Self-Domestication in Bonobos and Other Wild Animals
5 Video Views·Nov 8, 2022
It's my pleasure now to actually introduce Richard and he is known to many of you I'm sure
and as with many of our professors has so many things I could stand here for sort of 10 minutes
and tell you all the wonderful things about Richard but really you're here to hear him and
learn about bonobos so I'm going to keep this fairly short. He is the Ruth Moore Professor of
Biological Anthropology at Harvard where he has taught since 1989. His major interests are
chimpanzee and human evolutionary ecology, the evolutionary dynamics of violence and non-violence
and ape conservation. He received his PhD in zoology from Cambridge University, was a research
fellow at King's College Cambridge and taught at the Department of Anthropology at the University
of Michigan before arriving here at Harvard. Since 1987 he has studied wild chimpanzee behaviour in
Kibale National Park in Uganda. He has been president of the International Primatological
Society and an ambassador for UNESCO's Great Apes Survival Project. He has been awarded the
MacArthur Foundation Fellowship and is a fellow of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the
British Academy. His most recent books are Catching Fire, How Cooking Made Us Human in 2009 and then
of course what we're going to hear about this evening, The Goodness Paradox, The Strange
Relationship Between Virtue and Violence in Human Evolution although it won't be quite the book talk
as I'm sure he's going to mention in a minute but please join me now in welcoming Professor Rangan.
Thank you. Thank you Jane. So no it's not going to be a book talk exactly because when she asked
me to do this talk she said but you can't give your book talk because you'll already have given
a book talk in January which I did or maybe early February. So this is a chapter talk.
One of the chapters in the book is about bonobos and it's a great excuse to be able to share
my enthusiasm for thinking about bonobos as a really special case in human evolution which
may turn out to have larger lessons than just this particular species. So if you came here
thinking the book talk here's the three minute actually the three slide version or maybe it's
the two slide version. The Goodness Paradox is the paradox that on the one hand humans are one
of the nicest animals, we're also cooperative and tolerant and unaggressive to each other
and on the other hand we kill more members of our own species than almost any other animal does
excepting a few things like wolves that do even more. So where does all that come from? Well read
the book but briefly about 300,000 years ago we first get the first glimmerings of the
gracilization of our skulls and skeletons which indicate that we were on a path towards
self-domestication and I think that just as people have often said that humans are like
domesticated animals actually humans really were domesticated animals and in the book I tell the
story of how we can argue that the way in which we became self-domesticated is that we got
sufficiently good language to be able to start developing conspiracies, having safe executions
of poor victims who were the bullies, the aggressive ones and then this led to reduction
in reactive aggression. Well One Earth has got that got to do with bonobos. Here we have
the National Geographic doing a I think a rather wonderful portrayal they really tried to get hard
to work hard to get the science right of our two closest relatives who are equally closely related
to each other chimpanzees and bonobos and you may know that it was some years after bonobos
actually came to the United States and were live here that anybody was able to figure out
that there were two different species at stake because they do look kind of similar to each other
but one of them clearly looks a little bit different from the others. So we're going to
have to talk about bonobos and chimpanzees because if we're going to think about bonobos
we have to think about them relative to their very close cousin chimpanzee. So we got the males
in the middle and the females on the outside and what we're going to do is first of all think about
chimpanzees just bring you up to date or just rehearse you on what we know about chimpanzees
in relationship to aggression and then think about bonobos in relationship to aggression.
I just want to draw that contrast out and then we'll think about why the differences occur. So
very often when people hear about bonobos they think it's all going to be about sex.
I'm so sorry you've come to the wrong, that's in the room just, so we're going to talk more
about aggression and we're going to think about what it is that learning about the strange
difference between these two species can help tell us about human evolution. We're not going to
go far with that but that's the sort of the big aim. Okay so Jane Goodall was 85 last week.
In 1960 she started her studies of chimpanzees. That was in Gombe in eastern part of the chimpanzee
range. You see there on the edge of Lake Tanganyika it is really just beyond the great
West African and Central African forests that creep up to that place in the western rift valley
and since Jane Goodall started a whole bunch of studies of chimpanzees. One is the one I work in
in Kibale and what I'm going to say is some generalizations that have emerged from these
and actually some other studies that are further west where you can't quite see them in this
wonderful view of the earth. So now the first thing that is important is to recognize that
just like bonobos, chimpanzees live in social communities. They're up to 200 individuals.
