CFP® Reacts to Six-Figure Student Loan Reddit Thread

Loan Solutions
2 followers
Mar 21, 2025
Senior Student Loan Planner consultant, CFP® Professional, and SLP Wealth financial planner Meagan McGuire is doing another Reddit reaction video, this time covering threads of people sharing their six-figures of student loan debt.
Meagan shares some of her professional advice as a student loan expert on options these people have.
If you have six-figures of student loan debt, remember that you are not alone!
Let's play who wants to be a millionaire,
student loan edition though.
I'm Megan, financial planner,
specialized in student loan planning,
senior student loan consultant at Student Loan Planner.
And we're gonna thumb through Reddit today
to talk through folks who have hundreds of thousands
of student loan debt, what their situations look like,
what they should maybe be thinking about
and how to move forward.
Hi, babies.
Hi, baby.
Let's jump in.
This Reddit post is from boring underscore pomegranate 50.
Let's play who wants to be a millionaire, loan edition.
I have $407,000 of private and federal student loans.
Anyone else in this ballpark or am I a unicorn?
It's only grown over the years
because I haven't been able to pay on the principal.
Literally, my only plan to repay at some point
is make more money.
Godspeed, fellow loan survivors.
I am very curious what they went to school for
and what their makeup of federal
versus private student loans is.
Hopefully, there's a minimum amount of private student loans
and the vast majority of it is federal
because there's a lot more flexibility
with the federal system,
having income-driven repayment plans.
Private loans, they're just treated like private debt.
We have to pay the loans off.
Ideally, we get a lower interest rate
to work that off sooner and pay less interest over time.
So that would be my suggestion to this person
for the private loans is refinance those if you can
to try to get a lower interest rate.
We have seen rates go down.
I've been seeing between like four and a half
to 6% for interest rates for good credit
if you can get a lower rate than what you have.
The federal side of the equation,
there's a lot more flexibility.
If your balance on the federal student loan debt
is greater than your current income situation,
you may wanna be considering a forgiveness path
on an income-driven repayment plan
versus paying those loans off.
Some folks may have choked
at this hundreds of thousands of dollars situation,
but we commonly work with folks
who have lots of student loan debt.
So for example, medical professionals
are the most indebted out there.
So this is an idea of the different professions
that we've worked with,
how many people in that profession we've worked with,
and the average amount of debt that they carry.
So you'll see physicians, dentists, veterinarians,
they carry the higher amounts of student loan debt.
So maybe this person is in the medical profession.
Dentists do tend to be the highest,
most indebted folks out there, especially a specialist.
♪ I'm a specialist ♪
So we have general dentistry
with an average of about 417,000 in student loan debt,
where if you're looking at a specialist,
like an orthodontist, that's 621,000 on average,
or a pediatric dentist at 466,000,
or an endodontist would be closer to about 567,000.
So dental-specific school loans
are going to be probably the most,
but any other medical professional
will also have a decent chunk of student loan debt.
Lawyers as well,
some of these other professions you'll see on here.
Wildly expensive.
Income-driven repayment options are really great relief
in the sense of it makes your payment affordable
because it's tied to your income,
and it has a maximum repayment period
of either 20 or 25 years,
depending on the income-driven plan that you're on.
So once you make those income-driven payments
for 20 or 25 years, whatever's left is then forgiven.
We may have to pay taxes on that forgiven debt,
so that's something that we factor
into your student loan plan,
but mathematically, that could make a lot of sense
compared to paying the loans off,
if we're just paying a fraction of what,
in tax, of what the balance was when it got forgiven.
Boring underscore pomegranate 50
did say that their goal is to make more income
to tackle these student loans.
That's, of course, another option.
If your income is greater than what your balance is
for the federal student loan side of things,
then you'd wanna pay the loans off sooner rather than later,
so maybe that's where going and refinancing
the federal side of things could make sense
and could reduce your interest cost over time.
But remember, refinancing your federal student loans
is a permanent decision.
You wanna make sure it's the right decision
before you go and do it.
Refinancing private student loans that we already have,
that's a no-brainer.
As long as you can get a lower interest rate
in terms that you feel good about, go for that,
because it's gonna give you
some cost savings on the interest.
Save money?
Absolutely.
Sweaty-contract-7644 is next up here.
Me as well.
