Simon de Montfort was one of the most powerful, controversial, and extraordinary figures of medieval England. Born around 1208 into a noble French family, he rose to become the Earl of Leicester and eventually found himself at the centre of a bitter struggle over who should truly hold power in England: the king alone, or the king restrained by his nobles and the wider realm.
At first, Simon was closely connected to King Henry III. He married Henry’s sister, Eleanor, and became one of the most important men at the royal court. But their relationship slowly collapsed. Simon became increasingly opposed to the way Henry governed, particularly the king’s use of royal authority and the influence of his favourites. By 1258, discontent among England’s barons had grown so serious that Henry was forced to accept a programme of reform known as the Provisions of Oxford, which placed new restrictions on royal government.
The conflict did not end there. When Henry later attempted to recover his former authority, Simon emerged as one of the leading figures of the opposition. England descended into civil war, and in 1264 Simon achieved a remarkable victory at the Battle of Lewes. King Henry and his son, Prince Edward, fell into his hands, leaving Simon in control of the government. For a brief and astonishing period, a French-born nobleman had effectively become the most powerful man in England.
But Simon de Montfort’s story was about more than war and ambition. During his time in power, he summoned a famous Parliament in 1265 that brought together nobles and clergy with knights from the counties and representatives from English towns. It was not modern democracy as we understand it today, but the gathering became an important moment in the long development of parliamentary government and the institution that would eventually become the House of Commons.
Yet there was also a much darker side to Simon’s career. His political movement existed in an age of brutal violence, religious intolerance and persecution. His rule was associated with severe measures against Jewish communities, and violence against Jews accompanied the wider political turmoil of the period. Any account of Simon as a champion of political reform must therefore sit alongside the cruelty and persecution connected with his cause.
His triumph would not last. Simon’s position became increasingly fragile as powerful allies abandoned him and Prince Edward escaped captivity. On 4 August 1265, the two sides met at the Battle of Evesham. Simon’s army was overwhelmed by royalist forces led by Edward, and Simon himself was killed on the battlefield. His brief rule was over, and Henry III returned to power.
And yet Simon de Montfort was not simply forgotten. His rebellion had shaken the English monarchy, his Parliament had introduced a broader form of political representation, and his dramatic rise and fall left a lasting mark on English history. He was a nobleman who challenged a king, defeated a royal army, seized control of the government and, for a short time, was essentially the king in all but name.
Simon de Montfort was a French-born nobleman and Earl of Leicester who evolved from a close ally of King Henry III into his greatest rival. After leading a baronial rebellion and capturing the King, he established a landmark parliament in 1265. Though he died in battle at Evesham, his efforts to limit royal power and expand political representation left a lasting legacy on English governance.
Simon de Montfort was one of the most powerful,
controversial and extraordinary figures of
medieval England. Born in around the year 1208
into a noble French family, he rose to become
the Earl of Leicester
and eventually found himself at the centre of a bitter struggle
over who should truly hold power in England.
At first, Simon was closely connected to King
Henry III. He married Henry's sister Eleanor
and became one of the most important men at
the royal court, but their relationship slowly collapsed.
Simon became increasingly opposed to
the way Henry governed,
particularly the king's use of royal authority and the influence of his
favourites. By the year 1258,
discontent among England's barons had grown so serious that Henry
was forced to accept a program of reform known
as the Provisions of Oxford, which placed new
restrictions on royal government.
The conflict did not end there. When Henry later attempted
to recover his former authority,
Simon emerged as one of the leading figures of the opposition.
England descended into civil war, and in the year 1264,
Simon achieved a remarkable victory
at the Battle of Lewes.
King Henry and his son Prince Edward fell into his hands,
leaving Simon in control of the government.
For a brief and astonishing period, a French-born
nobleman had effectively become the most powerful man in England.
But Simon de Montfort's story was
about more than war and ambition.
During his time in power, he summoned a famous parliament in the
year 1265 that brought together nobles
and clergy with knights from the counties and representatives
from English towns. It was not modern democracy
as we understand it today but the gathering became
an important moment in the long development of parliamentary government
and the institution
that would eventually become the House of Commons.
His triumph however would not last forever.
Simon's position became increasingly fragile
as powerful allies abandoned him and Prince Edward
escaped captivity. On the 4th of August of the year 1265,
the two sides met at the Battle of
Evesham. Simon's army was overwhelmed by royalist forces led by Edward,
and Simon himself was killed
on the battlefield.
And yet, Simon de Montfort was not simply forgotten.
His rebellion had shaken
the English monarchy, his parliament had introduced
a broader form of political representation,
and his dramatic rise and fall left a lasting mark on English history.
