How Did A Medieval Battle Work?

Primordial Armor
3 followers
5 Video Views·Mar 27, 2026
In today's video we look into how a medieval battle would typically work - the pre-planning, the scouting, the information gathering, the command structure, and the reason for committing to a battle.
AI Generated·May contain errors
For thousands of years, great numbers of soldiers have gathered together on the same piece of land
and engaged in giant battles, with both armies moving their men all over the landscape to gain
the upper hand and crush the opposing forces. But how exactly did battles take place,
and how did they work? In today's video, we'll be taking a look at various battles
throughout history, specifically focusing on medieval warfare, in an attempt to understand
how a medieval battle actually worked. Firstly, before any battle could commence,
a vital step must be taken – scouting. Scouts were the eyes and ears of medieval armies.
They would ride out far ahead of the marching military, gathering a plethora of information
from various resources. The most common and vital pieces of information would include
the layout of the land. Understanding and surveying the landscape is incredibly important,
because there have been many examples in military history where a battle was commenced with one side
not knowing the geographical dangers and uncertainties around them. A good example of this
would be the Battle of Hattin in 1187, where the Frankish Crusader forces were in enemy land
deep in Saracen territory. The Franks found themselves with a lack of water, so attempted
to reach a natural spring, which turned out to be far too small to provide the entire army with
water. Severely dehydrated and morale at an all-time low, the Frankish armies set up camp,
but were soon surrounded by Saladin's much larger army who had set up camp around them,
preventing any escape. Saladin's men then proceeded to burn dry grass,
clenching the throats of the Crusaders even further. Then, once the Franks disbanded their
camp in an attempt to find another water source at the springs of Hattin, the Saracen army
descended upon them and slaughtered the Frankish army in droves. Whilst the Battle of Hattin clearly
showed European failures in multiple areas, one of the biggest contributions to their defeat was the
lack of forward planning with scouts, being unable to find suitable water sources and finding
themselves caught out in the open. Another major piece of information that scouts would be tasked
with finding would be local knowledge. Information from local peasants or townsfolk was vital when an
army was in a foreign land. Small roads, areas liable to flooding, difficult terrain and unknown
paths through woodlands were incredibly important for scouts to find out, and one single piece of
local knowledge would save entire armies from being caught out and massacred. Although this
can backfire, as seen when King Henry II sent an army to lay siege to the Welsh-held castle of
Dinifer in south Wales. A scout relied on the information of a local Welsh cleric, who agreed
to guide the English army through the many obstacles of the Welsh landscape, through the
heavily wooded valleys. Doubt began to spread amongst the English military commanders when
the path seemed to get the English no further to their intended destination, and their uncertainty
was set in stone when the Welsh cleric suddenly stopped at a meadow before kneeling down and began
eating the grass, telling the English generals that this is what Welsh people do for sustenance
in times of hardship. It is said that the Welsh cleric did this as a witty insult to the English's
low perception of the Welsh people, and in fact the local Welshman was indeed leading the army
away simply to waste their time. This ballsy trick from the Welshman seemed to have worked,
as the English were then forced to abandon their plans for besieging the castle at Dinifer.
Of course, a major part of a scout's role was to spy on the enemy army as well.
Recording their movements, how many men they had, and what was the composition of soldiers,
were they heavily artillery-based, is there a large proportion of armoured knights,
and how many cavalry do they have? Even down to the specific details like whether they look tired
or whether they have high morale. This would be one of the most dangerous roles that a scout could
do, as this placed them very close to the enemy lines, and of course the enemy would have scouts
of their own who were trained to capture enemy scouts if they could, then dragging them back
behind enemy lines to their commanders for questioning and possibly torture. A scout
during the Middle Ages was an incredibly dangerous job, but could earn you a pretty penny if you
scored some information that turned the fortunes of a battle. The information provided by scouts
would be collated and discussed by military commanders in their war tents, and battle
plans would then be made. Before we discuss how a battle actually began, it is important to note
that pitched battles during the medieval period were actually very rare. Indeed, a medieval soldier
could go their entire military careers without witnessing a single battle. They would instead
be much more likely to witness sieges of towns and cities, which almost always ended in a truce
or a diplomatic resolution rather than being forced to scale the walls in a dramatic attack.
If you consider the requirements for an open field battle, it must mean that, at least usually,
both sides believe they would be likely to win. Or at least one side believed that they could win,
and the other side believed that they could get themselves in a defensive position which would
tip their chances in their favour. If not, they would simply continue moving around the countryside,
evading conflict. In the rare circumstance that an open battle did have to occur, it was usually due
to the fact that a mobilised army cannot be moved away from a reliable supply line for too long.
A giant proportion of an army on the march consisted of baggage trains. We believe that
one third of the baggage carts drawn by horses were loaded with hay just to feed the horses
pulling the carts themselves. As such, a battle was most likely to occur when the main roads in
which these baggage trains had to traverse were cut off, and there was no viable way back.
