Testing Climbing Figure 8s with Hard Is Easy

HowNOT2
100 followers
2 Video Views·Sep 16, 2020
Ben from "HARD IS EASY" collaborated with us after many of you requested it about his figure 8 video found at https://youtu.be/QAr-uHd8h8o.
Learn how to tie figure of 8s like a ninja on @Hard Is Easy latest video https://youtu.be/PJkCaUUhqgs
We pull tested both ways to tie a figure 8 and spoiler alert... it really doesn't make a difference. But it sure is fun to watch shit break! Let us know if you want us to collaborate on future projects and what you want to see.
See our free ebooks, our open source lab results and donate at
https://www.SLACKLINE.com/
Hi, and welcome to How Not to Highline.
While Ryan is busy building his drop tower,
I decided to hijack his YouTube channel.
Do you know that there are two figure of eight knots?
Two different ways to tie a figure of eight
that look very similar, but they load very differently.
And one of them is easier to untie,
which I already showed in my video.
But now, let's find out which one is stronger.
Load line goes on the top.
And here, load line goes in the middle.
So, let's find out which one is stronger.
So, do you think that I'm so crazy to do this?
Well, yeah.
No, no, no.
I don't want to risk some projectiles flying into my van.
So, Ryan, do your job.
Hi, I'm Ryan Jinx, and welcome to my garage,
where we have a slack snap machine.
It's a big, giant rectangle.
Let me show you how it works.
On this side, we have a fixed bar,
which I used to have a set of pulleys on,
with pulleys that we no longer use.
And now we have hydraulics, which is really exciting,
because it's so much easier to reset.
This is here to keep things from flying,
since that's what they like to do.
And then we have our adjustable whoopee here
that goes to our sample.
And two dynamometers with kilonewtons here
and pounds of force here,
just so we get dual readings
in case something doesn't go well.
So what I have here is a 9.8 millimeter dynamic rope.
And that's what we're going to use to test today,
because this is a very common size, a climbing rope.
Now, when you tie a figure eight or other knots,
you typically will do half the knot
and then thread it through your harness.
Today, we're just going to show you how to tie a bite,
which is a folded part of the rope,
and then you tie it over.
If you just go around once,
this is called an overhand.
It's a very poorly dressed overhand.
If you go around one more time,
then you have a figure eight,
and that is what we're going to be discussing today.
You go around one more twist,
that is called a figure nine.
What I don't understand about figure nines
is based on the logic of that name,
you would think that an overhand
would be called a figure seven.
I thought that was funny.
Anyways, so when you tie a figure eight,
let's show you the load strand here.
Take your bite, and you kind of go around.
And if you pull,
then these strands kind of cross over each other.
And that's a little tricky to figure out how to do it
ninja style or super clean and dressed
without having to move things around a bunch,
because they do say to dress your knot.
And you do want your load strand
apparently on the bottom and not on the top.
And you can check out Hard As Easy's episode right here,
or to make it a little bit more convenient,
we're just going to have him show you
how to do that right now.
Okay, so actually the problem is
with the way most climbing coaches
and video tutorials teach how to tie a figure of eight,
because after you pass the rope through the harness,
now you need to trace the figure of eight with your tail.
But there are so many ways to do this,
and most of these ways lead to a really funky knot.
So if you want to see a method which works 100% of the time
and is super fast, like so, boom, watch my video.
Okay, so now I'm going to break the two different ways.
And what we have here is the load strand,
because this is going to get pulled against each other,
on the top side here,
and the load strand over here,
going on the bottom right there.
So it's important to grunt.
Tighten these.
Right?
So now that we've got our test,
we're going to figure out which one is stronger,
and then we're going to isolate it
and do the exact same one on either side,
and then pull them three times each
to find out if we can get consistent numbers,
or if they're just all over the board, which is my theory.
So I put one kilonewton, or 225 pounds of force,
on the rope so far,
and this has the load strand going on the top here,
which is incorrect, and squeezing the throat of this.
This is a little poofy, and it's going to start deforming.
This will probably flip over.
On this side, we have the load strand
is underneath, right there,
and you can see how it's squeezing underneath,
and this is loose.
I use the word loose loosely.
We will see if that deforms anymore.
Let's take it to two kilonewtons.
All right, so we took it up to 2.15 kilonewtons,
or around 450 pounds of force,
and you can see here,
this is around the force you would be top-roping.
