PANEL: EXTINCTION OF THE DOMAIN TO COMBAT TRANSNATIONAL CRIME

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
2 Video Views·Apr 16, 2026
18th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum Panama City, Panama 🇵🇦 June 29- 30, 2021
With today's afternoon program, we'll continue a very interesting point here, which is asset
forfeiture law, and to see some examples in some countries, and to understand how Panama
is doing in regards to asset forfeiture.
I would like to invite Jonathan Reid, which is the Secretary of Public Ministry of Panama,
on behalf of the minister, in representation of the minister, I would like to also invite
Mr. Germán Garabano from Argentina, former Minister of Justice and Human Rights of Argentina,
and one of the main promoters of the law for asset forfeiture in the Republic of Argentina.
Welcome, Jonathan.
Also online, we have Luis Petri, Deputy of the Nation of Argentina.
He will also be with us virtually.
He is a Congressman of Argentina for the province of Mendoza, and Mr. Armando Padilla,
which is a Justice Advisor at the U.S. Embassy, and a colleague and a strategic partner
in the law for asset forfeiture.
So, Armando, if you would like to sit over here.
I think there's more than a meter and a half.
When we talk about asset forfeiture, this is key for all countries, not only Panama.
Being able to remove assets, resources, money, bank accounts, and properties from organized
crime, it's fundamental to fight the structure of organized crime.
It does not help for the police and our law enforcement agencies in Latin America to arrest
people and different members of criminal organizations, because if you arrest one, there are other
10 waiting to fill in the shoes of that one that was arrested.
So the economic resources of the structure is intact, and we would never be able to debilitate
the framework.
In a process in the last few years supporting El Salvador in the law of asset forfeiture,
we were helping other countries when they wanted to reform the law, and along with that
experience, we started to support the government of Panama, mainly the Ministry of Public Security,
they now have a draft law presented at the National Assembly.
They will present this in detail and to understand the experience of other countries.
We now have Deputy Pietri from Argentina.
Welcome, Mr. Deputy.
And we're waiting to have Mr. Garavano on the screen also.
So I'm here as a moderator, as part of the panel, to allow myself to intervene.
So, dear Mr. Jonathan, can you tell us where Panama is and why you're working on this asset
forfeiture law?
Can you explain the process?
Yes, Alejo, thank you very much.
First of all, I would like to apologize on behalf of the Ministry of Security.
He is unable to attend due to other commitments in his agenda.
But I am here in his representation to thank the auditorium for being in this very important
forum in regards to intelligence and security.
I would like to start with two questions, Alejo.
How are we able to minimize the capacity of criminal organizations to reclude?
And how can we stop the level of expansion that they've shown in the last few years?
So, we have initiatives as asset forfeiture law that would like to weaken their financial
capacity, to remove their financial muscle, which is what they use to finance their legal
activities.
In that sense, the national government, through a technical committee, created a legal framework
that would like to include in our justice system asset forfeiture law.
This law gathers the best practices implemented throughout the region by countries like El
Salvador, Honduras, Argentina, where each of them, and also Colombia.
It's important to highlight Colombia.
Each of them have had experiences prior to ours, and they've been able to generate
very important and dismantlement of different criminal organizations through their asset
forfeiture law.
This working table members of the judicial branch of the Ministry of Economy and Finance,
which for a period of about a year and a half, we were debating as to what should be the
model law that the country needed for this.
Taking into consideration that the best practices have indicated that we need a solid legal
framework that is sustainable, that would allow those that need to ensure that the laws
comply with to be able to assess property with illegal ownership.
Meaning, through these assets, they are able to finance their criminal activities, and
by removing this, we can curb their recruitment, and they generate a lot of damage here.
So the draft law, it's for organized crime organizations.
Right.
The project is here to curb criminal activity, to take the resources with which they finance
and recruit new members for organized crime.
Thank you.
I would like to give the floor to Luis Petri.
He is a really good Argentinian.
We have an international audience here, Mr. Deputy.
