Today we discuss common sunscreen misinformation we see on social media. Shout out to EltaMD, one of our favorite sunscreen brands, for sponsoring this video!
*Affiliate Links Generate Revenue for the Channel*
Disclaimer: The informational content provided by Doctorly in this video is intended for educational purposes only and reflects their individual perspectives. This video is not intended to provide diagnosis, treatment, or medical advice. Please consult with a physician regarding any health-related diagnosis or treatment.
[Music]
what are they doing in this video is it
a recipe for date night no this is
homemade sunscreen making your own
sunscreen at home is it safer is it
better is it an insane thing to do this
month and probably the last few months
have been the craziest months for
sunscreen myths and hacks everyone wants
to just not wear regular sunscreen and
they want to do all kinds of insane
things so in this video we're going to
be talking about some of the craziest
things we've seen online including this
video homemade sunscreens homemade
sunscreen and sunscreen hacks here we go
here we
go first off we'd like to thank ala MD
for sponsoring this video first of all
this is a bobble head that ala MD made
of me which looks nothing like me and in
fact they made almost the exact same
bobblehead for Chris tasian which looks
identical to this one does yours look
exactly the same it does actually my son
sees mine and he says oh it's Dr sh
okay well I love it I still love it this
is 15th anniversary 15 years of Alta MD
UV clear and we've been talking about it
as long as we've had a channel which has
been four years and you've seen it
appear at least a dozen times so shout
out to lmd for sponsoring this video we
love this product because one it's
blendable two it has 5% niacinamide
which also has those skincare benefits
and three because it works yeah this is
easily easily not only only the first
but one of the most recommended
sunscreens on the channel but also in
person in the clinic one of the
dermatologists First Choice when
recommending a sunscreen probably across
the board so like obviously not
everybody but generaliza we recommend
this all the time and now they actually
have three different shade ranges so
they have the regular one which is
untinted then they have a kind of like a
medium tinted one this is the one that I
use and then they also have a deep
tinted one for darker skin tones and so
now they have an additional shade which
is amazing gives you more availability
gives you flexibility gives you more
blendability so first up homemade
sunscreens in the video that we were
watching earlier they put a specific set
of ingredients in it so let's go through
what was in that video they did coconut
beeswax shea butter cocoa butter hoba
oil and zinc oxide powder so let's go
through these one by one to be honest
until he puts the zinc oxide powder in
there it sounds like an amazing
moisturizer like the combination of
beeswax shea butter coconut butter hoba
oil I'm just imagining this is like a
great film for your skin a lot of
hydration and then he adds unfortunate
unquantified amount of zinc oxide which
is the only significant filter in this
recipe and that only one that I would
really think would carry some weight but
how much like it looked like a small
amount to me relative to the overall
portion of the recipe some of these like
if you look at coconut oil if you look
at hoba oil maybe they have some SPF
level some people will say coconut oil
has an SPF of seven right now our goal
is to get it to a consistent SPF level
of 30 and when you add the zinc oxide in
there it does need to be at a higher
concentration to achieve that
recommended spf30 level so it looks like
they sprinkled it in there a little bit
the truth is you just won't know what
the protection level is now sunscreens
in the United States are heavily
regulated by the FDA first you can only
use certain filters that qualify and
zinc is one of them they go through
specific SPF testing to make sure that
they actually block the amount of UVB
rays they are intended to block now why
is this important is because UV rays are
known to cause skin cancer we wear
sunscreen not because you know it's a
vanity thing you know it definitely does
help prevent wrinkles it definitely does
help to prevent hyperpigmentation but a
lot of people are wearing sunscreen to
prevent sunburn and skin cancer when you
use something that's homemade when you
don't know what the concentration is of
the zinc in the formula or how well it's
going to block you against UVB rays
you're just not going to get the
adequate protection though it did look
like a well-made product I will say that
and so I would actually say this too the
KN is entirely against the effort
because I think a big part of what we
want to do is Empower people to take
care of your skin at home do as much as
you can at home the question of
sunscreen is like is this something that
should be done at home and the answer is
probably not and here's the other
logical side of it if every year we are
having sunscreen scandals about the SPF
rating not being met whether it's an
American or non-american sunscreen it's
a worldwide problem where companies who
already are using independent labs to
test the SPF value the sun protection
factor and it's not living up to that on
occasion
it seems highly unlikely that we as
individuals just normal people would be
able to create a consistent product with
consistent benefits and consistent
protection for something as important as
sunscreen because like Dr Shaw said the
majority of your skin aging isn't
actually from time it's from sun damage
and the vast majority of skin cancers
are related directly to sun exposure all
right so now let's go on to the next
thing that we've seen online and this is
coming from an Instagram post or a tweet