They start at around 20 or 30 and within those communities they break up into traveling parties
that forage as a unit for a few hours or a few days or even a few minutes and generally you find
there are more males than females in those parties but in the community there are more females than
males. So what's going on is that the females are more often on their own. They're more often
traveling alone and away from the big parties where the males outnumber the females. Those
males are consistently rather aggressive. On the average day you're likely to see males
charging around, maybe just chasing, maybe beating others up. They use their aggression
to dominate others and when they dominate others they're doing it partly with the help of alliances
that they curry favor with all the time through grooming and other ways of being nice to each
other. They are pretty brutal. Those male allies can recruit each other to attack members of their
own group. So here are two males who are attacking an alpha male actually, the one on the left who
is called Pimu. This is in Mahali and on this occasion he was killed. He was killed by a
coalition that ended up being about four males. Some tried to defend him, some tried to attack him
and those were the ones who won. Females of course are terrified of males. They have a very unhappy
relationship with males for much of the time. They are extremely submissive. The males can force them
to pretty much do anything that they want and sometimes the attacks that they make are
quite unprovoked. Here Carol Hoover and I are examining some sticks that a couple of males
used to use to beat on the females but ordinarily you see these black and white photographs here
where a male has simply launched an attack and is pulling a female around and kicking her and
biting her and pounding her with his fists. And the males who do this are the males, well the male
who does this most to a particular female turns out to be the one who is most likely to mate with
her and is most likely to have her next offspring. So males are totally domineering. If they get
some really precious food then they are the ones that control access to the food. The female has
to come and beg from a male for a monkey like this. The sexual coercion is routine in the sense
that it is, as I said, the male who is most aggressive to a particular female who ends up
being the one who mates her most often and in one study in Gombe is the one who also has the
highest chance of being the father and in fact has a more than 50% chance of being the father
which is amazing considering there are maybe 10 or 12 males all of whom are mating her.
The females often get hurt by males, so do their young. They may get hurt by males within
the community, they may get hurt by males of a different community because adult males of
communities patrol the edges when they have the time and they have the energy, they have
enough food to be able to justify wasting it, as it were, in the possibility of aggressive
encounters with the neighbors. If they find infants from neighboring groups then they may
kill them. You see the puncture wounds from the canine of a male and the skull of Andromeda here
who was killed in intergroup interaction and more often they get into a shouting match with
the males from the neighboring group but if the shouting match turns out to be uneven and there's
only maybe one on the other side then that's when you can get individuals who are really
badly beaten up lucky to escape with their lives and not everybody does. So I said this was going
to be about aggression more than sex. That is chimpanzees. Domineering males, sexual coercion,
infanticide, intense aggression, and proactive killing where individuals actually take the
opportunity to go and look for opportunities to kill members of neighboring groups who are
vulnerable about being alone. And that's a generalization that we can make about chimpanzees
in East Africa and to some extent in Western Africa. Okay, so then now we can move to the
contrast with bonobos. When bonobos were discovered as being a species that was separate from
chimpanzees, people did not know that they were going to turn out to have very different behavior
from chimpanzees. Indeed at the time of the discovery, basically 1929, nothing was known
about the behavior of chimpanzees. So you've got these two species living in Central Africa
separated by the Congo River. In order to find out about bonobos, people had to go into one of
the most difficult countries on earth where the infrastructure is extremely poor. So it's not
surprising that it's taken time for bonobo studies to get to the point where people have battled
up the rivers and have walked sometimes 20 kilometers in order to be able to get from
the nearest village into an area where you can watch bonobos. And they started getting glimpses
of bonobos and that was enough for people to found long-term studies. And now in the area on the left
bank of the Congo River, there are four really significant long-term studies and a few other
shorter-term ones. But these are the ones that are producing data equivalent to what we have
on chimpanzees, the earliest going back to 1974 but interrupted by occasional periods of war and
insurrection. So it's very exciting that we're now at the stage where we're really learning about
bonobos. And just like chimpanzees, they live in social communities and within those communities
they live in parties. And you might say, okay, well, is it going to be like chimps with the
