Understanding Warfare: An Evolutionary Approach
3 Video Views·Nov 8, 2022
I am pleased to welcome Michael Wilson, Associate Professor in the Departments of Anthropology
and Ecology, Evolution and Behavior at the University of Minnesota.
As an evolutionary anthropologist, he studies the behavior of biology of chimpanzees.
His research on our closest living relatives reveals fascinating insights into our evolutionary
past.
His main focus is on intergroup relations, as you will hear, and his specialties include
warfare, human evolution, ecology, and evolution of social behavior and communication.
He received his B.A. in Biological Sciences from the University of Chicago, and obtained
his Ph.D. here at Harvard.
He has held numerous other prestigious academic appointments, including Associate Director
of the Jane Goodall Institute's Center for Primate Studies at the University of Minnesota,
and the Director of Field Research at the Gombe Stream Research Center in Tanzania.
He has also published widely in his work, and has served as an editor for a host of
academic journals, including the American Journal of Physical Anthropology, American
Journal of Primatology, Behavioral Ecology, and Proceedings of the National Academy of
Sciences.
He was an editor of that journal, but he articles in that journal.
His work has been featured broadly in the public sphere as well, through interviews
with a wide range of outlets, such as National Public Radio, Scientific News, Scientific
American, Nature, and so forth.
He's also got a blog called Monkey Business, offering thoughts on people, primates, and
evolution, and covering a range of topics in conversation, conservation, how conservation
could work, economics and language, and communication.
So I'm looking forward to this talk.
I hope you are too.
Please welcome.
Thank you.
Thank you for that introduction, and thank you for the invitation to speak here, and
thank all of you for coming out tonight on this beautiful spring evening to hear me talk
about primates killing each other.
So this painting, from the end of the Trojan War, illustrates the efforts that people have
made over the millennia to attempt to understand why people go to war.
The ancient Greeks had their hypotheses for why people went to war, and specifically,
the Trojan War was caused by this event, illustrated here, where Paris, the fellow there with the
red robe, is judging a beauty contest among the goddesses.
Because of a wedding invitation that was not issued to the goddess of discord, she threw
an apple into the wedding of the people who would become the parents of the Greek warrior
Achilles, and the apple was addressed to the most beautiful, to the fairest.
And these three goddesses argued about which of them should get the apple, and so Paris
was chosen as an objective person to choose which of the goddesses was most beautiful.
They each chose a bribe to influence his decision, and the winning bribe was the love of the
most beautiful woman in the world, which had the complication that she was already married
to someone else, and this led to a ten-year-long siege of the city of Troy, according to these
stories.
So the Greeks believed that war was something that happens to humans because of the gods.
The gods have their disputes, and we get caught up in them and die horribly as a result of
these divine actions.
Around the same time that the siege of Troy is thought to have taken place is the conventional
dating for the fall of Jericho, which is described in the book of Joshua.
This illustrates another hypothesis for the origin of war, or the cause of war.
In this case, God told his chosen people to invade this land and take over the cities
within it and kill the people in each of the cities.
So that's another hypothesis for the origins of those specific wars.
For most of human history, this has been the understanding that warfare is something that
we do because the gods are somehow causing us to go out and kill each other.
In Western political philosophy, really the first person to develop a secular hypothesis
for the origins of warfare was Thomas Hobbes.
Hobbes was inspired by Euclid, the Greek mathematician, and he was inspired by Galileo.
He sought to explain humans through natural philosophy without recourse to supernatural
explanations.
He attempted to explain society from first principles.
He thought very hard about what would life be like in a world in which there was no government,
no laws, no source of order.
He describes this attempt to explain human society from first principles in his book
The Leviathan.
His conclusion was that in such a situation, you end up with a war of all against all.
Hobbes is usually thought of as being this very pessimistic person who saw life as nasty,
poor, brutish, and short.
Focusing on warfare is something that people were engaged in constantly, but by war of
all against all, he's not really imagining battle lines.
He's imagining families defending what little they have against other families who are trying
to grab what they can as well.
Hobbes has ever since been seen as someone to argue against, especially famously by Jean
Jacques Rousseau, who was a French political philosopher originally from Switzerland.
In his discourse on the origin of inequality, he takes issue with Hobbes and Hobbes' imagined
view of the origin of human society.