So I think we should explain what's happening on your side of the screen.
So before I explain that I'm drinking mate tea, which is a traditional infusion for
Argentina, Uruguay, and Paraguay, I would like to thank my friend, Robert Bittinger,
for allowing me to be here on this panel, and for all the support that they always provide
to be able to move forward in legislation that is able to fight transnational crime.
Knowing and understanding the power of articulation and cooperation among countries to be able
to fight the scourge, this would not be possible without this push that we always have from
Robert Bittinger to ensure that we always have this type of meetings where we're able
not only to articulate, but to ensure that legislation is able to standardize in points
as important as seizing assets in many countries in the region.
Mr. Deputy, what is the situation of Argentina?
What's the experience that you could share in regards to the asset forfeiture beyond
the law and the legal instrument they use in Argentina?
The concept of asset forfeiture, and since we have parliamentary members of the entire
world, so maybe you could talk about that.
We have a criminal code which would be 100 years old, and we've had many reforms,
and it has used a figure that you understand where we're able to confiscate assets,
which was mainly to the elements of the crime, or the perpetrators of the specific crime,
but it was not focused on those gains from a crime.
The figure was expanded later because it was not enough to be able to prosecute the perpetrators,
but rather due to the proliferation of criminal organizations to be able to move forward
in the organized business of crime.
The criminal process many times was an obstacle, and in many international conventions,
and I'd like to mention the Iran Convention Against Organized Crime,
and the Convention of Fight Against Corruption,
many different standards that we saw at an international level,
but requested from the states that it should not only sentence,
or wait for a sentence to be able to confiscate assets in a criminal arena.
This was a very important change, not for the legislation,
not only of Latin America, but for the whole world.
Without having a criminal conviction, we were able to confiscate properties
when it was either due to prescription, death, or because the person escaped,
or any legal mechanism that would not allow us to move forward in the prosecution of certain processes.
Without a doubt, the investigation of the assets was still under the criminal scope,
meaning that we could still use the guiding principles of criminal law,
so it was impossible to work in a retroactive manner, which was a limitation.
The second point is that in the criminal process, and there is none,
at least in the Republic of Argentina, there is no serious investigation of patrimony.
So we have a criminal process where we need to typify and clearly state the perpetrator of the crime,
but the process does not really look at the assets and property, which are gains of the crime.
So now we move to confiscation, which no longer was an accessory, an auxiliary part of the sentence,
it became a sentence on its own.
In 1989, we have the drug trafficking law, and now we start to foresee this anticipated confiscation.
Nevertheless, it would take a lot more time because we needed to move forward in the money laundering cases,
and in terrorist financing cases.
We were able to achieve this in 2009, but within the criminal process.
In 2016, under the government of Cambiamos, Together for the Change,
at that moment I was president of the Commission of Security of the Interior Nation,
and the former Minister of Justice, Germán Carabano, and Patricia Woodruff,
which was the Minister of Security, we were able to promote in Argentina the action of asset forfeiture.
Taking as an example the experience of Colombia, which was thought to be very interesting.
They were not only able to approve the law in the 1990s,
but they removed the constitutional barriers with a constitutional reform
where it's no longer criminal, but now it's civil.
We're not going against a person, but against a crime in itself,
which can be applied in a retroactive manner and that can no longer be prescribed
because there is no way to be able to clean up everything that illicit crime has caused or harmed.
So our countries can no longer guarantee private property of criminal organizations
and this property needs to be removed and it needs to go back into the resources of the state.
So this is why it's important for it to be autonomous with specialized prosecutors
that are training us with a civil procedure that would be independent of all the principles of the criminal process.
For example, the principle of you are not guilty until your sentence.
In Colombia, the burden of the proof is switched with it in the condition of proving that they're not guilty.
And the person that has acquired the property through a legal way,
then they need to be able to prove it and if not, then it needs to go back to the state.
So there are many points that are part of the process in regards to asset management.
