understand the story of Talang Sari in 1989

Kamar Film
13 pengikut
76 Tayangan video·23 Jan 2025
In February 1989, a bloody incident took place in Talangsari, East Lampung.
This incident took place in the middle of the peak of a new order with stability jargon
and a development that is heard to be proud.
However, the stability jargon associated with the government's single narrative
about security and order,
immediately turned into irony
when the tragedy in Talangsari showed the public
that the law could not even be able to face the repressive powers of the country,
which clearly violated human rights.
This incident became a black mark that is difficult to be erased in Indonesian history.
And this time, we will remember again the Talangsari incident
to find out what really happened
or answer important questions about how a country that claims to be based on law
actually ignores the law itself in order to defend power.
The incident that took place in Talangsari did not happen for no reason.
In fact, this is the pinnacle of a problem that originated long before the tragedy.
After the September 30, 1965 movement or G30 SPKI,
the Suwarto government under the New Order regime
tried to build political and economic stability.
One of the important steps taken was by implementing the Pancasila Single Narrative.
The policy requires all social and political organizations to base on Pancasila.
This means they have to remove other ideologies.
The official purpose is to create unity and national unity.
However, in practice, this policy is used to control
and pressure groups that are considered critical of the government
to socialize and plant the Pancasila Single Narrative.
The government also launched the Pempat program or Pancasila Reconstruction and Practicing Program.
This program is an indoctrination of Pancasila
that can be implemented simultaneously on various layers of society,
from schools, government institutions, to community organizations.
Through this Pempat program, the government tries to plant
the interpretation of Pancasila Single Narrative
in accordance with the interests of the New Order regime.
However, the Pancasila Single Narrative policy and Pempat program
caused quite a strong reaction from some Islamic groups
because they feel that this policy limits freedom of religion and expression
and threatens the identity of Islam.
Some Islamic groups see Pempat as an effort to secularize
or separate the affairs of religion and country
which is forced by the government.
This feeling then triggers various protests and opposition
which in some cases end in a conflict with the security apparatus.
The well-known conflict is the Tanjung Priuk 1984 tragedy,
Barisan Juba Putih in Aceh,
and including the Warsidi group in Lampung,
which led to the Talangsari tragedy.
The Warsidi group is one of the Islamic groups
who feel frustrated with the government's policy.
They have their own views on Islamic teachings
and reject the implementation of the Pancasila Single Narrative
which is considered contrary to their beliefs.
This group then established a community in Talangsari
and carried out religious activities that are different from the main stream.
The New Order government, with a repressive security approach,
suspected that the activities of the Warsidi group
as a subversive movement that threatens stability,
negative stigma and false accusations were then attached to this group.
Warsidi himself is not an ordinary person.
He has an important background to understand the context of his role in Talangsari.
Although detailed information about his past is limited,
but it is known that Warsidi is a former soldier
or at least has a close relationship with the military environment.
This experience is likely to affect his perspective
and how he leads his community.
Community establishment in Talangsari is also not a sudden thing.
Warsidi has long known the area of Talangsari,
a village in Lampung, and even became the owner of the land there.
Along with Nur Hidayat and several other followers
who initially numbered less than 10 people,
he then formed a community that then grew
and attracted more followers.
In Talangsari, Warsidi was elevated as an imam
and led by Nur Hidayat and his friends.
This elevation is based on several factors, such as seniority.
Warsidi is indeed considered an older figure
and experienced compared to other community members.
In addition, his status as the owner of the land gives recognition
of Wawenang and his own power in the eyes of community members.
Warsidi is also suspected to have charisma and strong leadership skills
so that he is able to move and influence his followers.
From here, with Warsidi's status as an imam and community leader,
Warsidi eventually played an important role
in regulating the life of the Talangsari community.
He gave religious teachings, led worship activities,
and made important decisions about the community.
Where the community built by Warsidi has a different view
and understanding of religion from the mainstream Islamic groups.
They tend to be exclusive and have a critical view
of the new government,
especially regarding the policy of the Pancasila Single Foundation
and the Pempat program created by Soeharto.
This difference of opinion is one of the factors
that triggers tension between the Warsidi group and the government.
