UNDERSTANDING THE 1998 BANYUWANGI ( DUKUN SANTET ) TRAGEDY

Kamar Film
13 followers
81 Video Views·Jan 31, 2025
Throughout 1998 to 1999,
Banyuwangi was plagued by a horrific tragedy.
Dozens of people died, not in open war or conflict,
but due to an unsubstantiated accusation.
Santet, which is unsubstantiated, suddenly turned into an open slaughterhouse.
In 1998, it was indeed the darkest year for the entire Indonesian region.
Because how can a belief that has existed for centuries
end with such a brutal slaughter?
What really happened behind this tragedy?
Who became the victims and who benefited?
On this occasion, we will try to dive deeper
about the tragedy of the Banyuwangi slaughterhouse in Santet
throughout 1998 to 1999.
This is a dark event that raises more questions than answers.
Get ready, because in this video we will reveal the dark side of
the fear, exploitation, black sheep, and power struggle
that shaped the history of Indonesia's black history.
To understand more about the Banyuwangi slaughterhouse in Santet
in 1998 to 1999,
we need to take a step back to see the social and political situation
that was developing in Indonesia at that time.
Indonesia, at the end of the 1990s,
was at the critical point of a multi-dimensional crisis
that involved a huge economic, political, and social crisis.
What happened in Banyuwangi cannot be separated from this huge context.
Hal Hill, in his book entitled The Indonesian Economy,
which was published in 2000, wrote
that 1997 was a very dark year for Indonesia.
A monetary crisis that hit Asian countries,
which began with the fall in the value of the Thai currency exchange,
finally hit Indonesia.
The value of rupiah plummeted dramatically,
inflation rocketed, and many companies went bankrupt.
This situation caused the decision to close large-scale jobs,
job opportunities became scarce,
and poverty increased significantly.
The economy was getting worse,
worsening the social situation in Indonesia.
The people were getting more and more depressed
with rising prices and uncertainty about the future.
People's trust in the government became weaker,
while the situation became more chaotic,
especially in remote areas such as Banyuwangi.
Not only the economic crisis,
Indonesia was also in great political tension.
The new order government led by Soeharto,
which had been in power for more than three decades,
created political stability in an authoritarian way.
However, in the late 1990s,
more and more criticism arose against the regime.
In 1998, major demonstrations took place all over Indonesia,
spurred by the economic crisis that shook the people.
Student groups known as the Reformation Movement
became the front line in demanding Soeharto's resignation.
The atmosphere became hotter,
and in May 1998,
large riots broke out in Jakarta and other cities.
Under such great pressure,
Soeharto finally resigned on May 21, 1998,
after 32 years in power.
However, Soeharto's fall did not end the tension.
After his resignation,
Indonesia entered a transition period full of uncertainty.
The people not only faced a long-term economic crisis,
but also an extraordinary political and social turmoil.
The internal division in the people's bodies became sharper,
and the fear of a dark future began to engulf many people's minds.
In the uncertainty that struck the people,
various ways to seek clarification and protection emerged.
One of the strongest ways in the Javanese community,
including Banyuwangi,
to seek clarification and protection is
by relying on the mystical world
and distrust of black science,
such as Santet and Dukun.
Distrust of Dukun Santet has long been part of people's lives.
Dukun Santet is considered to have a mysterious power
that can affect other people's lives,
whether through healing or the other way around,
causing illness, misfortune, or even death.
When a disaster like the economic crisis comes,
many people begin to look for a cause
from all forms of disasters that afflict them.
And it is not uncommon for Dukun Santet to be a target of violence,
although sometimes without clear evidence.
Banyuwangi, a district located on the eastern tip of Java,
has very unique social and cultural characteristics.
In this area, people's lives are influenced by traditions
and customs that have been passed down.
One of them is a belief in the unseen,
including Santet.
Irwan Zulkarnain in his book entitled
Banyuwangi, History and Culture,
mentioned that the Banyuwangi community,
although divided into several fields,
is still very attached to the tradition and old beliefs.
