Are natural products inherently safer? And what do natural ingredients mean for your skin?
We also look into the studies behind facial massage, applying deodorant to your whole body, and what skincare trends that we should keep and which to ditch this year.
*Affiliate Links Generate Revenue for the Channel*
Disclaimer: This video is not intended to provide diagnosis, treatment, or medical advice. Content provided in this video is for educational purposes only. Please consult with a physician regarding any health-related diagnosis or treatment.
All right, everyone, welcome to the podcast.
Let's jump right in to the topics
we have a lot to talk about today.
Right, and today we have, I think, some really exciting,
maybe a little bit controversial topics.
They're really gonna hit home for me, I think.
So I'm pretty excited to kind of go in the deep dive
and I wanna hear what Dr. Shaw has to say
about some of these things.
Yes, I think, you know, we have differing opinions
on a lot of these things.
So I think it will be interesting to see
where you land on this, of course, with this pod,
we're completely unhinged, not rehearsed at all.
So I have no idea where he's gonna land on this.
We have a couple topics that we both pulled
that we wanna walk through
and we'll see where we both align on these.
So first up, okay, is a article,
this is coming from JAMA Dermatology, I believe,
about natural skincare products
and the allergens that we find in them.
Do you wanna summarize the article real quick?
Yeah, so there was an actual, what do you call it?
Not a study, but an article just talking about
how this idea of natural being safer
has really come to the forefront,
is really just taking, it's a billion dollar industry
that's just really helped.
People are making decisions off of it,
I guess I should say that.
They see the word natural, they see the word clean,
and they're trusting those brands more.
But then the article was basically taking a little bit
from the study saying that, you know what,
even though they say natural and clean,
it doesn't mean that they're safer,
especially when it comes to contact allergens.
And then the article,
then the study itself actually talked about,
well, we took a look at different stores,
I think it was Walgreens, Whole Foods, and Target,
and they just took a look at
all of their skincare products.
This was done out of Stanford.
And then they took a look at the ingredients,
and then they just determined
what were the most common problematic ingredients.
Mostly they were all natural,
and they were mostly allergens.
Right, so basically this is the article
coming out of JAMA Dermatology,
published September 14th, 2022,
prevalence of contact allergens
in natural skincare products from U.S. commercial retailers.
So, you know, so this is one of the things.
And I think that a lot of dermatologists
have spoken about this on social media,
but it doesn't somehow penetrate into your average consumer.
And it's basically this idea
that things that are natural are somehow safer
because they exist on this planet
in some type of natural capacity.
And, you know, I think even all of us
sort of feel that way when we see foods, right?
Like if you go to a place and it's like,
oh, this is a natural food store,
we sort of assume that that means
somehow it's healthier than McDonald's, right?
Like we make this assumption
that the natural food store is somehow healthier, right?
And because it gives us a sense of like,
oh, this must be good for you because it's natural.
And the truth is actually,
even when it comes to health foods, we have no idea.
We have no clue whether or not
those foods are actually gonna be healthier for us
or that they're not, you know,
cooked in something that's terrible for you, right?
Now, a lot of times with food,
it's a little bit more transparent,
but when it comes to skincare ingredients specifically,
I think that most people feel,
how do you feel when you see the word natural?
Does it give you a sense of safety?
I think it probably does very subconsciously.
And then actually I was gonna ask you something similar
in that, you know, what does it move you
when you hear a brand come at you with a natural product?
Because I think when people ask me about that,
what I think about natural skincare,
I actually kind of, I'm neutral.
Like, I don't let it move,
I try not to let it move the needle positively
or negatively because a natural ingredient,
in my mind, is still an ingredient,
has a similar potential, good or bad,
as any other ingredient.
Yeah, you know, for me,
it doesn't move me in any general direction at all.
You know, I don't feel positively towards it.
I don't feel negatively towards it.
But the truth is that natural
is actually completely undefined, right?
So we have some terms in cosmetics that are regulated,
and then we have other terms
that are not regulated in any capacity.
And when you say something is natural,
I mean, I could literally take, you know, pure petrolatum,
you know, your Vaseline, which is, you know,
comes from refined petroleum or, you know, fuel,
and call it natural.
And really, like, nobody is gonna stop me, right?
Because there's no, like, legal definition
of the word natural.
So I think that that's the first part of it, right?
Is, like, a company can use it in branding,
regardless of whether or not it's true.
So that's problem number one.
And then problem number two is that
just because it's natural doesn't mean that it's safer.
And that's what this study was showing
from JAMA Dermatology.
They looked at the ingredients
in all of these different products
that were claimed to be natural,
and they found that they were actually high in allergens.
All the products contained allergens,
and oftentimes more allergens
than in other skincare products
that didn't claim to be natural.
So basically what they're saying here is,
you're, like, even though it's saying natural,
you're still likely to cause,
it could cause allergic reactions.
