Maintaining your Asian culture. Do you keep all of it or do you discard the bad stuff?
Yeah, we got to talk about it. This is a viral thread on Asian American reddit right now
This person said do you think critically about maintaining your culture to what extent do you think it's important to maintain all aspects of?
Your culture and to what extent are you willing to critically analyze and discard the negative aspects of your culture and upbringing?
All right, everybody. We're gonna talk about what the negative aspects of Asian culture that he's referring to
How do you mix and match? Can you have the best of both worlds, especially if you're raising an Asian family in America?
Everybody wants the best of both worlds. So we're gonna talk about it in this video
Please hit that like button and check out other episodes of the hot pot boys
But you know what is not a compromise this smaller sauce
It's maintaining the best of both worlds the Italian chili oil with the Chinese mala chili oil
Check it out foodies and chefs. Love it. Check out our Instagram right now. We got a lot of cool content real quick, man
I think that the weird thing about this post was he didn't provide any like super strong hard examples
Oh, I'm sure what he was referring to
Yeah, but I'm assuming that he's probably referring to maybe a childhood that was possibly more sheltered more withdrawn
not allowing the kids to be rambunctious or explore their individualism possibly keeping the kids or
De-emphasizing team sports or especially team contact sports like football in their youth David
do you think a lot of young Asian parents right now like we have some friends who are starting to have kids and
They do kind of have thoughts in their mind like wait
How much of an Asian parent am I going to be?
because in a way there's aspects of their childhood that they really don't like but they
They they do like who they became and they understand that there is some value with being a conservative Asian family being strict
But they're like, I don't know what aspects I want to keep in what aspects I don't like I want to be American
I want to be an American parent, right?
Cuz that means my kid is gonna be able to navigate America better, but I also want them to have certain Asian value
Yeah, and I think the truth is obviously you want to be the best of both worlds, right? You want to be a Lexus hybrid?
Specifically I'm saying a Lexus hybrid, you know
Why because the Lexus hybrids are still very powerful, which is one of the major downsides typically of hybrid cars, right?
That was one of the major complaints about the Prius series. Of course the 2023 Priuses
They're trying to fix that issue. But here's the issue. You have to study
Eastern culture or your own parents culture or your own even
Socio-economic education way from that culture as well as have a deep study of American culture to really like mix-and-match
properly, right because otherwise you're just living as a
Mishmash of things that you are organically. You're not actually being hyper calculated in which aspects
You're picking and choosing and mixing and matching with you mean almost like they should make a list of
Asian
Aspects and then American aspects and then pick and literally circle the the traits that they want to continue with like this
Should it be that specific? Maybe yeah, I mean that could help it
Yeah, you could say all I don't know. It's weird to me to break down culture or you know, so compartmentalize
yes, if you made me ultimately say whether it's better to just to have vague reddit posts or actually break it down on a
Bullet-point by bullet-point level the bullet-point method would be preferable
Um, I think the immediate answers is when it comes to Asian parenting Andrew
A lot of people are gonna associate the old way with authoritarian parenting, right? Right? It is the unfun
sheltering
emotionally
Compressed not very loving very cold stoic East Asian stereotype. It's particularly more of a Confucian upbringing, right?
Particularly more prevalent I say in East Asian family, right specifically really academic Chinese families, etc
Right, and then I guess would you contrast that with what a lot of stand-up comedians call like the hands-off white approach?
Where it's kind of like I don't know Billy's just acting up. I let him do his thing
And then obviously there's a third style Andrew, which is authoritative parenting. It's not authoritarian. It's not laissez-faire
It's not hands-off. It's authoritative. We're basically you're making the kid understand the mission themselves
Yeah, I mean that that sounds like to be the best balance to be on
Yeah
I mean
would you say the best balance of parenting that I guess you could call it a mixture of of
Both the Eastern and the Western style but ultimately it's just a better style of parenting is that the kid feels the fire to
Accomplish things in life internally versus the authoritative style is putting a fire below their butt
You yeah, I feel like visually there's a difference between dragging your kid along into a direction that they don't want to be in
Versus kind of like slightly pushing them into a direction
Or I'm saying even them having the internal guidance themselves. Oh or telling them like yo, this is this way
This is this way if you take this path choose your path, but this is what you're gonna see when you go there
Yeah, cuz I do think that the problem with a lot of Asian parenting is you get results
But ultimately it's still different because there's a lot of resentment from the kids you get the results, but at what cost
Um, obviously when it comes to food and or I don't know if this person was referring to food
But it's probably best to expose your kid to to low middle high versions of all different types of cuisines, right?
