The Frisians were a Germanic-speaking people living in the coastal area of the Netherlands and Germany. Before the conversion to Christianity, a long process beginning after the Frankish Conquest of Frisia, the Frisians worshipped a series of gods, likely closely related to the Norse gods known from Icelandic Mythology like Odin, Thor, Frey and others. In this lecture, I talk about what archaeological remains pertain to the paganism or heathenism in Frisia, their cemeteries and burial practices, relations to the Norse and Anglo-Saxon worlds.
This video is taken from a section of a talk I gave at the Pre-Christian Student Conference in Oslo in November 2023. Full video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V4c4g7BanSo
let's finally and I'll go a little bit
faster because we're a bit behind
schedule um but let's take a look at the
archaeology so I had a look at some
funery rights from Fria to see what
information can be gleaned there for
that I looked at three main cemeteries
so the cemetery of which is in South
Holland very fun one to pronounce we can
all try that at the pub later um there
are two from Fran there is one from b o
b in Dutch andum which is H in Dutch uh
and then try to compare what we saw
there so what is it that we see in the
funerary rights so we see that there is
both inhumation and cremation burial and
there is no clear pattern uh to uh to
age gender and social status so what I
mean there is that we don't say that it
is only women that are created and men
that
are buried let's say it is pretty much
all through each other it's very random
quite similar to to what we find in
Scandinavia around the same time that
there there isn't a clear way that
someone is to be buried it's very
diverse what's also varied is the the
positions in which the deceased are
placed especially if we compare that
with the later Christian burials some
are on their backs some have their knees
crossed others are in crouched positions
and some are in such weird positions
that archaeologists have called them
deviant burials and they may have been
uh criminals in life they may have been
foreigners is another thing that's been
suggested based on some of the uh DNA
evidence that has gone with it and maybe
they were just incredibly quirky
individuals we don't really know but
that's the fun with funery rights so we
frequently find grave Goods that are
also alongside around half of those that
I looked at had grave Goods with them
and these are often typified on the
basis of the sex of the deceased so a
lot of the time we will find uh jewelry
that is associated with women with them
fib life for example and broaches like
the D type as well as spindle walls of
course spinning was incredibly important
and later fian law uh makes gives a very
high find to someone who harms a person
who is involved in spinning wool I.E
most of the time a woman so clearly that
was incredibly important and these were
things that followed them into the grave
we have a few examples though where the
sex of the individual does not line up
with the grave good that they are given
and based on some of the comparative
approaches by looking at Scandinavia
this uh transgression of the the
traditional gender role with what they
were given um perhaps indicates that
they had a religious role in life
thinking especially about save and other
such things um but again it's hard to
tell uh based on the the quite scant
evidence that we have it's worth bearing
in mind that because of the soil
conditions of the Netherlands with
frequent flooding these cemeteries often
aren't incredibly well preserved um the
terapin uh the these Hills that were
piled up were incredibly fertile
farmland and in the 19th century the
fian farmers found out and they thought
hey this is brilliant they started to uh
excavate them uh to use them as
fertilizer on their own Farmland which
was great for them but they started to
pull out all of these old things so we
have a lot of these uh yeah they didn't
really know what to do with them so a
lot of them have disappeared a lot of
the uh fines that we know were once
there we don't have anymore or we don't
know what their fine contexts were like
so it's yeah it's often uh rather
difficult to work with the
material one particularly interesting
thing for f is that we have horse and
dog burials now uh these are frequently
buried alongside
humans the horses were almost always uh
stallions they were almost always in the
primes of their lives so perhaps we can
suggest that these were sacrifices they
weren't old uh you know Mayes or or Nags
as you might call them which had sort of
dropped off and then they Chuck them in
the grave these were probably part of
some right that was part of the dead but
and for any dog lovers you'll be pleased
to hear most of the dogs were quite
large and actually going on a bit of a
tangent but a later old fian law code
has five ranks of dogs uh depending on
how much wear Guild you have to pay if
you harm such a dog it lasers from dogs
that can kill wolves to dogs that lie
around the farm and don't do anything
and aren't particularly useful but
anyway but these dogs most of them are
quite old so it suggests that these may
have been the the kind of pets or the
animals of the individuals that died and
that when they died they were also put
with their human so that's quite
nice but what does this tell us about
beliefs in the afterlife and potential
uh spiritual beliefs it's quite hard to
say the dead don't bury themselves um
and as Connor mentioned for St cth but
we're not entirely sure whether we're
looking at something that we should call
religious or is this something that is
cultural that this is a cultural
tradition and that the horses and dogs
