This Painting Hides A Disturbing Secret
4 Video Views·Aug 20, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Beautiful, isn't it? Summer by the sea. A sleepy seaside town, sailboats, locals lounging in lazy
poses. But how long has this body been lying here? And how is it connected to this knife?
Wait, what is this over here? If you didn't know that this 16th century painting by the
Flemish artist Pieter Brueghel the Elder is called Landscape with the Fall of Icarus.
You wouldn't even see any Icarus here. You might notice, though not immediately,
these two legs. And only then, the splash. The scattered feathers. Oh right, that's probably
Icarus who was told not to fly too high or he'd crash. His father Daedalus, a famous inventor,
created wings out of feathers and wax to escape from King Minos of Crete, the guy with the minotaur
and all that drama. But let's take it from the top. How did Icarus and Daedalus end up in this
situation? King Minos' wife, Pasiphae, fell in love with a prize bull, a curse placed on her
by the god Poseidon. She asked the famous inventor Daedalus to come up with a way to seduce the bull.
So Daedalus built a hollow wooden cow that Pasiphae could climb inside to trick the bull.
And it worked. As a result, Pasiphae gave birth to a creature that was half bull, half human.
The infamous minotaur. And her husband Minos was absolutely not thrilled about this.
So he locked the inventor Daedalus at the top of the highest tower in Crete.
This structure in the painting gives us an idea of what that tower might have looked like.
The only way to escape was through the air. So Daedalus built wings and explained to his son
that he shouldn't fly too low. Or the sea would soak the feathers and not too high. Or the sun
would melt the wax. But Icarus started fooling around. Flew too high. The sun melted the wax
and he fell and drowned in the sea, which has been called the Icarian Sea ever since.
Quite a tragedy. We know all this from the ancient Roman poet Ovid. From his work
Metamorphoses. But if the painting is about a tragedy, why does it take up so little space
while this guy with a plow is front and center? You might even think this painting is about him,
not Icarus. And this leads to the first incorrect interpretation of this painting.
Incorrect, but thrilling. Look closely. Near the furrow that the plowman recently dug,
you can spot a lifeless body that has been lying there for a while. The plowman has passed the
body with his plow more than once and had to have noticed it. Yet he hasn't tried to do anything or
called for help. We can see the shepherd down below is clearly oblivious to the situation.
He just keeps following the plow, furrow after furrow, and pretty soon he'll finish his work
and get as far away from here as possible. Taking with him this long dagger and this purse,
presumably full of money. Exactly. The plowman's red shirt isn't the brightest spot in the painting
by accident, nor is he in the foreground for no reason. Bruegel is showing us a murderer.
The plowman killed this poor guy with that very dagger for the sake of that purse.
He hid the body in the bushes, and to avoid drawing attention, he continues plowing as if
nothing happened, tries not to look in the victim's direction, and generally tries to
keep a low profile. That's exactly why he didn't even turn toward Icarus. Sure, he might not have
seen the actual fall, but he definitely should have heard the scream of a boy plummeting from
the sky. There you go, the mystery of the painting is solved. Pack it up, we're done here.
This, as I mentioned, is a completely incorrect interpretation of the painting.
Why it's wrong, I'll explain a bit later when we get back to that guy in the bushes.
For now, let's finish with the plowman. Many researchers point out this foot here.
The plowman is stepping onto a freshly plowed furrow, and supposedly, a real plowman wouldn't
do that. Anyone who has ever watched a person walk behind a plow might argue that this is
exactly how it works. When you're following a plow, you simply have no other options of where
to step. But admittedly, there's something deliberate about this step itself, and how it's
depicted in the painting. It's as if the plowman is intentionally stepping on the freshly plowed
furrow, as if he doesn't value the fruits of his own labor. Add his clothes to the mix.
Seriously, isn't he dressed a bit too sharply for a plowman? And we get another explanation.
The figure in the foreground isn't a plowman, but King Philip II of Spain, under whose rule
Bruegel's native Flanders was at the time. Next to Philip lies a long dagger, symbolizing the
wars this king is fighting. And the purse symbolizes the equally endless taxes Philip
collects from the Flemish to pay for those wars. These are the only two things the king cares about.