number of males in the average party being greater than the number of females? And I think you'll get
the answer when you look at this picture. So here we have something like 20 individual
bonobos and at least eight adult females. And they're with their babies. They are dominating
the number of males numerically. There are more females than males in this party and it turns out
that this is the regular feature that you see in bonobos. So all of a sudden you've got a sex
difference that is the reversal of what we see in chimpanzees. And the really key feature
that seems to be very important underlying much of what goes on with the social behavior of bonobos
is that females form these alliances against males. And they form the alliances through very often
having sex together. One of the rather charming ways in which this all begins
is that at adolescence, just like chimpanzees, a female leaves the group in which she is born
and moves to a new community where she probably doesn't know anybody very much. She might know
them a little bit in bonobos. And when she does that, she is not greeted particularly warmly by
the females in the new group. But she kind of hangs around, often apparently targeting a
particular adult female in the new group. So when I say targeting, what she's doing is spending her
time very often within a few yards of that particular female. It tends to be the female
that she is closest to. And eventually after a few weeks, it has been described that the target
female kind of welcomes the new female. And they have a quick sexual interaction. And then
basically what happens is that she introduces her to all her friends. And then from then on,
she is part of the network of females. And that network is important because they are able to
support each other if a male loses his temper very foolishly with her. So the net result is
that instead of males dominating the females, the females are co-dominant with the males.
In chimpanzees, every single adult male is absolutely dominant to every single adult
female. In fact, the way he becomes part of the male hierarchy is by forcing every adult female
to scream. The females that used to dandle him on their knee. Well, in bonobos, the co-dominance
is probably really in favor of females. But it's slightly difficult because of the rarity of
aggressive interactions to see exactly who is dominant at the top, as I understand it from
the riddle bonobo experts. So you've got here an alpha female and an alpha male. And sometimes
the alpha females are clearly dominant. And sometimes it's more that they're kind of in
parallel. And what is so interesting is that when your male is dominant, when he is the alpha male
above the other males, he is only there by virtue of the support of females. So here is an example
of a male who I actually happened to see in the wild at Wamba in 1996. And he is now 48 years old.
He used to be the alpha male. That was when his mother was alive. When his mother died, he sank.
And that is the story that happens repeatedly. That as long as you've got a living mother,
then you can rise in the hierarchy. But without it, you don't. So the females are very important.
One example is that whereas the males are controlling food sharing in chimpanzees,
the females are much more likely to be in control of a delicious food like a big fruit
or a piece of meat. Compared to the regular sexual coercion of the chimpanzees, there is
essentially no sexual aggression in bonobos. I'm sure that experts have occasionally seen
some sort of tendency for a male to get so frustrated that he tries a little something.
But there's a huge difference. There is such a lack of aggressiveness in the bonobos in terms
of sexual interactions. Now, one of the fascinating areas of development recently
has been the ability to tell who are the fathers in chimpanzees and bonobos
through DNA analysis of the infants. And the expectation when people knew all that about
sexual coercion not being important in bonobos was that the paternity would be rather widely
distributed among the bonobo males because every male's got a good shot. Now, none of them are able
to use their violence to impose themselves on the females. So it was a fascinating surprise
when Martin Sobeck and colleagues discovered that actually the way in which the paternity
is distributed is even more in favor of the top males in the bonobos than it is in chimpanzees.
The reproductive skew is intense. Why? It's not because the males are dominating them,
it's because the females are choosing them. So if you really want to be a successful male,
you get to be a favorite of the females, the kind of male that is being supported by the females,
and then the males will be chosen by the females. Now, I don't want to portray bonobos as totally
unaggressive. There was a terrible situation about, I can't remember, five, six, maybe more
years ago when some bonobos were released in the wild and they ended up attacking the very people
that were caring for them and looking after them and imposing terrible wounds on them. They seemed
to have just been surprised and not understanding who was there. And within bonobo society,
there is enough aggression that you will sometimes see missing knuckles or cuts on them.
Nevertheless, the overall impact does seem to be less because the fighting is relatively mild
in its intensity compared to the pounding that male chimpanzees give to each other and to females.
