Mike Simonsen on the housing market trends to watch this year

DollarHomes
3 followers
Jan 14, 2025 #homeprojects #business
#homeprojects
#business
On today’s episode, Editor in Chief Sarah Wheeler talks with Mike Simonsen, president of Altos Research, about the two big housing market trends to watch in 2025.
Welcome everyone.
My guest today is Mike Simonson,
President of Altos Research,
to talk about the two big housing market trends
to watch in 2025.
Mike, welcome back to the podcast.
Always good to be here, Sarah.
Great to have you on,
especially as we're starting 2025
and you are watching this housing market
coming up very closely.
And so I really wanted to talk about
an article that you wrote in December,
at the end of December,
about the two big housing market trends
to watch in 2025.
And those two are affordability and sellers in the market.
So let's jump in and talk about affordability.
Yeah, well, so I mean,
it's no secret that we have an affordability crisis
in the country.
Home prices went way up compared to incomes,
especially during the pandemic,
but really over the last 15 years.
And even when sales,
the demand came way down,
mortgage rates went up,
home prices didn't come down.
So now we have a double whammy on affordability.
We have home prices that went up
and we have the cost of money that went up.
So mortgage rates went up.
And so, and as we roll into January here,
there's no sign of that subsiding really anywhere.
You know, there are a few markets,
maybe more than a few that are,
have a, you know,
especially across the South Texas, Florida,
some of the Sunbelt markets
that have a lot more inventory,
like inventory really built as demand fell
over the last couple of years.
And so home prices are flat or they're down.
Some of them are down.
You can, and depending on how you measure them,
you know, there are home prices,
some markets haven't even found the bottom yet,
like still declining.
So there are some parts of the country
where home prices are down,
but they're not down 30% or something
to get them back to affordable.
And in those markets, you know,
especially if you're looking at the Florida markets,
we have the additional costs of things like insurance costs.
So affordability gets a triple whammy
in some of those places.
So as we look at 2025, you know,
there's no sign of that really abating in any dramatic way.
And that is, that will, you know,
be a cloud over the housing market for the whole year.
Yeah, it's just crazy.
At the same time, we've seen some, you know,
we've seen some signs that demand is picking up.
So I think that that's interesting.
Also, I mean, one of the things you pointed out
in your article is that we are
at the highest mortgage payment for homebuyers
starting this year at the highest ever,
which is surprising to me.
Yeah, so mortgage payments are a function
of the cost of the house and the cost of the mortgage.
And so, you know, when we have,
mortgage rates have surged back over 7%.
And there have been moments in the past two years
when they were like seven and a half or almost 8%.
But 7% at the beginning,
over 7% at the beginning of the year is significantly higher.
It's at the high end of the range
that we've been at for the last three years.
And the median price of homes is up 4% over a year ago.
And so the payments that we're making are at their highest.
And so like affordability as measured by payments,
you know, can get better during the year
if mortgage rates fall back down into the 60s.
That's great.
We saw last, we saw in the September, October time
when mortgage rates came down close to six,
that for just momentarily that stirred demand.
It was suddenly payments were 10 or 12 or 15% more cheaper
than they had been just months earlier.
What do you see when you look at the other data
that shows you that affordability is getting hit?
What are the other metrics that you see?
Is it like a time to sell a house or what does it look like?
Well, it's really, you can see it in the demand metrics.
So, you know, so for example,
as mortgage rates most of last year
were in the upper sixes or over seven,
we didn't see any demand pickup.
Even as rates eased down to about six and a half percent,
there was real no, the needle didn't move
in terms of people are like getting ready to buy the house.
But when it got closer to 6%,
suddenly there were a few more people
we could see transaction volume pickup.
You know, overall, we can see the time on market is slower.
It's about 20% more days,
20% longer to sell a house now than a year ago.
And that was obviously longer than the year before that.
So the time to sell homes is climbing.
So all of those are the demand,
the big demand metrics that you can,
we can track across, you know, a bunch of areas.
Well, let's see about, let's talk about inventory
because that has such a, that has such an effect.
And that's actually a better story this year
than we've seen in the last couple of years,
but maybe for the reasons that you're talking about,
not for great reasons.
