China Über Alles: Levi Browde On Falun Gong

Falun Dafa Information Center
4.3K followers
1.5K Video Views·Aug 15, 2021
July 20th marks exactly 22 years since the Chinese Communist Party launched a massive campaign to eliminate the Falun Gong spiritual movement in China. Millions of Falun Gong practitioners in China have since been imprisoned, tortured, or killed, including through forced organ harvesting. The party’s persecution of Falun Gong has also extended far beyond China’s borders, resulting in censorship, cyber attacks, and transnational repression affecting believers in dozens of countries.
The Falun Dafa Information Center’s executive director, Levi Browde, joins the China Uber Alles radio program to provide the latest updates, trends and global impact of this human rights crisis in China.
He is on the KSL telephone now. You want to introduce him for us?
Yeah, Levi Brody. It's a CEO of Falun Gong Information Center in New York.
He's our return guest. He was with us back in April.
And now, like I mentioned earlier, in the beginning of today's program,
July 20th marked the 22nd anniversary of the persecution of Falun Gong.
It started in 1999. At that time, China had about 100 million people practicing Falun Gong.
And all the people practicing this meditation, spiritual exercise, has been under persecution.
So, Levi, welcome to our program.
Thank you very much for having me back.
I understood that in the past couple of weeks, all around the world,
there was a lot of protest in all different countries,
because Falun Gong now is practiced by people living in more than 100 nations.
So, all around the world, there's a lot of protest going on.
Can you tell us a little bit about that?
Sure. A couple of days ago marked July 20th,
and July 20th is the anniversary when the persecution began.
It was 22 years ago on July 20th that all around China, in the cover of night,
people were pulled from their beds in the middle of the night and taken to detention centers.
And it started the nationwide persecution of the 100 million people
that were practicing Falun Gong there at the time.
And that's been raging for the last 22 years.
Yeah, I thought there was a lot of activities going on, like a protest in front of Chinese consulate.
I know that Sunday night, they have some candle vigil night
in front of San Francisco Chinese consulate by local Falun Gong practitioners.
And I also heard that there was a lot of activities going on in Washington, D.C.
Do you have some of the information about those activities?
Yeah, I mean, a lot of the activities were centered in Washington, D.C.
We had a whole day there that started with a rally,
where we had a lot of national and international NGOs come out to speak,
everywhere from Freedom House, groups like that, some of the government agencies.
So we had a rally right there on the mall.
And then after that, there was a march through Washington,
and that culminated in a candlelight vigil just along sort of the,
I think it's the north side of the Washington Monument.
So that was a day-long event.
That was sort of the largest event, but as you mentioned,
I mean, Falun Gong was practiced in many cities around the world.
And so you had smaller events in San Francisco and Paris and London,
and all these different places where there are Falun Gong community
wanting to commemorate this sort of sad and tragic day.
Levi, is there any indication to you, to your group,
or to people who are fighting this persecution around the world,
that any of these demonstrations are even paid attention to by China?
Is this more of an effort to publicize the fact that it's happening,
rather than trying to change the Chinese government's ways?
I think it does change it, and I think there's two things that happen.
One is, you know, any time news,
any time something happens in the West,
there is a network run by Falun Gong practitioners
that is literally millions strong throughout China,
that normally what they do is it's sort of like an underground news source,
where they, you know, in their back rooms,
they have printers and they print out leaflets,
and they distribute them to towns and villages around China
in an effort to counter the persecution.
Well, in town, there's sort of a state-run narrative
to sort of let people understand what's really going on in their country,
but over that same network, news from the West travels as well.
I mean, obviously, the state-run media in China is not going to cover it,
but if we hold a huge rally in D.C., pretty soon, you'd be surprised,
people in even small towns and villages in China
see pictures and get news that that's happening.
That brings all kinds of impact in China.
It gives hope to a lot of people.
It also sort of stays the hand of would-be persecutors,
because they kind of see that this is an issue that's getting more attention,
and if you're somebody who's, like, working at a labor camp
or, I mean, a prison or a black jail,
and you're involved in torturing somebody, that really gives you pause.
So that's one thing that happens.
The second thing that happens is these events become a rallying cry
for major government forces.
So, for example, the State Department issued a statement on July 20th.
The Foreign Relations Committee of the U.S. Congress issued a statement.
Those two, those statements, make their way into China.
