*Affiliate Links Generate Revenue for the Channel*
Disclaimer: This video is not intended to provide diagnosis, treatment, or medical advice. Content provided in this video is for educational purposes only. Please consult with a physician regarding any health-related diagnosis or treatment.
What's up everyone? Welcome to Doctorly Unhinged. I'm Dr. Shaw. I'm Dr. Maxfield.
And today, this is our Unhinged podcast, so we just talk about things that have been coming
through the newswire, things that are on our radar, things that people are tagging us in,
and we give our unbiased opinion, sometimes our medical opinion, but mostly just our thoughts
on these topics. Yeah, it's unbiased. It's unsolicited. We'll kind of get into the weeds
with this. So hang with us. Enjoy this long thought process, but we're going to have fun
and keep it light as we go. Exactly. No one asked for this. No one asked for a podcast.
We gave it to you anyway. So today we have a ton of stuff to talk about. There are a lot of things
that have been coming through as very popular topics, especially on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube,
that we've been getting tagged in. We want to discuss them today and give our opinions on them.
So we're going to just hop right in. We're going to cut out the fluff here.
Today we're going to be talking about ozempic face first. So first, what is ozempic face?
Right. So ozempic, if you're not familiar with, this is a medication that's come into the press.
It's not exactly new. This was approved actually a couple of years ago for weight loss, but it's
actually traditionally used in the diabetes space. And one of the things that has been noted to do,
though, is help people lose weight. And is it effective? It actually kind of is,
based off of the studies. Now, what we're actually going to dig into today is kind of
consequence of that. So since people have been using this medication for weight loss, and since
it's working, now people are finding out that they're not loving the results. And that's where
this term has been coined. Exactly. So ozempic is a brand name for a medication that is similar to
many other diabetes medications, a glucagon-like peptide agonist. So it basically is similar to
this peptide called glucagon that's normally secreted by our body and does many things in
our body to regulate insulin production, to regulate glucagon production. And overall,
it actually makes you feel full. It suppresses your appetite and slows the emptying of your stomach,
so you end up actually eating less food. And like Dr. Maxfield was saying, a lot of people
noticed that they lose a lot of weight on the medication. Now, it was initially approved for
and then became approved for obesity, but really only in people that had other comorbidities. So
you had to have diabetes or hypertension, high blood pressure, or high cholesterol,
or some other type of thing to be approved. So really, the way that it's being used today,
a lot of celebrities have talked about it, a lot of content creators have talked about it,
and it's really gone viral because people are using it for weight loss, even though it's not
approved for weight loss unless you have other issues going on. So they're almost using it,
what we call off-label, but it does cause weight loss. And when you lose weight rapidly,
that's when you start to see effects on the skin and people don't like their appearance.
So this happens with anybody. If you lose, if you get gastric bypass, gastric sleeve,
use Ozempic, and you lose a ton of weight really, really quickly, your skin doesn't react fast
enough to really take into account, I don't know, what am I trying to say here?
The loss of volume. It can't compensate for the loss of volume. So what Dr. Shah is kind
of getting at here is the skin that's been, I don't know if I want to say stretched out,
but it really has. Just over time, your skin is used to having more underneath it,
so you've got more of it, right? And so then when you lose the fat underneath it,
it is kind of stretched out, it's lax. And that redundancy contributes to the appearance
of things like wrinkles and even, I don't know, a term that Dr. Shah doesn't, it's hard,
no one uses the word sallowing, but it's like a, it's an aging term, not only to the quality of
the skin, but also like a sallow face. I think that's a thing, right? A sallow face is where
you kind of have hollow, concave cheeks. Gaunt, I think. Yeah, that's exactly right.
So, and you see this, right? In anybody who loses weight rapidly, even on their body,
a lot of times they'll need surgery to actually correct all that hanging excess skin. And the
same thing can occur in the face where that now, that skin, it's like a balloon that you've now
deflated. It doesn't just shrink down completely. Like if you have a balloon that's full for a long
period of time and then you shrink it down, it doesn't go back to its original elasticity that
it always had. It becomes floppy and has extra folds and extra skin. And so that's essentially
what would happen to your face. If you used Ozempic and did lose a lot of weight, you would
end up having like bags underneath your eyes and your skin would sag a little bit and your wrinkles
would be more pronounced. And eventually with time, that should get better as your skin adjusts
and changes with time. But in the immediate period, you will look hollowed out. Yes. And
the reason I think, even without realizing it, that people are finding this fairly untoward
is it mimics some of the natural changes that occur with aging. And so if you're losing weight
dramatically, drastically, and quickly, you're going to feel like you've aged tremendously in
a short period of time because, and Dr. Shah and I have talked about this, in the changes of the
face that occur with aging, not only do they occur in the skin where the skin becomes dull, like you
get excess texture due to loss of oils, it can become redundant, but some of that is actually
due to the changes underneath the skin. So when the fat pads atrophy or they shift and migrate
down, that also, or bone resorption, the same thing, bone resorption, it's loss of volume
underneath the skin and that contributes to the appearance of an aging face. And so when you lose
weight from something like Ozempic, the changes that you're seeing in the mirror actually are a
dramatic and drastic realization of the aging that may have taken place over the next 20 years,
but it just mimics it in a short period of time. Right. And I would actually take it another step
further and discuss the use of facial filler in general. You know, I think that you could
potentially have the same downfalls, right? So facial filler, usually hyaluronic acid, I mean,
we have other substances we use, but by and large, nowadays, the most common filler we use is
hyaluronic acid filler. We inject it into the face to give the face volume in areas that we either
lose volume or we want to change the face. So for example, if you inject the upper face
with hyaluronic acid and that basically will stretch out the skin, fill in volume loss,
but after that begins to get absorbed by the body after a year, year and a half, two years,
it does stick around a lot longer than we initially had thought, but doesn't stay in the
same place that we initially injected it into. And so eventually that area will also deflate.