And nowhere is this more striking than in the relationships between communities, between these
larger social groups, where you can get, between members of neighboring communities, grooming,
sexual interactions, play, and even occasional food sharing, which was reported just a few
weeks ago from one of those sites. Now, to someone who studies chimpanzees over many years,
this is just simply unbelievable because chimpanzees are so far from having the capacity
to be tolerant towards members of neighboring groups. Toleration like an individual, Anna here,
reported by Takeshi Furuichi, after spending a year as a temporary immigrant in one group,
the E1 group, left, and then five years later, the E1 group meets the group to which Anna
had moved. And what happens? Anna comes over and meets her old friends. She apparently recognized
them as individuals, and they spent some time together, having intense social interactions.
Gigi rubbing is the sex that happens among females before the groups quietly separated.
Entirely different from anything you'd see in chimpanzees. Here's a particularly astonishing
one, a form of play that's pretty astonishing just within a group, because what happens is
that a male or a female will be playing with a juvenile that does not belong to them,
in the most interesting cases, and takes them by a foot, as you see here, and swings them about.
So this is the Michael Jackson moment in the forest. And you see, up to 40 meters above the
ground, the juvenile is totally in the power of the adult. So, you know, we'd all be sort of
quivering with alarm. But the juvenile looks happy. They allow this to happen because they trust the
to take care of them. So that happens within groups, but it also happens between groups,
where a male of one group can play with a juvenile of another group. If a chimpanzee was doing that,
we know what kind of play that would be. That would involve bites and flailing against a trunk.
And here you've got these bonobos just taking extremely relaxed attitude. It's not totally
relaxed, because when the sex goes on, the males from one group sort of look at their females
walking across and having sex with the males of the other group. And the males don't come across
and sort of, you know, get together and be friendly about it. They kind of look rather
resentful, is my understanding. But nevertheless, this is all very, very different from what we see
in chimpanzees. And there have now been sufficient decades of study to be able to say that the fact
that there have been no violent deaths seen in bonobos from other bonobos attacking and killing
them is statistically significant. That is to say that bonobos are really genuinely different in
terms of the amount of observation that's been gone on from chimpanzees in that particular measure
of aggression. So there we got chimpanzees and bonobos, two relatives so similar in body size
and, by the way, in the degree of sex difference in body size, that it took some time for scientists
to recognize that they were different species. And on the one hand, you've got all these aggressive
aspects of chimpanzee behavior. And on the other hand, with bonobos, you've got all these much more
peaceful, supportive aspects. Female alliances, females co-dominant with the males,
female choice much more important in sexual interactions, friendly intergroup interactions
with no killing. So that's the background. So obviously what we want to know is what's going on?
Why is there this remarkable difference in aggressiveness between the two species? And what
I've done here is to bring up a map that shows in red the four different subspecies of chimpanzees
in the different areas they live. And in blue, the subspecies, as it used to be, and now we call
it the species of bonobo. And the critical thing here is that the bonobos are separated from the
chimpanzees by the Congo River. So what I want to do is to sort of start thinking about the
evolutionary aspect between the relationship between bonobos and the chimpanzees. And a
feature is the age of the Congo River. People used to think it was relatively recent and that
maybe some populations had been divided so that bonobos and chimps could equally well be each
other's ancestor. But now we know that the Congo River has created a deep sea canyon opposite its
exit into the Atlantic Ocean. And people have been able to work out that that is more than 30 million
years old. And the difference between bonobos and chimpanzees is thought to be between one and
two million years. So the Congo River long predated the existence of the chimpanzees and bonobos.
And people have been able to work out that only occasionally was there a drought sufficient to
enable a crossing of the river. And I've shown here roughly where that crossing would have been,
somewhere in the northeast of the range now of the bonobos. And the genetic evidence is that
bonobos evolved from a relatively small area of the chimpanzee populations just once. It's a
monophyletic evolution so that we can reconstruct bonobos as evolving from the East African
subspecies of chimpanzees sometime either a million years ago or 1.8 million years ago to
judge from when droughts happened. And the genetic data with the uncertainty about rates of mutation
are not quite sufficient to resolve that confidently as to whether or not it was the
more recent or the more distant date. So it looks as though we've got bonobos evolving from a
chimpanzee-like ancestor. And what they did was to evolve by reducing aggression from a much more
aggressive version. The different subspecies of chimpanzees all showing that contrast to bonobos.