Not just their own not just American food
I guess probably organically growing up in America
You're gonna be exposed to low-end mid-end high-end American food without much effort
But then it's gonna take more effort to expose your kid to both
Motherland heritage food or country of origin food as well as a diverse range of foods
Yeah, I mean, especially that a lot of Asian American parents that are like in the 30s and 40s
They're probably not as traditional of cooks themselves. So whatever they cook at home is only gonna be partially
Authentically Asian you said it's already gonna be Asian fusion. It's already kind of kind of be Western
Um, I think the most important thing though is not to only focus on is my kid being exposed to this or exposed to that
It's uh, I think it's letting your kids know to not use food Andrew as a cheap dopamine drug
Basically, you know what I'm saying? Like like beyond even the cultural thing
It's more important for your kid to have a healthy relationship with food in general. Oh, okay
Um, also, I think you need to look at counterbalancing weak points
Like, you know, this person is talking about like, oh, yeah
Should I discard it all or should I keep it all obviously you should mix and match?
But I think that for the parts that you didn't take what are you replacing it with?
Right, like you know I'm saying like there's there
I didn't see any talk in the post of like yo
I'm gonna read all the stories of all these great Americans and those are gonna be the aspects that I'm gonna replace
The gaps in my childhood teaching with mmm, like you got to fill the gaps that you want to yeah
Quality material, I think it's totally cool to
Discard or not carry on certain aspects of a culture
But you understand that that that hole is gonna have to get filled with something
So you should know what the other culture is that you're filling it up with yeah
I think that one thing that a lot of people could look at Andrew is maybe like a lot of upward mobile
Black American sort of like Denzel Washington
Jay-z Michael Jordan D Wade LeBron with like Maverick Carter and Rich Paul Andrew
You know what?
I mean like I could see that being a nice counterweight because your kid is still gonna get the American success story
But with a little bit more of a minority bent to it
Right because they're not gonna they're gonna be you're gonna be raising a minority child, right?
Right, right, but yeah, I mean obviously you could look at Franklin D Roosevelt Tom Brady Walt Disney Ray Dalio, etc, etc
There's so many other ones to learn from and like we're saying it's really important to not only know Asian stories
But also Western stories of diverse types particularly success stories that you want to incorporate in your kids teachings, right? Right? Um,
Last but not least Andrew. There's actually a lot of racial identity
Development models developed by researchers over time and I pulled a bunch of the infographics here
so a lot of people are saying that uh, it actually starts Andrew a lot of
Minorities they either go into conformity or dissonance and then they can go into resistance and immersion and then they become either
Integrative or introspective and this is actually like a very classical flow chart for second-generation immigrant
So it's almost like conformity a lot of it
That's like the self-hating this of being Asian where you're like, I don't want to be around Asians
I don't want to be around and then all the way to introspection and integrative awareness. That's when you're like, yo, I understand it all
I appreciate it. I like being Asian. I like my Asian culture. I know what Asian culture is, right?
Right, right and last but not least Andrew. Here's a quote a quick thought from Bruce Lee absorb. What is useful discard?
What is not add what is uniquely your own?