And I would argue that that could also cause your skin to sag in the future as well,
if you don't continue with those injections. So it's like a whole nother level of filler
addiction because you have, there's, cosmetics are addicting in a, in a way. I mean, I don't
know if it's, I don't know, like the science and studies behind it and the psychology literature,
but it is in a way, because it's rewarding. Like you inject yourself with a filler, right? And
you get this return to probably, it could be depending on how you do it, something similar
to what you looked like 10 years ago, or at least to mimic it. And so not only is that addicting,
but now you're saying that if you stop doing it, it not only could take you back to where you were
before you started it, but maybe even exaggerate it further than it ever would have been before
because it's stretching out the skin. It's like a whole nother level. And I hadn't honestly thought
about that side of it before. Well, if you think about it, even if you're injecting lips, right?
You're changing the anatomy, the natural anatomy of your lips. And so, you know, by putting that
volume in there, you're pushing other things out of the way. And once that goes away, what happens
to the lips, right? Like, do they just go back to what they normally were? Or is there exaggerated
skin? Is there distortion of the normal anatomy with time, right? So, I mean, filler works very
well if placed correctly, but once you start to change the normal anatomy, it can distort the way
that you look. And that's why with filler, we always talk about using filler to restore volume
loss that happened with time, right? Because as you age, you notice wrinkles and you notice things
moving in the direction of gravity. And you notice that bone resorption very commonly along this arch
in your upper face. And so, if you just inject a little bit in these areas to restore the volume
that's lost, it gives you a more natural look and doesn't cause you to have a distorted look that
then you would have to constantly put more and more filler to fight against. So, you're almost
trying to just balance what you lose. But on the same side as ozempic, if you're losing volume
really quickly, you're going to have this appearance. Now, that can be, you know, like, that's
unavoidable because of how rapidly you're losing the weight. The question is, what do you do about
that if it happens? Like, what would you recommend? Would you recommend then saying, okay, well, you
lost a lot of volume. Let's replace that volume with filler. And that's what I'm seeing a lot of
people say is, if you develop this ozempic face, that you should use filler to replace the volume
that was lost. Now, so, I think based off of what you just said, that's perhaps one of the best
options for that. Because again, the whole goal is to replace the volume underneath the skin.
In this case, in that setting to kind of make the skin look more healthy, less redundant. And I would
agree that that's probably going to be useful. Now, I actually think it's also going to be
more useful than topical things. And this is, I think, where people get into trouble a lot of times
is they're looking for a topical product-based fix for something that's really structural and
where topicals couldn't address. And I think this is going to fall into that category because I'm
not sure anything that you do to really just target the skin like collagen elastin or anything
like that is going to replace or really address the underlying problem here. And that is excess
skin overlying a loss of volume. So again, I think filler seems reasonable. And again,
you're compensating with filler in particular though. So, if you're adding it over the bony
arch in the upper face, you're going to help address the redundant skin that's inferior below
it. Now, one thing it won't directly do is actually perhaps replace the volume of the fat
itself. And so, one place my mind went is the utility of like a fat pad transfer or a fat
transfer rather into this area. And now, it doesn't work. So, what a fat transfer is like you take fat
from a separate site and then you put it into an area where you want it right off. I think you see
this a lot in the buttocks. That's an area where people are always looking to get a little more
volume, take it from somewhere else, put it there, that'd be nice. But with the face,
could it be helpful? I'm not sure. Would that maybe be an alternative or would it be
more problematic than adding filler to fix this problem? No, I mean fat transfer to the face has
actually become very popular in plastic surgery as an alternative to hyaluronic acid fillers,
right? Because I think people are finding with hyaluronic acid fillers that they're not happy
with the way that they look or the fact that they stay around longer than we anticipated is becoming
concerning to people. And so, because fat transfer doesn't last as long and it's naturally produced by
your own body and then placed back in there, people are opting actually more and more for
fat transfer in the face. And so, I don't necessarily think that you would be worse off
using that. But I would then say that we're just going to be constantly like inflating and
deflating the face, which I don't know if that's like necessarily the outcome that you want,
right? Like if you lose weight and you feel healthier and you're happier with the way that
you look, but now your skin looks wrinkly and older, I would recommend like skin tightening
procedures probably first, right? So, things like CO2 laser really and radiofrequency microneedling
if, you know, it's not that severe. Or even maybe even like a facelift as an alternative to like
then just putting more volume into this. Because I think that once you're playing the volume battle,
you're just going to be in that forever versus things that would appear more natural
like tightening procedures where you're not changing the anatomy.
Yeah. And so, I'm picturing all of these different outcomes in my head. And as always,
and with all of our channels, we talk about personalization of this. Because each one of
these different procedural options is going to be very individualized and tailored towards it.
Because in my head, in my head, when we were talking about the redundant skin,
I was thinking of something similar to like a hound dog or not Eilers Danlos. What's the other
cutis laxa where the skin is very redundant to an extreme? And for me, I think the skin
tightening procedures, something like a facelift or where you just do a skin reduction where you
like take a portion of skin, hide the scar and actually move the skin up would be valuable.