In fact, it may be more likely to cause allergic reactions.
Right, and so I guess a couple things with that, too.
So even though natural is this undefined term,
I think there's this,
I think there's almost this accepted
gentleman's agreement, per se,
that natural means plant-based.
I think if you were to poll the mass population
and be like, oh, what's a natural product,
without naming it,
I think they would list out plant-based ingredients,
and that's where it would end.
So I agree, the term is completely unregulated.
Even if it was regulated,
I don't know if it would change anything,
because I think there's this unspoken rule
that it's a plant-based product.
Yeah, I think that that's the fair assumption, right?
But then you look at some of the ingredients
in these products that are claiming to be natural,
and they contain purely synthetic chemicals
in them as well, right?
And maybe one of the lead ingredients
is like a botanical of some sort
that comes from a flower.
But overall, they still are using preservatives,
and they're using other emulsifiers
in the product that are just
completely synthetic ingredients.
So even then, when they say natural,
I don't even think that,
yeah, I think they may be marketing
one ingredient that's natural,
but I think overall it's not either 100% natural,
or even if it was 100% natural,
again, that doesn't mean that it's safer by any means.
Like for example, I think this gives rise
to that essential oil market as well, right?
Because essential oils are derived
a lot of times from plants,
and they produce a fragrance to them.
And some of them have some medicinal properties
where they do heal different conditions.
And they've all been studied in different capacities,
from lavender to tea tree oil
to all these different things.
You are a big fan of tea tree oil,
but still we find that a lot of these ingredients
do have benefits,
but they also do have a lot of allergic potential.
Yeah, exactly.
And I think that's what the whole point of this article is,
and I think that's one thing
that the general public is missing.
And you've already emphasized already,
but they just see natural, they think it's safer.
But for me, tea tree oil is I think a perfect example
because it is a plant-based ingredient.
It is also an essential oil.
It is also a potent allergen and an irritant.
However, it's been studied and has a deliberate purpose,
so I find it acceptable for use
because it has its niche roles.
But so for me, I treat it completely differently
than I think the general population does or how I grew up.
You know, I grew up in tea tree oil
along with some other things like colloidal silver
or grapefruit seed extract.
We took that by mouth to kill worms,
just a little tidbit there.
But these things were touted almost like cure-alls,
and I still see that as a prevailing thought
amongst the general population.
Oh, yeah, it's natural, it does everything for you,
it's anti-inflammatory, which is another whole broad term
that means very, very, very little, medically speaking.
But they can have a deliberate role
in some of those essential oils,
like you mentioned, really do.
Yeah, and you know, I'm actually,
you know, I've always said this.
You know, I think that especially things
that have been passed down from generation to generation,
you know, things that like kind of pop up,
like yesterday, you know, I'm more skeptical about,
but things that have been passed down
from generation to generation,
like you almost have to give the benefit of the doubt
and say, you know what, like,
if this has lasted 200, 300, 400 years,
there may be something about this that is unquantifiable.
And you know what, I'm gonna go one step further, okay,
and get into a little bit of conspiracy theory here.
So I believe, right, so I traveled to Egypt this year,
I mean, I saw the pyramids, and you know,
I think the pyramids, you know, are just,
I mean, once you see them in real life,
the scale of this building, these buildings,
these three pyramids, the main ones,
is just so astronomical,
and it's like nothing you've ever seen before,
and then to believe that these were built, you know,
that long ago, how did they have
that engineering capability, right,
to be able to build these?
Like, it's a mystery, right, like nobody knows,
I mean, there's theories,
but really nobody knows how the pyramids were built.
This is a fact, okay, nobody knows who built them,
nobody knows how they were built.
I mean, everything is a theory, right,
because there's no evidence,
there was no writing on the walls of the Great Pyramids.
Okay, so that being said,
there was some type of wisdom at that time,
and, you know, people that have studied this building,
from the red quartz to, you know,
different things in the building
that were impossible to, like, you know,
engineer with what they thought
the technology existed at the time,
they knew something, essentially, that we don't know.
And, you know, I think that there are a lot of things,
a lot of ancient wisdom that, you know,
we put our sort of Western medicinal minds to,
and we say, oh, well, you know,
it hasn't been shown in JAMA dermatology to be effective,
and therefore, I'm gonna throw it all out.
But, you know, I think there's something
about ancient wisdom that, you know,
we have to give a little bit of benefit to.
I mean, as long as there's no, like, harm to it,
like proven harm in recent times to it,
then, you know, I think I'm a little bit,
I'm a little bit likely to lean towards some of that
if it's been around for many, many years.
Okay, so I kind of, I don't wholeheartedly disagree
with you, and I don't wholeheartedly agree with you either.
So part of my skepticism,
and I think we approach the same way in that,
like, you know, I think, in fact, I think most doctors are.