that are buried have no religious
significance but rather it's to show the
social status of the person who was
buried rather than that they believe
that there was some kind of religious
symbolism behind it or purpose however
what I will say is that it's very
interesting that we find grave Goods
alongside them the kinds of grave goods
are also enlightening and the fact that
we find animals buried alongside them as
we find of course in the Old fian Law
codes these dogs could be very useful
they could be taken into battle they
could defend livestock against wolves or
they could lie around on the farm being
not particularly useful but it may
suggest that these were objects that
people were expected to need in a second
life that they might have if we're
looking at Combs knives spindle walls
for spinning gaming pieces Etc these are
things that suggest that it isn't just a
soul that goes on into the next life it
is a body because why would you have a
comb if you don't have hair to comb with
unless of course it is rather not a
religious thing but a social thing
however I think that seems unlikely uh
given the effort that was put into a lot
of these so an interesting facet of uh
fian burials is that we do have a few
ship burials unluckily for us we don't
have any huge Royal boat burials like at
Sutton who and places in Scandinavia
however we do have some smaller ones so
we of one from solfelt near denh uh and
we have two from uh a fron you'll be
happy to hear from dham and fet these
are more like rowing boats and they are
then covered over with planks that
deceased being placed inside we also
have half a Dugout Cano from a burial in
yum which is in vest fron and we have uh
one of the heon burials uh which we
unfortunately no longer have because it
was excavated in 1905 uh around then
that was also said to have been in a
boat-shaped coffin which is also a
rather interesting little illusion
another piece of evidence for this is
that 17 out of the 42 nails from a BM
were clinches and clinches are a kind of
rivet that is used on a ship to make
sure that the I believe it's that the
hole can actually endure the force of
the Waves crashing against it so an
essential part of a
ship so why are they burying people in
ships here well a lot has been said
obviously about ship burials in England
in Scandinavia some thoughts about the
fian examples because none of them are
large Royal ships with slaves and
animals chucked in they are they are
simply a person in a rather small ship
that has been buried perhaps it's the
case that they need some kind of
transportation to get to where they're
going next or is it because they might
be coming back we know from later
Icelandic sources that when it comes to
grave Mounds that sometimes people would
sit or lie Li down upon grave mounds and
that the dead would communicate with
them and give them information they
wanted is it possible that such Boats
were meant to be so that the dead May
sometimes return and be of use to their
Community it's hard to say but it's an
interesting
idea we also have from a very
interesting case where we have secondary
deposits so primary deposit is the first
time something goes into the ground
secondary means that uh it has either
been dug up once again and then buried
again we also find similar parallels
with the Norse uh fery ritual uh
especially if you read price he goes
into some detail about that but what is
very interesting is that we also get
secondary deposits from us that have not
actually been buried at all but they've
been excarnation and excarnation is when
you let the body decompose above
ground now even more interesting in my
opinion is that we also have signs of
Scavenging marks by carnivores and by
birds indicating that these animals uh
sorry that these bodies have been left
to be picked clean by various animals
and the types of of wounds that we see
on these these bones obviously after
they they've already died are PEC marks
so probably from crows and other
carrying uh as well as the bite marks of
various carnivores possibly wolves foxes
dogs that sort of thing and it's
possible this is related to the GIC idea
of the beasts of battle which are
described as appearing before a battle
there are many Kennings which go into
feeding the Ravens or the the Wolves
preparing to Feast that kind of thing so
could it be that these animals The
Wolves and the Ravens which as uh Tom
mentioned in his talk are very much
associated with the god Olin are perhaps
part of a specialized ferary right that
is reserved for warriors particularly
intriguing is that those secondary
deposit bones that show signs of
excarnation are all from young men so
perhaps it is something that is
associated not necessarily with the
warrior but with young men in general or
perhaps are we seeing evidence of the
prior Iron Age right of excarnation
instead it should be mentioned that so
before we have that mass Exodus out of
the terapan area following the Roman
period we know of no burials from that
time but we know that there were people
there so is it possible that the reason
we don't have any burials from that
period is because they aren't burying
people but they're leaving them above
ground we know for instance from places
like Tibet Mongolia various Native
American tribes that c certain social
groups are also excarnation instead of
being buried so it's an intriguing
possibility that we don't know the
answer to but there are several possible
options there I'm going to go really
quickly through material culture so that
we can get on to uh Jonathan a lot of
this is based on the excellent work of
yan Nikolai into metal work and kingship
in Fria and what we see if we look at
some of these broaches from fron is that