This is what happened at the famous Battle of Agincourt in 1415. The English army, led by King
Henry V, were marching around the French countryside, attempting to travel from the
recently captured port city of Harfleur to the English-held city of Calais. The French army had
managed to catch up to them and cut off their route, forcing King Henry to formulate a plan to
engage the French in an open battle. More about Agincourt later. So we have decided that we are
going to commit to a pitched battle. What happens next? Well, thanks to your excellent scouts, you
have been told everything you need to know about both the enemy forces and the immediate landscape.
Now you just need some good weather, which is appropriate for fighting in.
This is a very difficult thing to get right, since oftentimes an army is forced to engage with the
enemy and the clock is ticking. So they could be on the back foot and unable to choose an ideal
part of the day to fight. But both armies would likely prefer fighting in good weather as it gave
them the best chances, since they would both be impeded if rainy or stormy weather caused the
fields to flood and turn the grassy meadows into churned up mud. This is likely what happened at
Battle of Crecy in 1346. The English army arrived a day before the French, allowing the English
forces to dig in and prepare their military lines. The French didn't arrive until around
four o'clock the following day. We don't know exactly why, but it is believed that a mix of
lack of organisation within the French ranks had delayed their arrival, as well as the fact that
there had been a rainstorm the previous day and the French army consisted of many Genoese crossbowmen.
Who could not shoot their heavy crossbows in the rain due to the crossbow strings losing elasticity
when dampened. So the French decided to postpone the battle for one day, which turned out to be
disastrous for them because the English had just marched 300 miles in 30 days to get here, and the
extra day allowed for the King of England to do a full review of the English army, who were now
well rested, and also make sure his army were well fed and well prepared for the impending battle.
Solid leadership is also vital for a battle to go to plan. We said that we would revisit Agincourt,
and this is a perfect example of both great leadership and where leadership had clearly
broken down and failed. The English army had one single leader, Henry V, the King of England.
The French army had the Dauphin of France, who was the son of the French King Louis VI,
however he was not present at the battle. Instead, a group of military commanders and
members of nobility had arrived with their respective armies to form one large French
military consisting of around 15,000 men. And these leaders all wanted to be the primary
commander of the French army. Indecision took place, with each man demanding that they should
be the one to lead, and some commanders refusing to provide their soldiers if they were not the
in control. Not only this, but the original pre-organized battle plan had been compromised,
as a French scout carrying the plans on his person had been captured by the English.
And the message was sent to King Henry's war tent, allowing the English to know exactly what
the French were planning. This caused a fracture in the French army's leadership, and they were
forced to provide a new unstructured battle plan. The French knights still attempted their heavy
cavalry charge, which was no longer a viable option due to the muddy environment from recent
rainfall. And the extended amount of time it took for the French knights to reach the English lines
meant that the French took an incredibly high amount of unnecessary casualties in the first
hour of the battle. A common misconception is that the French army heavily outnumbered the English,
but it is now understood that the English actually likely outnumbered the French slightly,
since multiple French commanders refused to send their troops and their hired mercenaries
into battle after being disallowed the privilege of being the overall commander of the French army.
Before the battle, the army who arrived first would typically try to find the most advantageous
area to place their soldiers. But this can sometimes be deceiving, as we see at the Battle
of Touton, 29 March 1461. Touton goes down as the bloodiest battle ever fought on English soil.
The pre-setting of the battle is one of hatred and disdain for each side,
with the agreement of no quarter to be given to each side, meaning no prisoners. The Lancastrians
had positioned themselves atop a shallow hill, giving them the high ground and an excellent
place for their archers to shoot from. Unfortunately, a snowy blizzard had rolled
in on the day of the battle, and heavy winds blew snowfall directly into the faces of these
Lancastrian archers. This meant that their longbowmen were highly ineffective against
the Yorkist forces, blinded by the snow and their range being heavily restricted.
In opposition to this, the Yorkist archers were able to shoot from a safe distance,
with the wind in their favour, allowing them to shoot further away and not be reached by
Lancastrian longbowmen. This forced the Lancastrians off the hill as they suffered
heavy losses from the Yorkist longbows. And they had to charge down the hill and engage the Yorkist
army with their men already battered by the volley of arrows, devastating their ranks and
lowering their morale. A medieval army was made up of an overall commander in charge of the entire
army, who had a handful of generals in charge of individual companies of men, which could be
anywhere from one hundred to five hundred men or more. Then each company would be divided into at
least three flanks, the left, right and centre. Another commander would be responsible to lead
each flank. Each commanding officer would have their own job roles as per the battle plan,
given to them by their overall commander, and would be expected to read the battle as it
unfolded in order to enact their individual roles when the opportune moment arises.
Perhaps one company of cavalry were assigned with the task of keeping an eye on an enemy
company of cavalry, so that they may engage the enemy cavalry as soon as they saw them begin to
charge into battle, harassing them in the hopes to prevent them from carrying out their original
plans. Or, half a company may be expected to stand back and wait for the best moment to outflank an
enemy, who may have stretched themselves too thin in a certain area on the battlefront.
