Student Loan Expert Reacts to Dave Ramsey’s Parent Plus Student Loan Rant
3 Video Views·Dec 15, 2024
"Oh yeah, we’re going there. CFP® Professional, Certified Student Loan Professional, and Senior Student Loan Planner consultant Meagan McGuire is reacting to one of Dave Ramsey’s rants on Parent Plus loans and student loans in general.
"
Is this Dave Ramsey rant warranted?
Let's find out.
I am a certified student loan professional.
Hey, Boonie, look at him.
He's paying attention now.
Senior student loan consultant
on the Student Loan Planner team.
Welcome to the Student Loan Planner channel.
I'm going to react today to one of Dave Ramsey's
recent rants on parent plus loans
and student loans in general.
What would be my take as a financial planner
specialized in student loan repayment?
This should be fun.
I'm curious to see what he has to say today.
So we'll jump on in.
Our question of the day comes from Brandon in Maryland.
He says, I've had several friends
whose parents took out our parent plus loans
and had them go sideways once they graduated.
What's your stance on them?
Obviously they're a bad idea,
but if they were taken out,
whose responsibility should it be to pay them
once they come due?
Well, I mean, legally it's the parent's name on the bill.
And so, I mean, I guess from like a legal perspective,
it's the parents.
I mean, what's frustrating about this whole thing though,
is that, and we've heard this multiple times,
is that, you know, the student agrees with the parent
that they'll pay it, you know,
but the parent takes out the parent plus loan.
And-
The student fails to tell their new fiance.
Or the student camp doesn't get a job.
You remember that time you said you were going to pay
this loan and they go, now I did.
So parent plus loans are federal student loans
that a parent can borrow for their child
if they're going to an undergraduate program.
And they're more and more common these days
because the cost of attendance has gone up quite a bit,
but also the student themselves can only borrow
up to a certain amount, 5,500 for their freshman year,
6,500 for a sophomore year,
and then up to 7,500 for junior and senior year.
So it's not a lot.
According to College Board, these are some of the averages.
For a public four-year in-state education
for just tuition and fees,
the average is about 11,260 for one academic year.
Public four-year out-of-state college, 29,150.
So more than double if you're going out-of-state.
Public two-year in-state or in-district
would be about 3,990.
So this would be like a community college situation,
public in-state.
And then a private not-for-profit four-year entity,
that would be $41,540 for one academic year.
So the average cost of college tuition is not cheap.
It's not cheap.
And this is just tuition and fees.
This is not taking into account housing, transportation,
like the basic needs for living expenses
when you're going to college.
Parent PLUS loans, they're accessible
and you can borrow up to the cost of attendance.
So it's an easy way to be able to cover
the cost of attendance for your kid going to school
if you didn't already have that savings.
And that is right where the parent is legally responsible
for the Parent PLUS loan.
Many folks I work with, though,
will have some kind of handshake agreement with their kids
where their kids are responsible
for paying half of the balance off or the full balance off.
Or sometimes the parent wants to take over
the full responsibility of the loan.
And so that's their burden to manage going forward.
But legally, it is under the name of the parent.
It stays under the name of the parent
if it stays in the federal system.
There's no way to transfer it
to the student in the federal system.
You can transfer it to the student's name
if you go to refinance the loan post their graduation
and they have a job and they're eligible for refinancing
per the company's underwriting requirements.
But that's the only way you can transfer
the loan legally into the student's name
by looking at a private refinance later.
Well, that or the student didn't pay
and then the parent's like,
well, I guess I have to pay it.
And then they're frustrated.
I mean, like, it's just, it ends up being
this like tangled mess relationally.
But whose responsibility once it comes due?
I mean-
Whoever promised to pay it morally.
If the kid promised to pay it,
then they should go back and pay it.
They're not legally liable.
So if you, if the kid, if you said,
mom and dad, if you take this loan out
so I can go to the college of my dreams,
then, and mom and dad are stupid enough to go do that.
Then they sign the note.
They're legally liable,
but you made a promise to them to pay it.
That's you keeping your word.
You go pay it.
