Hudson Institute: China’s Forced Organ Harvesting Continues (IRF Summit 2022)

Falun Dafa Information Center
4.3K followers
185 Video Views·Jul 7, 2022
The Hudson Institute hosted a breakout session on forced organ harvesting in China at the 2022 International Religious Freedom Summit on June 30, 2022.
Host
- Nina Shea, senior fellow and director of the Center for Religious Freedom at the Hudson Institute
Guest Speakers
- Nury Turkel, chair of the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom & Hudson senior fellow
- Levi Browde, executive director at the Falun Dafa Information Center
- Ethan Gutmann, Co-founder of the International Coalition to End Transplant Abuse in China
The summit and this opportunity to speak twice
about the forced organ harvesting.
It is one of the worst human rights crimes
of the modern era.
It really rivals some of the Nazi doctors,
Mengele, I think that was Katrina Atlantis' sweat analogy,
and I think it's very apt.
So we have the world's experts on this issue
with us this afternoon,
and I'm really glad we have a longer period
than we did at the plenary session.
So let me quickly introduce them,
because I know you're eager to hear from our experts.
So it's Levi Braud, who is the information,
the executive director of the Falun Dafa Information Center.
My colleague at Hudson, Nori Turkle,
who is now the chair of the U.S. Commission
on International Religious Freedom,
and he is an author of a fabulous new book
that's very worthwhile reading for everyone
interested in human rights and religious freedom,
and that is No Escape, out on Amazon.
And he heads several associations, advocacy associations
for Uyghur Muslims in Xinjiang.
And then Ethan Gottman,
who actually bridges both communities,
and he has been embedded with both communities,
both the Falun Gong and also with the Uyghur Muslims
and Kazakh Muslims that were from Xinjiang,
and has written The Slaughter in the early part of this,
well, almost 10 years ago,
and has been researching the issue
from the early part of this century.
So, and let me add that Ethan
is the world's foremost human rights field researcher
on this issue.
We're also very blessed today to have with us
a remarkable young woman, Han Yu, who is with us here,
and you may have seen her video that was absolutely powerful
and a very moving video testimony
of the situation of your father,
who was a Falun Gong practitioner,
arrested in a detention camp, and then pronounced dead,
even though he was a healthy man, as you said.
Several months later, you viewed his body,
and as you described on the video,
you saw that his torso had been cut open
from top to bottom and sewn shut with black sutures,
and it really bore every evidence
of being a victim of forced organ harvesting.
Before we start, Han Yu,
would you like to give a message
to our audience just briefly?
Thank you so much.
Yes, please help stop it.
So, forced organ harvesting, again,
is when a heart patient, for example,
calls a transplant center in China,
gets a date certain for maybe the next day
or a couple days later, a couple weeks later,
to get an organ transplant.
The transplant hospital then checks the government database
for a tissue match from among a vast network of detainees.
Usually, these are, as we're finding out
from the UN and others,
religious prisoners, religious minorities,
particularly, primarily Falun Gong,
but also now moving to the Uyghur Muslims and other people,
also affecting Tibetan Buddhists,
also house church Christians.
So, then the detainee is transferred to a hospital
where a surgical team removes their organ,
their heart, in this case,
and while they are still alive,
the surgeon performing as an executioner,
extrajudicial executioner,
and then the transplant takes place.
This has made China the foremost,
maybe the first or second transplant industry in the world,
and it has been done with a lot of American help,
and we're gonna get into that a little bit more today.
So, Levi, I'd like to start with you.
Could you tell us about some of the features
that affect Falun Gong,
like what have you found over the years?
This has been going on for two decades now,
and give us some, just a few minutes of insights
into what happened with Falun Gong.
Is this purely profit-making?
Is there a persecution element?
Give us some of the insights
into what the reasons are behind this,
how it got started,
and what the perspective of the various actors.
Okay, thank you very much, Nina.
So, with Falun Gong,
there's an interesting thing to notice
about the correlation between the imprisonment,
the mass imprisonment of Falun Gong
and organ harvesting that took off in China.
You have to understand, in the 1990s,
Falun Gong was immensely popular.
There were 100 million people practicing.
It was endorsed by the government.
It was every park, every village,
every town around the country.
It was widely celebrated
because it brought back traditional values and so forth.
So, this was a rather abrupt change,
and the change was this.
The leader of the Communist Party at the time,
Jiang Zemin, saw in Falun Gong,
obviously, an enormous group of people
that were outside Communist Party control,
a group of people
that were restoring traditional Chinese values
that the Communist Party had been trying
to stamp out for decades,
but primarily, he saw a group
that was stealing his thunder, to be quite honest.