Warsidi, who was then accused of being subversive with his group,
made him the main target of the security apparatus
because he was considered a threat to the stability of the country.
The direct trigger of the series of events that ended the Talangsari tragedy
was a report from the head of Duku Karangsari on February 1, 1989.
He sent a letter to Commander Kramil or Den Ramil Wejepara,
Captain Sutiman, who provided information
about suspicious activities in his area.
The activities included were religious group activities
led by Warsidi, who planted themselves,
Commander Mujahidin Fisabilillah,
and located in the village of Raja Basalama,
Wejepara district, which was then part of Lampung Tengah.
This report indicated the beginning of an investigation process
and the gathering of information by the security apparatus.
On February 5, 1989,
there was a kidnapping of five people from the Warsidi group
who were doing a round in Post Kambling.
This kidnapping showed an increase in the actions of the security apparatus
against the Warsidi group.
This action caused fear and anxiety among community members
and worsened the relationship between the Warsidi group and the apparatus.
Then, the report continued on February 1,
Finally, on February 6, 1989,
the Board of Directors of the district or Muspika Wejepara held a meeting.
Muspika is a coordination forum between government agencies
at the district level consisting of the district,
Den Ramil, Kapolsek, and other elements of the government.
The meeting was led by Captain Sutiman as Den Ramil Wejepara.
In the meeting, it was decided to ask for clarification to the Warsidi
and its followers regarding their activities.
This decision showed that the local government
began to consider the seriousness of the presence
and activities of the Warsidi group.
On the same day, on February 6,
a large group consisting of about 20 people left
from the office of the district of Wejepara to the Anwar residence complex.
The Warsidi group had gathered.
This group was led by Mayor Sinaga,
Chief of Staff Kodi Melampung Kengah,
which showed the involvement of higher command elements.
In addition to Mayor Sinaga and Captain Sutiman,
this group also consists of Chief of Staff Julkifli Malik,
Kapolsek Wejepara Letu Poldul Badar,
Head of the Old Kingdoms Amir Puspa Mega,
as well as a number of members of Koramil and Hansip.
Although the group that found the Warsidi
involved elements of the civil government and security apparatus,
but the original plan was that they wanted to solve the problem
by talking about it first
and finding out the actual activities of the Warsidi group.
But suddenly at the location,
some sources said that there was a misunderstanding
between the two sides,
so that there was a clash
between the Muspica group and the Warsidi group.
In a source, it is said that the arrival of the Muspica group
was greeted with an arrow attack
and the opponent used a hammer from the Warsidi group.
In fact, what actually happened
was the Muspica group led by Captain Sutiman
shot the Talangsari people,
until the bullets ran out and the people were forced to fight.
The physical clash could not be avoided anymore.
In the clash incident,
Captain Sutiman finally died,
which immediately changed the situation to be more terrible.
Attempts to have a dialogue could not be done,
and this conflict immediately became a much bigger armed conflict
and perhaps will never be expected
by the people involved in it.
The death of Dunda Milweje, Captain Sutiman's men,
clearly triggered a strong reaction from the security apparatus
who did not accept their commander was killed in the clash.
This event was the justification
to carry out a much larger military operation
to capture and capture the Warsidi group in Talangsari.
The commander of the military resort or Korem-043 Garuda Hitam Lampung reacted
and saw Captain Sutiman's death as a direct attack
on the state apparatus and considered a threat to stability.
In addition, Captain Sutiman's death also provoked anger from his members
and sparked a desire to avenge.
At that time, the commander of Korem or Danrem-043 Garuda Hitam Lampung
who as the highest leader in the region
has a full responsibility for handling the situation in Talangsari.
The death of Captain Sutiman under his command demanded a firm action.
Colonel Hendro Priyono then ordered a military operation
to take over the Warsidi group.
Preparations for the military operation were done quickly.
In contrast, on February 7, 1989,
at 4 o'clock in the morning,
an attack under the command of Korem Garuda Hitam-043 was carried out.
Combined troops consisting of 3 army platoons
or about 90 to 150 personnel
and about 40 BRIMOP members from special police units
moved to Cihideng,
which is the center of the Warsidi group activities in Talangsari.
