The Real Reason Chainmail Took Over

Primordial Armor
3 followers
1 Video View·Feb 27, 2026
Explore the construction, history, and durability of this enduring armor. Learn how different ring sizes and riveted patterns provided protection against various medieval threats.
Hello everyone and welcome. So, we have spoken a lot about different sorts of armours, like scale armour, lorica segmentata, lamalla and so on.
Now, you might have noticed that a lot of these armours have disappeared or been less popular, and a big reason for that is mail.
So, it is finally time we start actually talking about mail.
Now, some of you will probably know mail armour as chainmail.
Now, chainmail is one that was invented in the late 18th century because mail, in the form of letters that you send, were becoming more and more popular.
So, there was more and more confusion between the mail armour and the mail, the letter you sent in the post to whoever you wanted to send them to.
So, the mail armour changed name to chainmail, or at least certain people started using chainmail instead of mail, just to avoid any confusion.
Now, in this video, I'm going to be talking about mail, but in case you were wondering, I'm going to be talking about the armour, not the letter.
Now, mail was invented around the 3rd century BC.
Kind of debatable, we don't exactly have very clear sources, so it's kind of hard to pinpoint exactly when it was invented, but we do at least have some sources from that period of time.
But we know it was probably invented by the Gauls or Celts, and from there, the Roman Republic very quickly adopted it.
The Roman Empire kept it, and it even became more popular during the Roman Empire.
And then, after the fall of the Western Roman Empire, it had become the primary armour of basically everyone in Western Europe.
Now, clearly, you did probably have some other armours, like the scale armour for example, but mail had replaced all other metal armours to a very large degree.
Of course, you still had some other armours, like padded armours, gambesons, that were still in use, but that's not really metal armour.
And it stayed the primary armour of everyone in Western Europe until the 13th century, when people around that time actually started experimenting with different plate armours.
So, coat of plate, brigandine, and later, plate armour.
But even after those plate armours had been invented, so whether that's brigandine or plate armour, mail was still a very important armour.
It was very often worn under brigandine, it was very often worn on its own by poorer soldiers, and it was also used a lot in the gaps of plate armour.
And even on early plate armours, it was worn underneath the other parts of the armour, so the breastplate for example.
And on later plate armours, it would be placed in the gaps of the armour and different places.
And we even still use mail to a certain degree today, for example, diving suits to protect against shark bites, for chainsaw gear to protect yourself from the chainsaw, and that kind of stuff.
So it's still used today to a certain degree.
So what exactly is mail?
Now, mail is basically, well, an envelope, and in that envelope you'll put a certain...
No, I got the wrong one. This is not what we're talking about, we're talking about the armour.
Mail armour is a certain armour made up of different rings interlocking together to form up a certain mesh that is going to make up an armour.
Now, except in the case of butted mail, but that is not really a historical sort of mail, it's more of a modern sort of mail that we make today because it's easier to make.
But in the case of historical mail, the rings are going to be riveted together.
Meaning that you are going to have a ring, the two ends of the ring are going to overlap, and you're going to drill a hole and put a rivet through that overlapping section so you can actually shut the ring and it will be way harder to break open.
This is not the case on butted mail, but again, butted mail is not really historical, it's just a modern sort of mail.
In butted mail, the ends of the ring will just be touching each other, they will not be connected with a rivet, which obviously makes it way weaker.
Now, that is the base principle of how mail armour is constructed, but you have different exact variations depending on period, region, and use.
For example, some mail armours will only have half of the rings riveted, the other half is going to be basically an entire ring that is going to be punched out of a plate.
Meaning that there is no riveted section for that ring, it's just an entire full ring.
Now, this is commonly done because you don't need all the rings to be riveted, because if you have one riveted ring, it can go through all of the non-riveted rings and you'll still be able to make the armour.
And obviously it's way easier to not have to rivet every single ring, so it's just better to have that full ring, just to make the armour easier to make.
But obviously not every ring can be a full ring, because else you wouldn't be able to attach them together, so usually you will have one row with riveted rings, one row with entire rings, one row with riveted, and so on.
So you can actually attach everything together.
Now, the size of the ring can also vary a lot between different mail armours.