Okay.
Mom and dad took out the loan
and nobody ever said anything to nobody.
And then mom and dad come back later and go,
you need to pay for your college.
No, I don't.
I didn't tell you I'd pay it and I'm not gonna pay it.
So there's no moral contract and mom and dad are up a creek.
Bottom line is you can avoid all this
by staying away from the stupidity completely.
No student loans of any kind are good
in no freaking circumstances.
Parent plus loans are stupid.
Oh my gosh.
I, I completely disagree with this.
I don't think that we should be shaming people
for borrowing student loans.
I think student loans should be looked at
as an investment in your future self
and your future income potential in your career.
And there are bad investments.
And 150,000 bucks in student loan debt
to get a PhD in German polka history
or some such crap, right?
I'm not gonna study left-handed puppetry.
Bad investments if we're looking
at certain circumstances here.
But I don't think we can say borrowing student loans
is always a stupid decision.
I also hate how he uses the word stupid.
He's kind of mean here.
This is why like, I don't know.
I think rage bait with like financial planning
or financial stuff is super popular right now.
Like I think people just like to see people get yelled
at on the internet about money.
And Dave Ramsey kind of started this whole thing.
He is the godfather of rage bait
when it comes to like financial rants.
Coming from a personal financial planner,
there are lots of circumstances.
I could argue that are appropriate
for borrowing student loans,
borrowing Parent PLUS loans even.
Education is something that is not accessible to everybody.
Let's just call it what it is.
It is not accessible to everybody.
And federal student loans have made that possible
to make education accessible to more people.
There are professions that you cannot not go to school for.
So if you wanna be a veterinarian,
if you wanna be a dentist or a doctor,
there's no way around it.
We've gotta go to school.
There are families that can put their kids through college
and assist with helping them on the financial side of things.
There are families that cannot,
and they need to rely on loans
to invest in their kids' education.
It's hilarious to me that when people are stupid
about education, that's an oxymoron, isn't it?
We've lost our stupid minds on the subject of education.
I really just don't like how Dave will speak really poorly
and condescendingly to people who may have done this already
who have already borrowed the Parent PLUS loans,
who already have the student loans.
This might be a scare tactic, of course,
to scare people out of borrowing these types of loans,
student loans, Parent PLUS loans.
I understand that side.
And saying that student loans of any kind
shouldn't be borrowed under any circumstance
isn't advice that's applicable to everybody.
It's not.
And so what are you gonna do?
If you listen to this advice,
are you just not gonna go to school to be a veterinarian?
Are you gonna give up that dream
because Dave Ramsey said so?
Are you not gonna go to school to be a physician?
No way.
It's gonna take,
thinking about the cost of education, right?
We just talked about undergrad tuition
and fees a moment ago.
Talking about graduate school loans
is a totally different story.
You can't budget your way through
paying for the cost of attendance
and be able to jump into your career
in a reasonable amount of time.
Well, it took me 55 years.
I think there are smart investments,
smart investments into your future,
smart investments into your education.
And then there are not so smart
investments into your future.
And that's what you have to identify.
Is this going to be a smart investment in my future?
And do I have a plan
for what I'm gonna do with these loans post-graduation?
That's what's important.
So you're not stupid.
I will say, do you feel like in recent years,
in the last two years or so since COVID,
I feel like people have woken up to this though.
I think that there-
Student loans?
Yes.
I think that there has been a backlash
against just collegiate in general.
Like just, I mean, I think people are-
Well, higher education has gotten a backlash.
And the politicians, you guys, you Congress people,
somebody ought to just smack one of you.
Y'all are just, it's unbelievable.
The student loans are horrible.
We need to forgive them while we continue to make them.
That's so intellectually dishonest.
If they suck and they hurt people,
why don't you stop it?
Hello?
Okay, so let's pause here for a second.
Because I think a lot of times
the focus is on the symptom, right?
The symptom of a bigger problem is the student loans.
We have to borrow student loans
to pay for the cost of attendance.
The cost of attendance is outrageous, right?
So let's go back to that last sentence.
The cost of attendance is outrageous.
