This week the crew of TMRO talks about the seemingly impossible EM Drive. Could this be the technology that allows humanity to truly visit the stars?
In Space News: * Orbital ATK wants to use old ICBM’s with mixed responses * SpacePlane * Environmental testing underway for JPSS 1 launching in January * Aerojet Rocketdyne tapped to build high-power ion drive * Nasa Space Apps Challenge 2016 * Gamma-ray space telescope poised to pin down gravitational wave sources
TMRO Space Pods are crowd funded shows. If you like this episode consider contributing to help us to continue to improve. Head over to http://www.patreon.com/spacepod for information, goals and reward levels. Don't forget to check out our weekly live show campaign as well over at http://www.patreon.com/tmro
Coming up, old ICBMs may launch commercial satellites.
DARPA's space plane enters phase two.
Why have a gravitational wave when you can have a gamma ray burst as well?
And we talk about the EM drive, hashtag impossible drive.
Stay tuned. Tomorrow begins right now.
And welcome to Tomorrow, episode 9.14 for April 23, 2016.
And if you are joining us live or on YouTube,
welcome to our show.
Now let's go ahead and get it started
by looking at our Tomorrow Patreon premiere members.
These folks have given us ten, that's right,
ten dollars per episode for our show to be made.
They have access to some awesome stuff,
such as our Google Hangouts,
also some of our behind-the-scenes stuff that we throw up on Patreon,
and also they get instantaneous access to our live show in its entirety,
along with the After Dark immediately as soon as it is posted.
And if you folks would like to know how you can do this for our show,
you can head on over to Patreon.com slash T-M-R-O.
And we are joined today not just by myself, Jared Head,
the host for you today, because Ben is out doing ITAR Redacted.
We also have the wonderful, the lovely, the beautiful,
the not-my-wife Carrie Ann Higginbotham right next to me here today.
And just to the left, your right, or maybe my right, your left on the show,
we also have Space Mike coming to us live from the mythical land of heat,
known as Arizona.
How are you guys doing today, both of you?
Doing great, doing great.
All right.
Well, we're actually going to get started with our show,
not just talking about heat,
but some really hot things that are happening right now.
And we're going to throw it to Space Mike to tell us about an interesting plan
that not a lot of people may be happy about.
Mike, why don't you fill us in on that?
Yeah, there's definitely a lot of interesting things
happening in the rocket industry right now.
And one of those things is that Orbital ATK
manufactures what they call their Minotaur series of rockets.
And they make these from Minuteman and Peacekeeper motors
that were made for ICBMs, or Intercontinental Ballistic Missiles.
And a lot of those have been decommissioned since the 1990s.
And when they use these to make them into their Minotaur line of rockets,
they're primarily used for government payloads.
And the use of commercial launches has been banned for the past 20 years.
However, the company has been pushing legislators to lift that ban,
especially in the 2017 round of bills that they're going to be doing,
so that they can market the Minotaur series of rockets commercially
and internationally to fill the kind of small satellite launch vehicle niche.
And the kind of thing with this is they're getting a lot of opinions on both sides,
where certain companies feel kind of threatened.
They feel that they would have an unfair advantage
if suddenly they were able to get several hundred of these rocket motors to have these.
Whereas at the same time, the head of the Air Force Space Command
said that he supports this idea if Orbital ATK
or any company that wants to buy these leftover motors would buy them at a fair price.
And he feels that that would be kind of the factor that would make it fair
for all the companies in this market.
And there's lots of small vehicle launch providers that are kind of against this plan,
most notably Virgin Galactic.
At the same time, though, the House Science Committee,
or specifically the Space Subcommittee within the House Science Committee
in the United States Congress, has been debating this for a little while now.
And they've gotten several different testimonies and several different opinions,
and they haven't reached any sort of clear consensus on it yet.
However, most of these lawmakers do agree that these leftover motors do have worth
and should be used in some sort of capacity.
And all the different skeptics and supporters of this idea alike
do want to form some sort of compromise for this.
So it's very interesting, and I'm very curious to see how this plays out.
And it would be very cool if Orbital ATK is able to start launching the Minotaur IV
with commercial payloads.
So that would just be very cool.
Yeah, and I think that would probably help benefit the Air Force as well
because they have to store those motors and that propellant,
and that is not easy stuff to store.
And that can probably get a little expensive in the long run as well.
Absolutely. Thankfully, they're not liquid-fueled rockets.
These are just solid-fueled rockets, but still.
Still, there is costs involved with storing them, so absolutely.
It is very much an expense in making sure that solid motors don't accidentally go off.
Well, and Neuropilot in the chat room says he's, well, he or she, I suppose,
says, doubt it will happen because it's essentially handing the U.S. government an ICBM,
which is an interesting way of looking at it, I suppose.
Yeah, I think as long as it's a U.S. company,
they won't have too much of a problem handing that over to them.
Obviously, ITAR and stuff would interfere with an international company allowing that to occur,
so someone like ATK or even Virgin Galactic could probably purchase something like that.
So, yeah, that is a very good point.
You are basically getting what was a government missile
and converting it into use for the commercial sector, which is pretty cool.
They've already converted the missile.
They already have several launches under their belt with the Minotaur for different government launches,
and I feel like it would be the same as if we were launching a rocket for the European Space Agency or for anyone.
I mean, all these sort of laws exist to be able to launch international payloads on American rockets,
and there's lots of plans and procedures for that,
and as long as they're international customers, they don't get, of course,
all of your information and all your blueprints and everything for your rocket.
But there are things in place for that, and if they were to market it,
then, of course, they would have to go through all of that.
But I agree that probably if they are successful in this,
a lot of their early customers probably would be United States-based.
Yeah, very, very cool.