So for example, if we take this armour right here, it is made up of 6mm rings, this armour that I'm wearing right now is made of 8mm rings, and if we take something like the mail on this helmet here, it is made up of 10mm rings.
The thickness of the wire used in the rivet can also change, and also some rings will be flattened and some will be round like that in the wire used to make up the rivet.
So that's usually going to be used in weak points in the gap, generally speaking around the neck, because you want to protect that more and you need that heavier, denser mail to protect that place more.
Therefore you usually want to wear it over some sort of padding so that it can absorb part of that blunt force.
So there is no evidence that they used any form of padding underneath, for the early Romans that used mail, so during the Roman Republic, there is no evidence that there was any form of padding underneath the mail.
So now that we know what mail is, we can start to talk about why it became so popular and why it mostly replaced the other armours.
And also if you look on the inside of the edging, the part that has been surrounded by that edging is actually pretty rusty because the edging has contained all that humidity.
Now, that's not too much of a problem. It will basically remove the rust the next time you wear it so it's not too much of a problem but mail can still rust a little bit.
Now, when mail wasn't used for a long period of time, typically during the Roman Republic and Empire where you had different soldiers and you didn't necessarily have enough soldiers compared to the amount of armours you had at a given time.
So obviously you could imagine that these armours would start rusting because they are not in use and they are not being shaken off the rust all the time.
Now, the good thing about mail is that there is a very simple way you can store it and that is simply by putting it into a barrel of oil and what that will do is just prevent any rust from forming because you are constantly surrounded by oil.
And also the good thing about mail is that you can just pack it into a relatively tight bundle that will shape up to any form you are putting it inside.
If you take something like a solid breastplate, you cannot put it into the barrel if the barrel isn't wide enough for the size of the breastplate.
So fitting a lot of breastplates inside a barrel is much harder than fitting mail inside a barrel.
So in the end, mail is very rust resistant and that can really be useful.
And in actual fact, a lot of mail shirts would actually last for centuries once they were made and would be inherited from father to son over the course of several generations because it was so durable that it could actually survive long enough.
Now, aside from durability, mail also has the big advantage that it has no gaps.
Meaning that where this armour is supposed to protect, there is no gap.
My side is protected, my armpit is protected, everything is protected where the armour is supposed to protect.
If we take something like a lamella, even a scale armour, a lower cut segmented torso or anything like that, they will have different gaps.
Usually that's going to be the armpits that are hard to not have a gap in, but it can really be anything.
And obviously certain armours also have the problem that certain blows angled in different ways can actually pierce the armour.
For example, if you take scale armour, a blow coming from underneath can actually come underneath the scales and actually pierce the armour.
Mail doesn't have that problem at all. No matter where the thrust comes from, it will not be able to easily pierce mail without actually piercing through it through a link.
So now let's talk about the disadvantages of mail.
Now, the main problem mail has, I would say, is that it's much slower than an email.
Wait, what? No, we're not talking about mail, we're talking about mail.
Anyways, I understand myself.
So anyways, what are the disadvantages of mail armour?
Because clearly it does have some disadvantages, it cannot be perfect in all situations.
Now obviously mail is really good at protecting against all sorts of slashes and cuts.
However, while it's not the best at protecting against piercing damage, it can still protect against most piercing blows.
Only it's not the best.
Like, a heavy war bow, especially if using vortican arrows, will probably be able to pierce mail.
And some later medieval mail weapons like Warhammers, Rondledaggers, things like that could probably be able to pierce mail pretty easily.
But in terms of earlier weapons, in terms of swords like Viking swords, Barthelgladius, in terms of spears, all of that, most probably they will not be able to pierce mail.
And mail will be able to protect you relatively well against those attacks.
Especially if we're talking about some good quality mail.
Because usually if you're seeing tests on YouTube, for example, where they are actually testing how protective mail is.
The problem is that sometimes they will use buttered mail that is way worse at protecting against everything.
So it's not really the same armour at all.
And generally speaking, even if they use riveted mail, they will actually not necessarily use the best quality riveted mail.
That's the first problem.
Now obviously you did still have some bad quality mail in history, but good quality mail is better.
And in any case, I have never ever seen anyone trying with small rings.
The smallest I've probably ever seen is 8mm rings.