Now for undergraduate, there are borrowing limits
on how much we can borrow.
And they're pretty low, like we talked about,
between 5,500 and 7,500 per year.
And that's not a lot, but I say that's not a lot
off of what today's cost of attendance looks like, right?
Those limits haven't changed in years, years, years, years.
It is not adjusted for inflation,
but the cost of attendance has adjusted for inflation.
It's actually outpaced inflation.
Year after year, the cost of attendance
has increased 5% to 8%, depending on the school, of course,
compared to regular inflation of 2% to 3% over time.
Tell me how that makes sense.
And wages haven't kept up with that either.
The student loans are a symptom.
They were meant to be a way to gain access to education.
But to blame the government or Congress solely
for this issue, or to say like,
well, they just shouldn't lend student loans,
that's not focusing on the problem.
The problem is the cost of attendance.
And what's happened is these schools
have taken advantage of the fact
that you can borrow up to the cost of attendance.
Because who dictates the cost of attendance?
The colleges, they dictate the cost of attendance.
The opportunity for colleges to charge
whatever they want is there,
because they have the ability for people to go
and borrow whatever they need
for that cost of attendance in these loans.
The poor little victims of the student loan,
and you keep making them.
And you're the villain, Congress.
It's your fault.
And the schools.
Schools are the villain.
Schools and the cost of attendance that they charge,
that's the villain.
The argument here is,
let's just stop lending federal student loans,
or maybe let's limit how much people can borrow
in student loans.
So there should be more responsibility, I think.
There's a million ways that this could maybe be solved.
And there's a million complexities
that go into why this is such a big problem right now.
But maybe one solution is having the schools
have more skin in the game for the success of students
and the success of students getting a good job,
a good paying job post-graduation
with the education that they took from their school.
Nobody would have student loans.
That'd be an awesome thing.
And the universities would probably lower tuition
because nobody's gonna be getting it.
Oh, I promise you they would,
because people couldn't afford to pay it.
The demands.
And people would wake up and go,
wait a minute, this is like real money in my hand
that I earned.
I'm gonna make better value choices about what I study.
I'm not gonna study left-handed puppetry
and pay somebody $85,000 a semester for that
and call it an Ivy League education.
And I'm-
Totally fair.
I think the thought process, the research,
the really just the extra thought
about what you're investing in
when it comes to your education is super important.
You're just shoveling money out.
And by the way, it was my money,
because I'm the taxpayer.
And now you're not paying it
because you've got a degree that's worthless
and you're a barista.
And so that's what happens.
Higher education is to blame.
The Congress is to blame.
Weak parents that won't tell their spoiled freaking children
no are to blame.
Everybody in this thing.
But before we had borrowed,
before we had borrowed future and all of it out,
you said, we don't have a student loan problem.
We have a parenting problem.
Because you talk to these college students,
to your point that graduated 21 years old
with 120 grand in debt to not an Ivy League.
I mean, they're charging insane money now
and they wanna go and be a missionary or do something,
where they're not making a ton,
but they got all of this debt.
And I'm like, how did your parents direct you?
Well, they didn't talk to me.
And you're like, oh my gosh,
like an 18 year old is sitting here making a decision
that's gonna affect them for the next decade of their life.
And a parent didn't step in
and at least have the conversation.
College can be fun,
but it is not meant to be just a funsy experience.
And we don't think about these other things.
College is designed to further your education.
So you can get a good job,
make a good livable wage in the future
and be a productive person in society.
It's not just for the experience.
And I think that's sometimes what kids
definitely don't think about.
They think about the experience itself
because of what they see on Alabama Rush
or something on Netflix.
And they're not putting together
that this is setting themselves up for their adult life.
And if they're not taking that seriously,
then they can really start their adult life financially
in a negative net worth position,
which is extremely difficult to climb out of,
especially if we didn't make a smart investment
in what we went to school for.
Nothing is being said.
Are we gonna call like,
my daughter told me she's going to this school
that we can't afford.
So we're gonna have to take out student loans.
See, there's the problem.
