Origins of the Silk Roads
4 Video Views·Nov 8, 2022
Hello, everyone.
Welcome, and it's my pleasure tonight
to introduce our speaker.
Rowan K. Flad is the John E. Hudson Professor
of Archaeology in the Department of Anthropology
here at Harvard University.
He holds an AB from the University of Chicago,
an MA and PhD from the University of California,
Los Angeles.
At Harvard, he served as the Archaeology Program Director,
Director of Undergraduate Studies,
and Department Chair for the Department of Anthropology,
and the Chair of the Standing Committee on Archaeology.
And he's an affiliated faculty member
of the Inner Asian and Altaic Studies Department.
He also serves on the academic board
and was a founding board member
of the Institute for Field Research,
and serves on the founding board
of the Esherick Gay Family Foundation.
His research is focused on the emergence
and development of complex society
during the late Neolithic and Bronze Age periods in China.
This work incorporates interest in diachronic change
in production processes and technology,
the interaction between ritual activity and production,
the role of animals in early Chinese society,
particularly their use in sacrifice and divination,
and the processes involved in social change in general.
He's conducted excavations at a salt production site
in eastern Sichuan Basin,
regional archaeological survey in the Chengdu region
focusing on prehistoric settlement patterns
and social evolution,
and currently directs an international collaborative survey
and excavation project in the Tao River Valley in Gansu.
This project focuses on technological change
in various domains and investigates
the formation processes of community interaction
involved in the development of the proto-Silk Road.
His current research and writing projects
focus on several aspects of social complexity,
including specialized production and technology,
the anthropology of value, mortuary analysis,
archaeological landscapes, inter-regional interaction,
cultural transmission, and animal and plant domestication.
He also teaches.
Please join me in welcoming Professor Slatt.
Thank you, Jane, thank you, Jeff.
I wanted to thank the Peabody Museum staff also
for putting this program together,
and also thank my collaborators in China
without whom a lot of the work I've been able to do
on this project and others I wouldn't be able to accomplish.
It's delightful to have so many of you here today
to join us in this discussion
about the origins of the Silk Roads in China.
Despite the weather, you have braved
the transition of seasons, and it's nice to have you here.
Today I'm gonna be talking about
the nature of networks of interaction
that connect distant places across Eurasia.
I wanted to point out from the beginning
that my vantage point is decidedly eastern,
situated in China, where I conduct my fieldwork.
And so most of the conversation that I'm gonna have today
will involve discussion of the origins
of the Silk Roads, and to a large extent,
the proto-Silk Road that Jeff referred to,
from the point of view of the places
where I've been working on the kind of eastern parts
of these networks of interaction.
I also wanna emphasize that these networks of interaction
at the origins that I'm gonna be talking about
for most of the time are really not trade routes per se,
as Jane referred to them,
and as we often think about the Silk Roads.
But we'll get there in a second
in terms of my framing of this discussion.
Before I get started, I did wanna mention one thing
Jeff mentioned, I'm on the board
of the Institute for Field Research,
which is a program, or it's an institute,
a nonprofit that coordinates archeological
and ethnographic and environmental field schools
around the world.
As a board member, it's part of my duty
to publicize this organization,
and encourage any of you who have students,
who are students, who are teachers with students,
who have children who might be interested
in getting them involved in the conducting
of real research in an explicitly educational environment
to ask me questions about this
if you're interested afterwards,
or to just go to the website ifrglobal.org
and see the offerings for this coming season,
which will be announced as November 1st,
and there'll be about 55 field schools around the world
that are all rigorously vetted in the process
of the work that I and others do.
All right, I'm gonna start my lecture today
with a question, and this is what I wanna do
to have your cell phones still available for,
those of you who happen to have cell phones.
I'm gonna ask you to send me a text.
And this text addresses the question
from the perspective of East Asia,
which is kind of something I added on at the end,
when did the Silk Roads begin?
Now, you're here at this lecture,
you presumably have heard of the Silk Road before,
or maybe you were just curious about what it might be,
so you might have an idea.
Now, this first one is an oddly specific date.
I'll explain that in a second.
This you can more or less consider the medieval period,
so again, 581 to 907 A.D.,
a period well into the dynastic cycle in China.
The Han Dynasty, about the time of the Roman Empire,
or earlier, I guess, is the last choice.
So, as we get some text here that should start to populate,
if it's working, oh, there we go.
You text this, you send that word to that number,
and then you put A, B, C, or D.
You text that word to that number,
and then you text one of those letters.
A, B, C, or D.
Nobody seems to think 1877 is right.
Oh, hey, all right, there we go.
I think these people might just wanna know
why I put this on here.
All right, a lot of you are into the proto-Silk Roads here.
All right, so the trick here, if it's not already obvious,
is that, to some extent, all of these are true,
but you may wonder why some of them are,
and I'll kinda go through, for my first few slides,
a little bit about each of these.
It may not be obvious that this 1877 year is relevant,
but it is.
This term, the Silk Road, was actually introduced
as die Seidenstrasse by this guy,
Baron Ferdinand Freiherr von Richthofen,
who is a relative of some relative close relationship
with Manfred von Richthofen, the Red Baron.
He's a little more famous in most circles.