They're more than perhaps filler, certainly more than CO2 and microneedling. So, let me
organize it this way. If a person has something like this, and if the skin is only slightly saggy,
it just kind of looks a little bit loose or redundant, but it's not actually hanging or
draping. It's somewhat subtle. I think CO2 laser microneedling would be a great first start.
If a person's finding that it's just very redundant, it's like a very obvious, obvious
loosening of their skin and almost like if jowls, I think then you should look at perhaps skin
tightening procedures like a facelift. And that's where you actually grab the
SMAS underlying the skin and tighten the whole thing. I think that might be more useful.
And then for filler, I think, you know, we'd look at the way this can be done. I think that would
be more like a person per use situation when there's a, I think it would actually complement
some of the, I think it would just complement all of it because it brings something unique.
Filler would complement and replace some of the natural aging changes like bony loss
resorption in the upper face. And that would probably complement a fat plaid replacement
or complement the facelift where you'd be targeting perhaps a different area.
So, I guess what I'm saying is it's going to be personalized and a person might end up
betting benefiting from just all of it. But yeah, well, no, I think actually there's a
strong argument here for combination therapy. Like, you know, I didn't know what direction
I was going to lean on this, but you know, after you saying this and me thinking about this,
a small amount of filler, right, to replace some of the volume loss, but not to the point where
you look exaggerated or bloated, complemented with skin tightening procedures, whether that
be a facelift or it be really aggressive CO2 resurfacing, being a way to come together to
give you a more natural look that you're not constantly chasing like throwing volume at
something that you're never going to catch up with. And so, I think that that would probably
be the way that you're going to have the most sustainable results with this. Because like,
what are you going to just not take Ozempic if you have diabetes or you have obesity with
these other comorbidities? It's been shown to have like overall health benefits, right? So,
it's like if you're using it inappropriately, right? If you're somebody who's using it and
it's not necessarily indicated, it's used off-label, then of course, like you don't
like the way that you look, then stop using it. But if you have these other health issues that
could shorten your lifespan, then, you know, using Ozempic or Wagovi or one of these similar
medications, like you need them. And so, how do you address the resultant skin problem that
develops as a result of using this? And I think then it's that multifactorial approach of using
multiple modalities to tighten the skin and make you overall look healthy over a long period of
time. Yeah. And that's kind of a big part of this too, is we've really focused on the purely
cosmic. So, like we were just kind of assuming that it was a cosmetic problem you're trying to
address at first, but there's a whole subset of people who were actually taking this functionally
for a bigger picture, health picture. And now this is just something that they're left with.
And interestingly too, though, this isn't the first diabetes medication that's been associated
with weight loss. In fact, before this became fairly routine, I would hear of people using
metformin for a similar purpose because metformin, which is another medication used in
diabetes to increase your insulin sensitivity, also has some studies behind it showing it can
be helpful for weight loss. And perhaps one of the reasons that the problems of what is
the term the Ozempic phase didn't come out with metformin is maybe it wasn't as robust. Maybe it
wasn't as good at promoting weight loss now as these new medications. But this isn't the first
time that this patient population or people with these lifestyle or metabolic or health problems
have been using a diabetes medication for weight loss. This isn't the first time this
has been introduced. Yeah, so I think that that's a good point. I would probably argue that the
metformin weight loss is not as aggressive as Ozempic from what I've heard. But yeah,
you can lose weight with multiple different medications. And there are people that lose
weight for many reasons rapidly, right? Like, you know, whether it be cancer, whether it be,
you know, intentional with surgery or exercise or any modality. So it's not really
an Ozempic problem as it is a weight loss problem. And what do you do with excess skin
once you have aggressive weight loss? And, you know, I think that what we're recommending here
would help in any scenario in which you rapidly lose weight. So it's definitely it's definitely
it's, you know, it's just more of a weight loss issue than it is a drug issue in my mind.
Yeah, I think that's even a better step back into the biggest picture of this is yes,
those are universal concerns for people who have lost a lot of weight due to myriad of underlying
medical conditions. Now, a big problem with all of the things we recommended is the cost
of doing a comprehensive, what do we say, facelift, fat pad transfer, filler on a regular
basis. This is insane. The cost of this is like prohibitive. No one, no one is going to be able
to keep up with this consistently. And so, you know, aging pretty much like everything in life
is a losing battle and aging like hair loss, you know, it's a losing battle, but we're going to go
down swinging. And this is I don't know, you could actually transition slowly. You could actually if
you were going to jump into the space of, okay, I'm going to address this with all of the things
that Dr. Sean, Dr. Maxfield mentioned, you could do a little bit here and there, do it all at once,
and then do less and less progressively over the course of a couple of years. And it would make
the aging process seem more gradual. That's another option so that you're not spent spending
thousands and thousands and thousands of dollars for the rest of your life.
That would soften the blow perhaps. And I would also argue after that initial weight loss that
even with time alone, the skin would tighten up, right? You know, because your body would adapt to
having less, less, you know, like being less full. And so, you know, when you, when your skin
remodels and your collagen is being produced, you know, especially if you're younger and your skin
is more adaptive to changes, it would probably tighten up with time even with minimal intervention,
right? So then even without any intervention, it would probably, time would correct like half of it
in my mind. And then, you know, the other half, you know, you could use treatments to try to
resolve it. So you're more optimistic than me, I think, a lot less than half. I think of a lot of
the people we see post bariatric surgery and the redundant skin, we see that that fairly frequently
and it can be pretty dramatic. The skin may not return to what you'd feel like or what a person
might expect for a normal baseline, but this is certainly going to probably be less dramatic of a,
it is less dramatic than the weight loss associated with the estrog bypass or something like that.