All right, and speaking of some United States-based military in space,
Carrie Ann, you've got a very interesting story here.
I have a DARPA story, you guys.
Woo!
Yeah, it's because I didn't pick it.
No, but I did actually find this one interesting, which is why I decided to go with it.
Oh, no, it's a very cool story. I really like it.
So DARPA, or the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency,
which the name of the agency is part of their, their, what am I trying to say?
Anyway, I just was surprised.
I suppose DARP, just saying you're part of DARP is kind of silly.
Anyhow, so the U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency
announced April 7th, actually, at Space Access,
which I believe was in Phoenix, if I remember correctly,
at Space Access 16 conference,
that phase two of their experimental space plane, or the XS-1 program,
they're moving forward into phase two, is what I'm trying to say.
Oh, goodness. Thank you.
So phase two is going on to develop a prototype of a reusable first stage
combined with an expendable upper stage
to launch small and medium-sized satellites for less than $5 million.
They're going to do the phase two award in 2017.
Phase one contracts initially went to Boeing,
Masten Space Systems, and Northrop Grumman,
but phase two will be open to any company that is willing to develop their designs
and enter into flight testing.
They need to demonstrate flying 10 times in 10 days,
which is a huge, huge deal all the way around.
Just a bit.
Yeah. At least one flight has to carry a faux payload of 400 to 680 kilograms.
Test flights have to be done by 2020.
And like I said, phase two is completely open.
It's not restricted to just phase one participants.
DARPA is putting in $140 million into the development of phase two,
but that may not be enough to fully fund it.
In fact, pretty much everyone has said that it's not going to be enough
to fully fund phase two,
which is making some people a little bit upset, notably Boeing, per se,
of them saying, well, that's great.
I mean, we'll probably still work on it,
but we're just not going to put as many people on it
is essentially what they've come down to,
which is really kind of an interesting idea all the way around.
Yeah.
But yeah, no, so that's really interesting.
Yeah, all the way around space plane, space plane stuff.
Ben gets really, really excited about space plane stuff.
So I bet he's just itching right now to say something about it.
And of course, we said the words Masten as well,
which means that my heart fluttered a little bit.
Yeah.
I think the collective tomorrow heart sort of fluttered
all the way around about that.
Just start to 1701 in the chat room is asking,
do all 10 flights have to go to orbit?
I don't believe so, but they do have to fly 10 times in 10 days.
We have a disappointed Ben graphic.
If you want to go ahead and see.
There he is.
That's amazing.
We can pretend that that's live, even though it's not,
but it's that's really amazing.
I'm pretty sure it's actually faces making right now anyway.
So just pretend like that's true.
Oh, goodness gracious.
Did I see somebody else in the chat room say something about
who is Masten?
Is that right?
Or my, my chat room is all crazy pants all over the place.
Maybe.
But yeah, the 10 flights,
basically the access one is supposed to be like a rapid deployable
kind of thing where you watch the access one and there's actually
a way to deploy the payload to orbit from the access one.
And then the access one goes suborbital.
And then at the peak of its suborbital flight, I guess,
at apogee with the highest point,
you launch a second stage and it can carries that payload up into orbit.
So the access one itself does not go to orbit, but it does.
It is sort of a critical part of getting things that the military wants
to have up very quickly in orbit.
So very interesting program.
10 times in 10 days.
That's an incredible launch cadence.
Yeah.
That's beyond Russian launch cadence.
That's beyond Chinese launch.
That's beyond pretty much any cadence other than a plane and plane plane.
Wow.
I was punny because it's a mark this day down because it's a space
plane.
Wow.
April 23rd, 2016.
The day the pun arrived.
Yep.
There you go.
Fantastic.
Get off of this.
Let's move on.
Sure.
Moving on because we are talking about the environment, of course,
because we just had Earth Day this past week.
So woo-hoo, this planet that we're on.
We only get one.
So we've got environmental testing underway on a satellite called JPSS-1.
And you may be wondering what the heck does JPSS-1 stand for.
It's a terrible acronym.
It is a very bad acronym.
It stands for Joint Polar Satellite System-1.
So this is the first spacecraft in the Joint Polar Satellite System.
And it's called the Joint Polar Satellite System because this is a
collaboration between NASA and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric
Administration, NOAA, N-O-A-A.
Now, the tests that they are performing on the spacecraft include vacuum
chambers, thermal loads, systems testing, and vibration tests as well.
Now, it's going to be launched into an orbit 820 kilometers above the Earth
at an inclination of 98.7 degrees.
Now, it will study weather, environmental factors,
and it will help improve meteorological understanding and models that we do.
So in other words, it's going up there to look at the weather from a very
close platform and help us understand why weather does what weather does.
And from doing that, we'll also understand environmental problems
and maybe some climate change issues and some other wonderful things
that we get to do with a space-based platform like that.
Now, what I'm very excited about is that it will launch on the penultimate
Delta II, and they already have the launch set for January 20, 2017,
at 947 Coordinated Universal Time, which for those of us who live here
in California, where it will launch at Vandenberg Air Force Base,
means that it will launch at 147 in the morning.
So get yourself up early, get your coffee going.
I'm going to be there for sure, and I can't wait to see that.
Oh, that's going to be – I just realized that's the day after my birthday.
Yeah. Well, hey, let's go have a birthday dinner for you,
and then we'll take you to the launch.
As long as we have the birthday dinner down here and then go up to the launch?
Sure.
Is that going to be okay with everyone?
And then, yeah, I'm okay with that.
There's a McDonald's in Lone Pope up by Vandenberg.
No, no, not for my 40th birthday, okay?
It's not going to happen.
Why does everyone try to ruin that?
Okay, okay, that's fine.