He presents his own imagined view of human society, in which he argues that in the state
of nature, people didn't live in families, they lived independently, they hardly recognized
each other as individuals, men and women just met to have sex with each other, and life
was free and peaceful and happy.
He argued that this was the way things were, and that warfare was something that developed
more recently as the result of property and other cultural inventions that people came
up with and ruined things.
These two philosophers, to this day, form the competing or opposing poles of debate
in thinking about warfare, but they were working at a time when they didn't have much empirical
evidence to really dispute one another.
How do you test these claims?
Did we live as solitary individuals or did we live in small family groups?
Really the basic underpinnings of why people do what they do were not at all clear.
The person who we owe a lot to in terms of shedding light on why people do the things
that they do, as well as why other animals do the things that they do, is of course Darwin.
Darwin introduced, really for the first time, a scientific foundation for understanding
human behavior, because Darwin was the first person to really provide a compelling reason
for why humans behave the way they do.
What is the meaning of life as it were?
Of course the answer is to make copies of our genes.
That's what we're here for.
Now of course Darwin didn't state it that way.
Genes hadn't yet been discovered, and of course that's an oversimplification, but from an
evolutionary perspective, the introduction of these ideas from Darwin finally provided
a basis for really thinking in a common currency about what effect human behaviors have on
fitness, and how likely they are to evolve.
Darwin argued quite simply that traits that help people to make more copies of their genes
– again I'm speaking a little anachronistically because Darwin didn't know about genes – but
they became, those traits that help people to survive and reproduce become more common
in the population.
Darwin introduced a number of tools that have been indispensable for thinking about the
evolution of traits, including warfare.
This includes the comparative method in which Darwin was the first to recognize that we
are all part of a family tree, we're all members of the tree of life, and in order
to understand any particular branch of the tree of life, you really need to look at the
other branches and how they interrelate with one another.
Looking at this tree, once you understand that we are all part of a big family, you
can see that closely related species often have similar traits, and you can understand
the traits of a given species better, understanding the context in the family tree, and also sometimes
there are differences.
Closely related species differ in interesting ways, and distantly related species are similar
in interesting ways.
Looking at these using the comparative method helps show that similar problems can be solved
in similar ways through evolution, even among quite distantly related lineages.
This is really the foundation for what I'll be talking about today, using the comparative
method, especially focusing on one of the two living species that is most closely related
to us, the chimpanzee.
In talking about warfare, I realize that I'm getting into a very contentious subject.
People have been fighting about warfare for a long time, and these debates are very heated.
People argue with a lot of emotional investment about the answers to these questions, such
as, is warfare evolutionarily ancient, like Hobbes would argue, or recent, like Rousseau
would argue?
Why do people kill their enemies rather than merely chasing them away?
Seems inefficient, a waste of effort.
How can risking one's life in war increase fitness, which depends on surviving and reproducing?
How can risking your life increase your fitness?
Is warfare something that will always be with us, or is it something that might one day
go away?
People argue a lot about these.
This raises questions about why this debate is so heated.
I think at least part of the answer is that when people make an argument, people listening
to them often hear some other argument being made.
People have so much invested in this issue emotionally that they may misinterpret or
over-interpret what's being said.
I think of this often in terms of my own experience when my son was born.
I was a graduate student here at Harvard.
I told some of my friends that I was so impressed at the rate at which my son was growing that
my wife must be producing elephant seal milk.
By that I meant, he's growing so fast, he must be getting really good nutrients.
This is really good stuff that she's producing.
This is what I pictured in my mind.
A cute little baby elephant seal next to its mom who's taking such good care of it.
I only found out recently that all these years what my wife thought I was saying was,
my wife is like an elephant seal, which is not at all what I meant.
Tonight I want to make clear first some things that I don't mean to say and what I don't
think the chimpanzee data that I look at and analyze can say.
I don't mean to say that war is good.
I don't like war.
I don't mean to say that war is inevitable, that we have some instinct for always producing
warfare kind of invariably regardless of what the context is.
I also don't mean to say that war is natural and therefore excusable, that if warfare has
an evolutionary history that somehow means that it's okay, go ahead and make war.
I don't mean to say that war is the product of one or a few simple genetic changes.
I also don't mean to say that war is the result of genes that are only present in certain
individuals or ethnicities.
I think of warfare as the product of our common evolutionary heritage, something that we all
have within us.
This isn't what I mean to say, any of this.
I also think that as fascinating as studies of chimpanzees are, chimpanzee studies by
themselves can't tell us a lot of things about human warfare.