And the skin is less redundant too. Right, right. We don't, I think we're seeing 14% weight loss or
something like that. So it's not like 50% weight loss where you'd expect as dramatic changes,
but still, even so, I think, you know, it shouldn't, it shouldn't, like in my mind,
if you need ozempic for health reasons, this side effect in my mind shouldn't deter you
for you getting to a healthy weight that that doesn't have these other comorbidities,
which could shorten your lifespan. And so, you know, I wouldn't, I wouldn't let it scare me
away because a lot of these videos that I've seen are like, don't take ozempic because of this,
right. And if you need it for other reasons, you know, I think you have to weigh the risk benefit,
right. You, you may have this gaunt appearance, however, you know, you need it for your health.
And so, you know, I just, I think sometimes people, you know, we see this a lot in dermatologic
medications as well. Like don't try these medications because they have X, Y, Z side
effect. It's like, well, no, like you need this. Like we're not, you're not taking this
for fun necessarily. Right. So I think, I think that that also needs to be considered.
Okay. So now let's let's diverge, diverge. Let's, let's move on to the, what if it was
just for fun? What if, what if at some point in your life you decide that the gaunt look is the
look for you and you decide to go into something like a buccal fat pad removal, right? Now,
because this is purely cosmetic, there's not a, so we just giving people an idea, which is buccal,
buccal or buckle. I've heard it both ways. Buccal fat pads are the fat pads within the cheeks.
Underlying the cheeks and they are underneath the sagomatic arch and it gives your face,
I don't know, a nice rotund cherubim like appearance.
So I have pronounced a buccal fat, I would argue. So it's basically the fat in this area
that gives you, yeah, like, like Dr. Maxfield mentioned, a more rounded appearance to your face.
Now, some people would argue that that is a more youthful appearance to the face because it's the
part of the face that, you know, you're, the people, you know, pinch when you're a baby,
right? It's, you know, kind of that baby fat appearance a lot of times is that, that buccal
fat. And the opposite of that would be like, you know, more of that sort of teardrop hourglass
shape of the face, that sort of inverted triangle where, you know, your chin is sort of the peak
of that inverted triangle and your zygoma is the base of that triangle. Essentially, like,
having hollowed out area within this area, some people find that to be desirable. It's the
Zoolander look, essentially. The blue, blue, what is it? Blue magnum? I don't know. You were going
Zoolander. I was going with the bad guy in Emperor's New Groove. I don't remember her name.
Blue steel. Blue steel. Yeah, exactly. So, blue steel appearance of the, of the buccal fat. So,
so that's the look or handsome Squidward or something like this where you get these,
you know, really, really, really strong jaw, really strong upper cheekbones, and then a
hollowing in between. And you see this in a lot of celebrities as well. Like,
who's the one with the lips? Angelina Jolie. That's a good example.
Right. So, Angelina Jolie. And so, so basically people are now, it's become popular and it was
becoming popular maybe three or four years ago as well. And it's ramped up again because a lot
of celebrities, again, are talking about this, is, is actually removing that, that buccal fat
through surgery, removing the fat pad to have that appearance of that shape.
Right. And so, with that, they get the same, you can get a similar, a similar outcome, I guess,
to the previous conversation where you just have a more sallow, I still think that's a word, gaunt
face. Now, the difference here though, I think, again, is you don't have that functional back
side of it. And so, it's like a tattoo, in my opinion. It's like, you better be committed to
this. This better be the look you want because it's only going to get exaggerated the older you
get. And I, I, you know, looking at the pictures, you know, and just speaking purely about aging of
the face and the changes that are associated with the aging face, I, I do think that the,
the buccal fat pad removal, it does, I think it does age people like the way it looks. I think
it really does actually add, I don't know, I'd say like five to 10 years to their pictures,
just like a before and after depending on the lighting. So, it's something you really want to
be able to commit to. Yeah, you know, I, I think it's permanent in many ways, right? So,
to talk a little bit about the procedure, it's done by usually a plastic surgery, plastic surgeon
or an ENT, facial plastic surgeon, and usually done from inside the mouth. So, basically, they
go inside the mouth, they remove this buccal fat pad, which is within a certain compartment.
Usually, they don't remove the entire fat pad. I think they just use, remove half of it or two
thirds of it or three quarters of it. They, they don't remove the entire thing usually,
and then they kind of stitch you back up. And so, getting this procedure done in general,
of course, has risks, right? So, anytime you cut a hole in the skin, there's risk of bleeding,
there's risk of infection, there's risk of scarring. There's other also important structures
in this area, right? You have the parotid duct, which runs from in front of the ear down
to the corner of the mouth, and you could injure that parotid duct. You could also injure nerves
in the face that, you know, give you the facial expression, smiling, sipping a straw, you know,
things like this. And so, there are important anatomical structures in this area, and those
are at risk when you get this procedure done. Like any cosmetic procedure, you have to weigh
the risks and the benefits. Now, if you go to somebody who is knowledgeable, you know,
they're going to definitely take all this into consideration, but these are things that you'll
have to discuss with them as well. Now, whether or not you want this appearance, yes, like it is
an immediate result. Yes, it gives you that, like, quote-unquote, you know, model look or that
Angelina Jolie look immediately after the surgery. So, you know, I think if you want that look,
like any other cosmetic procedure, it's something that, you know, you have to decide whether or not
you want that appearance long-term, right? Because I think that that is the pitfall of any procedure
where you change the way of your appearances. So, I don't think this makes it any different
than any other cosmetic procedure, other than, like, I agree, like, it does, it can make you
look older, like, because I mentioned, like, it's like the baby fat, you're removing that sort of
baby fat appearance, and so it can make you look more, I don't know if I want to say older, but
maybe more mature, is that? It's an, I mean, um, nah. Like, you don't think, because, like,
sort of, they're correlated with, like, age and maturity are sort of correlated with each other,
but they're almost, like, more mature features, I don't, like, does that make any sense?