And I say here, does this mean that we're talking about self-domestication? Because I want to define
domestication as the evolution of reduced aggressiveness. And the evolution of reduced
aggressiveness by a species in the wild without humans being involved at all would be self-domestication.
And in order to think about this, what we have to think about of course is the domesticated animals
as a model for understanding the reduction of aggression. Now the domesticated animals are
really fascinating because we've got an experiment that's been repeated 20, 30 times in different
species, the evolution of reduced aggressiveness and domestication. In wild animals, nobody has
really thought until recently about the possibility that when you have aggression being reduced over
evolutionary time, there may be some sort of analogy to what is happening in captivity. But
there seems to be a reason for thinking that. Because in captivity, according to the great
experiments done by Dmitry Belyaev and Lyudmila Trut in Novozibirsk in Siberia since 1958,
if you select animals, whether it's foxes or rats or mink, for reduced fear and
aggression, so if you select for breeding those individuals who are least emotionally reactive,
then it turns out that you get the features of domesticated animals in addition to
a reduction in aggressiveness. Features like white patches and floppy ears and curly tails.
I wish that we could say that bonobos had ears long enough to be floppy or tails at all
or some indication of white patches. They sort of have some indication of white patches. We can
talk about that later maybe. But much more interesting is the view from archaeology.
Because the view from archaeology is, according to Helen Leach and colleagues, that there are
certain consistent ways in which it is possible to recognize when domestication has happened from
a wild ancestor. The domesticates end up with a lighter body than the wild ancestor, a shorter
face and smaller teeth, with, if there are sex differences, increasing feminization of the skull
and the skeleton, a smaller brain in the domesticated species, and some evidence of
pedomorphism, juvenile characteristics being retained into adulthood, something that's very
characteristic of dogs compared to wolves. Well, let's think now about bonobos, because
the prediction is that if bonobos have been through a biological process of reducing their
aggressiveness that is parallel to what happens in domesticated animals, then we should see these
features. And the short story is that we do. The bonobos have got a lighter body, particularly in
the males, than the females. So for a given body weight, they have literally thinner limb bones and
lighter muscle mass. They have shorter face and smaller teeth. Here what you see is a view from
above of a couple of skulls and jaws laid out on a bench, as it were, and you see the humerus,
the arm bone, and that is scaled to the same length. So you see that for a given length of
the arm bone, the chimpanzee has got the longer cranium with the longer face and also a very
slightly thicker arm bone. The skull and skeleton are also feminized. So one way you can see this
is that the canines, the fighting weapons of the bonobo, are reduced in length compared to those of
chimpanzees, and their skulls are narrower, and that is an association both with maleness
and with aggressiveness in humans and in other primates. The brain, well, you know, you can kind
of tell there's a reduction in the size of the brain just by looking at the size of the head,
you know, because here we've got a bonobo and a chimpanzee, and obviously the chimpanzee looks
as though it's got a bigger head. People sometimes have called bonobos the pygmy-headed chimpanzee,
but now if you look at the most recent publication on this, where people have been able to to work
out the relative change in size of the brain of bonobos in blue and the chimpanzees in red,
then males in particular are getting a smaller brain, females a little bit, compared to the last
common ancestor as they infer it, and certainly compared to the chimpanzees. And then the final
topic was pedomorphism, and absolutely you get pedomorphic anatomy. Harold Coolidge, who some
of you may remember, who lived in Cambridge and was long associated with Harvard, he was the man
who discovered bonobos in 1928 in the Royal Central African Museum in Tervuren in Belgium,
and he did so by pulling out a drawer of skulls and looking at a particular skull of what he
thought was a juvenile chimpanzee, and he said what clearly looked like a juvenile chimp skull
from the south of the Congo, to my amazement the sutures were totally fused. The sutures were fused.