The chimpanzee data alone can't tell us important things about the past.
For example, how long has warfare occurred in the human lineage?
Just because chimpanzees have war or something like it doesn't necessarily mean that it's
always been present in the lineage leading to humans as well.
Looking at the chimpanzee data alone I don't think can tell us whether warfare was frequent
or rare for the human ancestors, we need to look at human data as well as that.
Looking at the present, chimpanzee data don't tell us why war occurs in specific instances.
We need to look at those specific instances that have historical contexts.
Looking at the future, just looking at chimpanzees doesn't tell us whether warfare can be reduced
or eliminated.
I think that definitive answers to all of these questions about human warfare require
studies of human warfare.
I'll talk a little bit about some of those studies, but I'm mainly going to be talking
about chimpanzees.
After listing all those things that I don't think the chimpanzee data alone can tell us,
I do think nonetheless that the chimpanzee data can tell us, or at least point to some
very interesting possible answers to these questions.
I don't claim to have all the answers, but I think that the data that we have been able
to put together tells us some interesting things.
The first of these that I'm going to look at is this question of whether warfare is
evolutionarily ancient or recent.
This is a photo that David Bygott took in September of 1971.
It's the first really clearly documented case of an intergroup killing in chimpanzees.
This was taken at Gombe National Park in Tanzania, where Jane Goodall had been studying chimpanzees
since 1960.
When Jane first arrived in Gombe, she had a very strong impression that chimpanzees
were basically peaceful.
She didn't even believe at first that they had clear boundaries to their groups.
They seemed to come and go and intermingle with many different subgroups and get along
well with one another.
It was only 11 years into the study that clear evidence to the contrary really started to
emerge.
In this case, males from the main study community attacked, killed, and partially ate this infant
from an unfamiliar female.
Since then, other intergroup killings were seen at Gombe.
This raised many provocative questions about the evolutionary history of warfare.
To put this in context, this is our family tree as we currently understand it.
The dates in millions of years ago are on the left there.
Those are approximate dates.
We have pretty wide confidence intervals on all those dates.
We do know that of the living apes, the living African apes include humans.
We are an ape.
Our closest cousins are chimpanzees and bonobos, those two species.
Our more distant cousin is gorillas.
We're more closely related to chimpanzees than chimpanzees are to gorillas.
We have fossil evidence from a number of earlier species of human.
We know that at least going back four million years, a bit more, there were bipedal apes
that roamed the woodlands of eastern and southern Africa.
We can infer a little bit about their behavior.
There are some things that using the comparative method, we can get some clues about what might
have been the common behavior of our last common ancestor.
They're called panprior, the name that Richard Wrangham has proposed for the species that
no one has discovered yet.
There are some things that the living apes in this group, humans, bonobos, and chimpanzees
share in common.
We all have pretty high quality diets.
Chimpanzees rely on ripe fruit.
Humans rely on fruit and meat and other things that are pretty easy to digest.
We have fission-fusion dynamics, which means that unlike a baboon troop, for example, we
don't all spend all of our time together with just the same social group instead.
We fission apart into little subgroups, we fuse back together.
In chimpanzees and bonobos and many though, by no means all, human groups, males tend
to stay in the group that they're born in and females tend to move to a different group
when they reach maturity.
There are some things that chimpanzees and humans have in common that they don't have
in common with bonobos, like tool use.
Chimpanzees use lots of tools, so do humans.
Bonobos hardly ever use tools in the wild, and hunting is something that chimpanzees
and humans do.
Perhaps this is something our common ancestors shared and was lost in bonobos for some reason.
We don't really know for sure.
Another trait that's like this is coalitionary killing, where we know that humans do this.
We call it warfare.
We know that chimpanzees do this, and we know that bonobos don't do this.
Is this something that we share from a common ancestor from panprior that was then lost
in bonobos, or has this evolved separately in humans and chimpanzees?
We don't know.
That's a hard question to answer.
What we can do is look at comparative data to see whether the things that cause coalitionary
killing in chimpanzees and humans are similar.
We can also look at whether the rates of killing are similar in these two species.
People have argued either way.
Some people have argued that chimpanzees are not as nasty to each other as humans, and
that humans have a long history of much fiercer intergroup relations and more killing.
Other people have argued that humans actually only recently became so warlike, and that
the very warlike behavior of chimpanzees' violence is something that disappeared at
some stage with these woodland apes.