and here's what the text says I'll read
it out loud if you're concerned about
sunscreen safety a mineral-based zinc or
titanium dioxide up to 25% concentration
version is generally agreed upon as safe
people debate chemical based sunscreen
safety no one debates a physical barrier
and this is from a very well trusted and
respected scientific creator online
let's say when we look at the different
types of sunscreens that are available
out there really is kind of three
buckets and we've talked about this
before but there is the mineral based
sunscreens and these are zinc and
titanium they're also called inorganic
sunscreens and then you have the
chemical based sunscreens which are
called organic sunscreens and these
include things like avobenzone Octan
oxide oxybenzone and on and on and on
and then you have the hybrid sunscreens
which is usually a combination of a zinc
based sunscreen or titanium based
sunscreen and a chemical based sunscreen
they put them together and they kind of
amplify the effects and so you're able
to get the physical sunscreen without as
much of a white cast generally is what
these hybrid sunscreens are able to
accomplish and usually you're able to
get better UV a protection in the
process this is generally what you see
available on the market in this though
there is like an always and never
statement and that is like no one
debates the safety of a physical filter
right and I think that's in and of
itself perhaps not quite true but I
understand the sentiment we actually
experience this a lot in the office we
experience this in real life some people
come in with a predetermined and
preconceived idea that is unmovable that
they will use nothing except mineral
filters and with that you kind of have
to live there acknowledge it and
recommend something but I would say when
it comes to Effectiveness both are
effective and when it comes to safety
there's a lot of data behind both
showing that both mineral and chemical
sunscreens are actually quite safe when
used as intended there is a debate about
chemical sunscreen safety so I agree
with this tweet or this Instagram post
about it being debated like Dr Maxfield
said a lot of people still debate the
safety of mineral sunscreens as well so
it's not universally accepted as safe
but chemical sunscreens are definitely
debated more and a lot of people come
into our office and they say I'm not
going to use a chemical sunscreen what
do you do at that point I usually
generally say like I personally use
chemical sunscreens I recommend chemical
sunscreens to my family members but if
you don't want to use chemical
sunscreens here are some other options
that are pure mineral sunscreens right
I'm not going to try to convince anybody
to do anything differently I'll tell
them what I personally do and hopefully
they trust my own recommendations but if
not then I I I'll recommend mineral
sunscreens and I think that that is
completely reasonable that being said
the FDA does consider zinc and titanium
sunscreens to be generally regarded as
safe and effective so I don't actually
think there's anything quite problematic
about the messaging here the only thing
is it signals that chemical sunscreens
are less safe or could be less safe or
could create concern for chemical
sunscreens because there's not too much
Nuance in this post because there is
some studies that show that chemical
sunscreens absorbed more into the body
than we' previous ly thought but just
because they absorb more into the body
than we previously thought doesn't mean
it has any untorn effect on the body
just because something is increased
absorption under these conditions that
no one really uses sunscreen which is
like dousing your body and high levels
of sunscreen multiple times a day and
more concentration than you would ever
wear sunscreen doesn't mean that it
actually is going to cause any harm on
the body it's just that it's absorbed
more than we thought that's where a lot
of the fear comes from but there's no
indication that chemical sunscreens or
physical sunscreens really cause any
harm in anyone like Dr Shaw said the
mineral and chemical Sun screens both
have a benefit the effectiveness again
isn't What's Up For Debate this is
Quantified objective something you can
rely on chemical and mineral both
effective and they have complimenting
benefits so this is where the
formulation comes into play some filters
are particularly good against UVA some
are particularly good against UVB he
mentioned that you can actually boost
the effectiveness of another ingredient
by adding another filter and that's why
these hybrid sunscreens have a role you
can take a formulation create a
completely or very effective sunscreen
and then couple it and improve the
Aesthetics of it B by having a nice
filter combination and so hybrids
sometimes you kind of get the best of
both worlds when I look at chemical
sunscreens I think blendability these
are generally going to be invisible with
no white cast if they're made well and
then zinc based sunscreens or Titanium
or physical sunscreens generally have a
white cast or a slight white cast and
that's why tinted sunscreens are super
effective to kind of blend in with
multiple different types of skin tones
chemical sunscreens tend to be more
likely to cause allergy where mineral
sunscreens are less likely to cause
allergy so they both have their pros and
cons and we always say to people you got
to find a sunscreen you love and you got
to wear it every single day because the
sunscreen that he loves and the
sunscreen that I love are going to be
very different than the sunscreens that
you potentially love so it's a lot of
trial and error to find a sunscreen that
you love just look for a sunscreen that
has a minimum of SPF of 30 and I will be
very very happy with you right that's
the least we would hope that you would
do to protect your skin and have good