Colombia, which has been able to obtain for over a billion dollars
when they started with this asset forfeiture law
and we were informed through the United Nations in their report,
everything in regards to asset management which had an environmental and ecological impact
specifically when we talk of the hippopotamus of Pablo Escobar
that multiplied and generated a harm to the ecosystem.
I think there are many different points that we need to think about
but the world, the region needs to be able to work on creating asset forfeiture law
that could de-finance criminal organizations.
Mr. Deputy, I could ask you what is the process of asset management
and what concrete examples do we have in Argentina
in regards to assets that have been seized through asset forfeiture?
And now I would like to introduce our colleague Armando Padilla
from the Department of Justice of the United States
to explain the experience of the United States
in regards to confiscation
and how the United States through the embassies
are able to support the different countries in regards to cooperation.
As it was mentioned this afternoon,
organized crime is able to enjoy illegal resources or illegal wealth.
And according to the report of the United Nations,
1% of these assets are seized.
99% are still in their ownership
and this wealth is used to finance violence
and other types of crime and even corruption of authorities.
Crime has no boundaries.
We need to keep in mind that especially this phenomenon
is something that trickles down into the economies.
In what sense?
Because it produces artificial economies
and it promotes different monopolies
which does not allow legal investments to come
because it's not reasonable
because the essence of these illegal organizations
is to do money laundering.
As has already been mentioned,
different international conventions
and different efforts of the international community
have been able to enact an advance
in different tools that allow to be able to confiscate assets.
In Europe they have certain mechanisms,
in Latin America and just like in the United States.
I would like to focus on what's happening in Latin America.
There is a model law
which has been approved in some sessions
by this organism
and it's allowed different states to uptake asset forfeiture laws
which is a criminal prosecution
focused on the patrimony
to be able to debilitate the power of criminal organizations.
These model laws and the shared efforts
of countries like Colombia, Mexico,
El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Peru
most recently and Ecuador
they all show that the property
would be returned to the state
if they were not obtained to legal means
through a process
as our speaker from Argentina explained.
Within these models in the region
the public ministry
is who would do the investigation
of the patrimony with assistance
of financial investigation
and other judicial branches.
They request a judge to adapt
precautionary measures
whether it's to localize
and fine assets
which are the proceeds of crime.
So after a period of investigation
the prosecutors request
for specialized judges
that specialize in asset forfeiture
to ensure that they can move forth
with the application of the law.
There are several variables
if we can talk about the case of Panama
it would be to carry out this activity
firstly to ensure that it's within
the specific jurisdiction
meaning that only a judge can carry it out
not administrative authorities
and in an oral trial
meaning that the prosecutor
should show the reason
for the asset forfeiture
meaning that he needs to be able to prove
that these assets are proceeds
of a crime
that they come from the transformation
or conversion of other assets
that even though they were legally obtained
they were used to conceal illegal activities
if we're able to see that there was
illicit enrichment
that legal and illegal
properties are used together
in this scenario
we protect, as we've said
the good faith of third parties
in what sense do I mean that?