The large number of personnel shows that this operation
is no longer just a capture effort,
but has become a military operation on a larger scale.
The invasion of Cihideng was carried out with full force.
Combined troops stormed and invaded the complex
where the Warsidi group settled,
where the attack was directed at the Warsidi training base
which is located in the outskirts of Cihideng, Dusun, Talangsari.
During the attack,
the base or Warsidi followers who came from various places
were preparing to conduct the Akbar training in the morning.
With a horse-drawn carriage position,
the soldiers then fired in a row
and burned the building of the building
which is said to contain hundreds of jama'ah
consisting of babies, children, mothers
who are mostly in pregnancy, teenagers and parents.
Meanwhile, outside this burned building,
there was also a fierce battle between security forces
and members of the Warsidi group.
Given the very balanced difference in strength,
the resistance of the Warsidi group did not last long.
By dawn, the situation in Cihideng had been successfully controlled by ABRI.
After the final battle,
many casualties were found by the Warsidi group
and even civilians who were in the location.
The number of casualties is still a debate until now
with a variation of tens to hundreds of people.
According to the Solidarity Committee,
students from Lampung or Semalam
who participated in the investigation and advocacy for the victims,
at least 246 civilians were killed in the battle.
This number is one of the highest compared to other sources.
Meanwhile, the Committee for the Missing and Victims of Violence or Contrast
provided a report from the Pro Justicia investigation.
This was done by the latest Comnasam in 2006.
It was said that 130 people were killed in this battle.
Then, there was forced deportation of 77 people,
the violation of the freedom of 53 people,
torture of 46 people
and persecution of at least 229 people.
Meanwhile, if we refer to the book entitled Talang Sari 1989,
the testimony of the victims of the Ham Lampung violation
which was published by the Perse Study Institute and Sijado
mentioned that the number of victims reached 300 people,
which is one of the highest estimates so far.
The difference in the estimated number of victims
is actually quite reasonable.
Because after the Bentrokan conflict,
access to the location of the incident and information about the victims
is very limited,
making it difficult to identify and identify the victims.
Moreover, the situation is still very tense
and there is a trauma faced by the people
making the parties and institutions difficult to get
let alone gathering accurate information on the ground.
It is also suspected that certain parties are trying to make the information
become a mess and manipulate the data
to minimize the number of victims
to reduce the negative impact of this bloody incident.
In addition to the victims,
the data provided by Comnasam shows that there are
hundreds of orphans and heirs
who were arrested after the military operation was successful.
They are detained and interrogated.
Even some of them are suspected of being tortured.
Even worse, the victims and survivors of the Talangsari incident
are still alive in a negative stigma.
They are described as a movement to disrupt security or GPK.
This stigma is used by the new government
to legalize repressive actions against the Warsidi group.
The label as GPK
aims to isolate this group from the public
In addition, they are also labeled as an anti-government community
where this stigma links the Warsidi group
with the opposition to the new government.
This strengthens the narrative that government actions
are needed to maintain stability.
The last is the label of the PKI Islam
which is a very heavy stigma
because it links the Warsidi group with the PKI
which is the main political enemy of the new order.
This stigma is again used to isolate the Warsidi group
and legalize repressive actions.
These stigmas have a very bad impact
on survivors and families
because they experience discrimination, social isolation
and difficulties in accessing justice and recovery.
This stigma also hinders the process of data
and the resolution of the Talangsari case.
The Talangsari incident was called by Komnas HAM
as a heavy criminal offense in the past.
Law No. 26 of the year 2000 on the justice of HAM
regulates two types of heavy criminal offenses
which are genocidal crimes and crimes against humanity.
In the context of Talangsari,
its focus is on crimes against humanity.
Article 9 in Law No. 25 of the year 2000
defines crimes against humanity
as one of the acts committed by the government
or the commandos of the military
or non-military as part
of a widespread or systematic attack
against civilians.
The Talangsari incident meets all the criteria
of a criminal offense in the law
because this military operation was carried out
by the order or command of Dendrem-043 Garuda Hitam,
Colonel A.M. Hendro Priyono
which involves hundreds of personnel
and has a wide impact on civilians as well.
