The Christian Knight

Edmund Leighton
2 followers
1 Video View·Jun 8, 2025
With special guest Kathryn Ball (fellow 12th English teacher), we discuss the qualities of ancient knighthood. The painting is Edmund Leighton's "God Speed." By the way: this episode is far more entertaining when you replace "chevaux," french for "horses," with "cheveux" french for "hair."
Hello and welcome to Classical Stuff You Should Know. I'm Graham Donaldson and I'm joined today
by AJ Hannenberg. Here. And Catherine Ball. Here. A new addition to the podcast. Catherine,
in the tradition of the Classical Stuff You Should Know podcast, can you tell me,
tell the listeners a little bit, what did it, who you are and what you teach at Veritas and who you,
and your, what was it, what are the words you use, credentials? Credentials. Credentials. Your
street cred. Your classical cred. Your classical cred. Ooh, okay. Well, I was not warned of any
of this in advance, so I'm going to have to try to do this on the fly. Well, as was said just now,
my name is Catherine Ball. I teach 11th grade American literature. I co-teach 12th grade
literature with these fine gentlemen here, and a few other things. My previous experience with
classical education before coming to Veritas was being classically educated in grammar school,
and so classical education has been something near and dear to my heart for a very long time.
But enough about me. I am very anxious to hear what Graham has to share with us today. That's
right. Catherine, AJ and I are the great unwashed, whereas Catherine is the one that who has been
trained in classical education from birth. We had to go with unwashed. That's the phrasing
that we used. That's gross. No, like the hoi polloi. What in heaven's name does that mean?
All right. Maybe you all are the great unwashed. All right. So today's topic,
something that I have not evidently just displayed is about the virtue of the Christian
knight. So as a 10th grade teacher, I teach a lot of the Middle Ages stuff, and this talks about
in the 10th grade, we talk a lot about who or what is a Christian knight.
Now, a little bit about knighthood in historical context. So in the Middle Ages, the knight class
was this class that was sort of below the ruling class of the king and the aristocracy, but they
were above the peasants. And in the Middle Ages, you had this sort of weird technological thing
happen, and that is that all wars were fought with bladed weapons and with
pointy weapons. Yeah, swords and shields and lances and halberds and that kind of thing.
Actually, halberd is armor. But they invented this thing that was the mail, either full plate mail,
or they also had chain mail. It was very expensive to make, and only the upper class
could have it. And this meant that all of the rich people were invulnerable to dying in battle,
pretty much. It was incredibly rare for somebody who was wearing full plate mail or wearing chain
mail to actually die in war. And this created actually quite a really interesting social
problem. And that is, all of a sudden, you have the sort of the rich upper class members of society
who could essentially come out the other side of a battle virtually guaranteed of not dying.
This is not true for the peasantry. So this created a bit of a problem, especially for society. You
had these people who could throw their weight around. They could be actual jerks and know that
they could get away with it, because what is a peasant wearing a t-shirt going to do if these
people that were wealthy had plate mail or chain mail. And a horse. And a horse and all these
sorts of things. Claymore and nice weapons that weren't going to break. Exactly. And there was
nothing going to happen. Right. So what arose was this idea of chivalry. Now, chivalry first,
as the sort of name suggests, chivalry came from how to take care of your horse and how to do like
horsey stuff. Chevalier, cheveux is the French word for horse. I was wondering if you were going
to get around. Yeah. So cheveux is the French word for horse. So chivalry was like horse stuff.
But this became basically the code of conduct of what these knights were, how they were supposed
to act. If you were to take another knight captive, how do you negotiate his release?
If you were to win something in a pitched battle, how are you to sort of figure out,
because everyone's still alive at the end of it, they're sort of beaten up and hurt,
are all the aristocrats, all the knights are still alive. How do you now like figure out
where all the chips fall after some sort of conflict while you had this sort of code of
chivalry? So this sort of code of honorable conduct arose where you have these, this knightly class,
and they all sort of lived by this code of honor. And the topic for today is that there was a,
the highest, there was one virtue that the knightly class themselves were supposed to
keep all of their gaze upon. You guys, either of you know what the highest virtue of the
Christian knight was? I do not. I'm going to venture fidelity. It was not fidelity. Oh,
that's a good one. And we'll talk about what the Christian knight's idea of troth is in a second.
