How can instructional design create a space where all students achieve maximal success?  As a second language English teacher, I affirm that all students can be successful, but my experiences as a struggling high school student helped me better understand the elements that lead to success - as well as elements that do not.  In a recent discussion, I was asked about the most engaging lesson I ever experienced. Two high school projects came to mind.

The first project was a recitation of Shakespeare's MacBeth in my 11th grade English class. In that lesson, a friend and I decided to act out a battle scene between MacBeth and MacDuff. In addition to memorizing the lines, my friend and I took the initiative to learn about the attire worn in ancient Scotland. We were surprised to learn that the characters in the story likely did not wear shining armor - as seen in the movie adaptation we watched in class - but rather wore plaid tartans like those worn in Mel Gibbson's Braveheart. Inspired, we went to the fabric store and created authentic costumes. We also learned about swordsmanship and practiced reciting our lines while fencing outside in the cold of winter wearing only our costumes. That day we discovered that boots and pleated plaids are actually quite warm.  This experience taught us far more then we would have learned simply reading the book in class or watching the movie adaptation. Having ownership over the project, we developed a greater sense of self efficacy than we had experienced in English class in the past and created memorable experiences that will last a lifetime.

The second engaging lesson took place in a chemistry class during my senior year of high school. Small groups were tasked with learning about a renewable energy source and sharing that knowledge with the class. My partners and I picked “switchgrass" as a renewable energy source knowing nothing about the topic other than its unique and somewhat humorous name. While collaborating on this project, we learned how fiber can be chemically broken down into simple sugars to create ethanol. We learned about soil erosion and how removing hearty weeds like switch grass from the great plains helped cause the dust bowl in the 1930s. During our presentation one of our group members - a kid in tie-dyes who went by the nickname “Salad”- dressed up like grass and explain the benefits of using switch grass as a renewable fuel source. The combination of a meaningful task, exploratory learning opportunities, a little humor, and an opportunity to teach something novel and unique to our class created the most impressionable science lesson of my K-12 career.

The successful elements of these two lessons are present in the Universal Design for Learning (UDL) guidelines (CAST, 2018). The nine-part UDL guidelines are a blueprint for high-quality learning. This blueprint gives educators guidance for accessing, building, and internalizing new concepts through engagement, mental representation, and expression. In the lessons above, the teachers engaged students by giving us choice in determining the direction of our projects, clear goals with a need for collaboration, and a space to manage our own progress through the projects. Rich project content forced us to create representations of the content in our minds and meaningful symbolism through constructed materials. Additionally, the presentation and collaboration elements of these lessons created a space for synthesizing concepts and communicating these elements with others.

In both of these group activities, most of my group mates and I were diagnosed with unique learning challenges, such as ADHD or dyslexia, and were struggling academically. Although the above mentioned Shakespeare lesson was one of the most memorable lessons I experienced, I struggled considerably in English class, failing this subject several times throughout secondary school.  The majority of our assigned class readings were above my reading ability and developmental maturity, creating frustration and, later, apathy.  Additionally, most lessons did not include elements of choice or collaboration and there was little applicable feedback concerning areas were my comprehension was breaking down.  While lessons aligning with the UDL guidelines (CAST, 2018) where both memorable and successful, I struggled considerably with more mundane learning tasks like understanding assignment expectations or completing assigned readings.

Rodríguez and Rodríguez (2017) describe three distinct types of learning difficulties.  Type I problems are the product of an ineffective learning environment - an issue that the UDL aligned lessons described above largely addressed.  Type II problems are compounding issues wherein a child’s needs are consistently not met - as with the above-mentioned assigned readings that were not level or age appropriate.  Giving students opportunities to choose content based on personal interest and access to differentiated materials can do a lot to address a wide-range of learning and motivational needs.    Both of these problems can be addressed with a robust and differentiated curriculum (CAST, 2018). There is a third type of problem that might not be solved through innovative classroom instruction alone.

Type III problems involve special needs that can not be addressed by general education alone (Rodríguez & Rodríguez, 2017). One example would be my previous struggles with reading. The university I attended for my undergraduate studies was well-equipped to deal special needs students. The school was created during the Vietnam war and served many soldiers upon returning from the war. As such, special needs services were prioritized early on, and are now among the best in the state. During my first semester I was given audio versions of all my textbooks to support my learning. Later, my blind classmates taught me to make use of text to speech features on my laptop for an auditory reading experience. These technological advances have been instrumental in my learning and are a key component of my current doctoral studies.

Because of my unique learning experiences, I have a nuanced perspective on delivering high quality instruction. A robust curriculum with high-quality lessons should incorporate elements of collaborative engagement, mental representation, and expression - as in the UDL.  The qualities of the UDL can make lessons much more accessible to students with unique interests and create a space for meaningful learning experiences.  That said, additional resources should be made available to address individual learning needs. This may be beyond the capacities of some teachers or require special training.

References

CAST (2018). Universal Design for Learning Guidelines version 2.2. Retrieved from http://udlguidelines.cast.org

Rodríguez, A., & Rodríguez, D. (2017). English learners with disabilities: What is the current state? Insights into Learning Disabilities 14(1), 97-112