because asset forfeiture protects
the right to property in Panama
the constitution states
that private property
is protected if it was acquired
by legal means
meaning that any assets of an individual
outside of a legal scope
because if it's the proceeds
through an illegal activity
then it can be under this law
if we talk about acquired rights
and that cannot be altered
through the law
but specifically those assets
that are part of the patrimony of a person
whether a corporation or individual
without complying with the specific standards
cannot call upon the constitutional protection
in this region
in the specific proposal of Panama
we would like to consolidate
an administration organism
that can conserve the value of the assets
to ensure that their worth is not lost
and also for companies
we can ensure
if they are seized
to ensure that people do not lose their jobs
and the company does not lose their worth
so that this administration organism
is able to sell the assets
and to have a level of economic gain
which then can be used for education
and strengthening security
the way in which asset forfeiture
would work
it would work through the elements that I explained
in regards to good practices
the Parlatino has a model law
for asset forfeiture
plus a cybersecurity law
that was approved this year
plus the law to fight illegal
trade and transnational organized crime
and model law approved in February of this year
these are three instruments
that should work together
as model laws to be able to inspire
the legislations of other countries
whether it's in their reform
or for the policy makers in the countries
that do not have these laws
but we should also think about them
as independent instruments
in Parlatino we have this experience
and the capacity to share this
with other countries
because there are legislations
that can always be improved
another example is Honduras
we will talk about what happens
with these funds
Honduras has a really good experience
in regards to specific assets
that came from drug trafficking
and through the asset forfeiture law
came back to the state
and they were able to transform this
into a home
for children and adolescents
that were in very vulnerable situations
the most important thing is that
asset forfeiture as a tool
that can assist public authorities
to work against organized crime
specifically against cartels
allowed for a specific drug trafficker
where his assets were seized
from his protection circle
when finally he no longer had
his protection circle
which was based in money
finance and properties
finally this individual did not have
this circle of protection
and we were able to move forward
and this is a really good example
of how the law resources can be used
going back to what would happen
to the assets
which is a question of the citizens
who would manage these assets
two simultaneous questions
first Panama and secondly Argentina
so what would you do with the assets
what does the law indicate
that you would do with the assets
in Panama
the question for you is an example
from Argentina of assets that were seized
through the asset forfeiture law
those resources came into the states
and a specific benefit that they've had
in Panama's case
the law has established an office
specifically for assets seized
through this law
and it seeks to minimize
the development of criminal activities
it also seeks to
in any way possible
return or repay
those who have suffered
restitute those who have suffered
because of these crimes
there is also a very effective
administration of the goods
in terms of advanced sales
the possibility that the authority
in the ministry of economy and finance
might be able to use those resources
quickly
actually what's happening now
is that many times goods are lost
because it is a slow process
so what you're saying is that
with the Panamanian project
those goods are used to support
government programs
it is a public order and social interest law
so the goal is to meet the needs
of the population
especially considering the fact
that these goods are collected
to support the government
and to avoid the continuation
of these kinds of crimes
I would like to comment something here
because asset forfeiture returns
that social concept to these goods
it returns the goods to the society
and so it is really important
that that is our goal
these are products, goods
that had an illicit source
or they were legal products
but they were used by organized crime
a home for example, a vehicle
it could be anything
these are goods that are returned
to society so that they can be used
properly and legally
Mr. Petri, what are the beneficial
experiences that you've had in Argentina?
I'm not sure if Germán Garbana is there
he was going to talk about the law
that we have in Argentina
but if he's not here I can explain it
it is true that in the Republic of Argentina
I was the informant for the committee
and there were certainly some goods
that have that characteristic
this project that we were working on
spent quite a lot of time in the legislative branch
it was modified and came in completely
different to the legislative branch
there were no autonomous processes
there were a lot of different problems
that we were seeing and concerns
about how the asset forfeiture could happen
so at that point the president
of the country at that time
presented a decree which is one of the
abilities that the president has
to create legislative decrees
that in the case that this would not
be approved by both legislative bodies
then it would continue to be valid
that decree was not enforced
and some provinces among them
I will specifically mention my province
Mendoza made modifications
to their processing legislation
and so this legislation
which is not being applied
was being used only for crimes
against public administration
not specifically corruption
so there were kind of two processes
one has been completed
the other one involved forfeiture
and the forfeiture has been completed
for a public officer who was condemned
or was found guilty of corruption
and his goods were returned to the state
three vehicles, luxury vehicles
and three properties
so this asset forfeiture law