All right.
Then, yeah, I'm in.
Speaking of –
It's supposed to be the last Delta II launch, right?
Second to last.
Second to last Delta II launch.
So the last one will come later in the year.
Actually, I think the last one is scheduled for Halloween 2017.
Oh, that'll be awesome.
We can all dress up like rockets.
Yeah, let's – oh, my gosh, I have a great idea.
Let's do what Carrie Anne just said.
I'll show up as rockets.
Because there was somebody – when I went to the Falcon 9 launch in January,
the last Falcon 9 1.1, there was somebody dressed as a Falcon 9 out there.
Nice.
Like, I'm not kidding.
There was somebody.
And I wanted to, like, put them in a headlock and be like,
you're a nerd, give me your lunch money.
So some really cool stuff with that there.
As a fat kid, I call Falcon heavy.
Okay.
That's fine.
Fair enough.
You get to have it.
So you get to have it.
I'll be a Black Brant, one of the sounding rockets,
because I have a very aerodynamic hit to my head.
All right, enough of this.
Speaking of rockets, which is what we're talking about,
let's throw it to Mike here because he's going to talk about an interesting type of propulsion.
Mike, tell us about this.
Even though I'm sad about the Delta II retiring,
I'm very excited about better rockets, or not necessarily rockets.
What we're actually talking about here is ion thrusters.
Aerojet Rocketdyne has received a contract from NASA that's worth about $67 million
to develop an advanced version of what's formerly known as a hull thruster.
I don't mean formerly like prior.
That's a very formal thing to say.
Sorry.
With these hull thrusters that Aerojet has been commissioned to make,
they want these to be much more powerful than the traditional ion engines that are used today.
With this, we actually have an example of several different tests of ion engines that have gone through.
Yeah, very pretty looking.
Wow.
Where can I get one of these?
Well, Aerojet Rocketdyne makes some and several other companies as well, Boeing notably,
but with the Aerojet one, this whole contract is to double the thrust of today's ion thrusters.
With this, they want to be able to have something that uses xenon gas
and so that has it passing through an electric field to generate the thrust
and isn't like some more unconventional plasma thrusters.
But what they want to do is have advances in fuel efficiency and thrust
that are vital to future missions that would be able to send humans to Mars
because they need to be able to send a lot of different cargo and infrastructure
before humans would ever set foot on the surface of Mars.
But not only that, the objective of all this is to practice the different procedures
and demonstrate technologies such as the advanced electric propulsion systems
and also the large solar arrays to power it.
What NASA wants to do is with the ARM mission for Asteroid Redirect,
they want to have a solar electric propulsion that would be able to generate 300 kilowatts of electricity
and with that, they would be able to power large clusters of these different ion engines together
so that they could have something that would be fairly efficient
but a little bit faster than some previous pros like NASA's Dawn or New Horizons missions
that had ion engines on them.
And so with that, they would be able to send a large amount of mass
to whatever destinations they're going to and take advantage of the increased thrust
that you get from ion engines the longer that you leave them on.
And with the different studies that NASA's doing,
they're working with Orbital ATK and a company called Deployable Space Systems
on a lot of these advanced large solar arrays that would be able to be used for systems like this.
So I'm very excited about this and I'm hopeful that they're able to achieve the goals
that NASA has set forth for them.
This contract lasts 36 months and it's also going to include options for potential purchases
of these ion engines if they're successful with this.
So hopefully everything goes well with that
and I guess we're just going to have to wait and see about three years
of whether or not they're going to be successful with this or not.
But I'm wishing them all the luck.
Oh, go ahead.
Yeah, I was going to ask, just if you could repeat,
what was the efficiency that they were going to have in comparison to current ion engines?
They're looking for double the amount of thrust.
And as for efficiency, that has more to do with the solar panels
and the amount of electricity they're able to generate.
Because in theory, if you can pump a lot of energy into an ion engine
and so long as you don't run out of its fuel, in this case xenon,
then you can actually ramp them up pretty high to have a pretty good ISP in space.
But that's where it all comes into how much power you're able to generate.
And you can only do so much with the RTGs, the radioactive generators
that some spacecraft are equipped with.
So it all kind of goes from there.
And that's where I think they're going to be relying on other companies to help with that work.
Yeah, and just to give some people some specs,
there is a spacecraft right now called Dawn,
which is around dwarf planet Ceres that uses ion engines.
Its ion engines have a specific impulse of 3,100 seconds
and they generate a thrust of 90 micronewtons.
So essentially what I was told is that the thrust of Dawn's ion engines
is that if you put a piece of paper on your hand,
the amount of force that that single sheet of paper is exerting
is how much thrust that the ion engine has at full throttle.
But of course you can leave that engine on for years at a time,
which means you can build up speed.
Dawn is something like 0 to 60 miles per hour in three days, I think,
which isn't fast, but then again, leave it on for a year
and you get some incredible velocity change with that there.
So it's already at 3,100 seconds of impulse.
How do you get any better than that?
That's ridiculous just as it is.
I love this idea that they have with it here.
And just to give you an idea, rocket engines at best
can pull like 470, 480 seconds of impulse.
So we're already talking like nine times more,
nine times better, if you will, than rocket engines,
or chemical propulsion, excuse me, with that there.
So that is some mind-blowing stuff.
And this is just part of a much larger,
I'm seeing questions in the chat room,
this is just part of a much larger study
that NASA is doing for advanced propulsion concepts.
The VASIMR engine is also part of this sort of concept
that NASA is putting research and development money into.
Yeah, very, very cool.
They want to have something, though,
for at least the asteroid redirect missions
and definitely a lot of the future ideas for Mars missions as well.
All right, well, thank you very much, Mike.
