understand the Poso tragedy

Kamar Film
13 followers
15 Video Views·Jan 23, 2025
Speaking of Poso's riots, I think we should start with a simple question,
about why a rich, beautiful and harmonious region in diversity
could be engulfed in a terrible conflict.
Poso, one of the central regencies in Central Sulawesi,
initially lived side by side with religious differences and tribes.
But then, it turned into a battlefield for rival groups,
occupying power, territory and identity.
Poso's conflict was not just an incident,
let alone the spontaneity of the small-scale problem,
but part of a much wider social-political dynamics.
But, why did Poso become a very vulnerable region in the face of conflict?
What actually triggered the major riots in Poso?
This time, we will try to trace the traces of the riots in Poso
to understand the conflict that happened.
Poso, after the independence of Indonesia,
has become a comfortable home and a battlefield for various ethnic groups
with different cultural backgrounds and religions.
Traditional communities such as Pamona, Mori, Napu, Besoa and Badak
continue to occupy high-level areas in Poso.
They are mostly Christian,
a result of Dutch missionary activities since the colonial period in the 20th century,
whose center is located in the city of Tentena.
On the other hand, the coasts and cities in Poso are dominated by Muslim residents.
In addition to Muslim communities,
there are also trans-immigrants from various islands in Indonesia,
such as South Sulawesi, especially the Bugis tribe,
and also from the Gorontalo area in the north.
There are also many Arab traders who settle in this area.
Even their descendants play an important role
in religious and Islamic institutions.
Poso is also the target of the government's trans-immigration program.
It moves people from densely populated areas,
especially Java, Lombok, and Bali.
The presence of these trans-immigrants
further enriches the ethnic and cultural diversity in Poso.
At the end of the 1990s,
Muslim population was the majority in Poso,
with a figure of more than 60%.
The problem is,
the interaction between ethnic and religious groups that are so diverse,
turns out to create a very complex social dynamic,
leading to conflicts due to conflict of resources,
identity differences, and social injustice.
The Poso conflict at first
was centered on the tension between the Bugis immigrants,
who are diverse Muslims,
with Pamonay ethnic groups, who are mostly Christians.
The conflict was initiated by small incidents,
which then grew.
Although the initial conflicts were recorded differently
in various sources,
it was generally agreed
that this conflict started from the conflict between individuals
which then spread to larger groups.
The supporters of the provocateur theory
show that the violence started
right after Arief Patangga announced his resignation
from the re-election of Poso as the regent
on December 13, 1998.
Coincidentally, this phase is also the time
when the violence broke out
and the end of the class that took place throughout Indonesia
after the fall of the new order.
On Christmas Eve, December 24, 1998,
which coincided with the month of Ramadan,
a young man from the protestant majority
community in Lambogia,
named Roy Runtu Bisalemba,
raped Ahmad Ridwan,
a Muslim young man from Kayamanya community.
Information circulating on the Christian side
says that Ridwan ran to the mosque after being raped,
while the Muslim version describes it
as an attack on a Muslim young man
who slept in the mosque area.
And in several versions,
it is also mentioned that the victim was praying
or even becoming a Muslim.
It is not certain which version is more accurate
from this incident.
What is clear is that after the incident,
the figures and religious leaders of both sides
then met and agreed that alcohol
is a problem and agreed to ban it
during the month of Ramadan.
Pores Poso then ordered thousands of hard drinks
to be destroyed.
The problem actually worsened after this regulation
because on one occasion,
when Christian youth tried to protect
a legendary shop owned by a Chinese Christian,
they met with the early Muslim youth
intending to rob the shop.
And the clash between the groups
could not be avoided anymore.
This incident soon spread as rumors and bird news.
The problem is that the story is changed a lot
and the news circulating on the Christian side
is mostly stating that there is a church
that was burned.
On December 27th,
finally a group of Christians armed
a truck carrying trucks from Tentena
led by a member of the Poso DPRD
named Herman Parimo,
known to be a member of the
Central Sulawesi Youth Movement or GPST,
a former pro-government militia fighting against the Permesta
and DI in the 1950s to 1960s in Poso.
On the other hand,
suddenly there were 9 trucks carrying Muslim groups
from Ibu Kota Palu, Parigi, and Ampana.
A report from a Muslim source
estimated that there were 100 Muslims
who arrived using 27 trucks,
pickup trucks, and motorbikes.
On that day, the riot increased to the point that
the police could not do much to stop it.
Even though they admitted
that they had blocked the roads leading to Poso.
After a week, the riot again heated up
in the middle of a heavy rain
and those who lost their homes
due to the riot
chose to stay in Tentena, Parigi, and Ampana
as the areas that felt safer.
As long as the riot continues and there is no peace,
there are a lot of banners, leaflets, and graffiti
attacking the government officials of the Poso regency
whose Christian religion has begun to fade,
especially the target of Mr. Rimo
and the people who are suspected to support him,
Yaya Patiro, who also volunteered as a regent.
The riot became more and more rampant,
almost uncontrollable again.
The commander of the Wira Buwana Military Area Command
stated that what spread the riot
were 8 rioters from the Christian group
who were finally detained by the regional military command.
However, members of the Kulun Asam
stated that the results of their investigation
showed that the riot in Poso
did not actually occur due to religious or ethnic tensions.
They said the violence occurred due to miscommunication
and claimed that there were no local officials
involved in the effort to restore peace in Poso.
In response to this incident,
the government of Sulawesi province is forming a clarification team
that will search for 40 witnesses
and also concluded
that there were no Poso regional officials
who acted as provocateurs.
However, Mr. Rimo, who is said to be the leader
of the Christian group's vehicle
that departed from Tentena,
was finally arrested.