It's all he's even capable of thinking about. Aside from war and taxes, he doesn't give a damn
about anything. Not freshly plowed furrows, not corpses in the bushes, and certainly not a boy
falling from the sky. Quite plausible. I won't claim that this is definitely untrue. Bruegel
often used political satire in his work, and had a lot to say about the current events of his time.
So I won't completely rule out the theory that the Spanish king is the one walking behind the plow
here. But in any case, if there is a political element to this painting, it's far from the main
one. After all, the painting is about the fall of Icarus, yet in the foreground we have the Spanish
king, a local with a dog, and a fishing enthusiast. Let's get back to Ovid. Describing
the flight of Icarus and Daedalus, he literally writes the following,
Every fisherman with a trembling rod, or shepherd with a crook, or plowman leaning on his plow,
who saw them flying freely through the sky, stood frozen, taking them for unearthly gods.
Everything matches up in Bruegel's painting. The plowman, the shepherd, the fisherman,
with one minor difference. Nobody stands frozen, and nobody pays any attention to them whatsoever.
The plowman, as we've established, doesn't even turn his head. The shepherd is looking in the
opposite direction. And the fisherman, even though he's the closest to the fallen Icarus,
is clearly focused on his fishing rod. This is a crucial motif for Bruegel.
Suffering happens right in the middle of ordinary, everyday life. The indifference of everyday life
is an essential part of suffering. And suffering is just a part of everyday life.
In The Harvesters, the suffering happens in the background, and all the characters in the
In Two Monkeys, two free birds soaring in the sky are entirely indifferent to the chained-up
monkeys. In Icarus, no one noticed the boy falling from the sky, and no one changed their plans.
Even the ship has its back to Icarus, continuing its course away from him.
In this whole painting, there are only two truly interesting mysteries left.
First, what is the shepherd looking at? Because if you follow his gaze,
there's absolutely nothing there. And second, the sun. Why is it so low? And how could it
have melted the wax on Icarus' wings when he foolishly flew too high and got too close to it?
Let's start with the shepherd, then we'll quickly tackle the mystery of the body in
the bushes and come back to the sun. It's true that if you follow the shepherd's gaze,
it seems he's looking at nothing. But in reality, he's looking at Daedalus.
This is a copy of Bruegel's painting by an unknown artist.
Paintings about the fall of Icarus were popular, and Daedalus was always in them.
It was important for the narrative to show the father's tragedy,
his loss. And the copyist most likely couldn't say no to his client.
The client probably asked him to add Daedalus so that everything would be
proper and easy to understand. So the artist followed the shepherd's gaze and added the
flying father right there, even though Bruegel had nothing there originally.
Here I have to make a disclaimer. The painting we've been discussing this whole time
is also a copy. Yeah, I know it's one of Bruegel's most famous paintings,
one of his calling cards. For instance, Andrei Tarkovsky, in that famous scene from Solaris
where he shows Bruegel's Hunters in the Snow, also shows Bruegel's Icarus.
But a few years ago, the painting was x-rayed with infrared light,
and it turned out that the underdrawing wasn't done in Bruegel's style at all.
So it's not Bruegel, but an early copy, which, although better executed than the
one with Daedalus, is still not the original. The original is seemingly lost forever.
But we know that even though the brushstrokes and paints aren't Bruegel's, the composition,
the placement of the figures, and the plot are definitely his.
Now, about the body in the bushes. As the scans revealed, Bruegel didn't have a dead body there.
Instead, as you might expect from Bruegel, there was a man with his pants down, calmly relieving
himself. In Bruegel's paintings, a man relieving himself is kind of like a game of
I Spy. It's genuinely hard to spot, but it's almost always there. It's a signature easter
egg expressing, depending on the circumstances, absolute contempt or extreme indifference.
In Icarus, it amplifies the apathy of the surrounding world.
People literally couldn't give a crap about Icarus's flight and his death.