This von Richthofen was a geologist who worked in Eurasia
and actually wrote a book that talks about the Silk Road,
die Seidenstrasse, and introduced that term
into the literature.
And so, to some extent, actually,
this concept begins in 1877 with von Richthofen's
discussion and publication that reflects
on the interactions across Eurasia.
There's a great paper by Tamara Chin at Brown University,
which is cited down here, about the history of this term
and this concept that I recommend
to anybody who's further interested.
My poll also highlighted the Sui and Tang period
in the medieval period, perhaps, of China,
during which we really see a pulse of incorporation
over parts of Central Asia that purport to show the,
and you see these maps that purport to show the extent
of the centralized control associated with dynastic families
whose capitals are located in various parts
of the eastern part of China.
During the Sui and Tang, which we've passed already
on my sequence, there is some degree of formality
over the control of the networks of communication
that developed, in large part,
to foster and facilitate trade and commerce,
this notion of trade routes that was referred to before.
However, more often, we think when we talk
about the Trans-Eurasian Silk Road,
what comes to mind are these controlled routes
that coalesced in the late centuries before the Common Era
and into the Common Era during the Han Dynasty,
particularly as the Han Dynasty established
some sort of military control
over their far western borderlands.
In some tellings, the origin myth of the Silk Road
focuses on, not surprisingly, silk,
which purportedly first traveled outside of China
in the possession of a princess promised
to the kingdom of Khotan
in the first century of the Common Era.
Maps such as these come to mind,
and the connections that they portray
reflect critically important component
of globalizing world system
into which Han China was becoming integrated
during this period.
Likewise, what's not drawn on these maps
is routes to the south,
sometimes called the Tea and Horses Road, or the Chamadao,
connecting the Han core and other parts of the Chinese world
with Southeast Asia and across the Tibetan Plateau,
which was becoming established
during the Han Dynasty as well,
and we have good evidence now for that archeologically.
The grand narrative of the subsequent millennium
of interconnections has recently been told
in a 2017 book by Peter Frankopan,
which many of you may be familiar with.
This is a best-selling book for good reason.
It highlights the various ways
in which these connections were complicated,
multiple, and dynamic, involving connections of faith,
commerce, conflict, empire, and a technology
all the way up until the 20th century.
This theme of multiple networks of connectivity
lies at the root of why I use the plural roads
in my talk today, and what I intend to talk about
are the origins of these networks and connections,
and as it should be obvious by now,
the plural in origins is also intentional
because there are many different origins
for these Silk Roads that we are going to be talking about.
The proto-Silk Roads that I'm gonna be focusing on
are really not evidenced by historical records,
and instead, we see them through archeological evidence,
specifically evidence of long-distance connections
reflected in technology, and Jeff mentioned
that one of the things that I work on
is the archeology of technology,
so I'm gonna take a little side trip here
into discussion of technology and what technology is.
We'll start with a definition.
Technology can actually be defined in many ways,
but I really like this succinct and satisfying definition
by Carrie Brzeen, who is a specialist in Andean textiles,
who received her PhD here in our anthropology department,
and worked on technologies
during the early contact period of Peru.
She writes that technology is a system of practices
interrelating the transformation of material resources,
abstract and practical knowledge,
and social and political relationships and cultural beliefs.
There are many parts of this definition
that I really wanna highlight here,
and perhaps first and foremost is this notion of practices
that draws attention to the aspects of technology
that involve the process of making or doing things.
Furthermore, I wanna emphasize that this definition
talks about the transformation of material resources,
and that focuses our attention on how resources are vital,
practices are formative, and that often, if not always,
technologies are material,
and therefore archeologically visible.
So if we wanna understand technologies,
we can do so even in the absence of textual sources
because of the residue that they leave behind.
Interrelating these various aspects of the material
connects these resources and practices to knowledge,
relationships, and beliefs,
and those are the really core elements
that we as scholars, that we who study technology
wanna get at when we are looking at technological remains.
So this interrelationship of technological practices
reflects how technology, with a capital T,
is an essential component of what it means to be human,
connecting all aspects of human behavior.
It is through the chemistry of technology
that a society and economy are able to function.
This chemistry metaphor comes from a book
that some of you may also know,
which is called The Nature of Technology
by W. Brian Arthur, an economist
who works on complexity theory,
particularly in relation to positive feedback loops
and economic returns,
and someone who's argued about the enabling effects
of technological innovations.
Without belaboring the perspective of this book too much,
I wanna summarize some of Arthur's main points.
He shows us how the concept of technology,
such as the concept that,
including the definition I just gave to you,
can actually be considered
at different levels of abstraction.
Certain technologies at the most basic level are singular.
They are processes or individual devices,
means to fulfill a human purpose, as he defines it.
He uses examples mostly from modern military technology
for some reason, like particular types of aircraft,
but we can think of horse riding in this sense,
or even individual tools
as a type of technology in the singular.
Second is a plural definition that are assemblages,
and this is quoting him again,
assemblages of processes or components,
such as electronics or agriculture or pyrotechnology.
And finally, there's the general
or composite collection of technology,
technology with a capital T,
the entire collection of devices
and engineering practices available to a culture.
When I said before that technology is what makes us human,
this is the level of technology
that I was really referring to.