But the highest virtue- I'm 90% convinced you're making up every single one of these. I'm not
This is real stuff. This is true. We'll talk about troth. It's where we get the word betrothed.
Troth. So you pledge your troth to someone? That's right. You give your truth to somebody.
You give your word. But the highest virtue of the Christian knight was sort of, strangely,
charity. So charity was supposed to be the highest virtue of the Christian knight. Now,
charity nowadays, when we talk about charity, what do we usually think about? Giving to the poor.
That's right. Giving money to the poor. But the old virtue of charity was a love. In Caritas,
it was the love that gives without expecting anything else in return. It's the love that
Jesus showed on the cross, that he emptied himself and gave himself up for the world.
It was charitable love, agape love, that kind of thing. So the idea of charitable love was supposed
to be the highest virtue of the Christian knight. So in many ways, the Christian knight was almost
like this weird philosopher of love. Charity was supposed to be the thing that he thought about the
most. Charity was supposed to be the thing that he held as his highest ideal and what he fought for.
So really, instead of the way we would conceive of knights now as being valor-centered and
honor- and glory-centered, which is probably a selfish notion, they're really focused on
loving without expecting things in return. That's right. So this is kind of a transformation from
the ancient ideals that you see with some of the Homeric characters, where their own sense of honor
and their own sense of valor was ideal. And if their honor was besmirched, you have that very
sort of Roman idea of falling on your sword as a very honorable thing to do. You got besmirched,
you're going to fall on your sword, and all your kids are going to be like, Dad was awesome.
But that sort of falls away in the Christian tradition when you get into the Middle Ages.
You don't see knights falling on their swords. You don't see them honorably killing themselves
at all. Is a piece of that because the Catholic Church looked not fondly on the idea of suicide?
And one of the reasons why they don't look fondly on suicide is, I mean, among other things,
suicide is a giving up on God's creation. But in terms of being a knight, it was a sort of a failure
of your mission. In fact, a lot of the knight stories that we have are not knights going off
and being these sort of valorous butt-kickers, which, although there is a couple of those stories,
but a lot of the knights in classical tradition are often going through great trials and
misadventures. The Red Cross knight getting thrown in jail in the Fairy Queen, or the Dungeons
of the Giant. You have these knights that go through sort of almost these, which would
classically be looked at as like honor-destroying actions. You have the Christian knight sort of
enduring these kinds of things with great distinction. Like Sir Gawain.
Yeah. And so Sir Gawain is a great example of talking about the idea of charitable love and
action. And so the Christian knight is supposed to... Do we need to say who Sir Gawain is for
those who don't really know? So Sir Gawain was one of the knights of Arthur's court,
and he was King Arthur's nephew, and he was supposed to be the most courteous, well-mannered
knight. And the famous story of him is called Sir Gawain, the Green Knight. And this is one of the
texts that we study in 10th grade. And it is a text that is a trial. Sir Gawain goes through
this trial of going to the sort of Green Knight's castle. Maybe there's a whole other podcast we
could do on the actual story of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. I thought you meant reading
it was a trial when you said... Oh, no, no, no. Reading it is not a trial. Reading it is very
fun. It's also very fun to read at Christmas time because it takes place all at Christmas.
And the knight is all green and covered in holly and gold.
That's right. And he's a big grump. Yeah. He's kind of a grump. He's also kind of great.
And he might be a fairy, which is kind of interesting, which is not how we think about
fairies. That's a whole other topic. Different kind of fairy than you're thinking.
That's right. Not Tinkerbell. Yeah.
