Three External Forces to Consider When Designing Curriculum
I had a great conversation earlier this morning with some young musicians in my English conversation class. I asked them how they plan out their instrument practice. A trumpeter in my class detailed a format his coach taught him to ensure he practices all the essential elements of his craft each day. This discussion about instrument practice routines stimulated rich debate among his fellow musicians. I shared with them that all professionals need to make similar considerations in practicing their chosen trade. I told them I similarly follow a set routine when designing my lessons each day. I avoided getting too technical, but in the back of my mind, I recalled the curriculum design principles detailed in Macalister and Nation’s (2020) Language Curriculum Design. Having served me well for several years, this text provides a comprehensive framework for educators to considered the various elements impacting curriculum planning - whether it is a single lesson, a course, or a full program of study.
Before going into the content and structure of a robust curriculum, Macalister and Nation (2020) stress the importance of understanding the external factors driving course development. These include environmental constraints, the needs of learners and stakeholders, and principles guiding instruction. Environmental constraints - or external factors affecting instruction - could include class size or student demography, student and teacher time availability, cultural expectations concerning class format or content, the availability of facilities and resources, and many other factors (pp. 15-28). With these environmental factors acknowledged, a needs analysis can identify the practical learning needs of students, instructional standards to be met, gaps in previous instruction, and learning goals of students, parents, and other stakeholders (pp. 29-43). Without acknowledging environmental factors and stakeholder expectations, gaps the course curriculum can emerge. To address these needs, research-based principles of teaching and learning need to be identified.
While training to teach English as a foreign language (TEFL), Deborah Crusan (personal communication, 2010), my TEFL professor, shared a pithy maxim that greatly affected the way I view curriculum development and instructional planning, “If a school can’t tell you the theoretical basis guiding their curriculum, don’t walk away; run!” Contrary to this common sense, Macalister and Nation (2020) found that many so-call “modern” language courses appear to be copying one another, differing little in substance or structure, with one such course appearing to be directly based on a Berlitz language course from the 1890s (p. 44). The authors discovered that even well established instructional principles, such as the role of repetition in fostering long-term learning (p. 229), were completely ignored in the content progression of these courses. As a teacher and curriculum designer, I find that knowledge of my field is one of the most powerful external factors shaping my curricular decisions. The more I understand about learning, motivation, communication, and memory, the more freedom I have to make substantive improvements in my teaching practice and effectively communicate best-practices to other stakeholders (American College of Education, 2021).
One way to identify principles and best practices for teaching and learning is through conducting an umbrella analysis (American College of Education, 2021). Whereas a systematic review or a meta-analysis is a meticulous overview of contemporary research concerning a specific subject - often identifying best-practices in that area and prevalent gaps in the research - an umbrella review examines a range of systematic reviews and meta-analyses related to a specific topic. For example, I am currently conducting an umbrella review to identity best practices for teaching a foreign language. Macalister and Nation (2020) share a list of 20 research-based principles for a rigorous language curriculum, and suggest that repetition is one of the most effective practices to consider when designing curriculum (p. 45). To better understand how to better employ repetition in my classes, I carefully read a meta-analysis examining the relation between repetition and vocabulary acquisition (Uchihara et al. 2019). While reading, I identified several best practices which I had not fully considered previously. For example, Uchihara et al. (2020) identified that vocabulary repetition encountered through reading is more impactful than watching television and that mass exposure to a new word in a single day is more impactful than the same number of exposures over an extended period. These are substantive principles to consider when planning my courses. This is one example of how education research inform curriculum and instructional choices.
According to Macalister and Nation (2020), these outside forces - environmental considerations, student needs, and principles of teaching and learning - are necessary for guiding the key elements of the curriculum - content and sequencing, format and presentation, and assessment. Larger societal expectations and students’ practical needs often set standards for academic success and inform course assessments. Student needs and established principles of instruction drive content choices. Similarly, established instructional principles and environmental factors - such as the available time and teaching space - greatly influence the format and presentation of the curriculum. These three basic areas comprise a comprehensive curriculum at every level from a multi-course program of study to a single-day lesson plan.
References
American College of Education. (2021). CI6103 Curriculum and instruction design for diversity: Module 1 [Part 1 video presentation]. Canvas. https://ace.instructure.com/courses/2032377/external_tools/118428
Macalister, J., & Nation, I. S. P. (2020). Language curriculum design (2nd ed.). Routledge.
Uchihara, T., Webb, S., & Yanagisawa, A. (2019). The effects of repetition on incidental vocabulary learning: A meta-analysis of correlational studies. Language Learning, 63(3), 559-599. https://doi.org/10.1111/lang.12343



Comments