Probiotics may influence immune function, mood and skin health through interactions involving the gut microbiome, but researchers caution that evidence remains preliminary, strain-specific and insufficient for broad treatment recommendations.
By yourNEWS Media Newsroom.
Probiotics are best known for their role in digestive health, but emerging research suggests some strains may also influence the immune system, mental health and inflammatory skin conditions, according to a report published by Verywell Health.
The potential benefits remain under investigation. Researchers cautioned that existing clinical trials are generally small, results vary substantially depending on the probiotic strain and dose, and findings in one population cannot necessarily be applied to another.
No probiotic product has received broad regulatory approval specifically to prevent illness, treat anxiety or depression, or manage conditions such as acne, eczema or rosacea, according to the report.
Researchers therefore describe the findings as promising rather than conclusive.
Gut Microbiome May Influence Immune Function
One area receiving increasing attention is the relationship between intestinal microorganisms and the immune system.
Certain probiotic strains have been associated in some studies with fewer or shorter respiratory infections, including common colds, although researchers said the evidence remains inconsistent and many of the trials have involved relatively small groups.
“The immune system and gut microbiota interact, but we cannot yet say probiotics prevent illness,” a researcher quoted in the report said.
A substantial amount of immune activity occurs in tissues associated with the gastrointestinal tract, helping explain why researchers are interested in whether changing the gut microbiome could alter immune responses.
Gut bacteria also produce compounds known as short-chain fatty acids when they ferment certain dietary fibers. These substances can help nourish cells lining the colon and participate in processes involving inflammation and intestinal-barrier function.
Author Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall has described short-chain fatty acids as helping support immune cells and the intestinal wall in Eat Better Forever.
Separate reporting has estimated that a large proportion of the body’s immune system is associated with the gastrointestinal tract, although precise percentages vary depending on how immune tissues and functions are defined.
The existence of close communication between the microbiome and immune system does not mean probiotic supplements necessarily prevent infections. Researchers said larger and better-controlled clinical trials are needed to determine whether specific strains produce meaningful benefits.
Consumers were also advised to discuss probiotic supplementation with a healthcare professional when considering it for a particular medical purpose.
Researchers Explore the Gut-Brain Connection
Mental health represents another developing area of probiotic research.
Scientists increasingly study the gut-brain axis, a network of neural, hormonal, immune and metabolic communication linking the digestive system and central nervous system.
Preliminary studies have suggested that certain probiotics could influence symptoms associated with anxiety or depression, although the research is not strong enough to establish probiotics as treatments for either condition.
A systematic review by researchers at York University in Canada examined studies of probiotic supplementation and reported evidence suggesting possible improvements in some anxiety and depression measures.
“The findings are hypothesis-generating; larger trials are underway,” one study author said.
Researchers have also investigated whether particular bacteria can alter activity in brain regions associated with emotion.
Lactobacillus bulgaricus, a species commonly associated with fermented dairy products such as yogurt, has been discussed in research examining whether changes in the gut microbiome can influence emotional processing through the gut-brain axis.
Vanessa Kimbell, author of The Sourdough School Sweet Baking, has cited research suggesting probiotic organisms may affect brain activity associated with emotion.
Other researchers have focused on intestinal-barrier dysfunction and whether inflammatory compounds originating in the gut can affect the nervous system.
Akil Palanisamy, writing in The Paleovedic Diet, has discussed the theory that increased intestinal permeability may permit inflammatory substances to enter circulation and potentially contribute to neurological or psychological symptoms.
Those mechanisms remain subjects of ongoing research, and probiotics should not be considered substitutes for established mental health treatments.
Effects also appear highly dependent on the microorganism being studied. Two products both marketed as probiotics may contain entirely different species or strains and therefore cannot be assumed to produce the same biological response.
Skin Conditions Are Another Area of Study
Researchers are also examining whether probiotics taken orally or applied topically might influence inflammatory skin disorders.
Small studies involving Lactobacillus, Bifidobacterium and other organisms have investigated possible effects on acne, eczema and rosacea.
Results have been mixed.
“Some patients report improvement, but placebo effects are strong in skin studies,” a dermatologist quoted in the report said.
Researchers have proposed several possible explanations for a relationship between the microbiome and skin.
Alterations in gut bacteria may influence systemic inflammation, while microorganisms living directly on the skin also interact with the skin’s immune defenses and protective barrier.
Diet may further affect skin through hydration, antioxidant intake, fatty acids and nutrients involved in collagen formation and repair.
Separate nutrition reporting has highlighted the importance of vitamins, antioxidants and healthy fats in maintaining skin structure and resilience.
Fermented foods are another focus because some contain live microorganisms capable of contributing to microbiome diversity.
Studies have associated diets containing fermented foods with changes in gut bacteria and inflammatory markers, but those findings do not establish that fermented foods or probiotics will treat a specific dermatological condition.
The FDA has not approved probiotics as treatments for acne, eczema or rosacea, and researchers said people seeking treatment for persistent skin problems should consult a healthcare professional rather than relying on probiotic supplements alone.
Strain and Dose Can Change the Results
One of the major challenges in probiotic research is that the term “probiotic” encompasses many different organisms.
Different species — and even different strains within the same species — can have substantially different effects.
Dosage, duration of use, a person’s existing microbiome, diet, age, medical history and other factors can also influence results.
A probiotic that appears beneficial in one clinical trial therefore cannot automatically be expected to produce the same outcome when a different strain or formulation is used.
This strain-specific nature of probiotics is one reason researchers have cautioned against making broad claims that probiotics as a category improve immunity, mood or skin health.
Larger randomized clinical trials will be needed to determine which organisms, doses and treatment periods might provide reproducible benefits.
Foods May Offer a Different Route to Probiotics
Probiotic microorganisms can be consumed through supplements, but they also occur naturally in some fermented foods.
Depending on how they are produced and processed, yogurt, kefir, sauerkraut, kimchi and other fermented products may contain live cultures.
Fermented foods can also supply nutrients and fermentation byproducts that differ from those found in isolated probiotic supplements.
Researchers are increasingly examining whether diets that support microbiome diversity may be more important than relying on individual probiotic products.
Fiber-rich plant foods can provide substrates that beneficial intestinal bacteria ferment, while fermented foods may introduce additional microorganisms or metabolic compounds.
The report nevertheless cautioned that evidence remains incomplete regarding how much these dietary changes directly affect specific diseases.
More Research Needed Before Clinical Recommendations
For generally healthy people, probiotic foods are typically considered safe as part of a balanced diet.
Supplements require more individual consideration, particularly for people with weakened immune systems, serious underlying illnesses or other medical vulnerabilities.
In rare circumstances, live microorganisms contained in probiotic products can cause infections in highly susceptible individuals.
The Verywell Health report concluded that probiotics may eventually prove useful for purposes extending beyond digestive health, particularly in areas involving immune regulation, the gut-brain axis and inflammatory skin conditions.
At present, however, researchers do not have enough evidence to establish broad clinical guidelines.
The developing research suggests that microorganisms in the digestive tract may interact with far more of the body than digestion alone, but identifying which probiotics produce meaningful health effects — and for whom — remains an active area of scientific investigation.
Explainer Infographic
Comments