So investigations of technology in archeological contexts
must rely on the material manifestations
of ancient technological practices
that represent these various levels of abstraction.
The ceramics, bronzes, plant remains,
features that connected to pyrotechnology,
like this one up on the upper right-hand side
part of this slide,
aspects of agricultural technology,
like the plant remains that we see below.
These sorts of things are the means
that we have to investigate technology.
Arthur talks about how technologies result
from a combination of different other
pre-existing technologies.
And so technological change results
in this combinatory process of adding on
and is based on the technologies that exist before.
And furthermore, that these technologies
draw on natural phenomenon.
Accordingly, we should then explicitly examine
how newer technologies,
whether we're talking about the modern day
or the ancient world,
build upon, or perhaps in certain cases,
don't build upon pre-existing technologies
when they're introduced from another place.
Do the pigments used in ceramic production,
like the example you see on the upper left here,
for example, change or remain the same
when we identify shifts in iconography
or shifts in decorative practice?
Second, we should pay particular attention
to technological domains
that involve multiple combined technologies.
In the realm of pyrotechnology, for example,
are the kilns and furnaces and other facilities
that are used to make ceramics
similar or different to, related to, or not,
those that are used to make
other types of pyrotechnological materials,
such as metals.
Do they have similar functions, orientations,
placements in the sites where they are found?
Third, if natural phenomena are critical
to the operation of technology,
understanding these phenomena
should affect the ability to successfully incorporate
new technological components into a technological system.
And so this is perhaps the most important one
I wanna point your attention to today.
So I'm gonna talk about the technological evidence
we have for the Proto-Silk Roads
and these connections between places.
What I want you to think about
is how people at the local level, in their everyday lives,
how were they were able to incorporate these new things,
new types of plants, new types of animals,
new types of ways of dealing with the environment around them
into their own everyday lives?
It's not as easy as it may seem,
and it doesn't rely on a simple calculation
of efficiency or effectiveness
when one is already situated in a particular context
where you're used to doing things a certain way.
With these notes about technology in mind,
I'm gonna move back to our discussion topic
on the Silk Roads today,
and I wanna focus our attention on
the connections we see across Eurasia
in the realm of technology
that constitute this Proto-Silk Road.
To address the questions about technologies
and how they're intertwined
in the development of networks of interaction,
we, of course, need to consider context.
In addition to the chronological context,
such as the Tang or Sui or the Han Dynasty
or the prehistoric period that I'm gonna really focus on,
we must also understand how technologies are related
on a regional scale.
For example, where we find evidence for shared
or different but functionally similar technologies
at one time and on a specific site scale,
including understanding how the position
of technological activities at a site may differ,
for example, from one place to another,
or the ways in which the placement of technological remains
relate to other parts of the space in which people live.
As is true with almost all anthropological studies
and archeological studies,
context is the most critical variable.
I will discuss context on three scales,
three spatial scales today.
First, we can explore how the data at the macro scale
indicate connections across Eurasia
in the Trans-Eurasian Silk Road
and some connections towards the south
in the area that develops
into this Southern Silk Road region.
And the first part of my talk today
will really kind of involve a discussion
of some of the data that exists
that demonstrate these sorts of connections,
these longer distance connections.
But I wanna emphasize this next point,
that is that macro-regional patterns themselves
only tell a part of the story of technological change.
What is really missing in our understanding at the present
is a focused investigation of micro-regional
economic and social development.
And so the project that I'm involved in leading
and what the second part of my talk today
will introduce is really trying to focus on that work.
Work in an area called the Tau River Valley
that really kind of sits at the juncture
of these two networks of longer distance interaction.
The Tau River is a tributary to the Yellow River
where we've been conducting work for a number of years now
and it sits at this really interesting location.
Along the Tau River Valley,
localized processes must be investigated
to provide a finer spatial and chronological resolution
if we are eventually to address the technological changes
that sit at the foundation of Chinese civilization
and that sit at the foundation
of the origins of the Silk Roads.
It is through networks of proto-Silk Road
that all sorts of technologies were transferred into
and out of the region that we now call China.
Today I'm briefly going to note some of these changes
and the work that we're doing to investigate them.
The Tau River is a fruitful region to investigate these
for a number of different reasons.
One concerns the fact that there's actually
a lot of data to start working with.
A total of 531 known prehistoric sites
exist along the Tau River Valley.
Based on, and these are known to various levels
of, to various degrees.
This is based on the third national survey
of cultural heritage which was conducted,
completed in 2012 and which,
at every single provincial level in China,
was intended to bring together the known data
that have come into the understanding of archeologists
and people who manage cultural heritage in various ways.
And so one of the reasons why the Tau River Valley
is a useful place to investigate these sorts of questions
is because there are data to work with.
It's also a place that plays a seminal role
in the origins of the practice of archeology in China.
And that is in large part due to this guy,
a guy named Johan Gunnar Andersson,
who is sometimes thought of as one of the fathers
of archeology in China.
He was a Swedish geologist who was brought to China
by the Republican government in the 19-teens
and was intended to help develop
the National Geological Survey.
And in the process, he, as was common
with geologists at the time,
was interested in understanding antiquity, stratigraphy,
and recognized the evidence for a deeper antiquity
than had previously really been understood
based on a historical approach to the past.