The situation did not subside
because the riots continued
that there were high-ranking officials in Poso
who were behind this violence,
such as the regent Arief Patanga,
who is of Islamic religion,
or the secretary of the Yaya Patiro regency,
who is of Christian religion.
Therefore, when Patiro was given a position
in the provincial government in Palu,
this triggered the anger of the Poso Muslims.
Then in February 1999,
the police arrested the younger brother of a regent named Afgar Patanga
with the accusation of inciting violence.
The ongoing riots
eventually caused Governor Habe Paliuju
to choose to remove Arief from his position
as a regent in June 1999.
The removal of this position was also pushed by Afgar Patanga
as a writer of a letter without a name
which contained an accusation of the Christian officials of Poso
as the party that started the riots.
When the election was held in 1999,
the new Law on Decentralization
was approved so that the regent's position
should be filled not through the removal as before,
but by the election in the DPR in Poso.
The Poso region, which is close to religious and ethnic differences,
is now an arena of fierce political identity warfare.
The general election held in June 1999
was said to be quite tight and peaceful.
After this election,
Poso experienced a period of calm for more than a year.
But the series of political events and legal incidents in April 2000
caused tension again until Poso became hot
and the second phase of the Poso conflict arose
which continued along the same line of combat
with the conflict in the first phase.
In the second phase of the Poso conflict,
the Christian area suffered the most damage.
At the same time as the break-up of the second conflict,
the Afgar Patanggah trial has begun.
In another trial involving a corruption case,
a local businessman named Alianza Tompo
was accused of embezzling funds from the village's credit program.
This corruption case is said to be related to the conflict case in Poso
because there are rumors that some of this money was used
to buy time to attack the court building
and burn documents related to its involvement in the first Poso conflict
which is called Afgar Patanggah.
As a result of this corruption case,
the court was forced to postpone the two cases.
In order to avoid further corruption cases in the Poso trial,
the trial for the next Afgar Patanggah was held in Palu.
The problem is that the heat in Poso did not subside
but actually worsened because there were political interests in the government
that used corruption cases in Poso to be held.
At that time, the position of the secretary of the Poso region was being disputed
and there was a statement from a member of the DPRD,
from the Partai Persatuan Pembangunan or PPP,
which was made in Surat Kabar on April 15,
where he predicted that there would be much more violence
if the ex-candidate for regent, Damsik Lajalani, was not elected.
One day after the Surat Kabar was published,
the next day, a Muslim youth claimed to have been attacked
by a group of Christian youths
and showed a wound on his arm as evidence of attack.
From here, the Islamists retaliated
and the battle between the youths of the Christian majority of Lambogia
with the Muslim youths of Kayamanya and Sayu
increased drastically to become a widespread violence.
For the next few days,
houses owned by Christians in Poso
near the bus terminal and Lambogia were burned.
This worsening corruption incident
caused the Police of Poso to send a car brigade,
a.k.a. BRIMOB, from Palu.
It was reported on April 17
that the BRIMOB members from Palu
were trying to aggravate the situation
by shooting at the crowd of people,
occasionally killing them.
From the shooting,
it was reported that Muhammad Yusni, 23 years old,
and Nianto, 13 years old, were killed,
while eight other Muslims were injured.
One of them, named Rozal Mahmud,
was later reported to have died due to his injuries.
From here, after the Surat Kabar was published
on the afternoon after the shooting,
the Muslim youths who were angry finally attacked Lambogia
and burned houses, churches, and schools.
In response to this incident,
the next day, Governor Pali Uju visited Poso
and was greeted by a Muslim group
led by a businessman who was suspected
of lying to the Tompo Alliance.
They demanded that Lajalani accept the position of Secwilda
so that the case against Afgar Patangga was closed.
Then the Police of Poso was sacked
and the BRIMOB troops were sent back to Palu.
Human Rights Watch,
which observed this conflict,
assessed that the demands of the Muslim group
actually reflected the conflict situation
that was caused by political competition,
political justice system,
and people's dissatisfaction with the law enforcement.
One of the demands was finally fulfilled
by sending the BRIMOB troops back to Palu.
However, the riots continued with the burning of houses
after an unidentified body
was found next to a hat
that is usually used by Muslims.
The mass believed that the body came from
a Muslim group in Angiayat.
This incident was long-lasting
with Muslim groups from the city and its surroundings.
In the end, they burned houses, churches,
and even PDIP branch offices.
They left the areas of Lambogia and Kasintu
in a state of devastation.
The mass was burned in the Amara cave,
and then carried out a raid
in the form of a religious identity check,
which started in the Muslim majority area,
where in the surrounding reports,
it was reported that some Christians
were reportedly forced to get out of the car and killed.
The situation was almost uncontrollable
and threatened stability in Poso,
so Major General Tendi Selamat Kirbyantoro
in Makassar
sent 600 troops
to put an end to the fighting.
This effort succeeded
and to really stop the tension,
the governor asked the Christian community in Poso,
many of whom fled to Tentena
or hills around the city of Poso
not to take revenge,
but to rely on God for what has happened.
The situation escalated.
The police also announced that the second phase of the conflict
was over on May 3, 2000.
It is said that during the second phase of the conflict,
both sides began to use colorful headbands
and armbands to distinguish themselves.
Christian fighters are known as the Red Army
or the Red Group,
while the Muslim group as the White Army
or the White Group.
However, the term is too simple
because the complexity of the Poso conflict
far exceeds the limit of religious differences
due to the role of the social structure of the community,
the struggle for power,
and external intervention
that worsened the situation.
Unfortunately, the peace in Poso
after the second phase of the conflict
was very short.
Only three weeks after the second phase was over,
the third phase,
which according to some observers
became the biggest and worst phase,
finally began.
This period is dominated by a wave of retaliation
by the Christian Red Group
against the Muslim community.