He was a nobleman who challenged a king,
defeated royal army, seized control of the government
and for a short time was essentially the king in all but name.
This is his story.
Simon de Montfort was born in around
the year 1208 into a powerful French noble family
with important connections to both France and England.
He was the youngest son of Simon de Montfort,
the 5th Earl of Leicester. His father was a famous
military leader and one of the main commanders
of the Albigensian crusade against the Cathars
in southern France. Simon's strongest claim
to England came through his paternal grandmother,
Amicia de Belmont.
She was a co-heiress to the earldom of Leicester and belonged to the
powerful Belmont family
which held large estates in England since the Norman period. This gave
the Montfort family a hereditary claim to Leicester,
even though they were based mainly
in France. The claim was complicated
by the political divide between England and France.
After King John lost Normandy,
he refused to allow Simon's father to take possession
of the earldom, and instead placed it in the hands of Ranulf,
the Earl of Chester. Meanwhile,
the elder Simon built a huge power base
in southern France through the crusade, but he
was killed during the siege of Toulouse in the year 1218,
after his death. Simon's
elder brother Amory inherited the family's main lands in France,
but he struggled to
keep them and failed to recover Leicester's inheritance.
Eventually, Amory agreed that
his younger brother Simon could pursue
the English claim in return for giving up his
rights to the family's French possessions.
The decision would shape Simon's entire future.
Simon arrived in England in the year 1229.
He was educated, spoke French, the language
of the royal court, but he did not know English.
King Henry III received him favorably and
did not oppose his claim to Leicester.
Simon then worked to secure recognition of his inheritance
and after years of negotiation,
Henry formally invested him as the Earl of Leicester.
So although Simon was French by birth,
his ancestry gave him a genuine connection to
to one of England's great noble families.
As a child, Simon traveled with his parents
during his father's campaigns
against the Cathars in southern France.
In the year 1218, he was with his mother
at the siege of Toulouse when tragedy struck.
His father was killed after being hit on the head
by a stone hurled by a siege engine.
Simon was still very young,
but the violence of crusading warfare
was already part of his world.
Two years later, another of his older brothers,
Guy, was killed at another battle.
Of Simon's brothers,
Amory remained the senior heir to the family's French possessions.
Simon seems to have followed the military path expected
of a nobleman of his background.
As a young man, he probably took part
in the later stages of the Crusade,
and he later joined the Baron's Crusade to the Holy Land.
These experiences would have given him early exposure to warfare,
religion, and the wider
politics of the aristocratic world.
Even though Simon was not an elder son, he managed to charm
the King of England into giving him his ancestral right
to become the Earl of Leicester. Simon de
Montfort's marriage to Eleanor of England
in January of the year 1238 changed his position
almost overnight.
Until then, Simon was a foreign-born nobleman who had only recently
established himself in England.
By marrying Eleanor, however, he entered the royal family
itself. She was the youngest daughter of King John and Isabella,
and the sister of the reigning
King Henry III. Simon was no longer simply an ambitious Earl at court.
He had become the King's
brother-in-law. Eleanor carried
an extraordinary royal ancestry through her father, King John.
She descended from Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine,
two of the most powerful figures
of the 12th century.
Her great-grandmother was the Empress Matilda, daughter of Henry
the First, and through that line Eleanor was also
a direct descendant of William the Conqueror.
She therefore brought Simon connections to both
the English royal dynasty and the great
aristocratic families of France.
But the marriage was controversial from the beginning,
Eleanor had already been married
once to William Marshall,
she had been widowed while still very young and had reportedly
taken a religious vow of chastity after his death.
Her decision to marry Simon therefore caused objections within
the church, while the secrecy
surrounding the wedding angered many of England's leading nobles.
A marriage involving the king's
sister was normally a matter of considerable political importance,
yet Henry III had allowed
it to take place without first consulting his great barons.
There was also another reason for
outrage. Simon was still regarded by many English nobles
as an outsider. He had been born in France
and had risen quickly at Henry's court.
To see such a man marry an English princess
appeared to some barons as an extraordinary advancement.
Eleanor's brother Richard,
the Earl of Cornwall, was particularly angered,
and the dispute became serious enough that Henry
had to work to restore peace within the royal family.
Simon nevertheless had the king's support.
He travelled to Rome to resolve
the religious questions surrounding Eleanor's earlier vow,
and for a time his relationship with Henry remained extremely close.
Later in the year 1238, Simon and Eleanor had their first son,
whom they named in honour of the king, Henry.
In February of the year 1239,
Simon was formally recognised as the Earl of Leicester.