And so, again, coming to those people who are actually doing the persecuting inside China,
when they start reading that the State Department is saying stop it
and the U.S. Congress is saying stop it,
and combined with the sanctions that their State Department has been doing
over these last two years,
it does strike real fear into a lot of the police apparatus,
and that has real impact on restraining them.
Hi, Levi.
Do you have any information for the CCP
how they track down the Falun Gong people inside of China or outside of China?
Well, it's inside China.
It's largely done in two ways, technology and human intelligence.
And on the technology front, as you guys probably all very well know,
for the last 15 years, the CCP has built up the Great Firewall of China,
which started as just really a firewall to block people inside China from reaching free information.
But it has developed into way beyond that,
in which case they have anywhere from monitoring all the WeChat messages or Weibo messages
to doing facial recognition.
And we've had people actually picked up and arrested
because of these technology and surveillance ability and put into prison.
We even had a woman, you know, just recently actually in Tung Chung City in Hebei Province.
She wasn't even a practitioner. Her husband was.
And he was picked up and thrown to jail.
She knew that was a grave injustice, so she took to Weibo and WeChat,
and she started making a big fuss out of it.
They grabbed her. They put her in prison for four years.
She eventually died.
Is it inside China?
That's inside China. That was in Tung Chung City in Hebei Province.
So there's that. And then, of course, there's the old school human intelligence
where they simply grab Falun Gong practitioners and torture them
until they give up the names of other Falun Gong practitioners in their area.
And that, unfortunately, has been going on for the last 22 years.
Now, Li Wei, let me ask you this.
It's been going on for 22 years.
Do you have the information that how many people are actually being arrested
and how many people die in China?
Very, very difficult. It's very difficult.
Here's what we do know.
I had mentioned this network, right, which these days is million strong,
and it has been that big for many, many years.
So this is coordinated by an overseas website called minghui.org.
So every single day, they're getting between a dozen and several scores of reports
of people being imprisoned, harassed, extorted, tortured, sentenced.
And so they're getting that every day, and they have been for the last 22 years.
The problem is it is most definitely the tip of the iceberg.
So any numbers that we have there is just the ones we know about
because it's so dangerous.
As I mentioned about this woman from Tung Chung City,
it's so dangerous just to get online and report this stuff out of China.
It's just the tip of the iceberg.
So I'll give you an example of how different the numbers could be.
So minghui goes through a pretty thorough process
when they hear about a practitioner who's been tortured to death, for example.
They'll record that. They'll verify it in various ways.
So over the last 22 years, they've only recorded about 4,500 people
who've been tortured to death, a huge number.
But if you talk to some of the third-party investigators
like the journalist Ethan Gutman or the investigator and lawyer David Mattis
who's been looking into organ harvesting,
they'll tell us that by their estimations,
just looking at the number of organ harvesting transplants that are going on
and the fact that Falun Gong up until recently has really been the only source,
it's likely 60,000 or many, many more people are being killed for the organs
every single year.
And they're just looking at it from a forced organ harvesting.
So that's their estimate.
But you really, it's so difficult because obviously, you know, China's a cold system.
They're not going to just open up their doors and let you kind of walk in
and sort of talk to people and count this stuff.
But I will say for every single day for the last 20 years
across every single province in China,
minghui has received reports of imprisonment, detention, sentencing, torture, and killing.
We do know that.
Levi, let me ask you this.
In a country of over a billion people,
how many people do you estimate practice Falun Gong?
Well, we have a couple of data points on that.
We know for sure that when the persecution first started in 1999,
there was a government survey that came back and said
that there was at least 70 million people practicing.
Later that year, Shanghai TV, which again is state-run media,
said that there were over 100 million.
And, you know, state-run media is not going to say something
unless that came from somewhere.
So that was their estimate back when they didn't have an incentive
to change the numbers or make them smaller.
It's interesting to note that after they started the persecution,
they dropped that number to 3 million
to try and make it sound like the Falun Gong group was very small
without any sort of explanation.
So that's 70 to 100 million.
That's one data point we have.
The other data point we have is about, I think it was like five years ago,
four years ago, Minghui did an audit of all the people around China
who were downloading leaflets in order to print them out
and distribute them around China.
And they had a way of kind of analyzing unique IP addresses
and how many people are working in each of these sort of, you know,
living room print centers, we'll call them.
And they estimated it was about, they said at least 20 million people
were active.
So that's not including anybody who's just quietly practicing at home
or anything like that.
That's 20 million people are active.