For them, Dukun is not just a traditional healer,
but can also be a very important figure
in solving various problems,
both physical illness and other problems in life.
However, in a situation full of uncertainty,
like what happened in 1998,
the role of Dukun Santet becomes more vital
when the people feel oppressed
and haunted by fear of mystical powers,
they begin to associate all disasters
with the existence of Dukun Santet.
This excessive disaster creates
a very dangerous social condition.
With the presence of social uncertainty
caused by the economic crisis
and the political tension of Pasca Suarto,
the Banyuwangi community began to be engulfed
in a circle of fear and suspicion.
In such a situation, Dukun Santet
becomes a symbol of everything
that is considered to be the cause
of disasters and difficulties in life.
This is a very important background
to understand why the violence
against Dukun Santet could happen
between 1998 and 1999.
1998 was a year of turmoil.
Around Prabonsuarto,
many terrible events occurred,
from rape, imprisonment,
and relatively far from the capital,
fear of Dukun Santet in Banyuwangi
began to erupt.
The people who were overwhelmed by the worst economic conditions
and personal tragedies
began to look for a black sheep for all their sufferings.
Bert Hoffman,
in one of his journals entitled
The Witch Hunt in Banyuwangi,
Social Tension in the Wake of the 1998 Crisis,
which appeared in the journal
Journal of Southeast Asian Studies in 2001,
tells how the Banyuwangi community
began to search and hunt
for people they considered
to be the perpetrators of Santet.
Without clear evidence, many people
were wrongly targeted by the mass mob.
Not a few were accused of doing Santet
just because of accidents that afflicted others.
The unbased prosecution process
resulted in many innocent victims.
From 1998 to 1999,
the situation in Banyuwangi
was getting worse.
Tommy Ariktonang,
in a report on the violence of Dukun Santet in Banyuwangi,
in the magazine Tempo Edisi 15,
which was published in August 1999,
wrote that
the massacre of Dukun Santet
was not only limited to a single accusation,
but also involved a very brutal violence.
Dukun-Dukun who were accused
as Santet perpetrators were beaten,
burned alive, or killed in a very cruel way.
Tirto,
in one of his reports on this massacre,
pointed out that the massacre of Dukun Santet,
the operation of the Green Dragon,
and the terror to the National Union
gave testimony of one of the victims,
named Untung Hadi.
In the report, Untung Hadi explained
that in addition to killing his father,
the perpetrators also destroyed his house.
And when the atmosphere became tense,
suddenly the hill in the garden was also burned.
In that tense atmosphere,
he did not find a single village apparatus.
And in his statement,
Untung Hadi speculated that the murder
that afflicted his father may have been planned.
The incident reported
happened in the village of Pondok Nongko,
Kabat, Banyuwangi, East Java.
And still in the same district,
but at a different time,
Abdullah became a witness of his brother's massacre.
In the village of Sukujati,
Arifin, his brother, along with his wife and children
were massacred by a group of villagers.
Abdullah said that
his brother, along with his wife and children
were picked up by the mass.
And in his statement,
Abdullah also explained that the mass
that brought his brother's family was not far,
but the villagers as well.
And why did his brother become a victim?
Abdullah explained that it was because his brother,
named Arifin, was accused of having the knowledge of Santet.
These murders did not happen
in a short time.
Those who are considered to be Santet followers
became the target of yesterday's mass that has been provoked
by rumors and growing fear.
The mass that was organized often
came to Santet's houses,
dragged them out and carried out
unimaginable violence.
This action happened almost every month,
creating more and more tension.
Nationally, this incident
was later known as the Santet and Ninja Massacre.
The resonance of the news
on this incident quickly spread
even to the international government.
Some foreign media,
such as The Sydney Morning Herald,
on Saturday, November 7, 1998,
released news about the massacre
under the title of
Indonesian New Wave of Terror.
In addition to what was reported by Australian media,
BBC News Online,
on October 13 and 24, 1998,
also reported this massacre
with two headlines.
