DROWNING MACHINES - Deadly Underwater Pitfalls

We Science Too
67 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
As the administrator of a large underground facility filled with dangerous machines and
laboratory equipment and non-Euclidean organisms that defy traditional classification,
I'm very familiar with very scary warning signs. Don't worry about that.
If you need an anti-matter reaction warning sign or a non-standard space-time sign,
you can be sure, and you might get into something pretty harrowing around here.
But by far the scariest warning sign that I've ever seen outside of these walls
has to be this one. What exactly is the drowning machine?
If you were to walk along the shore of one of the many rivers in the United States that has
a dam within it, you might encounter a sign like this. And no, it's not a joke,
or a photoshop, or a plant. A drowning machine is a real, if a bit dramatic,
engineering term that describes one of the worst water-based situations you can ever
find yourself in. Now, to understand why a sign like this is absolutely necessary,
we have to begin with flow. And no, not the flow that you hear on your radio.
Thank you, Aria. I know that was embarrassing. I mean flow like moving liquid like water.
Now, one of the ways to categorize the flow of water would be to see how waves
move within that flowing water. Now, that sounds a bit esoteric, but you're already
familiar with this distinction in air. When something is moving slower than waves do in air,
we call it subsonic. When it's moving faster than sound waves in air, we call it supersonic.
And when something is such a bad character design that it costs a movie company tens
of millions of dollars and endless internet outrage, we call that sonic the hedgehog.
Similarly, when water is flowing slow enough for waves to propagate through it, like
throwing a pebble into still water, it is called subcritical flow. And when the water velocity
surpasses the wave velocity so waves can't move through this fast water, it is called
supercritical flow. We already looked at a fascinating example of this when we created
our very own sonic black holes in a previous episode. The event horizon in the bottle that
we looked at was the boundary between sub and supercritical. And like the sonic black hole,
what interests us today is again that boundary where different flows meet.
Think about what would happen when very fast moving water smashed into slow flowing or even
stationary water. You'd think that all that kinetic energy has to go somewhere,
and it does. When super meets sub, kinetic energy is transformed into potential energy
as the water bunches up and rises in what's called a hydraulic jump. This is the equivalent of a
boom in air, but this boom in water is very impressive. Risings of the tide, so to speak.
You can see it in large dams and rivers, but you can also see hydraulic jump in your sink.
Probably the quickest and easiest way to see a hydraulic jump is to simply go to your sink
after finally putting away the dishes like you said you were going to do last week,
and turn on the faucet. Now watch the water. See that little circle that forms right here?
Now you've probably seen that circle form thousands of times without thinking twice about
it, but this is indeed a hydraulic jump. Well, why does it form here? Well, once a film of slow
moving subcritical water forms the bottom of the sink, it's still encountering the fast moving
supercritical water from above. The boundary here is where all that kinetic energy is being
dissipated. Cool, right? Administrator. Yes, Aria, what is it? Kevin has ignored the self-replicating
machines. Warning sign. Viewers, please enjoy a short commercial break. I have something
apparently very important to handle. Oh, my science fair everywhere. Was that goo a person?
Where's Kevin? No, they're dismantling the labs. Oh, Aria, engage countermeasures. They are not
responding to the signal. What do you mean they're not responding to the signal? Get them contained
now. My leg! Oh, no! It's fine. You're fine. You just saw someone get molecularly melted
from the inside out. It's not going to scar you for life. It is good coffee, though. Oh,
I'm sorry. What were we talking about? Seems kind of dumb now, what with all the death.
Oh, hydraulic jumps. Hydraulic jumps are the operative mechanism in the drowning machine,
but we need a bit more fluid dynamics before we fully understand them. You see,
depending on the conditions, a hydraulic jump can happen at different points. Observe this
first ye olde engineering graph. In this graph, you see some supercritical water spewing out from
some opening, and it's encountering water downstream that doesn't really have any
hindrances to it. So the water does exactly what it wants to do and jumps up perfectly according
to the conservation of momentum. In this second figure, you see something different happening.