That is just an unbelievable work that they're doing
in order to get that going.
Exciting, too, and also very pretty as well.
Yeah.
Speaking of stuff that NASA is working on, Carrie Ann,
you've got a really cool thing that NASA's actually doing right now.
Right now, like right now, right now.
Now, now.
Like, if you're not watching us, which you should be,
but if you're not watching us live,
then maybe you should be watching this instead.
Yes.
This is the NASA Space Apps Challenge 2016.
This is actually the fifth year it's been going on,
so if you maybe feel like you've heard about it before,
this is a whole other year of doing it.
It's one of the largest hackathons on the entire planet.
Which I didn't realize, just last year,
there were 14,264 people gathered in 133 different locations.
Wow.
Because you can basically do it anywhere that you've got Wi-Fi.
Yeah, you could just remote in.
Totally.
Pretty cool.
So you can create your own group locally,
or you can join another group from far, far away,
which is really amazing.
There are six different categories.
There's technology, aeronautics, space station, solar system,
and Earth, as well as Journey to Mars,
with their each own little hashtag,
like tech exploration, fly NASA, be an astronaut, out there,
which is my favorite, Earth right now,
and of course, hashtag Journey to Mars.
They got really creative with that one.
NASA provides not just contacts and hashtags,
but they also have data and resources,
and that's the whole idea,
is that NASA just has this huge data pool,
almost like a data dump, and they're like,
here, do something,
and then you get a chance to do something with it,
which I think is a really, really cool idea.
Should I do it again?
Yeah, that's totally going to be, I know,
I should never have done that in the first place,
but that's what happens when you watch live.
Anyway, so you can work in a team or individually,
which is really great,
and from, again, virtually just about anywhere.
You're solving challenges using real data.
That's the other thing,
and the other thing is, it's not just sort of,
how do I word this without getting myself into too much trouble?
All the challenges are completely different,
and there's easy, intermediate, and advanced challenges,
so if you've never done coding before
or if you are a known hacker,
there's usually something that you can find,
and there's all different kinds of challenges,
which I think is really interesting.
You can win an award in one of six categories as well.
There's best use of data, people's choice, galactic impact, awesome,
most inspirational, best mission concept,
and best use of hardware.
You can also go back and look at other challenges
and what's happening and what's going on.
You can pretty much join in at any given point in time.
That's awesome.
They, again, are all over the world,
and there's 42 of them that are streaming live,
so if you get bored with Pakistan,
I suppose you can tap into San Francisco or Zurich or Austria
or pick a place.
There's probably one, and it's probably interesting,
and the live stream, the social media stream
that's coming off of those things is really incredible.
Some places have shirts and patches and stickers,
and others are like, we're going for a coffee break,
and it's really a lot of fun, a lot of fun.
I think it's very cool.
Nice. I like it.
Yay.
Very awesome.
Now I want to go make an app.
I know, right?
All different kinds of things.
You can be like, ah, the best way to put on your space boots in zero G.
Like, that could be a whole thing.
There's an app for that.
Well, there will be now.
There will be now.
So there.
All right.
So I guess we're going to have to take phones with us into space
and to Mars and stuff.
That might be a little difficult.
I can get on my boots manually.
I don't need to take a photo and have my Roomba do it for me
or something like that.
Anyways, moving on, because there is something very interesting
that has just recently been announced.
It was sort of announced back in January,
but then people were like, no, not really.
But then the scientists were like, yes, yes, actually.
So we all know about the gravitational wave that was discovered by LIGO,
which LIGO, for those of you who want to know what it stands for,
is Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory.
This is the one we listened to, right?
It sounded like a heartbeat?
Yeah, it kind of sounded like a heartbeat a little bit.
It's not so much you hear it.
It's just we just made it so that you could sound like you could hear it
in the human hearing range if you want to.
But we discovered it back on September 14, 2015,
and that was the first direct detection of a gravitational wave.
It was two black holes approximately 30 times the mass of the sun
merging together.
And because LIGO only had two detectors,
we basically had to best guess where it was in the sky.
And that's what those little blue and green slivers you see right there are.
Now, interesting thing.
Fermi, NASA's gamma ray observatory in low Earth orbit,
detected a gamma ray burst from within that best guess of sky
within half a second after the detection of the gravitational wave by LIGO.
So the chances of that happening by coincidence are 0.2%.
They actually crunched the numbers and they figured out.
So it's a 1 in 500 chance that that just so happened to happen.
Well, what they did is that the gamma ray burst detection
was at a very high angle relative to where Fermi was.
So they actually didn't accurately know where that burst came from.
But they know the direction that the instrument was looking,
which was in red there,
and they know the part that the Earth was blocking as well.
So that yellow space is the field where that potentially could have come from.
So they think that the gravitational wave could have come from
that yellow area that you see right there.
And this is sort of like a luck of the draw,
and it actually ends up narrowing down that field two-thirds in size.
So it's only about 30% as big as the original field
of where the space that the gravitational wave could have come from was.
Now, in the future,
because they are making more gravitational wave observatories,
we'll have three so we can triangulate its position very easily.
But this was just basically the best we could do
with the two detectors at LIGO that were sensitive enough
to actually pick up that gravitational wave.
Now, this is a little weird
because they would have expected two black holes merging together
to have a clean area around them.
In other words, the black hole's gravity would have basically ate,
if you will, everything around it, like the gases and stuff.
And it should be just a clean merger of two black holes.
This, with a gamma-ray burst,
indicates that there might have been some gas around, which is unexpected.
So they may have to go back and look at their models
and see what happens when they throw gas around in it
and see if it actually does turn up a result like what we got.
So they're fairly confident that that gamma-ray burst
actually was from those two black holes merging,
which means that maybe gamma-ray bursts aren't just the birth of black holes,
but maybe they're also black holes merging together as well.