So what that meant was that it was an adult. The juvenile characteristic, the shape of the
skull, had been retained into adulthood. That is pedomorphism. And so it was that there was
the basis for his rushing into print to try and publish that species, and nowadays people like
Dan Lieberman in our department have done careful analyses with geometric morphometric measurements
and have been able to show that the crania are indeed underdeveloped relative to those of
chimpanzees at any particular age. And that's pedomorphic anatomy, and there's a bunch of ways
in which the behavior is pedomorphic as well. This is one that's rather nice because there's
actually a little bit of data that really crystallizes it. These data are from captivity,
but what they show is for chimpanzees and bonobos how much time the offspring is spending away from
the mother, in this case more than five meters away from the mother. And what you see is that
at the age, say, of about two and a half years, the bonobo is spending about 20 percent of its time
more than five meters away from the mother, and the chimpanzee is spending more like 40 or more
five meters away from the mother. Much more independent, the bonobo is behaving more like
a juvenile of the chimpanzee. Again, it is pedomorphic. So isn't this astonishing?
We got the reduced aggressiveness of bonobos compared to chimpanzees, and in all of these ways
that archaeologists can recognize the difference between a domesticated animal and a wild animal,
bonobos show the differences. The lighter body, the shorter face, smaller teeth, the feminized skull,
the smaller brain, and the pedomorphic anatomy and behavior. Domestication is a really frustrating
area because not every species shows every feature of the domestication syndrome. You know,
I said that bonobos don't have curly tails and they don't have floppy ears. You know,
that's probably because the ears of them, like other primates, are so short that the difference
between the cartilage inside and the external part of the ear is so little that there's very
little opportunity for them to be floppy. But nevertheless, this looks as though there's a very
strong case to say that bonobos are echoing the process that happens in domestication of animals
at the hand of humans, only they're doing it in the wild. They're losing their aggressiveness,
they've become self-domesticated. So now I want to go into a little speculative
set of questions about why this might have happened. What kind of selection pressures
would have made bonobos less aggressive? And of course, what we're talking about
is those darn males. And the principle is that I want to say is that the present offers us a clue
to the past. And what I mean by that is the way in which bonobo males are controlled in terms of
their aggression nowadays can give us a clue to the way it has happened in the past. Well,
nowadays what happens is that if a male is aggressive, then he has a good chance of being
dominated by the female alliances. He is actually apparently a little bit afraid of the females.
He doesn't like to be aggressive towards the sexually active females. And maybe that is
because he has learned that he will then be disfavored. And that's all because ultimately,
he cannot impose his will through simply bullying and aggressiveness. So I like to think that what
we're talking about is the critical advantage, the critical feature of female power, of females
being able to support each other against the males. Now, then the question is, well, why is it
that bonobos do this and why don't chimps do it? You'd think that chimps would just have all sorts
of advantages as females in being able to spend a lot of time together and attack those males.
So then the question is, what is it that allows bonobos to have relatively stable parties,
parties in which you can have lots of females supporting each other? And I approach this
question from the point of view of the environment because the key features enabling animals to stay
together in groups is when feeding competition allows them the luxury of their each other's
company. And if we take the forests of the bonobos and the chimpanzees, then there's not that much
difference, apparently, between the two species. They tend to occupy areas with really rich
rainforest where they're eating a lot of fruits. These particular fruits are eaten by bonobos,
but they're very much like the type that are eaten by the chimps. However, I think a clue comes
from comparing two different parts of the diet. One is the fruit diet, and that is very much the
same between bonobos and chimpanzees. But then there is the herb diet, and it has been shown that
the quality of the herbs that are eaten by bonobos is better than the quality eaten by chimps. They
have more options, apparently. In both species, this is quite a common thing to do. If you can't
find enough fruit, often by the middle of the day, then you resort to eating leaves and stems like
these ones here. I want to explore the idea that it's because bonobos are able to eat those sorts
of things that they're able to eat and live in stable parties. And the essential underlying notion
here is that whereas fruits are clustered into isolated fruit trees where there's going to be
competition for those trees, the herbs are a continuous layer under the trees, and it's
possible for the bonobos to stay together, munching on those herbs without being pressured
to get away from each other in order to be able to feed better. Now, with that idea in mind, then
let me put this conundrum here. You've got bonobos and chimps living basically on the equator.