It's really only in the past 10 years or so that enough data have come together from different
sources to start answering some of these questions of, do chimpanzees and humans in non-state
societies kill each other at similar rates?
It turns out that the estimates that we've been able to come up with are really strikingly
similar.
These are chimpanzee data from several long-term study sites on the left, and some data from
foragers, hunter-gatherers, and forager horticulturalists in the Amazon from a recent paper.
In blue are killings that have occurred within group, and in red are killings that have occurred
between groups.
When you add these together, humans and chimpanzees both face about a 12% risk of dying from violence
in these societies.
In both cases, there's a bit more within-group violence, within-group killing, than between-group
killing.
If we compare those rates to our own societies or state-level societies in general, we see
a striking contrast.
Those of you who have read Steven Pinker's book, The Better Angels of Our Nature, will
be very familiar with these data and this contrast.
In state societies, even in ancient Mexico, which has a reputation as being a very warlike
society, the percent of deaths from violence in the archaeological record are closer to
5%, so less than half of what they are in these non-state societies and in chimpanzee
societies.
In other, more recent states, the rates of death from violence are very low.
Even in the 20th century, which is often thought of as the most warlike century in history,
because people killed each other on such a horrific and massive scale during the two
world wars and various genocides that have occurred, this figure shows the estimates
of deaths from war worldwide during the four quarters of the 20th century.
In the quarter 1925 to 1950, with World War II right in the middle of that, the percent
of deaths worldwide from warfare is still a lot less than what we would see in a chimpanzee
society or in many non-state human societies.
Going back to this question of whether warfare is evolutionarily ancient or recent, we see
that hunter-gatherers, the people living in the sorts of societies that we spent most
of our evolutionary history living in, and chimpanzees have similar rates of killing,
both between and within groups.
People have argued in a very common argument in archaeology and anthropology, the argument
that Rousseau makes, is that we need these special human things like property or agriculture
or settled, sedentary societies, projectile weapons.
These are all special things that humans have that cause war, but chimpanzees don't have
any of those.
This at least supports the idea that coalitionary killing is something that could date as far
back as the common ancestor with chimpanzees and humans.
When people talk about warfare as an invention, which is something that Margaret Mead did
in 1940, she argued that warfare is something that people have invented.
It's a cultural construct, and archaeologists often point to things like the fortifications
that we see around ancient walled cities like Babylon.
They say, this is the beginning of warfare.
When we see people erecting walls around their cities, that's when we know that warfare has
really gotten serious.
Before then, people were just fighting, and it didn't make such a big deal.
What I think is going on there is that actually what we see with those fortifications is the
invention of peace, and that before people were able to build walls around their cities,
they were living in a much more vulnerable world, a world much more like what chimpanzees
live in and what hunter-gatherers live in, where you don't have a safe place.
When people finally develop the technology and material luxury to be able to build these
fortifications, that's when we see a place where at least some people, once you're inside
the city walls, you're safe.
It's outside those walls that people are vulnerable, as chimpanzees always are, and as most people
have been through the course of human evolution.
The next question I want to address is, why do people kill their enemies rather than merely
chasing them away?
It's a real puzzle, and it's something that's unusual about humans and chimpanzees.
There are lots of species that have aggression between groups.
They defend territories, they fight with each other, but in most of those species it's enough
to chase them away.
If a troop of baboons meet and fight over a waterhole or a fruit tree, one troop will
run away, the other troop will stay put and get to use the resource.
They don't kill each other, and that's much more common in animals.
Why go to all the trouble of actually killing your rivals instead of just chasing them off?
People have proposed various hypotheses for this.
One hypothesis that I think has become very popular among anthropologists is that it's
because of human impacts that these killings occur.
Jane Goodall, when she first started at Gombe, early on in her study she started feeding
the chimpanzees bananas.
Some people have argued that feeding the bananas somehow caused them to become more violent
and to do things they wouldn't otherwise.
More recently, this is an aerial photo of Gombe from about 10 years ago.
You can see where the park is.
It's very green and lush.
The back side of the park, outside of the park boundary, is quite barren.
People have cleared the forest for cassava fields and their farms.
The habitat that's available to chimpanzees is shrinking.
People have argued also, maybe it's a result of habitat loss, that the chimpanzees are
facing more stress.
They're competing for fewer available resources.