Yeah, so inventory is really the expression
of the other trend for 2025,
which is, are we finally seeing
more sellers entering the market?
And, you know, we track,
you can track supply by the total number of homes
on the market, those are, that's active inventory,
but you can also track it by the new listings each week,
how many new sellers are entering the market.
And so inventory can build if we have very few sellers,
but even fewer buyers, inventory will build.
So this, so, and in the post-pandemic era,
the defining characteristic has been
how few people wanna sell their house.
We've got cheap mortgages, we've got,
we're not changing jobs, we're not moving,
we're like staying here, I'm not selling my house.
I'm not, and so very few new listings each week.
And you and Logan talk about the new listings data
all the time, it's been very low,
but in 24, it's been climbing,
it's about eight or 10% more sellers each week
than a year prior.
And so in 25, I think we'll still,
we'll see that growth as well,
so another 10% more sellers each week.
And these are folks who maybe, you know,
have been delaying their purchase
or their move for a couple of years,
and now it's finally, like now we've got two kids
and it's time to move, those kinds of things,
inch back into the market,
they were like a shadow supply of people
who were really holding off.
And so the reason that's the important trend to watch
for next, for this year, 25,
is that if those, if the sellers move faster
than the buyers, we could get a more significant increase
in inventory, so inventory rose by 27% over last year,
we expect it to rise by another maybe 15% in 25,
but it could be, what if it's 20 or 25% more,
like that could then have impact on prices,
because now there's a lot more homes for sale
than there is demand.
So that's why I'm looking at that.
You know, in general, I think more sellers is a good thing,
it means more supply for, more options for buyers,
it means less, even if prices aren't coming down,
it's less upward pressure on prices,
so another year with flat prices means your income grows
and that helps affordability.
So in general, we wanna get back to an old normal levels
of inventory of sellers each week,
those sellers are buyers,
so that means more transactions are happening,
all of those things are in general healthy,
but it could be a signal of getting out of balance
and getting out of balance means you end up,
would be a thing where you have a big price correction
and we haven't had any signals of a big price correction,
you know, in almost 20 years now,
so that's something that we wanna keep our eyes on.
So maybe, you know, just summarize for us too,
because not every listener maybe knows,
the way that you look at inventory,
the way that you guys are tracking it,
versus say, maybe they're used to looking
at the NAR inventory or something like that,
how does Altos look at that?
So at Altos Research,
we track every home for sale in the country every week
and we can track the new listings
and we can track the price of the new listings
and we can track the ones that went into contract
and the price of those,
so there's all this rich signal in the active market
and the way NAR traditionally tracks
is they look backwards at,
right now it's January,
they'll be looking backwards at December
and say how many houses were on the market
at any point in December and call that inventory.
In fact, at any given moment,
there's a lot fewer homes than that
because if a house is on the market now
and it gets an offer this Friday,
it's not an active inventory next week.
Yeah, you can't buy it
because it's already in a sales process
and so, but NAR, when they look backwards at January,
they will count that as active inventory.
So the Altos inventory is at any given moment,
right now there is 635,000 single family homes
unsold on the market around the US.
Like that's it, that's the choice you get.
It is 27% more than a year ago,
but it's still fewer than the pre-pandemic times
and so that's how we watch that
and why we watch the active inventory.
Like there's so much signal in where prices are going
and for example, one of the things right now we can see
is sales have been increasing by about five or six
or 7% over 2023, over a year ago, through December
and as of right now, there are about 5% more homes
in the contract pending stage than a year ago.
So those homes will close in January
and we can see that there are 5% more of them.
So there's likely to be about 5% more sales
that closed in January.
So a little bit of sales growth over a year ago.
Now, the challenge though,
is that we also track the newly pendings each week
and in December and we talked about this
in this week's Altos data is in December,
we're showing no growth over
and the weekly sales numbers over a year ago
and so there's a few things going on,
one of which is that the holidays,
Christmas and New Year's were like on Wednesday
so it like kind of destroys two full weeks.
So it's a little tricky to see,
but the other things happened of course,
is that mortgage rates are higher
and they're over 7% and so then,
is this a function of buyers just waiting?