He famously introduced,
among his first discoveries of archeological data in China,
he worked at a place called Yangshao,
in a place called Mianshi in Henan Province,
where he recognized prehistoric pottery
that had painted designs on it.
And in his familiarity with the relatively
non-systematic research across Eurasia at the time,
he suggested that there were connections
between that site and sites far to the west
in Western Eurasia associated with the Anao culture.
These artifacts are actually here
in the Peabody Museum collection, many of them.
And so you could, if you're interested,
look at them yourself.
Superficially, these similarities are quite striking
if you look at the drawings that he produced at the time.
When you look at the artifacts,
they're actually not very similar to each other.
But that's kind of irrelevant to the point,
which was at the time he suggested
that there might be a connection,
a historical connection between these places.
And because of the big gap in between,
it drew his attention westward,
from Henan in the lower Yellow River Valley
towards this part of China,
where the Tao River Valley is located.
And in fact, it was known to many locals
that there were painted pottery cultures,
painted pottery sites in this region,
including along the Tao River Valley,
where he came to do surveys
and investigations in the 1920s.
And so he came to the Tao River Valley
specifically for two reasons.
One of which is that as a geologist,
he was interested in understanding stratigraphy,
particularly the stratigraphy of lust deposits
in northern China.
And the Tao River Valley is a very good place
to examine stratigraphic profiles
that provide evidence for that.
But furthermore, it was in the Tao River Valley
that people who sold antiquities in Lanzhou
knew there were sites to be found
that had archeological remains.
And so he came down there to investigate them.
And here you see an example of photographs,
a number of photographs in this wonderful book
by Magnus Fiskarsson and Chunqing Tan
that documents the evidence of Anderson's work,
much of which is kept at the Museum
of the Far Eastern Antiquities in Stockholm, Sweden,
where half of the material that Anderson collected
at the time was taken during the process of research.
This is a photograph from one of his collecting trips.
And the next photograph is from an excavation
that he conducted at a site called Qijia.
And we're gonna hear a fair amount about Qijia
in the subsequent conversation today.
These sites, these names that you see
on the left-hand part of this slide
are the names of archeological traditions
that are used to be shorthand for chronological phases
in northwestern China by archeologists
even to the present day.
And practically every one of these
was based on a site identified by Anderson.
The Yangshou culture I already mentioned
was from this site in Henan.
But the rest of these, Majia Yao, Banchan, Qijia,
Xindian, and Siwa, these are all sites
in the Tao River Valley.
So essentially the entire chronology
of northwestern prehistory is based on archeological sites
in this one river valley, all visited by Anderson
during the 1920s.
And so it's important historically for that reason
because of the influence it's had
on our understanding of the history
of the region more generally.
Now I show you on the right-hand side here
general chronological ranges for these traditions
as we understand them now.
However, it's important to point out here a couple things.
One of which is that these chronological ranges are fuzzy.
We actually don't have a really even to now
of a very firm control over them.
Furthermore, Anderson originally had this Qijia period,
which sits at a really critical point
in the chronological development
of northern Chinese societies.
He originally thought that Qijia was
at the beginning of this sequence.
Now we know that's wrong now.
We know it's wrong in large part
because of work by another very influential archeologist
named Shanai, who was the director
of the Institute of Archeology
in the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences for a period.
And perhaps one of the most influential archeologists
in the later part of the 20th century.
He did work here that demonstrated the position
that the Qijia culture should sit
in this chronological sequence.
But Anderson didn't just put it at the beginning
for no particular reason.
He did that for two primary reasons.
One of which is during his excavations
that you see in the background here
at the site of Qijiaping,
which is the type site for the Qijia culture,
he identified this material of the Qijia culture
in situ, in the underground.
But on the surface there were some painted pottery.
And so by the kind of basic law of superpositioning,
the stuff buried underneath should be earlier
than the stuff on the surface, right?
And so the painted pottery cultures,
the majiao, banchan, and machang,
should be later, perhaps,
in that stratigraphic relationship.
Furthermore, the Qijia materials is much simpler
in nature.
It's typically undecorated plain wares
in terms of the ceramic assemblage.
And he didn't find any bronze material
in the excavations that he conducted.
Whereas he thought that the painted pottery cultures
should be of the bronze age
and should be associated with bronze production.
And that's actually where he got things most wrong.
In fact, it is during the Qijia period
that we see the real introduction of metallurgy
into this region of China.
And then subsequently, bronze metallurgy in particular
becomes one of the hallmarks of Chinese civilization.
The scale of bronze production
during the later part of the second millennium
and into the first millennium BC
dwarfs all bronze production anywhere else in Eurasia
or anywhere else in the world, really.
And it's at this point in time,
and associated with the Qijia culture,
that we really start to see the introduction
of this technology into East Asia,
into this region from places presumably further west.
And we say that now because we have a reasonably
clear time series of bronze production in Central Asia
that precedes this and is very similar in nature
to the small sorts of bronze objects
that are reflected here.
Now, that's not to say that all bronze production in China
is derivative of this technology
that comes in from Central Asia.
In fact, the way in which bronze production
develops in China is really a unique trajectory of its own.
But the first stages of that see metallurgy
associated with the Qijia culture.
And these are from a site called Mogo,
which is a really interesting site,
again, in the Tao River Valley in the upper regions of it.
