I Wore Only Medieval Clothes & Armour In FREEZING Temperature And I Was SHOCKED!

Primordial Armor
3 followers
26 Video Views·Jan 14, 2025
Living through winter posed immense challenges for Medieval people across all social classes. The wealthy huddled in great halls and castles that were difficult to heat properly, with tapestries hung on stone walls providing minimal insulation against the bitter cold. Smoke from central hearths would often fail to properly ventilate through roof holes, leaving inhabitants to choose between warmth and breathing clean air.
Hey noble ones, welcome back to my channel, this is The Metatron speaking and today I would like
to focus a little bit and talk about medieval armor and medieval clothing but specifically
within the context of extreme weather conditions. Now given extreme weather conditions, of course
when we're talking about the cold in this case, winter weather, what's considered to be extreme
very much depends on where you're from. I'm a man from the Mediterranean, for me already 50 degrees
Fahrenheit is extreme but if you're a northern European you'd probably be laughing your head
off at that. But regardless, I think today was a fantastic opportunity to do some testing because
outside is snowing right now and that's great because one, I can film some really good looking
footage in medieval clothing and armor that I can use for the video that I will be posting tomorrow
which is a video on the origins of the medieval knight. So you will see that footage in glorious
4k tomorrow but today we can still use the experience and a little bit of the footage
to discuss how difficult it was for me to stay outside in winter weather wearing nothing but
medieval clothing and armor. So make sure to come and check the video tomorrow for the
deep historical analysis and for today let's go and do some testing. Okay so the first thing I
would like to say in order for us to be a little more scientific is to tell you precisely what I
mean when I say well it was cold. So the specific temperature that we had when I was wearing my
plate armor outside was around 32 Fahrenheit so we are around zero degrees Celsius. Obviously that's
not like incredibly cold, we're not talking minus 20 type of cold but it was still cold and wearing
plate I have to say it was very insulating and even without the armor, I mean with the armor on
I could have been outside for hours and it wouldn't have bothered me. On the other hand
my wife was wearing regular clothing such as you know a jacket, a hoodie and she felt the cold more
than me and that's important because usually I'm the one who's sensitive to the cold so I think
that a large factor of that was the sort of insulation that I was getting not only because
of the armor and the plates but also specifically the plates in combination with the sort of fabrics
that I was wearing aka my 15th century northern Italian arming doublet based on the paintings by
Piero della Francesca. It is important to say however that I think one of the most important
aspects of me being able to sustain the cold outside is the fact that there was no wind,
virtually no wind. I believe if the wind had been stronger then my hands and my face would have been
severely affected. With that being said of course you can wear gauntlets, I do have a pair of medieval
gauntlets that I did put on and the moment those were on not a problem and that has to do, I mean
I'm not confident enough to speak about the physics involved, if you are please let me know,
but plates of steel must must be really good for some reasons. But what about your face? Well you
can wear a helmet. In my experience one of the things that I noticed is that depending on the helmet
up to this point the one helmet that really appears to be excellent defense not only against
the cold and in general but most likely the wind although I still haven't had a chance to test that
extensively is my frogmouth and I think the reason is the fact that the frogmouth helmet has a massive
solid plate of steel in front of your face whereas for example a helmet like this one still good,
definitely better than wearing nothing, but if you open the visor, yeah never mind, but even with the
visor down it is a lot more open, it has openings because you need to be able to see through these,
you need to be able to breathe, it's good for ventilation, excellent against overheating but
then again when you when it's zero celsius outside I mean overheating was not low in the list of
things that went in my mind but something like this would still provide some protection some
shielding from extreme wind but not as good or as well as a frogmouth. Moral of the story if you're
outside and it's windy do wear your frogmouth helmets. Another question that we may have is
is there a big difference between wearing full plate when it comes to your major protection for
your torso or just wearing a brigandine? Well I am specifying torso because if you see in my
configuration here even though the helmet is not it's kind of an old school helmet that would be
with that kind of brigandine that I have which is a 15th century brigandine and so are my shoulders
and arms really that helmet is more of a late 14th century so it would be either a knight who is
messing around with his dad's helmet maybe even granddad or I should be wearing something more
like an armet or some other kind of helmet but with that being said still for testing it was fun
to put on also to give us a visual difference between the other set that I'm wearing with the
frogmouth and this one. When it comes to dealing with zero celsius or 32 fahrenheit brigandine
full plate they are both absolutely fine and I didn't see a massive difference or any difference
that would be numerically significant even if we were to use electronic tools or any sort of
machinery to quantify the persistence of my core body temperature. Of course the fact that I'm
wearing full plate arms and shoulders as opposed to for example having your shoulders also made
of brigandine is historically justifiable if anything I would say it's the most common way
let me show you. If we spend some time with actual medieval iconography you'll see that
the brigandine will appear several times more often in some countries than others I think Italy
has got quite a lot of and France have got quite a lot of representations of brigandines for example
this one it's a red brigandine that you see this man is wearing but this is from the late 14th
century and you see the man on the right is wearing a brigandine but in Germany too this is from