He became one of King Henry III's counsellors, and was even chosen
as one of the godfathers of the king's eldest son, the future Edward I.
The marriage was therefore far more than a romantic union,
it transformed Simon's status.
A young son from a French noble family had married a granddaughter
of Henry II, a descendant of William the Conqueror,
and the sister of the King of England.
Through Eleanor, Simon became bound by blood
and marriage to the dynasty he would later challenge.
For a time, Simon seemed
to have achieved everything he could have hoped for in England.
He had married the king's sister,
been formally recognized as the Earl of Leicester,
and become one of Henry III's trusted companions.
But beneath this closeness lay two very different personalities.
Henry could be generous and affectionate,
but he was also capable of sudden anger and long resentment.
Simon, meanwhile, was proud, forceful,
and extremely sensitive to any insult to his honour.
Their friendship was strong, but it was never entirely stable.
Historians have argued that these personal tensions would become
an important part of Simon's eventual opposition to the king.
The first serious rupture came in the summer of the year 1239,
only months after Simon had formally received the earldom.
Simon had borrowed a substantial amount of money from Thomas,
the Count of Flanders,
and had apparently named Henry III as security for the debt.
The problem was that Henry had not agreed to this arrangement,
and when the king discovered that his name had been used
to guarantee Simon's borrowing, he was furious.
On the 9th of August of the year 1239,
the disagreement exploded into an extraordinary
confrontation. Henry accused Simon of deceiving him,
and threatened to have him imprisoned in
the Tower of London. According to the chronicler Matthew Paris,
the king also reopened the painful
controversy surrounding Simon's marriage to Eleanor.
According to the chronicler,
the king said this to Simon: you seduced my sister
and when i discovered this i gave her to you
against my will to avoid scandal for Simon
the attack must have been deeply humiliating
only a short time earlier he had stood close
to the king as a trusted relative and counselor
now Henry was publicly questioning his honor
and even the legitimacy of the circumstances
surrounding his marriage.
Simon and Eleanor quickly left England and crossed to France
rather than risk the king carrying out his threat.
But this was not the end of their relationship.
Medieval politics could be surprisingly personal and flexible.
Kings and nobles might quarrel
bitterly one year and serve together the next.
Simon eventually returned to royal favour and
Henry continued to employ him.
Because Simon possessed qualities the king badly needed,
he was an experienced soldier,
an energetic administrator and a useful diplomat. His
importance at court recovered sufficiently for him
to be entrusted with major responsibilities.
His later career shows that the quarrel
of 1239 damaged trust between the two men,
but did not yet make them permanent enemies.
Simon spent part of the following years
campaigning and travelling abroad.
Simon de Montfort had declared his intention to join
a crusade several years before he finally travelled east.
During the Baron's Crusade,
he reached the Holy Land as part of the army led
by Richard of Cornwall. Although Simon does not
appear to have taken part in any of the major fighting there,
the expedition achieved important
results through negotiation.
Simon left the eastern Mediterranean in the autumn of the year 1241.
The following year,
he joined Henry III's campaign in Ponthieu against Louis IX of France.
The expedition went badly,
and Simon became openly frustrated with the king's leadership.
His anger was so great that he reportedly compared Henry
to Charles the Simple,
an old Frankish king who had been imprisoned by his own nobles.
The remark reflected the growing tension between the two men,
and Simon's increasingly poor opinion
on Henry's judgement.
Like his father, Simon had considerable ability as both a soldier
and an administrator. He also became increasingly troubled
by the dissatisfaction spreading through
England. Many nobles believed
that Henry showed too much favour to his relatives
and to members of Queen Eleanor's family,
financial pressure, poor harvests, and widespread
frustration with the royal government added
to the growing sense of unrest. In the year 1248,
Simon once again prepared to take the cross,
this time intending to join Louis IX on his crusade to
Egypt. Henry, however, persuaded him to abandon the expedition.
By the late 1240s, Henry faced
a serious problem in Gascony,
the king's remaining great possession in southwestern France.
Gascony was exceptionally important to the English crown.
It brought valuable trade,
particularly wine,
and gave the English monarchy a strategic foothold on the continent.
But the region was difficult to govern.
Powerful local lords guarded their independence fiercely,
while neighbouring rulers placed pressure on English authority.
In the year 1248, Henry chose
Simon to restore order there, appointing him as Steward of Gascony.
It was an extraordinary
position of trust. Simon effectively became
the King's chief representative in a troubled
and strategically vital territory.
Henry appears to have chosen him because he needed a strong
commander capable
of imposing royal authority where weaker governors had struggled. Simon
approached the problem with characteristic force.