He was a leader that was desperately trying
to build a power base,
and all everyone around the country
was talking about was Falun Gong,
and so, in the summer of 1999,
he himself, over the advice of the Politburo
and many leaders in China,
ordered that Falun Gong be eliminated,
and almost overnight,
a highly celebrated traditional Chinese practice
becomes public enemy number one.
In the ensuing few years,
hundreds and hundreds of thousands
of Falun Gong practitioners are rounded up,
putting in labor camps,
sometimes in some of these secret camps
that the PLA runs,
and Jiang Zemin's order was basically
to destroy them financially,
destroy their reputation,
destroy them physically.
What you saw in the early 2000s
is someone or a group of people realized
that they could implement Jiang Zemin's order
to destroy Falun Gong,
and also make millions and millions of dollars.
This is a billion-dollar industry,
and so, the beginning of the 2000s,
whereas organ transplants were very rare
in China beforehand,
suddenly, if you look at a graph,
it suddenly just takes off
in exact correlation
with the number of Falun Gong practitioners
that are being held in prisons,
and that's really as it started.
It was the perfect mix
between implementing Jiang Zemin's order
to stamp out Falun Gong,
and also make a ton of money in the process,
and that's really how this whole thing got started.
So, it was a monetization of persecution,
as I like to call it,
and has this ended?
Nori Turk, I'm gonna throw this to you.
Thank you, Nina.
Thank you so much for your continued efforts
to shine a spotlight
on the ongoing commercialization
of human organs in China.
For the Uyghurs,
it started as a part of the punishment method
way back in the mid-'90s.
It turned out to be a commercial,
it appears that it has been commercialized
in addition to the punitive nature
of the practice in China.
If you look back,
the ratcheting up,
the Chinese pressure on the Uyghur communities
started in the mid-'90s
after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
China tried to prevent the Uyghurs rising up
and demand political sovereignty
like the neighboring states.
And then with the February 1997,
Uyghur youth took to the street
that resulted in a large incarceration
of Uyghur religious conservative community members.
And then following that,
there was a mass trials
resulting death penalty to the Uyghur dissidents
and community religious leaders.
That's how I grew up in China
learning about this practice.
This is nothing new to me.
I knew that this was-
I was born in a concentration camp,
a re-education camp to be exact,
which is much like the one
that we're trying to fight to shut down.
But I spent a lot of time in Kashgar and Urumqi.
Kashgar is considered as a hotbed for Uyghur nationalism.
So there's always been a focus on my place of birth.
So, and then in the last several years,
particularly since the start of the current crisis,
the genocide that has been recognized,
we've seen some disturbing signs.
One, the fast track organ transplant at the Aksu Airport
that came to our attention through a social media posting
in the early period of the ongoing crisis.
And we were curious and what on earth
that the airport has that green
Chinese and Uyghur language fast track direction.
And then before that,
including some of my family, friends, and relatives.
That's for the organs from the hospital
to be rushed out onto the plane, to be taken to-
Taken to inland Chinese cities for organ transplant.
And then before this was known to us
or came to our attention,
we were somewhat dumbfounded
that there was a free health checkup, blood testing,
including some of my family members and relatives
were asking me why would the government offering.
And these people that we know
did not need to have a free medical checkup.
They were in a pension,
they had their own health coverage,
but they were just literally forced to go
to have their blood samples were given.
And then in 2019, 18 period,
Radio Free Asia reported crematorium
around the camps that China has built.
And also it begs the question,
why would you have that many crematorium
adjacent or next to around the same area as those camps?
And then around the same time,
there's something also very disturbing
that we find out that there was a video circulated
coming out from Beijing
about Halal Organ Transplant Hospital.
And the patient was interviewed and he was so pleased.
The wait time is short,
the hospital is world class.
And the gentleman was speaking Arabic.
So with that, I think that the Chinese government's
ongoing persecution of the Uyghurs using various methods
now becoming kind of a commercial
or political economy for them.
So the Halal Organ video,
when they're boasting that the Chinese hospital
is boasting that it can offer supposedly Halal
or kosher as we say organs pitched to Arab speaking world
based on Uyghur Muslim, Kazakh Muslim organs.
So when, about what year was all this that you know,
that observed?
This is approximately 2019.
Okay.
And organs don't have to be Halal to be transplanted.
No, of course not.
But that's one of their methods to promote, market.
Yeah, it's sort of clumsy effort to market this.
And so you have hospitals which are making a profit
from this.
And this is nation in Beijing.
And you have, and it also indicates a tourism,
a transplant tourism attracting people
from all over the world who can pay
because the wait time is so short, so incredibly short.
Kidneys in the United States takes over four years
wait list to get a kidney transplant.