I think doctors are inherently skeptical,
especially of new things,
because we kind of run it through this filter
of not only our, like, bachelor's degree,
our science degrees, our medical degree,
our clinical experience, but then also, yeah,
the whole idea that it has to be scientific,
which means reproducible and, like, validated.
But I'm particularly skeptical, I think,
because of the naturopathic world I grew up in,
where I'm actually finding that there are small studies
to support just about everything,
and it makes everything somewhat justifiable,
and it's very difficult, I think,
for people to kind of sift through,
well, this study said this,
or this small study said this,
this small study said this,
and we talked about this before,
like rosemary oil versus minoxidil for hair loss.
That's, like, a perfect example in my mind.
There's a study showing they're comparable.
And that's why I think, for me,
I may be a little bit more critical
of some of these older things that have almost no data,
and there's nothing kind of showing
that they're reproducible,
so I'd be slower to jump on that bandwagon.
But also, also, Dr. Shainer worked in the same
geographical part of this country for a while,
and I'm curious if you've heard of this
from any patients or individuals in the area.
Do you have any thoughts on speaking out warts
or speaking out the fire,
or has that something you came across
from any of these patients?
Yeah, yeah, I've heard of this.
Basically, people meditating warts away
or having some type of witchcraft to get warts to go away.
No, I think that's totally bogus and unfounded, right?
Like that, to me, even though,
because you know what the problem is
with things like warts and alopecia areata
and other conditions that sort of come and go
or have an unknown,
like a lot of times get better on their own
without treatment, like warts or molluscum contagiosum.
These are conditions that get better on their own,
and so I'm a little bit more skeptical of any treatment
that is touted to benefit in those conditions
because it could have just gone away if you did nothing,
and a lot of times there is no control group
in these studies or in these reported case studies
of things like that happening.
So something like that, I'm like, no, I don't think so.
What do you think?
Yeah, it seems unlikely, right?
I mean, I definitely am not a believer in speaking out warts,
but I've heard secondhand from multiple, multiple people
that it worked for them,
but again, I think that's a slippery slope
and a danger that I don't accept
is that secondhand, firsthand anecdote,
but it's extremely convincing for everybody else.
Yeah, and you know what it is?
You know what I think, right?
As long as there's no harm being done, right?
So for example, if you wanted to do this
and you wanted your wart to go away
and you wanted to, and you believed in this somehow,
first of all, it's not harmful
to keep the wart around most of the time, right?
So I'd say, okay, well, depending on where it is,
but if you have a plantar wart,
it might be a little bit painful.
You wanna wish it away for a year and it doesn't work,
come to see us, we'll treat it.
No harm, no foul.
I think when you start to get wacky
is when there is something that is imminently dangerous,
right, like some type of cancer, right?
Like pancreatic cancer.
And then you're like, you know, I'm gonna actually,
I'm gonna wish it away
or I'm gonna take some type of supplement
that I read about in one study.
I think you can do both, right?
Like you can say,
as long as they're not like interacting negatively,
like I could say, well, you know, I really like turmeric
and you know that I'm a big turmeric guy.
I could say, well, yeah, I can take my turmeric supplement,
but I'm also gonna take the chemotherapy
that has been proven in multiple studies
to be effective, right?
And I think once you start getting into the world
where like there's imminent harm
and then you start to like say,
well, I'm gonna like lean into natural ingredients
that have been unproven,
I think that's when you start to get dangerous.
Okay, yeah, I think that's very fair,
but also very relevant.
And so I've seen this firsthand
in where they've had cancers.
Some of them are a bit skeptical of modern medicine.
So they also see as naturopaths.
And so they've opted out of certain treatments
for very aggressive cancers
and opted in to natural,
really just diet-based changes to try to cure their cancer.
And I know that's just a small sample size,
but I know that people all over the country
and world are doing that.
And I think the danger is foregoing
a potentially effective treatment
for maybe scientifically doing very little to nothing.
But at the same time,
some of those cancers and some cancers,
there really isn't much
that Western medicine has to offer either.
And so again, I think doing both often is reasonable.
And there are actually a lot more studies now coming out
with how does this vitamin dietary supplementation
complement or work with or against this
either chemotherapy, immune therapy,
or modern treatment for skin cancers or cancers in general.
Yeah, just, yeah, I completely agree.
And I think these things can be supplemental
to each other, right?
Like, I definitely,
like you mentioned the minoxidil and rosemary
to give some context right there.
It's a study that compares minoxidil or Rogaine,
which is the only over-the-counter FDA approved
for the treatment of hair loss.
And then there's a study comparing it to rosemary oil
for the treatment of hair loss.
And they were equally as effective.
And maybe the rosemary was less irritating
in this study, right?
And so then you say, well, it's one study.
Like, is that like,
should I then now change my behaviors?
No, like when people come to see me in the office
and they ask me like what to go get,
I'm not like, I got the thing for you.
Forget the minoxidil.