He attempted to break the power of rebellious
nobles, strengthen castles, and enforce the king's authority.
His methods could be severe.
From Simon's perspective,
firmness was necessary because Gascony had become dangerously unstable.
To many Gascon nobles however,
his government seemed harsh, aggressive and overbearing.
Complaints began reaching Henry's court accusing Simon of abuses
and excessive violence.
Modern scholarship describes his rule as high-handed
and notes that his policies
helped drive parts of the duchy into something approaching civil war.
This placed Henry in an uncomfortable position.
He had sent Simon to impose order,
But now some of the very men Simon was trying
to control were appealing directly to the king
for protection. Henry began listening to their complaints.
Simon meanwhile believed he had been
carrying out the difficult task the king had ordered him to perform
and expected royal support.
The resulting dispute reopened all the old wounds between the two men.
Simon returned to England to
defend himself before the king and royal council.
He was accused of misconduct in Gascony,
but the proceedings did not destroy him.
Accounts of his career describe him as being cleared of the
charges. What mattered almost as much as the verdict,
however, was the damage done to his
relationship with Henry. Simon believed that after years
of dangerous service, he had been abandoned
by the man whose authority he had been defending.
Henry, for his part, increasingly saw Simon as
difficult, independent,
and unwilling to submit quietly to royal direction. The quarrel became
intensely personal. Simon was not a man who easily forgot an insult,
and Henry was not a king who
enjoyed being challenged by one of his own subjects.
Their relationship developed into an
uneasy mixture of family loyalty, dependence, and distrust.
They still needed one another.
Henry continued to use Simon on diplomatic missions,
while Simon remained part of the
highest level of English political life.
But the warmth that had marked Simon's first years at
court was disappearing.
Their differences also reflected a wider problem with Henry's reign.
many English nobles had become frustrated
with the way the king governed. Henry was
criticised for granting influence
and offices to favoured relatives and courtiers, for demanding
money while struggling with royal finances,
and for failing to consult his leading subjects
sufficiently. By the 1250s,
Henry's government was facing mounting difficulties. The crisis
This became particularly serious
when Henry became involved in a papally sponsored plan
to obtain the crown of Sicily for his younger son Edmund.
The scheme placed enormous financial obligations on the English crown
and became one of several
grievances that helped unite leading nobles against the king.
Simon increasingly found himself among those demanding change.
the year 1258, the crisis finally came to a head.
A group of leading barons confronted
Henry and demanded reform of the government.
Their complaints included royal finances,
the influence of Henry's relatives and favourites,
and the way important officials were chosen.
The resulting provisions of Oxford placed
a major restriction on the king's freedom
of action and transferred much of the business
of government to a council of fifteen. Simon
became one of its leading members
and increasingly emerged as one of the strongest defenders
of reform. The personal quarrel that had began with money
and wounded pride in the year 1239
had therefore grown into something far greater.
Simon and Henry were no longer merely two
two relatives who disliked one another.
They had come to represent opposing ideas on how
England should be governed.
Henry defended the traditional authority of the crown, especially
his right to choose his own ministers.
Simon increasingly insisted that royal government
must be restrained by sworn agreements
and the council of the political community. There
was a powerful irony in all of this.
Simon owed much of his English career to Henry the
III. The king had welcomed him, recognized his inheritance,
accepted him as a brother-in-law,
and entrusted him with positions of enormous responsibility.
But each quarrel left behind
another layer of mistrust.
The argument over Simon's marriage, the financial scandal,
the bitter experience of Gascony,
and the wider struggle over royal government slowly turned
former friends into political enemies.
The unity of the council of 15 did not last.
Henry gradually succeeded in dividing the barons
and winning some of them back to his side. As
support for reform weakened, Simon became increasingly isolated.
In the year 1261,
Henry rejected the provisions of Oxford
and attempted to recover the powers he had surrendered.
With the baronial opposition divided,
and his political position weakened,
Simon left England once again.
The dispute between him and the king had now moved far
beyond personal resentment.
It had become a struggle over the limits of royal power,
and the conflict was drawing England steadily closer to civil war.
Simon de Montfort returned to England in the year 1263,
after a number of barons increasingly
convinced that Henry III had no intention
of preserving the reforms of 1258, called him back.
Simon quickly placed himself at the head
of a renewed opposition movement. His declared aim
was to restore the system created by the provisions of Oxford,
and once again place
limits on the king's freedom to govern without consultation.
