Shout out to @Kevin Jubbal, M.D. team for making this video possible and providing me with ALL of the research and details of the case. Go check out his even better video on this topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW5oMCVb5S0&t=1s
1RaDonda Vaught, a former Vanderbilt nurse, was criminally prosecuted for a fatal drug error in 2017, was convicted of gross neglect of an impaired adult and negligent homicide after a three-day trial in Nashville, Tennessee. Vaught faces three to six years in prison for neglect and one to two years for negligent homicide as a defendant with no prior convictions. Vaught's trial has been closely watched by nurses and medical professionals across the U.S., many of whom worry it could set a precedent of criminalizing medical mistakes. Medical errors are generally handled by professional licensing boards or civil courts, and criminal prosecutions like Vaught's case are exceedingly rare. Did this case just change healthcare forever? Let me know what you think in the comments below!
00:39 - What Happened in this Case 03:53 - Summary of what happened 05:08 - Why People support this case 06:35 - Why People are Against this case 10:01 - My Thoughts
*None of this is meant to be construed as investment advice, it's for entertainment purposes only. Links above include affiliate commission or referrals. I'm part of an affiliate network and I receive compensation from partnering websites. The video is accurate as of the posting date but may not be accurate in the future.
What terrifies me the most about all of this is that this could have been any of us.
Welcome back to the channel, everybody.
For those of you who are new around here, my name is Michael, aka Dr. Chalini,
and I am a board-certified diagnostic and interventional radiologist in New Jersey.
Okay, so by now, you've probably heard of Radonda Vaught, who is a former Vanderbilt nurse
who was recently found guilty for criminally negligent homicide and gross neglect of an impaired adult
in the death of a patient who was accidentally given the wrong medication.
She is now facing jail time for those charges, somewhere in the range of three to six years.
So this is a pretty groundbreaking case and a lot to unwrap,
so let's go ahead and do a deep dive right now.
Let's go.
Okay, so by now, you've probably heard of the synopsis of what happened,
but if you don't know anything about this case,
let me do a quick run-through of exactly what happened.
This particular incident occurred at Vanderbilt Medical Center in December of 2017.
Radonda Vaught, who was a former nurse at Vanderbilt Medical Center,
was a help-all nurse at that time.
During the time of this particular accident,
she was taking care of a patient by the name of Charlene Murphy.
Charlene Murphy was being treated for a subdural hematoma or bleeding around the brain.
Allegedly, Murphy's condition was improving at the time nurse Vaught was taking care of her
and she was going down for a routine PET scan.
Now, let's just pause there because I found this part very interesting for these reasons.
One, why is somebody with a subdural hematoma going for a PET scan?
That literally makes zero sense.
Number two, why is patient Murphy having a PET scan as an inpatient?
PET scans are almost exclusively for outpatients
and are used for staging and workup of cancer, not brain bleeds.
Anyways, back to the story.
Prior to the PET scan that this patient was receiving,
she was worried about being claustrophobic during the examination,
so the physician on the case ordered Versed or Midazolam.
This happens all the time in radiology and nuclear medicine.
If a patient is claustrophobic,
the physician orders an anxiolytic or Versed in this particular scenario
so the patient can get through the case without moving or feeling claustrophobic.
So, what did Radonda Vaught do?
Well, she went over to the Pyxis system or whatever the medicine vending machine is
and looked up Versed and couldn't find it.
So instead, she used the override function and found a similar drug that started with VE,
but this wasn't Versed, this was Vecuronium.
Vecuronium happens to be a very powerful paralytic that's used during intubation.
It literally paralyzes every single muscle in the body, including the diaphragm.
Once she pulled out the Vecuronium from the system using the override feature,
she drew it up and injected it into the patient.
According to the allegations, Vaught ignored many red flags during this whole process
and also failed to monitor the patient's vitals after the medication was given.
Approximately 30 minutes after the medication was administered,
the patient was found by patient transport to be unresponsive.
A code was called and CPR was administered.
The medication error was discovered at this time
and was reported to the physician and the nurse manager.
The CPR was in fact successful and they got Return of Spontaneous Circulation or ROSC.
But the fact that the patient has been without oxygen
for the past 30 minutes due to paralysis,
the patient suffered an anoxic brain injury and the family ultimately decided
to put the patient on DNR and comfort care.
The patient was removed from all of her life support devices
and ultimately died shortly thereafter.
Two Vanderbilt neurologists ultimately reported the cause of death
from the subdural hematoma and not the medication error.