I got you on the rosemary.
In fact, a lot of times I'll say,
you know, the proven treatment here is the 5% minoxidil.
Go out and get that.
And then they may say like,
well, I want something
that's a little bit more natural remedy.
And I'll say, you know, actually,
you know, rosemary is another option,
but I recommend that you do these two things together,
right?
Like if you're going to do it,
do them together because you'll get compounded benefit.
And so, you know, I'm definitely not against them.
And the reason,
the other reason why is because a lot of the things
that have had,
have withstood the test of time,
have come from natural ingredients in the first place,
right?
So, you know, I always talk about salicylic acid,
you know, salicylic acid came from the willow bark tree,
was then they realized like, you know,
people were chewing on willow bark,
their fevers were going away for four hours, right?
So they were like,
oh, if you chew on this willow bark tree,
my fever will go away.
I chew on this bullet shark,
this tree, it goes away, right?
They actually thought it was going to be a cure
for malaria, I think,
but it only worked for like four hours at a time.
They didn't understand why, right?
Well, essentially they were ingesting aspirin.
And then later on, I think like Bayer,
one of the pharmaceutical companies,
like were able to isolate acetylsalicylic acid
or aspirin from these willow bark trees
and then commercialize it.
And all of a sudden now you have this medicine, right?
And Western medicine is really pushing this.
Now, if somebody came along
and started chewing on willow bark tree again,
we'd be like, oh, this guy's insane, right?
So I think that at some point we have to say like,
there are things we don't know.
Like there are so many things we don't know,
especially about medicine.
And the more I learn about medicine,
the more I realize that we don't know a lot
and there's a lot more to learn.
And it's so humbling to study the human body.
It's just like, it's such a fascinating,
we're fascinating creatures from the ground up,
the way that our minds work,
the way that our bodies work.
And I really just think that we need to give
a little bit more interest in these natural things.
So I'm actually 100% with you in part of that,
the humility thing.
I think the longer, and we've talked about this before,
but the longer I've trained, the longer we train,
I think the more humble you become.
Because I think the most proud I ever was
was probably after my second year of medical school,
which is, for those of you who don't know,
that's at the end of your academic,
purely academic portion.
Because I had just ingested thousands and thousands
and thousands of pages of medical information on paper.
And then you get out into the real world
and during your clinical studies,
your residency and fellowship,
everything else or whatever,
you're like, oh wow,
this is all fairly imprecise and imperfect.
And so I think there is a ton of room
for learning in any medical community.
And I think that, I think probiotics
are actually a perfect example of how Western medicine,
modern medicine has kind of adopted something
that started out in the more naturopathic space.
Because I grew up on probiotics
and that was like 30 years ago, I think.
Probiotics, soy milk, rice milk, almond milk,
it's been in buckwheat.
It's been interesting to watch what's stuck around
and gone en masse as to what I grew up with.
And where probiotics, it's again, same thing.
It's like, oh, this could be helpful.
In fact, oftentimes, this is helpful for everything.
And now we're coming back to a place
and especially for us as physicians
and in Western medicine, it's like,
well, this is probiotics.
This is how it can be helpful,
topically in the setting of eczema
to out-compete some of the bad bacteria on your skin,
maybe internally to try to change the pH
and provide a little bit of diversity,
which I think is a nuanced thing in itself.
Like if you're consuming a million live cultures
of one bacteria,
is that really promoting bacterial diversity?
I don't know.
It could definitely out-compete some pathogenic bacteria,
especially on the skin.
Yeah, so like you said,
I think that there's still so much for us to learn
and I'm open to learning, right?
But most of the time when people tout natural remedies,
in exchange of things that are proven, right?
Someone's got really bad,
I think I see this mostly in the acne space with us
where you have somebody who has scarring forms of acne
and I'm like, and it hurts my soul
to watch these people suffer and come in.
And then you have even some of these people
making videos online and then you see the comments
and someone's like,
oh, we'll do this sort of natural remedy.
And I'm like, yeah, like that's great and everything,
but this person's gonna have permanent scarring.
Like I know the natural course of this condition
and if we don't treat it aggressively
with therapies that have been proven in the office,
then this person is gonna have severe scarring.
So like it's not harmless at that point
to make those recommendations.
So I think that it just sort of needs to be looked at
on a case-by-case basis.
But going back to this article that we found here is,
one, the article showing that natural ingredients
are not safer, right?
I mean, this is scientific proof that natural products,
products that are labeled natural.
So to just summarize this in full for everyone,
as clear as possible,
products that are labeled as natural in your stores,
when you see them and you hold them,
just be aware that there is scientific evidence
that these products are no safer
than products that are, quote unquote, not natural, okay?
So that's number one.
And the number two part of this
is that they actually did like a sub-study,
like a study before this, 2017 study,
also in JAMA Dermatology,
looking at moisturizers, common moisturizers,
and found also, again,
one, that there was a lot of allergens
in common moisturizers.