So those are the two data points we have.
Anecdotally, we know that that flow of information coming from China
every day has not decreased.
It's increased.
And there's a lot of stories of people, you know,
a practitioner will be put into a prison and trying to conduct themselves
according to their principles of truthfulness, compassion, forbearance.
It's not uncommon for a lot of the criminals that they're incarcerated with
who have kind of lost hope on life, see that this person is trying to act
very morally and sort of shows them some of the practice.
And they start all practicing in the jail cell.
So those stories are very, very common.
That's all we can really sort of say in terms of what the numbers
would look like.
In hearing your number range, depending on which side of it you believe,
it's roughly twice the population of the entire state of California.
That's a lot of people.
Over 100 million, they stated.
Actually, probably much more than that.
Well, yeah.
The other end of the figure was like 30 million.
So if you take his low estimate of the people who are actually practicing,
California has like 34, 35 million people.
So it's from Levi's low figure to Levi's high figure is somewhere
twice as many people as the state of California.
That's a lot of people.
So, Levi, do you have any information, people from outside China,
they went back to China, they are following gong practicing,
but are they being monitored, arrested recently?
Any case?
Do you mean, yeah, sorry, do you mean people who are here in the U.S.
Yeah.
And went back to China?
Or other countries.
Yeah, yeah.
I mean, it's something that people avoid, quite frankly,
just because of that problem.
Yeah, I would avoid it.
Yeah.
So I'm talking about if they enter the China,
they had to answer the question, like you are practicing Falun Gong,
or you are a member of the Falun Gong or something,
have those kind of forms to fill out when you apply for the visa.
There have been several, what I know of,
are normally if you're going to try and go back to China,
they'll just deny it.
They don't want you back in the country.
But those that do, it tends to be much more sinister,
where they won't sort of formally ask you about, you know,
sit you down and tell you to fill out a form.
They'll let you go back.
They'll watch you for a couple days.
And then they'll bring you in for a quote-unquote chat.
And they start to work on you.
They have a tea, I think they call, have a coffee or tea.
Yeah, exactly, exactly.
And I think what's striking about…
That means secret service to interrogate you.
Yeah.
Have a coffee, yeah.
That's right.
And I think what's scary on those instances is that
what the Chinese officials will disclose
is they know everything about that person back in the U.S.
Wow.
They know where they work.
They know how much money they make.
They know who they talk to.
They know where they live.
And that really kind of freaks people out.
Well, sure, it rattles them because now they realize
the government of China now knows all about them.
Yeah, yeah.
Now, Levi, what about the investigation
of the false organ harvesting?
It's been going on ever since 2006.
Now, did you guys have any new information?
What's the latest that the Chinese government
say about the false organ harvesting?
Well, they haven't said a lot that's of substance.
I mean, I think the biggest thing in recent years
to point to is the China Tribunal.
And this was an independent tribunal set up
by the lead prosecutor against Slobodan Milosevic,
who was the war criminal from the former Yugoslavia.
So the same guy that prosecuted him,
he was the one who spearheaded the tribunal of lawyers,
journalists, and other China experts in London
about two years ago.
And they went through an exhaustive process,
months and months and months.
They called witnesses from across three continents.
And their determination was sort of the biggest news
that's happened in the last five years,
where they said essentially their final judgment was
not only is this happening,
not only is it happening on a wide scale,
Falun Gong is a primary source,
and it continues to happen today.
So when that came out,
that broke a little bit of what had been a media silence.
You know, we had, you know, anywhere from half a dozen
to around ten major papers, the BBC, Sunday Times,
all kinds of papers that were sort of covering that story.
That was kind of the biggest news.
And that's also sort of the latest,
is that there is no indication this has necessarily slowed down.
So they've just taken steps
to kind of go a little bit under the radar
now that there's so much scrutiny from the international community.
What has been good in terms of a development
is countries stepping up,
and the U.S. might be the latest one
with a new bill that's in Congress right now.
And that is binding sort of legal measures
that curtail or prevent people in other countries
from traveling to China and getting an organ
that is likely sourced from someone who was murdered.
Levi, we're joined by one of our regular contributors,
Michael Olson, who has a question for you today.
Yes, thank you, Levi.
Earlier in the show, Amy Howe was talking about
the Hundred Flowers campaign of Chairman Mao,
in which she encouraged everybody to speak out
against the regime,
and once they did, they were chopped down.
And the anti-rightist campaign.