healthy skin now because it is lmd UV
clear's 15th 50th 15th 15th anniversary
this is a hybrid sunscreen so this has
both Octan oate and zinc oxide which is
why it's so blendable compared to most
sunscreens now the first one I ever used
was actually the UV clear untinted but
then once I realized there was a tinted
version the medium tint became the
version that I really fell in love with
this one also has an nicomide like I
said so it helps to regulate oil
production but it also makes it really
good for people with blemish prone Skin
So anyone who has acne prone skin this
is a really good option for you as well
right an ninite is a great supporting
ingredient ingredient for any sunscreen
it just complement so many other skin
conditions whether it's anything from
blemishes to the signs of skin aging
it's extremely helpful across the board
now I really wanted to show you the
three different shades that are
available now this deep tint is going to
be really nice for people with darker
skin tones but this is how they all
three line up you got to find the one
that's going to blend best for your skin
and the one that you like the most so I
personally like both the non-tinted and
then the medium tone one matches with my
skin particularly well it feels
extremely gentle on the skin it's
hydrating it kind of doubles as that
like hydrating moisturizer sun
protection if you want to simplify your
routine both of these sit well for me
both great options and you can see how
well it Blends into both of our skins we
have different skin tones and you can
see that even though this one is the
middle one for both of us it Blends
really really well the next one that's
particularly pervasive is the idea that
you need to get sun exposure
particularly if you don't get enough sun
exposure you'll actually have vitamin D
deficiency so is there any validity to
that claim so there are two messages
within the one message the first is that
you need sunlight exposure for vitamin D
synthesis this is in fact true so the
way it works is the sun UVB converts
provitamin D to previtamin D and then in
its temperature dependent manner it's
ISO isomerized then activated by the
liver and the kidneys to become active
functional vitamin D so at the beginning
of the whole pathway UVB does have a
role the second part of that messaging
was that if you apply sunscreen implied
is that you will not be able to
synthesize vitamin D because you're
blocking the Sun and interestingly it
just doesn't seem to be true it does
speak to perhaps the imperfection or the
incomplete application or the small
amount of UV that does get through
sunscreen so albeit imperfect it
actually satisfies a need because that
little bit that gets through is enough
for us to create vitamin D that's
sufficient for our body so if you're
using sunscreen adequately you'll still
get enough vitamin D production by the
skin that you wouldn't be vitamin D
deficient despite that most people
especially in northern hemisphere are
vitamin D deficient and it could be
related to just sunlight exposure in
general it could be due to the UV index
in general and many people are still
going to need to supplement vitamin D by
taking them through either their diets
or through a supplement the sun
interacts with cholesterol in your skin
to produce Vitamin D it is a complicated
pathway but in the end you do need
sunlight to produce vitamin D and about
80% of the vitamin D that we get is
actually from the Sun and from our skin
synthesizing vitamin D and actually not
from our diets you need to get vitamin D
vitamin D is a very important vitamin
but wearing sunscreen doesn't seem to
affect the vitamin D synthesis as long
as you're getting sunlight at all and
there's actually been a plethora of
studies on this many many studies and a
lot of it started in the Australia
literature Australia has the highest
rates of melanoma and so they were the
biggest proponents from a national
objective of pushing sunscreen out there
to the public and so sunscreen use in
Mass at higher SPF levels was seen first
in Australia and then spread to the rest
of the world and so a lot of the data
comes out of Australia and it doesn't
seem to affect vitamin D levels now I
want to read you a few excerpts from
multiple different studies that I read
so first conclusion there is little
evidence that sunscreen decreases
vitamin D concentration when used in
real life settings suggesting that
concerns about vitamin D should not
negate skin cancer prevention advice
however there have been no trials on
high SPF sunscreens that are widely
recommended and so more data needs to be
shown so like Dr Maxfield said second
thing is although 50 plus sunscreen
decreases significant cutaneous vitamin
D production so there was another study
that showed that it did increase
cutaneous vitamin D production when you
were using an SPF 50 or greater but what
they said was that it did not affect
circulating levels of vitamin D now they
don't know why that seemed to happen
even though it was somehow decreasing
vitamin D concentration locally it
seemed that your body was still able to
produce enough vitamin D not to affect
the levels in your body the next thing
was vitamin D can easily be produced
through ultraviolet light exposure only
a small amount of Exposed Skin is needed
to produce vitamin D so now if you're
not using sunscreen in your hair and
you're not using sunscreen on your chest
while you're wearing clothes you're
still going to get sunlight exposure
that may be enough to produce vitamin D
so ultimately there's enough studies and
suggestions to show that even though
despite most of America is actually
vitamin D deficient about 40% of people
are vitamin D deficient it doesn't seem
to be do to sunscreen use and I think
it's interesting but the whole
constellation of all that effect really