So that's number one.
And even products that had claimed to be hypoallergenic.
So that's another thing.
So even when you're out of the natural category
and you look at something that's labeled as hypoallergenic,
again, hypoallergenic is not something
that is regulated in the sense that we say,
okay, if it says hypoallergenic,
that doesn't mean that it doesn't even have fragrance,
right?
Fragrance is the most common allergen in skincare products,
right?
Still maintains today,
the most common allergen in skincare products is fragrance.
And you'll still have products
that are labeled hypoallergenic that have fragrance in them.
And that's because they did a study
on let's say a hundred people
and they tested that product on their skin
and they found that those,
that a hundred people didn't have allergic reactions.
And so they're able to then say,
this is a hypoallergenic product.
That doesn't mean that if you have an allergy to fragrance
that you're not gonna react to this product, right?
So like, I think that there's a lot of messaging
in skincare labeling, not just on the natural side,
but even on the dermatologist recommended side,
even on the hypoallergenic side,
it is a lot of times misleading to consumers
who are just trying to make safe
and effective purchases for their skin.
And so it really puts the consumer at the disadvantage here.
So with that then,
like taking a look from the consumer's perspective,
like we already said, you know, fragrance is problematic.
It's in both from this recent study,
it's in both these clean natural products
and it's also in,
it's also the most common allergen in all products.
But like how, what are some things
I think a consumer could look for
that would help them navigate through this nonsense?
Yeah, I don't know.
I don't know.
Like, I don't know what they're like, you know,
I actually thought, you know, going into this,
you know, when I was studying that like,
if I saw something like dermatologist recommended
or dermatologist tested or hypoallergenic,
that these would somehow mean
that these products were safer and they're not.
Like it really needs to be case by case ingredient basis.
I think there's a website called SkinSafe
or something like that,
where you can like type in a product
and it tells you if it has common allergens in it.
It's a little bit better,
but again, like we don't wanna like fear monger people
out of using products altogether, right?
Cause even in the study that we're looking at,
the highlighted study today that we're talking about,
they looked at the 100 most common allergens,
the 100 most common allergens.
That's a lot of ingredients to look at, right?
So like, just because like, you know,
once you get down to number 100,
that's a very low percentage of the population
that's gonna be reacting to that, right?
And you still need to use the products, right?
To see a benefit to them.
So, you know, ultimately I would say,
try to avoid the top five most common allergens,
maybe the top 10 most common allergens.
And also if you are personally allergic to something,
then obviously you wanna look at the back
of every ingredient list and make sure that,
you know, you're not allergic to it.
Or you could watch our videos on YouTube.
We talk about products all the time.
Okay, okay, here we go.
This is it.
This is how you go through it.
I'm gonna just come up with this right now.
It's very simple.
One, you wanna look for a short ingredient list.
I think that's actually very helpful
and might be understated.
Not because all of the ingredients don't have a purpose,
but because the longer the list,
the more likely you're gonna be allergic to something.
In fact, I was using a lot of products.
Should I call it a brand?
I used a SkinCeuticals, highly reputable brand.
Loved most of their products.
It was a facial mist.
Is that good?
Bad?
Let me Google this.
Isn't it reputable?
I mean, I could be wrong.
Like, no, no, no, like I could be saying,
like I've been, I said disheveled my whole life
and not disheveled.
So I could be wrong.
I thought it was reputable.
Is it reputable?
Can we get a tiebreaker?
Lou, Lou, can you chime in?
It's reputable.
Lou has it as reputable.
All right, okay, we got at least two for 2v1 right now.
Yeah, but you all are reading in the 20th century.
My readings come from the late 19th century.
Old English Oxford, yeah, that's right.
Luke Maxfield, Lord Luke Maxfield over here.
Which, yeah, by the way, I also found out
you can like buy a plot in Scotland
and become officially a lord.
That's a whole nother thing, kind of tempting.
But anyway, short list.
You would do that, you would do that.
I would, I do wanna earn it.
But so anyway, there's this facial spray, right,
from SkinCeuticals, like good brand.
Most people think highly of this brand's quality.
As soon as I read the back of the ingredient list,
it's like, oh, this is gonna be a problem.
I don't have allergies.
I don't know that I'm allergic to anything
except for maybe penicillin.
But I sprayed this on my face.
Three days later, the worst allergic reaction
I've ever had topically in my life.
You had an allergic reaction to something?
Yeah, and I don't have sensitive skin.
I'm not gonna lie, I feel a little bit of redemption here
that you had an allergic, because I told you,
okay, I'm the nutty one when it comes to allergens.
I'll give you that.
Like I'm the one that's always trying to avoid allergens.
I got the sensitive eyelids.
I'm always like freaking out about fragrance.
And he's the one that's all laissez-faire over here.
You know, oh, all is good.
You could put dirt on your face.