That's the most you would probably get.
That's three.
Let's take this side.
That's 4.4 kilonewtons, or 1,000 pounds of force,
which is around the force you would get
when you lead fall.
You can see how it's squishing that.
This was on top, and now it's kind of going underneath
because it's being pulled underneath this guy here.
It's interesting when you put 1,000 pounds of force on it.
And this one, you can see here,
that's the bottom strand,
and how that is staying in place,
but it still looks kind of gnarly.
Let's pull to destruction and see which one's stronger.
Okay, so this is still pretty deformed, okay?
But the correct way was stronger.
This broke in this knot,
and it broke here
when it went around and came back through.
And then we have 13.15 kilonewtons.
So what we're gonna do now
is we're gonna make both sides the wrong way,
and we're gonna test that three times,
and both sides the right way,
and test that three times,
and see if we can actually get a variable bigger
than one or two kilonewtons
to see if it actually makes a difference for strength.
Wow, that was a whole lot of work.
I'm definitely not gonna teach you
how to do this efficiently.
We'll let them do that.
Let's go break some stuff.
You can see the deformed knot.
I did pull this as tight as I could, all four strands.
This side broke, and then, you know,
comes undone just a little bit.
12.75.
Well, that was a very interesting result.
Look, a scrunchie.
Feels pretty hard.
There's another scrunchie for ya.
It's interesting that the sheath breaks before the core.
If you would like to see all of this information recorded,
you just have to walk by the Museum of Slack Life
to come into the studio,
which looks way more organized than it really is,
and come to Slack Snap.
We're gonna put all the data on here,
and you can see this on slackline.com,
and it helps if you donate.
This is the homepage, and it has this on the homepage.
Also has my kitty cat here.
Yeah, you can check it out on the charts
and all the raw videos I have as well,
including our Bolt Buster stuff.
So the numbers don't look that drastically different,
but Ben is the engineer,
so what do you think, Ben?
What do I think about you forcing me
to dig through your Excel to find out
that there was almost no difference?
Yeah, you need some serious engineering mind
to see that the numbers are very similar.
But to anyone watching this, give Ryan some love,
because the amount of work here is crazy.
Ryan broke so much stuff here.
It must cost so much money.
Wow.
So we have one last goodie for you.
What happens if your loop is so big
that you end up cross-loading it and pulling it this way
instead of pulling the, let's see,
what is the load strength?
This one, instead of pulling this one.
So let's find out.
I don't even know how to put that back together.
That is extremely warm,
and it shifted quite a bit before it broke.
And the grand reveal.
It's a lot stronger if you do it wrong.
Okay, so I just got done talking to Ben,
and basically it split, like that's the issue.
Otherwise, you basically created a shitty loop.
And a loop is technically almost twice as strong
as pulling straight in line.
And so it's just not how you're supposed to do a loop,
because it pulls, as you can see,
against the knot so funky
that it actually starts to undo it.
The knot literally just doesn't hold.
So I'm gonna put even a shorter tail probably than this
and show you what happens if you do accidentally clip this
instead of your belay loop,
making it to where you're either gonna get
a super strong loop or you're gonna die.
Let's just see what happens
if you do more of a shorter tail.
So as you can see, we got 23.4 kilonewtons,
which is also pretty strong for a 13 kilonewton rope,
but it's in a loop.
And you can see how short this tail is.
And if that tail were to slip one more time
as the knot folds over on itself, you're gonna die.
So don't cross-load figure eights.
So I wanna say thank you to Ben
for collaborating with me on this video.
If you do like to see us collaborate together,
please let us know in the comments.
It'll be kind of fun to do more projects in the future.
Let us know which ones you wanna see us do
and go to his Patreon and help support him.
Go to mine and help support me.
It's really the only thing that keeps this thing going
because we make virtually no money on this channel.
I do make instant coffee with my friends.
And so this really helps if you support Juno Coffee
by getting some instant coffee.
Literally, it's instant coffee.
Just pour it in hot water.
That simple.
If you're gonna take 20 minutes
and try to perfect your knot at the gym
and you're holding up other parties,
tell them about our videos and share it with them
so they don't hate you nearly as much
and they understand why you're holding their party up.
Instead of you smashing your figure eights with hammers
trying to untie them because you did it wrong,
smash that like button.
And make sure you subscribe.
See ya.
All right.