Bonobos on the left bank, chimpanzees on the right bank. And you would think that the growing
conditions are the same for both of those species because they have similar humidity
and temperature. So why is it that there should be some difference in ecology for the bonobos
from the chimpanzees? Well, here I think is the answer. Gorillas live only on the right bank,
and gorillas eat those herbs and compete for them. So gorillas are widely spread on the west side,
they're more narrowly spread on the east side as the humidity is declining and the herbs are
becoming less numerous. But everywhere they live, whether in mountains or in the lowlands,
they are able to survive without eating fruits at all if there are no fruits available by munching
on these herbs. And that seems to me enormously important. And it seems to me
explicable that gorillas only occur on the right bank because during periods of relative climatic
drought, the gorillas retreat up into the mountains, it seems, where there's still a
little bit of humidity sufficient to keep those herbs going. But on the left bank of the Congo
River, there are no mountains. It's all totally flat. So that during periods when the area got a
little bit drier, there wouldn't be any herbs. And if the gorillas had ever got across, they would
have gone extinct. So the speculation I have is that you've got in the area of the bonobos abundant
gorilla food, because there is all of these herbs in this nice lowland area, that allows the bonobos
to live in relatively stable groups, just like the gorillas living on those herbs live in relatively
stable groups. That enables the females to form alliances, and therefore the males ultimately
to be controlled. So the ultimate sort of notion here is that the way in which bonobos
became self-domesticated is all a result of the fact that there weren't any mountains
on the left bank of the Congo River. Well, that of course is speculative. We want some kind of
answer. I think it's the best that I've come across. Maybe there'll be other answers that
can come up. But nevertheless, it seems to me the right kind of answer, in the sense that
we can expect species to undergo sometimes selection in favour of increased aggressiveness,
and sometimes in favour of reduced aggressiveness. And the way in which we're going to understand
selection for reduced aggressiveness is best going to be seen by seeing what happens nowadays.
And nowadays, groups of females are able to control the males. And so we have to think about
how those groups of females were made possible. And there's my answer. Regardless of that sort of
fun speculation—I hope it's a fun speculation—it seems to me quite remarkable that the differences
between bonobos and chimpanzees that we have reviewed have boiled down to such similarity
between domesticated animals and their wild ancestors. The domestication syndrome is not
easy to understand except as an incidental consequence of selection against reduced
aggression. Nobody has separate explanations for all of these different features. What is truly
remarkable is that if this happened a million years ago, which is one of the possible genetic
dates, or could be earlier, then how is it that the species has not reversed? How is it that you
get these incidental consequences coming along for the ride when selection favours reduced
aggressiveness? You would think that over time the brains would have got bigger, the teeth would
have got bigger, but no. They are showing these very persistent signs of the domestication
syndrome apparently going back a million years or more. Well, I like to think the bonobos
offer us a window into a type of evolution that we don't normally think much about,
and that is a non-adaptive evolution. The fact that it is associated in the bonobo case with
incidental consequences of reduced aggressiveness is very interesting when you think about the fact
that at an evolutionary stable state where you've got thousands of different species of, say, mammals,
some of them will have had ancestors that were less aggressive than themselves,
others will have had ancestors that were more aggressive than themselves,
and every time you've got ancestors that were more aggressive than themselves,
then you've got reduced aggressiveness. I think bonobos are suggesting you would expect to see
a whole suite of incidental characteristics produced like we've seen in the bonobos.
So what about islands? Islands are totally fascinating because it's a predictable
phenomenon that you get reduced aggressiveness on islands. Back in 1885, island lizards, birds,
and mammals in high-density populations often exhibit reduced situation-specific aggression
towards conspecifics. I think islands are going to be a wonderful place to look for
evidence of these incidental non-adaptive effects. I had really fun going to Zanzibar
off the east coast of Tanzania and looking at the red colobus there compared to the red colobus that
I knew from Kibale. So here we are on the island. It's been isolated for more than half a million
years, so that's probably how old the red colobus are on Zanzibar island, and it turns out they do
indeed have lighter bodies than those on the mainland. The sexual dimorphism is reduced.
Males are becoming more female-like. Their canines are shorter, and it's already been published that
their skull is pedomorphic, and so is their coloring. If you look at these pictures, what
you see is on the left an adult from Kibale on the continent. On the right, you see an adult
from the island, and look at the facial coloration. The pink around the nose looks just like the
picture in the middle, which is the infant from the continent. It's retained that facial coloration
right into adulthood. No one has really studied the behavior of the Zanzibar red colobus enough to
know anything in detail, but Tom Strusaker has taken movies of suckling by males of adult females
who are presumed but not known to be the mothers, and that suckling happens later than known in any
other primate. It's been seen in adolescent males and actually even occasionally by adult males.
