point that men even when you're trying to train in a safe and thoughtful
way self-defense, which does include violence.
Yes, that our parents still don't want to understand, you know, a lot of
them to understand right in the world that they were raised is that violence
was not even a resort.
It was not even option for them and for them to be successful in life.
They had to have a good education.
They needed to get good grades in school and they would basically try and
get as high education as possible.
Right, right.
So for us it ended with of course a PhD but still a D but for them is to keep
your head down right even in the workplace and that was something that I
had to actually talk to my parents with and also first-generation Asians are
now settling and raising second-generation Asians here in America
is the fact that again that culture clash is so different between Eastern
and Western right is that you have to understand that no one else is going
to stand up for you except yourself.
I feel like this you guys tell me I I think tell me what you think.
I think that a lot of Asian parents in their hearts.
They they try to raise you the right way to set you up for success through
the institutions the ladders educational system go to school.
That's how we raise you and it is does breed results.
We can't deny the numbers.
It is how many educated Asians there are out there.
How many Asians have PhDs?
It's not even rare that you guys have PhDs offense.
It's where it's more rare that you guys are PhDs and teach self-defense,
but I said it's not rare that you have a PhD but I'm saying in your agent,
but I guess like they raise you to be able to climb that ladder which it
takes a different skill set than to survive in essentially the streets,
right to to stand up for yourself in the streets in real life man-to-man in
kind of this mono E mono face-to-face like masculinity to masculinity or
it could be masculine to whoever else or like female fight has to sometimes.
Yes.
Like a beer.
Well everybody.
Yeah, I meant like yeah, but you know what I mean?
Like I guess I don't even see it as a mask in the masculinity or
femininity thing.
I do see it as being able to express yourself and be able to be safe to
breathe by yourself.
Yeah, and so it you know again, we train have trained hundreds of women
and met right and it doesn't be over a thousand.
I think it's over.
It's been over down well over a thousand.
Yeah, we lost count and we don't know when I said masculinity.
I think I was referring more that I just feel like a lot of the assailants
are usually men.
Yeah, statistically speaking.
Yeah, they're by far men.
Oh, yeah, absolutely.
Yeah, but yeah, obviously.
Yeah, I mean so I guess okay.
I mean like any other reasons that come to mind like we got stereotypes
got selective abstraction history cultural clash keep your head down.
What else I guess social norms social norms.
So when I was going to grab when I was going to this is one of those
things where I think I was through some exam.
I was studying or no.
It was a course where they were saying that the most effective form
of countermeasure against bullying.
I think this was in a school setting.
I could be wrong because I'm not good at I only remember things well
enough for the test or for my job but the point but somewhere in my
readings it was that one of the best countermeasures for bullying
in school was bystander intervention not the person standing up not
the teacher but the bystanders right in bystanders trying to do
something to be like, hey, that's not cool.
That's not cool.
We don't really have much of a unfortunately I with Asian Americans
that we don't really have much of that bystander support.
Unfortunately, no anti-Asian racism has been normalized that they
get varying degrees over time.
Remember that in 2020 2021 it was not even safe for you to speak out
about it was not even safe for you to admit that it was a thing.
This is regardless of you know, which social circle that you were
in it was not it was and when you have people who are you know, kind
of what do you have people who are okay with this happening?
Guess what?
It's going to basically be the people who are being attacked that
have to fight back.
Is it the most reliable thing?
No, it would be nice if others stood up but they don't it's been
long accepted.
It's been long ingrained in you know, during different times.
We've had to deal with the breadth of it especially in New York
is such a stigma between wanting to say something and not actually
saying something here in New York.
It's almost as we hear it all the time in the subway.
If you see something say something right and in New York City, they
had to actually post that because you know, historically when I grew
up here in the 90s, it was if you don't see nothing don't say nothing
don't rat nobody out snitches get stitches, right?
Right, right.
I mean that still applies for like Luigi Mangione, but still yeah.
No, I mean, I there's so many reasons that we could go through
and I'm sure there's even more but one thing that I feel like is
an overrated reason.
I think a lot of people go to the physicality aspect and they're
like, oh well Asians are shorter and weaker and I'm like, well,
there's plenty of you don't have to be big to be lethal.
Like there's plenty of I mean, how come we're all talking about
the best the best boxers are always like the 140s 130s.
These guys are small guys, but they're fierce fighters.