Because I love Rachel,
but when Rachel was 18 and we were spending my money,
she didn't tell me nothing.
I told her some stuff, but she didn't tell me anything.
That's not how this works.
That's backwards.
So-
There wasn't much dialogue.
No, there wasn't.
It's like, you're gonna go to this school
and I'll pay for it.
That's pretty much how it went.
All three of them went to the same school.
The dialogue was, if you take all these classes,
you graduate in four years.
Take the freaking classes.
Yeah, that's fair.
Because yeah, and-
I did, that was the dialogue.
And to be transparent, you guys paid for our education,
but we had to stay in-state.
Yep.
We had to take in-state tuition
and we had to graduate in four years.
If you went four and a half,
you had to pay-
And you had to freaking behave.
And if you did, yeah.
And if you went out of state-
You don't get to go off the reservation and get my money.
Yeah, so this is already putting them in a biased position
because they're speaking to the masses.
They're saying student loans suck.
There's never a case where student loans make sense.
But Dave Ramsey, his family, his business,
his career has set himself up financially speaking
where he could have cash flowed
the cost of attendance for his kids, right?
That may not be your parent's situation.
So you can't assume that everybody
is going to have the financial resources
to be able to pay cash for college.
And that shouldn't be a shameful thing either.
I'm gonna, you're confused what you're there for.
You're there to take these classes to get this degree.
And if you take these classes and pass them, it's magical.
You graduate in four years.
And we go, we're sitting in the orientation
at the University of freakin' Tennessee
where the kids went and I went.
And they said very proudly,
we have a 57% graduation rate.
Of the people that are sitting in this room,
57% are gonna graduate.
And I'm thinking to myself,
I almost raised my hand and said,
if they make a 57 in class, don't you give them an F?
You wouldn't be bragging about that.
That's called failure.
Oh, and then they pipe up and say,
and only 20% of the ones that do graduate
will do it in four years.
And I wrote across my oldest daughter's
little orientation packet.
So have a freaking plan.
I agree with that.
Have a plan.
I think the 56, 57% graduation rate
is a symptom of everybody thinking
that they just have to go to college.
That's like the next step.
What is your plan?
What do you wanna go to school for?
How much income potential could that degree give you?
What is that return on investment?
That's what you wanna find out.
And in black magic marker,
while this idiot was on stage telling us this.
I mean, how are you bragging about a 57% graduation rate?
That's failure.
And this is another lesson that you take out loans
and you may not even get the degree
and you're paying money back
for a degree you never received either.
Yeah, 43% of the time.
Yeah.
Apparently, you don't get the degree.
Oh, well, Brandon from Maryland's question of the day.
Hope that's set.
Poor Brandon.
This was like a whole rant
outside of answering the question.
I mean, community college, it's getting worse and worse.
It's worse and worse.
It is.
Okay, go and you can go to,
you can go for free in most states,
you can go to community college for two years.
So get your prereqs done, yes.
I mean, there's a plan to go about it.
It's not the most glamorous.
You're not studying anything that matters
in the first two years anyway, usually.
Yep, yep.
So there is a plan
and it probably doesn't look like the shiny plan
that you always have in college.
And here's an idea.
Get a degree.
It'll help you get a job.
Okay, so I agreed with a lot
that Dave and Rachel had to say.
I disagreed with a lot
that Dave in particular had to say
about just there not being any reason
to borrow a student loan.
So I hope this is able to give you
a more diversified opinion on borrowing.
You're not stupid if you have student loans.
If you do need some help navigating your repayment path
or starting to plan out what that future repayment
of the loans could look like,
we do this on our day-to-day, one-on-one help.
We do student loan repayment help
and we build our custom plan for you
for how you're gonna tackle your student loan situation,
how we can save as much money as possible
and maximize what's available in the student loan system
to help you be smart with your money,
thrive in your new career
and not let student loans hold you back
from being successful financially speaking.
So check us out if you need some additional help.
We've got free resources on our website as well.
Thanks for hanging out with me today.
Hope this was interesting.
Dave, I do like you.
Rachel, you're cool too.
See you in the next one.