Anyway, so knights as sort of philosophers of love. And this is why often you have these stories
where knights are tempted by ladies, like Sir Gawain, the Green Knight, being a great example,
where you have these ladies who are tempting the knights to sort of give themselves over to
sort of a baser sexual love, whereas the knights are supposed to be these philosophers of this sort
of higher charitable love. So where was I going with this? So we have... Shoot, what were we
talking about? This is embarrassing. You were talking... I mean, it seemed like we
had sort of put a cap on most of the things you were covering. I'm not sure where we were
headed with it. Maybe you were talking about Sir Gawain as an example of the Christian knight?
That's right. Sir Gawain is the example of the Christian knight and the high view of charity.
Is there anything more to say? I mean, there's like lots to say,
but we'd have to go on to like all of Sir Gawain, the Green Knight.
Is that a bad thing? No.
In the meantime, I have a question. Oh, let's hear your question.
And that is, at what point did this concept of a code of chivalry develop? Do we know
anything of how it came to be as opposed to just springing up out of nowhere?
Ah, so that's... Good. Thank you. That's a great question, because that was kind of where... That
was the thing I was trying to remember. Yes. So we have this ancient honor code where honor was
supposed to be the central thing of the ancient hero. And then this idea of charity is this
almost like Christian reimagining of the hero. So when you get these stories of the Christian
knight, you're getting these... The authors are, especially in Sir Gawain, the Green Knight,
they are consciously trying to retell the stories of the classical heroes,
but with the Christian virtues in mind. So the one of Sir Gawain, the Green Knight, is an actual...
Trying to retell the story of Paris and Helen. And this is a little strange, because the story
of Paris and Helen, Paris is coming to Menelaus's house and he's stealing Helen away, and the whole
Iliad happens in the fall of Troy. That causes thousands upon thousands of deaths and the end of
a civilization. Exactly. Sir Gawain, the Green Knight, actually in the first stanza of Sir
Gawain, the Green Knight, they make a reference to Troy. So any classical reader would be like,
oh, I know the story of Troy. But the story of Sir Gawain, the Green Knight, is this retelling
of what would a Christian hero do as opposed to this Homeric hero. The Homeric hero goes in,
sees a pretty lady and says, I want that, and takes her away and doesn't care about the strife.
Whereas Sir Gawain is this hero who's in a very similar situation. He's in somebody else's house.
He sees a very beautiful woman who happens to be the host's wife. And in this story, the host's
wife throws herself at the Christian knight, and he goes through this very long story of
sort of rebuffing her advances. Always, and if you look at all three of the mornings that she
comes and tries to talk to him, he uses this Christian virtue of charity as the thing that
wards off the woman from turning into a second Troy. So the Christian knight is sort of this
recasting of the classical hero. And in the Middle Ages, I would argue that they're very much
saying, what would these ancient stories have looked like if we had had characters who adhered
to these Christian virtues, which are these baptized version of the classical virtues?
So charity is kind of like this baptized honor, as opposed to striving and serving for your own
name, you're striving and serving for the name of God. And so, yeah, so we get these Christian
knights who are seeking and striving after virtue. I tell my students that there's kind of
lots of different cultures have this idea of the sort of honorable warrior. The Japanese have the
samurai and the Americans have the cowboy. That's our version? It is. Canada doesn't have
anything. Maybe the Mountie. We kind of get close to that with the Royal Canadian Mounted Police
with the red. They're called Mounties, yes. They're Canada's version of the FBI. Oh, I've
seen them. Yeah, they're cool. They're cool. So it's kind of recasting what people in power
should do with that power. Exactly. And that's the thing that I find very fascinating is you
have this technological advancement. You've got plate mail, you've got chain mail, you have this
ability where the wealthy and the elite of society are essentially, they can't easily die
in combat. And so you have the church coming in and saying, what do we need to sort of backfill
this technological advance in order to keep society honorable? And then they appeal to the
sense of their Christian fidelity and Christian duty to this code of chivalry with the highest
virtue of charity. And that kind of leaves the question, all right, so if we have other
technological advances that are equally as disruptive as the spurs for a horse or as the
plate mail, what kinds of codes of conduct and virtues do we have that can sort of come in the
background and backfill so that with this increase in power, we don't have an increase in vice?
