PANEL FREE TRADE ZONES AND TRANSNATIONAL CRIME- Mr Juan José Vides

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Apr 17, 2026
18th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum Panama City, Panama 🇵🇦 June 29- 30, 2021
-Mr. Juan José Vides
Honduras Customs Director
I would like to give the floor first to Juan José Vides, which is the Customs Director of Honduras,
so he could tell us about the situation in Honduras in regards to free trade zones.
Thank you, Alejo. Good afternoon, everyone. Senator Robert, thank you very much for
your invitation. Chair of the Parliament, thank you very much for the invitation.
I would like to open with a question, specifically when we talk about free zones.
Can somebody tell me how many free zones there are in the world? Raise your hand if you know
the answer. Well, raise your hand if you know how many free zones or how many companies are
in the free zones in your countries. It's a hard answer. It's very complex. Let's not
think of free zones as something bad or evil. They're vehicles of investment to be able to
promote exports. If we think of exports, that's the strongest element to increase the GDP in our
countries. But what happens when we start to play a very perverse game and we erode the fiscal base
and the fiscal incentives become perverse for tax collection? Or even further, when we see that
organized crime is able to penetrate these organizations and they play against institutionality
itself? I would like to tell you about the Customs Administration of Honduras. It's been created
recently. And I thank the CAPTAC and the FMA for a very fast presentation. And I would like to
have the idea of what happens when there are no rules and where we don't have controls,
or if we don't have a very clear vision as to where we are. Illegal trade is an activity
that entails many different crimes, contraband, counterfeiting goods, piracy, corruption,
passively turning a blind eye, and many others. If we start thinking that there could even be
money laundering, just like we see here in regards to trade-based money laundering,
many countries work towards finding legal frameworks so that the actors that are part
of these operations in the day-to-day, with border police and other institutions, to be able to
guarantee security to our population. When we talk about customs, it's not only the security
what comes in, but also to ensure that whatever comes in upholds the safety measures, that they're
paying their right tariffs, and to ensure the taxes are paid. So what criminal activity have
we found in Honduras? We've seized non-controlled chemical substances. So when we started to do
joint operations, meaning that we work in a streamlined manner, there's something that we
need to find here. And I thank my friend Werner Ovalle for that. Because when you have the will,
and they're honest people that have this desire to fight organized crime and leave a legacy
for your country, you can even exchange information through WhatsApp. You know, they find something,
there's an information, the prosecutor, you speak to the judge, and everybody speaks to each other,
and we understand that we're able to lift the barriers, and we can find common ground.
When we find common ground, then it becomes legitimate, and we go through each institution
to be able to find and identify how to control this. It turns out that Senator Bill Cassidy
mentioned yesterday, when we find a difference in an invoice or in a bill of lading, the bill of
lading says that the shipper is sending an invoice for $25,000, but somebody is invoicing $100,000.
That's a red flag. But if it's only a red flag control for customs, just to adjust an invoice
without having curiosity to further investigate, we then lose control. So in this specific case,
there is 244 tons of a non-controlled chemical substance that their chemical precursors used
for drugs. We carried out an operation with the prosecutor's office to see all the transits
that moved from Port Cortez to the free trade zone. We looked into the inventory, and we told
them, you brought in X much, and we would like to know where this substance is, what happened to it.
He had to justify where the goods were. How did it come into the country? We had no idea.
And this is where we have this curiosity and doubt. What is happening with the companies
that promote export? What is happening if we do not control chemical precursors?
A different case. We saw counterfeiting documents specifically for commodities that are paid.
There was a case that I read in a previous forum. We can see that 0.02
cents, but it was a merchandise that was invoiced for $1,000. And is this something that was really
going to be exported or not? And we see that in customs, we'll have to go beyond one step further
to be able to identify all the banking information with the FOU to see if there's something that
could also affect the economy of the country, and to see if something else that could
maybe mean activity in regards to money laundering. In the agriculture sector, when we say that we
give grants to export shrimp and lobster, but it's impossible to count how many shrimp they're
taking out of the sea, and how much they're actually shipping out, and then they report
losses. No, my container was stolen. No, this other thing was stolen. And they start reporting
this. And we need to think as to how to stop this. And there are many providers and sellers and
vendors in the street selling something that was supposed to be exported, but it's being sold in
the domestic market that generates a competition, an undue competition. And here we have to work
with customs agents. What happens when there's a company that has an advantage,
an undue advantage over another company that's paying all the taxes and all the tariffs?