So 5% or a few, there have been a few more buyers
in the market in the fall
that we've been tracking every week since about September,
but now in December and in the weekly readings,
those seem to have kind of evaporated.
Now we'll get, it'll be a little more clear in January,
as January progresses, we have fewer holidays,
mucking things up and so it'll be a little more clear,
but that's something to keep our eyes on,
has the sales momentum that we've seen
in the last few months, which in the NAR,
when they look backwards at the previous months,
they've been, the headlines are now reporting
the same things we've been reporting weekly
for several months now and the headlines have caught up.
So they're about three months,
but if we roll through January
and mortgage rates stay in the sevens through January,
we could see a scenario where sales do not pick up
and they're suddenly flat and then the,
now the headlines will be behind again
because they won't see home sales flat
until February or March.
I think that's so fascinating.
So you are speaking,
we're having our housing economic summit, February 26,
you're speaking and what you're speaking on
is the housing data signals people should be watching
to know what's gonna happen with the housing market.
So it's exactly what you're talking about now
and how the data can lead you there.
So when you look at that,
I think I've talked with Logan
about how it's pretty unusual
to see those pendings going higher
in like starting in November and December.
If you look back historically,
it's happened the last couple of years
and this to me is really, really wild.
What do you make of that?
You know, I think that post pandemic,
you know, post 2020, we lost some seasonality
in the real estate market.
You know, part of that is,
part of that was during the pandemic,
we're just buying everything
and we just kept on buying
right through November and December.
You know, we used to have big seasonal swings
in the fall, you know, inventory would peak in July
and then start ticking down in the second half of the year.
Now inventory doesn't really peak until October
or even November.
And so then there's a little bit of seasonal decline.
And so, you know, there are some of those factors
where the cost of money has been,
was super cheap, therefore we were buying,
it slowed very down.
And then last year,
mortgage rates peaked in like October, November
and then started coming down
and that actually spurred some activity late in the year.
And so, like the timing of mortgage rate peaks
is it also goes into that relative effect.
Like people are sensitive, they'll happily delay,
buyers will happily delay a purchase for a couple of months
to see if money gets cheaper.
It's true.
And I do think the whole idea of seasonality,
like to your point on mortgage rates,
in the period of running up to 2020,
I mean, mortgage rates change so little
over a year's time timeframe.
You know what I mean?
Like if we had a point, you know, 50 BPS,
one way or the other, it was kind of a big deal,
which seems like incredible now looking back on it
because we've had such volatile rates.
So I do think that that makes sense
how that can sway things,
because otherwise it's like,
we tend to think of housing
kind of following the school year.
You know what I mean?
People are looking in the spring
so that they can get in the summer
so that the kids can start in the fall.
And it feels like, well, that couldn't have changed, right?
I mean, that part of it does not change.
So what are the other variables?
Yeah, and so that part of it even changed a little bit
and maybe changing more.
But yeah, you know,
there's still some of that seasonality in there.
And in fact, you're talking about
the wide range of mortgage rate in the year.
And one of the fascinating things is when rates are at 4%,
if they move 50 basis points,
that's kind of a big deal.
In the past few years,
rates have moved like 220 basis points,
150 basis points.
And in fact, we think for 2025,
we expect, you know,
we could have as much as 150 basis point move
in rates within the year.
And the housing wire forecast is,
you know, a high end of the range is seven and a quarter.
We're in January.
We're kind of pushing that right now.
And as Logan mentioned yesterday about the jobs data,
like pushing mortgage rates higher,
like we could, we're pushing that.
And if we're lucky,
we get some of the right economic news at the right time.
The 10-year falls during the year.
And we get some compression on spreads.
If we're lucky, maybe during the year we inch under 6%.
And we get some people,
some borrowers get a chance to refi
if you have the window timed,
or some people, buyers get to act really quickly.
If we're lucky, that happens.
And so that's what we're looking at.
And I think when we look at other forecasters for 2025,
it's pretty conventional wisdom
that there is nothing in the cards
to get rates below 6% for any substantial.
There's nobody, a year ago,
there were still people holding out for 5% mortgage rates
by the end of 2024.
All of that optimism or hopeful optimism,
hopium is gone now.