Alongside the direct clash with the Islamist White Group,
there was also the kidnapping
and murder of people who were not interested.
The interview conducted by Human Rights Watch
also confirmed that the migrants from South Sulawesi
and Gorontalo
who were generally victims of the action,
but there were also other ethnic groups and tribes who suffered.
At the beginning of May,
there was news of birds
that many Christian youths who fled
then fled to a camp
led by the Red Group in the Kelei area.
Christian troops operating in this phase
are called the Red Cavalry and the Black Cavalry,
where the Black Cavalry
is a group that wears a cap like a ninja
and is said to target Muslims
in Kayamanya,
who are considered responsible for the attack in Lambogia
in the previous phase.
This ninja group is said to be led by Fabian Ustibo,
an immigrant and a farmer
with a Catholic religion
who comes from Flores, NTT.
Fabian Ustibo was reported to have been imprisoned
for the murder of a man
years ago.
In addition to the name Fabian Ustibo,
there is another Christian figure
named Adven Lateka,
who is described by the press and the police
as a mind, financial capital,
and intellectual actor behind the violence that took place.
On Tuesday, May 23,
a ninja group is said to have killed a police officer,
Sarsan Mayor Kamarudin Ali,
who is 47 years old,
as well as two Muslim civilians named
Abdul Syukur, 40 years old,
and Baba, 60 years old.
The ninja group was later reported to be hiding
in a Catholic church in the Mongkok area.
The group, including Tibo,
began negotiating with the police
to surrender,
but because they saw a gathering of Muslims,
Ali Ali finally surrendered.
Tibo and many members of his group chose
to flee to the hills behind the church complex.
This action angered the church
to the point of a church fire
at 10 a.m.,
and the fight broke out around the city.
The most intense riot took place in Sayo,
where 10 people were injured
by archers and stones.
Seeing this situation,
the governor again indicated
that there was a provocateur from outside.
Meanwhile, the police have announced
that three suspected ninjas have been detained
and brought to the police station
after being beaten by the mass.
Two weeks later, after the announcement of the arrest,
three suspected provocateurs,
who were identified as
Yan, 25 years old,
Raf, 20 years old,
and Leo, 21 years old,
were officially detained
on charges of inciting a riot
on May 23.
A few days later,
on May 28,
a large-scale attack on Muslims
took place in several villages in Posoh.
In the most famous incident,
a Christian group,
where some sources say
that Tibo and his group
participated in circling the village of Sintuwulemba,
which is also known as Kilo 9.
Women and children in this village were arrested
and some of them experienced sexual harassment.
About 70 people tried to escape
to the nearest train station,
namely the Wali Songo train station,
where in this train station
many were killed with firearms.
Regardless of whether they surrendered or not,
those who fled were successfully arrested
and then executed.
Then the bodies were thrown into the Posoh River.
There are about 39 bodies
found in three mass graves.
Although Muslim sources estimate
that there are a total of 191 deaths
in the attack.
From the testimony of a survivor,
he told reporters
that he was arrested four days later
after the attack
and brought to the river for execution.
But the victim was lucky
because he once again
became one of the few people
who managed to survive.
According to a report compiled by Muslim academics,
in the morning of the attack,
villagers tried to seek protection
at the Komodo Military District office in Kaua.
However, the villagers claimed
that the head of the district again
and the head of the district police
forced them to return home
with the excuse that the situation was safe.
In fact, the situation was not entirely safe.
This became a source of anger
in the Muslim community
who saw that the security apparatus
was biased and non-neutral
in handling the conflict.
A systematic attack pattern
against Muslim villages in Posoh
was also revealed in the testimony of the victims
in an interview conducted by Human Rights Watch.
The attack in the village of Tabalo
which was accompanied
by an attack in Kelo Sembilan
became a striking example.
The attackers,
most of whom came from the surrounding villages,
attacked with traditional weapons
such as arrows, sticks, and weapons of assassination.
They burned Muslim houses,
forced them to flee,
and even kidnapped a number of villagers.
The victims who managed to survive
told their terrifying experiences,
including the arrest
and intimidation
carried out by the attackers.
In this event,
religious institutions such as Al-Khairohid
were also mentioned.
Some Al-Khairohid leaders
are suspected to be involved
in mass mobilization,
arms trafficking,
and the spread of propaganda
that sacrifices the spirit of jihad.
Although not all Al-Khairohid members
are involved in violence,
the involvement of some of their leaders
has damaged the image of the institution.
The attacks in Posoh
also showed a clear pattern of targeting
against certain ethnic groups
such as Bugis and Kurontalo.
This intensifies the indication
that the conflict in Posoh
was not only driven by religious differences,
but also by social and economic factors.
In addition, there is an accusation
that this attack was planned in a mature manner
by taking advantage of the momentum
of the National Al-Quran Reading Competition in Palu,
so the winning party
is diverting its attention
to the event
with the presence of the President
and the Vice President,
making an assumption
showing an effort
to organize violence systematically.
Continuing to the conflict,
at the end of May,
it was said that the conflict
again occurred in the surrounding villages
to the city of Posoh.
The governor pointed to Adven Latteka
as the responsible party
for the latest violence.
On June 2, 2000,
there were hundreds of people
who joined the clashes
in the Muslim environment Kayamanya,
where Latteka was killed
in this clashing event.
The Palu government finally asked for help
from the army in Jakarta
and the military area command
who sent another 1,500 troops,
10 tanks and 1 combat unit.
On June 6,
Christians fought
with the police on the east side of Posoh,
which resulted in more victims.
The police also arrested 9 people
and identified three of them
as provocateurs.
But even though they were arrested,
the bodies continued to appear
until July in the Posoh River
or Jurang-Jurang near it.
The tension continued
until mid-July
when 124 protesters
were arrested in the south of Posoh
in the colony of Dale
for carrying weapons,
especially guns.