Maybe it's something to do with that.
It is the case that we've seen killings at sites that don't have either of these impacts.
This is a male chimpanzee who was killed in Kibale National Park, where chimpanzees have
never been fed bananas.
It's a nice big park without much habitat loss within this really huge area.
Here's another male who was killed in Uganda, in a different community, on Kalinzu, where
they've never fed them bananas.
This is a male chimpanzee who was killed in Fongole in West Africa, a site where the chimpanzees
have not been artificially fed, and they range over a very wide area.
At least anecdotally, many of us who have been studying chimpanzees have thought, well,
it's probably not human impacts that's causing this killing, but we want to know for sure.
I worked with the leaders of all of the long-term chimpanzee study sites, and also the Bonobo
study sites, to analyze the data, all the data that exists on killings at these sites.
We ran some statistical models that found that the measures of human impacts that we
had, such as whether banana feeding occurred, had no impact on rates of killing.
Instead, the rates of killing depended very much on the number of adult males in the group
and the population density.
Just to explain this figure a little, there's a bar for every one of the communities in
the study.
The ones that are labeled with B are Bonobos, and the ones that are labeled with E are Eastern
chimpanzees.
The W's are Western chimpanzees, and the P stands for provisioning.
These are the groups that have a history of being fed by researchers.
We see that the groups with the highest rate of killings per year are not the ones with
P's, but here we have Ngogo, the largest chimpanzee community that's ever been documented, something
like 200 individuals, and they have the highest rate of killing.
They have lots of adult males, and when they meet the neighbors, they can kill them pretty
easily.
It's not human impacts that's causing these killings.
Instead, what is a better supported hypothesis is the imbalance of power hypothesis that
Richard Wrangham developed.
I've really spent much of the past couple of decades testing this hypothesis, testing
various predictions of it.
This is a hypothesis that focuses on the costs of killing as well as the benefits.
From the perspective of a chimpanzee, there can be any number of benefits to killing.
You can get more stuff, basically, by killing your neighbors.
You can get their stuff.
But the costs of doing so really vary depending on how many chimpanzees are on each side of
the conflict, and the cost of killing is going to be lower when your side has more guys than
the other side.
Just as a cartoon to illustrate this, here we have two territories, a red territory and
a blue territory.
They each have 10 males illustrated here as squares.
For ecological reasons, these chimpanzees travel in parties of varying size.
The blue community doesn't have very much food right now, so they're traveling in small
groups of twos or even off by themselves, whereas the red community has enough food
that they're able to stay together all day, and so they go on a border patrol to the edge
of their territory where they find this blue male, surround him, and kill him.
Now there are fewer blue males, and as a result, they are less able to defend their territory,
and red is able to expand the territory.
That's a cartoon of the hypothesis.
There are various predictions from this that we can test, and I've been trying to test
these predictions.
One is that because these imbalances of power are so important, you should avoid going to
the periphery of your range unless you've got a lot of buddies with you, unless you're
in a party with many males, you shouldn't go to the edge of your range.
But if you do have more males, then you should be more likely to fight, more likely to win,
and more likely to kill, and as a result, winners should gain more territory.
In testing these predictions in Uganda, studying the Kanyawara community, we found that when
they go to the periphery of their range, they have about twice as many males as when parties
stay in the core of their territory all day long.
I did a series of playback experiments with these chimpanzees where we hid a single speaker
about 300 meters away from parties of varying size in the listening community.
We had two teams for these experiments.
In one team, there would be people actually watching the chimpanzees and recording what
they were doing.
The other team would be at the site of the speaker.
As soon as we did the playback, a single stranger's call, we'd pack up the speaker and take it
away.
One of us, often me, would stay at the speaker's site and see what happened.
What happened was that if we played the call to parties with just females, then the females
stayed very quiet.
They looked nervous.
If they climbed down from the trees, they would move away from the speaker.
When we played this call to parties with one or two males, they also stayed quiet, but
in about half the cases, they would climb down from their trees and cautiously approach
the speaker.
In cases where there were three males or more in the listening party, they gave a very loud
vocal response right away, and they moved very rapidly towards the speaker.
When I would be there waiting at the speaker's site, I remember hearing footsteps coming
towards me and looking and seeing a line of males with their hair out, looking very excited,
looking for an enemy.
When they saw me, they knew who I was.
I wasn't very interesting to them, and so they moved on looking for this enemy chimpanzee
that we had invented.