I don't know. Yes and no. I mean, I think it's so hand-in-hand, it's just, like, is it a duck
or is it a duck? It's kind of like facial hair, it's like facial hair, exactly like facial,
like, facial hair tends to make you look more mature, but doesn't necessarily make you look
older. Doesn't? Okay, okay, I don't know, this is all, like, very subjective, right? So, you all
have your own opinions about this, but I sit into the facial hair thing, I mean, I do agree with
that, I don't know if anybody's noticed, I wear facial hair more often now, and it's not necessarily
because I like the way it looks better, but I do, actually, surgeries fairly frequently,
because I'm also a Mohs surgeon, and I feel like it does instill more of a sense of confidence
within the patients, and I think it's because of what Dr. Shah just said, they either think I'm
older, which I like to think that I'm naturally youthful and glowy, and so I have to offset that
with this beard, this facial hair, so I look old or wise, depending on who you ask.
I don't know, I just, I think it's a marker of maturity, I don't know. So, I mean, well,
whatever, the appearance of the space, whether you like that appearance or not, I think that's
always subjective, right? Like, we're always going to have our personal opinions, do we like
really big duck lips, do you like the appearance of the BBL, do you like the appearance of, like,
all these other things that people are doing, like, that's very subjective, and some people do
want to pursue this look, so I think the risks that I mentioned are inherently there,
and then sort of the long-term, like you mentioned, the long-term consequences, I don't
know necessarily that those are well elucidated, because we don't, I don't know that this is being,
having been done for long enough, or at least not at the capacity that we're seeing it happening
today, that we know, like, what all these people are going to look like 10 years from now,
and the natural changes of the face, right, is that you get, and we've mentioned this several
times even today, is the redistribution of fat in the face happens naturally, right? So, you get
a natural movement of shrinkage of certain fat pads, other fat pads getting larger, and then
everything kind of moving in the direction of gravity as the compartments don't stay as well
intact, and so what you would probably expect is that that buckle fat pad shrinks with time,
which is why you see older people, and you can see more of their, like, I'm talking about very old
people, like 100 plus, start to develop that more, like, skeleton appearance, because they lose a lot
of that buckle fat as well, and so, you're looking at me like I'm going to get in trouble
from the 100 plus, the 100 plus population. If you're 100 and you're watching this,
congrats, that's how I feel. You start out with, like, the very old population,
and then you qualify with an age, you just, I was wondering if Dr. Johnson was like,
the very old population, the 30 over. No, that, you said that once, like,
you said once in a video on retinol, if you're 30 plus and you're not using a retinol, then,
like, you know, like, I was like, whoa, but no, no, no. So, I mean, like, 100 plus, you start to
have a skeletal appearance, and, you know, part of that is due to loss of fat in some of the fat
pads, and so would that then be exaggerated at an older age where you start to have that more
gaunt appearance? I don't know whether or not time has, well, time will tell, essentially,
especially if you're getting this done at a very young age. That being said, we probably will have
methods to reverse it by then once Elon Musk and others figure out how to reverse time. Actually,
I saw, interestingly, about that quickly, because there's a lot of, like, researchers,
very popular podcasting, actually, in the world of, like, longevity. I don't know if you've seen
any of these, like, health-related longevity podcasts where the entire focus is trying to
make you live forever, and they asked Elon Musk at some point, like, why don't you focus on trying
to, like, make people live forever? And he was like, I don't think people should live forever
because new ideas. This is a Max Planck quote, who's, like, a physicist, actually, but
essentially, he said, people's opinions don't change, they just die, and younger generations
grow up with new ideas. And so, his whole thing was, like, people shouldn't live forever because,
like, no new ideas or new thoughts would come about. It's a very interesting reason to put
forward why people shouldn't live forever. Out of everything you could pick, it's just because,
like, the progression of ideas wouldn't move forward. I mean, that's actually very interesting.
Ideas and beliefs, right? Like, in many ways, right? I don't, you know, I don't know.
No, I mean, I don't, you know, he's probably right. It seems like most people kind of get this,
like, fixed sense of identity. I mean, it's obviously, people definitely get a more fixed
sense of identity, but also more rigid belief system the older they get. So, I don't disagree
with that, that idea. But maybe older ways are better ways.
It could be, too. Maybe the next generation will figure that out for us. It's like,
maybe the older way was the better way. Who knows? It's interesting. I think, I don't know.
Yeah, I think it's interesting. I don't listen to many of those podcasts yet. I'm on the podcast
Kick. Maybe you can recommend some to me and I'll listen to it on the way. The one thing with,
I think, aging that's interesting, too, is, okay, so one of the most consistent ways for people to
age less live longer. One of the ones that's been shown to be consistent is, like, calorie
restriction, eating less. And I don't remember, because it's been a long time since I've, it was
like undergrad when I saw this study, or the professor talked about it, but I think it actually
prolongs the telomeres or helps prevent telomere shortening is by calorie restriction and eating,
decreasing your diet, like, more so than exercising, right? I think exercising is much,
I've heard this several times. Yeah, you too. It seems like common knowledge at this point.