Hearts may be a little shorter,
maybe it's a couple of weeks.
But in China, it's like immediate for any of these
because they go down apparently a database
of those blood samples and tissue screening,
organ screening.
And you know, it's first emerged as Levy pointed out,
you know, in 2000, you know, 2006 in the United States,
we knew about it, but it's been ignored.
And I think Chris Smith, Congressman Chris Smith
had a hearing this spring and there was a doctor
who was defected, who was part of this organ transplant.
He came here and talked about it.
He testified before Christmas Tom Lancelot's commission
and said that, you know, it's almost too bad to be true.
And that was what, you know, my colleague
at Hudson Peter Hosea there said to me
that he just heard this recently
that people don't believe it.
They think it's been completely debunked
because China has worked to debunk it through its propaganda
and because it's just so horrifying and so extreme,
it's hard to believe.
But Ethan, can you tell us this inflection point of 2015,
China has said, asserted,
very definitively that they abolished this practice in 2015
and have moved to a voluntary donor pool,
you know, that there would be voluntary donor registry
and that all the organs supply,
the source of human organs for transplantation
would come off of this list.
What has your field research found?
Can you shed light on this?
Yeah, I don't wanna spend very much time
on Chinese misinformation,
so I'm gonna handle that very briefly.
Basically, a funny thing happened on the way
from China declaring that it was on a voluntary program
and two things happened in particular.
One was that we came out with a report in 2016
right after they had announced this
showing that their transplant volume in China
was not 10,000, but was actually 60,000 to 100,000 per year.
And we were able to prove that,
it was a very extensive report.
That was widely reported.
So imagine that, so let's start with that
as a kind of a figure, 75,000 transplants per year,
that puts them almost twice the volume that America does,
by far the biggest in the world.
This was very easy to establish.
We found one hospital which was doing
about 8,000 per year, a single hospital.
They're in every province.
That's what followed,
and this is what they built on fallen gong organs.
The second thing is that they,
to try to reach that kind of volume
because they felt they had to respond in some way
by showing some kind of growth,
so like 20,000 or so, or 23,000 I think
was the number they came up with.
They started making up the voluntary numbers.
Now the way we know that is because
Matt Robertson and Jacob Levy from Israel
put together a report where they just basically
looked at those statistics.
It turned out it was all based on a single equation,
which was creating a parabolic curve,
and that was the voluntary donation numbers.
Now the chances of that happening in real life
are a million to one, and you would only do this
if you were trying to cover up something.
Presumably you wouldn't do this
with a successful voluntary donation program.
After that, you are left,
I can supply some numbers for right now,
which I think represent where we are.
The first is 25,000 to 50,000 Uyghurs
are harvested for their organs every year.
The average age is 28 years old.
I can't tell you within that framework
exactly what that number is.
I can say that Falun Gong are still being harvested.
I don't know the scale.
I know that two of my witnesses from Kazakhstan
mentioned seeing Falun Gong in their camps.
I've interviewed about 20 witnesses,
which is actually a lot.
That's far more than anybody's been able
to come up with in this world
because the Chinese are keeping this very close.
But I can say that out of that,
two people did mention this.
They can't tell me how many of the numbers,
how many Falun Gong were there
because they're not allowed to speak to each other.
Everything is under complete surveillance,
which is a difference from the Falun Gong days
where people did talk sometimes in labor camps.
But having said that,
and Nuri mentioned the fast lanes,
the organ fast lanes, and that's true.
But it's also true that we found,
Gulchara Hoja was the one who discovered this
from Radio Free Asia,
and I've added to it a bit.
But basically, we discovered a compound,
a hospital that used to be a SARS hospital,
then became a religious dissident hospital,
and then became a transplant hospital.
And then it became a hospital surrounded by a camp
for 33,000 Uyghurs.
Next to it is a 16,000 Uyghur camp,
and then just above that,
again, this is all within a single kilometer,
is a crematorium.
It is the largest crematorium I've ever seen.
There is presumed to be nine of these
that were constructed.
The order was given a couple of years ago
to construct these crematoriums.
We know that the guards are all Han Chinese.
There's 50 security guards in the Urumqi crematorium,
and they're all paid $1,200 a month.
This is unbelievable salary for that part of the world,
and I've never heard of a crematorium in my life
which has 50 security guards,
and I don't think anybody in this room
has ever heard of such a thing.
Yes, well, there's another thing.
While I was doing work on forced labor in Turkey,
I happened to run into several people who were from Aksu.
They didn't even know each other,
but I asked them, have you ever driven down this road?
And they said, yeah.
I said, anything to report?
And they said, yeah, there's a crematorium there.