So some very interesting stuff that we originally thought was wrong
but actually turned out to be correct, if you will.
But, of course, they're going to study it a little bit more.
This isn't a thing. Oh, wait, this is a thing.
No, this isn't a thing. No, this is a thing.
It is. No, it's not. But it is. But it isn't.
But it is not. Is... isn't.
Yes.
And, of course, speaking of things that is and is not at the same time,
when we come back, we're going to be talking about the EM drive,
the impossible drive, the thing that defies physics.
And we will come back to that. We're going to talk about it.
We're going to, most of us, probably learn about it today
and hopefully wrap our brains around the physics
that allow that to apparently exist.
So we'll be right back, and we'll see you in just a second.
And welcome back from that break.
Before we get into our topic today,
we are going to go back and take a look at some of our Patreon patrons.
We're going to start with our TMRO premiere members.
These folks gave $10 or more to us per episode,
so they get access to all the amazing things that we talked about earlier.
But, of course, we also have our TMRO producers as well.
These folks gave us $5 in order to have their names not only just in the show,
but also they get access as well to things like After Dark immediately
and our Google Hangouts and all the other fun goodies
that come with being a TMRO patron on our Patreon.
So if you would like to consider donating to our Patreon,
please go to patreon.com slash TMRO.
And we absolutely love the fact that everybody gets to play their part
in making this show happen.
We wouldn't have this show without you guys.
So that's the great part about it.
We love you from the bottom of our hearts
and the top and the left and the right.
It's true. I was there.
Yeah, it is.
All right.
So what we are going to do now is we are going to get into something
that is unbelievably controversial and amazingly incomprehensible,
but also at the same time physically understandable,
but not at the same time as well.
I actually have it written in the rundown.
These are not really talking points.
These are just things that I gleaned from a couple of articles,
and you guys are going to have to explain this to me.
I work in propulsion for rockets.
I don't even understand how this thing works.
I can scratch the surface on it, but I'm just like, well, what?
So we're going to talk about this.
And I guess, Space Mike, you're the most well-versed person in this.
We're, of course, talking about the EM drive,
which if you haven't heard about it, here it is.
It looks absolutely terrible.
It looks like a medieval torture device is what it looks like.
Somebody went to a dumpster at NASA and was like,
what can we do with all these things?
I don't know.
Maybe we'll just throw it together and see what it does.
It literally looks like something you would make in Kerbal Space Program
as a joke, but it's an actual thing that apparently does something.
And Mike, why don't you go ahead and fill us in on this,
because this is an unbelievably complex.
I mean, my brain is just hurting right now trying to get us into this.
I'm not sure that I understand the physics 100%,
but I try to understand it in the same way that ion engines
or plasma engines work.
They create an electrical field and charge up the ions
from whatever noble gas they're using.
And those ions moving around and being pushed out
is what generates thrust for them.
And this is a little bit different.
It's not just an electrical field, but they're also creating magnetic fields.
And they use a device called – I know I'm not going to pronounce this properly,
but I believe that it is called a magnetrometer.
And essentially it's like a really fancy microwave
that would be able to help to generate a very, very small,
very minuscule magnetic field with this microwave.
And with that, there's also a little bit of radiation in there as well.
And from the way that I understand it,
from the way that a lot of these studies have been put out,
I mean, the first guy who did this was a British scientist named Roger Sawyer
who prevented this concept way back in 1999.
And the whole thing with this EM drive is,
like in the way that ion engines produce a very small amount of thrust,
the difference between them is that ion engines need a fuel like xenon
or argon or something like that in order to have the whole process work.
But with this EM drive, there is no fuel. There is no propellant.
They're essentially creating this thrust from nothing.
Yes, being able to have electricity and these microwave beams going through it,
but there's no other fuel. It's a reactionless engine.
And the whole process with this is we kind of have a graphic here
that kind of shows an idea.
Inside of the shape of this canister that they have here,
this cone that they have here,
they are having different amounts of microwaves
in the different areas of this cone.
And you can kind of see how the back of it is heated up.
What they try to do is to have the most amount of it in one area
and a lesser amount in another area.
This also goes to the concept that light has mass.
And if light has mass, then it should potentially have inertial mass.
And if it's being bounced around by all these microwaves
and everything inside of this cone,
in order to not violate the law of conserving momentum,
then it would need to produce a little bit of thrust
in order to keep a constant
while it's being bounced around inside of this cone.
And that is what creates the thrust that these things are generating.
At least that's what the people working on it think.
And I don't even understand the concept fully.
And the thing is, some of the people working on this say,
oh, it doesn't violate the law of physics at all.
It's just kind of like a weird exception.
And other theorists are just like,
no, this would have to be a completely new physics
in order for this to work.
The thing is that there's 8 different teams working on this idea
and actually testing it.
It has built models and is testing it.
And some of them, of the tests that have occurred,
some of them have produced nothing
because they're trying all sorts of different methods.
And also the shape of the cone.
And some of them are just doing flat canisters.
And some of them are putting grooves and rivets into it.
And they're having all sorts of varied results.
But the problem is that the majority of all these different tests,
or not the majority, but more than 60% of these tests
have been able to measure a very small, minuscule amount of thrust.
And even if the theorists themselves don't understand what's happening,
there is that thrust.
And it still could be an error in the sensors
because what we're talking about is so small
that it could, you know,
I'm sure that there could be plenty of reasons
why they could be able to have an error like that
to measure those very small, minuscule amounts of thrust.
But because they are getting this thrust,
and by the way, this is just a little bit of electricity
that is being pumped into these things with a large amount of electricity,
they're thinking that with the results they're getting so far
that they could potentially get something going
around as fast as, like, 0.4 newtons of thrust per kilowatt.