So, that's one way to live longer. And that's kind of a do less, get more kind of thing,
as opposed to perhaps inventing something new. If we actually just calorie restricted,
perhaps we'd all just live longer. Well, I think that, you know, that's one of the things that
is consistently touted within this realm is that, and one of the frustrating things, I think, about
diet, nutrition, and its relation to health and longevity is that there are so many, like,
so much more than skin. There are so many more conflicting studies that come out day to day
that say, this is the best diet. No, you should be a carnivore. No, you should be vegan. No,
you should be, you know, only eating, like, you know, the toes of horses or something like that,
right? There's always some, like, in-fat diet based on, like, a small study that everyone
gets, like, really attached to. And probably what you mentioned, intermittent fasting,
this idea of not eating for, you know, like, let's say 16 hours and only eating during a
short period of time during the day, that diet seems to have one of the longest staying powers
of any diet I've seen that have come out. And I think that there's a lot of good evidence to
support the benefits of intermittent fasting from, you know, increased longevity, it being, like,
overall just good for your health in general. And then now there's this new study that comes out
that says it doesn't actually help with weight loss. Yeah. Now, so, okay, I have, just putting
this forward, I've actually been very consistent. This is one of my, my actually habits I've stuck
with. Intermittent, I've been doing intermittent fasting now where I don't eat after, like, 7pm
and I don't eat again till 11am. Out of the last, let's say, year and a half, I've probably done
this for 15 months. And it may be even longer and better than that. And anecdotally, I have not lost
a pound. Like, but the reason I stick with it is it's sustainable. It's like, I, it's, it's,
it's sustainable. And I know that on some level, not eating like a 17-year-old for every meal at
every waking moment of the day has got to be good for me. Like, at some level, this has got to be
working. But some people argue that intermittent, like, that, you know, like, constantly eating or
eating small amounts every couple hours would then speed up your metabolism because your body
would think that it needs to constantly be in a high metabolic state. Yeah. Now, some would also
argue that if you're always providing, like, free glucose and, or, I guess, simple carbohydrates,
and then eventually free glucose to be converted into ADP, or ATP, rather, for your cells, like,
to energy, you would never, your body would never need to use your stores to back convert stored
glucose or adipose into free energy. And so, I mean. So, you'd never lose weight. Yeah. You'd
never be catabolic. You'd always be anabolic. You'd always, you would always be fed and growing.
And there would never be the opportunity for your body to get into a catabolic state where
it's breaking down your stores and converting that into free energy to be used. And that's
one of the reasons I think intermittent fasting makes sense on a very simple level is the whole
A goal. One would probably calorie restriction just by eating less. And then the second goal
would probably be by trying to get your body into a fasting state where you're forcing it to use
some of the stores. Now, one of my questions with it, and I think a lot of stuff there,
I think there are actually a lot of studies that show that it doesn't create meaningful weight loss
long-term. I don't think this is the first one. Actually, I know it's not because when I first
looked into this, I found many studies that said it doesn't work. And it's like, ah, it's all right,
I'll try it anyway. Now, I don't know if you remember in medical school, and I think it's
something like, I think it's something like five days of ketosis, five days of ketosis,
it gets to the point where your, is it your brain can start using a different energy store,
or you start really fully going into ketosis at that point. And so I don't know if intermittent
fasting over what a 16 hour period is actually really long enough to be meaningful in any way
to use your stores. That's my main thought on it. And I'm not sure if that's true or not.
But yeah, I mean, I think that any weight loss study, there are so many conflicting variables.
Did the people in the study actually do that? Or like all diets, do people break the diets? Like,
what did they eat while they were intermittent fasting? Like, what other genetic issues do
they have? Do they have diabetes? Or do they have thyroid disorder? Like, you know, there's so many,
like, I don't know how well controlled these studies are anyway, that I feel strongly about
like, whether or not weight loss. And even if you're not losing weight, is that like,
you're not healthier? Because like, you could maintain the same weight and be much healthier,
because you have improved insulin sensitivity, or you have lower blood glucose levels during
that time period, a lower A1c over those, you know, 90 days, you have lower inflammation,
signs of inflammation in the body, reduced oxidative stress, like, you know, all these
types of things that have been shown to be beneficial in intermittent fasting. Like just
because you didn't lose weight, does that mean that you didn't benefit from those things? But
that's why I don't get too hyped on diet, right? Like, it's just, to me, like, it's one of the most
poorly studied things in all parts of medicine, because it's just so hard to control for the
different variables. Yeah, I agree. And I think it's disappointing for us as professionals. And
I know it's disappointing for people as, I don't know, viewers, or just everyone in the public in
general, because it's one of the most commonly requested topics. Like, hey, why don't you talk
more about diet? Yeah, I have a lot of beliefs about diet. I have, like, some very strong
opinions, some not very strong opinions. But the fact of the matter is, I don't feel confident
backing it up with data. No, that's, I mean, really, I just, like, you know, we've always
said, like, there's this sort of humility in what we do, that every time we record something,
we have to be open to the possibility of currently being wrong about what we believe,
and being wrong about what we believe in the future as more studies go out, right? And
there's a certain comfort level with what we talk about, because a lot of the things that
we talk about in dermatology have been well described, and have years of data backing them,
versus the health, the weight loss and nutrition space tend to come out with,
you can find a conflicting study from, like, almost anything, right? And so the problem is
that you open yourself up as somebody who's a medical professional giving advice on these things
to being wrong more often in the future. And I don't know my comfort level for that, right? Like,
I like that my content is usually evergreen, for the most part. And, you know, if we ever have to
go back and debunk ourselves, we do it from time to time. But I don't, I would hate, like, every,
every week, a new study coming out and saying, like, hey, I'm wrong, actually. So that to me,
like, it's just, it's sort of like, I mean, we can touch on and I think we'll expand on it within
our doctoral universe with time. But you know, if we ever do expand on it, I just hope the public
gives us some grace, because there's going to be many times that we're going to be disproven if we
if we try to venture into that realm. Yeah, I couldn't agree more with that whole set.