And I said, well, how do you know?
He said, oh, the smell.
Okay, so the smell is of human bones,
and then there's a sign,
and they just presumed it was all for Chinese
because Uyghurs don't like to have their bodies cremated.
But I just say this is where that Aksu compound
is 20 minutes away from an airport,
Aksu International Airport, which does have a green lane,
just like Nuri Turkel described.
So that part of it's a bit new,
but I wanna say one last thing just in closing.
The continuity I see between the witnesses,
the continuity of the numbers
between the Uyghurs and Falun Gong,
I mean, I'm sorry.
I mean, the BBC was calling me up and saying,
can you give us some new exciting news?
I said, no, it's all the same story.
It's just different faces.
It's just different ethnicities.
That's the truth.
I've seen incredible continuity
ever since this rose with Falun Gong,
from about 2000, 3004 to now.
Nothing has changed.
And I'd like to point out that the uniqueness of this panel,
because we have here today the experts
both on Falun Gong, the top experts,
and the Uyghur Muslims, and we're able to draw this link.
I also wanna point out that the significance
of both the crematoriums and the detention camps,
the detention camps have no oversight,
and there's no independent Red Cross presence
that's going through checking on what's happening
and the welfare and well-being
of each and every detainee in it.
There's no due process.
They don't go before judges or courts.
There's no sentence.
And it gives every opportunity for all kinds of abuses.
And we have heard about that
with the Uyghurs just recently,
with leaked police reports to our press and videos.
A Chinese Communist Party was telling us that these were,
and telling the world that these camps
for the Uyghurs in Xinjiang were simply re-education camps
so they could get a vocational training camps.
Not re-education camps, vocational training camps.
They're emphatically not.
The internal documents show,
the police internal documents, the security internal videos
show exactly that they are concentration camps
and they're very close to the public.
So every opportunity is there for this kind of abuse.
The same thing happened with Falun Gong in earlier era
where there was massive detention
after 1999, early part of the century,
massive detention so that there was,
this was a living organ bank essentially
for this budding industry in China at the time.
And then the crematoriums, the significance of this
is that, I mean, Han Yu's case was,
father's case was somewhat unique
in that the family did, and Han Yu did view his body.
But in most cases, the family is not given returned,
is not given a chance to do that.
And instead, they're told that their loved one
has died in prison or they're told nothing
and they're just disappeared and they're never seen again.
And maybe the family is given the ashes if they're lucky.
So Levi, can you give us, I mean, China does hide this.
No one has access.
There is no, as Ethan said,
communication is very, very difficult now
with constant surveillance.
How do you get your evidence of what,
how did you piece it together in the early years,
from the earliest years, that what was going on here?
Can you give some examples?
Sure, sure.
I think the early years were tough.
The very first word we got was that early 2006,
we're actually coming from a doctor and or a doctor,
as well as a doctor's relative.
And they were the very first ones that came out
and said this is happening.
They got lambasted.
They were called crazy.
Fortunately, some heroes stood up,
one of which is here with us today,
Ethan Gutman, David Mattis, David Kilgore.
Several of investigators said,
we need to take a very close look at this.
And it didn't take long to realize
these people were telling the truth.
If you looked at the hospital websites
of some of these institutions,
they would be openly advertising
what Nina had just talked about.
Wait times of a week for a kidney that was,
or a vital organ that would normally take three months.
The only way that's possible
is to have a large bank of pre-screened people
that you're ready to kill
and to fly in when you want an organ.
We also noticed, and what I found was the most shocking
is the admissions by the doctors
and the hospital administrators themselves.
We had undercover investigators calling into China,
pretending that they needed a vital organ.
And you have doctors, these are medical doctors,
hospital administrators openly admitting
that they have fresh organs that can be had at any time,
that yes, indeed, they're Falun Gong,
and isn't that great?
Because the Falun Gong lead a healthy lifestyle.
They don't drink, they don't smoke.
So these are gonna be very good organs.
These are people openly admitting this over phone calls.
And it was phone call after phone call after phone call.
And in many cases, we had a couple investigators
around the room, like David Kilgore was sitting there
as we would call to authenticate the number
and who we're talking to.
I found that the most shocking.
And it's been difficult in more recent years
because for obvious reasons,
they've been very careful what they say.
But even as recently as a year and a half ago,
some are still doing this, admitting over the phone
that they have Falun Gong and they can come and get.
So I think this was an enormous piece of evidence.
Ethan already talked about a couple of things
that I think were obvious.
The blood tests that Nuri mentioned
are still going on.
You have cases and cases and cases,
hundreds and thousands of cases of people
who are being tortured or mistreated
or even just they were at home
and the police came and ransacked their home
and at the end of the ransacking, they take a blood test.
