The Awakening Conscience

William Holman Hunt
2 followers
Well now, here we have a painting created by an artist called William Holman Hunt.
He was one of the founding members of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood. He painted this in
1853. It was a commission and he called it the Awakening Conscience. And what we have in the
painting are two young people, a man seated in front of a piano and rising from his lap
is a young woman. She seems to be gazing over our shoulders and there's a mirror behind the
couple which shows us the scene which she might be staring at out of some double windows.
Now when we look at this painting from the perspective of the 21st century there are
some things about it that we're actually quite blind to but they would have been obvious to a
19th century viewer. The most significant one is that this woman is not wearing a dress.
She's wearing her nightdress and hastily tied around her waist is the counterpane from a bed.
They'd also have realised that she's very late in getting out of bed in the morning that the
young man is dressed and ready to go visiting but she's still in her nightclothes. So that
makes this a fairly scandalous painting of a young woman who keeps unusual hours and who
finds herself inappropriately dressed in an intimate situation with a young man.
The other thing which would have been obvious to contemporary viewers would be the uncharacteristic
untidiness of this Victorian sitting room. If we look down at the floor we see all sorts of
things scattered about. The young man has tossed his glove aside it's landed on the carpet and
there are strands of wool which have fallen from a tapestry which we imagine the young woman has
been working on which is unravelling. Tapestries of course featured in the Odyssey where Penelope
waiting for her husband Odysseus to return from the Trojan Wars famously used her tapestry
to maintain her fidelity to her husband while he was away but this tapestry is actually falling
apart. And here's another collection of little clues or cues placed in the painting by the
artist. On the piano music stand although we can't see it clearly in this reproduction
is some sheet music and it's the music of the setting of Thomas More's poem
Oft in the Stilly Night and this is a sentimental poem which regrets the happier days
which are gone because true friends are no more. We also see on top of the piano
a vase of flowers and the flowers are beginning to droop and fade as though they've not been
cared for or properly watered and there's a clock and the clock is encased in a glass dome
so within this sitting room time itself has been imprisoned and taken captive.
And again the quality of this reproduction doesn't allow us to read this but tossed aside
on the floor is a musical setting of Alfred Lord Tennyson's poem Tears Idle Tears which was just
published just a few years before this painting was completed. A poem which speaks about the
regret of happy times which are past and to add to the general chaos of the room. Underneath the
table there's a cat which is toying with a trapped bird. It's already torn one of its wings and
from what we know about cats it's not going to kill the bird immediately it's going to play with
it and cause it a great deal of suffering before it finally dies. And when we look at the hands of
the couple we see that the man with his one remaining gloved hand is idly playing a tune on
the piano. His other hand appears to be open in a gesture where he might be protesting a point or
asking for an explanation but it's the woman's hands which are most eloquent.
They're clasped together there as it were she is wringing her hands and we can see her left hand on
top and on the fingers of those hands on all but one finger there are rings and of course the one
finger without a ring is her wedding finger. So this is a picture of what the artist considered
to be an immoral situation. Two unmarried young people in an intimate position without a chaperone
alone in what we presume is either her apartment or an apartment which he has provided for her.
Now the woman is in the moment just rising from the lap of the young man as though she has
suddenly realised something or one might say come to her senses. She seems to be staring out of the
possibly at the scene we see reflected in the mirror which is a scene of springtime where
new life is bursting from the otherwise apparently dead branches of a tree in the garden.
Now the woman who posed as the model for the young woman in this painting is a lady called
Annie Miller. We know this from notes about the painting itself but also because she was
used as a model by a number of the other Pre-Raphaelite painters. We don't have any
account as far as I know from Annie Miller about her relationship with William Holman Hunt but we
do know that at the time of this painting they were engaged to each other. The relationship
actually broke up some six years later because Holman Hunt said that he found her behaviour
unacceptable and other male members of the Pre-Raphaelite brotherhood also reported
about her behaviour in fairly negative ways but we need to bear in mind that those are only the
accounts of the men who knew her and not her own account. The young man in the painting is
based on a friend of William Holman Hunt, a man called Augustus Egg who was himself
a painter and artist. Now Augustus Egg is famous or notorious for one particular set of paintings
which he created. They came to be known as his triptych which simply means three panels but
is often thought of as something which you find in a church. The first panel is a fairly stark one.
It shows a Victorian family. The man is slumped in a chair while two children play
unaware almost in the corner and in his hand he's clutching a letter.
We are led to understand from the things which the artist wrote that this man has received a
letter informing him of his wife's infidelity and at his feet we see his wife in an attitude
of pleading. Now the second panel shows a scene from a few years later and these are the two girls
in the first painting who are older now. One of them wears a black dress of mourning and
the artist tells us that what has happened is that their father has died from a broken heart
and their mother is nowhere to be seen. She is elsewhere as far as we know from this painting
and the two girls are living in what would have been called straightened circumstances.
The room is hardly furnished at all compared to the room that they grew up in as children
and this is a consequence of their mother's adulterous relationship.
Now the third and final painting in this set of three actually takes place on the same evening.
It's the same moon that we see in the sky there but the girls were staring at out of their window
but here we see their mother. She's clearly destitute and taken shelter in one of the
arches by the Thames. She seems to be carrying a child, an infant, whose legs are sticking out from
under her cloak or covering and we've got no indication about whether the child is alive
or dead. And just like Holman Hunt's painting, the artist Augustus Egg has scattered clues
around the scene. There's a poster on the wall of the arch advertising two plays,
one called Victims, the other called Cure of Love, which were both about unhappy marriages.
There's also a poster advertising pleasure excursions to Paris and we know from elsewhere
that the equivalent of travel agents promoted Paris as a destination, certainly for single
or even married men because of the attractions of the alleged loose morals of the women who
could be found there. So this is a very gloomy set of paintings to say the least
which purports to show the consequences of the infidelity, the adultery of a woman
in an otherwise happy marriage. I'm not going to say more about that at this point because it's a
subject all of its own. But these kind of paintings, sadly, were not that unusual in
the 19th century. There are a number of others of young women with babies being cast out of family
homes, women whose bodies are found drowned on the shores of the Thames having thrown themselves
and bridges in their despair and they are clearly pointing a very moralistic
finger at the responsibility of women in society. Let's get back to Holman Hunt's brighter picture
here. Then he's presented us with a couple in what he wants us to understand as an immoral
relationship and the woman is rising from his lap. It seems to be symbolic of her about to
decide to leave this corrosive relationship, a relationship which would be corrosive for both of
them and for her to set out on a new path. Now things aren't always what they seem in paintings.
This painting was a commission and when Holman Hunt originally painted it,
the young woman's face did not look like this. As far as I know, we don't have an image of what the
original face looked like. But the man for whom the painting was made, a Mr Thomas Fairburn,
an industrialist from Manchester, said that he could not live with the original painting
where the woman's expression was one of shocked despair. Someone who realised that for her there
was no hope and that the future was bleak to say the least. And he urged and required
Holman Hunt to change the face, which he did to this more hopeful expression.
We need to know that later in his life, Holman Hunt expressed his regret that he had changed
the face. Clearly he would have preferred a face which was full of despair rather than one
full of hope. And so here we are with this painting which on the face of it looks colourful
and when you see it on the walls of Tate Britain it certainly catches the eye. And yet to me it's
a very gloomy and judgmental painting. It is a painting where a male artist has put a heavy
weight on the shoulders of women and doesn't seem to have any judgment for the man involved
in the relationship. Victorian society was not as prudish as we've often grown up to believe
and yet this artist in his mid-thirties saw fit to create a work which makes these very severe
judgments on people in circumstances other than his own.