But it is intriguing. It is intriguing, I think. And I think one of the reasons that
people want, they want it to work, I think it's because it's something that's pretty easily
controlled, right? Like, we all have to eat, we're all going to spend money on food anyway.
And boy, wouldn't it be nice if there was something we could buy more of, especially more of
here in America? Oh, boy, wouldn't it be nice if I took more of this? And, and I would have some
amazing, meaningful change, impactfully, especially within our health overall. And
it very, very rarely seems to pan out. And I think you're going to kind of assess this by looking
back at things. Because a lot of things will catch fads, they'll catch a lot of attention,
and like all the hype, a study will come out, another study will come out. And then one or
two years, I'll say like one or two years, it's just blowing up. And then it kind of quietly goes
away. And it's gone. And so if something is staying power, I'd say if something is staying
power for five years, plus, that's pretty meaningful, especially in the realm of health,
health, yeah, I'd say health in particular health and diet in particular, if something seems to be
consistent for five years, plus, there's probably something to it. Yeah, I completely agree with
that. I'm not like quick to jump on trends, unless there's like overwhelming evidence that,
you know, that this is way better somehow. But, and this is like, not out of, you know,
the lack of advice in this category is not out of like, not not like our desire to provide you
with valuable information. It's just that there really is not a lot of great information out
there, like even on how diet affects the skin. So it's just like, we don't want to give you bad
advice. Because then that depletes trust, right? I think we saw this, you know, throughout the
past couple years is, you know, a lot of medical, medical professionals making recommendations on
things when the full story had not developed yet. And the risk of that is that you then erode the
trust, right? And so I think part of, you know, part of what we do is try to get all the information
first before, you know, then then talking about it. But and of course, like facing the public with
some degree of humility that, you know, we we are definitely open to being wrong and debunked in the
future. So that's something let's talk about something that's, like, you know, strongly in
our wheelhouse. Because this is all in our wheelhouse, you know, but what's let's talk
about something strongly in our wheelhouse. Let's talk about this article coming out of CNN Health.
And it's titled, a common nail salon tool may cause DNA damage and mutations in human cells,
research finds. And the research is based on this study in Nature, where the title of the article
is DNA damage and somatic mutations in mammalian cells after irradiation with nail polish dryers.
And so the common concern I'm seeing now on social media from a lot of people is, is you
using a UV lamp after getting a gel manicure going to cause skin cancer on the hands? That's
the concern that people have right now. So what are our thoughts on that? So okay, it starts with
a familiar premise. And that is that UV, UV light, UV radiation, which is in the spectrum of the light
provided by the sun, causes DNA damage. And we know this is true. So that's not, that's not up
for controversy here. That's like not up for debate. We know that UV damage damages DNA,
it causes these cyclobutane dimers or pyrimidine dimers that are reflective of damage. And that
overall does lead to an increased risk of skin cancers. And now that the focal premise here
is that the idea of using these devices that cure these gel nails hardens them fairly quickly,
will eventually lead to skin cancer as well. And you know, what's interesting, too, this also is
not a novel topic. This is definitely something I think we've talked about in passing over the
last few years. And this is not the only study. This is just a study. And it's an in vitro study,
meaning it wasn't necessarily done on live humans reproducing what would be reflective
of real life results. It's more of a lab based study here. Yeah. So I think one of the pitfalls
of any news that comes out is you got to go back and look at the original article. And this is
something that's been debated for a long time. If you go back to many studies done in dermatology
on the risk of UV lamps on skin cancer on the hands, they found that there was no,
there was no identifiable increased risk of skin cancer on the hands in previous studies. And the
evidence that, you know, in this group of people that have used UV light to cure their gel manicures
in the past have had increased risk of skin cancer on the hands in the future. Then there
were other studies that said, oh, well, maybe it is tied to melanoma on the hands because,
you know, retrospective studies had shown that looking back to people that had melanoma on the
hands, how often they got, you know, these gel manicures was related to them. And so the studies
have been mixed back and forth in the first place. And then this study comes out and actually looks
at what we call in vitro. So they look at like human cells, but not like wall, they're attached
to the body. And they look at, you know, mouse cells as well. They irradiate them under this UV
lamp for 20 minutes, and then they look for damage to the cells. And what they found was they found,
you know, DNA damage, they found oxidative damage as well. And we know, we have known forever
that UV light over periods of time, and I think specifically UV lamps that cure gel manicures are
in the UVA range. We've known for a long period of time that UVA does cause damage to your skin
cells. And we also know that it can increase your risk of squamous cell skin cancer. So this has
been like well elucidated, like this is not a mystery. And so taking a UV lamp and then irradiating,
I'm not surprised that you're seeing like skin cell death, damage to your skin cells,
and changes in your DNA. Like this is not a surprise to me. Now, what does this look like
in real life? Because we see this all the time. Every single time you walk out of your house and
you're exposed to sunlight, you have these same changes that occur in the skin. And your body
naturally has repair mechanisms that fix these problems so that we never, like we get what we
call sunburn cells when we're exposed to the sun, and we get DNA damage. And our body is programmed
to fix these problems before they turn into anything problematic. So yes, do I think that
there are, it is showing markers of DNA damage that could then lead to skin cancer in the future?