Redonda Vaught reportedly had multiple conversations with risk management
over the next few days and ultimately was fired.
Of note here, Vanderbilt Medical Center decided not to report the medical error
on the state or federal level, which is required by law.
And speaking of Vanderbilt Medical Center,
they also decided to settle out of the court system
with Charlene Murphy's family for an undisclosed amount.
This settlement happened somewhere in 2018 and required Charlene Murphy's family
not to speak out publicly about the death or the medication error.
Nobody knows the actual amount that Charlene Murphy's family was given,
but I'm sure it was a nice chunk of change.
Okay, so let's quickly summarize before we continue.
Redonda Vaught administered an incorrect medication to Charlene Murphy
which ultimately resulted in her death in late 2017.
Vanderbilt Medical Center allegedly covered up this whole thing
and settled outside of the court with Charlene Murphy's family.
And with all of this, Redonda Vaught was fired.
And that's case closed.
Well, not exactly.
Here's where things get kind of interesting.
Almost a year later, October of 2018, after everything was kind of taken care of,
an anonymous tip was reported to the federal health officials
about an unreported medical error.
And after this, the Tennessee Health Department obviously found out about it
and chose not to pursue further investigation or disciplinary actions on Ms. Vaught.
About this time, the Vanderbilt Medical Center was investigated by the CMS,
or Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services,
which ultimately resulted in a slap on the wrist.
Now let's fast forward to February 2019.
This is when Redonda Vaught was arrested and criminally indicted
on the medication error that happened in 2017.
And after a long COVID-delayed trial,
she was found guilty on March 25th, 2022,
of criminally negligent homicide and abuse on an impaired adult.
Okay, so now that we know what happened here, let's discuss both sides.
Because if you've followed anything about this case
or been browsing social media about it,
you've seen many different sides and many different opinions.
Okay, so first and foremost here,
a lot of people are arguing that Redonda Vaught was negligent
in that the fact that she ignored all these red flags with this medication.
All these red flags could have prevented
this whole medical error from actually happening.
So let's go through each of these red flags.
First one, she couldn't find the Versed in the system,
so she had to override the system to be able to open the drawer and browse the medications.
Two, she pulled out Vecuronium instead of Versed.
Furthermore, on the Vecuronium bottle,
it literally says paralyzing agent warning on the top of the actual vial itself.
Three, Vecuronium is actually a powder that you have to reconstitute,
whereas Versed is a liquid which you literally just drop and inject.
There are not multiple steps in using it.
And I'm willing to bet she's given Versed hundreds of times in her day,
especially working in the radiology or nuclear medicine department,
so these things just didn't click when she was going through it.
And fourth, the patient should have also been monitored
after giving a medication like Versed,
Versed in this case,
because if the patient was monitored,
they would have known that there was respiratory depression
and maybe they would have seen the vial that they accidentally given the wrong medicine
and could have reversed it with something like Sudamidex,
which is a reversal agent that anesthesiologists use for this kind of paralytic.
Another reason why people are on board with this case
because they think it sets a good example for healthcare staff going forward.
They think it may force healthcare workers to pay attention to the checklists
and the policies in place to help prevent this in the future.
And if they don't, they will be held personally liable or even prosecuted, like in this case.
Okay, so there are always two sides to every story,
so let's look at the argument against this case
and how the charges brought upon Ms. Vought are not good for healthcare system as a whole.
First and foremost, even though Redonda Vought did everything wrong
in terms of administering the wrong medication
and all the red flags she ignored along the way,
she actually did the right thing once she realized the error.
She reported the error to the nurse manager, the physician,
risk management, and many other people along the way.
And even though she reported to the appropriate people at her hospital,
it was never actually reported to the authorities by Vanderbilt Medical Center.
So she was transparent with her mistake,
but still charged with criminally negligent homicide,
which is usually reserved for healthcare workers who have intent behind their actions,
not in the realm of negligence caused by a mistake.
Furthermore, one could argue now that, with the results of this case,
being transparent and reporting your mistakes could have severely negative consequences,
which may lead to underreporting of mistakes in the future,
which is something we don't need in healthcare.
After all, why would you want to report a medical error
no matter how big or small it is if you could be criminally prosecuted for it,
or even go to jail?
This may actually go the complete opposite way of decreasing a culture of safety.
And one thing I keep seeing over and over
is that Redonda Vaught is a scapegoat throughout all of this.
Vanderbilt clearly didn't pursue any legal actions against Vaught,
and even the family chose to forgive her and didn't pursue criminal charges.