establishes specific goods
and cash
whatever other kind of financial
instrument it may be
and it ensures their
return to the government
the judge has to authorize this process
so that quickly the goods can be sold
which avoids damages where those goods
cannot be properly maintained
in their original state
thank you very much for that
coming back to the region and to Panama
Panama is a logistics hub
in terms of international commerce
and with many countries
not just in Latin America
but in nearly every continent
what is the expectation for dealing
with this with other countries
there may be goods that
while they may belong to Panamanians
or Panamanian companies
they may be in Panama
and during an investigation
you may discover that they belong
to organized crime
but their goods are not in Panama
how do you intend to work on that
so the framework establishes
international cooperation
to an extent where investigations
can be done in a joint manner
with the authorities from those countries
where we believe that there are goods
that are the product of illegal activities
we are able to share the information
and to develop those investigations properly
there must be a due process
the Panamanian law respects
the right to property
as you mentioned at the beginning
and our framework establishes guarantees
so there is a right to a defense
there is a right to a judge
which is called a rights judge
and there are other rights that are protected
what about the good faith third party
this is something that worries a lot of people
the good faith third party has
a special protection
in the asset forfeiture law
and there are recommendations
and international standards
there is a model law from the UN
for us and it gives an example
it provides protections for those
who have received these assets
in good faith
it does require a certain level of due diligence
on behalf of anyone who acquires
any good
that is to say
there is a possibility
there must be some care taken
to avoid participating
in these kinds of illegal activities
so businesses and others
must participate
in this kind of cultural shift
when you acquire a good
it is important to be able to show
that it was acquired in good faith
I know this client, I know my counterpart
and there was some exploration done
to try to understand
what the situation of this good
was before
we know that organized crime uses
different tools to hide their goods
or to transform them
or to throw you off the trail
of their illicit origin
we do know of many cases
in the countryside
in many Latin American countries
where those organizations come in
through a local structure
and perhaps a young person
who grew up in the same neighborhood
their whole life
asks an older woman
if she could open a bank account
for him
she opens up an account
and allows him
to deliver certain assets
to her
and then she is under investigation
but it's someone she knows
someone she knew from her neighborhood
of course she trusts him
so this requires that we do
a little bit more research
to understand what's behind it
and this is also why it's important
to have awareness raising
and education of our population
so that they can understand this
during the asset forfeiture process
what would you say from Argentina
in this issue of goodwill third parties
well certainly we have to pursue
the goods even when there have
been simulated transfers
or other kinds of transfers
in that case the goods will still
need to be returned to the state
now in the case of good faith third parties
our decree does determine
that the action of asset forfeiture
is not valid
for goodwill third parties
so when we find ourselves facing
a goodwill third party
and there needs to be a sentence
of asset forfeiture
then the amount of the goods that were
transferred to the third party
cannot be included in that asset forfeiture action
it must be substituted for the cash amount
that was represented by those goods
and then we can do
the action of asset forfeiture
yesterday and today we were talking
quite a bit about cryptocurrency
and crypto assets, digital assets, etc
the question always comes up
with asset forfeiture law
we understand that these should be
modern legislation but what is the
connection here between asset forfeiture
and crypto assets
we understand that there is a way
to forfeit digital assets
is there a way to do that
or is there not
and does the law need to include that
does the law have jurisdiction
this is a question which is quite broad
as you mentioned
the new criminal
activities really force
those in law enforcement
to reinvent ourselves
in the Panamanian security forces
we are constantly updating our staff
and training our staff on cybercrime
a financial investigation came into the police force
and there was a
financial investigation unit
for cybercrime specifically
which shows how we are
being resilient and adapting
to new criminal methodologies
organized crime does not stop
and crime does not stop
they are reinventing themselves every day
the security forces must do the same
we have to keep in mind
that the experience of criminal investigation
in the past traditionally
in our countries and in the region
was concerned primarily with forfeiting assets
that were physical assets
a vehicle
some other property
and so the criminal process
was limited
but when we are looking at asset forfeiture
we can see that the focus
or the attention is directed
at the entire patrimony
so to speak
that this person has
all the profits from this illegal behavior
so asset forfeiture
seeks to investigate profits
not necessarily the person
but the goods
let me give you a really clear example
you have a vehicle
a public transport vehicle
many times in criminal processes in the region
the vehicle itself might be seized
but not the license
with which the vehicle was operated
and that may have
in some places even more value than the vehicle itself
so the goal of asset forfeiture
is to open up that spectrum
of course that will require
investigative technology
specialized investigations
close collaboration with FIUs
and international assistance
thank you Armando
Luis, cryptoassets and asset forfeiture
where is crypto
included in asset forfeiture?
