Why the US Army electrifies this water

We Science Too
67 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
Aria, could you take us to the Midwest, please?
Any place specifically?
Um, how about around 20 miles just south of Chicago?
You mean the home of the Chicago Bulls?
Oh, you betcha.
Accents are fun.
But today's video topic isn't all that fun,
because in the water that you can see behind me,
just outside of Romeoville, Illinois,
is the only stretch of water in the United States
that if you were to fall into it and have an accident,
the Coast Guard will not attempt to rescue you.
And the reason why is completely invisible.
Now entering the facility.
We begin today's tale with a fish.
What does this fish look like to you?
Well, to me, it looks extremely derpy,
but if you're one of the millions of people
who live and work in and around the American Midwest,
and more specifically, the Great Lakes,
this fish looks like economic disaster.
This is the Asian carp,
a general name for a cluster of different invasive species
that were first imported to the United States
as a way to clean out fishery ponds,
but then, for whatever reason,
they escaped into the Mississippi River basin.
Because these Asian carp didn't evolve
with other native fish, like many invasive species,
they can outcompete the local species for food,
they reproduce too quickly,
and they have no real natural predators,
which has led to a population explosion.
It is estimated that if these Asian carp
made their way into the Great Lakes,
where fish are relied on,
native fish, for food and business,
they could cause economic damages in the billions.
And it's not just money on the end of the fishing line here.
Asian carp can be dangerous,
just not in the way that you think.
Asian carp have an interesting way of escaping predators.
When they sense a disturbance in the water around them,
instead of just using their tails to swim away
or hide or do whatever it is that fish do,
they use their powerful muscles to vault themselves
up above the water surface many meters.
Now, that's fine in isolation,
but do you know what else disturbs water
and sits a few meters above the water surface?
People in boats.
Now, watch this clip.
A guy is going down the river,
his boat and the disturbance from the engine and the wake
makes the carp jump,
and then he gets slapped in the face by an Asian carp.
It's inarguably very funny,
but this guy was actually pretty lucky,
and math explains why.
Who let the carp out?
It takes some amount of work to move something around.
In physics speak, it takes some force
applied over some distance
to change the kinetic energy of an object.
So now imagine that you are boating down
some very beautiful section of Illinois waterway
at around 20 miles per hour.
Your boat disturbs the horde of Asian carp.
Beneath, one jumps up a few meters
into the path of your pretty face.
Keep in mind that these carp can weigh over 100 pounds.
When you get slapped in the face by this fish,
your head deflects maybe, let's say, six inches.
If you solve for force here,
you find that the worst encounter you can have
with one of these fish
is the equivalent of a Major League Baseball bat
swing to the face.
Thousands of pounds force.
The videos that we see online of this interaction are funny,
but the injuries are not.
The U.S. Geological Survey has cataloged damage to boats,
broken arms, legs, ribs, noses.
There are fish that have even jumped into boats
after being disturbed and slammed down the throttle,
putting everyone on the boat in immediate danger.
Make no mistake, my friends,
we now face a derpy, scaly menace.
How do we fight it?
There are, of course, a number of weapons
we could start deploying against our fishy foes,
some rather obvious.
We could start overfishing them and eating them en masse.
I hear they're quite tasty,
but my intuition says that the demand
will not meet with their reproduction.
We could also just start going around
in lakes and waterways and blowing them up
or shooting them with bows and arrows and guns,
or we could apply the traditional stabby-stabby,
but I don't think that's either safe nor practical.
We tried dumping thousands of liters of poison
into Chicago canals, but last time we did that,
it only killed a single carp, just one.
It's unlikely we're gonna get a handle on this problem
with active countermeasures,
and so the most recent approach
that has gotten the most attention is a passive one,
a barrier to the Great Lakes
to protect it from potential economic ruin,
and it also creates the water
that no one will save you from.
Now, when you think of an invasive species,
you probably picture something undesirable,
like a stink bug or a weed that spreads everywhere,
but then you really think about it and you go,
whoops, I actually have an invasive species that I feed
and I love more than any person
I've ever met in my entire life.
That's right.
Oh, hey, sweetie.
That's right, the domestic cat is listed
as one of the 100 worst invasive species in the world.
Don't let their cute little faces fool you.
They are tiny murder machines.
Every year in the United States,
there are 160 million feral cats roaming around,
killing 4 billion birds and 22 billion small animals.
Domestic cats are responsible for modern extinctions
of reptiles, birds, and small mammals of a third of them.
They're responsible for one third of these extinctions.
That little face, it'll get you, but don't be mistaken,
that's the last thing billions of small animals see.
Our story now brings us back to Chicago.
You mean the home of the Chicago Bears?
You got that right, sister.