It will be fine.
And then he got an allergic reaction.
I'm not happy about it.
I'm a little bit, but I am a little bit
like told you so right now.
Yeah, well, you know, my perspective is anything.
Tell me the five, what were the allergens
that you were, or was it just because the list was long?
No, it was both.
So I think with most of these natural products,
and this isn't one of those, but most natural products,
you'll start with the top 10 ingredients,
and a lot of them will look good.
There's water, glycerin, hyaluronic acid,
and things like that.
Okay, good, this has a purpose.
And then you get to numbers like 10 through,
in this case, probably 25 or 30,
and you're like, oh, huh, I don't know if this is necessary
or if this is helpful.
In fact, it could be bad.
So here, you know, we've like fragrance.
We have linalool.
We have, let's see here, a lot of colorants,
which I don't know if there's really allergic potential,
but they're unnecessary.
And then a lot of, lot of, lot of plant-based ingredients.
Again, just the more plants you use,
the more likely you're gonna have an allergy
to some of them, or irritation, in this case, allergy.
Yeah, you know, I agree.
So, you know, I actually think
this is a controversial opinion, actually,
that shorter ingredient lists are better.
I would say that, for the most part,
unless the whole list is like, you know,
water plus fragrance, right?
Like that's a short ingredient list,
but it's not a great ingredient list,
which there are like fragrant waters
that people spray on their face, to be fair.
But that being said, I generally agree
that shorter ingredient lists,
barring any major allergens,
are better and safer than longer ingredient lists.
And that's just my personal experience, even.
Like, I can look at a really long ingredient list,
and it's got no common allergens that I know to avoid.
And those products I have reacted to
much more than the shorter ingredient product list.
So I'm sort of on board from that,
from a like anecdotal experience.
But I'd be actually curious to see
if there's any studies on the length of ingredient lists
versus allergic potential,
because that would be really interesting.
Yeah, it would be.
Someone needs to put that together.
And we'll appreciate it if you do.
So, okay, length of ingredient list was one.
We'll say, okay, maybe we're on the fence with that.
The second thing, fragrance-free.
I am 100% with Dr. Shah on this.
Fragrance-free is the most important thing you could do
if you have sensitive skin, eczema,
or just wanting to be cautious.
I have no arguments there.
Do I use fragrant products?
Yes, because I haven't had a problem with that.
I know about my skin.
Although fragrance mix is unquantified, qualified,
you don't know what's in it exactly.
I've not had a problem with that before.
So I think that's number two.
Yeah, so going into fragrance-free,
you know, most of the time I agree.
You know, you say fragrance-free,
that is generally gonna be a safer product
than not fragrance-free or unscented or scented products.
That being said, there are some products
that do claim fragrance-free and are not fragrance-free.
You know, they have like some type
of aromatic compounds in them
that are like doubling as stabilizers or preservatives,
and they do produce a fragrance,
and then people do react to them.
So it's not completely foolproof,
but I would say of all the claims you'll see
on the front of a package,
I would say that fragrance-free
is probably the most reliable.
Okay, yeah, so fragrance-free being superior to unscented,
I'd say being superior to dermatologist-approved,
dermatology-approved, whatever those variations would be.
And then maybe number three,
what you could look for is
the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance,
which again, isn't perfect,
but it does go before a board,
and they do vet some of these,
well, they do vet these products and the ingredients,
and they screen out some of the more problematic things.
Now, I've talked about brands and products
that are on this list.
Some of them contains allergens.
They're not all perfect.
They're all not completely as gentle
as you could possibly want.
But again, if you're looking for three things,
that might be the place to start.
Yeah, again, I think I agree with you on that.
Most of the time, good products.
Most of the time,
the people that seek out that seal of approval
tend to be trying to get that approval
of hypoallergenic in general.
And so those products tend to have more
of that dermatology background in the first place.
And so you can almost assume that they're gonna be safer.
But again, I've also seen common allergens
in those products as well.
So I think that, again,
there's no foolproof method for you to hang your hat on.
But overall, I would say that
the recommendations I make,
I try to limit the allergic potential as much as possible.
Barring that I don't think there's a better product
in that price range,
and there's so many other things to consider here.
For example, Nizerol shampoo,
I recommend all the time.
It's got fragrance in it.
There is no competitive product on the market
that doesn't have fragrance.
So there's just several other examples
I can give you of this
where there's products with fragrance that are great
or products with common allergens that are great,
and you can't avoid them.
But I try to limit it because it sucks
when you have an allergic reaction.
It sets you back months, weeks in your routine.
You can't use other products.
You don't know what caused it.
You have to throw out maybe more than one product
because you don't know which one triggered it.
And it's frustrating, I think,
for everybody that it happens to,
and probably frustrating when it finally happened to you.
Yeah, it was.
Next though, I think, so anything else
on the natural you wanna talk about?