While we're on the subject of army compositions, it is important to note that, during the late
medieval period specifically, the typical knights and heavily armoured soldiers like men-at-arms
would only consist of a very small portion of a typical medieval army. The military force would
overwhelmingly be comprised of archers, levy soldiers like spearmen, billmen and halberdiers,
as well as mercenaries who could be armed in many different ways,
from specified troops such as Italian crossbowmen to lightly armoured cavalry like hobblers.
Cavalry and archers would be a key component to any late medieval army,
as archers were great at softening the enemy ranks, and cavalry were ideal at charging down
contingents of archers who may have found themselves left in the open. Heavy cavalry
were also utilised as tanks of the medieval period, being used to charge directly into
enemy foot soldiers to destroy their lines and cause havoc amongst their ranks with shock tactics.
Each company would be identified by the commander's colours,
often the heraldic colours of their household. Banners would be incredibly important on the
battlefield, and bannermen would be tasked to hold onto their flag for dear life,
always being easily viewable on the battlefield, so that the overall commanders knew exactly where
each company were at any one moment. Due to this, bannermen were highly prized targets for enemy
forces, since cutting down a bannerman would temporarily prevent their commander from seeing
where his companies currently are on the battlefield. During the Battle of Bosworth on
the 22nd of August 1485, the final formal battle to end the War of the Roses, Henry Tudor's standard
bearer, Sir William Brandon, was slain at the hands of none other than King Richard III himself.
In the chaos of battle, it is also true that sometimes confusion over heraldic colours would
occur. This happened during the Battle of Barnet, also during the War of the Roses.
The Earl of Oxford arrived with his reinforcements to the Lancastrian army,
but his banner was mistaken for the Yorkist Edward IV's heraldry, with the Earl of Oxford's banner
being the Sun with Rays, and Edward's banner being Sun in Splendour. This caused the Lancastrians to
fire upon their own forces, leading to the Earl of Oxford proclaiming treason. These accusations
whispered through the Lancastrian lines, which lowered their morale and cohesion, following in a
brutal Lancastrian defeat. Usually, the overall commander would be stationed somewhere away from
the battle up on high ground, being able to overview the battlefield and order his scouts,
sometimes referred to as custodians, to send messages to various commanders in charge of
different companies, giving them new assignments as the battle evolved and changed. It would be
impossible for the commanders on the ground to know exactly what was going on around them, so a
constant stream of updates provided by these scouts were vital to keep the battle in their favour.
As for the front lines, it would have surely been one big wrestling match. Both sides would try
their hardest to keep a unified, tight line of soldiers, preventing any gaps to appear. In an
effort to force these gaps, some military tactics included bulldozing into the enemy lines, ripping
a hole into the enemy ranks in an attempt to break them up and separate them, making it much harder
for a commander to keep a hold over their companies. Often, a stalemate would occur where
both sides had their spears pointed at each other, taking quick jabs whenever the opportunity
prevented themselves, but more importantly, they wanted to hold their ground, awaiting new orders
as the battle changed around them. This is why armour was so necessary during the later periods
in medieval history, since you may just be forced to stand still and deny the enemy any ground,
despite being pelted at with artillery such as arrow volleys and gunners.
In most cases, an army would break rank and retreat when that vital line of communication
broke down between the overall commander, the scouts and the company commanders. Breaking
rank would force the soldiers to turn and run, now becoming very vulnerable to the enemy,
who would often have cavalry ready and waiting just behind their lines to charge in and cut down
any fleeing soldiers. The moment an army breaks rank, the battle is lost.
We see this at the famous Battle of Hastings in 1066, where the Anglo-Saxons misplaced their
confidence in seeing the Normans appear to retreat, and they broke rank in order to chase
them down. However, the Norman soldiers then quickly turned round, and together with their
mounted knights, they cut down the Saxon warriors who had allowed themselves to be caught out in
the open. Yes, it would be very difficult to identify friend from foe on a medieval battlefield.
But battles of the Middle Ages wouldn't be like what we see in movies or on TV,
such as the Battle of the Bastards in Game of Thrones, where there appears to be no uniformity
or structure to rank from either side. Your enemy would be in front of you, and, if he was beside
you or behind you, something has gone terribly wrong. Often, battles would be lost when one side
breaks rank and flees, but sometimes victory would be called when the leader of one side was slain
or captured, as we see at the Battle of Hastings, and much later at the Battle of Shrewsbury and
Bosworth. But this message would take a while to go round all the troops on a chaotic battlefront,
so some soldiers would continue fighting long after their side had officially lost,
often resorting in fighting to the death. And so, hopefully you have learnt a few more things about
how a battle actually worked during the Middle Ages, and understood all the planning and
intelligence gaining that was involved before a pitched battle was able to take place.
This is by no means an exhaustive discussion of medieval battle planning,
but it is an introduction to comprehensively understand the most important things that
were involved. If you have any further points, please comment your knowledge and opinions in
the comments section below, and I would be happy to discuss these with you or talk about them in
a future video. Again, a heartfelt thank you to all the re-enactors featured in this documentary,
who have all helped bring history alive as a visual aid to this audience of history enthusiasts.
But for now, thanks for watching.