On July 25,
Thibaut was arrested
by the army near his house
at the head of the village
Jamurdi Morowali
and brought to the police station.
Meanwhile,
two other Catholics
from Flores
who were suspected
to be Thibaut's friends
who lived in Bateleme
were also arrested by the police.
As the violence in Posoh increased,
Indonesian authorities
took every step
to ease the situation.
The Brimob troops from Java
who started Operation Sadar Maleo
and the TNI from Makassar
who started Operation Cinta Damai
were mobilized to fight the conflict.
They placed troops
in sensitive areas
in order to carry weapons
and build barracks
for the refugees.
The number of victims
in the third phase
began to decline
after July in 2000.
In August,
the governors of Central,
North,
and South Sulawesi
met in Pentena
to sign a peace agreement
that promises assistance
to push back
the refugees.
President Abdurrahmanuhaid
alias Gusdur
who was in office at the time
and the leaders of Posoh
also attended a traditional ceremony
for this peace agreement
where the head of the tribe
was buried
as a symbol of peace
and unity
by using phrases
Pamona,
Sintuwo,
Ngaroso
which means strong
when united.
The phrase contains the hope
that the people of Poso
can unite again
and build a peaceful life.
Although this peace effort
should be appreciated,
many parties
criticize the approach
from above to below
because of the lack of
community involvement
in forming a long-term solution
so that the peace agreement
is more formal
and does not touch
the roots of the conflict.
After the peace agreement event,
the third phase of the conflict
did decline
in July 2000,
but the conflict
continued
for the next year
until it broke
into a much bigger conflict.
This was caused
by the continuous failure
of a series of military
and police operations
to prevent violence
or to ask for
retaliation from the perpetrators
so as to trigger
the arrival of radical
known as
jihadists.
Their arrival
caused a series of
new attacks
that destroyed
many villages.
The fourth phase
of the Posoh conflict
indicates a shift
in the pattern of violence.
If in the previous phases
the conflict was more centered
in the clash
between large groups,
then in this phase
the conflict is more
local and sporadic.
The clash
is often triggered
by daily events
such as
the confiscation
of natural resources
such as cocoa.
The clashes
and clashing
are the main triggers
of violence.
Each group
accused each other
has attacked first
so as to create
a vicious circle
that is difficult
to stop.
The violence
that occurs
is getting more brutal
and involves civilians
in large numbers.
When the trial
against Fabiano Stibbo
and his two friends
took place,
this trial
immediately became a scandal
at the beginning of 2001.
The three people
were accused
of being behind
the violence.
The figure of Stibbo
with his criminal background
became the root
of the violence
that was paid
to participate
in the violence.
It is also suspected
that Stibbo,
despite being Catholic,
was recruited
by the Protestants
because of his reputation
as a good fighter.
The judges believe
that the death
or murder
that happened
in 1990
was caused
by Stibbo's efforts
to help a Muslim
in fighting
the Bali attackers.
Claudia Stibbo
herself argued
that Stibbo was made
a black sheep
in this incident.
Supported
by Stibbo's defenders
who gave reasons
why Stibbo
could not be the leader
of the black scouts
because Stibbo
was uneducated,
a migrant
and a Catholic.
The prosecution
also gave defense
by claiming
that Stibbo
was only trying
to protect
the Catholic Church complex
in Mongkok
on the night
of the ninja attack.
Fabiano Stibbo's trial
at the beginning of 2001
was an important event
in the context
of the Poso conflict.
However,
it turned out
to be a turning point
towards the end of the conflict.
This trial
actually worsened
the situation
due to the harsh protests
outside the court building.
Witnesses
who were in the building
and felt frustrated
on both sides
over the handling
of 16 people
who were suspected
as criminals
mentioned by Stibbo.
The opportunity
to pacify the conflict
was lost
when the court
failed to conduct
the trial professionally
and carried out
an unclear investigation
and ignored
16 suspected names
who led
a group of criminals
before Stibbo
and his colleagues
were sentenced to death.
At the end of June and July 2001,
the Poso conflict
entered a new phase
marked by
an increase
in the intensity
of violence
and slaughtering
in cathedrals
targeting
especially women
and children
inciting anger
among the Muslim community
and worsening the situation
to open
wider doors
to accept
the Jihad.
This incident
also sparked
a debate
about the role
of the government
in managing
the conflict
and distributing
power locally
where
both sides
agreed
that the government
failed to effectively
deal with the conflict.
In June,
armed groups
became more aggressive
against villages
and farmers
on the outskirts
causing 10 people
to die or disappear
and many houses
in Poso
and Morowali
to be destroyed.
On June 28,
an unknown
armed group
attacked a vehicle
from South Sulawesi
near Watuwau,
South Poso.
The vehicle
was then found
burned
and six passengers
missing.
Protests in the office
of the government
of Poso
by Christians
from Tentena
immediately increased
the tension
further.
According to the police
and army officials,
Muslims from Ampana
lined up
towards Poso
on June 30
after hearing rumors
that thousands of
Tentena
would come
to demonstrate.
The Muslims
met in Malay
in Lage district
where the fight
caused a man
named Pakibu
to die.
Two people were injured
and 30 houses
were burned.
The army and police
sent two platoons
to detonate the violence
and reported
calm conditions
the next day.
However,
it was said
it had formed
in nearby villages.
However,
the leaders of Tentena
then said
they would only send
30 representatives
to the city
on July 2.
The problem
was that the delegation
from Tentena
was stopped
on their way
to Poso
by the residents
of Sayo
and forced
to return home.
The next day,
a man named Mercusuar
changed his name
to Radar Sultan
and reported
on burning houses
and blocking roads
with the title
of
Phase 4
Poso Conflict
exploded.
