Mantegna, Dormition of the Virgin

Renaissance & Reformation in Europe
170 followers
11 Video Views·Dec 6, 2022
We're in the Prado in Madrid, and we're looking at a small Andrea Montaigna.
It's the Dormition of the Virgin, and the painting that we're seeing
is only the bottom two-thirds of the original.
Right, so it would have had a top that showed the vaulting of the architecture,
the bottom half of which we see in this panel,
and would have also shown Christ receiving the Virgin's body.
That actually sort of raises the question, what does Dormition mean?
And so this was the moment when the Virgin was readying herself to die
and invites the apostles to be with her.
And this is an apocryphal story.
Right, not in the Bible itself.
I think, actually, Montaigna has played fast and loose,
even with the apocryphal version, because we've got this set
in a kind of classical environment, yet out the window or past the porch.
Cementua.
Yeah, we see this incredibly accurate rendering of an actual place in Italy.
And apparently this is very, very early,
maybe the first truly topographical landscape of a part of Italy.
I have to tell you that one of the aspects of this painting that I love
is the sort of precision with which Montaigna renders the folds
and the sort of textures of the drapery,
especially in the two front figures, in that green and that blue,
but then also the figure in the red that's leaning away from us.
If you look at it, it's almost as if there's static electricity
that makes the cloth cling to the body that exposes it.
You were mentioning the classical architecture.
Oh, he's clearly looking at classical sculpture.
This is classical sculpture, right, being brought to life again.
But I'm looking also down at the floor,
where we see the tiles forming the orthogonals of the linear perspective.
I'm not sure exactly where the vanishing point would be,
but the lovely feet and their sense of weight and the shadows.
We have a sense of light coming from the right,
illuminating the columns and casting shadows
that move out from the figures toward the left.
So there's a real sense of light and weight and space here.
It's incredibly convincing.
It's true.
Look at the way that the floor brightens in that little negative space
between the feet of the figure standing behind Mary.
And while mentioning Mary,
she seems so minor in comparison to the rest of the image.
She's so pale and so frail, but so small
in comparison to the much more vigorous figures around her
and also, of course, the scale of the architecture.
But we do have a sense of them surrounding her
and this moment that's about to happen of her death
and the figures grieving for her.
We see the figures on the left standing, holding a palm frond,
a symbol of death.
Not only a symbol of death, but of the triumph over death.
Yes, right.
And, of course, Christ would have received her into heaven
had the painting not been cut in two.
But I love on the right the way in which the figures are singing
and the way in which the candles are not held perfectly vertically
but are responding to the movements of the body
just ever so slightly
to make the sense of movement and rhythm and change
even in this very stable environment.
And that figure who leans over her bed
who almost is our counterpart in the painting.
♪