This attack was clearly planned
and organized well
so it was very systematic.
It was not a sporadic or incidental action
so there is an indication that the military operation
of Talangsari was indeed part of the plan
and the government of the winning party,
the government,
who wanted to do a hand washing action
in this incident
finally tried to seek justice
for their actions
by attaching negative stigma
to the Warsidi group
so many of them went away
which made it difficult for the victims
to access assistance and justice.
Meanwhile, the government got justice
for the repressive actions that were carried out.
In 2001,
more than 10 years after the Talangsari incident
and a few years after the collapse of the new order regime,
the victims of Talangsari
began to voice their demands for justice.
One of their main demands
was the formation of the Human Rights Abuse Investigation Commission
or KPP HAM,
an institution that was part
of the Law No. 39 of 1999
on human rights.
The law gave the opportunity
to Komnas HAM
to conduct an investigation
on heavy abuse charges.
This incident showed that the victims
and their families did not give up
in seeking justice
and acknowledgement of the suffering they experienced.
Komnas HAM also considered the incident
by taking concrete steps.
Based on the recommendation of the Paripurna Council
on February 23, 2001,
an internal investigation team was formed
based on Law No. 39 of 1999.
This team consisted of several members of Komnas HAM
with expertise in the relevant field
with the Talangsari case.
They are Eni Suprapto
who focused on the violence case,
Sam Sudin who focused on human rights,
Rusu Yati Surya Saputra
who focused on women's issues,
and finally Muhammad Farid
who focused on children's issues.
The formation of this team indicates
the beginning of a formal investigation process
by Komnas HAM
on the Talangsari incident.
The investigation team began working
from the end of March to the beginning of April 2005.
This investigation process includes data collection,
interviews with victims and witnesses,
as well as the study of relevant documents.
The next important step
is for the Komnas HAM team
to come to the field in June 2005.
This field visit is intended to collect
direct information from the location of the incident
and meet with the victims and the local community.
After carrying out an in-depth investigation,
Komnas HAM found strong evidence
indicating the occurrence of a heavy weapon violation
in the tragedy that took place in Talangsari.
This discovery is the basis for Komnas HAM
to determine the Talangsari tragedy
as a heavy weapon violation.
In fact, there are still many obstacles
in the investigation carried out by the investigation team
and Komnas HAM.
One of their main challenges
is the division among the victims.
This division is mainly caused by
the peace agreement effort
carried out by some of the victims
with AM Hendro Priyono since 1999.
It is rumored that some of Jamah Warsidi's ex-colleagues
chose to make a peace agreement
for various reasons.
Starting from economic pressure,
hope for help,
to possibly intimidation
so that they are afraid.
This peace agreement then created
a division among the victims
where those who chose to make a peace agreement
with Hendro Priyono
tend not to support Komnas HAM's efforts
to reveal the truth
and enforce the law through the HAM trial mechanism.
This makes it difficult for the support
and solidarity among the victims
to demand justice.
Because Jamah Warsidi's ex-colleagues
who have made a peace agreement with Hendro Priyono
are actively blocking other victims' efforts
to seek justice
by revealing the truth and the HAM trial.
Their efforts to block
are like refusing to give testimony
to Komnas HAM's investigation team
or in the trial process.
Then they also spread a narrative
claiming that it is important to reveal the truth
and even bad-mouth the efforts to enforce the law.
Finally, there is a suspicion
that they are also intimidating other victims
who are still struggling to seek justice.
It doesn't stop there
that Komnas HAM faces a lot of obstacles.
In addition to breaking up among the victims,
the HAM trial is also carried out
through a sermon
held by people close to Hendro Priyono in Talang Sari.
This sermon systematically
spreads messages
aimed at preventing the revelation of the Talang Sari case.
Usually, the speaker in the sermon
always issues a ban
to reveal the Talang Sari case in 1989
by convincing the public
that the revelation of this case
will only cause a breakup
and disturb stability.
In addition, the speaker also develops an alternative narrative
that allows the actions of the security apparatus
and ignites the Warsidi group
as was done previously
after the Talang Sari incident.