And so people who are being abused all over China,
Falun Gong, Uyghurs and so forth are being blood tested
in situations that just don't make sense.
So I think this was sort of
some of the more compelling evidence.
There is one thing I just wanted to touch upon
what Ethan mentioned.
I mean, he gave the right numbers.
I think those are the most authenticated numbers
in terms of how many people are being killed
on organ harvesting a year.
What is astonishing to me
is even if you took the Chinese government
at their own word, they said they have a million donors.
They say they have, in 2019,
they have a little over 8,000 people who actually donated.
Even if you run those numbers,
this means that the donation network inside China
is percentage-wise 62 times more affected
at yielding an actual donor from the donor pool
than America.
We've had decades and decades of a donor network situation.
So even if you use their numbers,
which are wholly inaccurate
for the reason that Ethan described,
they don't even add up.
It's completely nonsense.
And so I think those were some of the things
that really we looked at and said, this must be happening.
There is no other explained source other than Falun Gong
and then eventually the Uyghurs,
some Tibetans, some house Christians.
That's where these organs are coming from.
Yeah, I met a Christian from Xinjiang
who was in the camps that I guess Ethan
had first met over abroad.
And he brought him here with others,
a team of a group, the Victims of Communism Foundation,
brought him here this spring.
And he was blood tested.
He was terribly abused once he got
into the detention center in Xinjiang.
He was there for 10 months.
But when he was admitted,
they gave him a complete physical
and heart tests and heart screening.
I asked him about that specifically
and extracted his blood.
And the significance of that is that you need
to have that kind of testing for medical testing
for an organ match so the organ isn't rejected.
The UN special rapporteurs or experts,
12 of them got together in an extraordinary move
a year ago this month and said
that they were deeply alarmed.
They were alarmed by what they were hearing now
about this continuing practice of testing detainees
for their blood and screening their organs
that are transplantable and that they were
from all various religious minorities in China
and that it was continuing and that they were alarmed
that this was really solid evidence
of forced organ harvesting.
So the various,
ways of demonstrating this then has been
through case testimony.
It's been observed clues.
And it's been testimony from a range of actors
from what you're saying from doctors
to prison guards to the families
of the victims like Hanyu
and also from the transplant recipient.
And then there's statistical evidence
that Matthew Robertson and David Levy have done.
Ethan, you look like you want to say something.
I do really want to say something about that
because I really, you know, it was very nice of you
to say what you did about me and Kilgore and Maidas.
I do appreciate it.
Especially, I miss David Kilgore so much.
But the fact is, look, who are the people
who really stood up here?
Enver Tantay, the doctor, who had no reason to do so,
stood up in a London parliamentary meeting.
He could barely speak English at the time.
He had such a thick accent.
And he stood up and said,
they said, you know, open up for questions.
And he said, I don't have a question.
I have a story.
And he basically said, I did this with my own hands.
And he did.
He had killed a man.
And, you know, as he's told the story over the years,
it's become more and more intimate.
Basically, he never used to say this,
but he points out, this man was shot in the chest.
But he could have lived.
He could have survived.
He was in a condition to make that man survive.
But he was terrified.
Instead, he was just following the orders
that he was told to do.
Remove the kidneys, remove the liver,
do it as quickly as possible, then sew up the body.
So he killed a man, essentially.
This was an incredible admission.
And at the time, he was so scared afterwards,
that he thought that the police would come to his door
and arrest him, even though this had happened
all the way back in 1995.
So I think those kinds of people are heroes.
I think you're a hero.
I think the people who stand up and talk about this,
the witnesses in Kazakhstan,
they had nothing to gain by talking to me.
It was nothing but risk
to talk about their experiences in the camps.
Some of them have, not because of me,
but some of them have already been sent back
to Xinjiang to their deaths.
I only have tape recordings.
That's what's left of them.
So this is the risk out there, and it's a terrible risk.
And this is the long arm of China,
as felt so strongly out in the world, especially today,
even worse than it was during Falun Gong,
because of the surveillance methods,
of course, have gotten so much better.
Yeah, and I would caution you, Han Yu,
from going to Europe, because of Interpol,
and China is known to grab people who are from China
who report human rights abuses of all kinds.
So it's a real danger.
People are harassed in this country, in New York State,
and on some of our campuses.
So there was another compelling piece of evidence
that was astonishing, shocking.
It was Matthew Robertson again,
the Australian scholar and statistician who,
and I guess he did it with his partner, is that correct?
David, Dr. David Levy from Israel.
They did an algorithm of Chinese medical journals
for the word heart transplant and intubation,
words that would indicate the patient was alive
when the heart was extracted by the surgeon.