Because we can, yeah. Would you say that the rules of engagement that the military follows is that
sort of thing? I think it's part of it. I mean, it's kind of a code of chivalry. You don't shoot
unless shot at? Sure. I mean, we have, yeah, and I think we have these things that I think it's
it would be a fun exercise to actually sit down and think about what particular kinds of behaviors
do specific technological advances engender, and what sort of things can you develop to make sure
that those maybe negative behaviors don't run amok? Because like I tell my students,
it would be like giving an entire class of 17-year-old boys, letting them wear football
equipment to school, and then letting them basically like run loose in the hallway.
They're going to like body check each other, and then eventually, every once in a while,
they're going to like hit some poor peasant. So not to reduce it to a cliche, but it is a little
bit like the classic Uncle Ben from Spider-Man line of with great power comes great responsibility.
That's right. Uncle Ben giving us lessons from beyond the grave. Exactly. It's that kind of thing.
Do the parallels between Sir Gawain and Paris go any further? There's a moment at the end where
Sir Gawain has to submit himself to what he probably accurately believes will be his demise,
right, at the hands of the Green Giant. The Green Giant has, you know, taken one stroke from Gawain's
axe, and with the promise that Gawain has to take a stroke from his, and so Gawain has to bow down and
bare his neck for a stroke from the Green Giant's axe. And he does this with a certain amount of
not complete valor. I don't want to ruin the whole thing, but he does, you know, he submits himself
to the stroke of the axe. Whereas Paris at one point in the book faces Menelaus in a one-on-one
battle, and the stakes are the entire city, right? The winner of this battle takes Helen and all her
wealth home. And if that's Troy, then the Greeks leave, and if it's Greece, then they get to,
you know, take a lot of wealth and take Helen and go home. It should end the war.
In the middle of that, Menelaus is thoroughly trouncing Paris, and Paris is swept off by
Aphrodite to his rooms. And instead of doing the honorable thing that a prince should do, which is
return to the battle, because this means the death of your city, right? If you break the law.
So he does not submit himself to the blow of the Giant's axe, so to speak.
Yeah. Yeah, I think I, although I haven't done it myself, where I go through
really with an eye to looking at Paris. The parallels are so evident in the overall story.
Here comes a person from the outside. Now they're in this hospitality code situation.
What's the Christian hero going to do? And the very fact that the first stanza makes reference
to Troy, and it's kind of peppered throughout. It would be kind of cool to go through and see
how many are these overt, how many are the, is the author, who we don't know,
are there any overt references, more overt references to Paris? I haven't, I actually
haven't done that exercise myself, although it'd be kind of fun. Cool. And again, the hospitality
code that he's referencing, we talked about in a previous podcast, but it was the foundation of the
ancient world, right? If I, it under, undergirded all travel. If I spend a month getting to Graham's
house to say hello and to trade some sheep, when I get there, what I want is a bath, a bed,
and a meal. And for him not to talk to me or ask me any questions because I've been on the road for
a month. And probably enduring the dangers of the road, including wild animals and thieves and that
sort of thing. And then the next morning he'll entertain me and then he'll give me a gift when
I leave, right? So there's, there's a lot to happen in the hospitality code with the understanding
that I won't steal his daughters or his wife or his goods or besmirch his name. And if you were to
trample on the hospitality code, it would be a pretty egregious offense because it's, it's what
kept their society running, right? Yeah. So there's definitely like the recap, yeah, the thinking of
what does the Christian knight do? What does the Christian hero do in, in, in relation to this kind
of, of environment where you find yourself, where there could be pitfalls, right? Like the pitfalls
of the hospitality code sort of get featured in lots of stories with Paris and Helen being one of
them. So, yeah, so that's the Christian knight with charity as its highest virtue. We haven't
talked about courtly love, which is another Christian knight virtue, which is a little
more complicated. It has to do with what is the Christian knight's attitude towards all women folk.
And then there's also troth. Maybe we can end with troth because you brought it up earlier.