we can make out a face there
and we can actually also make out
another face here and what you can see
is if you compare the size of the eyes
is that all the time one of the eyes is
larger than the other perhaps giving a
oneeyed uh depiction of this face around
the eyes we get several beasts these are
mostly horses that we can see uh and we
get again more Beast faces on the foot
plate here on this brooch too there are
several examples of this that come out
of the ground sometimes these animals
look like horses other times they look
like birds or or Wolves or Serpentine
creatures that we see but very
frequently we get this idea of a face
and then several animal heads around
them or animal bodies the same is true
for brats which we also get in a large
abundance in Fria many of them are based
on examples from Scandinavia others are
more similar to those in Anglo-Saxon
England showing their contact there
what's very interesting about these
brats however is that they often show uh
animals mostly a horse with a face and
while this face was probably originally
based on that of a Roman Emperor it has
changed somewhat by this period what's
interesting about this example is that
you can see there is a man with a pretty
funky hair do some kind of mullet I
think uh riding on a horse but that if
you've ever seen a horse that is not
what H's Hooves look like but it is how
they depict human feet at this point so
we have a human head on top of a horse
with human feet and if you can see there
I'm not sure how clear it is but you can
see that the horse's mouth is open and
on quite a few the tongue is also
lulling out so how this has been
interpreted is that this is an image
probably of the god oin probably called
wen at that point in uh in Fria that is
becoming an animal and that this man
between Beast Motif as it's described
having that face between various animals
and of course in the metal it all sort
of blurs together might be the case that
we're seeing something shamanic where a
man is becoming an animal in various
rituals that we see so Nikolai echo's
olon study into odinic symbolism here uh
about migration period metal work and he
believes that these animals that are
depicted are Odin's familiars and that
the reason why the horse's uh tongue is
lulling out and why uh we saw in Tom's
presentation the two the two birds that
are sort of they appear to be leaning in
uh we saw uh in Peter's presentation on
the seat you can see the the female
looking figure there were also two
Ravens on the on the arm rests that are
also sort of bent in as if they are
speaking to the person is it the case
that they are getting Divine Knowledge
from these animals that they are able to
communicate with people just as we read
about in the story of the volsung uh
when sigot he eats the heart of F and
then he is able to understand the
language of birds very interesting and
these are possibilities that this is
what's being shown on the metal work
these are D broaches so typically fian
brooches probably worn by women uh and
the point I wanted to make here is again
we have that that that symbolism of the
two birds that are leaning in But as
time goes on we stop seeing so clearly
the lines of two birds and they
basically just sort of create the basic
shape they they don't really care about
the birds um at that point here are some
beautiful examples again from the fan
terpan area uh we have again this idea
that there are faces and animals between
But as time goes on the actual animal
becomes less important and it becomes
more stylistic with uh various SRS there
but with this very fancy graphic I just
wanted to show that if we flip it on its
head we can again see some kind of face
obviously there we do have something in
the eye there we don't and with a
mustache underneath so that may be again
odinic
symbolism this is interesting it's found
at elsfleth in lower Saxony so quite
close to the border with Fria this is uh
likely Frankish work uh probably
depicting Christ but if we zoom in we
can see that the nello fill of the eye
has been carefully removed to make it
oneeyed so here we have literally Christ
becoming
Odin in this way to perhaps make it more
suitable for people in this area who
were pagans at that time uh very
interesting uh piece of metal work so to
move quickly forward what are we seeing
on the metal work well I would uh posit
as others have done as well that we may
split it between various social orders
that for the upper nobility the Royals
in Fria the mythological significance
relating to wen and and possibly to
specific myths that were no doubt being
told in their Halls uh by their by their
scals as we read in baywolf that this
was very important that relation to wen
the god of the Lords The ancestral
connection with Scandinavia as well uh
as the Contemporary shared connections
were also incredibly important and were
being expressed through the material
culture so we have both the importance
of uh religion and cultural Affinity but
for the local Elites the lower nobility
that were making these debased D
broaches um where you can't actually
tell what is being depicted it's just
the basic shape um then it's a visual
representation of the personal bond
between a patron and the King rather
than a religious symbol so the symbolism
on the jewelry isn't important it's
rather the marker of the political
affiliation so this is very interesting
because it shows that various elements
of the pre-christian religion may have
been important to different people and
perhaps not everyone was allowed in on
the secret of the mythology that perhaps
Divine knowledge was also kept to a
certain group and that they had a
certain afterlife to which they would go