ok so first of all
I think the issue with cryptoassets
is individualizing them and finding them
of course
in general
when we talk about legislation
on the continent
asset forfeiture actions
happen in the preparatory or introductory phases
of the criminal process
in the region
at least in Argentina
in most countries of the region
in a few countries
we haven't been able to separate ourselves
completely from the criminal process
and that is why everything related to
titles, crypto
whatever other activity
it requires proof
that can be presented quickly
in Argentina we have a federal system
and when we're looking at crypto
it's very important at the very beginning
of the investigation
to have a full investigation
of assets, complete assets
when we are looking at
organized crime
there is movements of enormous levels
of property, whether it's cash
property, art, etc
so the proof that is needed
in order to seize
and forfeit these goods
is so important
even beyond that our legislation
does not contain specific specifications
and so it would treat
cryptocurrency just the same
as it does cash
thank you very much
thanks to all three of you
for participating
for sharing some information
about this idea of forfeiture
hearing from Argentina
from Panama
which is going through
a very interesting process
which the new assembly will have to deal with
as the year moves forward
we hope that will come out soon
because Panama urgently needs
this asset forfeiture law
for goods of illegal
goods that have been obtained illegally
and so we want to thank you
all for sharing your thoughts here
I don't know if we have any key questions
any really relevant questions from the audience
can we get a microphone
I think that they are getting a microphone
to you sir
I'm so sorry congressperson
they are trying to get you a microphone
I apologize
good afternoon and thank you very much
I would like to reiterate
or remind you I am a representative
from the Peruvian parliament
I would like to say once again hello
to Mr. Jorge Pizarro
Mr. Pittenger
Alejo Campos
organizers of this parliamentary forum
which is so important
to talk about intelligence security
I would like to say hello
to all of the representatives from Latin America
from the United States and from around the world
for this excellent meeting
ladies and gentlemen
I am a retired colonel
in the Peruvian police force
with more than 35 years of service
fighting criminal forces
in my country including organized crime
in these recent years
it has become more and more international
with well coordinated organizations
which commit crimes
like drug trafficking
human trafficking, kidnapping
arms trafficking, murder
trafficking migrants
contraband, theft
and other criminal actions
which negatively affect the security
and the well being of the Peruvian population
for that reason, financing
has a very important role
for the operation of these mafia organizations
currently in Peru
the cryptocurrency
is a financial asset
which is not regulated
so it is not considered a currency
or a legal currency
it is not backed
by Peruvian banks
unfortunately, sanctions against
money laundering
are not regulated
in the Peruvian legal system
for this reason
I would like to hear your comments
I would like to ask about your experience
I would like to know
what regulations
what guides or laws
would you recommend
in order to protect the financial integrity
of the country
and how can we regulate the very high volatility
as in price of virtual currencies
thank you
this panel is specifically
about asset forfeiture
what I would recommend
is to get together those experts
on the topic of cryptocurrency
so that we can meet together
and see what kind of recommendations
and suggestions they have for Peru
we are not going to ask our colleagues
to talk about a topic
that is not their topic
representative from Costa Rica
hello everyone
I'm a member of the directive board
of Parlatino
thank you very much for being here today
to talk about this very important subject
which many of our legislative bodies
have avoided talking about
in Costa Rica
there was a project presented
a bill in 2015
which started in the previous period
the representatives who were in a position before me
and they did manage to develop a text
to the legislative process
however those who were adverse to this process
have tried to
file this away
I am perfectly aware of the need
to advance and make progress
with an asset forfeiture law
however with the project currently in Costa Rica
there are 18 possible
crimes
that allow for asset forfeiture
certainly that is very open
like corruption
and tax evasion
there is a concern
that those goods may not be
100% related
to one of those crimes
but rather just a small percent
so listening to the experience from Argentina
specifically
and those of you who spoke at the beginning
of the discussion