And so there, you know,
it's pretty conventional to see people in 6%.
I think, you know, even a few months ago,
it was rare to see anybody forecasting above 7%.
When we actually announced our forecast and saying,
like, we think rates could be above 7% for part of the year.
And it was pretty rare to see forecasters do that.
Some of those forecasters, it's, you know,
handy go, oh, six to seven is about where it will be.
And that's largely right.
But almost none of them said, had a seven handle.
And we thought there could indeed be.
So suddenly, you know,
we're in January with mortgage rates in the sevens,
and no sign yet of them easing.
So, you know, we're looking at that.
And like those kinds of combinations,
a little bit stronger inflation numbers,
a little bit stronger jobs data.
You know, the Fed doesn't cut any, like,
not to cut the 10-year drives higher.
Like all of those factors could keep our mortgage rates,
you know, in the sevens,
or certainly in the sixes for the year.
You know, props to you for that.
So this is the first time that we've had a,
Logan's done a mortgage rate forecast.
We've had other things.
You've done stuff.
This is the first time we've had a housing wire,
housing market forecast,
which included all sorts of things,
including mortgage rates.
And so I thought it was really interesting.
And obviously we do have the advantage
of some very recent data on all these things, right?
This is the Altos advantage that we see is that like,
like you said, you can see things coming in the data
before other people can do it.
So then you wrote a very interesting story,
like that said,
all those mortgage forecasts are already wrong
because not ours,
but like all the 2025 mortgages in the span of a week,
we, you know, we were publishing,
this is what this person says, this person.
And then it just, it was all out the window.
It was so sad.
Yeah, it was because suddenly,
because very few people were looking at sevens,
at rates in the sevens for 2025.
So all their expectations were in the sixes
and we were already in the sevens rolling into 2025.
So, you know, wrong is wasn't, you know,
a nice headline term,
but you know, they, very few people in those forecasts said,
hey, there's a possibility that we spend, you know,
some of the year in the sevens.
Now I am still optimistic
that we're at the high end of the range for the year,
that we get some good economic data.
We get some lucky economic data that brings rates down,
trades in the sixes for most of the year.
And if we're really lucky,
it drops to the low sixes like it did in September briefly,
or maybe even dips under.
Logan points out that the spreads have been compressing
and as there's less volatility,
the spreads will continue to compress.
So that's, you know,
will help mortgage rates for most of the year.
And so I remain optimistic that that's the case,
but that's really why we wrote that.
I wrote that piece on like,
all those mortgage rate forecasts were already wrong
because, you know, a year ago,
so many of those folks would say,
rates are going to be in the fives.
And, you know, we never even got close to that.
We barely got close to that for the year.
And I think that was worth pointing out.
I do too.
And I mean, I think everybody would rather have the,
I mean, we, of course we all wish in housing,
we all wish mortgage rates could go down,
not for any bad reasons, but just, you know,
not because we're in some, you know,
recession and everyone's, you know, hurting,
but just that like,
we've been in this really tight space in the housing market,
you know, it's been four years now,
like we're ready for a break here,
or at least the last two years, you could say,
last two and a half years.
But at the same time,
when we have those kinds of like forecasts,
like we did last year, it's almost worse
because I feel like for the last two years,
we've been like, okay, here's, it's just around the bend.
And we're going to come and like the disappointment of that
and also trying to plan a business around that, super hard.
Yes. And that's exactly right.
And it's plan a business around it.
It is, you know, that back to that affordability topic
where we started the conversation,
like it's really hard and it's hard for all kinds of folks
throughout the ecosystem.
And so it would be nice to have that,
to have rates come back down again.
And, you know, we'll report it when it happens.
We will, we will.
Mike, thanks so much for being on.
Looking forward to you,
would encourage all of our listeners,
sign up for that Housing Economic Summit.
You're going to bring it, really excited about your session,
about looking at which of the signals you need to look at
to know where the housing market's headed,
what those signals are telling you,
what's just noise that you don't have to listen to.
So it's going to be great.
And I appreciate you being on.
Yeah, that Housing Economic Summit
at the end of February in Dallas.
That'll be terrific.
Can't wait to see you then.
All right.