Started with 120,000, been in repayment 13 years now,
and it's at 200,000.
No hope for ever paying it off or it's to stop growing.
I'm a physical therapist for reference,
working three jobs, maxed out on income I will make.
The PTs that we typically work with,
on average they have about 183,500 in student loan debt,
so not cheap either.
Folks who go to PT school
typically do borrow just federal student loans
because if you're going to grad school,
you can borrow up to the cost of attendance.
So same story as the situation before.
If our balance is a lot greater than your income,
which it probably is at 200,000 as a PT,
then you would wanna pursue that loan forgiveness route.
There's a couple blog posts that we put together
at studentloanplanner.com that can be super helpful.
We'll link those in the description down below.
The first one is about physical therapy, school loans,
the cost of school just really soaring.
Let's see what some of the comments say.
There's a whole cadre of very condescending people
who don't seem to understand this,
like it's not simply paying them off
and that you can't because the boat
is filling up with more water.
Yeah, I think totally true.
There are so many people on the internet
who do not mechanically understand student loans
or federal student loans and how they operate,
how interest does still accrue,
even though we're making on-time payments.
It's a scam, it's a scam, and I refuse to be scammed.
Don't you wanna scream when someone says
they shouldn't have taken out loans
that they couldn't pay back?
Susan, Karen, come on.
This is not the same situation
as what it was 20, 30, 40 years ago.
The cost of attendance has completely skyrocketed,
and to be in these professions, you have to go to school.
The school dictates the cost of attendance,
and if you don't have another way
to cover the cost of attendance other than borrowing loans,
you're gonna be stuck with these larger loan balances
that we're talking about.
Schools have figured it out.
The cost of attendance is something
that anybody could borrow as a graduate student,
so what your uncle says or what someone 20 years older
than you says isn't really applicable
to what you're going through.
Next commenter is Satara.
I'm a veterinarian, don't have quite that high,
only 330,000, but I feel your pain, Godspeed.
And for veterinarians, our average debt balance
that we typically see is 288,000
for the folks that we've worked with,
but remember, averages are kinda dangerous, right?
Because we've got some folks
that have a lot lower than that in student loan debt,
and we've got folks that have a lot higher than that,
so averages might not always be the best number to look at,
but vet school, among one of those
for medical professionals that does tend
to be quite high upon graduation.
Some of the commenters on this post said,
my wife is at 267,000 last time I looked,
also a veterinarian, salaries aren't high enough
for the debt you have to incur,
and if you don't have rich parents to pay for vet school.
These income-driven repayment plans are really helpful
when it comes to having an end in sight,
still having a cost-effective
and affordable repayment plan
that can tackle the loans over time,
to still allow you to do the things
that you want to do in your life,
buy a home, start a family,
buy a practice or start a business.
So these income-driven plans are really helpful there.
No, no, don't put me on hold.
Typically, veterinarians are gonna be going
towards that income-driven forgiveness timeline as well,
the longer-term taxable forgiveness
that we've been talking about versus paying the loans off.
We do have a podcast that could be cool to check out
called Veterinary Financial Podcast
that talks about financial planning and student loans,
all related to folks in the veterinary profession,
led by a current veterinarian herself, DVM Meredith,
Meredith Jones, and then her colleague David,
and they're a great bunch.
You should check it out if you have questions
about finances and integrating your student loan plan
into your financial planning journey.
If you're straddled with a lot of student loan debt,
you're not alone.
Seriously, consider one
of the income-driven repayment plans.
Income-based repayment is a plan
that's written into legislation,
not something that can go away very easily.
We also have the pay-as-you-earn plan,
ICR, income contingent repayment.
All of these plans are off of a percentage of your income.
So it makes the payment affordable
so you could do the other things that you wanna do in life,
but also have a game plan to tackle the loans.
If you need help, that's what we offer, one-on-one help.
Check out Student Loan Planner
if you wanna walk through your game plan
or your strategy to tackle these things.
Drop a comment below.
Tell us what amount of student loan debt that you have,
what profession you're in,
and what your plan of action is.
Hit subscribe if you wanna hear more content
or information on these types of topics,
student loan planning,
integrated in with financial planning,
and to stay up-to-date
with the recent student loan stuff going on.
Thanks for hanging out with me.
I'll catch you on the next one.
