Teaching a beginning level ESL class, I find that every year I have one or two students who moan, groan, whine, or complain every time I say “let's write.” This sort of reaction can be quite disruptive to other students and create deeper aversions to writing for my reluctant writers. After a decade of teaching this class, I have adopted new approaches to better accommodate these students.

Engaging in regular, short writing tasks has been shown to build confidence in young writers (Payne & Jesiek, 2018) and can improve fluency and accuracy (Hartshorn et al., 2023). One of the most effective modifications I made to my ESL curriculum was the use of shorter daily writing activities. In the past, students in my class did a six-minute timed writing activity every week as a formative assessment mandated by the ESL department. Many students expressed frustration or fear with this activity. After several years witnessing this sort of reaction, I started having students do a one minute writing activity every day. Afterwords, resistance to longer writing activities was is significantly lower.

Last year, an adult learner I taught previously expressed doubts about her English writing ability. Having worked with this student before, I was a bit confused because she was generally a strong writer. She showed me a paper her teacher in another class had marked up. The paper was covered in corrections with every spelling, grammatical, and rhetorical error marked. In the student’s words, “I don't even know how I can improve.” She didn’t know where to start.

Kao (2023) provides pragmatic advice for offering effective and differentiated writing instruction. In a study on written corrected feedback for second language learners, the author found that offering feedback on one to three prominent error-types specific to the students’ writing —such as verb tense errors, preposition errors, or rhetorical considerations — was more effective for learners’ improvement than untargeted feedback or none at all.  Additionally, the author found that this focused and differentiated approach lowered students’ anxiety concerning writing.  Kao’s (2023) suggestions were used to modify feedback practices in the above-mentioned student’s class, and students in the class reported a more positive learning experience. While Kao’s (2023) research primarily looked at foreign language learners in Taiwan, the principles he uncovered can be applied to improve written feedback practices in a wide range of teaching scenarios.

One challenge in implementing a comprehensive writing across the curriculum program is that many content specialists lack an awareness of best practices in teaching writing and a handful of English classes are typically not enough to promote the communicative competencies needed in the modern workforce (Payne & Jesiek, 2018). Writing activities in any discipline are most effective when clear and meaningful goals are presented (Onyura et al., 2016, Payne & Jesiek, 2018, Saulnier, 2016) and a range of rhetorical formats are considered in the curriculum planning process (Payne & Jesiek, 2018). One way to create a culture of writing across the curriculum and connect the instructional competencies of instructors in different fields within a school setting is through professional learning communities (ACE, 2019). In my own teaching situation, I have found that curricular changes and faculty collaboration are easier to implement within a department than than the entire school. When positive outcomes from best practices become obvious, school-wide implementation becomes more achievable.

References

American College of Education. (2021a). CI6103 Curriculum and instruction design for diversity: Module 3 [Part 1 video presentation]. Canvas. https://ace.instructure.com/courses/2032377/external_tools/118428

Hartshorn, K. J., Rice, S. H., Eckstein, G., & Evans, N. W. Dynamic written corrective feedback frequency and its effects on ESL writing fluency, accuracy, and complexity. Feedback Research in Second Language. 1, 7-32, https://doi.org/10.32038/frsl.2023.01.02

Kao, C. W. (2023). A preliminary investigation into student writers’ perception of corrective feedback focus. Feedback Research in Second Language. 1, 236-246. https://doi.org/10.32038/frsl.2023.01.13

Onyura, B., Baker, L., Cameron, B., Friesen, F., & Leslie, K. (2016). Evidence for curricular and instructional design approaches in undergraduate medical education: An umbrella review. Medical Teacher, 38(2), 150–161. https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.201

Payne, L., & Jesiek, B. (2018). Enhancing transdisciplinary learning through community-based design projects: Results from a mixed methods study. International Journal for Service Learning in Engineering, 13(1), 1. 

Saulnier, B. (2016). The application of writing across the curriculum (WAC) techniques in a systems analysis & design flipped classroom. Information Systems Education Journal, 14(4), 13–19.