would you consider that asset forfeiture
should be focused primarily on drug trafficking
and organized crime
or should it be open more broadly
how can we ensure that we are really making progress
with the implementation of asset forfeiture
throughout the region
so that we can be more assertive
in this issue
especially looking at all sorts of crime
including organized crime
which then results in obtaining certain goods
what an excellent comment representative
I would say first of all
there is no crime that legitimizes a good
in that sense
we would have to think about
what sort of crime could mean
that a good is constitutionally and judicially legitimate
we would have to ask ourselves
any kind of financial activity
that generates illegal goods
should be included in asset forfeiture
we can then take away that financial strength
from these groups
and promote the development
of social activities
and appropriate social activities
limiting it to certain kinds of crime
will produce negative results
because there continue to be funds
that are the product of a criminal activity
thank you very much
would you like to comment as well
yes, really in the region
when we deal with asset forfeiture
in Colombia for example
we created it with a certain closed group
of crimes that were included
there was a list of crimes
however we had an experience with a specific case
which I think was shared
there was an organization
which did pyramid schemes
financial pyramid schemes
we have them here in Panama
there was a scam like that
in Colombia those crimes
are not included in the list
of illegal activities
that qualify for asset forfeiture
for that reason there was a modification
and we moved from having
that closed list of crimes
to having language that said
that illegal activities were subject
to asset forfeiture
specifically because of that experience
and that experience is the reason
that the model law for the region
talks about illicit activities
instead of reducing it to a certain
catalog of activities
in the different prosecutor's offices
which have the ability to investigate
these activities
each country has its own experience
for example there are countries in Central America
where we'll say what are we going to do
with these funds
that transporters are bringing
into the airport without declaring
so we decided to include that
in asset forfeiture
in Mexico for example
there are these workshops
where they worked on cars
there's a whole mafia behind that
and each country has their own reality
in terms of the illegal activities that they're doing
and that is why it is preferable
to talk about illegal activities
instead of having a specific catalog
of crimes
I do want to emphasize the fact that asset forfeiture
is a tool that should be directed and coordinated
at criminal organizations
and we should not lower its use
and use it for activities that are less serious
or to forfeit assets
or seize assets that aren't
significantly valuable
that's kind of the balance
from one to another
thank you Armando
we will wrap up with our comments
from Mr. Petri from Argentina
yes I absolutely agree about what's been said here
however from the Republic of Argentina
my opinion based on our context
and the difficulties that we have had
in dealing with this issue
I personally am convinced
that we must move progressively
in the implementation of this tool
to start to remove some of the fears
that exist about the improper use
of asset forfeiture law
to simply steal essentially
and so there are concerns
out there about crime
linked to organized crime
specifically organized crime
and not other common crimes
the bill and the law
does establish the kinds of crimes
that are included
and it does have to do with money laundering
terrorism financing, terrorist acts
trafficking in drugs
in people, in weapons
and customs and contraband crimes
I do believe that we need to continue
evolving the law progressively
and amplifying it progressively
to see what kind of others
will be included
Colombia for example
has threatened unions
that close the streets
or block the streets
and they have threatened
to use asset forfeiture law
against them with the fact
that they are committing a crime
by blocking the streets
I believe that this develops
a significant level of distrust
about the implementation of this tool
in our region
and so we must overcome
this square of impunity
that is the lack of trust
that there is because of
the judiciary operatives
when they apply this tool
disinterest
and a lack of information that exists
about asset forfeiture
so I think we have to break down those myths
we have to focus on crimes
that have a high economic impact
and crimes that have a high impact
on our community
Thank you very much
I would like to thank our panelists
and I would like a round of applause for them
and with that we will close this
panel for asset forfeiture
at our forum today