Beyond the supercritical flow, there's some change in the water that allows it to flow
more freely than it otherwise would, maybe a change in slope, and so the jump occurs
much further out from the boundary point. Now look at this third figure. Something downstream
of the supercritical flow is impeding the flow, like debris or maybe even another dam.
This pushes the water actually before where the hydraulic jump forms. The hydraulic jump
is now underwater, forming what is called a drown jump. This is the killer component.
Since 1900, there have been more than 700 documented drowning deaths in the United
States at what are called low-head dams. And since 1900, the death rate has accelerated.
Why? These smaller dams just happen to produce the perfect hydrological conditions
to produce the last diagram that we looked at, drowned jumps. Right past the point where the
water drops just a few feet off the top of a low-head dam, a drown jump forms beneath the
surface of the turbulent water. But the jump itself rises further away from the dam, where
the water looks like it's boiling. This creates a recirculating flow, a kind of vortex. Water is
deceptively heavy, and heavy water flowing quickly can be extremely forceful. The vortex
that can form on the other side of a low-head dam can therefore trap smaller objects within it
indefinitely in a never-ending cycle, washing machine-like, of submersion. The water is
usually freezing cold, making hypothermia a real concern. It's turbulent and full of bubbles,
making it less dense and much, much harder to float in, even if you're wearing a life jacket.
These vortices contain tumbling logs and debris and trash that will bludgeon anything that comes
into contact with them forever. Put all this together, and indeed you have, if you're unfortunate
enough to fall into one, the perfect drowning machine. These are so dangerous that not only
are there warning signs everywhere about them, it seems that almost every state in the U.S.
has some pamphlet or video about the dangers. There are thousands of low-head dams across the
United States, many of which are unmaintained or abandoned. Service, please, Zaria.
Beep boop.
So, these signs are absolutely no joke. The dams that harbor these hazards are extremely hard to
see if you're on the river, so they can hit you without warning. And if you were to fall into a
drowning machine, it's almost impossible to save you. I'm not exaggerating. You are advised against
trying to help someone who falls into a drowning machine without proper training and equipment.
Just a life jacket won't cut it. And I need to say that because, unfortunately, a number of
would-be rescuers, even professionals like firefighters, have found out the hard way.
Look, kayaking and tubing and other summertime activities that your friends who wear Birkenstocks
all the time will peer-pressure you into are very fun. Just be safe out there and heed any scary
warning signs that you see. They're scary for a reason. And nothing, nothing, is worth meeting
the drowning machine. Until next time.
Now exiting the facility.
Thank you so much to the very nerdy staff at the facility for their direct and substantial
support in creating this video. Today, especially, I want to recognize research assistant digital neo,
whoa, and visiting scholar Chris Onyx, cool name that I didn't almost forget. If you want to join
the facility staff today, if you want to join the nearly 1,200 nerds that are giving me episode
ideas and talking with each other, working with their own game nights and D&D remotely and
listening to a music bot that kind of works sometimes, you can go to Patreon dot, I know it
sounds fun, you can go to Patreon.com slash Kyle Hill and sign up right now to get on the facility
staff today. And if you support us just enough, you'll get your name on Ari here each and every
week. And as you can see, there's more and more of you each week, so I don't really know how to
pass the time. Hydraulic jumps aren't evil. It's just in low head dams, they just happen to produce
something that is very dangerous. But usually engineers will use hydraulic jumps to their
benefit. They're very good at dissipating energy. So with something like a dam, you can do clever
calculations to figure out how far you want the jump to happen, how high you want it to be, and
that can dissipate 60 to 70 percent of the water's energy, which can keep the subcritical, super
critical boundary from destroying your structure or eroding the riverbed or what have you. How long
I've been talking for? Jeez, there's a lot of you. Thank you. Thanks for watching. Bye.