But you do have mail with 6 or even 5mm rings that is going to be way more protective.
And obviously you have things like 6 in 1 mail armour that will be way harder to pierce too.
So generally speaking, against piercing damage, heavy warbows will probably be able to pierce mail.
But in terms of other things, they are unlikely to, at least in earlier periods of time, late Middle Ages, yes, things could probably pierce mail.
But the main problem is that it is bad at protecting against blunt force.
Because it is so flexible that it will not protect against any sort of blunt force.
And the blunt force will just go right through it because it's so flexible.
So you're basically only relying on your gambeson underneath.
Obviously the mail will remove some amount of blunt force, but that's going to be very little.
And that's probably the primary problem of the mail armour.
It's not very good against blunt force.
However, it is very important to remember that your armour is not your primary line of defence.
Your primary line of defence is actually going to be your shield.
And you're actually going to use your shield to defend yourself and you don't want your armour to absorb the blows.
The armour is kind of a last chance thing.
Just in case you get hit, even though you had a shield, you're actually still protected.
And that means that most, and I'm talking the vast majority, of blows that are actually able to hit the armour are not going to be strikes with a lot of force.
Meaning that first of all, even though you might have a weapon that has a chance of piercing mail armour,
it is unlikely to do it because you're not going to be able to hit with full force someone while he's trying to defend himself.
And even though the shield might not have been enough and you're still getting hit on the armour,
there is a very large chance that part of that force is actually going to be absorbed by the shield
because the shield kind of stood in the way and your opponent had to get away around the shield to hit you.
Or you came up with your shield just a bit too late so you're actually getting pushed down and you're still getting hit.
But the shield is likely to absorb some of that force and you're unlikely to get hit with full force.
Especially because you also have the problem that your opponent is unlikely to be able to deliver a blow with full force
simply because it's actually dangerous to deliver a blow with full force because you're exposing yourself to your opponent's attack.
So yes, mail might not be great at protecting against piercing damage, might not be great at protecting against blunt force,
but you are unlikely to get hit with full force.
So you're not likely to get hit with a lot of blunt force or having something that is actually able to pierce the armour.
And then you have arrows, because arrows will get shot with full force.
So when you actually get hit, you're going to get hit with full force.
But again, the shield is your primary line of defence against an arrow and you're supposed to stop the arrow with your shield.
Now obviously it can still get past the shield, you might not be able to block every single attack.
Someone might shoot from the side, from behind or from multiple angles so you can't defend yourself enough to stop all the arrows.
So that is probably the primary weakness of the mail, that it can be pierced by arrows.
But again, you have the shield to protect you, you have formations specifically designed to protect against arrows,
so you're still unlikely to get hit by an arrow.
Then you do also have some minor problems with mail.
For example, here it tends to get caught in the rivets of the rings quite easily.
It can be a bit annoying but it's kind of a minor inconvenience, it's not really a big problem.
And finally, you also have the problem that it takes a lot of time to make.
An average mail shield will have around 30,000 rings, meaning that you have in between 15,000 and 30,000 rings to rivet,
depending on whether you're riveting all the rings or only riveting half of them.
But in any case, you have a lot of rings to make and a lot of rivets to rivet together.
So it takes a lot of time to make, you're probably looking into the two months of work,
of basically constant working for a single mail shield.
And that is excluding going to get the material for the metal and stuff like that, of course.
So that was a big problem.
Now in the end, mail armour was basically good enough at protecting you against all sorts of attacks,
because your primary line of defence is a shield and the mail only comes in as a secondary line of defence,
meaning that the vast majority of blows that actually hit it will hit with a little force, so a mail is enough.
And other than that, it is a better option than some other armours,
because it is so durable that, well, first of all, it will never fail you at an unexpected point,
because there is no strap that you need to hold it together.
At worst, you'll lose a link, but as I said, that's not a major problem.
You can perfectly well use your mail shield, even though it has lost a link.
And yes, it takes a lot of time to make, but it is worth spending two months of work to actually get an armour
that will last for a century and that will get inherited by your children and their children and so on,
because it's such a durable armour that that's actually possible and it wouldn't be with other armours.
And obviously, during the late Middle Ages, it still kept being in use mainly because it is the only...