just equates to real life use so real
life we have different habits we have
different imperfections we have
different routines and it seems like all
of that collectively is enough to
produce enough vitamin D regardless of
sunscreen I do actually think the sun is
a good thing personally I think it
affects my mood if I don't get enough
sun exposure in general but I still
protect my skin when I'm in the sun
because one I had skin cancer and two
because I don't want to get wrinkles
much sooner than everybody else and so
ultimately there's two really good
reasons that I wear sunscreen you got to
figure out the reasons that you want to
wear sunscreen but it doesn't seem that
there's any negative effects of wearing
sunscreen over time that have been
proven and there's no reason you should
be not using it because of getting
vitamin D synthesis right I agree I
think the health benefits of the sun are
legitimate especially for mental health
I'm a big proponent of being outside
active whether you're running surfing
fishing whatever you can be in the sun
avoidance Camp that's fine I'm more in
the sun protection Camp live life have
fun have an adventure kind of like my
phrase for life but either way
protecting your skin is like definitely
the best way forward now the last
sunscreen hack I've been seeing online
and this one is a little peculiar but I
want to talk about it so this is the
idea of using a makeup brush to apply
your sunscreen so what people are saying
online is that when you wear a sunscreen
especially a mineral based sunscreen it
may not blend that well with your skin
but if you apply it with the makeup
brush they're finding that it Blends in
smoother it's more of even application
and then they can kind of brush it out
so that it Blends better with their neck
and their face what are your thoughts on
this is this something that you should
be doing should not be doing first let
me look up a makeup brush you don't know
what a makeup brush looks like this is
okay yeah so I I've felt these so I
paint not anymore I haven't painted in
like 5 years this brush in particular
the reason I say this is because when
you paint with oils or with acrylic some
of the brushes are like fairly stiff
have wide bristles and so I imagining
applying your sunscreen with those is
actually doing to lead to a very uneven
application this however these are very
soft they're not going to distribute it
in an awkward way I think you're going
to get an even application and I do
believe that it's going to be helpful
with your blend like just like when
you're blending out an edge on a canvas
if you're blending this out it's going
to help it fade and fan into the skin be
less obvious less apparent where you
have and haven't used it so like the
only question is like how much is the
brush going to absorb is it you need to
perhaps over apply to compensate for
that that's a possibility 100% be my
recommendation so exactly that direction
just like if you were to apply makeup
with your hands you're not going to get
the even application it's not going to
blend smoothly it's going to be lumpy
bumpy and so use makeup brush for the
same reason so I actually don't think
it's unreasonable to apply a sunscreen
using a makeup brush that being said
some of that is going to get absorbed
into the makeup brush so I would apply
slightly more not like double the amount
but slightly more just to compensate
from the absorption from the brush but
there's no other reason there's no
reason why this would affect the
advocacy of your sunscreen and there's
no reason why you can't do this so if
this is something that's going to make
you want to wear sunscreen more I
actually think it's a really good hack
especially if you're using like a tinted
sunscreen or something that has a little
bit more coverage no I think what people
are doing with sunscreen as a
replacement for makeup these days is
great it's wild sometimes um I know it's
not this one not a perfect hack but when
you use different sunscreens to like
create different shadowing it's it's
impressive uh perhaps imperfect because
you're blending sunscreens efficacy
possibly dips but uh people are creative
with sunscreens I love it I think it's
great and that kind of gets into the
question of whether or not sunscreen in
your makeup is enough protection and
when you see a a a makeup that says SPF
30 on it or SPF 50 on it it still went
through the same testing that any
sunscreen is going to go through so it
does give you that protection it's just
that you need to use the amount that you
would use of a normal sunscreen so
that's two finger lengths for the entire
face neck and ears now you probably
aren't going to be wearing that much
makeup or coverage and so you probably
won't be using enough to get the
intended SPF label so yes makeup in your
sunscreen does work exactly how it's
intended to work just need to be using
enough so that pretty much wraps up the
craziness that we've been seeing online
some of the hacks we like some of the
hacks we don't like as much and so we're
always here to debunk misinformation let
us know if you see anything else crazy
online now Ela MD is doing 15% off for a
brief a very limited time so definitely
go check out the link in our description
check out the product from UV clear it's
been 15 years so 15% off uh you're
probably many of you if you've been
following us for a long time are
probably already using a sunscreen so
you might need a refill so definitely
check them out now if you have a darker
skin tone you may want to check out this
new deeper tint that they have yeah it's
perfect if you've ever seen a
dermatologist and asked about sunscreen
this has probably been brought up at
some point so now is a good time to
check it out and see why thank you all
so much for tuning in please like
comment subscribe and we will see you in
the next video we'll see you next time