Now, that's not the place from which
we have the earliest remains of metallurgy
in East Asia, in China.
In fact, that's further to the northwest,
including at sites such as this one,
published by a group out of,
a collaborative group from China and Australia,
published about five, 10 years ago now,
that really documents about 2200 BC,
local bronze production at a couple sites
in a tributary to this region called the Heshi Corridor,
that place that really becomes the core
of the Silk Roads in more historic periods.
And so we see this metallurgy
as one of these technological innovations
for which we are developing an understanding
of the connections between Central Asia and Eastern Eurasia.
In the Tao River Valley, painted ceramics,
such as the ones on the left-hand side here,
reflect the pinnacle of craft production
through the third millennium BC.
But it's with the advent of metallurgy
that we see a very radical change
in the kind of decorative motifs
and the style of ceramics,
with the introduction of metallurgy,
such as those objects that we find at Mogo.
Metal objects actually, furthermore,
document a connection between this region
and Qijia culture specifically,
and long-to-end connections towards the Central Plains,
this region of China in the lower Yellow River Valley
that becomes the fount of Chinese civilization,
particularly the site of Arleitou.
We see some objects such as these bronze mirrors
that are typical of Qijia cultural repertoire,
but also, and for some of you who are familiar
with the collections of the art museum here,
objects like these.
This one in the center is an object from Arleitou,
and we have a number of objects like this
in the art museums at Harvard.
These are bronze plaques inlaid with turquoise,
and these are thought to be something
that is associated with this very important site
in the lower Yellow River Valley
that is seen to be really indicative
of the transformation towards a major
bronze-producing culture in that region.
But it's important to note that similar objects,
like the one on the left,
have been found in Qijia cultural contexts,
and these really clearly represent,
with their unique style and combination
of different technologies,
connections between these places,
suggesting how important this Northwestern region
and the Qijia culture is
in the development of Chinese civilization.
A second realm of technological change
during this period that reflects changing local traditions
of symbolism and craft production
is the manufacture of jades.
True jade, jadeite, is not a material found
in eastern parts of China,
and access to sources in Xinjiang
have been thought to be another vector
of interactions to Central Asia
from a relatively early period.
However, in the context of Qijia jade production,
it seems that there are sources of nephrite,
a different type of jade,
in regions that are close to where
the Qijia sites are located.
So this is the Tao River Valley
flowing from south to north here,
and this is a mountain range called the Maqianshan,
where there are nephrite sources known even today,
and in fact, the place where those are located
is at a source of tributaries
that lead right into the Tao River,
right where Qijiaping is located,
and where there's a number of known other sites
that are contemporary with this,
where jade production seems to have been taking place.
These connections between Maqianshan
and the Tao River Valley
really suggest that jade manufacture
is associated with the Qijia culture sites in this region.
Another realm of technology
that demonstrates nascent networks
of long-distance interaction and influence
that sets the stage for historic-era silk roads
concerns the spread of new cereal crops
from their original origins of domestication.
We see the introduction of wheat and barley,
which you can see in the blue line here,
from places further west,
originally domesticated in the Fertile Crescent
and the Levant of Western Asia,
slowly into Central Asia and into Eastern Asia,
and similarly, and in a different direction,
the domestication of millets,
which first occurred in Eastern Asia,
then being something that is adopted by
and incorporated into some agriculture traditions
moving towards Central Asia,
and some people even have suggested
places much further west, all the way to Europe.
And so these connections
in the realm of agricultural technologies
is another line of evidence that we have
in terms of the big picture, in this macro scale,
to understand these proto-silk road connections.
We can say the same thing,
or a very similar thing in relation to animals,
where connections are shown
through the adoption, again, of domesticates
that come from a different part of Eurasia
into a new part.
The introduction of caprines, sheep and goat,
cattle, horses, are all introduced from places
further west in Eurasia into East Asia
from these long-distance networks of interaction,
and pigs and dogs toward Central Asia
from places where they were domesticated
further to the east.
And so animal technologies
and agricultural technologies in this realm
can also be thought of in relation to these practices.
Many of these animal taxa, particularly cattle and horses,
became really important symbolic and functional,
for symbolic and functional roles
in early Chinese civilization,
as I explained with the bronze technology before.
Cattle, for example, provide the bones
that are the medium on which
the first writing in China is known.
This example in the upper right,
an oracle bone from the site of Inshu in Anyang in Henan,
again, in the same general region as Arlito,
what I've mentioned before, and Yangshao,
is an example of this from about 1250 BC.
This on the lower left is a turtle plastron,
which was the other medium for this type of writing.
Now, it's important to note
that these are not the earliest oracle bones in China.
In fact, oracle bones are another technological medium
that develops around this time,
around the beginning of, around the third millennium BC,
and into the second millennium BC,
and illustrates long-distance connections,
although not directly implicating connections
to Central Asia.
These early oracle bones from northern China,
different parts of northern China,
did not have writing on them.
And so, I wanna make that clear,
because these are not evidence of earlier use
of these types of bones for writing,
but they are burned in the same fashion.
They were put to the same sort of purpose of divination
in order to help mediate the world
around the people who were using them.
Finally, we have the realm of ceramic technologies,
the changes in which are often used as fundamental lens
through which we observe change in technological traditions.