Of course easier said than done. It's all about ultimately the execution, right? All right, let's get into the comment section here
This first person said well, first of all culture isn't all static if you studied any history
You know culture is constantly changing and exchanging from influences with neighboring groups and religions
Yeah, they go on to say the Chinese culture of today is different from Chinese culture 50 years ago a hundred years ago a thousand
Years ago. There's a reason why we don't practice foot binding and castrating men to serve as eunuchs anymore cultures change and adapt to times and situations
Yeah, okay. Yeah, this is a smart comment
But it's not fully addressing in my opinion what the original poster was trying to get at
because as much as people don't do foot binding and and castrating you could essentially proverbially or
Or in a metaphoric sense still be a eunuch in 2023. Oh
Yes, you could be yeah, and I think that that's like the biggest issue where I'm like, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, of course
We're not gonna be eunuchs in 2023
Like the physical but we could be the metaphorical manifestation of proverbial eunuch. Yes. Yes
Yes, yes and in terms of it relating to it in a proverb type sense
Um, this guy said I don't really think we can think about things critically because we're already based biased on how we're raised
this person was saying like how do we understand living in an individualistic country and
Words like individualism and collectivism. How do we really understand that because Andrew oftentimes in the East it's characterized as collectivist and
The West is characterized as individualistic, but how do we even see itself?
How do we see these things manifest?
Yeah, I mean, I guess I mean wouldn't you say that that you see a manifest in America being individualistic where it's like yo
It's all about my identity how much money I want to make my life. Don't get in my way
I won't try to stop any other people. I won't get in your way, but don't get in my way. Yeah. Yeah
Yeah, I'm gonna reach the highest peak of as possible. Yeah, I think people have to understand
There's a micro application and then a macro application
I would actually say that sometimes in a way America Andrew they people can be really helpful towards each other and
That's more collectivist on a micro level but on in a macro sense. It's very individualistic. Yeah
There's different like applications of any different hard to sum it all up and like to put a blanket statement on something, right?
Right, right
This person was saying that we have to realize that whatever
Culture that we got raised in is not necessarily representative of Asian culture back in Asia
Yeah
That is true
It went to move on and develop without us and also like if your culture from Asia could be a different part of Asia
What do you mean by Asia?
so, of course
I think the best thing is is that you recognize whatever culture you grew up in and
what coach aspects of culture that you like that you would plan to raise your kid in and
Just pick and choose and just and that's having a plan and a vision right like let's say
You didn't have a lot of music being played in the house growing up, right?
But right so it's all gonna be hard for you to feel super musical, right?
Yeah, and let's say you're like, well, I don't know what type of music would I like to play in the house with my kids?
Is am I gonna play classical music? Do I want to play 90s R&B and rap?
Do I want to play afro beats or am I gonna be playing?
Latino music when if I had a kid right now, who knows? Yeah, or like whatever folk pop music
you know like you can even ask yourself that question because
Ultimately if you have a desire to play music in the house with your kids, what are you gonna play? K-pop?
Yeah, let me know for example. I would say that we are very much a product of parents that came what in the
1970s as part of a heartseller act highly educated right had came on academic scholarships
Like the only we have to understand that that was a very specific subset of the Chinese American experience, right?
That wasn't every Chinese family's experience
Yes
Like you said we got to identify even your like sub sub set to really get a grasp on like how you were raised
Um, this person said after some soul-searching I fully accept the label Asian American, which is ultimately its own culture
it's basically picking and choosing what you want and
Yeah, somebody was just saying forge your own identity and worldview. Mm-hmm. I like it. I like it
Yeah, I mean that's ultimately what you should do. Somebody said all culture is relative to the interpreter
I mean, there's some truth to that
But I think usually when you're trying to just talk about something you oftentimes have to use the most accurate broad brushstrokes
Like we can't get lost in like the micro micro tiny brush like when you're painting a painting
There's like the really big brushes and the little brushes and they all matter and the details and nuances and the niches and the exceptions
They matter but if we're just trying to break down something in a very broad generalized sense
There there is like a way to paint a canvas very quick, right?
Right. No, there is there absolutely is a stereotypical way to do it. I don't like that
Oh, this person says, um, you know what? I personally am choosing to discard my parents toxic Chinese culture
I no longer want to celebrate the holidays because I associate the holidays with some of the toxic outdated thinking that I was raised
Oh, man, I mean listen guys everybody Johnny. You don't want to celebrate Chinese New Year with us
You don't want to come back for mid-autumn festival. How come you don't want to come back home?