I know we're gonna transition into something here too.
No, all right.
So moving on to facial massage.
Right, so facial massage,
if you haven't seen a video on this,
there are plenty out there.
Just look it up.
The theory behind this is that through movements
either with your hands or a tool called a gua sha tool,
which is not at all used as it was historically
to move and manipulate the skin and soft tissue,
you can do almost anything.
You can restructure your face.
You can restructure your fat.
You can restructure, sometimes they'll say, the bones.
Now, there's a very strong following
of people who wholeheartedly believe in this.
And some of them are kind enough
to share some studies with me and say,
hey, look, once again, just like I talked about before,
there is a published study.
There may be two published studies
showing this can be helpful.
Now, that wasn't enough to move the needle for me.
Wait a minute.
Hang on a second.
Let's give some context here.
Hold on a second.
Rewind.
Okay, so facial massage, right?
We've seen it touted.
You know, there are actually even in-person places
you can go to to get a facial massage now.
You know, there are businesses built around facial massage.
There are tools that are built around facial massage.
A lot of people, you know, moving to this facial massage.
You're telling me that someone tried to convince you
that facial massage was good.
It was just like another creator,
another dermatologist, or?
It was a creator.
And honestly, I think they were fairly gracious
because basically I likened what they were doing
and promoting as doing absolutely nothing.
And they responded with a study.
And I was like, well, you know, that was fair.
That's a fair comeback.
Oh, so you, so nay, hang on a second.
This isn't like a friendly,
this was a you reacted to their video shading them.
And then they responded with a study.
Is that correct?
Absolutely.
Yeah, that's it.
I don't think that's ever happened to me.
And I shade people all the time.
Maybe I just didn't see that.
Has it happened?
You just don't, you have too many comments.
You can't get through them all.
I don't know.
I mean, listen, okay, okay.
So we've been provided with a study here
and we'll read the name of the study.
This is the analysis of morphological changes
after facial massage by a novel approach
using three-dimensional computed tomography, or CT.
And this is published
in the Skin Research and Technology Journal.
Terrible study, horrible study.
I read the study, horrible, horrible.
And listen, I'm not, I mean, it's a start.
We have, first of all, starting out 12 people in the study.
Well, small sample size.
Age range, okay, decent, 30 to 54,
where you're probably seeing most people
doing the facial massage.
And they really did do their best
to make it scientific here.
They have before and after photos.
And then they also evaluated with this functional,
this three-dimensional CT scan of the face
to see if there were any changes to the skin
after this massage.
The reason why I think this is not helpful at all,
and you could chime in here
and let me know what your thoughts on this are,
is because this was done like right after the massage.
So like, I've always maintained
that like putting ice on your face,
massaging your face, facial exercise,
like clenching your jaw and moving your jaw,
like all of those are gonna have temporary changes
to the face because like they're gonna, you know,
improve blood flow temporarily.
They're gonna maybe cause some temporarily swelling
and edema.
Maybe they're gonna constrict the blood vessels
in the case of ice.
So definitely, definitely short-term benefits
or maybe short-term changes, let's say,
short-term changes when you do any of these things.
But I don't think there are long-term,
sustainable benefits to this.
See, and that's exactly it.
So that was my main problem with this as well.
So it's very difficult though,
I think, for the general public.
They see something like this and they're like,
hey, it's a study.
Like, is this PubMed Index?
I don't know about this journal.
That's the problem too.
There's a lot of small journals that publish it.
Like, we've published a lot.
And we know for a fact there's a lot of journals out there
where you pay a lot of money to get your paper published.
And so with that comes this kind of overflow of information
that's really not well vetted but appears to be.
And I think this falls into that category.
Not that this shouldn't be published
because I think it's good to start the discussion
with this or similar topics.
But just like Dr. Shah, my main problem is like,
what was the timing from the facial massage to the imaging?
Because no matter what trauma you do for your skin
or for your face, if you image right afterwards
with a high-quality imaging,
there are going to be changes.
It's just, is it a product purely of irritation
and inflammation, or is it actually
a functional structural change that's beneficial
and has lasting effects?
And there are a few other studies I went through after that.
You know, I just made sure I wasn't missing anything.
There was another study, a similar CT study,
looking at five people with similar results.
But that's about it.
And so again, I just don't,
see, one thing I think too,
even before we come to these clinical studies,
it goes through that same filter I talked about before.
Like, does this line up with what we know about biology,
just human biology?
Does this line up with what we know about physiology?
And then, can it be extrapolated from there
into clinical real-world data?
You know, it really has to check all the boxes for me.
Yeah, that's really the scientific method
that we really need to be analyzing things.
That was actually, you know, Dr. Kligman,
who discovered, invented tretinoin,
had this sort of process about the way
that he looked at skincare ingredients.
Controversial figure, by the way.
We can probably talk about him on a future episode.