And here, you see a sequence that I've showed before,
but in a different form, from the Yangshao,
through the painted pottery cultures
of the Majiao, Banchan, and Machang,
through the Qijia, Xindian, and Siwa, and later cultures,
illustrated by the types of ceramics
that are characteristic of them.
The sequence of archeological cultures in the region,
from the Majiao, to the Banchan, to the Machang,
to the Qijia culture, does not reflect a pattern
that can be tried to, in a straightforward manner,
to the arrival of metal-producing, wheat-eating,
sheep-herding Central Asians.
Instead, the process of uptake and adoption
of these different types of technologies
was intensely local, and involved a differential adoption
of different new technologies in various places
at different times, and at different degrees.
And this is the rub.
This is why it's not sufficient for us
just to talk about the fact that we have this evidence
for long-distance connections, and there we go.
In fact, we must focus our attention on local communities,
where new technologies were taken up,
and therefore, we must return to the local scale.
So for the rest of the talk today,
I'm gonna focus more on the local scale,
where we can try to start understanding
the manifestation of these technological traditions,
and how they were taken up by local communities.
The project that I have been leading
for the last number of years
focuses on examining some of the sites,
some of these 531 sites known from the Tao River Valley.
We started by looking at the sites
that we were able to locate
based on this register of known places,
looking at their topographic conditions,
and seeing whether they would be conducive
to additional research.
And so for the next 15 minutes or so,
or 10 or 15 minutes, I'm gonna talk about
what that additional research involves,
and what the sort of things that we're doing
in order to try to address these problems,
these questions about local adoption on the local level are.
And I will tell you now that we aren't yet
entirely at the point where I can give you
definitive conclusions about things,
in case you are gonna be holding your breath for that.
But you can see that we already have
some really interesting data that speak to these processes
of long-distance interaction at a certain level.
So we started in 2012 with a survey of many of these sites,
visiting the sites that are known from the region,
investigating the nature of their composition,
their size, the degree to which we perceive them
to be worthy of additional work.
We then selected, oh, I wanted to mention one other thing.
In this process, in this site, and this whole project
has been built in large part in collaboration
with a number of colleagues, including colleagues in China,
but also these two people, my dear friend Chen Pucheng,
who was a classmate of mine at UCLA
and was teaching at National Taiwan University,
and Hongling Yu, who was teaching at Indiana University.
And both of these individuals have passed away recently,
very young, both from illnesses,
and I just wanna recognize their contributions
to this project.
This work is something that then focused
on picking sites among these.
We selected 24 of the known sites to do additional work on,
and some of those you can see depicted on this slide,
which is another image of the Tao River Valley
that I showed before.
We're gonna, I'm gonna focus most of our attention
on Qijiaping, the site I've mentioned already,
which was the type site of the Qijia culture
where Anderson did his work previously.
Our main goal is to understand the spatial organization
of features at this site and others like it,
and the others hopefully will help us
provide information on different chronological phases
of the work in this region.
And so my next several slides introduce you
to the kind of stages of the work that we've been doing.
We start by conducting a surface survey of the site,
and in this particular case, we were benefited
by the fact that our colleagues
at the Gansu Provincial Institute of Archeology,
with whom we work very closely,
had also conducted a systematic coring survey of the site
in preparation for the listing of Qijiaping
on the National Historic Register.
And so these maps, this one and the next one,
are maps that were generated by, in this process,
and they're very useful as a baseline
on which we can conduct our work.
What you see on here is a kind of a delimiting line
for where most of the archeological remains are found,
and the orange marks are different types
of archeological features that were identified
during this coring process.
From that data, we can identify two main clusters
of materials at the site,
and those two main clusters seem to be separated
more or less into a residential area
and an area which contained a cemetery
and perhaps some features associated
with pyrotechnology production.
In 2013, we, building on this previous information,
started to do some systematic work of our own,
including creating a map of the site.
Now, you might wonder why, if we had this map,
why we needed another map?
Well, it turns out that the group that did this map
for our colleagues in the Gansu Provincial
Institute of Archeology made a map
that is not very accurate.
And so it's useful for that sort of work,
but needed, for the purposes of the work
that I'm gonna describe in a second,
we needed to have a high degree of precision
as to where everything we found was located.
So we started doing some mapping of our own,
collecting surface material at the site,
and providing and creating a sense
of where we had the densest material on the surface
that might reflect the subsurface remains
that could be subjected to further analysis.
So all the yellow lines you see on this map
are collection areas where we collected the ceramics.
We can use that to create density maps such as this one,
and the white areas on this density map
show parts of the site that have the highest concentrations
on the surface of material.
And this gives us a sense that in the area
around the modern village,
which we think of as the residential part of the site,
there's a lot more material than we see down in this area,
where nevertheless,
there's some stuff on the surface as well.
Focusing our attention down there,
I'll turn back to one of the topographic maps that is made,
and it's associated with that coring data
that I showed before.
And you can see one dotted area,
which was a cemetery zone,
and then a number of other little red spots,
which are features that were identified
during this coring work.
Now that cemetery zone is known to be a cemetery
because it was excavated in 1975
by the Gansu Provincial Institute of Archaeology,
and it's the only excavations that have been done there.