They also try to form a negative public opinion
about the effort to seek justice
so that the public does not want to support them.
In the midst of this obstacle,
Komnas HAM continues to carry out its investigation as much as possible
and issued a report stating
that there was a heavy HAM violation
in the Talang Sari tragedy.
The peace declaration
is not legally appropriate
as a basis
to remove the heavy HAM violation.
According to the legal mechanism,
the report of the investigation
is submitted to the Supreme Court.
This submission should be the first step
in the next legal process,
that is, the investigation and appeal in court.
It should also be noted that in this submitted report,
the Talang Sari case
is not the only case
submitted to the Supreme Court.
There are other cases of heavy HAM violations in the past
which were also submitted together,
namely the case of mass shooting
at the G-30 SPKI event
in 1965-1966,
the case of the mysterious shooting
at Petrus in 1982-1985
which became an operation
to shoot people
who were suspected of treason,
the case of forced loss of people
since 1997-1998
which lost pro-democracy activists
before and after
the fall of the new order,
the case of May 1998,
the case of Ham Tri Sakti violation,
Semanggi 1 and Semanggi 2
against students and demonstrations
demanding reform,
and the last is the Waseor or Wamena event
that took place in 2003.
This combination can be interpreted
to press the Supreme Court
to handle the cases of heavy HAM violations
as a whole
which is getting more and more
unsolved.
But unfortunately,
the hope for solving the cases
must be extinguished after the Supreme Court
rejected all documents submitted by the Supreme Court,
including the former Talang Sari case.
The reason for the rejection is
formal evidence in the form of administrative completeness
or procedures that must be fulfilled
in the document of investigation
as well as material evidence in the form of concrete evidence
that supports the occurrence of heavy HAM violations
such as witness statements, documents,
and forensic evidence.
The rejection by the Supreme Court
has clearly caused a lot of controversy
and criticism from various parties,
especially from the activists of HAM,
victims, and their families.
They say that the reason given by the Supreme Court
is not basic and is only an effort
to pass the time
and avoid solving the cases of heavy HAM violations.
The criticism is bravely given
because the investigation carried out by the Supreme Court
is considered comprehensive,
detailed, and meets standards,
so that the lack of material evidence is considered
truly irrelevant and difficult to be accepted
by victims and activists of HAM.
This criticism also strengthens the suspicion
that there are deliberate elements
from certain parties in the Supreme Court
to prevent the solution of heavy HAM violations
because it involves
important figures in the past.
This rejection is also considered
as an insincerity of the government
in solving heavy HAM violations
and upholding justice for the victims.
After this rejection,
many parties are still advocating justice
for the Talang Sari case.
On February 20, 2019,
a peace declaration on the Talang Sari incident
was started by a joint team handling
HAM violations from the Ministry of
Political Affairs Coordinating Board,
Law and Security or Kemenkopol Hukam.
This declaration was held in the Talang Sari village
of W.J. Prasubing Putra 3,
Raja Basa Lama Village, Labuhan Ratu,
Lampung Timur.
This event was attended by a number of officials
and local community leaders
as a sign of support from the local government
for the initiative of the peace declaration.
However, the content of the peace declaration
then became controversial
because some points were considered problematic.
The main point that became an issue was
to prevent the victims of the Talang Sari
from disclosing the case.
The reason is because the case was considered
to have been solved by the government
by providing compensation in the form of road development
and public facilities in Lampung.
This is the point that aroused strong rejection
from the victims and the civil society.
They believe that the development of public facilities
is a state duty
to all citizens of the country,
not a special compensation
for victims of heavy HAM violations.
In other words, they feel that the government
is trying to overcome this heavy HAM violation
with an infrastructure development project
that should be a right of the people.
In addition, this peace declaration
was also carried out without involving
the victims at all in the process.
The victims and their families
were not involved in the formulation,
discussion, or signing of the declaration.
This shows that the declaration
is one-sided
and does not reflect the aspirations
and interests of the victims.
Without this involvement,
the government has actually violated
the principle of victim participation
in the process of solving the heavy HAM violation.