And when you bring this kind of into the idea
of NASA's advanced propulsion that they're looking at,
wanting to have a 300-kilowatt solar electric propulsion-capable craft,
if you were to apply to one of these drives or something like that
and have 300 kilowatts of available electricity,
then you might be able to generate quite a bit of thrust
and have something that could potentially,
we were earlier talking about the Aerojet ion thruster
that would be twice the amount of thrust as normal ion thrusters.
But if this works out to, you know,
if it scales up to what they've been looking at so far,
then it could be seven times more thrust than an ion engine,
and with no fuel.
So you have an extremely light engine,
and you could do so many amazing things.
Just some of the examples in some of the other people working on it,
there's another scientist named Mike McCullough
who actually disagrees with a lot of the original scientists' theories
as to how this could possibly work.
But in one of his papers, he gives a lot of really, really good examples
of how this could be applied,
and that journeys to Mars or even journeys to Saturn
could be two years or less.
In any case, I'm sorry, I'm kind of dominating the conversation here,
but that's the way that I understand it.
Yeah, it is incredibly complex
to the point of total madness, if you will.
And I was reading that some of the forces that they're getting out of it
are, like, in the micronewton range.
I mean, this is just unbelievable.
Immensely small.
I mean, like, 0.0 with, like, eight zeros
and then a number there, newtons.
That's absurdly small to measure.
It's measurable.
And also I'm seeing that a lot of these experiments that they're doing
are taking into account things like the fluctuation of air
because of the heat being generated from the magnetometer
or whatever it's called, from the system.
There we go, that clears it up.
And it's just unbelievable
because it really is one of those things that physics says no.
But for some reason, you've got multiple teams
who are at least saying that they are testing it
and confirming that there is a small amount of force coming from it.
Now, one of the problems, though,
is that not many of these have been peer-reviewed.
And that's a really big issue in science.
For those of you who don't know what the peer-review process is,
basically, if you're a scientist,
you do your work, you do your research,
and then you write up a report from your experimentation
that proves your hypothesis or disproves it somehow.
And then what you do, you publish that report,
and you send it to a journal or a magazine or something like that
or a place where everyone in your field can have access to it.
And then people from your field grab your report,
they look at your procedures,
they perform your experiment based upon your procedures,
and they try to see if they can get a similar result.
So that's essentially what happens.
If they get a similar result, well, bam!
Good job, you did your experiment correctly, all good.
If there's 1,000 people in your peer review that do the experiment,
500 of them do it and they get the same result,
500 of them do it and they all get a different result,
you've got to go back to the drawing board
and you've got to redo your experiment.
And that's not an unusual thing because, honestly, as a scientist,
if you're not going back to the drawing board,
you're probably doing lots of things wrong
because very rarely do you hit the home run out of the park
or do you get it right on the first shot with your experiment right there.
Now, an interesting thing, though, about peer review
is that if you have 1,000 people do it
and 999 people do it and prove you correct,
but one person proves you wrong,
you've got to go back to the drawing board and you've got to do it again
because somebody has found a valid point that you are incorrect.
So peer review is an immensely, immensely important part
of the scientific method
and the process by which we actually prove and disprove
or prove disproves of things as well involved in science.
And, you know, there was a lot of tension, if you will,
from some of the teams about getting their results peer reviewed.
A lot of them were sort of, I don't want to necessarily say opposed,
but they've been extremely slow to get their results peer reviewed as well.
And some of them were even just self-publishing their papers
like on their websites or something like that.
And even the NASA Eagleworks project, which has been working on it
for a couple of years, just submitted their peer review.
So, I mean, yes, it's been going pretty slow.
Yeah, and peer review is all basically about replication.
Is there successful replication of the results?
Is it consistent? Is it concise?
And is it understandable in the framework that we have built
in terms of physics and things like that?
But from what I understand,
they are actually moving some of these towards peer review now.
They're actually going to be releasing some of the data on these
and the experiments and the procedures from them.
And we're going to actually, probably within the next six months to a year,
find out whether, yes, it's correct, or no, it defies physics,
which a lot of people are pointing to the no, physics says you can't do that.
Because, let's face it, it's really hard to break physics in our universe.
We've tried to do it, but I personally have not broken physics yet.
Carrie Ann or Space Mike, I don't know about you guys.
Have you guys?
Yeah, I don't have a debug menu, unfortunately.
No, no, unfortunately we don't.
But, you know, it's a really interesting study that's happening, at least.
And I feel like it's a pretty neat idea.
How neat is that?
Yeah.
That's pretty neat with it right there.
And, you know, if we do end up proving it, awesome.
We've got a potential system that we can use as a form of propulsion
that may end up taking us and turning us into an interstellar species.
If we don't, well, we have a nice moment in history
where we can all look back and laugh for a little bit of time about it, I guess.
So, some very, very interesting research, to say the least.
An unbelievably complicated thing that we have going on with the EM drives.
Do we have anything from our chat room just to add in here?
So much.
Is everyone in our chat room just as confused as we are about that?
Actually, no, because Aeronaut actually had some interesting things to say.
Let's see if I can scroll back up and find it.
Yeah, let's go ahead and take a look at it.
By the way, you guys are correct, which is that photons,
they don't technically have mass, but they do have momentum.
So that is correct.
So that's why you can use things like a solar sail in order to move your spacecraft,
if you want to, because the momentum is,
a little bit of momentum is transferred in the collision of a photon against that.
Which, suppose you could also use that accelerating a photon, if you will,
to generate that as well.
But, yeah, it's so amazing.
So Aeronaut, the best part is Aeronaut starts off with, it's simple.