The rebellion was also tied to the
issue of debt. During Henry's reign,
Jewish communities were heavily taxed by the crown,
forcing many Jewish lenders to sell debt bonds
at reduced prices in order to raise money. Wealthy
courtiers were often able to purchase these bonds cheaply,
and indebted landowners could lose
estates when the debts were enforced.
This created a deep resentment and helped intensify the
anti-Jewish hostility already present in medieval society.
Simon's movement made use of that anger,
calls for the cancellation of debts became part of the rebellion,
and attacks on Jewish
communities followed.
These acts were also aimed at destroying the records that proved
what money was owed. In towns such as Worcester and London,
Jewish communities were violently
attacked, property was seized, and debt documents were destroyed.
The violence at Worcester
was led by Simon's son Henry de Montfort and Robert de Ferrers,
the Earl of Derby.
In London, one of Simon's important supporters,
John Fitz John, led an assault on a Jewish
population in which prominent members of the community were killed.
Contemporary and later
accounts describe large scale bloodshed and the seizure of property.
Similar attacks spread
to other towns including Winchester, Canterbury,
Lincoln, Cambridge, Northampton and elsewhere.
Meanwhile Simon's rebellion gathered enough strength
to force Henry into concessions.
For a time the king allowed Simon
and the reforming barons to take control of the royal
Council. But this settlement proved unstable.
Prince Edward, Henry's son, began using money,
patronage, and political influence
to win wavering barons back to the Royalist side.
By the autumn of the year 1263,
Parliament itself had become another area of conflict.
Tensions there helped renew open hostility,
and the Royalists succeeded in placing Simon under
increasing pressure in London.
With few alternatives left, Simon argued that the
dispute should be submitted to Louis IX of France for arbitration.
Louis was widely respected for
his piety and reputation for justice,
and both sides hoped that his ruling might settle the
crisis. Simon himself was unable to appear before Louis
because he had suffered from a broken leg,
but the baronial cause was still presented.
In January of the year 1264, Louis issued his
judgment. The decision strongly favoured Henry.
Louis annulled the provisions of Oxford and
effectively restored the king's authority
to govern without the restrictions that Simon had
fought to preserve. For Simon the ruling was a severe blow.
He had returned to England specifically
quickly to restore the reforms,
and now an outside judgement had swept them aside. Simon
and his closest supporters refused to give up.
The last real chance of peace had disappeared.
Within weeks, England was again descending into open civil war.
For a short time, both
sides moved through the country gathering men,
money and support, rather than immediately
risking everything in a major battle.
The kingdom was dividing into royalist and baronial
camps and violence spread with it.
By the spring of the year 1264, the conflict
could no longer be contained.
Henry's forces had gained ground and by May, the royal army
had reached Lewes in Sussex,
where the king intended to pause and wait for reinforcements.
The King remained with much of the infantry,
while Prince Edward commanded the Royal Cavalry
from Lewes Castle, a short distance away.
Simon meanwhile approached from the north,
with a smaller army, and still hoped that
a settlement might be possible before blood was shed.
Simon attempted to negotiate, but Henry rejected his approach.
Realising that battle was now unavoidable, Simon made a bold decision.
Under cover of darkness, he moved his army to the high ground.
The night march caught the royalists by surprise,
and gave Simon one of the most important advantages
he could have hoped for.
The royal army was probably significantly larger than Simon's force.
Simon divided his army into four sections.
His son Henry commanded one division, Gilbert de Clare another.
While a contingent of Londoners
stood under Nicholas de Segrave,
Simon himself remained with the final division, which served
as a reserve. To help distinguish friend
from enemy in the confusion of battle, Simon's
men wore white crosses on their clothing.
The battle began at dawn, Simon's forces
surprised royalist foragers,
and quickly forced the King's army into action. Prince Edward then
launched a fierce cavalry charge against
the Londoners on the left of Simon's line.
The attack was devastating.
The London contingent broke and fled, and Edward pursued them for
several miles.
At first, Edward's charge appeared to be a great success.
In reality, it became one
of the decisive mistakes of the battle.
By chasing the fleeing Londoners so far from the field,
Edward removed a large part of the Royalist cavalry
from the struggle at the moment when
Henry needed it most.
The Prince had won his own fight, but in doing so, he left his father
dangerously exposed.
Henry and the remaining royal divisions then advanced uphill against
Simon's position.
Fighting uphill placed the Royalists at a disadvantage, and Richard of
Cornwall's division began to falter.
Henry's men fought stubbornly, but Simon deliberately kept
part of his force back.
When the moment came, he committed his reserve against the exhausted
Royalists. The pressure became too much.
Henry's army was driven back down the hill towards Lewes.
