During amendment debate on Senate Bill 6347, Rep. Mary Dye, R-Pomeroy, delivered a constitutional and philosophical argument against a proposed state income tax.
Dye framed the issue around personal liberty and the value of an individual’s labor, arguing that what people earn through their work represents a lifetime of effort that should not be taken without constitutional authority. She emphasized that Washington was founded on principles of freedom and limited government, with laws designed to protect individuals from overreach.
She warned that creating an income tax without amending the state constitution undermines those foundational principles and shifts power away from the rule of law.
The bill passed the House on March 10 following a 24.5-hour floor debate, with Republicans offering dozens of amendments—most of which were rejected by majority Democrats. All Republicans voted no.
Thank you, Mr. Speaker. We have a state that was established by people who wanted to be
free and unfettered and were wildly adventurous, brave. They suffered, they struggled,
they established families and homes here. And when they set this up, you know what they said to us?
What I earned by the labor of my back and the work and my toil in my hands, I earned it.
And that represents my lifetime spent doing something productive that benefits the community
at large. That's why that we don't understand the fundamentals is that what you work for
and what you earn by hard toil in the service of others should be yours because it represents the
time that you will have spent in your life. You only get so many days in your life,
that time where you can be productive and put it out there on the planet for the benefit of
humankind, for your children, your grandchildren, them, the great-grandchildren that follow.
That is our point about being a free republic. That's why we established laws that sideboard
and bound governance so that you can't take from the time that we only have a short amount. We
don't even know when our life ends. We just know that we only have so much time. We spend it
productively and we're remunerated so that we can provide for our family and our community
and for our children and their children. That's what we do. That's why this constitution is there.
It's there. It says you cannot just take it willy-nilly. You must amend me if you want the
right to take the labor of a person's lifetime. It's not okay. I don't care if you get really
become a millionaire, okay? You did something productive with your time. You earned it.
You have no right to change that rule without changing the bounding laws. We are ruled by law.
We are not ruled by men or party or anything else. We're ruled by law. That law says you can't take
a man's life work. That's what that law says in that constitution and I would hope that you would
see the gravity of it and that's why we're motivated to speak on this issue so strongly for
so many hours.