Why are Home Prices not Falling? - Los Angeles Real Estate Market

DollarHomes
3 followers
#homeprojects
#business
Why are home prices not falling, despite high interest rates, lower sales, and buyer's loosing 25% of their purchasing? In this video we discuss how property tax policy (proposition 13), higher interest rates, and low home construction activity is preventing big price drops in the Los Angeles real estate market.
Since real estate prices peaked on the west side of Los Angeles in the spring of 2022,
sales are down by about 25%, interest rates have doubled, and buyers have lost almost 25%
of their purchasing power. Yet, home prices are not really coming down. I mean,
in Southern California, according to the California Association of Realtors,
sales are up 8.7%, prices up 3.1% compared to the same period last year.
So why are prices not coming down when pretty much everything says that they should be?
Well, here are three reasons. One, property taxes, to which you may be like, what? What
does this even have to do with anything? Well, property taxes in California kind of work like
rent control. They're typically based on the purchase price at the time that you bought the
property at an estimated rate of about 1.25%, and they can only go up by a maximum of 2% per year.
So for example, if you bought your house 14 years ago for $875,000, your property taxes would have
been about $10,900 a year with a maximum allowable increase of 2% per year, which means that today
your property taxes would be about $14,000 a year, which seems like a lot. But today,
based on real statistics, that same house is worth about $2.1 million. So if you were to buy your
house again today, your property taxes, instead of being $14,000, would be about $26,000 a year,
or about $1,000 difference a month for the same house, not a better one, the same one.
So yeah, essentially people who bought their house several years ago have like a monthly $1,000
incentive to not sell their house. Now, God forbid they bought their house like 20, 30 years ago,
because now they really don't want to sell. But anyway, this 2% annual cap on property taxes
started in 1978 with Proposition 13. And one reason was that prior to this, a bunch of,
well, old people were losing their houses because while they might have already paid off the house,
they couldn't afford to pay the rising property taxes. So yes, pros and cons to Proposition 13.
It brings financial stability to homeowners, and it's one of the benefits of owning a house,
but on the other hand, it also kind of incentivizes them to not sell, which can result
in lower inventory, higher demand, and higher prices for first-time homebuyers.
Now, one exemption to this is California Proposition 19, which allows people over 55
years of age to sell their house and transfer their existing lower property tax base
to a new house. So yeah, in a way, real estate kind of also offers senior discounts.
Now, reason number two, why prices are not falling. And by the way, my name is Daniel
Rangel, real estate agent on the West side of Los Angeles. If I can be of any help,
it would be an honor. And for a free consultation on buying or selling, don't hesitate to reach out.
And you can find my information in the description below. And for more Los Angeles real estate
videos like this one, check out my channel and consider subscribing. Reason number two,
why prices are not falling. Interest rates, specifically the sudden increase in interest
rates is incentivizing sellers to not sell. I mean, for the past 10 years, millions of homebuyers
were able to get some of the lowest interest rates in history at around 3.5%. And then we
suddenly saw them double to around 7%. Now 7% has actually pretty much been like the average
in the past 50 years. But the problem is the sudden increase in rates without a proportionate
drop in prices. For example, let's say you bought a house five years ago for a million dollars with
a 30 year, 3.5% interest rate. Now your monthly payment would be about $4,800. Now, if you try
to buy your own house again today for the same price, but with a 7% interest rate,
your monthly payment would now be about $6,500 a month or a $1,700 difference.
So unless your income has gone up dramatically in the past five years,
you can't even afford to buy your own house, let alone upgrade to a better house. But let's say
you did want to upgrade from like a $1 million house to a $1.5 million house, assuming a 20%
down payment. Now had interest rates stayed the same, you would have had to grow your income in
the past five years by an additional $5,000 a month. Now with a 7% interest rate, you would
now need to grow your monthly income by an additional $11,000 a month. That's like more
than double. So yes, the sudden increase in interest rates makes it harder for homeowners
to sell and upgrade their house. As a result, similar to like the property tax situation,
homeowners with a low interest rate have an incentive to not sell or can't sell because
they can't afford a replacement property resulting in lower inventory, higher demand,
and higher prices for first-time homebuyers. Now, reason number three why prices are not falling,
lack of new construction, but specifically for home ownership. Now, according to a report by
Up for Growth, in 2021, California was the state with the highest units of underproduction or
basically not building enough houses to keep up with demand. And the Los Angeles metro area landed
the number two spot out of 192 metro areas as the area with the worst housing underproduction
in the nation. So yes, Los Angeles and California are some of the worst and toughest places to build
housing, partly due to land costs, but also government policy and zoning. But at the same
time, there's no more space to build single family homes. I mean, Los Angeles has pretty
much already extended the single family suburb to like Las Vegas, Nevada. So really like the only
option to build new housing, especially on the West side of Los Angeles is to go up. But the
thing is like 70% of Los Angeles is zoned for single family homes. But even then, like the
little space that we do have to address the housing shortage is not really being utilized.
Actually, correction, it is being utilized, but not for home ownership purposes. I mean,
we've seen a bunch of new residential high-rises go up in Los Angeles in the past couple of years
in response to the housing shortage. And it's working because rents on the West side of Los
Angeles have come down. The problem is that like over 90% of the high-rises that you see going up
are rental apartment buildings for renters. No one's really building condos for homeowners.
I mean, in this small community in Santa Monica between 1970 and 1980, 1,195 condo units were
built. In the past 10 years, that number is 23. The reality is that currently government policy
makes it easier to build rentals over condos. At the same time, condos are a higher risk for
investors. Approval takes longer, financing is harder, and the liability is higher. For example,
California law SB 800 allows HOAs to sue the builder for construction defects up to 10 years
after construction. And according to some builders, suing before the 10-year mark has
pretty much become a default for many HOAs and a great marketing strategy for attorneys.
And for this reason, among many others, some builders are pretty much like, yeah, no,
that's cool. I'm just not going to build any more condos. And when you do see condos,
you'll notice they're pretty much like all high-end condos where the higher prices
can justify the risk. But anyway, yes, despite the adverse market conditions,
prices on the West side of Los Angeles are not really falling because the bad market conditions
are being counteracted by an equally powerful perfect storm of low inventory.
I mean, consistent price growth in the past 14 years has given many homeowners the benefit
of lower property taxes compared to a new buyer or essentially a property tax incentive to
not sell. Two, the rapid increase in interest rates makes it harder for homeowners
to sell, find a replacement property or upgrade their house. And three, to make things worse,
we're not building new housing specifically for homeownership.
Now to all of this, I'm not saying prices won't come down, but I'm also not saying that they
won't go up. Timing the market is nearly impossible. So my advice is always buy when
you can reasonably afford to buy. When the time makes sense for you and when you can
reasonably expect to hold onto the property for minimum five years, ideally 10 and super
ideally until like you die. And by the way, my name is Daniel Rangel, real estate agent on the
West side of Los Angeles. If I can be of any help, it would be an honor. And for a free consultation
on buying or selling, don't hesitate to reach out and you can find my information in the description
below. And for more Los Angeles real estate videos like this one, check out my channel and
consider subscribing. But either way, thanks a bunch for watching and have an awesome day.