But it is very revealing,
showing a collection of materials
that is very typical of the Qijia culture and nature.
Also bronze objects like this bronze mirror,
an oracle bone from a sheep scapula,
and some turquoise objects as well.
In this region, outside of the area of the cemetery,
there's a zone where there were a number of features
identified by the coring
that seemed to be pyrotechnological in nature.
They had red-burned earth associated with them,
and in that same region,
we found this object during our survey,
which is a paddle or an anvil
used in the production of pottery.
And so we thought of this as a very good location
to investigate for remains of pyrotechnological facilities
that would help us understand some of these questions.
We conducted a geophysical survey
where we laid out a grid,
used this device, which is a magnetometer,
to collect data systematically across certain areas,
and these gray areas of this map are the geophysical data,
the data from the magnetometer that we collected.
Blowing one of those areas up,
we see lots of gray, black, and white on this.
The areas of white or black are anomalies.
They are different from the surrounding baseline,
and they are worthy of investigation in some fashion.
You can't really tell what they are
other than they are affecting the Earth's magnetic field
in a way that is not typical
of the sediment surrounding them.
And so what I've circled for you here
is a number of particularly intense anomalies
that we decided were worth investigation,
particularly because one of them was very close
to a place that had been identified
as a potential kiln by the Coring Group.
Now, you'll notice there's only one kiln
identified by the Coring Group,
but we have six similar anomalies in this region.
We investigated one with an excavation trench
starting in 2016.
This is the coring that we did at the time
to see what it might be.
We found some burned red earth.
We started excavations there.
We found a more or less square burned area,
which we were very happy because it matched up
very closely with the geophysical data that we had,
and we called this Kiln Number One, Yaoi Kiln Number One.
This is an amazing kiln.
It is two meters by two meters in size,
more or less, 1.6 by 1.8,
and about, sorry, 2.8 long,
about 1.6 to 1.8 wide,
and is about, is almost four meters deep.
It's a really impressive construction
that included a number of tile fragments on the floor
down near one of the main flues.
Now, the tile, all along, as we got digging into this,
we started getting more and more worried
because at the beginning,
we were really happy to be finding a Qijia culture kiln.
A Qijia culture kiln, from our recognition,
although not very many have been excavated,
probably shouldn't be this big,
and in fact, this is not a Qijia culture period kiln.
This is a kiln from the Song Dynasty.
It's nevertheless, so much later,
in terms of its chronology from probably,
and I'll talk about the chronology in just a second,
but from around 1,000 years ago,
rather than 3,500 years ago.
Inside the kiln that was really well-preserved,
these pillars, incidentally,
are just bolts that we left
to keep it from collapsing on itself,
but in the background,
you can see these flue components to the kiln
where the hot air would have escaped,
and inside the central flue,
it was jammed full of a bunch of artifacts,
bones, a number of bones, some rocks,
including a very curiously shaped phallic-shaped rock,
which we believe was intentionally placed there
as part of the killing of this kiln
when it was no longer useful.
The tile fragments themselves,
as well as the porcelain fragment
that we found in the middle of the kiln,
suggest a chronology of this kiln
from the Northern Song period,
probably in the 12th century A.D.,
based in part on this.
Some of this work is done by a PhD student here,
Zhang Chengrui, who I know is in the audience,
and has done a really very interesting study
of the significance of this particular
Northern Song Dynasty kiln.
The dating of this is still not finalized.
One potential explanation for it
relates to the establishment in this area
of more firm control after the early 12th century A.D.,
we see very strong similarities
between the Xizhaping kiln and Northern Song kilns
from Luoyang in Henan.
And these kilns in Henan were associated
with a military establishment.
It is during this same general time,
oh, we have thermal luminescence states
that to some extent corroborate that at the moment.
We see a cluster of these anomalies in this region,
and this may be a cluster of kilns from this period
that could relate to the Northern Song expansion
in the 11th or 12th century A.D.,
when the Northern Song expanded into this area
that was previously controlled by a Tibetan polity.
So that's a bit of an aside,
but it's an interesting result that we have come up with,
not as closely related to the Proto-Silk Road materials,
but does relate to these interactions
between the core of China and polities
in its surrounding region from a later period.
We've also conducted geophysics
on the northern part of this site,
and all the rest of the remains I'm gonna talk about
really do relate to the chronological phases
that we're interested in.
The work in the residential zone
identified a large number of anomalies
in the geophysics data that we collected.
We have investigated a couple of them
with excavation units, such as the one you saw before,
and in 2016 and in 2017,
we recovered pit remains
within which we were able to extract
carbonized plant remains, animal bones, and ceramics,
all of which help us to start to understand
the various technologies that were being incorporated
into the daily lives of the people at Qijiaping
during this period.
This particular pit also had oracle bones in it,
and a pit number T2 in the same general region
excavated in 2017 had this guy,
which is our perhaps most evocative piece so far
in the excavation,
unless you count the stone phallus, I suppose.
And the plant remains from this project,
including the work at this site and others,
are being researched by scholars from Shandong University
under the direction of Jingwei Yun
and UC San Diego under the direction of Jade Geddes,
a former PhD from this department.
And among the plant remains that we found so far
at Qijiaping are wheat and barley and oats,
all of which are West Asian domesticates
that were transplanted into this region
by the time of the Qijia culture, if not before.
