Ryobi and 2 Other Drill Bit Brands to AVOID—And 6 Worth Buying Instead

Gadgets Tools
5 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Ryobi's titanium drill bit set took 50 seconds
to get through one piece of spring steel,
four times longer than the same bits needed for mild steel,
while a $28 Irwin Cobalt set did it in 24.9.
The company that sells Ryobi tools in North America
also owns a brand whose bits beat it, and I'll show you which one.
Today I'm covering three bit sets to avoid and six worth your money,
including a $36 set that won a test against sets costing up to $180.
$80.
First up is a brand with a very creative way
of advertising steel.
Number three is Drill Hog,
and I'll start with what it gets right. The bits can cut.
In an earlier head-to-head test of 14 sets,
a Drill Hog set came third in mild steel at 10.63 seconds
and held 212 inch-pounds of torque before failing.
The case against it sits in the marketing,
the origin wording, and the price.
The Amazon listing for the 29-piece set
says its high molybdenum M7 steel has
a melting point of 4,753 degrees Fahrenheit.
That is the melting point of pure molybdenum metal.
An alloy tool steel doesn't inherit it.
Melting point also has nothing to do with how a bit wears out,
since bits soften and dull long before anything melts.
Another listing describes the Pig Steel M60 series
as a proprietary blend of pig iron,
carbide, tungsten, and molybdenum,
with no spec you could check against a standard.
Then there's USA Made by Drill Hog.
The listings never name the factory.
Drillhog's eBay listings ship from Sunburst,
Montana, and the prices climb fast.
$75.99 for the 29-piece M7 set on eBay,
$139.99 for the super premium version on its own site,
and $12.99 for an empty 29-bit case stamped Made in USA.
A case can be made in the USA without anyone naming
who made the bits inside it.
Drill Hog reportedly sources its bits rather than grinding them itself.
Its eBay store has more than 100,000 feedback ratings,
which tells you it moves a lot of bits
and tells you nothing about where they were made.
A lifetime warranty is only as good as the company
that answers it. In a May 2026 test,
a $140 Drill Hog 29-piece set came out durable but slow.
It stopped less than a millimeter short
of getting through AR-500 armor plate,
while the $36 Comoware finished it in 58.69 seconds.
That's a set that was durable, still fell short,
and cost nearly four times the winner's price,
with an origin story that never names a factory.
The next set has a different problem. It starts fast, then quits.
Number two is Harbor Freight's Warrior 29-piece cobalt set,
item 61885, which is also sold under item numbers 36891 and 62295.
On paper, it looks like a bargain. Cobalt steel,
a 135-degree split point, sizes from 1/16th to 1/2 inch.
Harbor Freight's page has listed it at $74.99
and compares it to a clutch set at $129.99,
and members have caught it on sale for $59.99.
It cost $75 in a May 2026 test,
which is more than double the $36 set that won.
It came out of the gate fast,
19.51 seconds in mild steel, which is quicker than the winner's 19.65.
Then came Springsteel.
The set took heavy damage
and gave up just short of finishing its second pass.
The grade of Cobalt is worth a moment.
M35 typically carries about 5% Cobalt, and M42 about 8%.
And Bosch's M42 listing states the 8% figure outright.
The Cobalt helps the steel keep its hardness as the tip heats up,
and heat is what ends a bit in hard metal.
The earlier 14 brand test told the same story in a quieter way.
Warrior was slower than average in mild steel at 15.12 seconds
and below average in torque to failure at 141 inch pounds.
The bits are made in China
and the protection is Harbor Freight's standard 90-day guarantee,
which excludes normal wear and tear.
So you're paying premium set money for below average results
and cheaper sets beat it on the same bench.
There's a 29-piece cobalt set later
in this video that finished the armor plate,
one of only four sets to do it, so keep that in mind.
But first,
the one that earned the top spot on the avoid list.
Number one is Ryobi, specifically the titanium hex shank sets,
and any Ryobi set you plan to use on metal.
Start with who Ryobi actually is. The name belongs to Ryobi Limited,
a Japanese company that still makes die-cast parts
and builder's hardware in Japan.
Tectronic Industries of Hong Kong bought Ryobi's
North American power tool business in August 2000
and uses the name under license.
In 2005, Tectronic bought Milwaukee Tool and runs it
as a separate subsidiary.
So one parent company sells the bit set that failed
and one of the sets that won.
The lineup is broad and cheap, which is its pull.
The 22-piece titanium hex shank set, a 972203,
sells for $19.97 at Home Depot and lists a 135-degree split point,
which is the right geometry for starting a hole without wandering.
The 17-piece Speedload Plus titanium set,
AR2074G, is $25.27.