hence that they would have a certain
ferary ritual and that for other classes
in the society so those poor individuals
that RedBot didn't want to be with in
the afterlife that something else was
due for them it's
possible can we know anything about the
very lowest classes and what they
believed in well possibly by look at
Certain Magical uh objects I was about
to say omelet but that's not a not what
we're looking at here we have some
amulets though and some charms uh we
find tooth amulets especially those of
dogs and wolves teeth which have been
found and interestingly they seem to be
connected with children a lot of the
time and it's thought that there's a
possible connection with trying to ward
off sickness in children by giving them
a wolf's tooth we also find discs of Red
Deer Antler which also may have been uh
connected with fertility as these Red
Deer Antler were often hung outside of
apothecaries in the later Middle Ages
and from the Roman time we know that
they also had a connection with
fertility so maybe this was something
that was quite important for women at
the time speaking of which we also have
a shell from very that we don't find
these shells at all in the fian coastal
area so it's probably traded up from the
Mediterranean um and the this was found
on a woman's forehead in a grave at
and we may connect this shell uh with
ethnographic examples from Southern
Italy so in Sicily still in the 19th
century women were wearing uh amulets
with the exact same kinds of shell
around their necks and that was because
they thought that it would make them
more fertile and protect them in
childbirth we also have a few other
examples of these shells being used in
similar ways in uh northern Europe at
the time uh when the woman of fth was
alive so it's possible that that's
what's going on here because the the
shell itself when held in a certain way
looks just like a vula so perhaps that's
what they're trying to emulate by
wearing such a thing we also have a very
curious little bronze box uh that may
have contained herbs and appears to have
been something that could be worn around
the neck uh although of course that can
have other functions too so let's race
towards the uh conclusions here what can
we conclude about religion uh in Fria at
this time well we know from the textual
sources of the hagiographies that
shrines were very important places there
were special rules that applied here uh
and which were protected by law in this
case by The King by RedBot um or at
least the authority of of the Lamb so
place name evidence certainly suggests
that there were many of these shrines
around but archaeologically we don't
have any evidence for large temples or
lots of uh sacrifice like the the and
skulls from from Iceland and other
places we simply don't have it so it's
possible that whatever rights were being
performed there were archaeologically
invisible and that we therefore don't
have them it's also very likely I think
at least that these would be quite
minimalist rather than necessarily being
Grand structures anyway so we're not
sure what to look for in that case but I
think they were likely important Central
places the Lord or the king played an
important role in the religious cult
as he was tasked with the protection of
the shrines as The Giver of the law and
the law obviously included that shrines
had to be protected and we can assume
also that he oversaw the religious
ceremonies that occurred at the time uh
that's certainly the impression we get
from the vami if it can be believed the
symbolism in artwork the choice of
funerary rights and the understanding of
the social position we can understand
that the religious and the secular were
tightly bound together that probably we
aren't looking for a separate priest
class in this case but rather members of
the secular Elite um that were the
pveers of this
knowledge from the funerary rights we
get the idea that this is a non-dogmatic
approach to death and I would extend
that the religion also had a
non-dogmatic approach to life where
there wasn't a a sacred text or a kind
of um something to draw on that had all
the answers rather that it was more
diverse perhaps we can look at Regional
differences of course in South Holland
is an area where um there was more
settlement continuation from the Roman
period to later so perhaps they had a
different funerary right with the
excarnation it's possible that's an
explanation for that um the inclusion of
of animals in the graves I find also
very interesting because it says
something about their idea of what
happens in the afterlife although
whether we interpret that as being
solely religious or as more a marker of
social status is just the question and
by looking at the jewelry we can see how
these ideas developed and how possibly
um different things were important for
different people and different social
groups at that time it would suggest by
looking at these uh this jewelry that
the distinction between human animal and
divine is literally blurring within the
metal work and I would argue that by
including horses and dogs in Graves
you're also doing the same uh when it
comes to the fery right and and the
after life which is quite interesting
the idea that one could use teeth of
various animals or antlers and shell
amulets to give a certain Boon to people
and to harness some kind of desired
power that these animals have may
suggest that they also believed in some
kind of animism that there was a soul in
various objects that we would class as
being inanimate or otherwise why wear
them but as with many of these things
they raise more questions than we have
answers but I hope I was able to give a
few answers uh to you all today so thank
you very much for
listening