Why was it replaced? Most likely, it was the client again.
The guy was planning to hang it on his wall, maybe even in his dining room.
And while you might let Bruegel himself get away with that, you can certainly ask a humble
copyist to change it to something a bit more decent. Plus, the copyist actually managed to
capture Bruegel's metaphor quite accurately by replacing the defecating man with a corpse.
While the original showed the ultimate degree of indifference to the world's tragedies,
the copyist created an illustration of a famous Flemish proverb,
no plow stops for a dying man. It's essentially the same message, but now it's not embarrassing
to show it to guests. The plowman didn't stop for a dead body just a few steps away,
let alone some guy drowning down below. Now let's get to the most important part.
Why doesn't Bruegel have Daedalus? Why is the shepherd looking either after the departed
Daedalus, or deliberately pointing his gaze at an empty space where he should be?
Why is the sun painted so low that it couldn't have melted the wax and killed Icarus?
And what is this painting actually about, if not a cold-blooded murder, a father's tragedy,
or a piece of political satire? Ovid writes a strange thing. After Icarus fell from the sky
and died, somewhere in a marsh, Ovid writes, a partridge joyfully flapped its wings.
Why a partridge of all things? What does it care about the sea and someone dying out there?
But then Ovid explains why it cares, telling us how this whole story actually started,
and how Daedalus even ended up on the island of Crete with King Minos in the first place,
from whom he later had to escape through the sky. The thing is, he didn't just casually show up in
Crete. He had been exiled from Athens beforehand, and exiled for a terrible crime. Daedalus had a
nephew. His name was Perdix. From a young age, he showed extraordinary talent and invented all
sorts of incredible things. For example, he looked at a fish's spine and invented the saw.
He also invented the compass. Daedalus realized that when the boy grew up,
he would eclipse his fame as a great inventor, and he couldn't cope with this obsessive thought.
He lured Perdix to the top of the Athenian Acropolis and pushed him off. It was the
murder of an innocent child. The goddess Athena, who favored Perdix, managed to turn him into a
partridge just in time. Ever since then, the partridge has been afraid of heights and flies
low, remembering its fall. In Bruegel's painting, the partridge isn't joyfully flapping its wings
out in some marsh. Sitting right by the sea isn't a seagull or some other seabird. It's an easily
recognizable marsh partridge sitting right there, as close as possible to the son of its murderer.
This isn't just an origin myth about why the partridge flies low. Just like the myth of
Icarus isn't simply about how you shouldn't fly too high or the sun will burn you. These myths
don't just sit side by side by accident. Essentially, they are the exact same story.
Two boys put on feathers. One wears the wings of his father, the other the wings of the goddess
Athena. One dies after flying too high. The other falls but is saved and forever flies too low.
One is rescued from captivity by his father, but this leads to his death. The other is almost
killed by that same father, but the victim is saved and now watches the son of his attempted
murderer die. The fall and the feathers, high and low, death and salvation, crime and punishment.
It's perfect symmetry. This painting isn't about the grief of a father, who isn't even here,
nor is it about the sun that was too high and melted the wax. It's a painting about the
restoration of harmony in a world where justice has prevailed, and the world didn't even notice.
It just kept plowing, sailing, staring into nothingness, engaging in politics and war,
just like before. The victim is avenged. Icarus will soon sink to the bottom,
and the fish will eat him. That fish will be caught by the fisherman on his rod. He'll take
it home and eat it too. He might even share it with the shepherd and the plowman. That is exactly
how every story ends. Even one about flying to the sky. Of course, a lot of questions are still
left unanswered. Why exactly did Icarus die? Is he just an innocent victim? I mean, Daedalus
committed the crime and faced the punishment, so does that make Icarus just collateral damage?
Not quite. Artists have been wrestling with this question for centuries. One of the most recent
examples is the show The White Lotus. They actually have their own Icarus, too. I break
down his death, along with the reasons why he had to die, over on my Patreon. The video on why Icarus
had to die is being edited right now and will be up very soon. Click the link in the description
and subscribe. Thanks for your time.