The 22-piece titanium kit, AR-2042,
has four stars across 1,589 Home Depot ratings.
Ratings in the four-star range are why these sets keep selling,
and the fact that only 56% of those buyers recommend it
is why the bench results matter.
In an earlier 14 brand test,
the Titanium Ryobi cut mild steel in 13 seconds,
then needed 50 seconds in spring steel,
while that $28 Irwin Cobalt set took 24.9.
In the torque test, Ryobi gave out at 92 inch-pounds,
near the bottom of the field and just above Irwin's 88.
The leader, Century, held 225. The damage shows up fast.
The 25-piece black oxide set promises
three times longer life on its listing,
and a buyer of the A&R 2042 titanium kit reportedly
snapped two bits within their first five holes.
And Ryobi's own product pages list the warranty as
Consumable item.
Ryobi does deserve credit in one place.
That 13-second mild steel hole was faster than Warrior's 15.12.
The 25-piece Ryobi Black Oxide set runs about $21,
covers 1/16th to 3/8ths inch,
and is a fair buy if you stay out of thick or hardened metals.
So, for wood and soft material, a cheap set is fine.
For metal, a titanium coating is a surface treatment,
and in the spring steel test, the steel underneath decided the outcome.
If this is saving you from buying a bad bit,
a subscribe helps other people find it.
Now the six that earned it.
Counting down from number six to the set
that beat everything on this list,
starting with the set that finished
the plate Warrior couldn't.
Number six is the Irwin M35 Cobalt 29-piece set.
It has the same 29-piece layout as Warrior,
from 1/16th to 1 1/2 inch with a 135-degree split point.
It costs $130,
about $55 more than what Warrior cost in the May 2026 test.
And in that test, the extra money showed.
Irwin drilled mild steel in 23.55 seconds
and spring steel in 24.16 seconds.
And after the spring steel passes,
the bits still looked nearly as good as new.
Then it defeated the AR500 plate in 60.29 seconds,
second fastest of the four sets that got through.
It placed third overall.
If you've been told M42 always beats M35,
this is where that gets complicated.
Irwin is an M35 set, and it still drilled the plate.
The grade is a strong hint,
and the individual set still has to prove itself.
It sits at sixth because $130 is a lot of money,
and the sets above it did similar work for less.
But if you want a full index with the half inch bit,
this is the set that earned its price.
A similar layout to Warrior, a very different result,
which tells you the grade printed on the case only goes so far.
Number five is Bosch,
and this one is two products because Bosch is really two stories.
The first is masonry.
The Bulldog Extreme SDS Plus bit has a full carbide head
and variable flutes that go from 4 to 2.
Bosch claims 4x life in concrete with rebar,
based on its own internal tests against a standard SDS Plus bit.
So, weigh that, since it's Bosch measuring Bosch.
The claim is specific, and the bit is the pick for concrete.
Bosch also says the Variable Flutes give 25% more holes
per charge on a cordless rotary hammer,
and a bit that clears dust faster is a bit you push less.
The second is the CO14B, a 14-piece M42 cobalt set
with a 3-flat shank on bits 3/16ths and larger.
In the earlier 14 brand test,
the $34 Bosch set drilled mild steel in 11.41 seconds
and broke at 215 inch pounds, second strongest in the field.
In May 2026 though, the $40 Bosch M42
set suffered a bad chip in spring steel.
So I'd buy the masonry bits without hesitation and treat
the metal set as a decent value pick rather than a winner.
That's why it sits at number five.
Number 4 is DeWalt's Cobalt Pilot Point Set.
You'll find it as DWA-1240, and the newer Elite
Series version is DWA-MDCE-14-SET.
14 pieces, 1/16th to 3/8ths inch. Retailers sell it for roughly
$40 to $58, and it was $29 in a May 2026 test.
The pilot point tip starts on contact, and the
The three flat shank starts at three sixteenths.
DeWalt also prints a direct claim for select sizes.
Up to two times longer life than Milwaukee.
A tool company naming its biggest rival
on its own packaging tells you how closely these two
watch each other. And Milwaukee is the brand
that shares a parent with Ryobi. In May 2026,
this was the fastest set in mild steel when new, at 16.36 seconds.
It could not get through the
through the AR500 plate, and that's the honest limit.
Most of us aren't drilling armor plate.
For brackets, angle iron, and hardened bolts, fast starts matter more,
and a 14-piece set at this price covers
the sizes most people actually use.
The 3/8-inch bit in this set is German-made.
DeWalt is a Stanley Black & Decker brand.
Number 3 is the one with a factory you can find on a map.
Viking Drill & Tool has a 74,000-square-foot plant
at 355 State Street in St. Paul, Minnesota.