The next day,
on July 3,
the violence
increased
when the Red Army
attacked
Buyung Katedo,
Sayo,
and Toyado
while the White Army
burned houses
and churches
in Poso,
Pesisir,
and Kota Poso.
In one of the worst incidents,
on a Sunday
on July 3,
the attackers
killed
at least
13 Muslims
in Buyung Katedo
Sepe.
All except
two women
and children.
Musa,
a local
mosque imam,
was said
to have been burned
to death
while the others
were killed
with a stick.
On the same day,
the Red Army
entered Sayo
and burned
barracks,
temples,
and mosques.
The police reported
that the attack
killed civilians
and three policemen.
At the beginning
of July 5,
the shooting
took place
in Toyado,
Lage District.
The military
and police
reported
that hundreds
of Red attackers
burned barracks
built for
Muslims.
When the security forces
gave up,
they themselves
became the target.
After releasing
warning shots,
they
killed
six Red fighters.
As a response
to the increase
in violence,
the government
decided to increase
the number of
security forces
in the conflict area.
This is a common step
in a situation
like this
in the hope
of overcoming
violence
and restoring
security.
Although there is
an increase
in the number
of troops,
the strategy
used by
the security
is considered
monotonous.
The new regiment
commander admitted
that there was
no significant change
in the approach
taken.
The main focus
remains on the
encouragement
to conflict
groups
to calm
down
and find
a peaceful
The effectiveness
of this strategy
is questioned
as violence
continues
even though
several
security
operations
.
The fact
that the commander
himself is not sure
how long
the ambush
will last
shows a lack
of certainty
and a well-planned
continues
the same pattern
as the previous
operations,
namely providing
amnesty
to those
who
surrendered
weapons.
However,
the threat of
a tougher
for those
who
still carry
weapons
is also
emphasized
based on the
emergency law
of 1951.
Although there was
a previous increase
in violence
on July 7,
the government
stated
that the
situation
was
conducive
However,
this claim
was immediately
questioned
when the
governor tried
to visit
Tentena
and was
blocked
by the
Muslim
forces.
of the governor's
visit to
Tentena
showed how
high the
tension
between the
groups in
Poso.
The Muslims
felt that the
government
was more
biased
towards the
Christian
As can be
seen from
their claims
that the
ambush
only happened
in Muslim
as a
response
to an
unstable
the government
increased the
number of
security forces
in Poso.
However,
the location of
these forces
was not
perfect.
It could
guarantee
security and
stability,
let alone
peace.
People in
some areas
such as
Tentena
rejected the
presence of
security forces,
especially
Brimob because
people felt
they lost
their trust
in the
security forces
due to
the previous
violence.
The shooting
that killed
civilians on
July 5
has reduced
people's
trust in
the security
Although
they allowed
limited
troops,
it was
clear that
trauma and
fear still
haunted
them.
In response
to this
Morowali
finally proposed
a more
community-based
that is
looking for
new residents
to find
provocateurs
and show
that local
people want
a more
relevant
with the
context of
their situation
and involve
their participation
directly.
When the
government was
judged to
have failed
in reducing
the conflict
in Poso
in early
2001,
extremist
entered and
worsened the
situation.
One of the
most famous
events was
because of the
mass killing
in Buyung,
Katedo
that became
a trigger
for the
Jihadist
to be
officially
involved
in the
conflict.
The arrival
of the
Jihadist
to Poso
brought new
dynamics in
the conflict.
With more
complete
and better
the group
was able to
launch more
organized
and destructive
The use
of automatic
weapons
that are
more common
in various
regions
became
a proof
of the
involvement
of the
armed
group.
What is
surprising
is that
the presence
of the
Jihadist
in Poso
is not
a secret.
In fact,
the members
of the
group
visited
the
region
government
officials.
However,
the government
did not
make significant
to prevent
the
extremist
in the
conflict.
On July
25,
an unknown
perpetrator bombed
the police headquarters
in Palo
when hundreds
of officers were
preparing
to demonstrate.
Police officers
fired
and killed
three civilians.
According to
the LAPS organization
HAM in
Palo,
the three
victims had
nothing to do
with the
protest,
especially
with the
bombing.
The conflict
that happened
at the beginning
of July
was reduced,
but the
attacks on
villages and
farmers
continued.
The police
began in
October
named
Operation
SADAR
MALIO 5.
As in the
previous operation,
the supply of
Sukarela weapons
for two weeks
was followed
by the
deportation
of the
possession
of weapons.
At the
end of October,
tensions between
the Laskar Jihad
and security
forces increased.
The peak was
the incident in
Mapane village,
where a number
of Laskar Jihad
members were
arrested and
executed for
possession of
illegal weapons.
This incident
is quite significant
because there are
rarely cases
where armed
groups are
successfully
arrested and
executed.
However,
behind the
arrest,
there are
a number
of
deeper
problems.
Previously,
in July
2000,
there was
a mass arrest
against
124
protestant
Although
this action
was not
allowed
as an
effort
to protect
security,
many parties
doubted
the motive
behind the
arrest.
In addition,
torture practices
and execution
outside the
court
were
getting
worse.
Witnesses
pointed out
that the
violence
committed
by the
security
forces
was often
driven
by the
motive
of revenge
or
attack
against
the
not
merely
to
enforce
the
law.
The cycle
of violence
and torture
is getting
worse in
Poso.
Discrimination
between
people,
militants
and
security
is getting
worse.
Repressive
from
the
security
forces
incite
anger
and
push
the
militants
to
fight
back.
The
tension
in Poso
is getting
worse.
Each
side
has a
different
about
the
incident.
Laskar Jihad
released
a report
on the
incident
in
Mapane
village.
In the
report,
Laskar Jihad
provided
a very
different
opinion
the
incident.