The retreat became confused as royalist soldiers attempted
to reach the safety of the town,
castle and priory. Richard of Cornwall failed to reach the priory
and took refuge in a windmill
where he was eventually discovered and captured.
His hiding place soon became the subject of
mockery among the victorious rebels.
When Edward finally returned from his long pursuit,
he found a completely different battlefield from the one he had left.
His father's army had been
defeated, important royalists had fled or been captured,
and parts of the Lewes were in chaos.
Edward attempted to organize a counter-attack,
but the royal position was already collapsing.
With little realistic chance of reversing the defeat,
negotiations began. The result was one
of the most extraordinary victories of Simon's life.
Henry III was effectively in his hands,
Richard of Cornwall had been captured
and Prince Edward was forced to submit as part of the
settlement. The King had entered the battle as the ruler of England
and left it unable to exercise
power freely. The agreement that followed became known
as the Mise of Lewes. The original document
has not survived, so its precise terms are uncertain,
but Henry was forced to accept
the return of the reforming system associated
with the provisions of Oxford. Most importantly,
Prince Edward remained in the hands of the barons as a hostage,
ensuring that Henry could
not easily abandon the agreement.
This changed Simon's position completely. Before Lewes,
He had been the leader of a rebellion attempting
to force the king to accept reform.
After the battle, he controlled the king himself.
Henry remained monarch in name,
but Simon now possessed the military and political power
to determine how the kingdom was governed.
After Loos, Simon used his victory to rebuild
the government around the reforms first introduced
to Oxford in the year 1258.
Henry remained king, but the balance of power had changed completely.
The crown still existed,
royal documents continued to be issued in Henry's name, and the king
retained his title.
In practice, however, the most important decisions
were now controlled by a council, dominated
by Simon.
This allowed him to rule without openly removing Henry from the throne.
Rather than declaring himself king,
he governed through the existing monarchy.
provided the legal authority of the crown,
while Simon controlled the political machinery behind
it. Important decisions were now expected to pass through the council.
The parliament became
an increasingly important part of this new system.
Simon's position was powerful, but also fragile.
Many of the greatest barons distrusted him,
and some had already began to distance themselves
from his regime. To strengthen his government,
he looked beyond the traditional circle of bishops
and great nobles, and tried to draw wider sections
of the political community into national affairs.
This became especially clear in the parliament he summoned
in the year 1265. Simon sent writs
in the king's name to the counties across England,
asking each to send two knights.
He also summoned representatives from a number of towns and boroughs,
again usually two from each place.
These representatives were chosen locally
and came to Westminster to take part in the work of Parliament.
Simon did not invent elected representation from nothing.
Knights from the counties had already been summoned
to Parliament before his rise to power.
In the year 1254, for example,
Henry III had ordered elected knights from the Shires to attend
while he was away in Gascony and in need of financial support.
Simon had been present in that political world and understood the
usefulness of bringing county representatives into national government.
What made the Parliament of the year 1265 especially important
was that Simon went further.
He brought together not only nobles, bishops and knights,
but also representatives from towns and
boroughs. These men were not aristocrats.
They came from urban communities that were becoming
increasingly important to the wealth
and administration of the kingdom. This did not
create democracy in the modern sense.
Even so, the importance of Simon's parliament should not
be underestimated. By summoning county knights
and borough representatives together, he helped
strengthen the idea that national government
could involve more than the king, the bishops
and the great lords.
In time, this broader representation would become one of the
foundations of the House of Commons.
Simon's motives were not purely idealistic. He needed
political support. His government depended on a narrow group of allies,
and the loyalty of the
great barons could not be taken for granted.
By calling representatives from counties and towns,
he widened the base of support for his regime,
and gave his government a stronger claim to speak for
the wider kingdom. For that reason,
the parliament of the year 1265 was both a practical political
move and an important constitutional development.
Simon de Montfort was trying to secure his
own position, but in doing so,
he helped establish a pattern of representation that later kings
would continue to expand. For a time after the parliament of the year
1265, Simon de Montfort appeared to have secured
his position at the head of the English government.
Henry III remained under his control,
Prince Edward was still a prisoner, and Simon's
allies held many of the most important positions in the kingdom.
But beneath the surface, his authority was beginning to weaken.
The very coalition that had brought him
to power was starting to break apart, and some
of the men who had once fought beside him,
now feared that Simon and his family had become
too powerful.
One of the first signs of trouble came with Robert de Ferrers,
the Earl of Derby, who
was arrested and imprisoned in the Tower of London.
Far more damaging, however,
was the growing hostility of Gilbert de Clare, the Earl of
Gloucester.