It's like mom dad. I don't like home man
That's especially if you had to eat some of the more whack moon cakes and you just remember just eating so much of the whack
Some of the mooncake flavors the ones with the meat in them
I don't like those but you know what I will give it to this comment right here and say this person is at least
Giving things a hard. Yes and a hard. No, they have a plan. He's making a decision now. That is very important now
I'm not gonna tell him if he had a bad childhood or he associates the Chinese holidays
Lunar New Year with with some something whack about being Chinese. That's his choice, right?
But unless his life did yeah, but he knows he's not gonna do it
He's like I'm gonna stay far away from that. I'm not even gonna give my kids he read packets home bow
I don't care about that, you know, and I respect that. I respect that. He's making a decision, right? Right, right
You know what? It's not wrong. I'm not gonna tell everybody
Oh, no
You need to just come up with a better version of a home now because your parents probably took your home bow and they put
It in a bank account and they went use it. You never saw the money
You never were able to use it to generate dopamine like all the other American kids and then that's why you hated your upbringing
ah
It might be easier for some people to just completely compartmentalize and then just cut that out of their life
Yeah, my overall takeaway after reading these comments
I think though one and and I think like blending cultures is something that we've thought a lot about on this channel
So not that I know how to raise a kid in it
But I've definitely thought about it for myself and I feel like you do
pick and choose but you got to understand what your culture is because I think that it's very easy to just
Continue to carry on the culture that you experience from your parents just what you know
But your parents may not have been executing that culture on the highest level
Just like this guy's parents who clearly they did not have any fun growing up as far as the Chinese holidays
but maybe you grew up with a
Really good experiences with Chinese holidays and you're like that's what I want to keep up just like different family celebrate Christmas on a different
Level, let's say you already had horrible Christmases. Your parents were never there. You had a broken family
There's never a tree nothing was ever wrapped
They never had good gifts and all that reminds you is how much better all the other kids had it than you
Yeah, then you're then you got to decide like, you know what maybe that just wasn't the best way to celebrate Christmas though
So I'm gonna do it the best way for my kids. That's what I want
Right, right, right, or you could just say I'm not gonna celebrate Christmas at all
It's just depends everybody's gonna make their own decisions. I think that a lot of methods could work or not work
I think a lot of times people focus too much on methodology when ultimately the execution is
The devil's always in the details and stuff like that
But I do think certain game plans have more standardized outcome ranges than other game plans
Mm-hmm, you want to mean like that's that that's a fact too, even though anything's possible
I think ultimately everybody like we said is gonna make their own decisions
I think that some people find it extremely hard to break down culture and then
Rearrange it like a fusion puzzle like like Legos, you know
It's almost like taking two different Lego sets at Eastern Lego set and a Western Lego set and everybody's got a different sub sub set
Of each Lego set right like you could get the cowboy package
You could have got the log log cabin package from the Western set
You could have got a variety of different Eastern cultures at a variety of different income levels or education levels
And it's like you're trying to fuse them together. But ultimately if you can do it, it is something pretty amazing
Yeah, yeah, I do think there is it is possible that best of both worlds, but it definitely takes some
takes some planning right and I can see why people either opt to just like
you know, I wouldn't want to do this, but like just become a
spitting image of their parents or
They just go with the you know, obviously adopt like whatever mainstream
American norms there are right, right
No, I think that those are pretty common outcomes
But the best would be to mix and match the two like Alexis hybrid guys
Um, let us know what you think in the comments down below. How do you plan on doing?
How do you pick and choose which aspects of Asian and American or whatever other culture that you are in?
How do you decide on it? And what are you gonna decide on? Let us know what you think about this concept
Can you have the best of both worlds as an Asian in America? Is it possible?
Yeah, let me know hit that like button. Check out small our sauce calm and until next time we out
You