These were articles written by surgeons
in Chinese language journals,
and they unearthed, I think, 72 examples,
articles involving hundreds of medical personnel
admitting that they were extracting organs
and killing the person at the same time.
They didn't go into who these victims were,
but we know from other people's testimonies
that it was most likely either Falun Gong
or the Uyghur Muslims or other religious minorities.
Levi, would you want to add something,
or Nuri, would you like to discuss?
As for personal testimonies, evidence,
during the process of writing that book
that I mentioned earlier,
I've spoken to camp survivors,
direct, indirect victims, physicians.
I happened to go to school in inland China,
and most of my Uyghur friends were students
at Xi'an Medical University,
now either practicing medicine here, back home,
or completely pick up a different profession.
So I consulted, learned, including our mutual friend, Enver.
And one consistent story that I've been hearing
from all of the people that I interview
is involuntary medical checkup, blood testing.
In some instances, some Uyghur prisoners
forced to take a mysterious pill
that controlled their menstrual emotion.
And last December, the United States government
added Chinese Military Medical Academy
and its 11 affiliates
for developing brain-controlled weaponry
to be used for ethnic and religious groups in China.
This is the country,
this is the nature of the regime that we live in.
I wanted to be mindful about that.
And also, some of the DNA sequence-related reports
published early on in 2019, 2020,
pointing to an American scientist at the Yale Medical School
and also a thermo-fisher scientific,
the DNA sequencer maker,
also helped us to gather some information.
So there's a lot of information out there,
a lot of courageous people sharing their stories,
taking the risk.
But the question now becomes, what do we do about this?
How do we hold those doctors, those hospitals to account?
Well, Norah, you bring up the issue
that I think is even more stunning, if possible,
than what is happening in China.
After all, we've had a glimpse here
of China's depredations and unethical activity
during COVID and the pandemic in the early days then
when they hid so much information
and allowed the pandemic to spread.
And that is that there is enormous collaboration
between American universities and colleges,
medical schools and hospitals, transplant hospitals
with the Chinese hospitals, transplant hospitals.
And basically China has become the first
or next to the United States
or the second next to the United States
or the first in the world in transplantation
thanks to this Western support.
It wasn't just the United States,
but the United States heavily,
heavily have supported China in this.
Levi, could you tell us more about that?
Yeah, unfortunately, this is a chronic problem
across every industry in the United States
and in the West when it comes to the CCP,
ignorance and money.
It really comes down to those two factors.
On this particular topic in the medical industry
and the transplant industry specifically,
even today, there are hundreds of Chinese students
studying to become transplant doctors here in America.
And that represents a tremendous conflict of interest
for institutes here.
For example, there was a doctor
at a transplant institute in Utah
who is very much involved in an NGO
that's exposing transplant abuses in China, those crimes.
And he wanted to bring that to the attention
to his institute.
And when he brought it up, his superior was very candid.
He said, if you talk about this here,
we lose all our Chinese students and they all go to Texas.
And that's where they're gonna get educated.
And for that reason alone,
that issue is no longer talked about.
That's one specific story of an epidemic
that I think, according to Torsten Trey,
who heads up the Doctors Against Forced Organ Harvesting
organization, is rampant in the transplant industry.
And he sees it as two issues.
I mean, on one issue, there are people
who would sort of feel bad about this,
but they're very conflicted
because it's a very dark stain on their trade,
on what they do.
And they're not really,
they're very conflicted on what to do about that.
And then there's others who,
because of the economic interests,
and as we were talking before,
it's not just training doctors.
This is an entire industry.
It involves funding, it involves partnerships, technology.
All of that was trained, by and large,
by the U.S. and other Western countries.
And were this issue to come out,
it means all these institutions, all that money, fades away.
And that's a huge conflict of interest.
And I mentioned ignorance at the beginning
because that also plays a role.
I mean, there is an epidemic of ignorance
about the CCP, by and large, across the Western world.
They don't believe, they can't quite fathom
that a government, it's really a party,
would be this evil, that would actually do these things.
And so you have this two forces
where the non-believers, out of ignorance,
and the people who have economic interests
that are causing this whole issue to stay silent.
And I wanna give you one example
because I talked about this being an epidemic
across all industries.
There was a New York Times correspondent in China,
Beijing, who was gonna cover this.
They got the reading light,
they're doing some investigation.
They hear doctors, and this is in 2016,
so this is after they're supposedly
not using prisoners of conscience or anything like that.
She's investigating this.
She hears these doctors openly talk about
they're still using prisoners of conscience.
They didn't even know that the government
officially had banned it.
And so she knows all this stuff.