Gilbert had become one of Simon's most important allies,
and had played a major part in the
victory at Loos.
By the spring of the year 1265, however, he had turned against Simon.
defection was a serious blow,
because Gilbert controlled vast lands, considerable wealth,
and important military influence in the west of England.
Simon's position became even more
dangerous when Prince Edward escaped from captivity.
Edward had spent almost a year
under Simon's control,
but in the year 1265 he broke free and joined forces with Gilbert de
Clare and other royalist supporters.
This transformed the political situation almost
overnight. Simon had lost control of the heir to the throne
and the royalists now possessed
a young, energetic
and increasingly capable commander around whom they could rally.
With many powerful lords now moving against him,
Simon desperately needed new allies.
He therefore turned to Llywelyn ap Gruffydd, the Prince of Wales.
Llywelyn agreed to support him,
but only in return for major concessions.
Simon recognised his title,
and accepted many of the territorial gains he had made in Wales
along the border.
The alliance provided Simon with much needed troops,
but it also damaged his reputation
among English nobles.
To some of his former supporters,
it appeared that Simon was giving away English claims
in Wales, simply to save his own government.
What had once presented as a movement to reform
England was beginning to look, to his enemies at least,
like a struggle to preserve Simon's
personal power. Edward, meanwhile, moved rapidly.
He attacked Gloucester, an important crossing
point on the River Severn, and captured the town by the end of June.
Control of the Severn
became central to the campaign
because it restricted Simon's movements and made it
increasingly difficult for him to join the forces of his son,
Simon the Younger. Simon
now found himself trapped in the west.
His best hope was to unite with his son's army
and then confront Edward with their combined forces.
The younger Simon was moving westward
from London, but he moved too slowly.
By the time he reached the great Montfort stronghold,
Edward already recognised the danger and was preparing to strike.
Simon the Younger himself
escaped, but much of the force that was supposed
to reinforce his father had been scattered,
captured or killed.
The elder Simon did not yet fully understand how badly his son had been
weakened. Edward then turned south.
He had also captured a number of Montforian banners during
the attack, these would soon play an important part
in the final deception that drew Simon
towards disaster. Simon eventually managed to cross the River Severn
and moved towards Evesham,
still hoping to meet his son.
Edward, however, had already placed himself between the two Montfort
forces. On the 4th of August of the year 1265,
Simon found himself trapped near Evesham,
In a bend of the River Avon,
the bridge and northern approaches were controlled by the
royalists, leaving him with few ways to escape.
At first, Simon appears to have believed that an
approaching force might belong to his son.
The banners visible in the distance seem to support
that hope, but they were the Montforian banners Edward had captured.
When Simon realised what had
happened, he understood that he had been deceived and surrounded.
Simon had recognised that Edward
had learned the art of war
from the very methods Simon himself had once used. Edward had learned
from his defeat at Loos.
This time the Royalists occupied the high ground on Green Hill,
north of Evesham. Edward commanded one side of the army,
while Gilbert de Clare commanded the other.
Unlike at Loos, the Royal Army would not allow itself
to be broken apart by any reckless pursuit.
Simon's army was heavily outnumbered.
Contemporary estimates vary, but later accounts often suggest
that the Royalists may have had roughly twice as many men.
As Simon left Evesham in the morning,
a violent thunderstorm was beginning,
adding to the darkness and confusion of the battlefield.
At Lewes, Simon's supporters had worn
the white crosses as a sign of their cause. At
Evesham, the Royalists adopted a similar symbol,
wearing red crosses of their own. Simon understood
that a long defensive battle offered little hope.
His best chance was to concentrate his
forces and attempt to break directly through
the centre of Edward's line. The attack
initially made some progress, but the royalists quickly recovered.
Simon's Welsh infantry proved
unable to hold the wider line,
and parts of the force began to give way. The royalist wings then
closed around Simon's army.
What had begun as an attempt to break through, rapidly became an
encirclement. With the river behind him,
and Edward's troops blocking the routes ahead,
Simon had almost nowhere to retreat.
The battle turned into a massacre. The bitterness left by
Lewes was still fresh.
Many royalists had spent the previous year imprisoned, dispossessed,
or humiliated under Simon's government,
and they showed little willingness to take prisoners.
In normal medieval warfare,
noblemen were often captured alive because they could be exchanged
or ransomed. At Evesham, many were simply killed.
The chronicler Robert of Gloucester later
described the event as the murder of Evesham,
suggesting that it had become something more
terrible than an ordinary battle.
Simon's eldest son Henry was among the first great casualties.