These experimental results, we've since been able to confirm with analysis of 15 years
of actual intergroup encounters over time.
We found a very similar pattern in that the probability of giving a vocal response and
the probability of actually approaching the calls of strangers increases as the number
of males in the party increases.
There's this context-dependent response.
Looking at the patterns of killing from these data from all the long-term chimpanzee study
sites, we found a total of 99 killings that were quite well-documented.
Most of these killings were done by groups of males.
Most of the attackers were males.
Most of the victims were male.
The majority of the killings were intergroup.
They were mainly killing males from other groups.
This includes babies as well as adults.
In fact, the majority of the killings were of infants.
But these killings between groups happened during cases of overwhelming numerical superiority.
The average ratio of attackers to defenders was 8 to 1 in these intergroup killings.
As a result of these successful killings, chimpanzees are able to enlarge their range.
We see in Gombe National Park, the main study community has a larger territory where they
have more males.
To summarize, why do people kill their enemies rather than merely chase them away?
Well, insofar as people are similar to chimpanzees and that we also have fission-fusion societies
and coalitions of males who defend group territories, the particular grouping patterns that we have
make it possible to kill at low cost to the attackers.
This next question, how can risking one's life in war increase fitness, is a very big
one and I'm just going to touch on it with a few pieces of data.
But in general, warfare presents a puzzle for evolutionary thinking.
This was something that Darwin worried about back in 1871.
It's something that people still worry about because if the whole point of evolution is
maximizing your fitness, in other words surviving long enough to reproduce and making as many
babies as you can, then why on earth would you put your life on the line?
Why would you go into battle and risk your life?
That seems like a crazy thing to do.
Part of the reason why this seems crazy is because these sorts of battles that we're
most familiar with really are crazy.
They're the battles of huge state-level conflict, the battles of World War I and World War II.
It's really crazy to be involved in those.
People don't do it willingly.
They do it with a gun at their back from their officer and fear of court-martial and imprisonment.
It's really, really terrifying to be involved in these battles, at least that's what all
the people who write home about them say in the various novels that we have from these
battles.
Those battles are probably quite different from the battles that we evolved to fight.
If we read the data on, read descriptions of what warfare is like in hunter-gatherer
societies, it's much more like what we see in chimpanzees, where there's this preference
for low-cost attacks.
When chimpanzees meet in a big group, chimpanzees from another group, they chase each other
around and yell at each other and shout at each other, but that's not where the killing
occurs.
The killing occurs in these ambushes and gang attacks.
In non-state human societies, it's very much the same thing.
The encounters between big groups on both sides tend not to be very lethal.
What is deadly are the surprise attacks, the raids, and the ambushes, where the attackers
have the advantages of numbers and surprise.
One of the ways in which attackers gain fitness benefits is through resource competition and
by more effectively obtaining resources.
This is a chimpanzee in a food tree.
He's very excited.
If you look in his nether regions, you can see a typical male chimpanzee response to
a feeding excitement.
Chimpanzees spend most of the day looking for food.
That's mainly what they do.
That's the main business of chimpanzees.
It turns out that intergroup encounters occur most often when chimpanzees are looking for
food in border regions.
For example, here's a map of the territory of the Kanyawara community that I studied
in Uganda.
These red dots are the locations of a certain kind of tree, uveriopsis, which is much more
common in the south.
At Kanyawara, most of the intergroup encounters that occur, shown by these dots, are in the
same area and they occur at the same time of year that uveriopsis is fruiting.
These abundant resources at the range edge draw chimpanzees from both sides to compete
over them.
Ann Pusey and her team working at Gombe National Park have found that when the territory size
is larger, chimpanzees actually weigh more, so it looks like they're getting more food.
As a result of having more food, females have shorter interbirth intervals.
They're able to produce babies more quickly.
In chimpanzees, this whole business of territory defense and intergroup killing seems to be
a male reproductive strategy to acquire a maximum territory size so that you have more
food for yourself, for your mates, and your offspring.
It's kind of a male parental care strategy, sort of.
We see similar things in human societies, although the data for human societies relating
fitness to warfare are very scarce.
These are very hard data to come by.
One of the very few data sets that anyone has accumulated has recently been collected
by Luke Glowecki, who's a graduate student just finishing up here at Harvard.
Luke has been working with the Nyangatom cattle herders in Ethiopia.