Therefore, this peace declaration
then received strong rejection
from the victims and the civil society
who said that the declaration
did not solve the root of the heavy HAM problem
that occurred in Talangsari.
The declaration only focuses on physical development
without touching the aspect of justice,
expression of truth, especially
reparation for the victims.
The victims and the civil society also continue
to insist that the development of public facilities
is a right of all citizens of the country
and not a compensation
for victims of heavy HAM violations.
The compensation that should be given
is a more comprehensive amendment
such as psychological recovery,
rehabilitation, and guarantee
that the incident will not happen again.
The victims and the civil society also
criticized this declaration process
which is not participatory and not transparent
because it does not involve
the parties involved.
After this peace declaration,
the victims who were included in the
Talangsari Lampung
or PK2PTL
even harder to seek justice.
They did this struggle
with the assistance and support
of two non-governmental organizations
in the field of human rights,
namely Kontras and Amnesty International Indonesia.
This cooperation strengthens
advocacy efforts and expands
the range of information related to the Talangsari case.
PK2PTL,
with the assistance of Kontras and Amnesty
International Indonesia,
decided to take legal action
by reporting the peace declaration of Talangsari
to the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia
or ORI.
The report was based
on the suspicion of mismanagement
in the process of making and
implementing the peace declaration.
Mismanagement here can be in the form of
legal action, violating the constitution,
violation of the constitution, and other actions
that are contrary to the basic
government principles.
After conducting an investigation and investigation
on the report submitted, then
on December 13, 2019,
the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia
stated that the Talangsari peace declaration
was indeed mismanaged.
This finding strengthens the arguments of the victims
and civilians that the declaration
is illegal and cannot be
used as a basis to stop
the effort to reveal the truth and
enforce justice in the Talangsari case.
The decision of the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia
can also be interpreted as a cancellation
or withdrawal of the peace declaration
because it has been proven that there is
mismanagement in the process.
This decision also strengthens the victims'
process in fighting for their rights,
including the right to justice,
truth, and reconciliation.
In addition, the decision of the Ombudsman of the Republic of Indonesia
should also push the legal process
which actually continues to this day.
The legal process to reveal
the truth and enforcement of the Talangsari case
through the mechanism of the HAM trial.
With the statement of the Ombudsman
of the Republic of Indonesia,
the struggle of the victims of Talangsari
will continue until they get
the rights they deserve.
The current government is more focused
on resolving the Talangsari case
through a non-judicial mechanism,
that is, with a recovery program for
the victims and their families.
A resolution that is not as consistent
with the rights that should be obtained
by the victims and their families.
The Indonesian International Commission
even issued a public statement
in 2017 that strengthened their concerns
because the victims and their families
should get justice,
justice, and recovery
for the HAM violations they suffered.
The government was also considered
unsuccessful in ensuring that the perpetrators
were asked for accountability for their actions,
showing that the problem of impunity
in Indonesia is strong.
Non-judicial programs carried out by the government
are only an attempt to fulfill basic rights
related to civil, economic, social, and cultural rights,
both individually and communally.
This program is known to be
circulated through related ministries
or institutions, such as the BUMN,
the government of the province of Lampung,
and the regency of East Lampung.
So far, the process of
receiving victims in Lampung is still underway
to ensure that assistance and
precise investigation are carried out in the
non-judicial program coordinated by
Kemen Kopol Hukam.
Several victims have also received assistance
from similar programs in 2020.
On the other hand, the HAM Community
remains committed to upholding the rights of
the victims of heavy HAM violations,
including the victims of the Talangsari tragedy,
one of which is to verify the request
of the victims and their families.
Unfortunately, the victims who are called
in the PK2PTL are still difficult
to get their justice,
although they receive a lot of support
from civil society and organizations
such as CONTRAST and Amnesty International Indonesia.
The legal process related to the Talangsari
case has not yet shown significant
development, and often
only ends up in discussions
because they still have a very
big main obstacle, which is the
previous rejection by the authorities
related to the lack of formal
and material evidence. The Talangsari tragedy
has become a historical wound
in Indonesia's black record that
has not yet been resolved, let alone
treated. It is important to continue
remembering and controlling this issue
so that justice can truly
be enforced.
you