The first was titled,
Mock-up Murder Sweet Java,
and the second, Indonesian Ninja War.
The process of this massacre
is very related to the uncertainty
caused by economic and political crises.
When people face extraordinary
they begin to look for mystical explanations
to explain the disaster they are facing.
Santet followers are targeted
because they are considered to have the power
to cause disease or disaster.
Considering hundreds of incidents
of the murder of Santet followers by ninjas,
Afton Ilmu Huda,
the figure of Nadatul Ulama Jember,
said that this may be related
to the psychoculture in the local community.
Afton Ilman said that in the Tapal Kuda area
of Nadatul Ulama in Banyuwangi,
there is indeed an understanding about Santet,
although the perceptions are different.
Regarding Santet's knowledge,
which is close to the life of the Tapal Kuda community,
especially Banyuwangi whose majority
is Osing or Using ethnic,
Hassan Ali, the founder of Banyuwangi culture,
in his interview with Sadiqin
in his dissertation entitled
the murder of Santet followers in Banyuwangi,
a study of collective violence in a
constructivist perspective,
explained that Hassan Ali said
that Santet for the Banyuwangi community is a reality,
there is, and its existence is very believable.
Hassan Ali was also noted in the dissertation
stating that their majority
believes and has become a part
of the unity in the community of Using.
Santet has become the daily language
of the Using community,
how not, everything related to everyday life
that is considered important,
most of the Using community
will always come smart people
just to consult.
Hassan Ali added that the social system
that was built like that,
it became a fuel that ignited various massacres.
Hassan Ali also stated in this matter
that the Banyuwangi community
attacks something that has been alive in its history.
Similar to what Hassan Ali said,
James Brown who studied this massacre
and was later published with the title
Perdukunan, Paranormal,
dan Peristiwa Pembantaian, Terror Maut
di Banyuwangi 1998, explained
that the Banyuwangi bloodbath
in 1998 was actually
a recurring event that can be called
common, because it is related to the
social condition of the Using community
which is close to the culture of Santet in everyday life.
The assumption stated by James Brown
is also supported by Seyfour Rahim's note
in his book entitled
Merah Darah Santet di Banyuwangi
which states that the massacres
against the Santet community in Banyuwangi
happened 7 years ago in 1991
and 2 years ago
in 1996
and in his explanation,
Seyfour Rahim added that
when the first massacre happened
against some people who were introduced as Santet
people in Banyuwangi
were confused.
But apart from that, to anticipate
a similar incident on February 6
in 1998,
Purno Mesidik as the Banyuwangi regent
issued instructions to the entire
community to track down the paranormal,
support traditional medicine
and magicians. All of this was done
to facilitate the handling if
a similar incident happened. However,
the registration made by the village heads
on the community's instructions as the regent's order
then leaked and turned into
a murder target registration.
Because of the fact that they have been tracked down,
the murder case turned out to still happen.
Since February to September
1998, the number of victims
of the people's murder in the registration increased
as if there was a leak of
data secrets. On a larger scale,
the Banyuwangi incident in 1998
is similar to the incident in Tasikmalaya
and Situ Bondo in the election
in 1997 or
better known as Operation
Naga Hijau. News about
the perpetrator of Santet's massacre in Banyuwangi
also spread widely.
There was an issue that the massacre was
committed by people wearing black
uniforms similar to ninjas. Abdul Manan,
Imam Sumaat Majah, and
Feven Espewardana in a book titled
Geger Santet Banyuwangi
said that the ninjas
carried a kind of handi-tolki
or hate to communicate and be able
to move quickly, trained and
systematic. Initially, in this massacre
, the target of the murder was
people accused of having black knowledge
for bad purposes, which
was simplified as Santet's supporters
by locals and some communities.