So I feel like that thing is something that I realized after maybe
doing more martial arts.
I used to say like yo, it's only cut like oh Asians are short and
weak obviously working out being fit having a little broader
shoulder showing that you got a little muscle could help deter
things right though.
Of course, it's going to make you more confident going to make
you more fit to handle things usually but you don't have to be
that big because there's a lot of amazing fighters that are small
but I suppose that it's all these other things stacked on top of
maybe like a 5 foot 8 Asian 5 foot 7 5 foot 6 Asian, you know,
how yeah, it's like then you stack these on top of it and then
you get easy target.
You get an easy target.
Of course.
Yes, you know Asians, you know are at risk.
I'm I am well over 200 pounds that hasn't always been the case.
No, I tried to move you earlier.
You're you're solid like that was some invisible weight legs
are solid.
But yeah, but you know, I have almost been attacked now when I
face them and they notice that I have some metal objects on me.
Of course, they will suddenly stop.
I think a lot of I think there's I know you have a lot of Asian
audiences, you know, they trained they lifted like well, I wish
they attacked me.
Well, of course, it's like of course, they're not going to attack
you right there.
They're not looking exactly.
They're not looking for you as a target.
They're not looking for a fight.
They're looking for an easy target.
If you look for a fight or challenge a sparring match, maybe you
would go to an MMA gym.
Maybe you go to one of the sparring groups in the city and be
like, hey, you know and go with someone that you maybe have a
40 to 60% chance of beating right these people who are committing
these hate crimes.
They're looking for someone that has no chance to fight back at
all. No chance to even hurt them at all.
Right?
So the dynamic is very different.
Yeah, I agree.
I agree.
I always get the see the comments of like buff tatted Asian dudes
that are like, you know, and they're always like, yo, I wish they
would do that to me.
I'm like, they're not going after you.
You're already a deterrent on your own.
Even if you're not that tall, you're buff.
You're showing your tattoos.
You just have the markings of someone who's not going to go down
easy or you're going to put up a fight.
Obviously, a lot of people are picking on elderly, which is like
the word, you know, elderly women to be honest, you know, some of
the worst cases that we saw.
So yeah, I mean, I guess again, man, I think this list could go
on, but I guess to back it up so that we can wrap up this video
and then the next video is us demoing actual stuff and kind of
going through the scenarios walking through.
I guess what do you see as this current situation of anti-Asian
hate right now?
And do we feel like it's peaked probably not gone away, but maybe
some of the super hyper negative vibe is kind of like faded.
Could it come back?
What do you guys think?
I would say during COVID.
It definitely peaks the talks about especially from President
Trump about Kung flu and a lot of negatives against stereotypes
and stigma against Chinese specifically and your average American
doesn't know the difference between Chinese person and American
person the CCP Chinese person and Asian person and they have no
idea what the difference is and they don't care to know, right?
So they then stereotype all Asians as one bucket and you know, I
would say during COVID at least here in New York City.
We saw it the worst and during COVID we had a lot of short-term
prisoners inmates that were right.
They went in and out.
Yeah, man.
They were out in the streets and they were the shelters weren't
capable of handling them and they were actually looking to cause
trouble to actually get back into the prisons like almost.
Oh, you're saying that you think a lot of those attacks were not
they weren't really robberies.
They were there were not robberies of people who needed money for
food.
It was actually people who are trying to wreak Havoc to go back
into prison.
You think that that's where a lot of that stem from right a lot
of the random attacks the thing you have to understand and I hang
around the prison system quite a bit for work and the thing is
when you've been institutionalized your entire life is incredibly
hard to live on the outside.
And so what is more familiar to you at that point is to actually
get back into the institution and that is part of unfortunately
the if we want to talk about racial conditions here in New York
City.
Yeah, there are racial disparities among different racial groups
particularly our african-american community here and as well as
all over the all over the United States.
Yeah.
So the other yeah, so what's interesting that and I try not is
that, you know, my mom in my car.
Maybe they mean well, right?
They're like, oh if someone just you let a child in a debate with
you like if they rob you just give them your money, but you look
at like what actually happens like when was the last time someone
asked you for your money, right?
They just stab you right?
They just punch you.
They just shove you.
This is just crazy.
Yeah, it's a it's a difference.
It is a very different dynamic from I think what other people
imagine it to be.
Once again, they're well intentioned with it's just very very
different.