According to
Laskar Jihad,
long before
the incident
in Mapane,
Muslims in
Tabalo
have experienced
deportation
and
violence
of
Christians
in
Batalemba
The
peak
was
on
October
18th
when
a Muslim
working
in their
cocoa
farm
was forced
by
Christians
to
The
security
were
not
doing
anything.
Tonight,
as a
form of
process
and
retaliation,
a Muslim
burned
a car
that
took
him
Batalemba.
The
police
were
forced
to
flee.
According
to Laskar Jihad,
was a
form of
self-defense
against
violence
that
they
experienced
before.
The
tension
that
reached
the
peak
exploded
into
a conflict
of
weapons.
After the
incident,
the
Muslim
and
Christians
ready
to
confront
with
weapons.
The
security
took
a step
back.
On
October
20th,
the
Batalemba
police
and
the
to
stop
Tabalo
people
that
felt
threatened
and
no
trust
in
the
security
police
decided
to
attack
the
They
supported
Laskar
The young men who are angry and want revenge continue their attack.
In the attack, a Muslim officer named Ardian Shah died.
The other two were also arrested, but then released.
At 11 o'clock in the evening, most of the help troops had returned to the city of Poso.
But some of them were trapped in a search by security forces in Ratulene, Kasigunco.
With 150 to 200 remaining fighters, Muslim Tabalo asked Muslim Poso to send help.
This help force is the one who then accused the security forces of holding the prisoners, torturing and executing without justice.
A witness named Abu Halifah Romy then witnessed that he and a friend stopped their motorcycle in Poso Brimob in Mapane to report.
Two minutes later, a troop full of young men came from Poso to stop at the post.
And the officer of Brimob released a shot into the air and ordered all the passengers to get off.
According to Halifah, everyone was forced to fight on the ground.
After that, they were hit with an arrow, kicked and kicked.
Halifah said to the court that the officer of Brimob accused them of killing a police officer.
The detainees were suspected of being tortured from 3 to 5 o'clock in the afternoon.
Two detainees who were identified as Heri Kisenanto and Teguh Widianto,
then witnessed that they were tortured until Heri's head was bleeding, had to be sewn and her appearance was disturbed.
They also witnessed being forced to kick themselves and lie on the ground, then hit with an arrow.
Both were accused by the police as murderers.
According to the testimony of the prosecutor and witnesses in court,
the detainees were asked to run and go home, but because they were afraid of being shot,
no one ran, except for a young man named Ahmed Sutomo,
who then died in a chain of shots that were really released, according to their fear.
There were 43 detainees who were then brought to the police station and again accused of bringing weapons and murdering Ardiansyah.
But then, the police immediately released as many as 14 suspects, including 3 underage children who were also detained.
In a court hearing on December 10,
the prosecutors of the 29 detainees who were still detained,
brought up a number of serious procedural violations.
They claimed that the arrest, arrest and interrogation process
carried out by the security apparatus was not in accordance with the law.
Several violations occurred such as when arrested,
the detainees were not shown the arrest warrant as provided in the law.
The detainees also suffered severe physical and mental torture,
such as beatings, beatings and other torture.
Even a detainee was shot after being asked to run home.
However, the police defended themselves with the excuse that the suspects
were caught carrying weapons and explosives.
Therefore, according to them, there was no need for an arrest warrant.
From this situation, the court decided to release most of the detainees
on the grounds that there were procedural violations in the arrest and detention process.
However, the two detainees were still detained for technical reasons.
The release of these detainees caused various reactions in the community.
Umar Christian Diposo asked why.
The perpetrators of the violence were not judged fairly.
They felt that the ongoing legal process was not transparent and tended to side with one side.
Not long after the Mapane incident,
one of the first village evictions took place in Penedapa.
On October 29, according to the version of the Laskar Jat incident itself,
there was news that Christians from Penedapa in Poso Posisir district
disturbed Muslims passing by when they were driving through the district.
The village was also accused of rejecting Muslims from Parigi
to pay tribute to their people.
Muslims from surrounding villages also attacked
and Penedapa was razed to the ground that night.
In early November, there was another battle on the outskirts of the city.
The battle in the Sayo area and its aftermath caused several buildings to be burned.
One person was killed and four people were injured in the bendrokan in the Gebang Rejo area.
The battle on Jembatan 2 on November 11 caused several casualties,
including a retired soldier.
The police and the police sent personnel and both parties were reported fleeing.
However, a resident who took action said to Human Rights Watch
that the battle took place five hours before the troops arrived.
On November 12, the bendrokan reoccurred.
This time at the border of Tanah Runtuh and Lembumau villages
which involved hundreds of fighters who marched all morning
and ended again when the security forces arrived and attacked the white group.
Although there was a period of calm during the middle of November,
in fact, this was only calm before badai.
A number of villages in Poso Posisir district were again targeted by large-scale attacks.
Houses were burned, prisons and murders took place on a large scale.
The scale of violence that took place this time even surpassed previous events.
It shows how fragile the peace that has been built.
Each party has a different narrative about the cause of the violence.
For example, the Laskar Jihad continued to blame the Christian group
for provocations and attacks against Muslim citizens.
Meanwhile, the Christian group accused the Laskar Jihad as the party that started the conflict
and carried out violent actions systematically.
The cycle of violence in Poso is difficult to break.
Each attack will trigger a retaliatory action from the opponent
thus creating a spiral of violence that is increasingly difficult to stop.
The failure of the security apparatus to prevent and stop violence is also a drawback.
The withdrawal of security forces from a number of villages before and during the attack
gave room for militant groups to carry out their actions in a large scale.
This raises a big question about the government's commitment to safeguard security
and readiness in the area of conflict.
The violence that took place in Poso caused a huge impact on humanity.
Thousands of people were forced to leave their homes,
lose their property and suffer deep psychological trauma.