However, when the number of innocent people
who were killed continued to increase,
the target spread. Not only
people accused of being Santet's supporters,
people who are called religious teachers,
monks, mental disorders,
as well as ordinary civilians
were also brutally killed. The murder of
the monks, nuns, and religious teachers
is suspected to be strongly related to
political motives. The terror of massacres
initiated in Banyuwangi also quickly
spread to Jember, Bondowoso,
Sitobondo, Pasuruan, Malang,
to Madura Island. Fear,
tension, panic, and suspicion
that spread in the community
gave birth to various terrifying issues.
Thus, various media reports at that time
the tragedy of the violence against Dukun Santet
not only left trauma to the victims
and their families, but also
damaged the social structure in Banyuwangi.
The results of the research on the subject
of Ham and the politics of Pascawerdebaru,
the construction of the Ham violation
in the case of the slaughter of Dukun Santet in the
Banyuwangi incident in 1998
organized by Rai Permata Juang,
Teddy R. Fiantono, and
Muhammad Ali Azhar, said that the
sadistic event caused deep trauma
for the people of Banyuwangi.
The people who previously lived in peace
now suspect each other.
Not only that, the tragedy of the slaughter of Dukun Santet
also had a bad effect on
the image of the city of Banyuwangi, which
received a biased perception as the city of Santet.
As a result, the descendants or
the families of the victims of the slaughter extended the problem
because they did not want to be considered as the
inheritors of Santet's knowledge.
In addition, there are many religious figures and
local leaders who strongly condemn the actions of the violence.
According to them, the violence against
Dukun Santet undermines the values of local
values and customs that have long
maintained the harmony of the people of Banyuwangi.
After several months of widespread violence,
the government of Banyuwangi
began to take action to
overcome this situation.
Security operations were carried out to
intimidate the perpetrators of the violence and
to calm the people who were
frightened. The police began to arrest
a number of people involved
in the massacre. And the government
also made an approach by
socializing the people about
the importance of addressing social issues
in a more rational way and avoiding
violence. However, the fear that
has continued to spread took a long time
to recover. TNI agent Joko
Subroto, who was then in office as
Pangdam 5 Brawijaya, stated
that the murders that took place in January
until July 1998
were probably triggered by
hatred for Dukun Santet.
However, agent Joko Subroto also did not
expect that the murders that took place in
Banyuwangi in August until
September 1998 had been
used by other elements.
The current national political situation
became one of the factors
of terror against the people of Banyuwangi.
At that time, demonstrations began
to push back Suwarto after
he was re-elected as president
and in the general session of MPR
in March 1998,
Banyuwangi, which is known as
Tapal Udana Datul Ulama or NU,
was suspected of being deliberately chosen
as a target of violence with political motives
because it also targets the Santri community.
The incident of Dukun Santet's massacre
in Banyuwangi is often referred to as
Operation Green Dragon.
After the violence
that took place, Banyuwangi faced
a very big social impact.
When the distrust of Dukun Santet grew
in Banyuwangi, the people split
into two camps, those who believed
and those who didn't.
This caused tension that broke the relationship
between the people, creating suspicion
and fear. The trust that
was once part of the local community
now transformed into a weapon
used to attack each other.
One of the biggest impacts was
the split of social ties in the community.
A community that used to live in harmony
and harmony now began to be covered
by a deep sense of suspicion.
People who used to live close to each other
suddenly became estranged from each other.
This happened because they accused each other
and suspected that Santet was behind
the disaster that struck them.
Banyuwangi in a short time
turned into a place full of tension.
Everywhere, people began
to avoid each other and tried to keep a distance.
Fear of accusation and judgment
became part of everyday life,
even for those
who had nothing to do with the world
of Dukun Santet.
For the victims' families who were killed
or executed, the psychological impact
was much deeper.
Not only did they lose the people they loved,
but they also felt haunted by the social stigma
attached to them.
Regardless of whether the victim
was really a Dukun Santet or not,
the bad stigma due to the fear of the community
made many families suffer for a long time.
This stigma, which grew
after the violent incident,
not only made the victims' families feel
punished for no reason, but also
worsened their mental condition.
They felt ashamed, scared,
and isolated in a divided community.