Now, throughout the Chinese Communist Party's history,
we've seen these pogroms
for eliminating those that the regime feels is a threat.
And I'm looking at the Falun Gong,
and I'm wondering why the Chinese Communist Party
thinks it's a threat.
What are they afraid of?
Excellent question.
And I think going back to those campaigns,
the anti-right campaign and all those,
I think there was really two sides always.
One was to look at a group that they thought was a threat
and actually target it.
For sure, that was going on.
But there was a second reason for all these campaigns,
and that is to terrify everyone else
so that they came to understand
that when the CCP goes after a group,
you better distance yourself from them quick,
you better get away from them,
otherwise you're next.
And that's why the campaigns, they were continuous, right?
First, they went after the landlords
and the capitalists and the intellectuals.
They sort of group by group by group,
and kind of every 10 years,
they would go after a new group.
Yes, that's right.
Every 10 years.
So it was whether you need it or not,
you take the laundry out.
Yeah.
So what happened with Falun Gong
is kind of a perfect storm of a couple things.
You had Jiang Zemin,
who was the head of the CCP at that time,
and keep in mind,
he was the first leader
that did not go through the revolution.
He had no sort of credibility
or street cred, if you were,
with his peers.
He was really on sort of shaky ground.
He came to power, of course,
in the wake of 1989
because he stood on the side of the regime
and crushing the students.
And so he came to power that,
but he was really sort of shaky
and he was desperate to build up a legacy.
He was desperate to do what Mao had done
and Deng Xiaoping and everybody,
build up a cult personality around himself.
And right as he's getting ready to do that,
we're coming back to like 1992, right?
Right as he's ready to do that,
along comes Falun Gong.
Here is this spiritual practice
that is more Chinese than anything else
that was in China at that time,
in terms of being authentically Chinese.
It's from Chinese culture.
It comes out of Buddhism and Taoism
and these traditions.
And it swept the country.
And suddenly there's 100 million people practicing.
Everybody's talking about it
and nobody's talking about Jiang Zemin.
As petty as this sounds,
the people who looked into this,
one in particular, Willy Lam,
who was a senior analyst for CNN at the time,
he was the first one
who got senior officials on record
to admit this was very personal for Jiang.
He wanted to go after Falun Gong
because it was essentially stealing his thunder.
It was a threat to him personally.
But coming back to your question,
which is very good,
there was that second aspect.
It wasn't just a threat to Jiang Zemin personally.
This was the next campaign.
10 years later,
this was a group that he thought was weak.
They were passive.
They were peaceful.
We could target them, demonize them,
build up a whole campaign.
And in that process,
scare everybody else.
Because it's been 10 years, 12 years,
since they've been scared.
And this is the next wave.
This was the next campaign.
Those were the two real reasons.
And they're exact same reasons
for the previous campaigns
that Jiang Zemin and the CCP
targeted Falun Gong.
So Levi, I heard about that.
I left China in 1982,
so Falun Gong was afterwards.
But some of my friends,
they've been through that thing.
So they told me some of the background
inside the information.
You're right,
Jiang Zemin wants to establish his power,
especially military,
because he's never been military.
So he forced lots of people,
military officers,
to retire, early retirement.
So that way,
he can put his own people in the military
to control the country.
And so those Falun Gong people,
lots of them are retired peoples.
So that's why they get together,
and they can call people
in the Tiananmen Square,
like two, three hours,
a million people showed up
to practice Falun Gong.
So he was so scared.
But he was thinking
he wanted to be smarter than Deng Xiaoping,
because Deng Xiaoping led them
in the Tiananmen Square
for a couple of weeks or something.
He said never let those people,
those things happen.
So he had to make them disappear.
So use those neighborhood committee
to report each other,
and then send the people away,
disappeared.
Is that true?
You know more information than I do,
because I left the chat at that time already.
Well, I think,
Falun Gong, I think,
when it first started,
because it was,
one of the big things
that really took off
was health benefits.
You know, people were just getting healthy.
Just exercise.
Yeah, it was exercise,
but it was particularly effective
in sort of making people healthy,
especially really chronic stuff.
And so yes,
among the older population,
it kind of took off quickly,
right out of the gate.
But very quickly actually,
because of its sort of,
its rooted in traditional Chinese culture,
and its elements of Buddhism
and things like that,
it also quickly took off
among the intellectuals.
And so it was in the universities,
the professors,
and the students.