Bavaria 1375 I believe and you see that this guy is also wearing a red brigandine gorgeous one in
fact and still from Germany we've got three different patterns of colors and you can see
that the arms are in fact full plate they don't appear to be wearing any specific brigandine
arms or brigandine shoulders everything is in plate a bit like mine although this is in the
German style note and then the brigandine being the only factor that is in plate which of course
is a viable option they would be wearing male you can kind of see it with the guy in red here
that is in fact ditching the shoulder plates that's something that people did sometimes
these two do have spoulders in plate but this guy decided now male is enough and so you can see that
this is most likely part of the shirt of male that he is wearing underneath his brigandine and of
course for context for those of you who forgot about it a brigandine does have of course fabric
in the outside it usually can be wool it can be linen it can be silk velvet like in my case but
this is a french image that i always find interesting to discuss varieties within
brigandine settings for instance you can see that this guy has got a brigandine black and
silver brigandine breastplate but his fold is plate it looks yellow it could be that it was
gilded because this guy has a lot of money but what's interesting is that historically we also
find the opposite where the breastplate is actual plate and then the fold and even the placket would
be steel so both configurations exist and still for and still in france we see a heavy usage of
all sorts of brigandines worth of note this guy wearing a blue brigandine with a blue and silver
brigandine and i love the mace that is holding i mean i wish i had something like that still
within the topic of brigandine i think this is one of my favorite images so i still don't have the
legs working on it but my arms are kind of similar although he has got smaller shoulders and at the
pauldrons are full 15th century pauldrons they exist too in iconography in combination with
brigandines and i will show you another one but i think it's a beautiful representation of
once again a sort of closed helmet that he's wearing then he's got the brigandine because
of course it provides a lighter and more articulated torso defense that kind of it's
easier to wear possibly less expensive unless you really go for silk velvet like i did as compared
as opposed to like full plate and then you know he still has these arms and note that he's not
wearing gauntlets sometimes i get reprimanded on my videos when i don't wear gauntlets but i am
still wearing full plate well we do see that happening in war and in tournament in iconography
so it's not like everyone all the time always wore gauntlets or mittens oftentimes they did of course
but not everyone did so it's fine now whether my hands will be fine or not that's a completely
different discussion here we see a guy wearing a blue brigandine and a guy wearing some kind of
orange brigandine right next to a guy in full plate so as you can see both are viable options
and it's interesting that this guy on the left does appear to have a left big pauldron a bit
closer to my style but as i always say for those of you who are interested in this and are like but
would you have shoulders in brigandine too and yes the answer is yes and we see it in iconography
here is another wonderful sort of image or illumination from france and we are in the 15th
century here 1440 and i think it looks gorgeous the brigandine shoulders look really good and the
closing method of this brigandine appears very similar to mine once again and for context mine
is a brigandine it's often called the leeds brigandine simply because it's displayed in
leeds but it's an italian model kind of wanted to underline that see often people just say the
leeds brigandine it's not an english model it's an italian model nonetheless note that in this
configuration which could still be considered it's very well protective but it's a little
lighter since he's not wearing arm harness and he's just using mail for his for the protection
of his arms so the brigandine is a fantastic choice and i love it whenever i want to for
instance if i if i were to go tomorrow to let's say an event it could be like a renaissance festival
i would probably go in my brigandine with plate arms and possibly plate legs rather than in full
armor simply because it's just easier to pull off if you're gonna be outside for a very long time if
i'm gonna be standing for a very long time of course and it's not like i'm going on my horse
right so that would be one of the reasons why as a modern person i would choose the brigandine in
those situations but i have to say that plate would still be my favorite if i was a medieval
knight and i was gonna go on a campaign i think but then again more testing might be needed but
what about the defense from the cold well i have to say that the brigandine still insulated me very
well maybe not as well as plate but what i was wearing the brigandine i still didn't shiver
i still didn't feel the cold and i mean unless you put me northern europe in which case probably
doesn't matter you could put me inside of an oven and i would still be shivering a cold and i
thought that that was fascinating because i was actually expecting to be colder in within in the
brigandine but that wasn't the case another thing that we could ask is how different would the
climate the weather conditions whether it be extreme hot whether it be extreme cold or seasonal
specific temperatures between the medieval period and now and this is a very complex question and it
varies place by place century by century but one thing that we could say even if you choose one of
those areas that will have a difference in terms of the sort of climate that you would have in
comparison to what you're testing your gear in i still think you would be able depending on where
you are to still garner excellent data because whatever difference that it would have been
it wouldn't be so dramatic at least in my opinion in general as to render any experience that we
could have today as reenactors or for experimental archaeology completely useless we can use the data
also because weather always has a range of variability you don't always have the exact
same temperature every day for the entire season and so even if the one day when you're out it would
represent a day on the milder side of a medieval winter season rather than the coldest they could
get that would still work and it could be compensated by for example going to a country
