Can a Jewish person reject Zionism? Ukrainian historian Dr. Marta Havryshko explains why she identifies as Jewish and anti-Zionist, and why she believes Jewish identity should not be equated with support for the State of Israel.
In this excerpt from Cold War 2.0 #88, Havryshko discusses Christian Zionism, antisemitism, Gaza, Israeli settlements, Palestinian rights and the right of return.
📌 If you enjoy independent investigative journalism, consider supporting Kit Klarenberg's work and subscribe to Syriana Analysis for more in-depth geopolitical analysis.
📢 Disclaimer: Guest opinions featured in this video do not necessarily reflect the views of Syriana Analysis.
📢 Syriana Analysis is an independent platform providing well-researched geopolitical insights, founded by Kevork Almassian. This program provides independent journalistic analysis for educational and documentary purposes, focusing on complex geopolitical shifts in West Asia and globally.
This discussion explores the distinction between Jewish identity and Zionism. Marta, a Ukrainian Jew and professor, explains that Zionism is not synonymous with being Jewish, highlighting the historical role of Christian Zionists and the growing anti-Zionist sentiment among young American Jews who oppose the Israeli government's actions in Gaza.
Speaking of Gaza, just because Marta you also said that you are an anti-Zionist Jewish person,
right? Yes. So the online community, in the online community there are different types of people,
different opinions. Many people are able to differentiate what is a Zionist and what is
a Jewish person, but also some people do not differentiate between them, right? They say
they are the same. You identify yourself as an anti-Zionist Jewish person. How can a Jewish
person come out as an anti-Zionist? Is it the policies of the Israeli government or is it
the existence of Israel itself? What can trigger a Jewish person to be an anti-Zionist?
First of all, you know, in my classes on anti-Semitism and racism at university,
I explained to my American students, not all Zionists are Jews and not all Jews are Zionists.
First, Zionists were not Jews. They were Christians who really believed that we should get rid of
Jews. That's why they proposed this plan, you know, just to move them to Palestine.
Many Christians, seven million Christian Zionists in the US, they really believe
for religious reasons, they really believe that, you know, in order for Messiah to come,
Jews should be there, you know, in order to have redemption for all people, you know? And
in 19th century, many Christian Zionists, you know, out of really anti-Semitic motives,
they wanted just to remove Jews from Europe entirely. That's why they became very,
you know, passionate Zionists, you know, that they wanted, you know, them to remove to Palestine
and so on and so forth. But for me, you know, I had a lot of Jewish students,
because we have in the East a lot of Jewish students in Massachusetts, and many of them
actually are from a former Russian empire who escaped from Ukraine pogroms, actually.
And nowadays, we discuss all those, you know, issues with them and so on and so forth. But
majority of my students are anti-Zionists, and many of them took part in encampments and
anti-Israel, pro-Palestinian protest and anti-Israel protest. And we discussed a lot
during our classes, how to be vocal about the genocide in Gaza against settler terror.
We discussed a lot the concept of Jewish state and how it relates to democracy and the rights
of Palestinians. In order to bring the concept of, you know, the right to return of Palestinian
people after genocide after ethnic cleansing in Naghbam, I compared, for example, with
Crimean Tatar people and the deportation of 1944. And I explained to them, you know,
I made those parallels with Ukraine, you know, and I explained to them, you can't just treat
people of their land and property and everything and just not. And I explained to them, you know,
how a person like me, Ukrainian Jew, now is, you know, in Worcester, Massachusetts, can go to,
can make Halia and take someone's land, you know, while person who lives centuries in this land
can return home. How can it be? And you claim that you are the only democracy in the Middle East,
and you claim that you are democratic state. How it can be? How you can impose, you know,
this penalty only for one category of people, you know, for the same crime?
You know, we discussed so many questions. And my Jewish students, I must say, majority of my Jewish
students were so, so passionate about this. You can't even imagine, they wrote so important
essays about, you know, this issue, and they were so engaged in those discussions, you know. So,
and as you know, majority of Jewish people nowadays, they are anti-Zionist in the US,
and for the first time in US history, majority of Jews, they are very critical of the state of
Israel. Because what this Netanyahu government is doing, it's just inexcusable, and it endangers
Jews around the world. Because the first questions for us all, what is your position on Gaza,
on West Bank, on illegal settlements, on this settlement terror? How it can be? How you can be
silent? How you, you know, stay silent when your people, and I always tell people,
Israel doesn't represent all Jews, you know. Even if, you know, Netanyahu is trying to claim this,
so it doesn't represent all Jews, you know. It's, if I may, if I may, I mean, look, first of all,
I find it extremely encouraging to hear that among young Jews in America, American Jews,
anti-Zionism is now spreading. I personally, to clarify my position, I do see Zionism as a form
of fascism. I think it belongs to the fascist family, and I know that historians argue about
that. It's a minority opinion among them, but I have long given up on being too concerned with
what the minority of historians think, or maybe not even think, really. And so, look, I see Zionism
as a form of fascism, and if I may draw a parallel with Germans, right, I think what people like
Netanyahu do, and what all Zionists do, is the equivalent of a German Nazi claiming that the
only way to be a German is to be a Nazi. It's exactly the same move, right? Whereas, of course,
at least a priori, and in practice, even then it was possible to be a German, but be against the
Nazis. And they couldn't change that in reality, but of course their claim was exactly that. If you
want to be a good German, you are with us. You're a member of the Volksgemeinschaft, you're part of
the Nazi system, you believe in our Nazi values, right? And Zionism makes exactly the same move.
And what is, of course, and I will vent for one more moment, what is particularly terrible for me
as a German, is that Germans once again are making the same mistake, but this time with Zionism.
Because in Germany, the idea is still dominant that Zionism is the same as being Jewish, only
it's been morally inverted, so that now they defend Zionism because they think they defend,
as they call it, Jewish life. It is, of course, a completely perverse idea, but that's where Germany
is stuck again.