Tesla has not had a great earnings track record: Analyst talks Q4 expectations

FinFocus
3 followers
Jan 27, 2026
Tesla reports its fourth quarter earnings results on Wednesday, Jan. 28, after markets close.
So it feels like there's a lot riding,
maybe not just on these numbers,
but on Tesla execution generally.
I mean, the shares have doubled since last April,
but they've kind of gone sideways.
They kind of tread water since September.
So what in your view would sort of move the needle
more substantially in terms of these numbers?
Yeah, in our view, it's all about risk reward.
And given the run-up that the stock had had
really since last April,
caused us to go to a sell last fall.
We just felt like the risk reward was no longer favorable
and in fact, unfavorable.
So our current price target is $350.
If you look back over the last several quarters,
Tesla has not had a very good earnings track record.
In fact, they've missed on the bottom line
in seven of the past nine quarters.
So I think what you're seeing with the shares,
both today and leading up to this release last week,
ahead on Wednesday, is there's really a lot of caution.
We know Tesla's earnings were down 31% year over year
in the first three quarters of last year.
And now they're getting ready to report the fourth quarter,
the first quarter in which the US EV market
was no longer subsidized by federal EV tax credits.
So we're expecting a more substantial
year over year drop in earnings.
If you look at consensus,
they're expecting earnings to be down 38% year over year.
And we think that earnings,
really this earnings malaise is gonna carry over
into 2026, which is our primary concern.
It's just the disconnect between what the stock price
has done over the last several months
and the earnings trajectory
that we see in the coming quarters.
And in your view, is that elimination of those tax credits
sort of twofold?
On the one hand, maybe reduced demand for Tesla vehicles.
On the other hand, they sold those tax credits, right?
And that was a source of revenue for them too.
So what sort of combined effect,
how should we be looking at that?
Sure, so we know exactly what Tesla's vehicle sales were
in the fourth quarter.
They reported that in early January
and their sales were down 16% year over year.
But our bigger concern with Tesla
is just the sale of these regulatory emissions credits
under CAFE standards of the US government.
And that's been a very fast growing high margin revenue
stream for the company in recent years.
And essentially that market largely went away overnight
with the signing of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
because CAFE standards were no longer enforced.
And so these emissions credits,
which Tesla would sell to other automakers,
which didn't have as much EV exposure,
was a very profitable source of revenue
and earnings for the company.
And so that largely will go away
and that's gonna really affect Tesla's bottom line
in our opinion.
So, and then you look at 2026
and this is a year where Tesla really has a lot to prove
from an execution standpoint.
They've promised volume production of the CyberCab,
the Semi and the Megapack 3 this year.
And so, it's a big year from an execution standpoint
and we think the management really has a lot to prove here.
And on that front, what is your outlook for RoboTaxi?
I think Morgan Stanley sees a thousand of them on the road
by the end of this year.
Is that reasonable?
Our outlook is, look, it's a very impressive technology,
but that the rollout is going to be a lot slower
than what management is forecasting to.
Already since they went live in Austin in June of last year,
the rollout has been much slower
than what they had promised.
So, we think that will continue.
Even last week when they announced
that they've gone fully unsupervised in Austin,
it turns out that the Tesla vehicles were being followed
with other Tesla vehicles, which did have a driver.
So, that wasn't really true.
And we just think the rollout to other markets
is going to be a lot slower than expected.
Based on our channel checks in other states like Nevada,
they're well behind in terms of filing
the necessary paperwork in terms of getting permitting.
And so, we think it's going to be much slower
than what they're expecting,
which is a big risk.
So, we spent all of our time talking about Tesla,
not surprisingly.
I got to ask you a question about GM though too,
because it reports tomorrow morning,
there you have a hold equivalent rating.
And it feels like both Ford and GM
have really been struggling
to just correct their trajectories right now.
So, what does GM need to do?
How do they need to deliver?
Well, Tesla, I mean, sorry, GM has had a great run.
You look back, they've beat on the bottom line
for 13 straight quarters.
The stock was the best performing
auto manufacturer last year.
GM shares were up 54%.
And compare that to Tesla,
which Tesla shares were up only 11% last year.
So, it's had a great run.
This was one of our top picks in 2025.
And we just went to a hold on valuation in mid-December.
And so many things have gone right for GM.
They've grown their market share in the US
significantly over the last three to four years.
But really, it's their large EV exposure,
which gives us some pause here.
And was really the reason why we head to the sideline.
They've become the second largest company seller of EVs
in the United States in recent years.
And we've seen where they've already taken
some write-downs related to their significant EV assets
and investments that they've made.
And while EVs have been a major growth driver
for the company in recent years,
we think there's gonna be a reversal of that,
where they're actually gonna lose
some market share this year,
due to the EV tax credit expiring.
So, we're a little more cautious.
And again, it was a risk-reward call.
The stock had had a big run-up,
and we just no longer saw a favorable risk-reward,
a risk-reward that really appears
more balanced here in our view.
Garrett, thanks.
Appreciate it.
Good to see you.
Thanks for having me.