But all of a sudden, an anonymous tip comes about,
and these prosecutors jump on the case,
and ultimately turn it into a criminal trial.
And you can't help but think,
are there ulterior motives behind these prosecuting attorneys for doing this?
It is a unique case, and maybe it'll help them get their name out there
for future endeavors or whatnot,
or maybe it'll help them advance in their career
and be known as the attorney that prosecuted Redonda Vaught.
It's a very high-profile case, and it may open up more doors in the future.
It is interesting to see how this case was basically brought back to life
after being completely handled almost a year prior.
The next argument against this case is that
Redonda Vaught already lost her nursing license,
which means she can't practice as a nurse ever again.
What more do you want here?
Is there actually a benefit to criminally processing her
when she can't even practice again as it is?
Like, she literally doesn't have the ability to make that mistake again
because she doesn't have a license.
Criminally prosecuting her doesn't fix the problem that occurred
or even set a precedent for new safety guidelines going forward.
There just isn't a lot of reason behind prosecuting her.
Her mistake already helped bring to light
some of the issues at Vanderbilt Medical Center,
and because of this, those issues have already been rectified.
So what does sending her to prison really do for anybody
besides help the prosecuting attorneys win a case?
The fourth argument I keep seeing is that
this was clearly a systemic issue and not one person's fault.
Yes, she was ultimately the one who pulled those medications and injected it,
but there are a lot of questions about why she was even able to do so.
Why was Vecuronium even in the medication drawer near a PET scanner?
When do you use that down there?
Why would you intubate a patient at the PET scanner?
It's a really odd medication to have down there altogether.
Why was she able to override the medication system
to get Vecuronium instead of Versed?
Why isn't there a two-nurse system that helps verify high-risk medications,
like there are at a lot of hospitals?
Why is the patient not monitored in the PET scanner
after you give an anxiolytic medicine?
Why did Vanderbilt not report the incident to proper authorities?
Why did they not get in trouble for not doing that?
The point here is that there were a lot of people involved in this whole case
and there's only one person being criminally processed
and the others are completely scot-free.
Okay, so what do I personally think about this case?
For starters, I think this brings to light how the healthcare system is set up
in a way that makes medical errors inevitable.
As healthcare workers, especially nurses,
we are incredibly overworked with limited resources and no support
and we continue to be pushed upon our capabilities.
Many nurses are being asked to take care of more patients
outside of their comfort zone or what is considered safe.
They're being forced to work longer hours and are being pushed to their limits.
It's actually more shocking to me that more medical mistakes like this haven't happened.
And the administrations that are allowing these unsafe environments
for healthcare workers and patients will never have anything happen to them.
But this nurse who made the mistake because of the system
will get criminally charged and likely go to prison because of this.
It doesn't make much sense.
If anything comes from this case,
it's basically just highlighting the flaws of our healthcare system.
And rather than talking about how we can improve the healthcare system
or prevent something like this from ever happening again,
we are criminally charging one person and putting them in jail,
which does literally nothing for anybody
except maybe the prosecuting attorneys involved.
We are essentially overlooking the bigger picture here.
With this trial, we are essentially disincentivizing healthcare workers
from coming forward with medical errors and quality improvement.
After all, why would you come forward with a medical error
if you could go to jail from that error?
This does the exact opposite of making a patient safety a priority.
Under-reporting of medical errors is the absolute last thing you want,
especially in the current healthcare environment.
And I touched on this briefly,
but it's also alarming that this one healthcare worker
is the only person singled out from all of this.
Nobody else was responsible.
They're putting all the blame from this systemic issue on the one nurse.
And that's the scariest part of all.
This literally could have been any of us.
Furthermore, the pandemic has finally slowed and healthcare workers are exhausted.
Nursing shortages continue,
and how on earth do you expect to get more nurses when something like this happens?
You think people are going to want to go into nursing
knowing that they could go to jail for making one mistake?
This really sets a terrible precedent for all healthcare workers going forward.
I ultimately do not want to diminish what happened in this terrible tragedy.
However, this nurse has no business being prosecuted
for negligent homicide for a medical mistake.
We are human.
We do our best to prevent any and all mistakes we can,
especially ones of this magnitude.
The reason we have malpractice insurance is because we are human.
We make mistakes, even when we don't want to.
And what terrifies me the most about all this
is that this could have been any of us.
And that officially concludes this video.
Let me know in the comments below what you think of this case and about this video.
I'm curious to see what you all think about this case.
Keep it classy in the comments.
Follow me on Instagram, TikTok.
Subscribe to my channel, and I'll see you all on the next one.
Bye!