The Cleverly Hidden Meaning Behind This Painting Will Blow Your Mind!

William Holman Hunt
2 followers
Take a look at this painting and think about what it could possibly be about.
I know that there is a lot going on in this painting and it can be difficult to understand
everything all at once. So take your time, pause the video if you want to and get a good look at it.
Done? Let me walk you through it. A shepherd is sitting close to a woman,
trying to show her something cool he found. Clearly the man is not good at his job.
Look at the sheep behind him. They're all going away here and there.
While the scene might look very simple and the colours would lead you to believe that it's a
very light-hearted painting about these two lovebirds, there's actually a very serious and
quite dark message behind this painting. You may not be able to see it but the painter has cleverly
hidden the seven deadly sins in this painting. This simple looking painting once created a
big controversy and even to this date people are debating about the meaning of this painting.
So let me explain to you what this painting named The Highling Shepherd by William Holman Hunt
actually means in this episode of Artsight. Before you get into the meaning, let's take a
closer look at the scene. There is so much going on in this painting but while everything in the
scene looks chaotic, don't mistake it for some senseless addition by the artist. Every little
detail in the painting serves a purpose and adds to the overall meaning of the painting.
First, we see the Highling Shepherd who has found a death's head moth and is quite
fascinated by it. He shows it to the woman who seems to be his lover or perhaps prospective
lover who is still on the fence about him. I mean, look at her. The expression says it all, right?
A baby lamb sits on a lap and munches on some apple while some sheep in the background are
lying on the ground. But a few of them are heading towards the pastures of corn and wheat.
You can see two of them have already reached the wheat fields while others won't take long.
I don't know about the shepherd but what's going on behind him will not look good on his job
application. And trust me, he's gonna need one. It's like a barista adding heavy cream milk when
the lady said she wanted a vegan latte. The shepherd had one job and he has made a mess.
So what could be the reason for it? If you look at his flushed face,
it might indicate that he's jollier than usual. But how can you blame him? His love is sitting
right beside him. The sky is clear. Green lands all across. Oh, this explains a lot.
The keg filled with meat could be the reason that the shepherd has ignored his herd
and is lost in impressing the girl. I mean, you tried doing your job after four glasses of wine.
So is that it? That's the controversial meaning of the painting. A good-for-nothing shepherd
ignoring his sheep? Yes, it was the literal meaning of the painting. But now let's come
to the exciting metaphorical meaning. First, the shepherd is showing his love a death's head moth,
something that is often associated with bad luck or an impending disaster. Ironically,
a disaster is happening right behind him but the man is so lost that he cannot even turn around
and look at it. Then you have the woman all dressed in red, a color that is often associated
with temptation and here temptation is certainly taking control over the man. But all that aside,
did you notice that this painting is also showing the seven deadly sins? Let me show you. The lamb
of the lap of the woman is covered in red cloth, enjoying green ripe apples in pride, not knowing
that sour apples are poisonous to lambs. Then at the back we see another sheep looking at the
wheat field and the greed has taken over it as it walks towards it. Some other sheep are looking at
this greedy sheep with envy, soon greed will take over them as well. But another sheep is already
there, eating the wheat as much as it can, gluttony. Two sheep in the background are engaged in a fight
showing wrath. You can see a few sheep just lying down in the ground, sloth. Finally, the last of the
deadly sins, lust has been shown by the man here. So you can see that this simple looking painting
is actually showing the seven deadly sins in a clever way. Now let's move to the overall meaning
of this painting and it is going to blow your mind. I've seen so many people and publications
claiming that the meaning of this painting is about the rise of industrialization and how the
painter William Hallman Hunt expressed his concerns through this painting. Oh god, I'm not reading all
of that. But the meaning of the painting is very simple and people should stop over analyzing it.
The painting is not about industrialization or about the loss of our ecosystem but it's about
the religious unrest that was prevalent in England at that time. The painting also came with an excerpt
included by the artist. It was taken from Edgar's song from the play King Lear by Shakespeare.
It gives us a good idea about what the painter wanted to show. Sleepest or wakest thou, jolly
We all know that in Christianity, Jesus is the good shepherd. He cares for his people who are
referred to as sheep. But then there's the Highling Shepherd, one that you can see here in this
painting. Hunt used this Highling Shepherd to represent the pastors and clergymen and every
other religious leader who, instead of guiding people in the right direction, were too lost in
useless debates and discussions. How do I know that this is what the painter wanted to show
through his painting and not some ecological message about saving the environment? Well,
because he explained the meaning of the painting in a letter. Here's what he said.
Discuss vain questions of no value to any human soul. My fool has found a death's head moth and
this fills his mind with forebodings of evil and he takes it to an equally sage counselor for her
opinion. She scorns his anxiety from ignorance rather than profundity but only the more distracts
his faithfulness. While she feeds her lamb with sour apples, his sheep have burst bounds and got
into the corn. It is not merely that the wheat will be spoiled but on eating it the heap are
doomed to destruction from becoming what farmers call blown. The painting worked as a guide towards
the pastors and other religious leaders who did not care about the people, the very people who
trusted them. Do note that this painting was made in 1851 during the Victorian Compromise. It was a
time when people assumed that industrialization would improve the society. However, the opposite
happened. Disease, poverty, death, religious unrest. Hence the painter made a painting that
might look like a beautiful scene but it shows the calm before a disaster, a tragedy in making.
But then, what was all the controversy about? The controversy was not because of the meaning
of the painting but because of how it was portrayed. Hunt had used these two people in
a negative light. Notice their auburn hair and reddish face. These people belonged to the working
class and were considered to be illiterate and coarse. The controversy was that the artist used
these people to target them and express his prejudice against the working class. While it
may have been true, I cannot tell for sure. The next time I sit with Mr. Hunt, I'll surely inquire
about it. But the reason why I think he was not trying to demean the working class through this
painting was because he had no other choice. He had to show the working class doing the work, right?
He could not put a gentleman in a frog suit and a fine moustache sitting on the ground
taking care of the sheep. And that was all about the painting and the hidden meaning behind it.
I hope you liked the video. But tell me what do you think about this painting? Do you think that
there is another meaning behind it or did the artist intentionally put these people in the
painting to demean them? The comment section is all yours. Do give it a like and subscribe to the
channel if you want to watch more videos. Till we meet next time, have a great day.