He was killed in the fighting
while he was still a relatively young man. There was a bitter irony in
his death. Simon had named him Henry years earlier
in honour of King Henry when the two
families had still been close.
Now he died fighting against the forces trying to restore
that same kings freedom.
King Henry III was still Simon's prisoner and had been brought
onto the battlefield with the rebel army.
To make matters even more dangerous he was
wearing colours associated with Simon's forces.
In the confusion of the fighting, the royalist
soldiers did not immediately recognise their own king.
Henry came close to being killed by the men
who were fighting to rescue him.
He was eventually recognised and saved by a knight, who was a former
rebel who had returned to the royalist cause.
The king who had spent more than a year effectively
under Simon's control, was finally free.
Contemporary accounts remembered Simon de Montfort
as fighting with extraordinary courage at Evesham.
Even when the battle had clearly turned against
him, he did not flee.
His army was surrounded, his eldest son Henry had been killed, and the
royalists were closing in from every side.
Yet Simon continued to fight. Later chroniclers
portrayed him as fully aware that the battle was lost.
According to one tradition, when he saw
Edward's army advancing in a disciplined formation,
Simon recognised how skilfully the royalists had
prepared the trap.
The famous words later attributed to him suggest that he understood
death was near, but he chose to face it rather than surrender.
Simon was eventually unhorsed
in the fighting. Even then,
he is described as continuing on foot, surrounded by the remains
of his household and closest supporters.
The struggle around him became desperate and personal,
with little chance of mercy.
His courage at the end helped shape the way later admirers
remembered him. To his enemies,
he was a dangerous rebel who had overreached and paid the price.
his supporters, he died as a warrior who refused to abandon his cause.
Fighting to the very
last moments of his life, Simon's death did not end the violence.
His enemies mutilated
his corpse with extraordinary brutality.
His head, hands, feet and genitals were cut from
his body, and different parts were carried away.
The treatment of his remains were intended
to make an example of him.
Simon had defeated and imprisoned an anointed king, held the
heir to the throne in captivity,
and ruled England through the authority of the crown.
To the victorious royalists,
his body became a warning of what awaited anyone who tried
to do the same. Accounts of exactly what happened
to every part of Simon's body differ, and
later stories became increasingly elaborate.
What is clear, is that the corpse was deliberately
dismembered and pieces were scattered around the kingdom.
English heritage records that
his remains were distributed as a warning to potential rebels.
What remained of Simon's body was buried at Evesham Abbey,
but the attempt to disgrace
him produced an unexpected result.
Almost immediately after his death, admirers began
visiting the place where he was believed to lie.
Stories of miracles circulated, and Simon
Simon began to be remembered by some of his former supporters,
not simply as a defeated
rebel, but almost as a martyr.
Pilgrims came to his supposed grave, seeking healing and
divine favour. He was never formally recognised as a saint,
but a popular cult grew around
his memory.
The Royalists now moved quickly
to dismantle what remained of Simon's government. At
a parliament held at Winchester in September of the year 1265.
Those who had taken part
in the rebellion were declared disinherited.
Their estates could be confiscated and transferred
to loyal supporters of the crown.
For many surviving rebels, this meant losing not only
political influence,
but the lands upon which their wealth and status depended.
Simon de Montfort's death at Evesham shattered
the political power of his family. His eldest
son Henry was killed beside him,
while his surviving sons were driven abroad or forced
to build their lives elsewhere.
His wife Eleanor of England withdrew to Dover after the battle,
but eventually left England for France,
where she remained until her death in the year 1275.
Simon the Younger continued resistance for a time,
while another son Guy de Montfort
later established himself in Italy.
Guy's branch of the family survived on the continent.
But the Montforts never recovered their former position in England.
Their political dynasty
had effectively been broken. Simon's daughter Eleanor married Llywelyn
of Griffith, the Prince of Wales,
linking the Montfort family to the last great independent
ruler of medieval Wales.
She died in childbirth in the year 1282, and Llywelyn was later killed
that same year during Edward I's conquest of Wales.
Their daughter Gwellian was placed
in a convent where she spent the rest of her life.
Although Simon's family lost its place
at the centre of English politics, his reputation
survived. Some remembered him as a dangerous rebel,
while others saw him as a defender
of reform and good government.
His Parliament of 1265, which brought together nobles, clergy,
and representatives from towns became one
of the most important parts of his legacy.
Simon did not create modern democracy,
and his rule was far from perfect,
but he helped strengthen the idea
that the king should not govern entirely alone.
His rebellion failed, his family was scattered,
and his body was brutally mutilated,
yet his name remained closely tied
to the long development of Parliament,
and the idea that royal power should be subject to law
and consultation.