But Albert Kligman believed that in order to say
that a product worked,
one, you needed to know that it could actually reach
the targeted area, right?
So like, in the case of topicals,
it would need to penetrate the skin, right, to be effective.
So one, you needed to know that it could actually
be where it's supposed to be.
Two, we need to have a mechanism of action
that made sense, right?
Like, theoretically, even, right?
You know, the question is, does facial massage
have some type of theoretical benefit to the skin?
I mean, you know, I think in some ways, you know,
by helping to move lymphatic fluid,
you could help with people that maybe have some puffiness
in the morning or something like that.
So you could expect that, but, you know, again,
you wouldn't expect any long-term changes
to the collagen or anything like this.
But that being said, like, there needs to be a mechanism.
And then the third piece of that was always
that there needed to be clinical studies
showing that these actually worked.
So one, you needed to actually reach the target area.
Two, you need to actually have a mechanism that makes sense.
And then three, you need to actually have clinical studies
that are showing that it actually does
what we expect it to do in theory.
And so those are the three criteria.
And a lot of the things that are recommended
don't meet those three criteria.
You're right, exactly.
Which brings us full circle back to the natural thing
is that just it's tough for people to,
I think, convince me as a doctor of some of the benefits
without any of those links in the chain
or one of those links in the chain.
And this kind of falls in there, too,
is just a physical aspect of something
that people are promoting widely
and the results that really aren't founded.
I think that that's fair.
Again, you know, though, I think, you know,
even though I don't think there are tremendous benefits,
I don't think that these should be in lieu,
used in lieu of other things,
you know, most of the time not harmful.
And, you know, I have heard the argument
that Gua Sha, not done correctly
when we see it on TikTok, as we discussed,
but, you know, apparently there are maybe
some scientific literature in other languages
that have been published on the benefits of it.
And so, you know, I wouldn't, you know, again,
throw away things that have been around
for before we've been alive.
But again, you know, I don't expect any miracle changes
to the bone by massaging your face.
If you have the extra five minutes, 10 minutes,
then have at it.
Yeah, I agree with you too.
Interestingly about the Gua Sha literature
that I could find is a lot of it's done
with like breast fullness, breast milk,
headaches, which makes some sense.
But again, the way they're using this
and doing this is fairly aggressive
to the point of inducing bruising and purpura
and not at all like the like very nice experiential
light massage that's been popularized lately.
100% agree.
All right, so I think that covers it.
Yeah, facial massage, I'm not doing it.
You could do it if you want,
but let's move on to the next topic here.
This is gonna be quick.
We're gonna summarize the, it's gonna be a quick run.
This is for Dr. Maxfield, no preparation.
I'm gonna yell out a skincare trend
and I'll explain it briefly.
And then you tell me in one line, no long explanations.
Are we keeping this trend going into 2023
or are we trashing this trend, okay?
You ready?
All right, so first up, skinimalism.
This is where you're limiting your skincare routine,
not 10 steps, but you know, three or four steps.
Keeping it or trashing it?
Keep, keep.
Keeping it, okay, I agree.
Next up is skin taping.
Skin taping is where you like tape your face up
to hold it in position.
Are we keeping this one or are we trashing this one?
Trash, definitely.
I got so much hate from the brands,
the skin taping brands when I roasted this on my Instagram.
Yeah, not good for the skin.
I completely agree, trashing it.
Next up is menstrual facials.
Menstrual fluid facials coming back in hot.
What do we thought, keep it or trash it?
I trash it.
Yeah, I made a video about this and I got a lot of hate,
so I'm gonna stay quiet on this one,
but I silently agree with you.
Next up is skin cycling.
We've talked about it on our YouTube channel.
This is essentially where you rotate,
you exfoliate day one, retinoid day two,
take two days of a break where you just moisturize,
and then you start that cycle over again.
We keeping it or trashing it?
I'd say keep-ish, but it'll be modified.
It's already morphing.
Morphing, okay, so yeah, I agree.
I think it's in between.
We keep it for beginners and then we expand from there.
So yeah, that's an in-betweener
and we have a much longer video on it if you're interested.
And next up, just because of the time of the year
and because it's the most number one search thing
in skincare right now,
slugging, where you take Vaseline
as the last step in your skincare routine
or any occlusive petrolatum-based ointment
as the last step in your skincare routine.
Keeping it or trashing it?
Keep, keeping it, keeping it.
I love slugging this time.
I've already slugged last night.
So always keeping the slug.
All right, so that's pretty good.
Let us know if you like that.
Definitely, it's not subscribe to the podcast.
Subscribe to our channel, but enroll in our podcast.
Lou.
Lou, what is it?
It's follow the podcast.
Follow or subscribe to the podcast
coming from you everywhere, Spotify, Apple,
wherever you listen to your podcasts, we'll be there.
See you in the next one.
We'll see you next time.
Appreciate y'all.
Stay classy, San Diego.