It's employee-owned, and, by its own account,
it has been making cutting tools since 1951.
All its materials meet National Aerospace Standard 907.
Norseman, the brand you'll see at industrial suppliers,
lists the same State Street address.
In the earlier 14 brand tests, Viking finished first on average.
In May 2026, the $180 25-piece Metric M42 set was the slowest of the
four sets that got through the plate, at 32.85 seconds in mild steel.
It lost only 8% of its speed across the spring steel passes
and was one of four sets to defeat the AR500 plate.
Viking is slow out of the gate
and then stays the same all the way through.
At $180, it's a set for someone who drills hard steel a lot
and wants American-made tooling.
If you're doing a weekend of shelf brackets, a cheaper set will do.
If you're running a shop,
this is a set made by a company whose workers own it,
in a plant with a street address.
And that is a short list in this category.
Number 2 is Milwaukee's Red Helix Cobalt 15-Piece Set, 48892370.
It comes from the same parent company as Ryobi
and delivered a very different result.
The design is more involved than a basic jobber bit.
It has a four cutting edge tip,
a variable helix flute that goes from 35 degrees down to 15,
a thicker tapered web, and a three flat shank.
Sizes run from 1 16th to 3 8ths inch.
Milwaukee claims up to 15 times the life of black oxide bits.
DeWalt claims two times Milwaukee.
Those two claims measure against different things,
so you can't stack them,
and the bench results are the only place the two sets actually meet.
Retailers sell the Milwaukee set for roughly $38 to $63,
it costs $65 in a May 2026 test,
and retailer listings give the origin as China,
Thailand, or South Korea.
In May 2026, it was the fastest set in spring steel, at 17.65 seconds.
It got about 19% faster after break-in,
with a mild steel time of 17.24 seconds.
And it defeated AR500 in 1 minute 17.
The downside is that the set has no half-inch bit.
The faster time after break-in also means
the first few holes undersell it,
so don't judge it on one hole.
Milwaukee also sells a titanium line for impact drivers,
the Shockwave Red Helix titanium sets.
Shockwave titanium is meant for wood and soft metal,
and it isn't the bit for hardened steel.
So a titanium coating has a place on wood and soft metal,
and the job Ryobi's titanium set failed at was neither of those.
Number one is Comoware, a name most people have never heard.
On a set that costs $36
and won a May 2026 test against sets costing up to $180.
The specs are straightforward.
M42 high-speed steel, which means about 8% cobalt,
a 135-degree split point, jobber length,
and sizes from 1 16th to 1 1/2 inch.
It's built for hardened steel, stainless, and cast iron.
Mild steel took 19.65 seconds,
spring steel took 21.79 seconds on the first pass,
and 21.94 on the second, a loss of under 1%, the smallest in the test.
In plain terms, the second hole took
0.15 seconds longer than the first.
Then it went through AR500 armor plate in 58.69 seconds,
the fastest of the four sets that finished.
Drillhog stopped short of that plate.
Warrior quit before its second Springsteel pass.
Viking got through, but slower.
This $36 set outlasted all of them.
Line up what each set cost in that test,
and the pattern is hard to miss.
DeWalt was $29, Comaware was $36,
Milwaukee was $65, Warrior was $75, Irwin was $130,
DrillHog was $140, and Viking was $180.
The $36 set finished the plate fastest,
and the only cheaper set, DeWalt, never got through it.
It isn't the fastest at every task.
Milwaukee beat it in spring steel, and Dewalt beat it in mild steel.
But no other set in that test held its speed as well,
and it did it at a fraction of the price of the premium sets.
That's why it's number one.
For metal, look for M42 Cobalt and check what the set did on a bench,
since the coating on the surface told us very little.
When a listing says USA made by a brand name look for the factory.
If you mostly drill wood and
drywall a cheap set is fine
and Ryobi's black oxide has its place there. If you drill metal
a few times a year, Comaware at $36 or DeWalt,
which was $29 in that test, covers it. If you
want the fastest spring steel results that's Milwaukee.
For concrete buy the Bulldog Extreme.
If you want a full index with the half-inch bit, that's Irwin.
And if you want tooling made in a plant with an address, that's Viking.
Warranties deserve a second look.
Ryobi lists its bits as consumable items.
Harbor Freight gives you 90 days.
Drill Hog promises a lifetime,
which is only worth what the company behind it will honor.
A bit is a consumable,
and the best guarantee is a set that outlasts the others on a bench,
like the ones above.
For impact drivers, Milwaukee's Shockwave line is built for the job,
but it's a wood and soft metal tool,
so keep it away from hardened steel.
If this saved you some money, subscribe,
and I'll see you in the next one.