In addition, public infrastructure such as homes, schools and health facilities
also suffered severe damage.
Laskar Jihad again became the main actor in this conflict.
This organization is accused of being behind the attacks that took place
because Laskar Jihad has a strong organization,
complete weapons and adequate logistical support
to launch large-scale attacks.
The violence that spread in November also had an impact on the trans-immigrants living in Bali
most of whom have been left alone.
In some villages, the only house still standing is a house owned by Balinese.
However, in early December, more than 1,400 Balinese from several villages in Poso Pesisir
have fled to other districts.
The secretaries of the local Hindu organization reported
that the situation was too dangerous, there was no food to eat
and for the last week they could not go to their fields.
Almost 50 Balinese houses and at least one temple were burned in the attack.
The news of large-scale attacks against the protest center in Tentena
was strengthened by the organization of Christian Solidarity abroad.
It is difficult to determine how real the threat is.
However, the White Crescent troops clearly moved from village to village along the road.
This threat aroused international concern
and increased pressure on the Indonesian government to take firm action
to face the pressure and see the worsening security situation.
The Indonesian government finally took concrete steps to ease the conflict.
The security restoration operation involving TNI and PORI was launched
with the main goal of stopping violence, confiscating weapons and restoring security.
In this operation, PORI in large numbers did control,
but the role of TNI was still very large, especially in military and intelligence operations.
The presence of elite troops such as PPRC also showed the seriousness of the government in addressing this conflict.
Although the security operation has managed to reduce violence in the short term,
there are still many challenges to be faced due to the root of the conflict in Poso,
such as social injustice, discrimination and poverty are still ignored by the government
which is more busy defending physical security.
The people, especially the victims of the conflict, still feel safe and do not believe in the security apparatus.
In the middle of the government's efforts to ease the conflict in Poso,
a serious accusation arose about human rights violations committed by the security apparatus, especially TNI.
The kidnapping and murder incident of seven civilians from a Muslim group in Toyado, Tojo province,
where five of the seven civilians were found dead,
along with the Mapane case previously involving the Brimov police paramilitary unit,
the Toyado incident reflects a pattern of retaliation, not a strict law enforcement by the security forces.
The accusation that a victim was handed over to the Christian side to be killed,
even strengthened the public's view that the security apparatus, especially TNI,
is not neutral and tends to have one side in the conflict.
Several investigative reports on the incident covered the victims of a robbery named Riyadi or Aswat.
When the news of the kidnapping spread,
including the accusation that the kidnapped victims were taken to a house in Christian Tagolu,
the people gathered at the Bonesompe military post to demand their release.
The armed people were prevented from burning a church near the command post,
which caused a dispute between the people and the security forces.
A man named Sharifudin was reported dead in the incident,
while the shooting and explosion injured several others.
The commander of the military district refused to inform the presence of the kidnapped victims
and promised to immediately resolve what he described as a missing person case.
But the case soon turned from a missing person to a murder when the body of one of the missing people,
Soaib Lama Rati, who was 16 years old, was found with a stab wound in the river.
The police said they did not ignore the possibility of a military presence as a suspect.
Not long after, the army found four more bodies in the Dangkal cemetery near Tagolu.
The security minister at the time, who is currently in office by Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono,
although he admitted that he was a suspect,
seemed reluctant to openly admit the involvement of the security apparatus in the incident,
promising to bring the perpetrator to a fair trial and not to be involved in significant real actions.
Komnas Ham, who was supposed to act as an independent supervisor,
was also slow in investigating and giving concrete recommendations.
Meanwhile, the results of the internal investigation of the TNI showed
that there were a number of inmates involved in the Ham violation.
Nevertheless, the legal process was very slow and less transparent.
The public is increasingly losing their cooperation in the existing legal process,
especially considering the long history of impunity for the perpetrator of the Ham violation in Indonesia.
This response was carried out by the security apparatus against civilians,
as was the case in the Toyado case,
further strengthening the public's view that the security apparatus was not neutral
and tended to protect the interests of certain groups.
As a result, the process of military justice and the lack of public information on the results of the military justice process
worsened the situation.
This not only makes civilians feel unsafe,
but also hinders the efforts to reconciliate and rebuild public trust in the country.
This lack of trust then has the potential to hinder the efforts to enforce wider laws,
such as the expulsion of weapons and the blocking of roads,
which should be done to maintain security and order.
The conflict in Poso, which has been going on for years,
encourages various parties to seek a peaceful solution.
In the midst of the increase in violence, there is an initiative to hold a peaceful meeting in Malino.
This meeting sets a new foundation in the effort to resolve the conflict
by involving various parties, including the government, religious leaders, and civilians.
Visits by senior officials to the police, cabinet ministers,
and members of the National Human Rights Commission
also initiated the planning of a new reconciliation meeting,
including Laskar Jihad, who usually leads the reconciliation process,
admitting that the effort will be more effective than before
because of the importance of Jakarta.
However, this reconciliation effort is not without challenges.
The dominant approach to security in dealing with the previous conflict
has led to distrust among the people.
In addition, the threat from extremist groups
is also a hindrance in achieving continued peace.
In a rare step,
organizations and Christian parties call for the Security Council of the United Nations to join hands.
The meeting in Malino tries to overcome the challenges
by involving the people more widely in the process of reconciliation.
Participants are chosen from various backgrounds,
so it is expected to represent the interests of the entire community.
In addition, the consensus achieved in what is called the Malino Declaration is also more comprehensive,
covering aspects of security, humanity, and law.
The Malino Declaration contains 10 points,
such as 1. Stop all forms of conflict and disputes.
2. End the effort to enforce the law and support legal sanctions against lawbreakers.
3. Ask the state apparatus to act firmly and fairly in maintaining security.
4. To create a peaceful condition,
reject the conduct of emergencies and all involvement of foreign parties.
