Research Concept: Affective Filter Influences on Literacy Improvement
During my graduate studies in second language teaching, my academic advisor often told students, “If a school you want to work at can’t state the theoretical basis for their curriculum, don’t walk away; run” (D. Crusan, personal communication, 2014). This is advice that has guided me in my teaching and given me faith in the school where I teach. Though teachers at my school are all clear on the theoretical frameworks supporting our curriculum, many of the students may not have such a framework to guide them, negatively impacting their learning.
When I first arrived at my school, my supervisors gave me several books by the educator and linguist, Stephen Krashen. Before I taught my first class, they wanted me to be well-versed in language acquisition theory and Krashen’s (1982) natural approach. In a nutshell, Krashen believes that students acquire language naturally through comprehending input – reading and listening. He holds that drills and grammar training, while educational, do not result in true language acquisition. While these claims go against much of what I learned in graduate school, Krashen's theories concerning compehensible input align closely with my language learning experiences. In short, I failed French and Spanish in high school under a grammar-based curriculum and thrived learning Mandarin via comprehensible input. Ten years of teaching experience has also shown this theoretical framework to be quite valid.
The majority of my students are from East Asia – Taiwan, China, Korea, Japan. In their education systems, the purpose of language instruction is almost entirely geared toward passing high-stakes national exams. Because of this, my students often come with an advanced knowledge of grammar concepts and can translate countless words but struggle to complete basic tasks like ordering a hamburger and asking for leave. After two weeks (18 contact hours) of taking classes based on the natural approach, all students have been able to engage in robust conversations and tell simple stories. After three to five years, most can confidently engage with high school-level literature; the key word being most.
The Problem
Despite many success stories, about 10-15% of my students struggle to make consistent progress within the curriculum. There are several traits these students tend to exhibit. They often have anxiety about some aspect of English – usually speaking or reading. Often, these students look for shortcuts. For example, some struggling students will try to find the hardest, driest non-fiction book in the library because a well-meaning adult told them this is the best way to improve. Some of these students even engage in unethical behavior such as writing down unknown words during reading tests in hopes of doing better the next time. In most cases, the attitudes of these struggling students swing from apathy to anxiety. The result of these attempted shortcuts is typically nil.
Curti et al. (2021) talk about “imposter syndrome” being more prevalent in international students unsure about how to succeed in a foreign education system. While I never thought of my students' behavior in terms of a so-called imposter syndrome, I do agree that the authors’ assessment is relevant. Similar to how my academic advisor stressed that teachers need a theoretical framework to guide their teaching, my classroom observations have shown that successful learners are conscientious about their learning and are proactive in employing learning strategies. Conversely, struggling learners often resort to emotional or extreme methods in order to pass the next exam. A mixed methods study – using both qualitative and quantitative data – could reveal differences in how students’ emotional states affect literacy development.
Searching for a Solution
My hypothesis going into such a study is that struggling students exhibit more anxiety or negative emotion, what Krashen (1982) calls a high affective filter. Affect filter refers to intense emotions that block the brain’s ability to process and acquire language. Another facet of this would be what Bandura (1977) calls low self-efficacy, or a diminished belief that one can accomplish a task. My understanding is that a high affective filter and low self-efficacy contribute to academic struggles and a collection of poor study behaviors that Curti et al. (2021) attribute to the imposter phenomenon.
MacBeath (n.d.) provides a useful list of questions for assessing students' focus and emotional states (see Figure 1). He suggests doing a spot check periodically during each class to assess students’ engagement. At the end of the semester, students’ spot checks could be compared with their literacy improvement to see how affective filter issues over the semester impacted literacy growth.
Figure 1
Spot Check
(MacBeath, n.d.)
I believe this sort of daily student reporting will be critical for study accuracy. In the past when I have done similar questionnaires, it always took place at the end of the school year, after testing. This likely resulted in abnormally positive responses and made it difficult to formulate accurate conclusions.
Joining the Discussion
This study could be used to examine Krashen’s (1982) affective filter hypothesis and contribute to related research. For my own purposes, it would all help me better understand best practices for literacy development. By understanding how affective filter issues affect literacy improvement, I will be better equipped to guide struggling students.
References
Bandura, A. (1977). Self-efficacy: Toward a unifying theory of behavioral change. Psychological Review, 84(2), 191-215. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.84.2.191Links to an external site.
Cutri, J., Freya, A., Karlina, Y., Patel, S. V., Moharami, M., Zeng, S., Manzari, E., & Pretorius, L. (2021). Academic integrity at doctoral level: the influence of the imposter phenomenon and cultural differences on academic writing. International Journal for Educational Integrity, 17(1), 8-16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40979-021-00074-wLinks to an external site.
Krashen, S.D. (1982). Principles and practice in second language acquisition. Pergamon.
MacBeath, J. (n.d.). Week 2, Lecture 2: Teaching for learning [MOOC Lecture]. In J. MacBeath, Foundations of Teaching for Learning: Introduction. Coursera. https://www.coursera.org/learn/teaching/lecture/hoozX/lecture-3-teaching-for-learningLinks to an external site.


Comments