But troth is the word, it is like the honor of the Christian knight that he bestows. So when the
Christian knight gives his word to his king, it's, he is betrothing himself to the king. He has given
his troth. He is giving his truth. It is, when he says that I will fight for you, I will uphold
your name, all of the things that I do going off in the countryside and looking for acts of charity.
So saving peasants, killing bandits, slaying dragons, doing these things that are kind of
thankless tasks, going off and looking for opportunities to love without getting anything
in return, helping peasants from being, you know, overrun by bandits. All the peasants can do is say
thank you. The Christian knight is then supposed to go home after his sort of adventures and tell
the king these stories. He's supposed to come back and say, when I was out this season of knighting,
I killed four dragons and killed three brigands for you, for our court, so that our name could
be known far and wide, so that your name is king. Everyone would say that you are sort of this,
this wise and beneficent king. I think that's how you pronounce it.
And so when you pledge your troth, when you give your word to the king, you are saying that the
actions that I do are ultimately going to be reflected on you, my lord and king. So you can
see how this is a parallel to our Christian life. The actions that we do as Christians are no longer
done for our name, no longer done for us as Achilles or Odysseus, but all of these sorts of
things are sort of transposed to somebody else's ledger. I have given away my troth, I have given
my word to the king, and all of these actions that I do are ultimately going to be for your name and
for your glory and your recognition, and the knight is just this agent. And because, and so then the
expectation that they have, and also the gifts that they are given is this armor, and is this
these swords, and is this this sort of material wealth, but it is to be used in the service of
sort of this higher calling, as opposed to their own name and their own glory. It's a very different
conception of court than we would have in our politics, I'd say. Imagine if we conducted
ourselves in the political realm in the same exact way, where we consider all of our actions
to be to the good and, you know, support of the name of someone who was working above us.
Now, of course, this is the ideal. Now, if you go and you look at the actual history, I mean,
it's full of people who are self-serving, and it's full of people who are using their knightly
powers for their own name, and their own glory, and for raising up their own house, and that kind
of thing. But the ideal that they held before them, the understanding of the way that the sort
of imperium, the way that the universe was supposed to work, was this way. Which is why,
yeah, when you move to the more modern period, you have Machiavelli coming in and saying, like,
actually, politics works by everybody kind of being judged to each other. It was this, you know,
those sorts of new Renaissance ways of thinking about power and politics is kind of this,
seen as this break from what was supposed to be an honorable thing, even if maybe if you look in
medieval history, all the characters of history don't necessarily act that way. Cool. The Song
of Roland is a really beautiful example of that, too. Have you made it through it all? I have not
read it. Okay. Oh, I don't want to give any spoilers. But basically, the idea of pledging
your truth is usually symbolized by the handing of the glove from the king to the knight or whoever
to do a certain responsibility, and then the knight handing it back when the responsibility
is done. It's a recurring theme throughout and happens at this really beautiful moment in the
beginning that's, excuse me, sorry, near the middle, with the death of the main character,
but as he's finally holding out his... Oh, spoilers! But if you know anything about...
But it's a whole book. Yeah. All right.
But he holds out his glove in his dying breath to Christ as the ultimate liege lord.
Oh, there you go. As he's giving up his soul,
and it's beautiful. That's good stuff.
Fun things. Well, one last fun thing about being a knight is when you become a knight,
you know in the stereotypical movie scene, the sword touches your shoulders and now you're a
knight? It used to be that the king, or whoever was knighting you, would full-on, close-fisted
punch you in the face. Yes. And it was supposed to symbolize, scholars don't really know what
it symbolized, but the best guess was that now that you are a knight, this is the last
punch in the face you're going to get without having to have the other person answer for it.
So now that you are a Sir A.J. Hannenberg, when somebody hits you, they now have to expect that
there's going to be a fight in order to answer that hit. Whereas if you were not a knight,
I guess you'd get hit all the time. Which is exactly what happens to me.
So we should end there. We communally pledge our truth to you, our listener. That's right.
And we'll see you next time. That's right,
all the things that we are working is for your good. All right, see you later.