How much more pedomorphic can you get? So there are a bunch of cases, I think, where we can start
thinking that this kind of domestication-like process has happened in the wild, and one of
the areas that I'm kind of fascinated by is the possibility that there's been a hint of this in
western chimpanzees compared to the other three subspecies of chimpanzees, because in the western
chimpanzees, people have long been pointing out that although they show the characteristics that
I recounted in the first part of this talk, nevertheless, their females are more gregarious,
there seems to be less sexual coercion, and overall there is less violence, and they also
apparently have shorter crania, and we've just done some measurements of the brains of our
Kibale chimps and the brains, by comparison, of the western chimps and the brains of the
Kibale males are bigger than those of the ones in the west. So it's just a hint that maybe again
we're going to see some version of the domestication syndrome even among the chimps.
So I think we see some kind of self-domestication in humans, we see it in our two closest relatives,
and when one of those relatives, maybe we see it in the subspecies. This could be quite a common
phenomenon. The second reason that I think that it's fun to think about this self-domestication
in the case of bonobos is to emphasize the fact that ever since Darwin, much of the fight has been
can we really explain features as being adaptive? And what we're seeing here is that with that
fight largely won, that most features of animal species, including humans, can be thought of as
adaptive. Nevertheless, there may be systematic ways in which incidental non-adaptive effects
are produced. Now explaining why that happens, I haven't touched that, you may have noticed,
and for those of you who have looked at this area at all, you may know that one idea is that when
there is selection for a reduction in aggressiveness, then what that initiates is a series of very early
changes in the developing embryo affecting a tissue called the neural crest cells, and that
that has a whole series of incidental consequences that are very difficult to separate from just the
effects on aggression, and those consequences seem to be very well lined up with what we see
in the domestication syndrome. People are starting to test that idea quite well in domesticated
animals. It's going to be fun to look at wild animals that have got the domestication syndrome
and see if we can elaborate that same idea. And then the third aspect is can we get a
bonobo perspective on human evolution? From time to time, some people have suggested that
bonobos might serve as a nice model for an ancestor of human evolution.
Well, I think that the evidence increasingly suggests that's wrong. It's a nice idea because
in many ways bonobos have more attractive features than chimpanzees do. But nevertheless,
even if it turns out that we are descended from an ancestor that is more chimpanzee-like than
bonobo-like, what bonobos offer is another case of the self-domestication, because
that same syndrome that we saw exhibited by bonobos compared to chimpanzees, it's a syndrome
that we see in modern humans in terms of their skeletal material compared to our ancestors
some 300,000 years ago. So it looks to me as though bonobos and humans converged
on pacifism, converged on our, in the human case, the one angle of our pacifism, namely
the reduction in reactive aggression associated with ordinary day-to-day encounters with our
friends and neighbors. And again, I would think that the present is a clue to the past, and if
we look at small-scale societies, what we see is that if a man, as sometimes happens, is sufficiently
aggressive and sufficiently willing to bully others and sufficiently willing to go against
all the societal norms just to punch his way out of any kind of social conflict and take
people's meat and take people's wives, then what happens ultimately is that he is liable to be
executed, and that's very much why that is a clue to how it happened in the distant past.
So what I've suggested is that self-domestication in bonobos is a kind of model for selection
against aggression in animals in general, with its source of non-adaptive effects. I think that
it's going to be really exciting to use bonobos and other species to help explain the mechanisms
underlying domestication, because it's such a different kind of system, and then ultimately
to help think about the processes that led to evolution of ourselves. So the talk I've given
is based on all sorts of work that many different people have helped me with and given me all
sorts of ideas and supported me. They are the sort of female allies, as it were, if I was a
bonobo. I want to draw attention to two particular people here, Isaac Schamberg, who's in the audience,
and Martin Serbeck, because they are people who have done the long years in the field studying
bonobos. Isaac is here as a college fellow in the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology,
and Martin is arriving in the fall. He is, I think many people would say, the person who is pushing
the scientific study of bonobos in the wild faster and further than anybody else at the moment.
So he's coming as an assistant professor, and he's going to be a great person to have around.
So many thanks to all, and thanks to bonobos for offering a wonderful model. Thank you.