5. Reject all slander and lies against all parties
and maintain a respectful attitude
6. Emptiness is an integral part of Indonesia.
Therefore, every citizen of the country has the right to live, come, and live in peace
and respect local customs and traditions.
7. All rights and property must be returned to their rightful owners,
as before the conflict began.
8. Return everyone who moves to their homes.
9. Together with the government, implement comprehensive rehabilitation,
10. Implement each other's religious laws based on mutual respect
and comply with all agreements,
both in the form of laws, government regulations, and other regulations.
The Malino Declaration also includes two main work plans
designed to address economic, social, security,
and law enforcement issues in seven districts in Poso and Morowali
over a period of six months.
The first phase began on December 21, 2001 until January 6, 2002
in the form of a public call to hand over weapons willingly,
as well as the publication of heavy penalties for violators,
including the threat of life imprisonment and death penalty.
Subsequently, on January 7 to February 7, 2002,
amnesty was given to those who hand over weapons willingly,
with the procedure of handing over through the village head to the nearest security post.
In the next phase, which lasted from February 7 to March 7, 2002,
the focus was on the return of the handlers to their original places.
At the same time, the steps of law enforcement began,
which lasted until July 7, 2002,
when the police and military combined forces carried out a weapon collection operation.
The target of this operation was an individual who was suspected of having a weapon
or those who hid the perpetrator of the crime.
The operation involved driving a vehicle, a house,
as well as monitoring of witnesses and suspects.
In addition, cases that have not been resolved
were prioritized to be resolved.
Another part of this plan involved the return of foreign visitors
between February 7 and March 7, 2002.
The initial step was to identify visitors who did not have a permanent residence
or who did not register as a winner
within 14 days of their arrival.
They were asked to register immediately,
with the support of a local office,
to assist in the process of returning willingly.
This return was carried out through community agreements,
criminal law enforcement, or regional regulations.
However, this determination gave flexibility to new visitors
who chose to live in peace and respect local customs and traditions,
so that the case of direct deportation was not known.
During the period from January 7 to February 7, 2002,
the public's enthusiasm to hand over weapons was quite great.
In Poso and other districts,
hundreds of weapons were reported to be handed over to the police,
even before the amnesty period began.
In March, almost 39,000 weapons were reported to be handed over.
Despite the fact that during the conflict,
only one such weapon was found in March,
hidden under a bridge.
The leaders of both sides supported the handover of weapons,
but wanted the investigation of the house to be done fairly.
On the other hand,
Laskar Jet provided guidance on the rights of the owner of the house,
while the Christian community raised doubts,
considering the previous experience where the weapons were handed over
were used as evidence in the Tibo trial.
Skepticism also arose regarding the official number of weapons handed over,
because there was a mismatch in the reports of each side.
The Malino Declaration managed to lower the level of violence in Poso,
although tensions and sporadic incidents still occurred.
Violence such as burning villages and mass killings began to decrease,
but the threat was still felt,
so the people described the situation as unsafe but protected.
Residents often only send certain family members
to clean or rebuild their homes in Poso,
while others still live in emergency shelters.
Security is still tight,
and the presence of security forces is the main supporter of peace.
A spokesman expressed his concern that without security forces,
the conflict would soon break out again.
That concern was proven,
with tensions rising again when on New Year's Eve,
four churches in Palo were bombed,
including Pantecostal, Adventist, and Protestant churches in Indonesia.
Although these churches are not directly related
to the denomination of the Christian Church in Central Sulawesi,
and the incident took place in Palo, not in Poso,
this incident still aroused concerns.
One of the arrested perpetrators was a Muslim delegation from Malino,
who was found storing bomb material.
This incident raised accusations that the violence
was intended to arouse tension in Palo,
but this effort failed,
even though a small conflict still took place in Poso.
Concerns about the non-neutrality of the security forces also arose,
especially because there were reports of violations
against Muslim civilians by the Brimob and the army.
The incident of violence is often considered a common criminal act
to indicate that the conflict has ended.
Even so, the people still felt the tension,
especially in villages that are prone to terrorist attacks.
In May and June 2002,
reports of Malino's declaration of violence increased,
creating a shift in the violence pattern from an open war
to a secret attack,
such as a bomb and a mysterious shooting.
Yusuf Kala, one of the architects of Malino's declaration,
noted that a major conflict had ended,
but small terrorist groups were still active in sporadic attacks.
The incident of violence continued throughout 2002,
including a bomb attack on a bus that killed and injured civilians,
as well as a mysterious shooting attack on Christians in various villages.
The police often had difficulty identifying the perpetrator,
while the military reported internal terrorism indications
from outside the region.
Rumors of a new attack after the troops were pulled and spread
made the people hesitate to return to their villages in full.
A major violence occurred in early August,
including an attack on the village of Matako,
which caused dozens of houses and churches to be burned,
as well as hundreds of people fleeing to nearby villages.
The condition worsened further with the presence of bomb attacks,
burning and shooting in Christian villages
at the end of August to September.
The police arrested several local leaders
who were accused of being involved in arms smuggling,
but many of the perpetrators did not follow the procedure.
The situation became more complex with the presence of jihadists,
who although officially dispersed in October 2002
after the explosion of the Bali bomb,
still raised concerns about the possibility of their activities underground.
A number of jihadist members chose to remain in Central Sulawesi,
which made it more difficult to maintain stability in the region.
In the end, the continuation of the peace in Poso
was very dependent on strict monitoring
of existing radical groups
and joint efforts from various parties to avoid new provocations.
The people are still living in the shadow of tension
while the reconciliation process
and efforts to enforce the law continue
in the midst of an uncertain situation.
For more information, visit www.ilo.org