She testifies before the China Tribunal,
which occurred about a year and a half ago,
probably the most exhaustive investigation
into organ harvesting in the world.
And she was gonna report this story,
and her higher-ups at the Times killed it.
And so that feeds the ignorance.
And again, you've got this economic interest,
you've got this ignorance, and it's just a vicious cycle
that has really kept this thing quiet.
Doctors against forced organ harvesting
have chronicled the names of,
I think it's 340-plus Chinese transplant surgeons
who have been trained in the United States,
trained in their profession of transplant surgery
in the medical schools or hospitals in the United States.
And they have not only the names of the Chinese doctors,
they have the schools in the United States
where they were trained at.
How do they know this?
From their own bios.
If you go into the hospital registry
or the journal articles, medical journal articles,
you will find these Chinese transplant doctors' names
and their bios.
And it is, yeah, it is more than training.
It's educational exchanges, it's fellowships,
it's research, research money,
joint research money between American transplant hospitals
and Chinese transplant hospitals and publications.
It amazes me that there is so little curiosity
on the part of American transplant hospitals
and medical schools.
And these are the preeminent schools.
So I'm gonna name names.
It's Harvard, it's Stanford, it's University of Pittsburgh.
I'm sure, Levi, you know a lot more.
There are scores of them in the United States
that are collaborating
with the Chinese transplant sector.
And I think maybe they started out with altruism,
altruism mixed with ignorance.
China wasn't rich then,
and there was the prestige that goes along
with these international links.
And then pretty soon you had not only funds flowing
the other way from China to the United States,
but they still go from United States to China.
You also had this influx of students
that the universities depend on
and which China can hold out in a way
that this is going to be withdrawn, as you said.
So it's extremely troubling,
and I'd like to get your reflections,
starting with Nori and then Ethan and Levi,
on medical ethics.
And in the United States, transplant sector is obsessed
with trying to find organ supplies
because there is a shortage of organs.
People are dying every year
for lack of organ to transplant.
And they're experimenting with different blood techniques
to make the matches easier or with pig hearts,
but they never seem to ask the Chinese how they do it.
How do these hospitals have an unlimited supply
or have such an enormous yield
from their donor registry, as you explained?
So Nori, would you like to move on?
The practice is ongoing partly
because it has not been costly
for either the hospitals or the doctors,
and there is no proper
consequential actions that the US government,
for example, could take on them,
other than perhaps applying some sanctions measures.
Those doctors, those hospitals should be prevented,
specifically the doctors,
those 340-plus doctors should be prevented
traveling around the world freely.
Why would we allow them to come here
knowing that they have been complicit
in the ongoing crime against innocent people?
And also, we should also hold our hospitals,
university hospitals, to be exact,
I named Professor Kenneth Kidd,
who brought in an official,
known official from China's Ministry of Public Security
to his lab at Yale Medical School,
conducted DNA study of the Uyghur DNA samples.
So what is the consequence?
He was on NPR, did not even acknowledge
with a straight face that he knew of his lab assistant
was an employee of Ministry of Public Security.
So these kind of practices should stop.
We can be unhappy, and we should be critical
of the ongoing organ harvesting in China,
but what do we do to stop here the medical cooperation
between our academic institution,
our hospitals with the ones in Beijing?
Yes, I agree completely.
And there's another doctor, absolutely shameless,
is Dr. Francis Delmonico of Harvard University,
a Mass General.
He befriended someone named Wang Jiafu,
who was Vice Minister of Health,
but he was also a central committee member
of the Chinese Communist Party,
according to the Carnegie Endowment for Peace
in their register.
And this Wang Jiafu, the CCP central committee member,
proposed a task force to advise WHO,
the World Health Organization,
on ethical practices of organ transplant.
And they made Delmonico, the Harvard professor,
Harvard doctor, surgeon, transplant surgeon,
the head of it, the chair of it.
And Ethan, you were saying in the plenary the other day
that they never asked you, never took you up on your offer
to listen to detainee tapes.
And that took no interest in detainees
and what was happening to them
and these egregious reports that they were being used
as a living organ bank against their will, obviously.
A lot of this comes down to simple human.
Westerners do not like to lose face either.
They do not like to reverse their own decisions
or what they've said are their decisions.
Look, but by doing this,
and I'm not letting Beijing off the hook here.
They're number one.
It's their fault that we're in the situation we're in.
But it is true that the World Health Organization
and the Transplantation Society
are doing a great disservice to China
because China's future, seen in a practical level,
is pharmaceuticals.
That is their pillar industry.
They've always known it.
They have a huge population who can be experimented on.
They can run drugs out very quickly.