What he's found is that among the Nyangatom, like many other cattle herders, cattle raiding
is common.
Cattle are an easily stealable resource because they come with their own transport system.
Cattle are essential.
Cattle are the wealth in the society.
Young men need to acquire a certain number of cattle in order to pay the bride wealth
that they need to get married.
There's a direct link between the number of cattle that you can acquire and whether you're
going to have any reproductive success whatsoever.
What Luke has found is that men who raid frequently, which we see we have the non-prolific and
the more prolific raiders, they have more wives.
There's an indication for fitness payoffs in the society, where you can acquire more
wives by raiding more cattle.
To summarize this, how can risking one's life in war increase your fitness?
Something I didn't really discuss is that you can help your kin, help your inclusive
fitness, but most importantly, most fighters avoid risking their lives, if possible.
They avoid risky conflict, and the risks that they do take can pay off in chimpanzees
by increasing territory size, and in chimpanzees and humans by increasing access to other resources,
whether it's fruit or cattle.
So finally, I will look briefly at this question of, will warfare always be with us?
Those of you who've been following Steven Pinker's work will know that the answer is
maybe not.
This is a graph that shows the number of deaths from warfare for different regions for the
time since World War II.
When we read the newspapers, we see all kinds of warfare.
There's warfare in Iraq and Syria and Ukraine, and we get this impression that the world
is a very dangerous place, but if you actually count up the number of deaths, they go up
and down a lot over time, but there's a general decreasing trend.
Even in the past 10 years, the number of deaths from war, even though our country has been
directly involved in wars throughout this whole time, the number of deaths is quite
small.
So, in answer to this question, will warfare always be with us?
Maybe not.
I think it's something we can be hopeful about because of this decline in rates of death
that's happening worldwide.
Of course, we can't be sure.
A thermonuclear war could break out any minute, it's possible, and that would increase the
rates of death from warfare since we still have lots of nuclear weapons, but there are
multiple factors that are working together that all together seem to be decreasing the
likelihood of war.
This includes various things that increase the costs of war.
Nuclear weapons may be an important one of those, but also things like missiles and airplanes
that make the massed armies fighting in trenches of World War I and II not really feasible
anymore when you can use your satellites to find out exactly where those armies are and
eliminate them.
But there's also another way that costs have increased is that there are international
organizations like the United Nations that will punish perpetrators of war, and this
is really led by the American Leviathan, which is playing a role somewhat like what
Thomas Hobbes envisioned for the state, the government of a particular country.
The United States, in certain ways, does this for the globe.
At the same time, the benefits of war are relatively in decline compared to other less
risky ways of getting resources.
So generally speaking, the resources that people need for their reproductive success
are a lot easier to obtain by getting a good job and going to work on a regular basis and
not going off and killing people.
That's a really risky strategy to acquire resources.
So the take-home messages that I have for all of this are, first of all, several lines
of evidence suggest that warfare does have deep roots in human evolution.
It's something we share in common, and while it's very similar in humans and chimpanzees
in many ways, it suggests it's an inheritance from our common ancestor.
If rates of death from warfare and intergroup aggression more generally have been as high
throughout human evolution as they are in chimpanzees and in hunter-gatherer societies
living today, then warfare is likely an important source of selection pressure, shaping our
biology and our cultural evolution.
Warfare continues to be a very important source of evolutionary pressure.
Just look at how rapidly airplanes went from being something that barely existed just 100
years ago to very rapidly becoming weapons of war and destruction.
But at the same time, warfare is not inevitable.
We see this in chimpanzees.
Chimpanzees are sensitive to the costs and benefits of warfare.
They don't go out killing each other all the time.
They pay attention to the context, and so do people.
People are sensitive to the costs and benefits of warfare.
As those costs and benefits change, the benefits have decreased relative to other strategies
like trade and generally being peaceful.
As a consequence, warfare has declined.
I would like to acknowledge the many people who have been essential for the sort of work
that I've been doing over the years, including the many collaborators.
These are all of the people who are involved in the long-term chimpanzee and bonobo comparison
that I've described.
Most importantly, I'd like to thank the field assistants.
These are just some of the field assistants at Gombe.
There are people like these men and women at other sites across Africa who have been
working very hard for many years to follow chimpanzees and bonobos around, recording
everything that they do.
I wouldn't be able to tell you anything about chimpanzee behavior without them.
Thank you very much.