Yes. How that looks in a person's life, I don't think it's been proven at this point. Well,
I know it hasn't been proven at this point that like using these will cause cancer to you in the
future or increases your risk of cancer by any substantial degree. Yeah. So, exactly. So, Dr.
Shar, I was kind of bringing home the point that just because a study showed that it could doesn't
mean it will. And we see this all the time. There's so many different debates about this. Like let's
say we've talked about this vitamin C and niacinamide. If you mix them together, could it
make a deleterious effect? Can it make niacinamide more likely to cause flushing? Or we see it with
benzoyl peroxide. Or can it cause reactive oxidative species or self-tanner? Same thing.
Hydroxyacetone, can it cause oxidative damage? Yeah, in theory it can. A lot of things do a lot
of untoward things that no one wants, but it's not always meaningful. And so that's the question
here. Is this 20 minute exposure representative of perhaps the one minute, one, two minute
exposures of the gel curing that occurs in person? Is it the same thing? We don't really know.
Even if you're erring on the side of caution, even if you're erring on the side of caution,
it seems like it may not be representative of or reflective of what's actually happening in
real life. Plus there's some other caveats here too. I mean, is UV the standard still for curing
gel nails? I know there are other options available now too, like LED is being used,
which LED is different than UV. So like both of them involve the light spectrum,
but LED uses a more focused narrow wavelength. And you can use that in different spectrums of
visible light, which is completely different. It's a completely different energy, just as
different as one laser is from another. UVA and UVB are that different than visible light. They
act completely different on the cellular level. And so if you're using something like that,
then I think your risk virtually falls to nil. Like you probably have no risk of skin cancer
developing if you just cut out the UV portion, which is like an obvious thing to say, I guess,
but it just shows that like in real life, this may not be as big of a problem as you would think.
And then there are of course other alternatives for nails. I mean, if you just want to forego
gel nails altogether, you can get, I mean, traditional nail polish has its own problem
of being allergenic with the acrylates, but then you have nail stickers too. And
I'd asked my wife about that and some people at the office, and they loved, they love nail
stickers. They were hyped about the nail stickers. They look really good from what I hear.
Yeah. So I'm not going to get into the new nail fashions right now. I'm not up to date on them.
So I'm not going to chime in. You know who might be? So James Welsh actually created a new nail
channel on YouTube. I'm not going to have to watch that also because I'm also not up to date
on the new nail fashions, which is why I ask people like, what's your experience with gel nails,
gel nails versus like nail stickers. How do you feel about them? How has it worked for you? And
you know, the response was pretty positive. Right. Well, all right. So kind of jumping
into this gel nail thing. I agree. So I think that by and large, because of fear surrounding
the UV lamps at these nail salons, they've shifted mostly to LED lamps in the first place,
which LED overwhelmingly appears to be safe. And then with UV radiation, I think that you will
undergo some degree of damage during that two to five minutes that you have your hand under the
bulbs. If you're concerned about that risk, then I would recommend looking for a place like when
you call in for your nail appointment. Hey, do you use UV lamps or do you use or do you use LED
lamps? And they know because people probably ask them all the time and then just see what they
have. And if you're concerned about it, I would avoid it. But if you're somebody in the past that
use these UV lamps and now this study comes out and it says, well, you know, it causes markers
that could increase your risk of cancer. Yes, that's true. But you can't like go back and change
the past. I mean, you get UV radiation exposure every day that you walk outside just in the future,
continue to wear sunscreen on your hands. You could wear sunscreen on your hands, even in these UV
lamps as well. And then just exposure nails to this, this curing UV, or you could even use gloves
where you cover everything except for the tips of your fingertips. If you really, really, really
wanted to and had to use these UV lamps, but otherwise I would just call before and ask them.
And that would be my recommendation to my own family. I just, you know, why expose yourself
if you don't have to. Right. It sounds like we have better alternatives now. So just pick the
safer and probably equally efficacious option in the LED curing devices. Also, I guess one,
one notable thing that would be reminded for people, if you're someone, whether or not you've
used a UV lamp altogether, if you have a new dark pigmented band or a new growth underneath your
nail, I mean, go see a dermatologist, right. They'll help you kind of identify that, but that's
irrelevant. That's not necessarily exclusively in the UV gel nail cured population. That's a
universal recommendation. Correct. Right. Any suspicious lesion, definitely see your dermatologist.
All right. So I think that cover is like pretty four, pretty heavy topics
right now on, on social media and beyond. Let us know if there's a comment section here,
wherever you're listening let us know what you'd like us to talk about next. Make sure that you
subscribe on anywhere that you get your podcasts, whether it be Spotify, Apple, or even subscribe to
us on YouTube. We'll be coming out with content like this every week. So stay tuned and we'll
see you all in the next episode. We'll see you next time. We appreciate you always.