That's where the money is, not in organ harvesting.
There's plenty of money in organ harvesting.
I think it's 10 billion a year,
but that's nothing compared to the real payoff.
If you think about it that way,
they will never succeed in pharmaceuticals.
China will never.
Nobody has any trust in China.
Now, that's partly because their Sinovac was a disaster.
Okay, and the pandemic, obviously,
and the pandemic and their terrible vaccine,
but also because the whole system
has been completely corrupted by organ harvesting.
We're often asked,
and I'm sure this has happened to you, too,
that where does the money go?
Follow the money.
Well, we can't follow the money in China,
but we know it's divided up,
much like a gang divides up a bunch of drug benefits
after they sell a bunch of cocaine.
The money gets divided.
That's all we know.
I think it's important to recognize
that the Transplantation Society
is not doing itself any favors,
and the sooner that we move to what Nuri Turkal
was talking about, to a system
where we completely ban all contact
with the Chinese transplant,
any entities involved in it,
very similar to what happened
to the Soviet psychiatrists during the Cold War.
This is where we wanna be.
This is, at this point, this is the only answer.
Thanks.
Well, I think a first step is going to be
the passage of the Stop Forced Organ Harvesting Act,
and Chris Smith is backing that,
Congressman Chris Smith, who spoke at lunch today.
He's a stalwart on all these issues,
and human rights issues,
and it has 30-plus bipartisan members
of Congress supporting it now,
and it has a Senate companion,
and hopefully it'll be called for a vote at some point,
but before the end of the term.
But that's a first step,
which is gonna require the registration
of every medical institution
that collaborates with China.
That will be a start.
I want you all to think, if you have any questions,
we may have a minute or two for that.
Okay, good.
But would you like to have a last word on that?
I think I would come back to,
the medical institutions have been trying to save face,
and trying to save money, and some ignorance,
and I think both gentlemen here
are absolutely right on that,
and as well, what you talked about.
I wanted to raise one point that,
it was a point that was sort of a metaphor
that David Maitis actually brought up,
in terms of the impact of not doing anything.
You know, when he was doing,
he made an analogy between the COVID vaccine,
sorry, the COVID virus and forced organ harvesting.
It's not a metaphor.
And I think one of the things he pointed out is that,
what would it mean to stop
forced organ harvesting in China?
For real, stop it.
That means we have to have enough transparency
into their medical system
to understand what every single hospital is doing.
That's the only way, in the short term, to stop it.
If the world had taken that seriously,
and we had those mechanisms in every single hospital,
guess what?
One of them would have been in Wuhan,
and we would have seen what was happening,
and things would have been very, very different.
Well, is that point true?
Taiwan proves it's true,
because Taiwan had exactly that.
Taiwan doctors on WeChat,
were on WeChat with the Wuhan doctors
the night the virus first was discovered in the hospital.
In days, Taiwan was shutting down flights to Wuhan,
several days later, shutting down flights to all of China,
and look at what happened to Taiwan.
For the first year and a half of the pandemic,
they were on a different planet.
They had days and days and days of zero cases.
And so I think that is a very real example
that this is not just a metaphor,
it's not just doing the right thing.
This is real.
Not taking forced organ harvesting seriously
could have directly been related to the pandemic.
Definitely related to what happened to the Uyghurs then too.
Susan, you had a question?
Go ahead.
Speak up, because I guess we don't have a...
What made the exposure to get the message to the masses
in a way that is more powerful than any,
and any of you at this level?
First of all, you can't beat Genevieve Bujold in,
I mean, come on, give me a break.
It's an incredible movie.
My favorite movie of medical thrillers.
But now there have been some films that have been made.
It's middling success.
When I was talking to the BBC,
they've been working on something for some time.
This is not a terribly visual subject.
Let me just state that right now.
Most of the witnesses,
the most important people you will ever talk to,
you can't put them on camera.
And now some of them, as I said, have just gone.
And I think the BBC and a lot of other documentary
filmmakers have struggled with exactly this problem.
Okay.
One minute, because I think, no, go ahead.
Go ahead for one minute.
Just want to let you know,
it's the same problem as every other industry.
There actually have been a couple
of very compelling documentaries done.
Kate Rybczyk, you want to stand up for a second?
She's the producer of one of them in the building.
But they've hit the same problem
when it came to distribution.
No one wants to touch this as a documentary issue,
just like they don't want to touch it as a medical issue.
Faith, did you have a quick question or a quick comment?
Okay, that's a great idea.
I think the answer is yes.
We'll get together.
Okay, that's the end of our program.
Thank you all very much for coming.
Really appreciate it.
And I do.
Her courage.
Thank you.
Learned a lot from you.