So very quickly,
it was a very mixed group.
The one thing I have heard
about the military,
I have heard this exact same thing
you mentioned,
and it was interesting
that there was at one point,
I don't remember which year,
but there was at one point
where Jiang Zemin elevated to general,
more generals than any other leader
had done in their entire careers.
And he did it all in one year,
and the criteria was
who's loyal to him
in crushing Falun Gong,
and who's not.
Those who were,
were elevated.
Those who were not,
were kicked out.
So I do think there is
a military concern
in Jiang Zemin's mind,
at least from what I've heard.
And I think you're right
on that point.
Yes.
One quick follow up
on Jiang Zemin.
He is no longer,
I think,
actively persecuting Falun Gong.
But I have seen him
and his family
listed as the leadership
of the Chinese biotech industry
and research.
Yeah, I mean,
Chinese politics is like
an enigma wrapped in a mystery.
I mean,
a lot of this,
you know,
when Deng Xiaoping...
I'm glad you said that
because that's my biggest,
that's my biggest issue
in hosting this program
is trying to figure out
where the government's going.
Yeah.
I'm glad you said that, Levi,
because I wondered that myself.
It's tough.
I mean,
one pattern we do see
is that when someone
formally steps down,
they tend to retain
a power center
and they can operate
in a very powerful manner
for a long time.
We certainly saw that
with Deng Xiaoping.
You see that with Jiang Zemin.
His faction
that he built
and put in place
is still very active
in many areas.
And so it's always very tough.
You know,
you'll see in the news
that there's an
anti-corruption campaign
and this official
is going after that one.
Behind the scenes,
what's really going on,
usually it's that
factional stuff.
And Jiang Zemin
does retain
a certain power base
and a certain set of factions
that continue to contend
with the current leadership
and continue to drive
to some extent
the persecution.
So we know that,
at least,
but in any given event,
it's a little bit hard to say
who's behind what.
To the latter part
of your point,
yes,
this is a known phenomenon
that's been happening
for decades.
It's that
the family members,
especially the children
of high-ranking
CCP officials,
are some of the most
wealthy people
on the planet.
It's really
highly, highly corrupt.
LWIAY,
the persecution
of Falun Gong,
in my mind,
it really reflects
religious freedom situation
in China.
Not Falun Gong,
but underground
Christian church
Uyghurs group,
Tibetans,
they are all
persecuting,
I think,
a main part
of the reason
for the CCP
to persecute them
is to control
the people's
religious freedom.
Now,
what do you think
that,
from that aspect,
religious freedom,
that aspect,
what do you think
that in the near future,
the regime
is going?
It's a difficult thing
to answer,
is sort of
protect the future.
I mean,
there's patterns
that I could point to
that might help
allude to an answer.
And one is,
you know,
I mentioned
there is this
very large network,
million strong,
in China,
that has been working
diligently,
day in and day out,
to get people information
that the state-run media
is not going to tell them.
And that,
there have been
many, many little pockets
around China
where that's actually had
a profound effect.
I mean,
like cases where,
like the chief
CCP guy
in a village
who is actually
the leader of
abducting and even
torturing some people
in some cases,
kind of having
a change of heart
and coming around
and he's sort of like,
now he's kind of
the protector that
when the CCP people
come from the
bigger region
to inspect his work,
he kind of
tells the Falun Gong people,
okay, go hide,
they're coming,
and stuff like that.
So you,
you have these stories
and you get these
kind of stories
throughout China.
So,
we know for a fact
from these stories
that hearts and minds
are changing.
That's good news.
Yeah,
it is very good news
and I think if you combine
Unless they get
transplanted,
the hearts,
I mean.
Yeah.
Yeah,
that's true.
If you combine
that phenomenon
with the phenomenon
I mentioned earlier
that when like,
for example,
our US State Department
sanctions a Chinese official
and news of that
goes around China
and suddenly the police chiefs
in all these areas
are scared that they're next.
This,
both of those phenomena
are pointing to
a broader trend
where more and more people
in the rank and file
of the security apparatus
do not want to do
persecution anymore.
And I got to believe
at some point
that's got to tip
to a point where they're just,
it has to end.
Because there's no one
left to do it.
Well,
on that positive note,
Levi,
we are out of time
for this hour.
We want to thank you
so much for coming back on
and talking to you about this,
particularly on this anniversary.
Thank you, Levi.
Yeah,
thank you for having me.