There's no such thing as a complete vacuum.
In such, you are charging what is available in the vacuum.
You cannot have an empty vacuum.
It's just not possible.
And then it goes on to say, Einstein's equations allow for it in special relativity.
The rest mass of photons is massless, but the ideal and not approximate.
That's why I said they kind of don't have mass.
It goes on to say, the set of equations can be represented by,
Yes.
Right. Blah, blah, blah.
Lots of people said lots of other things.
In other words, it's complicated.
And then also, Aeronaut throws in, peer review is the curse.
So there's that.
Actually, do we have a live feed of Ben?
Probably.
He's on a plane now, so he probably is watching, I'd imagine.
Do we have a live feed of Ben thinking about it?
Oh, see, there you go.
There he is. He's very happy about it.
There's the happy Ben.
Aw, happy Ben is happy.
Is he using an EM drive in order to move?
Because I don't see a system there allowing him to do that.
Oh, goodness, goodness.
Yeah, oh man, it is.
This is great.
The best part is that you guys have comments, and you're going to have comments.
Please leave us comments, and then Ben will answer all of them next week.
You absolutely should do that.
Because I want to see Ben sweating bullets about hardcore theoretical physics.
Because that's what this is.
Who doesn't?
Because you can't tell, but I'm sweating bullets right now just talking about this.
Because my brain is like, that's enough of that.
And I feel like 50% of what I just said is false, but I don't even know the difference.
But we're not sure.
Nobody knows.
That's the amazing part about the EM drive.
Nobody knows really.
Not even the scientists.
Yeah, except for the people that are actually working on it.
And then even some of the people that are working on it are like, we don't know.
I don't know how it's working.
We're pretty much in the Matrix on this one.
So it's okay.
I think we can all agree that it's basically magic.
It's sorcery.
It's witchcraft.
I mean, if you threw it in a lake, it would probably float.
Right?
So.
Wow.
Talk about an inside joke.
All right.
There we go.
All right.
And now that we've done that, why don't we go ahead and head to a break?
Of course, as Carrie Anne said, leave your comments below about the EM drive if you can.
Leave some math in the comments if you want to.
So then I can go home and derive it and learn a little bit.
Or just put in the comments that we have no clue what we were talking about.
Because, hey, neither do the people working on it.
So anyways.
Might as well.
That way we can learn together.
All right.
So now that we've insulted everybody, let's go ahead and head to break.
And when we come back, your comments about last week's show, Vote for Space.
So see you in just a couple of minutes.
We've always looked to the stars.
They guide us.
Give us comfort.
Help us find our way.
We see ourselves out there.
When we look up, it inspires us.
On to something we don't yet know.
We yearn to go there.
So we venture forth.
We choose to go to the moon in this decade and do the other thing.
Not concerned to organize at this time.
Will go ahead and join in it or not.
Many think we stopped exploring.
But we know our journey didn't end.
We've only just begun.
Come with us and explore tomorrow.
And welcome back, everybody.
We are glad to have you after that break for the last part of our show.
But before we do that, let's go show you some more of our Patreon patrons that we have.
These are our TMRO premier members.
These folks have given us $10 or more per episode.
And when you do that, not only do you get great stuff, but you get your name in the show three times.
How awesome is that?
And in addition to our TMRO premier members, we also have our TMRO producers as well.
They are wonderful people who have given us $5 or more.
And they have access to everything, and they get their names twice in the show.
But of course, what if you don't want to actually give that much per episode?
Well, that's fine. You're more than welcome to.
We have our TMRO Patreon Plus subscribers.
These folks have given us $2.50 or more per episode.
They get access to all the goodies, and they get their names once on the episode.
And we still absolutely love everything they get to do.
But if you don't want to do that, you can give us as little as a penny per episode,
and that will get your name in the show.
These are our Patreon patrons who have given us a penny or more between that,
and they get their name in the show here.
Try to see if you can see your name with the small print.
I can just barely make it out from right here.
But of course, we want to thank everybody who gives to us through our Patreon.
If you would like to do so on a per-episode basis for the live shows,
please go to patreon.com slash T-M-R-O,
and you can help make the shows of tomorrow happen today.
So we're going to go ahead and get into our comments from last week's show,
which was a very interesting topic called Vote for Space,
where we actually had a political action committee that specifically works
to advocate for the government to vote for space.
So let's go ahead and go to some of our comments here.
Capcom, let's get it started with our first comment that we have right here.
This first comment comes off of Reddit.
This one comes from Brandon Mark, saying,
I like Ben's daydream on marrying SpaceX's first stage reusability plan
to ULA's second stage reusability plan.
Just curious, what would it take a ULA ACES,
which is Advanced Cryogenic Evolved Stage,
atop a SpaceX Falcon 9 first stage?
Technically, I mean.
Leaving out the politics, money, posturing, negotiating, egos, and all of that,
just in terms of hardware, would it be possible?
Sure, absolutely.
All it would take is like an adapter fairing or something like that.
Because the Falcon 9 first stage is 3.6 meters in diameter,
whereas the ACES upper stage is planned to be a little bit over 5 meters in diameter.
So it would kind of be like a Titan 3 type stack,
where they have a skinny rocket on the bottom
and then a really wide adapter for a huge payload fairing on the top.
So, I mean, technically they could do it.
And that's probably what it would take.
You could, yeah.
And, you know, like they were saying at the Space Symposium in Colorado
just a couple weeks ago, ULA,
Tori Bruno said that he would have no problem collaborating with SpaceX
at some point in the future.
So, who knows?
Maybe that was, maybe that was a little hint.
Yeah, let's cross everything in order to make that happen.
Because that would be really, really, really great.
All right.
So, Capcom, can we see our next comment, please?