that is colder than the modern equivalent where you're filming so all of this can be used and just
give you one example when it comes to weather data you have the climate of Anatolia which we
believe that in the 11th century was not significantly different to that of recent
years which means once again that modern data can be used to provide hypothetical weather schemes
particularly if you're wearing period accurate clothing now the impact of harsh weather is
recorded in the sources and it is a major problem when it comes to medieval life not only during
times of war but also during times of peace for instance we do know that a rapid onset of cold
weather could mean a severe loss of livestock just as an example and we do have a historical mention
of that which connects perfectly to the sort of material evidence that was found at Shapwick
Somerset where a mass burial of ovine and bovine was found and it's most likely explained as a
impetus brought forth by severe harsh weather that just occurred quickly and the animals died
if we want to focus and approach this in a scholarly manner in an academic manner we shouldn't
just focus on the sort of clothing and clothing availability of people in the medieval period or
maybe access to fire in order to warm themselves up so of course if you were poor and it was really
cold you may die because you can't cover yourself and you don't have shelter so shelter access to
fire access to good warm clothing this is all obvious but if we read the sources when it comes
to for example sort of difficulties faced during winter seasons in say the 1250s we see that there
is another mention or another item of discussion that we should insert when we talk about these
harvest failure not only because nutrition is very important when it comes to the ability to
sustain the weather but also it specifically connects to the loss of livestock that is because
if you have harvest failure if you have an economic crisis it could mean that you don't
have sufficient fodder for your animals and of course cattle but also sheep goats these are all
ruminants and one of their characteristics is that the source of body heat when it comes to their
core comes from the food they eat to be more specific about it because of bacterial fermentation
of the food they consume so if you have dearth underfed animals will struggle to maintain
even core body temperatures which could lead to death and all of this without even tackling the
susceptibility of any given population cluster to airborne diseases maybe on a dedicated video
regardless of the period that we will be focusing on for our research the environment has always
been a beast and a massive problem to deal with whether it be a medieval kingdom whether it be a
early modern settlement or major city or whether it be classical antiquity we could say that it is
in fact in the modern period that we start to be able to not only face some of these difficulties
that have to do with the weather but also that we start to understand them and things that are
impossible to predict for a medieval king as well as medieval peasants and farmers in the modern
period thanks to the development of technology become more easy to prepare for the lack of the
ability to prepare for some of these events is in fact probably one of the nastiest aspects of
having to live in the middle ages in classical antiquity and whatnot at the same time though we
shouldn't underestimate the ability to regulate and maximize or optimize your chances to survive
harsh weather conditions and even unpredictable event of people of the past you may not be able
to precisely calculate the say calorie expenditure that each agent or person whether it be a medieval
god whether it be a soldier on campaign or whether it be once again a farmer or a fisherman would
have to need and spend depending on specific climate variations but at the same time even
with the lack of specific scientific methods or technology to be precise about these calculations
the results of the conditions can still be studied in order to manipulate the environment around you
and the way you face the repercussions of certain actions over others that sort of deductive logic
was in fact something that the ancient medieval people excelled at because of two things that
they had access to experiential knowledge and accumulated knowledge as a species which is why
i'm going to say that most likely one of the greatest inventions for mankind was the ability
to pass along knowledge in the written form okay what about the regular clothing well obviously
without the help of armor regular clothing didn't necessarily give me any advantage over modern
clothing the sort of medieval garments that i'm wearing that i have are very well made and it's
kind of on the high end so it's something that a merchant a nobleman a successful man at arms or
entrepreneur of the medieval period would have been able to afford the sort of for instance of
boots that i'm wearing handmade leather boots well those worked perfect in fact they worked a lot
better than i thought they were excellent i did not get any spilling no snow went inside my
my shoes my my boots and hit my feet for instance my feet were not cold and i think what i'm about
to say is going to surprise you but my medieval boots worked better than cheap modern shoes the
sort of stuff that you would buy at a market perhaps made in china that is inexpensive you
can buy for twenty thirty dollars well those are worse they break they get hoarse sometimes they
get covered in snow or water and then the water goes through the fabric and i would rather when
now that i've experienced it i would rather wear my medieval boots if i had to walk for 50 miles
in snow than any cheap type of shoes that were made in the modern period now given you can have
specialized uh hiking shoes or stuff that people use that actually works really well and would work
better than the medieval counterparts of course but i have to say that i was expecting my feet
to get really cold instead they didn't maybe that has to do with the thickness of the leather
specifically in this case but i must say i was really impressed with how well my medieval boots
functioned in six to seven inches of snow and also because of the sort of grip that the
soles had on the snow i had no problems slipping or falling for instance by wearing my medieval
boots all right noble ones but i hope you enjoyed this video and if you did please remember thumbs
up and if you're not yet a member of this community become a number one subscribe to my channel for
more content from the metatron and remember the metatron spread his wings stay warm goodbye