So if we look into history, many of the companies that in all of our countries work
have been working and operational for many years. We need to identify for how long they've been
receiving fiscal benefits, and whether the government should continue to provide benefits
due to their exports. Imports without transformation. This is one of the biggest
alerts in a free trade zone. So when we talk about factories that would change anything, a good to
change it into something else, or should I just receive the good and stick a label on it?
But what happens with the companies that are legitimately carrying out everything or paying
for their taxes, that are abiding by the laws? And also if you think about the ministries of economy,
it's a right for us to support this type of benefits to those particular companies.
A hundred percent of domestic imports. So what's going to happen with the capitalist
idea of exporting? I will promote fiscal benefits where they will not pay income tax,
they will not pay any tariffs or anything else, and they will not also pay for this.
In other countries we call it dumping, and sometimes they don't pay that. So when we
have the economy of the country, specifically when we lose these controls, and we think that
the brilliant minds behind organized crime are thinking as to how they're able to infiltrate
these or other organizations to be able to talk about this, because it's faster to sell
1,000 boxes of cigarettes than bring in cash. So these organizations use cash to
ensure that they are able to avoid taxes. Financial behavior. Many times their financial
statements do not match their documents. And when we start to talk and speak to the IRS,
what are the taxes of this company that is exporting? And when I share this and I match
it up with the information that I have as a customers authority, it doesn't match up.
And then we need to see how to be able to follow up on this person and find a specific typology
that could ensure that we are not only pertinent or relevant actors within the investigation.
If we think that prosecutors think in criminal activities, but we work in a security arena,
meaning that everyone should work specifically within their area of expertise. My experience,
I've worked at the prosecutor's office and to understand how to typify specific activities to
not lose cases in court. Well, I think that would be the topic of a different forum.
So I'll ask you another question. How many of you know how many prosecution warehouses
you have or holding houses you have within your countries? So I go back to my initial point.
There is no way to be able to quantify this because sometimes we think that nothing is
happening. In this specific case, without offending anybody, there was an internal transit
of undeclared cigarettes from the Cologne free zone, from one free zone to another free zone.
We need to identify how we're able to improve this, which is part of this forum.
We would have a meeting with the authorities, a customs authority here in Panama, and we spoke
about this with Werner, how to improve this. And we need to be creative. Alejo, it would be really
good to think of another forum where we could have a think tank to find a methodology to fight
against transnational illegal crime, drug seizures, and coffee exports. Many of the
in Central America that export coffee have had this issue. Coffee is one of those exports
that are able to increase the GDP of a country, but it's something that is sought after by drug
traffickers because dogs are unable to pinpoint drugs due to the smell of coffee. So many times
we do the rip-on or rip-off where an exporter is concerned because they finally a container with
drug got to another country and they have no idea how to do this to this rip-on, rip-off
operations. I would like everyone to reflect on this fact. How do I visualize a logistic chain?
A nice train is able to sell pretty well, not only with maritime agency shippers and brokers,
and it's able to, you know, do well with everyone in intermediaries, but inside it's just a mess.
Looks good on the outside, but in the inside it's just messy. We've talked about blockchain
documentation, and we talked about all of these things that we are unable to coordinate
because we don't have the power or the scope to be able to visualize this. So when we think
about coffee and fruits and all of this affect transnational crime, we have containers that came
from Italy, Belgium, and Spain, and it was quite surprising for us the damage, the harm it would do
for a country. Okay, so when we have an illicit product from a country, it really affects our
vision of the country. Seizures. When we collaborate with the authorities of Spain,
there was a small company that was working in Honduras, Guatemala, and Nicaragua,
and it was counterfeiting rum. And it was not only contraband, but counterfeiting. So this is
intellectual property. It was counterfeiting or forging rum and then exporting it. We had no idea
what was actually in the container, so anyone that could ingest it could have a health problem.
So we were able to identify that in an export of 225,000 of counterfeit drug in Spain, a criminal
network that worked in Honduras but would trade and send this to Spain all through the free zones.
Ladies and gentlemen, I would like to say that everyone here in regards to security, we are here
and we've been able to identify there are many issues that could affect money laundering, and
that's what banks are there for. And they've been able to bring in everything necessary to ensure
that it doesn't happen. But you know what? That's only the front door. But through the back door,
international trade...