This is a great comment by a name I'm totally going to butcher,
so I apologize in advance.
Whoa, that's a great name.
And this one comes off of YouTube.
It's from, oh goodness, put the slate up.
I can't, don't watch me suffer through this.
Polco.
We'll just say Polco.
It's, okay.
Polkovniknades.
Yeah?
Polkov...
Polkovniknades.
Who says, hey, I'm from Australia,
and me and my friends love watching what NASA,
the U.S. launch industry does.
Is there a way that I, as a non-U.S. citizen,
can help out with U.S. space politics?
I'm sure many, many other international viewers share the same sentiment.
And the really awesome thing is,
while we don't even have to answer this one,
because we didn't have to answer this one,
because our guest from last week,
who was representing voteforspace.com,
answered it for us.
So, thank you, John.
I will now read part of your comment back to Polkovniknades.
John says, or voteforspace says,
if you really want to help with U.S. politics,
you can email volunteer at voteforspace.com,
and we'll have a discussion about additional research
that you can help me in facilitating other grassroots organizations to take action.
I'll forward you some of the conversations I've been having
so that you can see the type of foresight that needs to go into mounting a campaign
and research that needs to be done to support it.
And then, once we got all of that information into our timeline for the show,
then Lisa Stojanovski, who's one of our correspondents,
Lisa got up at stupid times of the day
to actually put in another little tidbit,
because she's also from Australia,
and there's a thing going on right now.
So for all of you Australian viewers,
all two of you, you could...
I think there's a little bit more than that.
Maybe three.
Actually going on is there's a review of the Aussie space law
that's going on right now.
So what you can do is you can hit up
http://tiny.cc Australia space, all one word.
I would give you the longer link, but it's totally not worth it.
We would be here for days.
So tiny.cc Australia space,
and there's a form you can fill out.
You can give your opinion, which is really amazing.
I'm super jealous.
And you can talk about...
Thank you, Sir Gamelot.
A couple people put it to our chat room.
You can talk about how you feel about Aussie space law,
what's going on, how you think is it still applicable,
and what you would like to see in the future,
which is really, really incredible.
And again, for those of you who are here in the U.S.,
of course, go ahead and visit voteforspace.com
and kind of get that going.
It was really kind of amazing to see all of this happen.
We had the guest on.
Somebody made mention of it.
Somebody said this.
Then this other thing.
It was really incredible.
This is why we do this show.
If I may just sort of, you know,
gather all of my Bencredible with me for a nanosecond,
this is exactly why.
We want to make sure that we are hopefully bringing some information to you guys
to help us learn, of course, like our main topic today.
And then help you learn and get involved in the things that you know and love.
So this was really amazing.
Thank you guys so much.
Such an awesome...
Ben actually used the word synergy,
and he hates that word because it's totally cohesion.
It's a crap word all the way around,
but it actually worked this time with how well all of that worked out.
So I thought that was very, very cool.
Yes.
Excellent.
How's that?
Sounds good.
Let's move on.
That was a great soapbox.
Thank you.
Round of applause.
Yeah, that was all Ben.
His soapbox will be back when he comes back.
All right.
Well, Capcom, let's go to one more comment for us for this show.
One more time.
Okay, so this last comment also comes off of YouTube.
This is from Kim Peterson and saying,
quote, speaking of man crushes,
I think I have a non-gender specific crush on The Tomorrow Show.
Aww.
I'm medicated right now, but I'm still fairly certain it's real,
which is hilarious.
And Kim for...
Kim, for those of you who don't know who Kim Peterson is,
because it's kind of a generic name, so I can understand you may not,
is head of the Monorail Society Facebook group.
Oh, boy.
Has even...
Wait, wait for it.
Made a book all about monorails.
Oh, my gosh.
Trains of the Future Now Arriving,
which is kind of an awesome title.
And Ben Credible does, of course, know Kim
and did spend some time with Kim a couple of weeks ago.
And just for Kim, because it has nothing to do with us,
and this is really just feeding Ben,
he made a hyperlapse to the group to view
from the Monorail Gold Walt Disney World's EBCOT line.
I believe that's what this is.
Go ahead.
Thanks, Capcom.
Actually, fun little factoid,
Kim is also the author of Monorail's Trains of the Future Now Arriving.
I got one right behind me.
And you can find that on Amazon.com.
He's also the owner of the Monorail Society,
or creator of the Monorail Society,
which you can Google and find more information on.
There's a closed Facebook group that I'm a member of.
It's really freaking awesome.
And he's just a hardcore monorail nerd, just like I am.
So it's really, really awesome to get a comment from Kim.
I kind of man-crush on him the same way I do Dave Mastin,
just a little bit, because monorails are so cool.
If you're a monorail geek, check out his book.
Like I said, it's Monorail's Trains of the Future Now Arriving.
And also check out the Monorail Society.
And thanks for the comment, Kim.
Awesome.
Was that live?
It probably was.
Yeah, live remote with Ben.
It felt like you didn't say it good enough.
You needed to repeat some of that information.
I mean, I totally watched that video,
and that's why all those words were stuck in my head in every way.
See, that's what happens.
Even when Ben's not here, he's still in there.
It's like the homunculus.
Oh, goodness.
Oh, boy.
I think that's it, right?
We're done, right?
That's it.
We are done.
That's it, everybody.
Thank you for joining us today.
Yeah, thank you.
We will be back next week.
Ben will be here, hopefully.
Carrie Ann, you will also be here, correct?
Yes.
Remember correctly?
And Space Mike, you'll be here.
I'll be here.
I'll be here next week for sure.
OK, sounds good to us.
So thanks for watching 9.14.
We hope you have a great day.
See you later.
Bye bye.