If you stand right on Romeo Road
and you look down on the Chicago Sanitary
and Shipping Canal,
you'll see about 450 meters of water
that aren't all that interesting,
but below the surface is a system of electrodes
pumping out two volts per inch throughout the water volume.
This is the electric dispersal barrier system.
It's meant to turn carp away with many shocks per second
that aren't going to instantly kill the fish,
but they will be uncomfortable enough
to deter them from swimming up and into the Great Lakes.
Yes, this is an electrified river,
which makes it extremely dangerous.
Perhaps even more dangerous than the drowning machine.
Pure water is not very conductive.
That is, electric current, moving electrons,
does not move through it very well.
But water in a river and water in a human body is not pure.
It has a lot of stuff dissolved in it,
stuff like sodium and chlorine ions,
which I already added to the water in front of me
in terms of table salt.
The loose ions and their charges, in effect,
make the solution more able to transmit current
by making it more electrically conductive.
That's hard to really see,
so I'm going to show you up close
by putting a nine-volt battery inside of this water.
Don't worry, nothing will happen.
Bad to me, probably.
Okay, now look here.
Look right there.
See now, thanks to a chemical reaction
happening at the electrodes,
specifically the electrolysis of water
to produce hydrogen gas,
what you're seeing in the bubbles right there,
we can see with our very own eyes
that current from the battery is moving out into the water.
Here is only a tiny, tiny current,
so it's so small that no danger actually comes to me
from putting my finger in the water.
But with the electric dispersal barrier,
we are certainly not talking about nine-volt batteries.
Ooh, I felt tingly.
As you likely know, we are a body electric.
We rely on tiny electrical currents,
the result of chemical reactions,
to do everything from move our muscles around
to think thoughts.
Where's my son?
Where's my boy?
It makes sense to think then
that too much electrical current
running throughout your body
can have some deleterious effects on it,
especially in water,
where the difference in resistivity between water
and human fleshy flesh is effectively zero.
The electrodes resting at the bottom
of the Chicago Sanitary and Shipping Canal
are pulsing about seven times per second
Well, Kyle, you may ask,
how many milliamps does it take
to start seriously affecting the human body?
This fact is why many studies
on the potential danger of falling into this water
produce figures like this,
where red areas indicate the areas
that if you were in that water,
you have a more than 50% chance
of experiencing some effect like cardiac arrest.
Yeah, it's all red.
Now everything...
No, but seriously, can someone like
carpe the carp, please?
Thank you.
Everything we've gone through up until now is why,
according to official documents I obtained
from the United States Coast Guard,
quote,
the electric dispersal barrier is the only location
where the Coast Guard will not attempt
to rescue individuals who fall overboard,
end quote.
Why? Well, the same documents
put the mortality rate for individuals
who fall into this water,
even highly specialized individuals
with training at 50%,
which is insane for an engineering risk.
It's so high.
Thankfully, no one has come even close
to being hurt at the EDBS yet,
and no carp have been found beyond it.
When I started researching this video
just to make sure,
I reached out to both the Army and the Coast Guard.
And at the time of publishing this video,
I have not been corrected on this recommendation,
which makes this stretch of water,
I think the most artificially dangerous water
in the world.
And I'm also on a watch list now, probably.
As we've been going through a number of times
on this channel recently,
pay attention to scary warning signs
because if you were to fall in here,
you're on your own.
Until next time.
Now exiting the facility.
Thank you so much to the very nerdy staff
at the facility for their direct
and substantial support in the creation of this video.
Today, especially, I want to recognize
Research Assistant Bitface at the facility
and Visiting Scholar, Crystal Small.
If you want to join the facility,
get on the staff,
get on the Patreon and the Discord
where you can talk with me almost every day.
You can give me episode ideas.
We have D&D nights,
Magic the Gathering leagues.
We have radio stations.
We share pictures of our pets and stuff
and their little floofy beans.
You can go to patreon.com slash Kyle Hill
and get on the staff today.
And if you support the facility just enough,
you get your name on ARIA here each and every week.
And as you can see, there's literally hundreds of you,
so I have no idea how I'm going to pass the...
Electric eels are interesting to me
because evolution kind of knew
the difference in electrical conductivity
between air and water.
And it doesn't know, of course,
it just happened to work.
And I think that is in line with the physics
and that's really interesting to me.
There are no animals that have something
like an electric eel ability in air.
They all live in the water,
whether that's an electric eel,
that's not an eel,
and the electric catfish and some other animals.
Evolution hit upon this conductivity property
where it could be a viable strategy in water,
but never in air.
And that kind of shows why electric current
in the water is so much more dangerous
or else it wouldn't exist in electric eels.
That's...
I'm not rambling.
You're still going?
Cool.
Thanks for watching.
Don't worry, I'm probably fine with this.