So this is a quick overview of the sort of work
that we've done at Qijiaping.
For the last five minutes or so,
I'm gonna kind of go through two other sites
that we've done similar work at
without dwelling on the details,
but just so that you can get a sense
of how we're going to do the work that's necessary
to frame these data and our understanding
of the transition in technologies in the Qijia culture.
One of these is a site called Huizuiwa,
which is a little bit downriver from Qijiaping,
where we've similarly done survey work.
We have done geophysics.
We were able to estimate more or less
where the residential part of the site was located,
and we've excavated a couple of pits
that in which we've found the sorts of ceramics
that are associated with the Xindian culture.
The culture is subsequent to the Qijia period.
And we found oracle bones.
You can see one in situ here as well.
Again, from a caprine, like the one at Qijiaping.
Another site that we've done this sort of work at
is called Dayato.
Dayato is located on this large platform
just overlooking the Tao River.
Qijiaping is actually just over to the side here,
so it's very nearby.
But this site dates to the period
before the Qijia culture,
the Ma Jiayou painted pottery cultures in this region.
We have similarly at this site
done a bunch of surface survey.
We have done a number of zones of geophysics
in the yellow in the background here.
And from this geophysics work,
we have a really interesting map
of a very complicated site.
Now, unlike most of the other sites
that we have focused some of our work on,
including Huiziwa and a few others,
Dayato has never had previous work done at it.
And so the trenches that we've excavated here
just this past season
were the first excavation work ever done there.
And for that reason,
we were really not sure what we were going to come up with.
One of those excavation units came down on a pit,
on a bell-shaped pit that was filled with charcoal
and has provided us some really great data
on plant use and animal bones from this period,
and seems to date quite firmly to this phase
on the third millennium before the Qijia culture.
Our other two trenches are really interesting
because they cut across a number of different features,
including a pit that had a burial in it,
but without any other type of objects
associated with the burial,
and have given us a better sense of the stratigraphy there,
which seems to be mostly associated with this phase
before the Qijia culture.
And we've also found some turquoise at this site,
which is interesting given the use of turquoise
in some of these types of objects
associated with the Qijia period.
We've been able to collect animal bones
from Dayato and Qijiaping and Huiziwa,
and start to,
and these help us understand the transition
and the way in which people were interacting
with animals in their environment.
And from these data,
perhaps the most interesting aspect
of our preliminary data from this project
shows a really clear transition from, again,
the earlier phase through the Qijiaping to the Huiziwa
of a transition towards an increasing use of caprons.
And what that relates to is a broader understanding
that sheep and goat pastoralism
becomes an increasingly dominant form
of subsistence practice and landscape use
in this region more broadly
during this transition from the third
through the second millennium BC.
Now, again, this is, at present,
simply fits into our broader overall macro-regional model,
but by understanding exactly when and exactly how,
to what extent these types of technologies were adopted,
we can really start to focus in
on understanding these processes of transition.
All right.
The last two things I wanted to say
had to do with the broader nature of this project.
In the context of this project,
we've conducted some training with our colleagues in China
on geophysics, the use of magnetometry,
and GIS, a workshop conducted by my colleague, Jason Er,
who's sitting down here in the front row a few years ago.
And this reflects on kind of a broader issue.
The technological exchange between East and West
does not have a neat and tidy beginning
that can be clearly marked,
which was the point I was making with the poll
at the very beginning of the lecture.
There are many beginnings.
And in some ways, the origins of the Silk Road
start all the way with the origins of humanity in Eurasia.
Similarly, the Silk Road has not stopped
becoming a meaningful phenomenon.
These exchanges of technologies
in the context of the practice of archeology, for example,
are one manifestation of this.
Another more politically inspired relationship
is related to the One Belt, One Road Initiative,
also known as the 21st Century Maritime Silk Road,
this initiative directed by President Xi Jinping
starting from 2013.
This involves infrastructural development,
rail and highway construction,
and is an aggressive soft power
and developmental diplomacy program
that China is using to project power across Eurasia
and further afield.
This builds explicitly on the metaphors of the Silk Road
and shows how even in the present day,
the Silk Road is relevant.
Even this 21st Century manifestation, however,
needs to be understood in a social and historical context.
In the context of our proto-Silk Road analysis,
we still have a lot of work to do.
But through future analysis,
our goal is to develop an understanding
of Qijia technology with a capital T
in this particular river valley
as a local manifestation of broader geographical phenomenon.
We intend to do this
by examining these devices and processes
that make up the realms of subsistence technology,
craft technology, prestige technology,
transportation technology, and so forth.
And to take steps in this direction,
the first question concerns where,
both regionally and within sites,
certain technological practices occurred.
The first stage of research, therefore,
aims to produce data
that specifically address this question.
I believe that the broad regional patterns
that we already have a basic understanding of
based on the work I've highlighted previously and others
are important and provide the necessary foundation.
However, if we are to understand
how communities of practitioners
who are involved in the operationalizing
of technological processes
and creating technological devices
combine known components and exploited certain phenomenon,
we need to develop a concerted,
multi-sided, contextualized understanding
with a high degree of chronological resolution.
And I will conclude with that.
Thank you very much.