And when the political tension
at the national level
was not completely normal,
some suspects of murder on the ground,
especially in Banyuwangi, were tried
and sentenced to death.
On October 7, 1998,
the East Java Police announced
the investigation results of the number of victims
of the Dukun Santet massacre in Banyuwangi.
Based on police data,
there were 85 victims,
3 seriously injured, and 7 lightly injured.
The police also reported
that they had evacuated 227 people
suspected of being Dukun Santet.
Meanwhile, the regional government
or the Banyuwangi Municipal Government
reported that there were 115 victims
of the Dukun Santet massacre.
The NU also formed a team of fact-finding
or TPF to investigate
the number of victims of this bloody tragedy.
The result, the NU reported,
was a chain of murders
that began in Banyuwangi,
then spread to 10 other regions.
According to the NU's data,
there were 163 victims
who died from five horse racing areas
in East Java,
namely Banyuwangi, Pasuruan,
Pamekasan, Sumanap, and Probolinggo.
Investigations were also carried out
by the Surabaya Law Enforcement Agency
which found 157 victims
and 10 seriously injured
in the tragedy of the Banyuwangi Dukun Santet massacre.
Until now,
it is still unknown
who was the perpetrator
of the Banyuwangi Dukun Santet massacre.
The police only arrested
80 people who were suspected of being the perpetrators.
They were intellectuals,
fundraisers, and executors
in the Banyuwangi massacre in 1998.
However, the efforts of the law did not reach
the people's curiosity,
namely who was the main actor behind it.
Voices demanded that the motive
behind this chain of murders
be investigated,
but always under the control
of politicians and law enforcers.
Faced with that unanswered question,
it was only in 2015
that the National Commission for Human Rights
or Komnas HAM,
in accordance with the Law No. 26 of 2000
on the HAM trial,
began to investigate this violent case.
The Ad Hoc Komnas HAM team,
in the conclusion of their investigation,
recorded the number of victims of the massacre
reaching 309 people,
194 in Banyuwangi,
108 in Jember, and 7 in Malang.
In addition, Komnas HAM,
through its Ad Hoc team, stated that
there was a serious violation of the HAM
in the Dukun Santet massacre in Banyuwangi,
Jember, and Malang throughout 1998
until 1999.
In addition, there were also suspected actors
who carried out propaganda,
an attempt to mobilize the masses to kill.
In conclusion, Komnas HAM also found
a pattern at the beginning of the precondition,
as well as a list of names,
so as to escalate and impress the public.
BK Ulung Habsara,
ex-chairman of Ad Hoc in this case investigation,
in his press conference on Tuesday,
on January 15, 2019,
stated that
Komnas HAM found that the murder
was carried out systematically.
The murderer always used the same
and repeated actions,
the perpetrator identified the victim,
then the mass came to the victim and harassed
and damaged the victim's house.
In the end, the Ad Hoc Komnas HAM team concluded
that this case was perpetrated by an intellectual actor.
The existence of an intellectual actor
is due to the emergence of a list of names
of people identified as Dukun Santet
by the Banyuwangi regent at that time,
the police colonel Hatipurnomo Sidik.
The list of names was issued
in the form of a radiogram
on February 6, 1998,
which was shown to the government apparatus,
from the district to the village head.
The radiogram was claimed to protect
and secure those people
from the threat of being killed.
Unfortunately, the opposite happened.
When the radiogram was issued,
there was a homicide
against some of the names listed in the list.
In addition to the radiogram,
the Komnas HAM investigation also revealed
that the homicide in several cities
in East Java had a pattern
that had the same element.
At the beginning of the precondition,
it was the spread of the Sarak issue,
especially the ethnic Tionghoa.
Another pattern that was found was
that each case always involved
non-local residents.
In addition, there were also similar signs
such as arrows, torches, and forced electricity.
The torches at people's houses
were signs of a homicide target.
In addition, there were signs
of torches and arrows at people's houses
that became targets.
The same element that was found
was also related to the issue of foreigners
who were suspected of entering the village.