We saw the peak of this by the way in 2020 for us in New York
City.
We saw the peak of this in 2022 that was when we did our volunteer
missions in subway support and you know, you would see the drag
comic of chat, you know almost got attacked.
I was traveling almost have pulled out my flashlight.
I pulled out my pen time.
We're just congratulating them and like the first I think five
or ten times John and I were just patting each other in the
back and it afterwards.
We just got used to it.
They were just like, oh, I'm glad okay, which is the unfortunate
part, right?
We were so conditioned to hearing about something that was going
on. And unfortunately, it is something that's not commonly
talked about.
The only reason our group chat was blowing up is because we all
know each other.
We all feel comfortable around each other.
We train with each other and we talk about yeah, it's not
something that a lot of young Asians want to start like a
discord or like a big chat room like an IG chat and like connect
with each other on like it's not something that I think a lot
of Asians are proud to talk about even if they got out of
their situation because I do think there's some of the shame
of like whether you were scared or you you did almost get hurt
and you're just you know, you're not like trying to use this
as a vehicle to connect with other people.
You're kind of like shameful of it.
So it is important to have comfortable group chats.
Yeah, where you guys can be like, hey coach shoot this thing
happened and then everybody's like, well, good job.
Like that's what you train for, you know, yeah, there has to
be a level of trust, right?
You can't just I mean you shouldn't be telling this or to
random stranger.
That's not a bad idea.
Do you don't know if they'll be validating or not?
It's like you should have done this.
You should have done this like realistically speaking.
Yeah, there maybe there could have been better days.
They could done but we do the best that we can in this based
on the circumstances that were given and we're just glad that
they made out of life.
Well, do you think and this was just a sentiment that was on
the internet?
I saw like on reddit and like, you know, right when Trump
got elected there was a lot of posts about like, hey, do you
think anti-asian stuff is going to increase now?
We don't know I you know, I don't think he's going to say
the same things.
I don't know if the sentiment is going to be the same but
Dr. Z we were talking earlier like what do you think should
happen?
If you have that inkling like what should you do?
Um, so there is good reason to date that'll come back and
it's of course a matter of when I don't like to wait to I don't
want to play the it's not a good idea to play the guessing
game as to what will happen right is stuff right now.
The heat is you directed on, you know, at other minority
groups, you know who I feel bad for because I know a lot of
them and I volunteer with some of them.
It's questions like when is that heat going to turn back
to us and this is not a good question to think I think the
question is really what do we do now?
What do we do now?
I'm not how about the question.
When do you start training with Dragon Combat Club?
I mean essentially like when when you start training you're
going to start just practicing when you can not not when things
are bad right when you can strike the term that I like to
I say is, you know, strike while the strike while it's cold
strike iron while it's cold.
I think people have historically as we look at the last few
years what often happens is that there's this very
horrific gruesome, you know atrocity that happens to an
Asian American and then others rightfully get angry.
Do you know understandably?
There's a state of panic they train for maybe one time.
Maybe if they're lucky maybe two or three times they get a
pepper spray.
They don't train how to use it, you know, they put it away
and then boom it stops it stops.
There's no there's no like substantial change.
Well, we the reason why Dragon Combat Club keeps up.
We found a way to sustain ourselves and idea is that we
keep it is what we call game-based learning.
We're not saying.
Oh do this because you're going to get hate crime.
We're saying practice these skills because you'll be faster
your brain will be more faster.
Your body will move faster.
You'll be stronger and also it's fun.
Yes, you may see your flash before your eyes.
Also, it's fun, right?
That's what keeps you.
That's fun.
The demo we did earlier was fun.
And I think when things are fun, you want to keep them in your
brain more and you want to keep them in memory.
Yes, what it's a game.
That's why it's so fun to learn games.
But when kids don't like math you try to learn math.
We got a gamify math for people to learn it.
So anyways guys, we're going to wrap up this video.
This is why Asians get targeted the most with two self-defense
instructors guys who have done a lot of thought about this
done a lot of work in this space.
You guys are out in New York City.
You guys are using different weapons and tools to simulate
things.
So it's real life stuff and it really does help.
And yeah, I mean, it's so cool and thankful that you guys are
here.
But the next video we're going to be talking about the most
common scenarios that Asian Americans find themselves in.
All right, everybody.
Thank you so much.
Check out the link down below check out the information and
until next time we out peace.