In this case, the Komnas HAM found
ground facts that the appearance
of people who were not from the scene
that was seen from the language
before the murder took place.
And based on these facts,
BK Ulung Habsara concluded that
there was sufficient evidence
that can categorize this case
as a crime against humanity.
This is contrary to Article 7 of the BJO
and Article 9 of the Law No. 26 of 2000
about the Komnas HAM trial.
What was said by BK Ulung Habsara
in the case of the Dukun Santet case
was actually discussed earlier
by the Ulama Investigation Team
of the Banyuwangi branch.
He announced the results of his investigation
and concluded that there was a suspicion
of involvement of the security apparatus.
Even Syed Akhil Syiroj,
who was then the head of the PBNU
in one of the articles
published in NU Online in 2007,
stated that from the results of the investigation,
the Ulama Investigation Team
concluded that the case was designed,
planned, and funded.
Therefore, the murder case in Banyuwangi
could not be an ordinary criminal.
Unlike what was found
by the Ad-Hoc Komnas HAM and PBNU team,
Tempob, who conducted their own investigation,
found that this murder
was actually committed by the locals.
They committed the murder
out of revenge and anger
which then mixed up
and became a kind of blasphemy to the Sumat.
However, apart from that difference,
the three have the same red thread
that this murder will not spread
and more victims will be killed
if the security apparatus handles this case faster.
In their findings,
Komnas HAM concluded that the apparatus
already knew the situation and even received a report,
but not very late
when taking action.
Similar to the findings of Komnas HAM,
Tempob's investigation also stated that the apparatus
was slow, even deliberately not intervening
in the assault committed by the locals.
According to several sources that were able to get Tempob,
the neglect of this apparatus
was done because the apparatus was afraid
to be a target of mass murder,
which was not a small number.
According to Tempob,
Banyuwangi was surrounded by Isu Dukun Santet Jilid 2.
There was a statement
of one of the officers who said,
maybe the police headquarters was burned.
Not only when it happened,
the negligence of the apparatus against the Dukun Santet
assailant who happened in Banyuwangi
and its surroundings was delayed
until the case investigation process.
According to the head of the Komnas HAM investigation team,
Muhammad Nuh Khairon,
the apparatus did not give any explanation
about this assault case.
The local police in East Java
even explicitly stated
that this case should not be covered
because the incident had been going on
for a long time and would cause
long-term injuries.
On the other hand, the Komnas HAM also found
the same thing when Kodam 5 Brawijaya came.
When asked for clarification,
Kodam did not open its mouth
on the basis of old data,
such as the Dukun Santet assailant case
in 1998-1999,
documents that were likely
to be destroyed or destroyed.
The statement of Kodam Brawijaya
is certainly disappointing.
This is because, according to Nuh Khairon,
the state institution should have the right
even though it contains old data.
Komnas HAM, which is also a state institution,
should be able to access the data.
The obstacles in revealing this fact
that did not cause the tragedy
of the Dukun Santet assailant
never got a clear point.
Especially in 2018,
Komnas HAM submitted the results of this investigation
to Kejaksaan Agung,
but so far there has been no further action.
The result is clear,
it has an impact on the victim's family.
In an interview with BBC Indonesia
in 2023,
some victims of the Dukun Santet assailant
still have to live with the shadow of social stigma.
In addition, the government itself
so far only admitted the Dukun Santet assailant
in Banyuwangi in 1998-1999
as 12 serious violations
in Indonesia.
But as said by Daniel Awigra,
from the Executive Director
of the Indonesian Human Rights Working Group,
in an interview with Magdalene
in January 2023,
that the matter was considered
only a gimmick or mere rhetoric.
Daniel Awigra said that the government
should use its authority
to directly cover up the serious violations
clearly.
Not to reaffirm the findings and reports
that have been done by Komnas HAM.
And as you can guess,
the intellectual figure of the Dukun Santet assailant
who was arrested in Banyuwangi
throughout February 1998
until October 1999
has not yet been legally proven.
This incident is still
covered up and
will not be solved
justly.
